HaRav Shach Praised Rebbe in 1982

i'm going out of shabbos [Music] actually hater tough shin pay aleph if i told you that the pondovich or shashiva the former panama shiva rabbi complemented would you believe it i know i as a teenager as a young adult as a midlife adult would never believe it so the story i'm going to tell you was publicized just this week in an in the eritrea website and it gave the documents to prove it but before i tell you the story just a brief introduction the panavicious shiva opposed the rebel lubavitch in many ways and it was a a very difficult situation in the sense that it led to much this much unhappiness much stress and many other such things and that is something that i'm not going to talk about that's not in my purview and as a hostage of the rebbe and the bavaj it's only natural to honor respect your rabbi your father in the sense that when someone disrespects him and embarrasses him and humiliates him and does so publicly you stand up for him but what i want to say is something that abhayam shalom deich told me this week i called him he was a student in ponovich from 1959 through the mid-60s i believe and he told me and he was very close to rabbi he learned by him and he said to me that he feels that his antagonism to the rebel later on in the 70s and 80s the 90s was not the age-old disagreement between snagden it was associated with his closeness with her to rabaran cutler which i already wrote about this in my book lakewood and lobovich at great length with documentation and for various reasons which we're not going to go into right now i just urge you to read what i wrote there rabaran opposed the frida karebe in particular his call for the alta lagi le chuvali alta lagiula truva will bring immediate redemption and rabara was concerned that that idea will lead to heresy god forbid because you know what if mashiach doesn't come there were other reasons that rabaran you know other reasons that he had issues with the previous rabbit of yeshiv which we're not going to go into at this moment was hired as a shiva teacher malamad a magic shirt in barabaran while his yeshiva was in class yet in europe in koletsk and rabbi dyche told me that he knows from various things that he heard or discussed with rabbi while he was in ponovich that bashar had a great respect for of aaron and he was still from those who didn't feel any changes to anything of traditional european jewelry should should should happen even though we're in eritrea's role and we're in america and times have changed but he was a very very old-fashioned that way so the idea of the khadesh ocean cipher's vert anything novel and new is forbidden uh was a very big believer in that and rabaran was as well and because they were close and they were related because rabaran's zalman foreign and ribes al meltz's nephew was rebecca so there was a familial relationship so from various angles there was a closeness and because and things like that which are not true of course but that was his concern now whether he's right or wrong i don't know but i say this because to bring you into the story so the story is that um [Music] in 1982 a trooper named rabbi mordecai yitzhak zucker of lakewood was working on his grandfather's safer his grandfather's name was um rabbi rottenberg mordechai rottenberg i believe and he wrote a safer yacht for yatmore and they pre-war and he never passed away in the war and he wanted to redo the safer make it nicer with footnotes and all that and he came across something there that um he didn't understand it was from the result it involved kabbalah so he decided he's going to ask his rebbe who was his rebbe he was his teacher as rasha shiva rabbi so he asked him about if you can explain this perplexing remark and rabbi shah said i don't deal with these issues this this is not something that i'm familiar with the one who can help you with this is the labacher you heard me right fellas you heard me right 1982 the heart of the beast the time when there was issues and sends rabbi zucker for clarification to the rebel because he knows this is not his field and the rebel knows that field well subsequent to that that ever wrote a letter to rabbi zucker which was you know a little unusual in the 80s for the river to write letters still he wrote more he answered set luck notes and made marks you know and then short comments but he wrote a letter and he explained not only that there was a mistake in the citation there and the word should be needs to be changed but he explained already the overall issue and robert zucker was blown away it's like i asked you this one question and all of a sudden you know you open up this entire understanding of which i really didn't get before and but you know of course you're the one that knows this field and thank you very much then they printed the safer in 1983 in tafsir mem gimble and on the page which originally was printed from the grandfather with the mistake they wrote in the footnote that there's a mistake here based on what we heard from will be a scroll and they didn't say the rebels name which um you know i don't know why um but um i'll allow you to uh come to your own conclusions but it does say that in a footnote so as we go into shabbos we have to know that is where it's at and it's now so many years later and we need to bring people together and to know that today they sing upon which the altar episode again there's no kiddish but the rabbis need not some of the is now sung in lakewood at various times i'm sorry in ponovich at the various times so they should help that we should have taka togetherness and unity and tomorrow shabbos is the yama lettuce of the rabbit and so it says gula it's a special time to say look hi and even monster shop is when you'll see this video mr sham on sunday you can still make up for it for it the first three days sunday monday tuesday still associated with the shabbos and to make lotus travis good decisions which is pizza to the record of mamish at one last point as i'm making this video today it's the art side of me looks rebel and he was a tremendous yidd as i discussed in the last video which if you haven't seen yet watch it uh because um he was a one-of-a-kind yid foreign