Rav Yosef Engel Revolutionizes the 3 Books that are Opened on Rosh Hashanah

this tour class is brought to you by torahanytime.com welcome everyone to the penultimate share before Rosh Hashanah so we'd like to present tonight really an incredible and remarkable way to understand the most well-known gamara relevant to the amtaf of Rosh Hashanah namely the gemara and Roshana taze about what is called tells us that on Rosh Hashanah three books are open the garage says one of resham gamurin absolute Wicked people people says written and sealed immediately for life they're written and sealed immediately not for life the in between are suspended they're in limbo from Australia says if they are they get life if they're not they get Misa that is probably the most famous gemara in Rosh Hashanah okay what is not as well known is the proofs and the evidence that the gemara has where it is rooted these three books in the Tanakh in other words we know that there are three books in shamaim and if we were to use our imagination we would probably imagine God has three books I remember I was when I was in fifth grade the Webbie had a safer has Aquinas I would sit next to your son in the fifth grade you know and uh and it was a privilege if you if the talmud got to be the one to write in the safer has so the rebby would appoint a talmud to write and you would record a yankel ass the good Kasha Barrel he gave a good tarot Fievel is a Russia marusha that was that was and obviously people would want to befriend the guy who who wrote the Savers because as you could imagine what the student wrote in the series and what the Revy wanted the student to write in the same didn't always have anything to do with each other anyway but that's just you know an old memory um but what we imagine that when the garage says there are three books God has a big book of the wicked because the gemara says most most they're more rosham than sadiqam the Gilmore says I don't have always created with the smallest letter because less people end up over there so we imagine there's a big book of the rosham maybe there's a smaller book of the Sadiq maybe there's a big book of the Bane in them there's three books the gemara says now how do we know there are three books the gemara brings some interesting riots the posix says it will be erased from the book of the living and with the righteous they will not be written the word they will be erased from the book that's the book of the wicked when the Torah says there'll be erased from the book that refers to the wicked when it says the Book of Life That's the book of the Sadiq and with the righteous they won't be written that's the book of the in-between so the gemara is saying there are three books what are they called The Book of the wicked is called erased the book of the righteous is called the the book of the righteous is called and the Book of the in-betweens is called they won't be written with the righteous now right off the bat and today's share comes primarily from the state fair um oh it's really safe which is a collection of dracious of abusive Engel I think I see my good friend hanok Weiss brought me the safer of Hersh Friedman who put together mamish an amazing a collection of the writings of Rubio savingo um all the dresses are up yesterday or many of the dresses and this particular drone show is called Chev deneka Masa and I've been to a number of kovarm one of the most interesting that I've been to was in Vienna which uh rabiosif Engel was buried there I actually went to that country just to go to that cover I don't know I had such a connection with the voice of Angola I personally find this Tyra so exhilarating because it's it weaves together negle nistar hasidos kabala lamdos okay reverse Engel doesn't need anybody sascoma certainly not mine but uh reviews angles Torah is really uh very unique and Rubio studengo asks a very interesting question the first question he asks are what exactly are these three books in heaven what are they what God has these three big books actually I'm remembering now when I started in my previous uh rabbanas in Queens my first month on the job so well and that Queens is in New York City you know this is NASA County I was in New York city so in New York City rabbona get free parking spots in front of their soul so it says no parking any time and it's reserved for the rabbi the only thing is you have to get the certificate of occupancy and letter of incorporation so where in the world are you going to get these from so we had to go down to like City Hall in Queens and we went to the clerk and the clerk says what year was the show built I think it was the first show in Queens like in the I don't know the 50s the clerk says come and she takes us to this big room and it's like you ever see the ad for it's like this this bookcase you know with like 500 uh shelves and the books on the shelves were like you know this big and you know she had to take us to the right Shelf and take out a book I think the book was like it's the book like you know would read that kind of book it was like I don't know seven feet tall or five feet tall and it opens this huge book and pulls out their certificate of occupancy okay anyway tonight is you know Nostalgia night anyway so what are the we imagine God has these big books in heaven what exactly are these books well God needs books you know first of all why doesn't he get it computerized that's what everybody tells me what are you busy with the files before I get a computer why doesn't have a computer system what are exactly are these books but furthermore if you look at the gemara's other Raya to the three books that how do we know there are three books from the past six God God save the Jewish people otherwise get me out of your book references the three books me is the book of the wicked your book is the book of the sadiqam that you wrote is the book of the benonium so I don't understand didn't we learn in kindergarten and in first grade and second grade that the three books are Yankovic so he's written in the book of the Sadiq that he put on cities and he worked fill in and he kissed the mezuzah and he did all kinds of Mitzvahs he didn't bring his phone into the basic and that's just all the good stuff and then Beryl is a Rasha marusha so he's written in the book of the resham and in that book you know he was uh he's a gun of an annoyage so the book of the wicked is also written the book of the Sadiq is written the book of the wicked is written why does the gemara keep on referring to the book of the wicked as erased every time we reference the book of the wicked oh what's the remnants to the book of the wicked from that's the book of the Russian what does a race got to do with the wicked that Sadiq are written in the book of the uh that sadiqara are written in the good book and there was written in the bad book The rashama are not less written than the Sadiq there's nothing erased about the rashayam so why do we always reference the book of the wicked as the book that's erased only that Sadiq have something that's written and the rasham don't have anything that's written and why is the being in him ah you know what the book of the being in him is they won't be written with why aren't they in a third book an in-between book where they're written like mediocre actions like he put up a mezuzah but it was only kosher or he wore to fill in but he diverted his mind from I mean why the banonium are always referenced from it wasn't really written a book that wasn't really written in other words the gemara seems to imply that Sadiq Kim's book is completely written the rasham's book is erased and the bayonium is like a quasi-writing that's not how we imagine that we imagined it that there are three books and in every book it's written what you did good bad or in between but furthermore as of Joseph angle how does the gemara approve from the pasok the mi in machine that these are three books in heaven said Erase Me from the book what book was he talking about think about the Torah say for Tyra my chabino said get me out of your book says get me out of the 20th book which is not talking about some kind of imaginary books or real books in heaven he's talking about the safer Torah if you want me to be the leader then save the Jews if you don't save them get me out of your books so how could the gemara learn from that there are any other books other than the safer Tyra okay next on the base like more wants to know when it's all said and done when the game is over yeah so you can go upstairs and Hashem is going to say new rabid what do you do sashem is going to call witnesses who are the witnesses your house the walls the beams and ligamar brings the soul of man will testify against him meaning the person will come up and Revolution will say you have uh 200 mid slice 2001 avarice this ain't good and you say no it's not true I have 200 minutes I said 197 of Heroes and God's gonna say could we get a witness in and who's going to walk in your soul the question is Rubio wants to know how will your soul be your testimony your soul is gonna what exactly is the soul gonna say to this to the soul see what you did does the soul can it see what is it what kind of witness and testimony will the soul give another interesting point there's a medicine references four kinds of Jews Jews that never sinned garim irishuva and the gemara says you know where Bali Chiva are alluded to in the Posse number seven third line um says this one says I belong to God that refers to Jews I never sinned when it says this is uh this is called Yakov these are righteous these are garam the plastic that says he will write for God that refers to Bali chuva Bali chuva are called those who write for God why are Bali tuba called those who write for god well what does writing for God have to do with Mali chuva okay I think so far every gemara we had so far as you know from we've done in dafa over here dickmara says if somebody is heaven forbid at a very tragic uh occurrence if somebody sees the death of a Jew so another if somebody is present they have to tear Korea why because it's like witnessing the burning of a safer Tyra so therefore somebody's present that is you have to rip your clothing the question is why is the death of a Jew like the burning of a safer Tire what is the death of a Jew got to do with the burning of a safer terrorist so Rashi on the roof says that a Jew is like to say for Torah why is it you like to say for Torah because he could have learned more if the person dies he could have learned much more so all that Torah that he could have learned his loss forever so it's like the burning of a safer Tyra however it comes the real estate angle and he says in his opinion he would say a different shot than Rashi that if somebody diesham and one is present it's not like the burning of a safer Torah because the person could have learned more but in a different sense a person is analogous to a safer Torah there's a different way in which a person is analogous to a safer Torah as we are about to see Mom is something amazing foreign number 12. Mr Deutsch how's that Australia everything good over there okay glad so the gemara they opened up the shoes yet no no okay so we're a little bit ahead but the gamaranida says that the best time in life when is the best time in life some people say when they were younger some people say when they're older but the gemara says neither the best time is in utero though the best time is you know basically you're floating around you could do somersaults upside down right side up nobody bothers you you have uh endless supply of food it's it's quiet you could relax that's the best time in life then an angel comes he lights a candle on your head and you could see from one end of the world to the other end of the world you can see what's going on everywhere you have front row seats of like all the greatest sights in the world and an angel comes the gamara says they teach you the whole Torah not just you know badly they teach you xiaomi Safra free everything now the gemara doesn't say who teaches you the Tyra who's the rabbi who who's the revi you know who exactly teaches them then the gemara says as soon as it comes time to be born Angel comes now also interesting who's the malach malach foreign and he makes you forget the whole tire just read a story you know back in um in Europe the managuas the Rev the rub would uh somebody asked me you know are you allowed to hit your kids so today you know it's you know it says initially you gotta hit you know but uh back in the day of course the parent hit their kid not only that in Europe at 100 years ago there's a particular Story one other I'm not going to say who I can tell you we could read about it foreign that was that was how uh you kept you and you know in fact in fact there was once uh a Rob was going around and he noticed that the filling of one of the balabatim was a little bit out of place so he went to fix it and the person like moved his hand like get out get lost smacked him now if the roof gave a smack you would have to move out of the city that's that's how it worked and the man moved out of the city and nobody heard from him so it's interesting this rub who would later go on to be one of the chief rabbis of the state of Israel ended up having to come to America to fundraise and this person became a very big veer and he uh he thanked he thanked the particular he said you know if not for you I would have been stuck in Europe I've been lost during the war and I would have been in onive anyway but uh this is what the Malik does the mouth comes he gives the Manisha zets he forgot everything he ever learned who's the mother who's the mama also the gamara doesn't say it doesn't say the revi was and it doesn't say who the who the the guy the Malik who punches you in the face sin crouches at the door now we know another discussion about this sin Crouch is at the door from the Sanhedrin sanheden records a conversation between antoninus and revi antonina says when does the yid Sahara come in utero or when you're born yeah so antoninus Reby said when you're uh Reby said in utero santanino said can't be in utero because then the baby would kick and come out so and Robbie says so what do you say antonina said when the baby is born Rebbie said antoninus taught me that the attire doesn't come till the baby is born that means that we're applying the pasta laptop very good so if I'm not mistaken we'll be keep Vega on the page who asks that we know about Isa was kicking to come out when uh when he was saying Rashi bring that also on Rashi in parashas tall dice but the bottom line is the gemara says that when does the yet Sahara come when you're born Nido says that an angel comes and makes you forget the Torah the moment you're born two and two together if La PESA it's indicates it's a horror comes when you're born then the gemara that says that when you're born someone comes and punches you in the face and makes you forget the learning that must be the Sahara and he punches someone in the face and he makes you forget the learning now I once saw a pisgate toy system is who teaches you the whole Torah theater however he's teaching you teaching you're teaching you until you're born when you're born the yet Sahara comes and yet Sahara he punches the Yates leaves until you're 13 years old and some people much much much later and the yesutova's gone and that's when you forget the Torah so it's very interesting the Yates are horror makes you forget the title who taught you the Torah how did you learn the Tyra and how did you forget the tire that's the subject of today's sheer and we're about to learn something for those familiar with tehilim look at number 17. says then I said and a scroll that's written on me God I want to do your will visayas is in my intestines says Engel the Jewish soul is cloth and on the clap of the Jewish soul is written voracious bhara and like yes and then it continues and it continuese and it has and the answer as you once were When In Utero because all you had to do is take the cheat sheet it says it on your soul so then you're telling me if I could read my soul I would be going on yeah so why can't I read my soul it's because with the yet Sahara comes and he coats your soul in like a screen it's cloudy you ever try to do kishavan on a cloudy night if it's really cloudy by the way I told you I was walking I told you this nicer I was walking matsushabis it was 11 45 P.M and I look up in the nighttime sky and lo and behold I look at the Moon and I tell my wife what in the world is next to the Moon there so there's a a red star next to the Moon she said what it's a plane I said no I'm not an astronomer Mars and the Moon were in Confluence for three days this week I'm sorry I'll send you a picture so what does that have to do with anything um on a cloudy night yeah you ever tried to do kids you can't see the moon sometimes so quiet says desire for this world The Pursuit Of Money pursuit of pleasure pursuit of covet it's like a thick coating that covers the safer Torah that is your soul and you can't read it you cannot read your safer Torah in utero you didn't have the Yates are harass so therefore the the letters of the Torah were illuminative but says abusive Engel if a person overcomes as yet sir Hara then you don't even need to have yigiya and Tyra there's a way to master the whole Torah without effort and that is Concordia if you concrete Sahara then you have access to what's written on your soul and you can actually Master the Torah even without amelo we're going to talk about that says abusive angle it comes out that this would explain again said the Romans were in war with the Greeks for something like 32 years and the Romans cannot Prevail until the Romans teamed up with the Jews and the Romans got into a whole camera any Jewelers here okay but anyway the Romans got into a whole conversation if you have a diamond and a ruby what should be a setting for what then uh and you have emeralds and you have gems until the Greeks asked the Romans and if you have a gem and a safer Torah what's more important the Roman says say for Torah and we have a safer Torah and we have Jews with us so abusive Engel asks why do they mention anything about Jews the question is do they have a safer Tara so just say we have a safe return what do the Jews Got to Do With It says angle this is exactly the point and that is a Jew in his ideal form is a safer Torah it's written on him and we could say that's the meaning of the gemara they don't stand up for a great person because a great person is a safer Tyra because on the person is written the words of the Torah and he has not coded it and covered it let's get a load of this comes of Joseph Angel and he says something astounding do you remember the government at the end of his life he lifted up his ten fingers and he said we banished it is revealed and known before you that I exerted myself with all of my fingers in Torah and I did not get pleasure from this world even with my small finger Robbie made two statements he involved himself entire he was amelan he toiled in Torah and he did not take pleasure from this world even though he could have he was one of the wealthiest people who ever lived okay says toaster says instead of a person in davening to the Republic please allow the words of Torah to enter my heart we all know you could learn you could learn you can learn you can learn but the Torah doesn't really penetrate so says the gemara it's so important to dive into Evolution that the Torah should penetrate your heart but before you pray that the tarah should penetrate your heart more important you should pray that the Delicacies and the desserts that you eat don't penetrate your your soul why how do I know we learned it from rebby so firstly abusive angle asks we learned from rebi you shouldn't pursue taiva I need rebe to teach me that everybody knows that I don't need to learn that from Rebbie why would the matter say we learn from rebi you're right Rebbie did say I did not get enough from this world even in Iota but why do we need to learn that from rebe this is not like rebby invented the concept that you shouldn't immerse yourself in the desires of this world and furthermore I have a question for you let's take a poll you know now I know no polls are accurate my polls are very accurate I had them you know tested I wanna what's more important good health or money let's take a poll who says money who says good health okay okay so now I have a question does it does the following make sense since good health is more important than money instead of davening for money just having for good health does that make sense I got that I know but I now let's put that aside now just follow my Poll for a minute good health is better than money does it make sense to say instead of davening for money diving for good health no they're two different things exactly it's it's it's mutually excl uh one thing has nothing to do with the other you need both you need good health but you don't have money you're not gonna be able to eat and I'm real to live so why what kind of is there in saying oh instead of instead of diving for money don't forget you need time for both that's not a y That's not a intelligent statement instead instead of dominating for money down for good health you got it down for both I know one is more important instead of davening for feet you should damn for a head I mean you need both you need feet and a head everybody acknowledges the head is more important than feet but everybody needs feed also so right so why why is why is the matter saying instead of davening for Torah to enter your system Davin that delicacy shouldn't enter your system you need to learn for both Hashem that you shouldn't get carried away without because I'm the Torah should penetrate says that Robbie is saying he does two things he exerts himself in Torah that's a seita and he doesn't involve himself in pleasure that's surma but he said it out of order you should first say oh I don't get benefit with my ten fingers and I exert myself entirely why does he say I exert myself in Torah and I don't get benefit from this world so yes of angle this is the point hello and every Jew is written and if you conquer the itsahara and you don't immerse yourself in taiva you clear away the coding of the Torah and the Torah will read by itself and you will meme without any any any effort so all you got to do is break away from the it'sahara and you'll know the Torah automatically because it's it's etched in your soul so why did rebby exert himself so much in Tyra if he didn't get any Hannah from this world because revi did not want to rely on the cop-out easy way now it's not easy but Reby didn't want to rely on the fact oh I don't indulge in the it's a horror so now let me take a freebie and know the tire for free Reby said I exert myself in Tyra even though I don't have to because I don't take pleasure from this world from there you know what I learned that you could get free Tyra without exertion because rebi's saying even though I didn't have to exert I exerted anyway but I could learn from there that if a person does not exert himself and merely removes the eight Sahara he will be given and bequeathed Tyra for free now than to get rid of the HR maybe maybe for most people but it comes out to really know the Torah and to have the kesser of Torah that that requires uh a very high level of amelos so technically speaking there are two ways of getting Tyra either you could work for it or you could overcome the yitzahara now let's think about the following this guy who's praying to God that the Torah should enter her system I don't think I would have said this this guy who wants the tar to enter his system does he want to get Torah commensurate to his exertion that's not what he's praying for because if you exert yourself you don't even have to pray Joseph Angel says will automatically get Tyra because angle says it's a Brisa it's like a sealed sealed deal yagati um if you exert you will automatically get Torah so you don't have to pray for that so this guy who's praying for Tyra what kind of Terror is he praying for it must be he's praying God give me Tyra for free beyond what I exert myself so we tell this guy pal you want free tire without exerting yourself instead of praying to God that he should just give you free Tyra overcome your yet Sahara and then you'll just have him in maywe where do I learn that from how do you know you could get free Tyra without working I know it from rebby because Webby said look rebby was misspire even though I didn't have to work I worked anyway so this brings us to the following concept on every single Jew and ruvane and shimmine and levy on Yehuda an Abram and everyone's sitting in this room it's written the entirety of the Tyra however says abusive angle we all know there's a concept that when a person doesn't have era he's play game in his he causes a deficiency he causes a weakness in his Holiness he is so to speak is makes a pagan he makes a lacking a deficiency in his Torah says abusive Engel on every Jew is written 613 Mitzvahs but he says if someone is in this Russia and a particular mitzvah so let's say it says on a person don't eat if you eat a cheeseburger then that pass look starts getting rubbed out starts fading starts getting coded and now if somebody were to read that Mitzvah on the Torah you would say oh what does it say it would be like you know somebody's leaning the Torah and they and the balcory finds a mistake you would have to call up an expert uh it says I don't know what it says the quality of the safer Torah that is you is dependent on your level of observance yeah it says but if a person you know wastes time then slowly slowly those IC eyes begin to wear out and Fade Out and dull until ultimately the letters could be completely erased now moreover but but Sadiq at least has Roy mitzvahs and in the safer Torah of the Sadiq meaning on the soul of the tadiq most of the words of the safer Tyra are intact and are in pristine form and we know there's a rule from days so the Torah of itsadiq in other words if you go to the book of the Sadiq what's the book says there are no books there's not a book of the righteous there's not a book of the wicked they're not a book of the bananium they're no books you know what there are Jewish souls and you know what it says it says the exact same thing in everyone's book voracious borrow like him ashamed it says in everybody's safety but in some people you could see every part of the ice and you could see all the tagim and their safety as a safetyra and in some people you say like that's not in my Ten Commandments the words are erased now as long as you keep the majority of the Mitzvahs you could still be called a book of itsadiq because on the other hand there being any his words you know I remember Maize that brought over from Europe so Savita you bring up bring up from here it's I guess it says boracious bar like him but it's definitely not sharp and you can't really see the tag him and are the letters touching are they not touching is it a cautious so you bring it to a cipher and sometimes you'll say yeah you know we could fix it we can fix it it will cost you a hundred thousand dollars you say I could buy a new one for 50. he says you should but I know what are you fixing this one but a banana knee is safe for a Torah namely the soul of the banana every word is rubbed out phased out and the Book of the wicked is erased there is no book of Sadiq and there's no book of Rashad and there's no book of benonium the book of the tadiq is a safer Tara shalim the book of the Russia is in a raised safer Tyra and the Book of the banani are letters that are it depends which kid you call up to decipher the quality of the letter therefore says abuse of angle you know how we know there are three books but isn't moisture abeno talking about a safer Torah he says exactly because that's what the safety were talking about you know what the three books are God your book is the book of the righteous the way God intended our safer Torah to be that's the book of the righteous erase me that's the book of the wicked because the wicked erased their safer Torah and then the book of the Bain on him is that you once wrote but now it's not really that sharp so there are not three books there are three kinds of Souls and depending on the quality of your observance that is the quality of the safer Torah when we say three books are open on Rosh Hashanah that means a person can find his soul in three possible States another passage the book of The Living that's the safer Torah of the soul of the righteous the book of the the wicked is and the Book of the banonym is they won't be written in the book of the righteous meaning their soul is not in the state of a safer Torah of the righteous so what when he's in the mother's womb I guess you have to say something like that or maybe he has a delayed inscription I don't know I don't know but Murphy according to this we could say an amazing ready for this we once discussed something called the safer Torah of ramayr there are four different that were of Mayor safetyra and in one place it says instead of and in one place instead of Masa rohimi it says four different discrepancies in mayor say for Tyra and instead of it says so we asked wait a second so what kind of sabertos did the mayor have so we said oh many more versions say it doesn't mean his actual say fertara means in his book of drushas but still it's a very uh unusual record that rev mayor safritara had discrepancies that we don't have an hour say for Tyra another interesting thing and that is when you're writing any soy from here no Jewelers no sorry for him okay plain Jews no such thing as a plain Jew um the gemara says a dentist Okay so okay so the gemara says that you cannot write a Magilla unless you copy it from a previous Magilla incos and Magilla in other words you can oh I know and he wrote about it says Ramirez says your eyelids will look straight ahead so there's a very interesting safer that's going to come out next week number 26. that offers what's shot in the gemara Magilla that mayor would be able to write a safer Torah from because the answer is Rev mayor wasn't copying it from an actual safer but remayers knew the Torah so well that he could so to speak look ahead and in his Mind's Eye he saw a safer Tyra and he sort of copied it from that etching in his Mind's Eye but according to abusive angle the shot is you know what it could mean that mayor wrote a safer Torah you know what he copied it from you know it's safe for Toyota from the super tour of his nashama but you can read the secretaries in your summer you know why you can't read your safety of nashama because you have a goof and the Gulf War has taiva or a mayor read the pasta within aleph ramire did not have like a physical goof of or his goof was luminescent it was transl translucent so he was able to look straight into his soul and copy from the savitar on his soul when the khazal say in Ramirez said with an aleph or with a mother so what does it mean and it's safer Tyra not the safer Tara and the arroying had said these things but on the safer Torah of his soul there were these discrepancies so so Romero save retire in the Orion was Avada Kasha and these shinuian we could say we're on the safer Torah of his nashama because I'll tell us that the Jewish people in the times of the qurban they sinned doubly like it says it says what's the Negan doubly and we were punished doubly and we have double nakama so the question is how did we sin doubly and how did we have double nahama very very passionate when a person doesn't have era it's a double sin because not only did you let's say you also did another average you did you you're over that bear of Mexico and then it comes out says what happens when you do chuvarado it must be when a person does chuva he's able to polish and be magia to say for Torah and fix the safer Torah so when you do chuva you're doing a double Mitzvah what's the double Mitzvah number one you're doing the Mitzvah chuva and number two you're being the kayem the Mitzvah of kasivas safer Taira says going back to number seven in what words of the past are used to describe the balchuva because they're taking the raised part of their soul and they're rewriting it they're polishing it they're sharpening it so the ballet Shiva are called those who write the safer Tyra so I want to suggest what parachute do we always read or hazino what Mr do we read foreign if you want to beautify though you see us if you want your save to be mahuddar that is the avoida of assassin the mitza of Siva safety so it comes out very interesting the primogadaim wrote a safer of philosophical hakirais it's called Matan and he has the following hakira let's say a person does an Avira on Shabbos is the worst to do in Avera on Shabbos than it is during the week based on the above presentation you know why aside from doing the Avira you're also over on the Malacca of rochnius of Mexico yeah so I go good Kasha yeah I had that question I wrote it down over here so Alexis asking you know so how do you do chuva on Shabbos what you're not a racing so you can say a racing you are because you're covering it over but the writing maybe it's just mamela it's a grandma I don't know let you think about it however says he concludes as follows think carefully about this uh premise about this suggestion that when a person doesn't have Vera he's literally erasing words in a safer Torah when you do chuba you're writing he says these words this is like a new premise this is a new foundational concept he says it's correct in other words this is like a fundamental principle in the world of angle is uh very proud of and again the bottom line is that instead of the usual way we think of the three books of Rosh Hashanah Sadiq rasham and banana learns that there are not three books because the book of the wicked is the book that is erased what exactly is erased there's one book the book is your soul the soul has in it everything it needs which um says reasonably some did it this way is that all a person has to do really is overcome the eight Sahara a little bit and then it's within us we say ribanisha it is our will to do your your will um what is the impediments in other words the inherent internal desire of the Jew is to do what he's programmed to do and what are we programmed to do it says on the manual look on the Soul on the soul it says this is what we want to do this is what we're programmed to do this is what we're meant to accomplish it's just that there's a coding and if we could just uncover through the process of chuva then it will be revealed that really koly Israel yes that inherently the soul of every Jew is the soul of it and if we remove the coating there's a shame you thank you thanks guys you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you byctoranytime.com