Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Zionism #25- Satmar anti putting Teffilin on w Jews was mistake - Satmar R wasn't against outreach
78 views
Categories:Torah/Chassidus
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
so we're learning uh
we're on page 115
and we're at the third paragraph anyone
that has their mute please turn it on
okay
so
in this uh section of the letter the
heading on page tells us what it's about
and that is
which means the campaign
the campaign that referring to the ten
point Mitzvah with the tadiq mitzvah
this Mitzvah and this
two different words and I told you that
last time
is a commandment and mifsa is a campaign
so this refers to the libera's campaign
10 point campaign of putting on film
with Eden and Mrs and sadaka and uh
etc etc
and along with that that spoke about
tanks tanks to fight assimilation and we
the ones who were went on the tanks we
were called the tankistin the tankists
the ones on the tank so this is the
heading of this uh section and it refers
to the arepa's Outreach campaign in
particular
now the Saturday and others had a big
issue and problem with this and I want
to say that it wasn't only uh the the
hasidim but also the lit vachera by
hootner and others
this was in a sense the uh what's the
expression it blew the cap off the
bottle I mean because this was really
going to the streets
you know tanks against assimilation
using uh Warfare
um imagery and wording to to to to put
Zuma with a jeweler in the system was
very very foreign and totally totally
unconventional and uh a lot a lot of
abundance and Rebels and people had
issues because and they didn't
understand
the the issue as the rep explained that
at length at length it ever spent so
many fabrangans I was at those Fabregas
many of them explaining the what he what
his objective is and whose Target
audiences and why he's employing Warfare
wording and imagery he did all that he
did it but you know who listens to those
except The Barbers and then who and
who's interested in really paying
attention very few so the easiest thing
is to say oh you you you you you you
became you're creating something so new
in Judaism that it's outrageous and it's
not acceptable
so the satma were the ones because of
their of combative Style
as David Myers uh I believe a professor
at UCLA has written extensively
um about the combative style of assatma
Reba which I'm sure angered many sat
Mercedes if they even are aware of such
a
art of you know academic article I
decided in my book sophomore Lubavitch
which by the way Rabbi uh Rock Cafe of
the Yu who teaches at the campus give
out Ram I think it is I forget where in
um in the eurosha lion he's been giving
shiram I've been told and called by
people and he's been citing my book and
reading passages so
um at least I made one Rabbi Happy who
has a kind of material to use with his
spin of course
but anyway
so now now we're at a point where the
rep the reviewer wants to make it clear
to the writer one second measure one
second
he wants to make it clear to the writer
my kind of refutation of the satmarshita
of of of
anti-habbat Outreach is primarily
against you hasidim who uh you know have
this this China this argument but not so
much against the satbar of okay motion a
brief question because I really want to
learn the text go ahead
[Music]
right the teachers
which is where and what section of
Europe should I buy for gun no somewhere
somewhere yeah thank you thank you yeah
I didn't that was a plate disappear not
not some would say
um but okay yes he's at the grocery okay
for why you
third paragraph hey my name is
my refutation and argument and position
to you guys is in the class of Shalom
against Europe
did have complaints why
Babbage is putting on film with
non-observant none from Jews
what's up yo says my my reputation of
your against mythsayam against
Outreach is not against him and it says
why
his argument his complaint was villain
it was specifically about going out this
was after The Six Day War during and
after The Six Day War with the rapper
came out with a campaign you should go
and put on film with the soldiers so the
Sacramento said that this is he's
against this why because
you know when you have inappropriate
thoughts you put on thrilling it's a big
No-No so the sacrament of one of his
issues was that they are having
how does he know what they're thinking I
don't know but that was his crash
another
will say it he was that they didn't
watch nettle Vasa before the mitzvah so
we may let their hands and tummy
right because if you touch let's say
parts of the body that usually covered
according to how long you have to wash
your hands
so so Trevino says
that the sacrament of only objection was
to demit to the midst of to the idea of
putting on film with other Yeadon who
are not from Avo
but again
regarding all other Mrs ankle suffixes
there's no doubt going outside but that
even the sacrament of
he believes
it's a Mitzvah an obligation I'll call
you every individual he started to put
forth effort effort with those that they
call the non-observant
that they should put up on mezuz on
their house
and so to the other Mistress of the ten
points of campaign trying to say good
morning
now
he has a long
um parentheses kind of in the brackets
in his delicate way is going to
upend the sacraments China until
before he was courteous and he says you
know a you guys are putting it again
everything into the same bag he says
you're wrong the sacrament ever had an
issue with one Mitzvah of the rabbit's
Campaign which what because let me let
me let me give you historical
information
the the filling that ever suggested in
The Six Day War in 1967
the other methodium obviously
it started in 74 75 76 he already had a
stroke in 68.
so he wasn't blasting you know
opposition in
1674-75-76 his people were and they said
that he he supports it that was a lie an
open lie but that's that that was the
tactics that they did everything's the
name of the river
you know he was a an old sick man and
they said to him but private is doing
these things they're driving these
trucks and they're putting on them doing
all these men getting the non-religious
people to do these things and he
probably shook his head I said very good
he took a pen and he and he didn't you
know he was a stroke patient not a bad
and a serious stroke patient but in 67
that was prehist stroke
he added a 68 and that ever came out
with the campaign to put on Film on the
soldiers on the front and all over in
attitude in 67 and to that he injected
so now abios gonna say so number one
don't mix all the myths all the other
myths I am campaigns with thrilling
number two
you know let's get to the thing itself
and that's what he's gonna do here in
this brackets let's see what he says
[Music]
because the people putting them on are
thinking about inappropriate things as
they're putting on trillion if there's a
girl walking by they're thinking about
the girl and meanwhile they're feeling
on the hand you know it's like only only
the soldiers are thinking about the
girls walking by but a guy's shoe
because she's a pretty girl on the other
side he ain't thinking about her right
yeah tell me another thing so it's it's
just it's ludicrous but that that was
that was the argument
they're standing on the front and there
and you're putting on filling and
disingolf and there's all these people
or Times Square and all these girls
walking around etc etc so they're
thinking about the inappropriate thing
as the rapping film but but but you are
sure no you're very holy because there's
no one to show seven in the morning you
know okay but let be that ass is me be
that as it may let's see what he says
he
refute it and responded to the argument
with gamara
and not China and not Chinese he
explained it with us and he said
it's explicit in the magana
and it gives you the citation
foreign
the first section of the code of Jewish
law chapter 38
um law is subsection four
balatanya and the outer web of the
balatanya lips
as an
actuality of their paragraph
oh
when do you say that you're not allowed
to put on food if you have heard him
shall you do Allah
when you know surely she she exercises
okay I mean do I have to be graphic or
everyone can figure this out
you go and stand in front of a brothel
you know and put it on filling you're
gonna have his Hootie
it's not a question it's it's a question
for before they
Avo Miss Suffolk
but if there's a doubt
yeah albums
facing the bikinis in the beach he
turned the other way I'm sure
Suffolk but if there's any doubt
like
[Music]
if there's a doubt whether the person is
thinking inappropriate or not thinking
in a problem things
you shouldn't prevent I mean it's a
feeling from putting out to him if
there's any doubt
so then the first thing that ever said
is how do you know what he's thinking
about
we're not talking about
you know putting on children in front of
inappropriate places we're talking about
putting on filling on on the front with
soldiers who's thinking that they're
looking to kill the enemy and protect
themselves and save their lives they're
thinking about girls now come on
okay and the people walking in Manhattan
and and and and and and and in disengulf
and wherever they end whatever they're
rushing to go to lunch they're rushing
to a meeting they're rushing to finish
lunch to go back to work now you're
telling me that right now they're having
fantasies about women I mean like come
on it says this ain't the time for it
their mind is occupied with something
else so you say maybe suffix
quotes
from a doubt you're not allowed to not
put on feeling you have to put on to him
only if you know for sure that they're
happy and Hoodie that's when it's Usher
so that's the first refutation
the next thing is Vanessa was there in
addition to this
um
it says over there that the nature
the nature of a human being is that when
it's when he had when it is confronted
with something hadash something new hako
roots on the crossing they run towards
it
and look how people actually do this in
real life
um
when a person sees a novelty something
new
and specifically when he himself does
this
new thing is
at least
during that time
he's engaged in one thing not in the
girls but in the new thing that he's
doing I.E putting on to it he never
sought to fill in or he did it as Bar
Mitzvah or you know what I'm saying and
all of a sudden Alabama
says put two in them
he's totally engaged he's arguing with
him or he's so he's doing it he's not
thinking about anything else because
it's a he douche
trillions of those that are not
accustomed to doing the midst of
thrilling posture too it's very simple
as a matter of fact
that their thought at that time who are
drought at villain it's about the
feeling
says this is the overall count answer of
the of the rabbit's refutation of the
sacraments concern about hid him
okay so basically the Sacramento for
some reason
uh felt that he houdin was more real and
he and he objected to doing that and
then Amber said according to you'll
notice and I'm not saying the satmarov
didn't have any support maybe he did
maybe didn't I don't know
um but what I do know is that but didn't
just say it my feeling is so and so as
usual the devil always pointed to a
gamara to Allah as you see here the
bureau summarize it let's go back to the
next paragraph I'll cope on him getting
back to the main main subject at hand
closer open the gala Mrs thrilling even
if we accept that the software of it is
right in objecting to trailer and
objecting to the one of the rabbit's
Outreach Outreach campaigns it's only
relevant to midst of children because
that's what he said he's objecting to
avoid Mrs regarding the other mitzvah's
it's not possible that when you're
knocking numbers on the door you have
inappropriate thoughts
it's just not the not the right time you
know you know frankly is so why they why
they decided that that's going to put on
film you can have inappropriate thoughts
it's oh there's only one reason because
you do it in in the street or at the you
know what I'm saying
but the the the the you know the the
other nepheum around the house the women
should like Shoppers candles
hold more private
and he says
those that scoff
and argue that this fulfillment of
Mitzvahs of wicked people you know again
he's going into their shoes because they
call non-religious people Wicked they're
gonna show you
ain't shubham is worthless that that's
that is the shift of these extreme
soccer that it's like you could put on
film statement it's worth nothing
[Music]
says as we learned throughout the
beginning of this uh section how
important it is to reach out to another
yeet
and it continues
and although they who argue and say that
it's worthless they're they believe
they're coming from a perspective of
being God-fearing Malaysia and kanoi him
and
zealotsam and therefore great is their
hatred
to the wicked ones
to the point where they are with they
poo poo not only the wicked people
themselves
you know it's bad enough next page it's
better to say the people putting on the
thrill in are wicked
of rum but they say not only are the
people putting on feeling Wicked the
mixers that they do are worthless in the
sense Wicked mistress because who was
doing the Mitzvahs Wicked people such
Wicked misses
next page
top of the page me keeping Shazam
negative
again since this is contrary to an
explicit Allah
their language
this type of zealotry is coming from the
negative side the Citra
how can it be that this type of kinoy
should be from God when they not only
call Jews to show him but they say that
their Mitzvahs are worthless can't treat
the clear hello yes is it
that's right yeah
that's right
fighter
meme
good here he goes
if you says that their attitude of
opposing Jews that they put on trillion
and and put a mistress and all that is
similar to the mizrahian and to the
agoodus
because who who make crooked who
confused the halocas because
they love Jews so much or therefore
they're going to
um be massive you know
lie kind of about this this this true me
meaning of that Allah and they'll use
Excuse me use it
to justify nationalism and think that's
how to the guild all those things that
we spoke about before that unfortunately
the Mizrahi and the Agoda have fallen
into as well as he said earlier
and he says
and and these these individuals who who
are massive who who obscure and lie
through their teeth and using they say
we only have one thing in mind we have
taramina
foreign
[Music]
Merry Christmas what
yeah okay
next paragraph um
there's a story kind of about a guzzle
who said about someone who would he
would he would use
um
and he would he would like kind of make
the Allah
foreign
minister
that that
it's a mistake here probably
um
and and I assume and he kind of is a
master and owner of the Toyota
foreign
I feel apprecially you show you even
with a small you would even change it's
more the Cloud Times of opposition slow
that because of opposite slow you're
allowed to change right because noise or
for reasons of zealotry
so what he's saying is that even if
you're a godtled potato that he is he
saying a anecdote story that there was
someone who was a Godly potato and he
took this he says I'm the master I'm the
minister I'm the boss and he changed it
to his liking that's that's
inappropriate
what time is it I don't have my watch
what time
[Music]
you're fine
thank you next paragraph third second
paragraph on the page third pack and
Astrid's voted by nowhere
says what I just wrote is
self-understood you don't need any uh
um rocket scientists to figure it out
because nevertheless
if someone says I tried very hard and I
didn't succeed in finding the object of
the uh the item or the issue outcoming
don't believe them because if you try
you should succeed we actually get the
dialogue after much effort muscle
self-self is a China they came up with
another argument
what's their argument now the heat if
Allah
I'll grant you that the activities of
Outreach of the biological see them is
that is obligated up is obligated they
are obligated by halacha to do so I will
self serve nevertheless had he could
have made them everyone agreed with
their own children in Our Generations
I'm sorry in the general in the past
Generations
no one took the time
to have non-observant fried non-prone
people don't misses the gamble of babish
kuffa look in the garbage itself it's
history
in the in the generation of drasha up
and he says specifically because the
South maxidum supposedly hold of the
rashab
they also came
they didn't go around the streets of of
Kharkov and her son and and Lubavitch
and whatever putting on film with those
that didn't put on film
Kane
but there's a Clayton and if you're
arguing as of you presented it then it's
a hello to reach out that he saw decided
before so why didn't they do that in the
garbage
truth of the next paragraph the answer
is
the non-religious people in the previous
generations
they were primarily most of them were
lahatis in spite they were they knew
that you're supposed to put until they
knew from Shabbos and they said we
reject it all
and if you would have met a Jew in
hearkov you know the time that I shot in
the street
when you tell them suggest him to put on
film who created by a similar vulnerable
it's an expression he would give you two
specs two Smacks
because
he was
anti-religion the system
they were anti
machine King conversely because my name
was there in our time
that most of the non-religious are
in the category of children that have
been captured in war okay
when you arouse within them the idea of
doing the Menses
him they listen they don't slap you
because they hate you because you're
from Jew
Liam Kane have therefore
in in in quotes the great question that
the Sakura have normally also came but
there's a name and why didn't during the
Rashad's time why didn't they reach out
and do that in the streets of Moscow
English
has no place of question whatsoever keep
potatoes
because it wasn't possible
I wanted to say that moisha pointed out
I'm glad he did he sent me what's
happened I want to just mention at the
end of this year we last week I asked a
question you know our parents were you
know like uh you must marry a Jew that
was an Issa even commented on his own
family his own parents you know but
everything else was acceptable
so um
it's like in a way uh a derogatory uh
common towards parents and uh so moisha
pointed out and writes with someone's
worth mentioning that our parents gave
us a lot of good things
I mean you know no one's perfect but and
it's true there's a middle study voice
many times non-religious people have
they have good middies good middies
and there's something to learn from so
even a parent who you know was not
religious or didn't appreciate or went
against religion you know etc etc
um we shouldn't forget the good middies
that they give and as we raise our
families and continue raising our
children and grandchildren future
Generations
it's something we need to highlight in a
way that that fits into the entire
puzzle and it's too long to discuss it
now but it's an important thing one of
one of the things that I try doing in my
books who's who in Lubavitch I tried
putting in it's about people have passed
on
you can't make it in the book until you
pass on
but
I I like to have balichuva
from come from you know pedigree I don't
want to just give one version
of Lubavitch I want to give the full
gamut
and it's a very very important thing
especially today that today I would say
I've told you this there's kind of a
complete abolishment where used to be
the ffps The Throne from birth didn't
marry the balchuvas it's pretty much out
the window from the biggest Chabad
families they're marrying the children
from Bali troop and all that so uh we've
reached another point and I could say
that there ever single-handedly is
responsible for that in the beginning it
was to the Chagrin of the old time
Laboratories they couldn't relate to it
but in so many instances whether it was
Gayden converts or Bali chuva Etc that
happened clearly and spardem and
ashkenazim he took his pencil and he
crossed out and he took his pencil and
crossed out the the These Foolish um
arguments and and said you know
etc etc so I'm just saying that
when we show our families and future
families who are going in you know maybe
for those that are going into literacy
yeshiven as we have a lot in Ramat but
Shemesh people who became balichuva and
their children are learning in hardcore
literacy yeshivas I think it's very
important to to to share to share the
good values of of the parents or
grandparents who weren't necessary from
that they were good people
you know and good people and and never
forget that and don't like be
embarrassed to talk about a grandfather
or grandmother wasn't religious
because there is this intrinsic
embarrassment in the community
and not just the it's all from
communities from hasidm to literacy it's
Universal
so uh that was a good a good remark that
you made my to point out but
nevertheless the the the ironic thing as
Israel said is that you know you can you
can eat Rafe you can violate Shabbos but
just don't marry don't marry um a guy or
non-ju you know so you know it it it's
like ludicrous you know it just doesn't
add up but at the time you don't realize
that before you become from you don't
realize that it makes sense you know
only later when you look back it says
Hey something doesn't equal here you
know and um it is what it is having it I
would love to talk but I have to go down
this year we'll see everyone tomorrow
you just kiss live good jump this go to
some fabrina tonight and maybe tomorrow
we'll we'll talk a little bit about that
have a have a good day today
to you for reminding me thank you