Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Zionism #14- Chabad opposes Zionism more than Satmar - Putting on Teffilin one time is essential
90 views
Categories:Torah/Chassidus
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay we'll start now
we're on page
I'm sorry koof Olive the last paragraph
agavis parentheses
the oil has been taught us that
the idea of a apple pieces
has to begin with the idea of Israel as
the basis
and the fact that is Israel Hotel
is very important and you can't just
dismiss it
and
at the same time you have to look at him
you have to know that it's important
not the sin
and to accept an ideology of
of sinners
being complacent in their position
just because they have nationalism is
not acceptable and he says in the
brackets agave
this is the brother
or Yahoo search Zeiss the rebel was the
one who instructed that the introduction
the letter of the rashab about Zionism
against Zionism should be publicized he
suffered the Kunta samayam as an
addendum to come to sumayan
in other words the the countries or
Mayan that we learned once
was written by the rashab as one of his
four contraceem his four essays that he
wrote
and it didn't have an addendum it just
it was the actual essay itself
when they printed it in in they when
they printed it
I guess during the 50s or 60s whatever
it was
it's printing I'm not sure if it was the
first time but the second third printing
the web instructed that they add the
letter of their shop as an addendum and
this I find interesting because I didn't
know it it was I would have thought that
the free the Caribbean instructed that
this be done and I I don't have rabiel
to ask here you know if if he's being
metallic which it seems he is he's being
particular in writing that the one who
instructed that the addendum be printed
together with the countries is the rebel
his point being um
from this itself one can understand well
our attitude meaning the rabbi and his
hasidum's attitude towards towards
zionists
so he he's saying to the to this satma
who's attacking the babic he's saying it
was the Le Bobby
who went a step further
than maybe his predecessor and he any
any and he instructed that the letter of
the Rashad be printed samayan
to imply and show how much we're against
Zionism
you got the point or not
is there a rum you're following yeah
okay yes okay I you know
and he writes and how ridiculous
means how ridiculous
the argument should tell him that some
argue that the satmar Arduino
I told you yesterday that the rabbit
deviated from the path
of the rashab he says that's ridiculous
he didn't deviate and Iota on the
contrary he instructed there were shops
LED it to be printed in the quintus of
mine when it wasn't necessary so he
deviated it's he who who pushed pushed
the envelope that's what he says in this
in this parenthesis
the depth of your heart attack
you believe in Hashem
Ellison
and therefore you inherently want to do
God's mistress next page type of Base
um
and this that you think you don't want
to do mean but God forbid you don't
believe believe you're not a
Believers
that's only the yait Sahara the evil
inclination that's convincing you
and he quotes
the words of the Rama that we said
before from
chapter 2.
that overpowers the person
isahara
opposes and fights your true inner self
we must beat him Lily until the Bible
just seen them explain to this Jewish
that being the Jew and committing a sin
are two opposites
this statement of causality even though
you you sinned he's a Jew whom
that's because of the panemius his real
penis your real Essence is that he wants
to fulfill the data
opposes and battles and fights his
jewishness
so in other words in this paragraph
that we just read learned that abuel
explains what the sheet of Lubavitch is
and how it understands the the
Israel who
and that is
that that that that that that every Jew
every single yeed wants to do the
Russian of Hashem as the rambam
rights rules
and it's only the extra hard on the
Netflix Obama is to come and overpower
him
his next paragraph Paige cuff bass
velvil cuff Bass
second paragraph
when we explain this to Aid
NASA is
there becomes the the right attitude the
right of scuffer the true Ash
which is contrary to the shita of
Zionism and what is the truth and we
what is the true
that a true is a Jew
let me tell you though the the fact that
he has a connection with Tata in a
concealed way
and that and that causes him to come to
the recognition
that is outer trimmings his outer uh
experiences
which in which he doesn't
is bad and bitter
that's that's that's the the truth
that's the reality
this idea of not keeping potato misses
is a fight that opposes yadus
the jewishness that's within your in the
summer
and this will ultimately bring into
Dutch oven
that is jewishness year laid out the
panemias over Helen that is Jewish it
should not just be inside and concealed
should be external and apparent
people speech of mice in action will
play a Mama's in actuality
in everyday life
and by the way what we just read
reinforces and and and refutes the the
lie that the babish that Chabad
you know saying just come in eat a good
meal and you can do whatever you want
you just heard it in front of you who's
the master in the name of that
that's a fallacy that's a lie and anyone
who's living that lie I don't care if
he's a chabotnik or not is a liar is is
wrong
the difference is the approach meaning
to say you know someone walks into your
shoes you say hey if you don't if you
don't cut off your long hair and you
don't cut off your this and you don't
get out of school and you're you're
Wicked no
but at the end of the day
yeah you got to make a change in your
life and you gotta you gotta work on not
allowing you Yates to Huda and you never
said Bob is to overpower you and stop
doing the Avera
so I just want you to to to know because
this has been I heard it I'm sure you've
heard it this has been one of the
accusations is oh yeah you go to you go
to Chabad and you can get away do
whatever you want that's a lie you can't
do whatever you want
but the the issue is whether you
pressure him right away or you bring
them in and you say there's there's a
there's 613 Mitzvahs and one day you
will you will Merit to do all 613 or as
many as possible
just like with a gate yes
I had I had this uh
with with a lot of people about this is
most of them were stuffed more on the
literature side it's an agricide and
basically what I tried to explain to
them and I don't know maybe you can
correct me if I was wrong but I said to
them the whole point of the mitza at
villain that you know I grew up with on
34th Street right yeah and watching that
I said it's about me it's about Disney
it's about a spark once a guy puts on a
beard so he never put a parent's villain
on you know maybe he'll get him to think
maybe he'll get him to feel you know
it's it's not that you put him on fill
it all of a sudden he's going to keep
all the Mitzvahs and everything it's
just it's like an introduction it's just
the spark like you light a match
that is true but it's even deeper as the
alternator says in chapter I think 34 of
Tanya and he says there every single
Mitzvah that's done by a year there's an
eternal Bond
so it's not it's so it's not just that
it's an introduction the actual Mitzvah
already puts you in the camp of a
straight potato mitzvahs
now the fastest you still aren't you
aren't keeping so many other misses well
guess what you and I aren't keeping all
mentors either so it's just a matter of
degree
but for so therefore desire I caught
this call someone who never put on fill
in karakafta the low Monarch thrilling
karkafta means ahead so aramaicafta
and desire writes very very negative
stuff about someone who never put on
film
so when you put on film with a yeet one
time in his life and he never again put
will put on thrilling you have taken him
out from the category of akarkafta de la
Monarch fill in into the category into a
category of a Jew that's put on
thrilling and that itself means that he
does everything desire writes that's
negative doesn't apply to him
well that that says we're in the in the
Zohar yes
desires no desire says that someone
that's ahead that's never put on fill in
desire writes very negative things very
strong things that will happen about
that person
so I'm now I'm I'm I'm extrapolating
so now if you put on Phil one time with
a Jew and he never again will put on
thrilling he no longer is in the
category of someone that never put on
thrilling
so everything the desire says that's
negative a bad against such a person
doesn't apply so you've done a great
favor for this Jew but that that's
another that could that's important for
you to know as well
but what I'm saying here in the is that
that mentions for Tanya that every
Mitzvah is a bond with Hashem a real
Bond not not it doesn't require another
Bond
every Mitzvah is a separate connection
and that's why that's really the
argument
to the to the literature and others
what's the big deal to put on film with
a Jew one time or two times or three
times if he's going home an hour later
and having a cheeseburger or turning on
the car or the television's not Shabbos
the answer is one thing has nothing to
do with the other and and and now we say
the third thing the third thing that you
said before that this will give him the
impetus and the desire to realize that
this is who he is in truth the Mitzvah
and to overcome The Temptations of the
eight Sahara and not to turn on the
second and the Devil Wants by fabranging
I remember in the 70s they never spoke
about you know even 74 I think they ever
came out with the Mitzvah of 75 that
girls should like candles from the age
of three on you know remember that that
whole thing like Lucas natives not just
married women
Joseph and others didn't agree some
agreed but didn't say shouldn't make a
brother it was a very big uh you know
discussion and disagreement in in the
from community
and many people did agree whatever so
the river the brain what if I bring us
said I got a letter from a mother who
said my little girl came home and she
was told in talmud Torah by some
kabadnik that taught a woman that she
the girl should light candles at from
right young young girls
and and my girl came home and she said
Mommy I want to have candle a candle to
light
so I said okay
the mother didn't like candles so it
came Friday night the devil said they
came Friday night the girl lit candles
she and she said their mother what's the
blessing
so the mother took out and helped her
with the blessing with the bracha but
then the mother was embarrassed that the
daughter is lighting she's not lighting
so the mother lit candles too
then the next shop is
the girl says to the mother how can the
television be playing when we light
candles when we're doing something for
Hashem
and mother said you're right
and the mother shut the television
so
and slowly but ever said the whole house
became a shame to shop his house
so what do you see
from one little girl lighting one candle
the house became machine shop his house
so the two things we have to know is the
fact that the house will become what
might become a Shameless house that's
that's great
but even if it doesn't become a famous
Shoppers house the fact that you light
up one candle you've done a Mitzvah and
that Mitzvah brings light into the world
to your family and it's Eternal that's
all
I did not gonna learn in kailu and they
might not learn to cuddle they might
either they might go to the movies an
hour later yeah
so if
the the person who imbused the message
and the person who hears the message
wakes up and says like this little girl
said to her mother they're not going to
go to the movies in a few weeks because
the little girl says how can you go to
the movies
we just did a Mitzvah we lit a candle
so it's all in the perspective and the
thing itself is the connection yes yes
sir
issue you want them to say something he
is oh I'm sorry okay let's continue
yes yes that was kind of our story
that's how we became the religious to
our daughter
she started going to every day school
and she started want to do more and more
stuff we end up following her alone as
they know the whole family's cave show
me Shabbos and give us your mind okay so
here it is
example you and your family of what the
rep said and that's for bringing it's
it's you know but but people just want
to you know say hey what's the big deal
they'll just put on film one time or
light a candle what
now I don't want to say something okay
so
I remember we had the discussion of your
999 go in and one comes out yeah
so so I have heard I've heard the
critique and I've seen myself
many people who are involved with Chabad
for years and years and years and
they're holding at the same place
as when they came in maybe they're doing
one Mitzvah or maybe they're going to
shul
but that's that's it that's the except
and it's years and years and years and
they're just they're staying where
they're at but to the story that you
told
99 go in and only one comes out
it's worth the one
yes yes but I want to just um add to
what you said is
I I do agree that even the the small
mixes I I understood
arguments right right
but why don't those that criticize ask
themselves a question and I'll ask the
question about myself
and
am I changing based and I learn and I
dive in and I teach am I changing to
what the way I know I'm supposed to be
no
no so so so if it's easy to say oh
they're just doing one Mitzvah and no
and I'm doing seven Mitzvahs and I'm
stuck at my seven misters what's the
difference
I'm worse because I know better pay the
lament and Tanya that's down today point
there they are sitting on the corners
with all the Schmutz in front of their
eyes with all the Temptations but mail
it but I'm not I'm sitting here in
Borough Park you're sitting in bed
shemash right and we're surrounded we
could do shintara and look how we look
and look what we do
compared to what we should be doing
we're doing nothing
so who's worse they are right so what
I'm saying it's so easy to say you know
um oh they're coming to Chabad house and
they're doing the same one mitzvah
foreign
they don't know any better than
ever taught us this is what I learned
from that but many things but
to always look at yourself really and
it's a heart but if you do if you're
honest and you'll see that you're a lot
worse than them
really because I know so much better I
know the way I doubt them it's not up to
par I know the way I learn or how much I
should be learning and I'm not doing
that I know that that's not him you know
is on and on so why what right do I have
to point the finger I'm telling you that
this is Sir is Clipper it's not coming
from kadusha at all I promise you
it's a Clipper because it makes you feel
the person better uh I can point the
finger on him and her at they and and
I'm doing so much better because I'm
religious
no
where did they come from where did they
come from what did they learn what they
know nothing little
okay we've we discussed it many times I
want to go back to the text let's go on
so he says
the second paragraph on the page
well I didn't say another point
is
the the war that wages against
nationalism
nationalism within Zionism the
nationalism of Zionism
let's take a look
at the style of chabad's opposition to
Zionism and nationalism he says how do
they do it through EK Mafia through
enlightening through Illuminating
there is by every Jew in a concealed way
yes this is a greater War my Muhammad
was opposition to Zionism
the Zionism and now he says okay the
husband said he said and to understand
what I just said that the approach of
Lubavitch
and it's a pro opposition to Zionism is
greater than satma's approach to Zionism
I'll give you an example
foreign
[Applause]
is false that's one thing they days
another way to oppose the bow
is
to make the announcement publicly the
gamla has been but but simultaneously to
explain
what does it mean to have belief in the
one God
Helix
the difference between these two Styles
is very is very very simple
the next to the last paragraph from the
bottom
foreign
we don't know about the other Idols
whether they are false right because
what am I attacking I'm saying this of
all the Zara this Idol is false my
shanking conversely
when we announce and we
explained we don't talk about the idol
we talk about what does it mean to
believe in God as I miss battling but
mailer then automatically are an old
coash
all ideologies of all Idols in the world
in other words but the second away
um the Volvo by understanding what a
moon and God is anything that's outside
of the morning God is false so whether
it's melee or bowel or this it makes no
difference
uses this as an example to our situation
for instance
the same things in our case
when we announce that nationalism within
of two years of Zionism is heresy which
is the sophomore way of doing it
it gives you no understanding what the
true essence of a Jew is you know
nothing about the Jew all you know is
you have to scream
outrageous throw the Rocks throw the
Rocks you're not teaching them Chavez's
you're just throwing the rocks
and if there comes along another
ideology of heresy that's similar to the
ideology of nationalism
could be that others will be will be
slept will follow it why because you
opposed only this Sita you throw the
Rocks only on Shabbos
or this this day it's all acceptable in
other words you're not attacking the
core issue by explaining what it means
to be a Jew you're attacking the
external aspect of the issue and
therefore you're
attacking one issue at a time and that
issue doesn't tell you anything about
anything else let's continue inside
even the the information that
nationalism is false but
but since you did not take the time to
explain why it's false
therefore the knowledge is very
superficial next page type of
cooked and it's not recognized and
understood from the inside of the person
shanking conversely because you must
beat him when you emphasize and you
announce
what the essence of a Jewish
does it he talks about what a true is
and that's what he emphasizes
therefore automatically will be an old
call ashita all the ideologies of
Heritage
by recognizing what the true essence of
a Jew is
whether those false Seekers will be
nationalism
so what's up y'all saying if you're
saying basically the approach that you
guys are doing is
I I have approach
or or in a way it's it's not it it
doesn't accomplish the goal because
you're attacking
this particular thing from the outside
you haven't given the person an
understanding of what it means to be a
Jew and to believe in Hashem etc etc and
therefore
something else comes along and they
don't see and hear the fire the fiery
storm against it they'll say I'll go
with this so that's what happened in
Russia right there was first communism
and intellectualism and humanism and
Zionism and every few years yet another
isn't so what happened yeah so when one
ISM fell aside because the person or the
group realized it's not as guidance
heresy they found something else another
isn't
but if you use the approach it says of
the of the Bible to show what a Jew is
and and once you understand what Aid is
that all Islams before sigh
automatically why because it contradicts
the the kernel the essence of what a Jew
is what time is it I don't have a watch
what time is it
3 15. okay yes unison
1975 I would be I was about a year from
Oh Come the about it and I had long
hair a bit of time went down to my
shoulders okay
and nobody said anything about cutting
my hair and it's not that nothing
but we're not born to feel him
every five minutes somebody came check
I couldn't take it anymore if I cut my
hair
yeah that's that's similar to right
that's it
it's similar to God the rubber secretary
who would walk back after the fabrangin
and he passed the store that was open on
Shabbos he didn't say anything he just
looked inside
from the outside he looked at the person
and the Egg was it was had a store open
the shop as he got embarrassed a month
later the store was closed in the
Shabbos Canada
we'll talk tomorrow Mom zeit is going to
have a great day bye bye
take it