Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning
friends continuing with the great
principle that any day that you learn a
reaber is a good day let's try
that Rashi tells us today we're going to
be focusing
on Rashi tells us on the top
of
that the is in the context that the
mishna said that if an says that she
already received the Cuba or if she
admits to part of the Cuba then she has
to swear the gar originally thought R
thought it's a and the say not
a is only when you swear and you're off
the hook you never swear and collect so
says both if
she's says that she was paid and both of
these cases it's
only but says gar there is a way for the
h usband
to obligate her to
swear how is that if he pays her theba
in front of tuim and then he'll have an
aid that he paid back the first time and
he'll consider that alone so then she'll
have to swear to be off the hook not to
collect that's a way to flip the so
Rashi is troubled what's the na between
and says Rashi
the with the name
of or with one of
hashem's uh nicknames
furthermore you're holding
on
very is merely a
so Rashi is saying that the na of a
being
a is one of two things
either
has
or is
with a the shame of hem number one is or
it's these are the two between
and now
other have a different take on this if
you look
in let me try to put it up on the screen
um didn't
go okay it's going now let's see
okay tus over here says that the naino
between that we like him that there's a
of that
by there's a
that if you're not able to swear you pay
that's
only not
by also says that there's a din
of is
only
um in other
words on the other person in other words
the are Str struggling to understand
what does Rapa mean that if the husband
is a smart guy he could bring her TOA
what do you mean she already
what's thean
between okay so Rashi says either is
with's
name or says
the is only the is only these are four
Naas um the Riff by the way says a fifth
Na and that is that if the
woman does not want to swear
the husband could grab away
her okay that's another na that's a very
interesting na in other words if
somebody if a creditor tells the dtor
you owe me money and the deor says no I
don't owe you money and the debtor has
to swear and the DOR doesn't want to
swear the Creditor would be allowed to
be okay here's what I want to get at
first I want to deal with
rash
because mean between and is you swear
name or you hold a sa for really that's
not what Rashi said
on who remembers this
rashash let's
see look at Rashi the first rash on the
you see
we don't flip
it so we don't flip
it so why does Rashi say a different
na why does
rash say
the and here Rashi says
right Rashi earlier says like the second
TS of tus that by you don't flip
it so why didn't why does rash here say
the
is
it's
okay to answer this question I want to
share with you an amazing question of
the rivid you ready this is a galic good
question you should have thought of it
the question is why are the bothered
what's the
between what do you mean what's the
Naina maybe there's no Naina but he
already made her swear because of the
who said
that uh she was paid she was paid
already so now she has to swear that she
wasn't paid but this is another way to
get her to swear namely you're going to
pay her the Cuba
again and then you'll have an A you'll
say that the first payment was a loan so
she'll have to swear a second time so
maybe there's no na between the and R
but what what papa is saying is even if
a d is not any more than a until he does
this she only swore once now she'll
swear a second
time it's not to exempt her of the other
meaning if it was to exempt her of the
other sh then you could ask what's the
Naina why would he do this why just
switch one sh to for
another he's making her swear
now he'll make her swear now in other
words he wants to make her swear that
she was was not paid she the husband
paid her he claims he paid her she says
no you didn't pay me so she'll have to
swear no you didn't pay me but now what
the husband could do is if he pays her
again for the
Cuba then he could at least get her to
swear that she didn't borrow money the
first time so in other words words let
her swear
again says the rid why is it necessary
for the to come up with Naas between the
first and the second Shu maybe all papa
is saying is let's obligate her in an
additional Shu but not that the
additional shua would have a different
halic status than the uh first
one so reaber uses this rivid to answer
the Ste on rashis
rash here says that the
between
is
didn't and this is the question the ask
rash so say based on the rid the brings
in the name of the rid that when thear
says EP
he could bring her
to meaning even after he made her swear
the so in other words it's an
additional he says look in the in the
beginning of he brings the name of that
someone who
swears and then the
comes in other words like this maybe
um what the rivit asks is whena
says after she
that she wasn't paid she
swears that uh she doesn't owe the money
for the
loan but if you look in the L of the
Riff the Riff says the only way it's
possible to be someone an
additional is if the second has
been what does that mean says from here
we see that there are times you could
obligate a second Shu provided that the
second shu is adding something to the
first the second is not adding anything
to the first you can't make someone
swear um
again if there is a distinction between
the second Shu over the first then you
could make someone swear a second shua
are
equal you don't go swear
again what is why is one different than
the
other so we could say like this it's
amazing the of the that you're allowed
to make someone swear again is
only that the of the
Mish the of the
is
without and is
with so therefore the asks if the he
could get her to swear again because the
first is without and the second one is
with by the way says you look in
the um
brings that even by
there so therefore according to the
second shu is not adding anything to the
first Shu so tus therefore has to say
that the only na between and is whether
you're M or not but Rashi who holds
there is a
difference that's not the real nafina
the real nafina is that you can make him
swear
again you can make her swear again but
you could only make her swear again if
there's a thata is in other words
there's
noash the real
between is whether you could be
M that's the Naina the only thing
is when the gamar
here is asking that he could bring her
to shua thear is really saying let him
make her swear again and to make her
swear again there has to be something
fundamentally different about the second
namely therefore Rashi says it's been
a but according to that even the the
mishna has
been then uh you can't make her swear
again so
what's the question the question is make
her swear one which
Isa he says on the
bottom wants to
explain even after she sore the first
time the question is let her swear again
and the Naina can't be well the
between you could flip it because if
there's nothing fundamentally added
about the you can't make her swear again
therefore rash has to say the
is that they're different that the the
the original the is only without and the
that saying you could add
is Rashi earlier was
saying that the the difference between
the and the r is whether you're or
not but here thear is asking let her
swear a second time that you need to
find the afina in the in the fundamental
nature of the shua so that's Raber's
approach to answer this rashis okay
RAB stay tuned for this week's da
schedule it may be Sunday Monday okay
I'll try to let you know uh a little bit
later on the day call T
[Music]
