Essence of Chasidus #20- What's the difference between Kabbala and Chasidus - Study Chasidus

so today is wolf campbell's today's the outside of a friend a friend an acquaintance someone i know his name was uh uh dr arthur reinhard whose uh hebrew name is avrom eliezer he never married he left no children and um he was a supporter of the babbage institutions and i i knew him and i tried to keep his yard side so i'm dedicating the shirt our learning will tell us may have a lifting gun he was a doctor at kingsbrook which is crown heights you know you go straight down there open your kingston you get to a hospital called kingsbrook medical center and he was there he was the doctor there for many many years and um i i made a connection with him a pretty solid connection and invite him to my house for pesach and you know if he whatever hashem took him the way he the way he went i told you once i don't think it was in a very kosher way that uh i think it was a setup somehow by family relatives who wanted his money i mean but again i have no proof to that so we're just gonna leave it for now but the bottom line is is that his the summer returned uh in the late 60s 67 68 69 something like that 66 and um would keep us the shum i don't keep his yards i don't know he's buried but he's buried i was told he had a yiddish burial and um we did a lot of good from his you know money his parents money that you know he wasn't he didn't spend much on himself and he lived i was in his house and he lived where much type and david lives over there it's called um what's it called by the water by the water what seagate is seagate he lives in seagate uh i as a boy i never heard of seagate i never wasn't see dave but after i met him i went out there and um was in his house and you know you could see his living as a single and um whatever but um he was a good yeah he was a good heed you know he had a good summer and uh he did good things so i had to say potato written for his parents while he was alive and that terror now is in my son my son-in-law in tel aviv so they read the they read the title this weekend i think and yesterday you know and they read from it several other times so there is a potato as a memorial for for him getting back to the text that we're learning here and we have to learn a very important footnote in a moment but before that johnny asked a good question and whatever you need we did find an answer and the question ain't asked is that in this my mind this uh contrast chapter eight the rabbit says here that hasidus gives a new highness a new life force and energy in all other parts of thailand which is shocked and image through sight and he gives as an example on page 51 he says all the avoidance of him a plato god needs to do them and they receive and when your keeper comes out of shabbos and you normally bring the car to lucifer shabbos right that's why we we do musical shabbos so the the the the yom kippur feelers elevate the muscle feelers so in other words the muscle the muscle feeler of your keeper qualitatively is a different muscle this is what he said so he asked the question why does he choose muslim why doesn't he choose rosh hashanah rashad is the head of the year and he made another good point that the you know the mouth he is so prominent in other words as far as music is concerned in our liturgy which stands out more the muslim yom kippur the muslim rosh hashanah i mean i mean that you can argue because because remember during muslim kipper you have the avoider but that's already the avoid the part of most of muslims the technical music of of yom kippur compared to the muslim it would seem and feels whether it is or not but you know it's it's shapeless this question was why not highlight that that and the answer is i should have got it but i you know i wasn't thinking i just heard the question i put it off but i'm thinking about discussing it with a friend the answer is what makes young kipper special naila right your kipper would not be anything other than a regular young thing if not for the ila right because there are other holidays in which we have we have uh the yamato will have all the four fort felix and then and and um and the special reading and all that what makes them keep it different the fifth field in the ela what is neela correspond to we we learn to yeshida to the the fifth aspect of the shaman that's most unique oneness no so that issue yay only exists i'm your keeper in other words what what i failed to explain is when we say whatever says he when he quotes the mishnah that the muslim of yom kippur becomes special because of young kipper what is your keeper neila so if he said that about you that's not true rosh hashanah he's not five fellas it's only four so now that rosh hashanah does not yet express the and that's the point that he's trying to make here that is so you have shot remember corresponding to the four trilos the four prayers of every holiday only when you have yeshida when you have siddhas that then which is analogous to yakita then the entire other thrillers become qualitatively different is that clear yes my yes what would you say can you say it shout out so which is which like which feels right right i again i don't know that now i i i believe it's brought in kabbalah i but i didn't research it so i'm not going to give you a bubble mindset um and it's not relevant really to the to the text which is which but it's a good question to put on hold and to get back to and believe that if i get a chance i'll try to i don't have slaughter in here you know but i hope i'll get to that sometime but you are thinking that's what's important not serious that means you've found a problem you want to say something i just want to answer his question uh yes those other foreign parts of the soul yeah so again that too if you're going to ask me which part corresponds to what to what i i i want to i want to look at that you know i don't i don't i want to give you the right answer it's not just pick and choose it's pick and choose my riff is this it doesn't work that way i i just for a second you see understand especially when it comes to kabbalah and this is a mistake you know this whole this whole world of gematria it it's become such a joke in other words if you could show me a correlation between my riff of of of your kipper and the level of nephesh then we could talk business you understand but you got to show me the connection i i could i could i believe i could figure it out you know what i'm saying but i i'm not thinking that way i want to i'm going to get to the footnote so um but the question that you're asking of rum along the line of what with moisture asked is good and let me let me get to it hopefully sometime later very good okay so here there's footnote 71. i need you to turn there and here we learned the text on page 48 in the english take a look at the english side the last paragraph of the text on page 48. it says here that in addition to the explanations which you see this gives to various subjects within all four parts of canada which negates the common misconception that facilities arose in order to explain only the esoteric part of torah now that ever writes these words he says the misconception and i'm telling you he's boy is he right because it's a big misconception as average man on the street young he walked down uh rodney avenue williamsburg 13th avenue park um whatever streets in muncie and you shall i aim about what a siddhis the average person who's a closet is going to tell you it's an explanation of kabbalah and what the rabbit says here is that it's not an explanation of cabola yes when you learn siddhis and it uses some kabbalistic language and ideas it automatically through the understanding of accidents those ideas become clear that's true but not that siddhis is an explanation of cabola and and velvet what's the logical argument for that position because if siddhis is just an explanation of kabbalah then it's not a fifth level then it's not five it's only four and and and so big deal some say it's four it's not five why must it be five because you decided because i decided because the rabbit decided no and this is where it touches your question i've run because there are five levels on your shoulder issa put your camera down i'd like to see your face since they're four left there there are four five levels of the nephesh and that's what in kabbalah so it behooves us to say what aspect of my meshung my being is so and therefore it also behooves us to say what aspect of torah is so this kind of brings us to understand that there is something that's greater than the four which is yeshida the oneness the uniqueness you could say this way then the ela within the soul then the ela within the world throughout the year and that's your freedom so if that's the case siddhis is not kabbalah kabbalah is one out of four and yahida is five so yahid is unique in it it has it just like capollo is unique that it's sold shot remiss brush soap so too yahida has its uniqueness but it's five it's five we normally have four what do you mean it's five and this is the rabbit's thesis in this essay that sydness is five and that illuminates every other aspect of torah as as we as you will see later in the countries as we continue learning we don't yet have a full explanation but i want to go to number 71. so he quotes here derebra in torah page 172 the world considers see this to be an explanation of kabbalah that is a mistake remember this is now from the rashad the statement concludes kabbalah is next page 50 is an explanation of siddhis wow the rashad turns it around and he says no no no you think citizen explains the couple you have it wrong compilers and explanations of cities to explain see this to explain sorry to explain in other words let's clap explain the rashad's words see this is the comprehension comprehension of divinity remember you want a definition for sinners here it is it's the comprehension of divinity right there is divinity we'll call that in hebrew get used to that word elokos is divinity you want to understand we want to understand that divinity that's called the comprehension of divinity siddhis gives us the tools to comprehend divinity yahida is in the feminine form it receives from skip this bracket let's go to the c8 the smallest part of god closed itself for the smallest part of man and it's called siddhis okay we'll go ahead sid this achieves this comprehension of god by using analogies parallels and explanations kabbalah though explains that's what i told you was the pipelines the location of god in terms of the body of the king and the sphero conception so cabela says kabul says kabul the right hand is tested the left hand is vula etc and we label the parts if you've seen you know secular writers and others they put a diagram of a human being and they label the human being by the that's caballus it's coming out in kabul it should be also be noted that the revelations of kessa analogous to darkness why is tesla darkness clever something called kessler right the crown above because it's so great and so powerful that to us it's dark we don't understand it so we call it darkness kessler isn't okay as discussed in chapter two so this is the effusion of new radius from okay this is getting a little heavy we're gonna skip this not relevant right now hold down um go to the next paragraph the bottom of 50. there are two major ideas discussed here the manner in which kabbalah is an explanation of cities and not vice versa and number two the fact that caballo is only an explanation a reduced reflection and does not capture the essence of cities so in other words like this one aspect is that kabbalah explains to you so the other one is that kabbalah only explains a glimpse of sinners not all of cities in the first part that ever distinguishes between the nature and methods of comprehension of comprehending god of citizen kabbalah and that is a descriptive anatomy so to speak of the body of the king that is the various manifestations of divinity it is interested in indexing i like that cataloging even better and locating these divine revelations assigning them places and names so is there when you make a bracha on wine friday night you make kiddush that's one location and if you want to know the location you have to know what shame hashems are being said in the brother and i told you once i saw someone do this as he held the cup and he made kids very slowly and someone do i know well and i asked him like what the kids are going to make to this and he said he was having a mind of the shame hashem in that particular brother yesterday [Music] okay with the steady way you have to have your mind saving his penis then you have to every morning death right so so youngster gave us an example a real life example of the covenants that you need to have for a particular breath at a particular time so that's called the location the indexing as he says here in the catalog hence let's go back and attack the footnote hence cabola is concerned with the technical identities and relations between the sphero the worlds i want you to make a note either here on paper on the safer that if you ever are looking to explain to someone the difference between citizen kabbalah refer to this you know but study it thoroughly and get it and get it but this is one of the places that i always think of of a place where you could see an explanation to the difference because it's so relevant to people when they say oh all in one okay siddhis however is concerned with the direct perception of divinity natural analogies underlying all these terms forms and locations you hear that sidness is not concerned with the locations the indexing the comatry is and all of that see this is concerned about divinity direct god the god that underlines all the indexing and all the gematrias that's what civ is concerned about let's go further it will thus employ all manner of explanations example parallels including kapolei in order to reveal the essence of divinity expressed in all levels that is kapolei is the technical explanation of these forms and terms in themselves while siddhis only uses and is interested in these forms as a means for perceiving divinity that's a beautiful word siddhis is not interested in the analogies and forms and and cataloging and indexing and democracy for its own sake it uses it to understand divinity god itself in other words my shirt if someone says you know what god is see let's see what what joeys have said before with the terrain one is being and all that right when is that important and and why is that is because there's a divinity behind it otherwise who cares who cares in other words so you need to relate to the divinity however the divinity takes a form of expression ceres but if you if you if you don't have the divinity behind it it's a meaningless experience so you could find an individual that's very knowledgeable in the yakuti and everything else and guess what and it has nothing to do with divinity it's an exercise it's a mind exercise there are people that like mathematics there are people like science there are people that like you know other fields of study and this falls into it but where is the divinity the godliness citizens deals with the godliness and it's okay again it's said we say in one word so this deals with godliness that's a whole study of who is god what is god what is god not how do i fit into the picture as the wolf yesterday and i'd you when i say something no okay good thing well so as discussed earlier analogy our doctor is still here no he went off but let's see here's an analogy if is this a physician uses biology chemistry anatomy only to gain comprehension of the body's essential life force in order that he may be able to bottom of 51 heal he is not interested in anatomy in and for its own sake but only in so far as it helps him further understand the nature of the body's existence similarly kabbalah is an anatomy so to speak while siddhis is concerned with the essential comprehension of god's being in existence that ever then proceeds to analyze the nature of kabbalah as a revelation of siddhis another analogy the anatomy test book helps the physician understand the body not the body nevertheless the text is only a schematic secondary reflection of the body and not of course the essence of the body's life force itself furthermore the full force and essence of the physician's understanding of the human body is demonstrated not in his particular knowledge of anatomy but in the practical effects of the healing similarly in kabbalah one is a revelation in quotes an explanation of siddhis is merely an explanation and not the essence of the citizen self the essence of sinners is captured only in action and practical deed this thing here is is powerful and it's so true well one second one second i i was i was waiting for your hand one second you might be wondering what if you ever say what cabo is not what a person who's a serious bomb of couples cabola is not looking to do it practical what what what is the what is the kabbalah part of his practicality you know as you said before have a mind that say right and settle that's not practical that is practical but it's not practical put it on triple putting them azusa if i read if i read the brother correctly with a sample or a set right i read i pronounce it correctly and i have no idea like most people don't and they're not interested they don't know they don't care same with being a cop but leave me alone have i done the mitzvah absolutely nothing is missing not an iota so to say that knowing the second one that say ray and this name of god and this pronunciation is practical it's not it's practical in its own sense but not compared to the mitzvah to the bottom line so cabola cabola was what was the english word esoteric mystical the meaning of which the connotation it's not practical see this it's just the opposite just the opposite you can learn and learn to learn and if you don't do you're not hasidic you're not a hostage because sin is about divine and divine is myself that's the nakuda the vinity is mindset what are we learning in this foreign operation north korea from the same but the edge is west in the beginning and the beginning is west in the air end what's the beginning of the thought what's the end action myself says in the sperm knows to be lost in the sight from the same from the colossal they're wedged in each other what does that mean that means if you strip and remove the self from the beginning and the beginning from the soap you're not plugged in you're not plugged in in divinity you're plugged into somewhere else i've run what do you want to say sorry yeah i was i was given the definition many years ago uh like this because is a verb a citizen is a verb and a present is one who does tests with man and with his neighbor that's from tanya chapter 10 and that's very nice but uh and it doesn't contradict what we're learning here it's no not a contradiction at all but the essence of considers is captured only in action practically that was the message of because is a verb meaning it's action ah i got it very good i had it i hear you contradiction at all right right right i didn't i i right what time is it what's the time okay okay um so i i took the time there's more but i took the time to learn this section of the footnote because it's very very valuable and i you know you know the way to learn this footnote is skip over the you know the cabola parts just try to get the more rational part so that you could you could you could become clear to you in your mind because if you read every single line without whatever you know it's gonna it's gonna throw you off because you know he interjects but if you stay away from the kessler and this that i'm not saying we shouldn't learn it but you know to understand the difference like citizen kabbalah of each this is a i feel a good english um essay kind of to explain i mean do you do you agree i mean what what do you think uh february and other others are available any comments or some workplace yeah i think it's very good think it's i think it's uh i think it's very good i know i've had many experiences with people speaking with people and they're not they're not most people are not aware of the difference between the citizen cabela's it's exactly right but what was the explanation that uh because it is not an explanation of kabbalah but it flips on its head so much of what they come and understand i know i know and and and i i still have to think about that part i didn't spend a lot of time on that what does that mean cabal is an explanation so i think what it means is because that's a very powerful statement and what does it mean it means that see this is about divinity which is my set capola comes to give you the pipelines of that action so what it says cabela's an explanation of citizens knows here's my problem with hearing this kabbalah's esoterics what do you mean it's an explanation of siddhis it's mysticism it's mystical it means an explanation it's no explanation of sickness it makes it more enough it makes it more removed that that's when i read that that's what i that's what threw me for a loop and i think the answer is what it means is that since sid is about like you said the verb the action kabbalah tells you it explains to you where to place that action and this sphere on that sphere on the right and the left ventricle in the back in the front and the head i think that's what he means by that that's what it means that kabbalah is an explanation of siddhis will continue tomorrow and uh and everyone else only simply don't have good things and it's a good month yes sir you want to say something thank you everyone have a great day take care bye-bye