Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Constructive Criticism - 17 of 31
7 views
Categories:Torah/Chassidus
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
figuring out it was most of introduction
the front of the safe the seeker at the
end of the first volume of the
Encyclopedia and that is what became
known as Quintus in your original Taurus
I shall see this you have a question you
wanna ask so anyway
why am I saying that so in that
countries the rebus says and it gives a
muscle for mother Ani that basically
Hasid as' is what he calls the fifth
part of Torah corresponding to your
feeder right there's five aspects to the
soul nefesh rule of the Shama hayashida
so your feeder is oneness and it's said
so the rabbi says it's like shemin's
like compared to oil which is my failure
say how cool it rises to the top if you
have other liquids always something
that's oil it rises to the top and that
episode see this is the energy that
enlivens every other part of Torah so in
other words it's not cosmic show love
outside of Torah it's an aspect of Torah
that enlightens the other parts of Torah
to understand what I just said you have
to study that country theatre studies
very well okay if you really want to and
it's an important work to understand and
it's a difficult work I'm not going to
say it's an easy work to understand but
it's very crucial to our sheering today
from p.m. both in English in addition
Hebrew women on that country so it would
be worthwhile to to learn it and I think
you ever have a shave here in the
community okay anyway so so I say that
because because we encounter as if
you've seen Sakarya you you know
ourselves that that there are bay and
bring and on one hand you could you
could say like it's like what's the
question what's the issue you know the
you know have a way of resolving it and
at times the
the questions are better than the
answers so you have to understand that
to appreciate am i Maha siddhis
it's not about questions that's not
about answers that's that's I think the
difficulty for a Western thinker and
we're trained in the Western Way of
thinking you know rabbi Zalman Posner
has a book called think Jewish and I
really urge you to read that book
because in that book he tackles this
idea what's Jewish thinking for Torah
thinking versus Western thinking and
basically and I read this as a as a
teenager and there's no young you know
the as I got into the work of slickness
and key Rovin and her father you know
know that it was very helpful because he
explains that it's two diametrically
opposite ways of going about a severe
subject an idea there's a Torah way of
thinking going about it and there's a
Western way and we're not talking about
a Western Way with in Torah Western Way
of thinking right that that's and the
supposin really tackles that it's a very
important very important to understand
that as well so I say this because when
you move to cities and you see a
question you've seen the answer and kind
of you know either yeah I got it I don't
it turns me on it doesn't turn me on
their battery answers in the
commentaries of the Talmud of the hummus
you know so you have to understand that
that's not the Iker of a minor that's
not what the Mimer
is is there to to get you excited about
and thinking about it's the content the
bulk of the minor you know that they're
certain my more'n if you look into the
my moorim of the fifth rubber the rubber
a sharp show um bear of the Babich where
it begins with the words will have an
onion to understand the
concept it doesn't even have a headache
a passage or a huzzah and in fact many
my mom were that way and then when they
obey Him went that's when they said it
when it came time to actually write the
Mimer they put a heading and end to it
so it makes more sense when you when you
when you read them paper when you learn
it on the paper what we see from that at
the beginning in the end that's not
that's not certainly the mind the minor
is the subject matter of godliness and
divinity that were that were that were
that's being discussed a minor like this
which is called in a bad language a
Nevada minor there's two types of my
morin two types of about discourses once
called Haskalah Mimer
or my Marin the the the discourses that
deal more with the intellectual right
the philosophical and then there is my
murim like this one where the subject
matter pretty much is avoider is service
refinement character development and
improvement
that's called avodah my Marin so in in
in both the subject matter is what
what's what's occur so I'm just I just
took a few minutes to to give you a
general overview of the structure of a
minor and therefore the questions an
answer and sometimes like in here it
could be a page long you know Martha
thought oh him and the Hazael you know
I'm saying but you don't need the - you
don't need a mind for that go to shops
go to the with the before shin I'm
saying you could it's not what you did
the my before the - deer to motivate you
intellectually and emotionally to be a
better servant of a shell and the whole
content of a my mirth is is Eliquis is
godliness you know there were Hasidic
that they in the old days we didn't have
swaram and if you know things and they
were hassidim today I heard this from my
spam they would learn and then they
would turn the page and the next page
didn't connect to the page and form
because they had torn pages and they
were so it's a continuation why because
they were driven to for the godliness
here they're looking for God so what's
the difference if it'll actually the
question the answer bromance you know I
find God on this page and I find that
Shem on this page but getting back to
what we're learning here it's all about
the idea of of authority and how someone
who was put in the position of authority
needs to deal with the people who he is
direct and this is what we're saying and
that ever said in on-page race you dress
he said he began giving us what we call
the criteria for criticism that Dovid
levy has been announcing constructive
criticism and what what are the points a
point one was Dov it let's see do you
remember what was point one