Zionism #32- Chasam Sofer's idea of ostracizing certain Jews doesn't apply to today's Jews

today today is the fourth day of Hanukkah we're coming to the fifth night the fifth little and then communities it's celebrated in a special way with a party uh masiba and latkes The hamaki Guild one of the reasons one of the reasons is because the Sadiq him the rebels that were imprisoned during the time of the outer Deb is imprisonment to the same time 17 they were they were released on on the fifth literal for example Carlene Stalin I believe celebrates tonight as the day of release of the of that end I don't know if they celebrate I I asked once Islam a grandson of Islam one of the rabbits he didn't know that means probably they don't celebrate it but that might be one reason Chabad yesterday it says I think I celebrate the third night but then I believe there might be a version that is the fifth night anyway that some acidic would make um a lot a lot kiss Advent a lot kiss evening and um you know tell stories with belshant of Magid and give out Hanukkah guilt um nail hey so that's the uh that's the uh custom in Chabad and probably other citizens to give out Hanukkah guilt and Nate hey tonight the fifth candle also nail hair tips the scale from the majority of the days of Hanukkah that have gone by right eight days four and four number five the night tips the scale and it's the idea of kadusha of other light that's another reason why we celebrate the fifth night of Hanukkah so let's not go to page and here as I told you yesterday um is going to address the shita of the Sam Cipher so that's those words let's read inside me it is simple that the the people of satna they they complain that our way referring to Chabad he believed contradicts its up its opposite it up it's against to the approach of the Sam Cipher who who implemented the idea of separation for me to show him at the time known as now login then I log in at the time in in Hungary in Czechoslovakia in those areas and therefore the Saltbox system seek to emulate the idea of separation from recharium in their own time I.E the zionists and I.E the non-religious people foreign it's an argument a position that they take that is erroneous it's a taut a mistake Heine and why not login did not login of the of the period of the Sam safer that he opposed they were Jews who were Rebels with despite in other words intentionally against it what did those things so the light began there they were not in the category of tinakis Chinese view of infants children that were captured in war and don't know any better and therefore says the comparison to the samsifers period and our period is apples and oranges the ones during the time of the sub saver were raised in kosher homes Shameless and it was regarding those individuals that some safer said you should have his Bible separation those and then they didn't applied like to the care rights in the time of their advice writes The Following on the Ramba abu's those that are found today this is writing about his time Emoji absolutely done how you mix related and if you'll be able to lower them you'll be a midst to lower them shall I behold you know because we each day we bring them back to be better um and we we drag them into believe potatoes about pear in the oral law which state the the colonial don't believe him and we work on doing so the aim nevertheless they embarrass and insult the baliacabolo they ain't nothing to say we cannot we we don't put them into the category of a Newson being forced into a belief that they don't like the Muranos and all that and the clay from potatoes about pair they are crazy in the oral role the difference that rabiel says man of some safer between the not looking at the time of the South safety will rub them to most to the majority of the people who are secular not religious in our time it's clear in that advising that there's a difference between the two just as the natvas writes the difference between the anusim and the crime the crime knew and they denied in Taylor Swift Affair and their Muslim were forced and and then they had no choice Fabio says that that Advance rights that there's a major difference so to hear rabiola says there's a difference between the people did not love him during the time after some safer grew up religious and knew better and they'd after became um we're there you have to ostracize them versus the people bismaneu who are ignorant [Applause] is doing is not uh is not changing the way of theta and the way of our ancestors the the car rights when when when there were those who tried to get them to do truva they would embarrass them and they would curse them therefore they didn't have the law of being forced On Museum and the dean clay for him they had a dinner for clay from of Heretics verses the the the the the the Carol rights not at the time of their advice but at the time of the rambam which one was able to bring them back to chuva Abraham didn't cry for Melody they had a different din so in other words we see here two Carol rights one is classified by that fast as clay for him and one that ambam classifies them not as clay for him but as a nusu why because these were willing to hear and to be inspired and to change their ways and the the the cataracts during the time of their Advance were not and therefore those that were have a thing like a new sin you have to you have to bring them back with much with words of Peace actually absolutely he saw that data until they'll come back to the strength of Toyota um that I I just he said I just cited you how lucky sources but look at the look at the horse look what's going on in actuality regarding what you call the clay from ship as maneno the Heretics of our time babe when we speak to many of them who prayleness and we impact them of course as is known from the many balatruvists ain't missed but Adam from items it's not just about but it's writing more Vehicles versus what you guys say You're simply wrong on the ground here are so many thousands of people were not from and everything else and yet people spoke to them and people that were awakened during the summer and then came about Troopers so what does that tell you that tells you that they're not um that's what I'm saying so your whole argument comparing you'll set our time to the times of the psalm Cipher within I love him is erroneous a false narrative the iron but you must sound safer we're going to go to the next page I'm not going to learn inside it's an entire page of the Sensei 5th go on to page hey but basically that's what it says what we it's just bringing the citation and I would think that he does that because it actually it's it's a grandson of some safer called the Hassan Hassan say if it was a noon and he brings his true for his responsive sponsor and I assume he does so because it's a full page because he you know because they are so uh big and some safer and and and and his kids and grandkids oh they have some safer lineage excuse me so he brings there they're writing to show that there's a difference that's why I would imagine that a bureau brings an entire page of citation okay second paragraph what was clear from the from the response of the Hassan that the approach of his grandfather the Hassan right is Hassan with a memade and this Hassan with a noon Hassan with a noon is the grandson of Hassan with a man the bill says it is clear that that the the approach of the Hassam sofa his approach of separating yourself is badlos it's called is the Hebrew word the it was about specifically Heretics will do it with the intent of angering God yes um yes [Music] to be separated so it's record yourself to be separated okay thank you yes thank you fight it they convince these they they work on convincing others to rebel and reject s uh so those individuals it is impossible to bring him back to goodness but those that are one is able to bring back with time to good cool it entirely or even partially for like we learned like it says in this pay this this response I'm on the other page that you could either bring back them complete you can work you can work on bringing them back and sometimes you you they entirely become Bali trova or sometimes partially which is also true verbada surely made them everyone will agree even those that follow in the path of some safer it's a Mitzvah to bring them back and to to bring them in under the the Trinity the wings of the srinam sorry there's nothing greater than removing this obstacle Nissan that you bring them onto industrina you bring and make them from do with that and no she comes to this the sacrament whatever I have uh all that I've elaborated upon until now your deity gamio deity it's in bold I know no I know my flag is it says there are many parties that are not religious that use the same logic oh how can you compare the eating today to the eating during the time because I'm safer because even today are children have been captured but these secular parties use that to go further inside and ours are very distant from each other but who mom is us it's so different from extreme to extreme if you just think about it a bit lost let's see zionists who used this argument they they use it to justify Zionism and and therefore and therefore they really would believe of Zionism they don't believe in Zionism because they're not aware of it okay we're like captured in other ideologies so they they use the argument of tinikish and Israel to support Zionism and us from people lavateurs and others they used the argument to uproot Zionism completely from the world but later not only Zionism but all kinds of idolatry valentia to implant the true Faith so as we said earlier so avram what he's saying is that again you have the same argument to Sir one uses infants have been captured and therefore not they're not responsible to justify why Zionism is correct and one uses it just the opposite why people who weren't religious today and became balituva are are proper because they didn't know any better they were they were they were teenagers in this book next paragraph a proof proof we'll see in a second yo says and to support to have to let me bring proof to this the martial City brings everyone closer who initial it's because and not that because we we are interested in partnering and joining the wicked as the soccer claim and we discussed earlier and their argument is that when you when you join and bring clothes to show him that Russia impacts you machine can be you know conversely the idea of loving people and bring them closer to the title which is brought in the mission and pity of us and sayaks it's not possible to be impacted from the people in the country who pay the land the individual bringing the person close to you this guy impacts them and he says it brings you proof the innate quote this is the bottom of page hey 125. the last part of being a large paragraphs to all kinds of cities the whole America All Over America and so in other countries like United in South Africa cooler cooler namish cool them you know with a with a with a um a comma all of them and cool them Amish all of them believe some Yates and that clown not even one exception is never been ruined in iodan not even one hair is an iota foreign do you think it ever entered the mind of any sleep in any City all over anywhere to Newton Colorado for himself for his wife small children don't have milk to drink by a guy if it's coaches kosher do you think it ever entered a Liberace and his family to eat past about them if you don't believe me I mean I'll bring a simple proof if there would be one slip was woke at first Kali government that would become ruined in his observance and his from the mixes even in the in the my nudist details with our Our Haters our enemies our opponents will already would already appoint the finger all over him they would say play nape and play me so and so name the person name the city name the Chabad house so and so that when I'm sleeping so there ever is they make up stories and and and I'm sorry they can't point the finger they say oh I heard so and so you know what he's doing what she's right I believe the heart is bad so I'll put Point your fingers show me one sliat that does it don't tell me you heard from him and him from him and all that how does that goof for that itself even in the most minutest way if there was an iota of an idea of joining there to show him the wicked in other words are learning from the wicked yeah surely the environment uh would impact if there was such a if there was that a Commandments caused another Invader Avila in actuality we see just the opposite has been impacted by his community every impacts hundreds of Jews to do true with the dividend these words says these words that I'm sharing with you that impact people to the truth aren't just stories that I heard be holy losses I could give you his writing to the supper I could give you names of such and I can give you their addresses you could travel over there go there there is a whole milk and Mayors and you you'll see hundreds she's killed all the time Taylor misses were pale Mama's of eating that started to keep potato you didn't say this is looking through this looking well govern this paragraph over here second paragraph when my toaster shall govern the truth of the matter is you don't have to go so far away yesterday yes it says there are two yeshivas in the greater New York area New Jersey area Brooklyn one is in Brooklyn you know 770. we are husband Morristown no I'm sorry to baltuvius one is hatar Torah on Eastern Parkway right 724 I think Eastern Parkway the first Yeshiva of notoriety that was made by Robert Jacobs in 1962. is on Eastern Parkway still exists today I just for bringed over there a few months ago has been Morristown and another one is the Yeshiva Marathon which I learned in the United States and I learned in in the late 70s early 80s and we are proud right proud alumni from Morristown Rabbi lipsker throw him in the Mikvah David Morris I heard a voice note from though with Morris yesterday uh I'm saying that for you Jonas and we'll get a kick I put English describe these baltuvius have so many students that have become closer totem is only recently the castle Islam is and you'll ask him how did you become a baltus maximum go there you'll hear them themselves answer you how to tell you that this is the SRI got me back and they told me to go to Yeshiva I went to Shiva and I became a full-fledgment and knowing Taylor and writing a book on meditation so what I want to say I want to say something because this does go on the air people watch it there are some that say well Gabriel wrote this in 1980 in the beginning of the year is now it's 40 years later and I know this is the schlieff who made a u-turn and listen Free Will Peter hofshis is a reality every day every moment that's the way it is and and are there you know have there been anyone in the 40 years that has done that and guess what the organization has fired them has let them go I don't want to say names because I think it's pretty obvious and if it's not oops let it be that way but it's it's a fact that the Chabad organization has let go anytime they find out or they heard they hear of people doing things that are against the of they tell them either you stop immediately or you can't work for us you can't work for the for about you know and and that's it now on the flip side I'll tell you a story this happened about 10 to 15 years ago in Borough Park in the Sky very stable by Diamond at the time a big town with cochrome and a very nice person he lives on my block and he comes to the show he says I must tell you I was in Krakow for Shabbos my family we went you know we they we made a Shabbos over there we went to the basic Forest we have relatives says and you know it's Friday and I came in you know a little before Shabbos and the chunked wasn't cooked yet and it was on the Fire and uh he's Atomic huckle me you know and he said he you know he was finding a Hector the rav Rob garrari is his name the one from coulon you know Rabbi johanni uh his son is is the Love on Krakow he came in he took off he said this child will not be eating the Shabbos so my friend my friend he says um maybe we can use this Saturday Noah Taylor this is not cooked there's no chance the Shabbos I'm the love here that's the way it's going to be and he told me that he told me he was so impressed by his yetis that he didn't he didn't even want to look for a Hector okay I'm just saying you're talking about here a massive Tom mccookum and a bear you know what I'm saying and he's not a cow Castle show him I know him I know him very well so maybe he was gonna use the header you know it's at Sayer sibo it's a whole family and and the expected child the laborator schlier says I don't care if your whole family not a family in my Chabad house if the troll does not cooked air of Shabbos you know more than two-thirds is we don't use it we don't play around and I remember him telling me he says I was so impressed that Aid they can learn so well is such a level he said I was I was stunned I was it's like my attitude towards you know and he's a friend of Chabad but nevertheless you know you know the you know I'm saying what do they really they really know how to learn you know that that old nonsense and this guy knew Allah knew the details and and his you know she reminds us it blew me away now I always remember the story because it didn't come from someone who is a we say in Hebrew katakani means a a low life who's looking for a Hector I was looking for a way out you know I'll turn on I want to watch the World Series uh it comes out of Shabbos I point out I put on my you know my my my my television on VCR whatever you have I'll put it on to go automatic the deal right exactly I didn't do anything went on automatically and maybe there's a Hector eyes playing and your kids come home for Shoppers you know and then one of them sneaks in and looks at the game or even if not right that that's a cooler maybe it's a cooler would have met with a Hector but it's a cooler and here he didn't look for any coolers and it was like this is the way it is there's no monkey business he said so if you're writing here about the the the shluchem it's a hundred percent true and again if you know of someone heard of someone who made a a cooler you know and then and lowered the standard to the point where it it goes against the principles of and and not the sacrament principles in other words for example they say you need to have a zero haircut so say the shriach doesn't have a zero haircut he he's terrible he's a grub young here is clipper anyway I got a number two or number three what what what what's okay okay she didn't get a one they didn't get a zero that's why it becomes you know what I'm saying and he said I'm not talking about the standards of the satma had but the basic stanzas says Point find me one person don't tell me you heard I want to know who the person is I want his address and and let's go down there it's like I told David Berger when he attacked Chabad all of habad that they're not just them but they're elohist and God forbid bringing the thinking the believing the rap is God and all that I said Mr Burger what rather than us debating and arguing my book versus your book I want to take you for a walk down Kingston Avenue in Crown Heights that's all and you stop anyone you want on the street and we're going to any store and ask them if they believe the rep is God and if they say yes I I will publicly admit that Laboratories would came hello kiss them up because okay and if they say no you'll retract your book your attack on Chabad of course he didn't agree to do that but that's the point that if you're saying to you don't tell me I heard and this I heard this you know in every group and every time there's a group a small group sometimes it gets a little larger but by and large the shita and the shita of uh of a Taylor organization a Toyota movement is the way it was from the beginning okay and that's it and if taka it isn't okay and then it's not then we have to make a Maha and um yes before you got on I was just we were discussing a few of us you know it's very difficult to light this man especially now because you know Shabbos comes in so early she can't come so early there's so many things going on especially in my life right now what what's the meaning they tried to Life by 4 30. nah you know I'm I'm here in Florida I haven't been able to do it I I you know when I'm in Brooklyn I'm able to do it but look going out and light and helping a Jews in a nursing home like the Manita takes precedence over that that is a Chabad meaning it may be a brisk meaning that's a that's a commoner fine but if you have to be at a nursing home you have to be with your father that's more important and when you come home you're dominative and then you like the Manita and that's what I'm doing now why the shoes one after the other so they they dive on a minute after the skier but it's not dark yet and I don't have a minion you know yesterday I was in Boca at BRS I don't have another million so I dive in there and I asked her up which is better to Daven be a bit with Dominion or Davenport he says and I really don't like doing it again I I try whenever I can not to do it so in Brooklyn I go to Sheamus Shabbos at one two in the morning I got an opinion you know what I'm saying but out here you miss Dominion you don't get it you have to gonna run around to Hollywood and run to Miami can't do that don't you know just not practical you know so so I would say that if you have the convenience you you know and you want to follow the men in Chabad you do that you that what you should do like two three in the afternoon so then then you don't have to rush you can before the skia you like the manure then they even go to Myers again but it's it's the preferred way but it it it it it it it cannot be done you shouldn't feel guilty but it's definitely the preferred way is it clear is it clear one second is it clear what I told you you're welcome yes it's or what but after afternoon what yes yes absolutely he was talking about the the the guy wants to follow so I'm it's it's always a balance even in Brooklyn it's a it's because the Chabad custom also is you know you need to sit a half an hour to sit with the candles for a half hour that means they have to burn about 50 minutes right because you're lighting at the before the skier and then and then a coin that didn't has to like has to burn a half an hour after say so it comes out about 50 minutes or so 20 plus 50 30. so say you have to make sure you have enough oil and so you stay for half an hour for and then by the time the half an hour finishes it's like minutes from when they dive in my room so if you have a stool next to you jump in you could make it but if not you're diving later you thought it might have later the only thing is the so that the child you're not allowed to eat before before you light the Magneto but once you like them and later you couldn't eat it already I wish everyone I I yes yes and what said what the dimension that the reason why I see myself if it could too many people came to change my feelings too many people came to address my civilians because my my team was moving all over the place okay okay I I have no problem with that whatever works whatever works I hear you yeah um it's Shoppers its Shoppers uh Hanukkah and so it's a three three separated and of course in many comedians the three different kuggles the election and the other xiaomi and the potato and um but it's a big heavy Shoppers so make the best of it Hashem the barring any flight changes or things um we'll learn Monday if there is some kind of change I'll let you know on the on the group have a great job as a friend Hanukkah only goodness and light Shalom bye bye good job