Zionism #16- Satmar radical shita is closer to Zionism than Chabad - Nationalism is Treif

I say by first wishing everyone a thanks to Hashem not just because it's Thanksgiving here in America but because we have to give thanks a day booster for being here together another day another opportunity and we'll finish the day the first section of this letter in malaham on page is uh concluding his refutation on the topic of Liu nationalism and the the attack uh at the accusation of the uh satmer who complained to the bavishers that the labich and the red Barrow are basically uh leaning towards nationalism and Zionism and that argument took it apart and he asked the um the the accuser to please be thoughtful objective and and think about what you're saying and he showed with sehol with logic that the Babbage is even greater antagonists to Zionism than satmer and he explained that in the letter I'm not going to repeat it because it's phenomenal and very important so to accuse Lubavitch of being a zionists and holding and of of nationalism is simply ludicrous that's part of what we learned until to the eighth now let's go to pagecoof dalit and we're on the second paragraph Okay Ace our vacation is great and now I will request of The Honorable Torah personality referring to the individual of great respect may you live she is foreign go deeply into it teeth means deep means get deep into it according to the truth and remove all personal agendas please he says think about what I'm writing truthfully put aside all personal agendas and then he says what type of education wages war against the shita of nationalism of satmar U um from that cheetah from the satwashita their derives in a uh in a in a kind of in a sensitive and unsensitive way in a in a way based on their scoffer what what what will follow although it it's it's um not none not obvious the following listen to discover changes from generation to generation why because according to their argument uh to begin with the idea of jewishness as he explained earlier so I'm not going to go and rehash his entire logic but he explained that length earlier that this this sheet will concludes and that either sky is an external thing really all hidden or non juice and therefore labial says if that's your if that's your attitude then it's just a matter of time before it's going to fall aside this is a very very heavy you could say accusation that Abuelo is casting um uh the satbar shita but that's what it says whether we agree or disagree and it's open for conversation we'll go on or by looking at the education of Lubavitch of Chabad of Allah person who identifies with Lubavitch which says that the difference between a Jew and is in the very core now I know you see if you don't if you don't if you haven't learned the letter until now this paragraph is is outrageous so the paragraph on its own is it makes no sense but you have you you have to have learned what he's what he said until now to appreciate what it's saying here so I'm going to go on because I just can't repeat it again ye shall I see and he writes if you will ask me everything that I've written before is correct and that is in the parenthesis I just mentioned that to you in the open of monologue that Lubavitch fights against Zionism much more much greater than satva does if that's the case why is that in Williamsburg remember this was an attack coming from Williamsburg why is it that in Willie's birthday believed that Lubavitch smells of Zionism God forbid says I will respond I will answer you this isn't a question at all I love me he says let's this was already so in history let's go back in history and he says you know there was this group called The Francis and they they were basically you know heretical and and the false and the balcanto fought against them the ideology of the frankius was similar to the sheet of the Shabbat Suite the Apple became of khasidism it rings and he belongs and Associates to the the group The Cult of Shabbat SRI got from it Anya foreign the feet of the outer lab we talks about every Eid having a unofficially kiss so some argue hey that sounds like Spinoza's argument if you understand cities well you know it's the total opposite of what Spinoza says but Moses said the bench is God what the altered was teaching is that the bench has godliness the bench is not God there's nothing that is here in the world that is God God's super transcends that concept this is God that's the opposite of the transcendental God which we call in Hebrew Atmos so what does the Alton ever mean and joinism will tell you as a long time student of this that there is nothing is there is godliness a Godly Force writes back to the letter that the sheet of kabbad is the ultimate opposition Spinoza to the Sita of Spinoza philosopher a a known heretical philosopher you do Allah became and nevertheless foreign why terrorism explains at Great length in its hasidus how the entire existence of the universe it is only possible through The Godly energy that creates and sustains the world come it constantly yes ex nilo from something from nothing to something this term quote the world is godliness but they met the Russians maximum writes and look into Spinoza's writing and you'll see that he says a similar language Spinoza does your maximum elimi what's the difference should be Moses says the world exists on its own independently because and what does Spinoza mean that the world is godliness he shall ailments that the world itself is godliness is Spinoza's argument is Mama's heresy he says you don't need a Godly energy to create the world constantly why because the world is God so the answer if the world is God why do you need a force what do you need an energy what do you need a yesmian you have God says it's the total opposite of Yiddish kite of basic Judaism that the world independent of God is nothing hypnosis says it's everything says is you're not you simply don't know the facts are you totally wrong he says he's still he's still saying that Espinoza argues that the world itself he goofa who goofa the world itself Holika is God next top of the next page comes what's the sheet of Chabad potatoes says the just the Opposites soon the world of Rome has no existence at all nothing that's why the world constant means God's energy that should create it every moment if you take away one moment from God the Creator being in the creation and giving and making and creating it now every moment the world there's no world you wake up in the morning you don't wake up because the world is not here for you to wake up in right foreign but when you don't want to study something with its face meaning and it's premius you don't want to really dissect you don't have the time you don't have the energy you don't have the interest you don't have the knowledge um and you just look at the word [Applause] and you find that in Spinoza you say Espinoza are one of the same all the molicus but what kushmanoza means by her olamolikus is distant from the East to the West in since these words which is found throughout so therefore there was many there were those who accused of following his pimnosis heretical View says basically before we continue he says you're telling me that since I I've explained to you so well how bad is as far as as far from Zionism as could be and even more the Sadler is far from Zionism right nevertheless walking the streets of Williamsburg and you'll hear them call the barbages and the red by the bigger zionists etc etc says hey my friends let's go look back in history it was the same thing with the ballot with the balcantov and the same thing with the altered about and the same thing with many others where they were accused and attacked I don't I mean I don't want to go into navigator from his issues and and you know and and on and on Le bleen I mean you know and until today they're writers in your holy controvers Israel that have written extensive academic works against the Sadiq and and basically try pointing trying to show that they're not holy and they're you know and everything else I'm sure you're familiar with this and if not you don't need to know so the fact that the street be speaks negatively about a group or individual so what imagine someone will say is there is a it's not a good it's not a good gig and there's no bad mouthing for no reason at all what could you do and that's the way the world is if someone wants to bad mouth you and lie about you and say that your philosophy hinges on heresy no one can stop it's a free world it was a free world during times of a free world time the altareba and a free world today responds to the person he says is the fact that they speak to Swain Williamsburg doesn't make it right it just means that their excuse the expression he doesn't say idiots and idiots in a sense they don't take the time and again they're not talking about you know he says Williamsburg doesn't mean everybody means those people that don't take the time to think and don't take the time to discern and don't take the time to really be open and honest and remove yourself to see that it's two different worlds so then you you're just you know it's like saying oh Spinoza says the world is God hold them Holy Ghost and the balatonya says oh it's the same right and you should know this is a very important lesson for us in our lives what's the expression English not not everything you see is the is the way it is sometimes you hear something you see something and attack it could be that way and you have to be careful and then and sometimes it's not that way it's pumped it's not that way because if you study it more you'll understand that it's something completely different okay let's continue says the same similarity is in our situation today foreign when one grabs excuse me literally means grabs it means one to size when when someone just scraps a word he picks out a word saying a teaching martial Obama's he says you know you'll abolishes you say should I'm push it Israel even Sinners amongst Israel eating Jews and yehudim are Jewish but and we said earlier the rambam actually uses this as an actual a law so so the williamsburgers they say this idea of saying that all Sinners are Jewish is the same shita as Zionism the truth is the habachita is just the opposite of Zionism Canal as we said and wrote earlier and just as we explained all of this regarding this particular area called nationalism within Zionism remember because now he's going to continue in the next few chapters talking about other aspects of Zionism this was this was the he tackled what we call again Liam youth look at the top of your page in the heading and it says hegares base Indian Hali um the particular area in which he he concludes and he wrote until now his refutation is about the idea of nationalism so let's go back to the text just as it applies to nationalism within Zionism is the same exact things so government again regarding the second aspect of Zionism and that is your innocent the idea of zionism's view of the Ula Redemption says as he prepares us for the next upcoming chapter he says the primary Muhammad of Lubavitch against Zionism was Dr and this issue that the giula started which we spoke a little bit about ascultured so that's what he's going to tackle now in the next section the view of Lubavitch that is opposes completely escalated what you see over here bureau's approach I'm conclude with this today you see that that that what is out to show is Sir is not only that labavage is opposes the the various ideologies of Zionism but it opposes an even greater than supper so he's turning the table over he says you you guys oppose Sionis he says really according to yoshita in a sense you have something in common with cyanus I mean he and this is you know if you think if if you're if you have the knowledge and understanding the background wise and you think about his writing it's it's phenomenal it's outrageous and phenomenal but it's it's true I think it's true you know and everyone should decide but that that's what he's getting at and that's why those that have taken the time to study this letter to read it and also to study it and like he says um issue not to unhappen avert not just to grab one word open up right yes sir wake up he said this doesn't applies to you the that your friend you gave him the safer he opened up he saw one word he closed and he spit that's exactly what abuel says that's like saying Le babic and the altaraba are students of spinosis exact same thing and you should show and you should show him this last pattern of where he says that this idea don't hop on a vert read the whole thing cover the cousin with all the references I always tell me in my books though we'll have some of my books you want to find the Real Salt and Pepper and energy in my book you got to read the footnotes the footnote my footnotes generally speaking are not just you know a reference there's so much there that I don't want to put in the text and it's in there in other words so what I'm saying is a smart reader doesn't just read the text he reads the footnotes too and and anyone everyone knows that a good book must have a bibliography you know what I'm saying because the scholarship there you really want if you really want us then yeah Couch Potato reading is laid down you start reading the book yeah oh I saw that one shirt you have no idea what you read I don't know what it says okay yeah story time and story times past time now you know is so what were you saying when we finished what were you saying like he's gonna read the whole thing no you told me you told me but but I I make sure I I when when you get around to it if he comes back to discuss with you to point out that it's a in other words this is not just showing you're wrong that's not the point as a as a Tom McLaughlin what you said he is that a speaker and a teacher in general you you never you know poo poo is safer that's yeah if you're having salivate you can know you know in such a genius and you know cerebral salvation when he would come into her house sometimes and we see a certain safer in the shelf that he considered ridiculous he would say what are you doing with that here you know but that that's a salivation you know that that's a genius that's you know it's a master but us regular people and most teachers and probably including him if I may say so are not on that level where you know we we should you know throw out the baby with the water right away yes unison me yeah no more coming from the grave I can't cut his name is [Music] got killed by manifestation every day something happens and they don't care they just don't give you know we're going to have we don't have these into the rest of the boys the same continues to give us trouble with wake up you're talking I think to the to the choir here you know we're on we're on the same page I don't think anyone disagrees at the same time you're going to sit at the same time you know foreign years ago the biggest problems come from within ourselves that's it of course we we have anyway just this morning I sent a message to my son-in-law and daughter they should get a guard my daughter runs a gun in Tel Aviv and my son has a shoe I said gets the best security you know you know I'm being pro I'm doing you know I could say at the afternoon the way if someone has to pay for it but but the point is okay 100 you're Innocent but you know I don't know I have a feeling I have a feeling that if we eaten would have more opposite slow really between ourselves and we can live with love and yet disagree no one says you have to follow the same sheetah that's not Jewish that's not Terror but respect real respect you know and if we would live that way every one of us and have another one another one I I I think there would be a less a lot less of all these things happening and I'm not coming like you know Prophet or as far as it wasn't the Rebel's way went through their each path but the walls were made of glass so that we could path is just as developed for him as mine is for me and we can all see each other and respect each other I never heard it thank you beautiful fart that's a beautiful vart that's a good yeah so what I'm saying is you're listening of course there's no kahula when we have bombings innocent young man a teenager it's it's been at that bus stop probably you guys too I've been there I know exactly where that is you know where it is there's a lot of buses a lot of people and the highways and people are going and coming and then on the entrance to give a show there was another bomb and now they started with new stick they're not even there they do it the remote control you know that Israel says it looks like it's a new a new type a new style which is much more scariest wait I don't know you know if you could be over there and and just hit at this and it explodes you know that's why they're always right what's it called right they're getting help from Miranda of course of course of course so that we have the enemies like Jonas and said but Sheikh is still not here so of course how could you say it's how to the Gula but you understand argued was that we have a state we have our own country and Abuelo is going to you know he finished addressing the nationalism point and now he's gonna go to the giula point so we'll see everyone with Hashem on Monday and I wish everyone a a good high dish today is Christ tomorrow 39 years ago uh tonight my wife and I engaged this was our day I we we could have gotten engaged early I told my wife since the Reba the first time he came home after after five weeks he had a severe heart attacks 1977. five weeks later was the first time he left 770 and by accident this was such a big simcha for us we were dancing and singing and sailing Hein for seven days it was like it was shiversary so I said to my wife I'd like to you know ask right to the bracha that we want to engage and to get a bracha and um and packet came out the answer from the red bag it came out that ever blessed us and bless the Andrus height is kislav so um it's a very auspicious day not just personally thank you not just personally but for Claudius throw even though the best passed on and all that but the the the the message from from every day that a Sadiq gave the world is to be celebrated that doesn't mean you have to not go to Yeshiva and close your your business and not saying that but but it take a few moments to to reflect uh on on this and of course those of us that witnessed it and I think you're innocent was already in in Morristown you know you know it was uh it was uh you can't imagine the the bottles of the pumpkin were fly empty it was I mean the devil was close to death I mean he had a Dr Weiss from Chicago he said he didn't know how his heart he checked the heart you know five hours or so after he flew in uh and he checked it and and um he didn't know how it didn't make more damage and that he survived so Hashem wanted him and he was it was well for 15 more four years from 1977 to 1992 when he had his debilitating stroke which ultimately led to his passing in 94. so I can tell you that those 50 years 15 years is when the the Schlage movement was went into you know high gear and when and when and when families started to the barbecue started to have many more children because in the 19 early 80s 82 or 83 I think he spoke about not Family Planning and so the babbages started to have as many children as God gave gives them and so there was a whole and then the seven minute has told you uh he spoke about he spoke about gas and oil in in 83 or 84. so there was a plethora of very Universal and important things that he he gave to the world after this massive heart attack so so this isn't just you know a um a kind of well someone was sick and he was and he got a God saved him and God made him fine and he goes on we see clearly the trajectory of what he accomplished in those 15 years compared to the 15 years before and there's no comparison and I'll go one step further and conclude with this that if you look at the trajectory of from 1994 when Gibble Thomas when he passed away until today there's no comparison I went to the third Guinness the third kindness 1985. I was there we had maybe 80 to 100 guys that's it today there's there were 6 500 people at the New Jersey Convention Center this past Sunday night now granted that let's say a thousand people were balabathim still 5500 men people involved with Chabad institutions and when I went there was a hundred Macs yes yeah you know I I enjoyed it you know because it was very intimate and you know it's different feeling but so the trajectory of of what was done what happened since gimmel Thomas until 1994 till now that's uh 20 uh right or so many years later uh 29 years or so almost not going on 30. it's uh it's it's no comparison so you understand you're right all of these things are a tragic but there is there is there is sense to this madness there is sense to this madness there is sense to this madness and if you you know Yiddish we say the expression in the velvel how cup you know and how cup means how Mr hold cup means your head but literally means don't lose your head what's the expression of English what stay focused stay focused exactly stay focused there's a question a tragedy the tragedy a tear is a tear foreign stay focused on on on the goal clever have a great job as a great credit with everyone on Mondays like bye bye thank you