Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
is going to be amazing don't you realize
what's happening what's happening is the
entire youth is saying tati mommy Bobby
said give me a Yiddish guide that is
purged from corruption from hypocrisy
from superficiality from stupidity from
Superstition from abuse from molestation
from addiction from leadership yeah that
is completely completely clueless and
detached from the conditions of people
give me a Yiddish guide that Embraces
the full spectrum of The Human
Experience give me a Yiddish guy that
allows me to celebrate my soul my heart
my body my mind my God my world my
existence that's really what's happening
the yeshiva.net
so in general
humans all of us
we've never been healthier we've never
been more authentic more vulnerable and
a lot of what we know today is coming
from obviously from The Source from Tara
but a lot of it's coming from the world
around us from the secular World from
psychology telling us about the
importance of working on ourselves
therapy psycho education and at the same
time many people specifically the youth
younger people are also being influenced
and impacted by the I want to call it
the woke world of tick tock or Instagram
you know even my my children will come
to me I heard about this I think like
well where did you hear about it she
said uh from Tick Tock it's like they're
getting their information this way
um and I'm not only talking about teens
I'm talking about younger people as well
young adults as well and we're seeing a
lot of amazing things happening we're
seeing teens that are working on
themselves young adults that are doing
their hard work and really changing
themselves from the inside out and at
the same time what we're also seeing is
um there are some ideas of victimhood
that are coming through and the left
liberalism mentality is spewing their
own ideology and their own thoughts and
they're it's coming through as well and
although they do have some truth in what
they're saying because we know that
everything stems from some is grounded
in truth
they have
there's a lot of victimhood and they're
getting stuck a little bit in this
victimhood
you know you and that's coming through a
little bit and it is holding people back
from truly growing and healing and I
know last year Yates
like a six hour for bringing that I
listened to and it was so incredible and
so life-changing in so many ways you
said many many incredible things there
and it was very revolutionary
and although they're all teachings from
the Revan from Sidis it felt very new
and it felt very much like a new
approach to the world
um you shared ideas about how people are
not bad but they're they're broken
um and so my first question is this is a
two-part question my first question is
how do we discern how do we
differentiate between what is coming out
of the tick tock Instagram woke liberal
leftist ideology victimhood mentality
and what is the real authentic
um true tyridica
um hasidis and because if somebody wants
to say and I'm sure there are people
that will say that some of the teaching
some of the classes that you're giving
have that I don't want to say um flavor
but I will say that it has that idea
coming through very very new Agee oh
it's not only Luigi it has that elements
of of those ideas that are coming
through a little bit even though I don't
hear them but I've heard people say this
and I want to add another layer a layer
to that is how would you respond to
people who would claim and say what
you're doing what you're teaching is no
different than what happened in the
early 19th century with the beginning of
the conservative movement that they
wanted to maintain the Jewish tradition
and they wanted to just adapt it to the
modern world because it sounds oddly
similar to the way that we are
approaching all this so two parks two
questions I know it was long-winded but
if you can help bring some clarity to
that question let me add one line on
that I think the term you guys used on
the yitza for bringing multiple times
was
that the times have changed and the
nature of people have changed and you
know it's one thing if I Reba tells us
that the times have changed and the Nate
or the rambam says that nature of our
bodies have changed fruits before the
elastic but it's you know with due
respect to you and there's incredible
amount of respect many are tiny who who
are these new thing old leaders to say
all these things
right
okay beautiful beautiful questions and
thank you for the candidness and the
opportunity to
address these questions with candidness
and sincerity and even you know with
some brevity but at least at least try
with God's help to give some clarity at
least the way I see it
in terms of your first question how do
you differentiate between what is
authentically Judaism
and what may be an influence not just
from the secular world but sometimes the
very left liberal secular world that is
very alienated
from the whole idea of Judaism entire
and God then responsibility and morality
and good and evil and all that how does
one differentiate between the two
I think
there are a few things but I would point
out two two major points
and that is
the first thing is you look at the
litmus test this I would I heard from
the rabbit from the Bible many many
times he would say sometimes there's
confusion in life you know when somebody
is teaching something is it good is it
not good it sounds good but you're not
sure
sometimes your own emotions are
confusing I'm having an emotion
should I cherish this emotion and go
with it
or maybe this is one of the emotions you
know I could bring up to my therapist
but I shouldn't really run with it I
should maybe quarantine it and say you
know you you're under invest you're
under investigation let's put it that
way we have to bring in the FBI and this
we can get rid of it maybe but how do I
know it's not always clear you know
obviously if you have an emotion to burn
down your house and shoot somebody today
we know what Judaism says about that but
we know not everything is so is so black
and white there are things ambiguous and
he would say something that seems simple
but it's really pretty profound he said
you have to always look at what are the
results in the person's behavioral life
if I hear a class right and as a result
of that class that night I am kinder to
my wife I am kinder to my children
I may pray to Hashem with more sincerity
I may be able to share my love
with more expansiveness and with less
inhibition I have more enthusiasm in my
learning of Torah and my celebration of
Mitzvahs my Shabbos table becomes a
warmer experience and my children
feel that their tati is more present and
more loving and they become closer to me
then you know
this is the devil would say you look at
the results the actions if you see
people becoming better
whatever better it means better from the
Jewish perspective entire
whatever it may be in their personal
life in their social lives in their
business life I'm becoming more honest
less gossip less slander less hate less
resentment less jealousy less negativity
more love more empathy that's it that's
the sign if it's taking me away from my
loved ones it's making me more selfish
more condescending more self-centered
less focused on bringing good into this
world and into my life then yes it
should be under a question mark So I
think it's very very important you know
when when people are listening to
classes what are these classes
motivating to you to do afterwards do
they tell you oh uh you know get into a
fight with your spouse get into a fight
with everybody you know you know stop
talking to your sister and also stop
talking to your sister-in-law
stop talking to your brother make sure
to never forgive anybody and go make
sure to go to sleep with a lot of
bitterness and resentment for you being
the only intelligent person on this
planet and everybody else being idiotic
then yeah those classes should be put
under investigation I think that's one
very very important thing we have to
really see the results if I hear from a
person that as a result of my class he
or she can now keep Shabbos
where they weren't keeping Shabbos or
somebody has been inspired to be able to
get help for their addiction
or somebody decided not to get divorced
and work on their marriage or somebody
for the first time in five years reached
out to their child
and started a relationship what does
that tell me
if that's not if that's not what Taylor
wants then what it what what is it that
Tyra wants let's remember the statement
of the rambam the rambam writes at the
end of the laws of tamura
something very powerful that the devil
would always quote he would say
which means most majority of all laws of
Torah you talk about all laws laws about
purity and ritual impurity learns about
laws about laws about sacrifices that
are there to help people repair their
Consciousness their mindsets their
deities their their perspectives their
opinions their feelings and make their
actions beautiful and upright
so whenever we see that classes entire
are helping people do that I think
that's a pretty powerful litmus test
I don't think it's the only but I think
it's a very powerful litmus test for it
being authentically rooted the second
thing that is always connected with
sources
which I try to be very meticulous about
most of my classes are textual classes I
do a lot of lectures but there's a
reason for it textual classes are often
more difficult to give and less
inspiring because they're tedious as you
know I teach a lot of most my classes
are textual classes and a lot of people
say I don't like that I just want you
know good joke a good story a good
message the reason I do that is for this
specific reason
anybody who sincerely sincerely learns
all of the works of the balshamtov he
didn't write them himself but his
students wrote them all the works of the
Margaret of Ms rich and their students
from all of the various Hasidic branches
people will be shocked
on the depths of love and compassion and
empathy that they continuously espouse
so yes it's the exact opposite the
reason the secular world started to
catch on to all these ideas is because
it first came into the world through the
spiritual masters of Judaism who have
revolutionized the landscape of Judaism
and once an energy is Unleashed into the
world the whole world receives it in
fact the katsuki everyone said something
amazing he said listen to this what he
said he said the reason why in the 19th
century there was an explosion of
romance in the secular World it used to
be marriage of Russian more as a
technical institution the 19th century
with all of the novels there was a
change of culture it's about love and
romance he says you know how that came
about he said that came out from the
Hasidic movement
the Hasidic movement he said opened up
the gates of love in heaven and the
whole world the whole world tapped into
it
so you could say romance love disgusting
immodest horrible you could say that and
you know what sometimes romance can be
very disgusting you know what if it's
with another wife not your own wife yeah
it's pretty disgusting
exactly and if I'm cheating and if I'm
dishonest and if I'm betraying my my
most important relationships romance
could be the most horrible thing but
romance essentially is the ability to
celebrate love it's the ability to be in
a relationship with Ecstasy with
enthusiasm where two people who cherish
each other wake up every morning smile
at each other and thank God that they
have each other in their life that's not
evil that's not impurity so this is what
the katsuki ever argued it really goes
back to the song of songs I'm just
giving an example so a lot of the most
powerful truths about the goodness in
people
I mean anyone who who even touched the
most superficial layer of Hasidic let's
call it teachings and writings Chabad or
otherwise knows that the tenet that
goodness is at the core of every person
is an absolute
so when we take that seriously and we
turn it into a holistic lifestyle it's
basically taking the balchemito's
teachings and really living with them
now we always have to be careful because
boundaries could be crossed we're all
human we're all prone to error and
that's why nobody should be above
scrutiny nobody should be above
investigation everyone should be
entitled to ask the question as we have
in Allah
what's your Source I once heard from my
brother it was a very wise thing he said
how do you know that you've chosen a
good Rabbi in life and he said ask the
rabbi a question and the rabbi will tell
you an answer and then ask him what's
your Source what's your Source he was
talking to Bali chuva the people who
returned to Judas if he looks at you in
this Dane like you're asking me what's
my Source Who Do You Think You Are I've
been doing this for 70 years you don't
even know how to read Hebrew it says
he's not the right Rabbi for you if he
humbly says here let me show you the
book here let's look at the source
together or I don't remember now let me
get back to you tomorrow or in a week
and I'll show you my source that's
correct because there is humility here
so whenever we have that ability to know
that somebody is ready to do that and
discuss it and say I'm sorry if I made a
mistake I think these are some of the
what I would suggest would be very
authentic litmus tests that somebody is
following the trajectory in the path of
Torah or somebody's deviating from it
when you say What's the difference
between the conservative or reformed
movement of the 18 movements of the 18th
century and some of the classes that
some of us are giving today
it's it's it's a it's a wonderful
question it's obviously a painful
question
but I think I hear again it's a very
very clear litmus test the mistake of
the conservative and reform movements
and many of their leaders had good
intentions it's important to emphasize
that not everybody had malicious intent
some people had very very good
intentions was they absolutely invited
and ushered in a path which literally
breached some of the absolute halachas
in Judaism
they compromised them they felt maybe
you had to they felt the youth won't buy
into it but they turned certain Mitzvahs
into irrelevant and they clearly called
for the breaking of what we were called
the code of the Jewish law and I think
in Jewish history that's been a very
very healthy litmus test meaning when
any Rabbi or teacher says you know
instead of Shabbos instead of making a
meal on Shabbos will start gardening on
Shabbos or we'll do other things that
violate Shabbos whatever it is the
moment one breaks what we call the
Messiah the halacha the Integrity of
Jewish law then obviously this is a
deviation of traditional Torah observant
Judaism and they may have good
intentions but they're making a
historical error because we're here
three and a half thousand years later
because of that tradition but within the
context of Allah within the context of
Judaism when somebody's emphasizing
certain points or bringing out certain
truth that actually allow people to
celebrate the Mitzvahs with more
enthusiasm and with more passion than I
think it's it's on the contrary I think
it's also important to point out till
now I was under defense now I'm going to
go a little offense and that is it
almost seems to me and I say this with
really with a lot of respect because
I just don't have judgmentalism inside
of me so I really I just don't judge
people I really I've seen enough pain in
my life not to judge people so I really
don't say this was judgmentalism but it
almost seems to me I told this to
somebody
that if Judaism sounds too happy
and giving people too much Serenity and
trust and celebration it almost sounds
like that some people think it must be
heresy in other words if I would get up
and give speeches fire and brimstone and
tell people how evil they are how
disgusting they are how their children
are even worse than them and their
children are worse than them and we live
in the most horrible horrible generation
ever and the entitlement of our kids
they are brats they are all suffering
from narcissism and it's all their
parents fault their parents who are
listening to podcasts by racial
Schusterman or other gurus who are
teaching them to feel entitled and every
emotion that they have has to be
worshiped and if they haven't had
problems in childhood there must be
something wrong with them just to say
thank you to Mommy and tati is the most
horrible thing in today's error and you
are all teaching this to them and if you
would just tell them the truth that they
are horrible self-centered monsters who
are destroying tradition destroying
their families and they should repent
that somehow for some people sounds very
very Jewish oh this is tired this is
mitzvous you know what I feel bad for
you
because if this is really what God comes
down to him but the whole Terror comes
down to okay I can I can honor your
perspective but when somebody says
that there's a Judaism that we can teach
people that makes them feel alive and
empowered
allows people to explore every single
part of themselves and not amputate
anything
allows people to confront all their
darkness and through pain go out of the
pain and even transform it and develop
the deepest forms of marriages and
relationships that are based on
vulnerability and authenticity where
people can really celebrate life
I think that's the most exciting thing
that I would love to hear and if we
believe that we are on a journey from
exile to Redemption isn't the definition
of redemption
that the glory of Hashem of God is
revealed in the world and Judaism
becomes organic not any more traumatic
and not any more repressive
so I would argue that any class that I
hear in Judaism that is not making us
feel the celebration of the infinite and
the celebration of goodness is probably
a very very narrow version of Judaism
and I think our youth deserves and is
eager to hear something much deeper and
more authentic
okay that's very very powerful if I can
drill down a little bit and I'm not
holding on to the need or the desire to
have miserable Judaism but so it's but
but to drill down on this idea of quote
unquote new ideas so it's clear that if
it's sourced
um and it's beautiful
then it's good
um and and certainly can I violate the
boundaries of Allah but there's also
and there's just certain things that are
they're they're not black and white
they're not law they're just Traditions
the way the way things have been done
forever like and your knowledge of
history is certainly certainly going to
be better than mine but was there a time
when you describe was the beautiful that
you just described
I mean I mean prior to today's
generation maybe right great question so
I'm gonna address I want to just add one
more part to that just wanted to add a
layer to that I apologize for
interrupting you said the word litmus
test
and you said if the litmus test is a way
to gauge and the rabbit you heard the
rabbit talk about this was the results
look at the results so I would hear I
could hear people saying to me okay then
if that's the case so let's look at the
letting us test all of you are being so
open-minded and so warm and so welcoming
let's look at our youth today look what
look where it's going in the direction
that it's heading right now the face of
Lubavitch what it will look like or the
face of yiddishkite with this kind of
thinking what it's going to look like is
not within the parameters of SNES not
within the parameters we have team that
are not keeping Shabbos we have we have
we I don't have to list it you know it
um all everyone listening understands
what I'm talking about
so maybe they would say that your litmus
test actually the results are not so
great Rabbi Jacobson
well on others we talk about connection
we're connected but we're not
necessarily getting the results from
well I guess the definition is what's
the definition of results right is it
from kite or is a connection is it love
or is it moratorium my kids will be very
connected and happy if I was to be calm
and have pesos would be just joyful and
the state it would be like full of jokes
and laughter and happiness
okay well that's that's another level
that's not a lot that's such coffee you
could be happy but okay but okay you can
go to beautiful kmr um peso program and
have no good Bros and have absolutely
the most amazing time ever but
I guess I confess I confess I was there
that's lucky you so digging down into
that I'm just I'm just adding another
layer if you don't mind before we go to
another one an excellent excellent
excellent question
the fact is that in the last 20 30 years
we have seen an enormous amount of
children growing up in very religious
homes leaving the path of Judaism
in all communities in Chabad
visionsburg Papa
etc etc all Hasidic communities what you
call the litwish community where you
call the Shivers Community what you call
the more modern Orthodox Community what
you may call the national Zionist
community in Israel etc etc
and this is a fact anybody who deals
with youth today knows that the numbers
are very very large unfortunately and
the families that are affected are
basically almost every single family
either the Family itself or I have a
nephew have a niece have a cousin have a
brother a sister an uncle an aunt Etc
almost I'm not going to say every family
but almost almost every single family
and I would say from somebody who has
probably without exaggeration spoken to
not hundreds but thousands thousands of
parents who have seen their children
leave yiddishkite sometimes one child
sometimes two children
sometimes three or four children
and leave I mean not only leave you know
they stop doing my Macarena before
benching or they started to eat abrupts
which many many wonderful Jews eat
gabrooks
if God fearing Jews
but many other Jews do it but things
that let's call it this way a little
more serious than getting your mat
putting guacamole on your matzah
which in some circles is very serious
and I'm not I'm not I'm not
underestimating it but in some you know
much worse I've spoken to them both
privately in conventions like
kashinavshi seminars workshops emails
Etc
I would say probably 95 of them maybe 90
percent of them have attempted to do
exactly what you said let's buckle down
and follow their Messiah the tradition
they have all experimented with this
we want the results we want them to come
closer to Judaism and closer to the
families and we love them and therefore
let's buckle down let's tell them the
rules in the house let's create
expectations let's say if you want to
come home and you want to sleep at home
it's wonderful but you have to you must
adhere to the laws of our tradition our
we have ashkapha we have minig most of
these parents have did this
and what happened
I never heard I never heard I'm not
saying there was no but I never heard
from thousands of cases a success story
what I have heard was their children
left them were alienated and left
Judaism and drifted away even further
because they were coming for pesach they
stopped coming for pesach they were
coming for sukkas they stopped coming
for circus they were maybe lighting the
Hanukkah menorah they stopped doing that
and that's the reason why thousands and
thousands of parents started to ask
themselves maybe there's another path
and the results of the other path which
is more closeness more attachment more
empathy more understanding has resulted
at least in most cases in the children
becoming closer to their parents closer
to their families maybe not returning
completely to the lifestyle of their
parents although in many cases that too
but perhaps participating in some of the
Traditions some of the rituals
preventing many of them from horrible
horrible addictions
saving them from overdose and suicide
and when we talk about results we have
tried both paths very very successfully
we have we have I mean we have tried
both past for a consistent amount of
time
and we have to be able to look at the
data we have to be able to look at the
research I mean when I speak about these
things right I have first spoken to
dozens of people who are in the field
for decades an example is somebody you
know well Rabbi Sherman Russell I asked
him directly I said could you give me a
number of how many teenagers you have
met who have left the district and he
told me ten thousand
ten thousand because he began practicing
at the therapist in Lakewood
approximately three and a half decades
ago
has done this all day for almost 35
years continues to do it today in
Jerusalem
that's a number to reckon with I have
asked Avi fischoff
how many kids went by home sweet home
that was a residence that he once had
for children who were struggling he gave
me the number you're talking about
thousands of children and then thousands
of parents who he deals with today
Etc other other therapists whether in
Lakewood or Muncie or in Israel that
I've spoken to over the years smaller on
a smaller scale or a large therapists
who deal with less people with more
people and they all said the same thing
I asked them for the data and they all
said the same thing the parents tried
to say these are the rules this is The
Messer we love you shape up or ship out
and in most cases the situation
deteriorated more and more and more and
more and more sometimes to the point of
sadly sadly and I'm still going to cry
no return
sadly sadly there was a reason they're
not all
all these people are not evil people who
are saying how can we destroy Judaism
for the Next Generation how can we make
sure that the kids who leave the Derek
should never come back I know what we're
gonna do we're just gonna smile and say
you guys are great and we will ensure
that Judaism will be dead forever
everyone who comes to the keshanashi
conventions
everyone I can promise you I can say
everyone because I didn't speak to
everyone but most of them have tried the
other method sometimes for years and you
know where he got them
it got them nowhere it did get them to a
place where their families were
destroyed where their children weren't
speaking to them where they were hearing
horrible stories about their own own
children I'm just going to give you one
example it's a very dramatic one
but this
I know the father and I know the
daughter so I'm not saying this from
hearsay I know the people involved
there was a girl a teenage girl who
unfortunately got involved in uh in
drugs basically to numb her pain and
with a bunch of friends and Saturday
night Matari Shabbos they would go to
their dealers and stock up for the week
her father completely changed his
mindset and he developed a very close
relationship with this girl
and matsoi Shabbos he would imagine it's
not and this is not easy to say and not
easy to hear and I also don't like
saying it because I know how difficult
this is
it's the last thing any father wants to
do his father would take her every
Messiah is in his car dressed like a
before the tree of knowledge or close to
that and go to this place and pay
this man
for providing his daughter with the
substances so to speak she needed for
the week
to be able to keep her away from other
troubles but she was home and she was
close to him and so forth
a few years later
she went into recovery she transformed
her whole life
and then she told her father these words
and I want you to hear this coming from
a girl she said Tati
you were the only father who was willing
to pay and take me none of the other
fathers were you think my friends didn't
get the drugs you think they didn't I'll
tell you what they did
they sold their bodies for prostitution
all of them
and they would provide services
and with that money they went and bought
the drugs I was the only one who didn't
have to do that
now you hear such a story
you say oh but he bought drugs for his
girl yeah he did buy drugs is it
horrible it's horrible you know Winston
Churchill once said
democracy is a horrible form of
government right it's just the best of
all the other ones
what this was this is sometimes the most
painful Choice people have to make
do I have my daughter or my son in my
house close to me not dressed the way
they should be dressed not dressed the
way my mother and grandmother and
great-grandmother were dressed but
she's not selling her body
for promiscuity and that means there's
hope there's connection she's going to
get older she's going to have resources
she's going to feel confidence because
she feels so much love and one day maybe
she's going to turn to mommy and tati
say you know I need a little help could
you help me
that's what we're talking about that's
called results in my world that's called
results
between selling your body for
promiscuity and we know what's the next
step after that and having your child at
your Shabbos table enjoying your food
and maybe even singing along with your
song even if she's making fun of your
religion I know which results I would
want
okay what would you answer somebody who
said with response to that that maybe
it's supposed to be the way maybe we're
supposed this is this sounds very severe
but like maybe historically let's go
through history we always lost people
people always left this is not a new new
thing that's happening now even though
we like to think it is
um what would you say to them that you
know maybe it's supposed to be that way
we're not supposed to drop our
boundaries
standards to keep our standards we're
now dropping our standards we're still
losing yes some are coming back
excellent what's the points on questions
maybe I should have wanted it for
thousands of the years who are we now to
change that this is God's way of calling
the herd right and I I heard a very
prominent person say that he quoted
something from Isaiah and and I and I
just said it's all very shocking I know
it's a hard question to ask but I
actually I I have to say I cherish all
these questions they're they're very
good questions maybe that's the terror
path maybe the tire path is I have three
kids who left you describe but I have
another three kids at home tell these
three kids this is not your home if
you're ready to do chuva come back this
is not your home sleep in the subway
station go find some friends who will
celebrate you write a book against your
religion and against your mother tell
the world how horrific we all are and
when you're ready to repent and you do
it the right way we'll welcome you back
I have three kids to save or maybe a
little less less intense than that maybe
just this is our home you want to behave
that way you could do that over there uh
we were still did we still come Welcome
to our home it's not all or nothing I
was just doing it with a little Rabbi y
drama but yeah okay but I'm saying but
there are people that maybe are
listening or saying well I don't do that
but then they do say well I'm not going
to be giving you your monthly um thing
because you're not living the standards
that we want and not because they're
trying to be obnoxious they genuinely
feel that we have to keep them a cere
this is the educational system that the
rebrashab set up this is the homes that
our grandparents went to the to the to
the death death camps um to protect uh
you know throughout history you know
everybody everybody went to the death
camps
everybody went to the death camps The
Atheist too let's remember that I'm
saying I'm just saying not for
necessarily only the extreme extreme
situation even though even the lower
cases where people are saying in my home
we dress sneez in my home we do this if
you want to do it there I mean we're
still welcome you can live I'll even pay
for your apartments part of this it's
like you're out of my house and you're
living on the streets and you're still
alive and begging for food there's in
between
yes to those people they're maybe saying
that same idea beautiful beautiful
question and there's two parts and I'm
going to want to address them both very
briefly the first question is a question
what does the title really believe about
this it's a very legitimate question and
this is where you tell people let's go
back to our Messiah
go to the teachings of the balshamtov go
to the teachings of the I believe it's
go to the teachings of the altered
balatanya of the lubavat should have
been our most recent generation
and listen to their words did they say
that before mashiach comes there's going
to be a certain amount of our children
who we have to get rid of and they're
going to get lost
or
is almost every teaching of theirs
literally a battle against that mindset
to quote what I myself heard from the
Reba may be hundreds of times
is that the prophet who speaks about the
Gula yes
with a lot of emotion that Hashem is
going to hold each Jew
each Jew by his or her hand and bring
them
um
every teaching of the balchem almost is
saturated with the idea that every
single soul ultimately can and will be
embraced and rescued the devil would say
thousands of times that in this nobody
is going to be left behind nobody should
ever be left behind the whole Chabad
movement over the last 70 years the
whole slickest movement is predicated on
what sending a couple for 50 years to
some remote Community you'll forgive me
with his 200 people
severed from their immediate family for
the rest of their lives I think I'm
speaking to such people you didn't go to
New Zealand but you went far away from
your families
to do what why why
so that a Jew who may have tattoos from
head to toe may be intermarried eats
pork for breakfast lunch and dinner and
for sale shrimp
right and from a lava malka Lobster and
that Jew
you put a fill in on him or she light
Shabbos candles wow and then every slick
would write a letter to the rabbit on
Friday and say this is true let's shop
this kind of happens I'm going to take
this letter to the my father-in-law's
resting place and this is what Chabad
was celebrating for 70 years and
suddenly when we use this language with
our own children what's the source
what's the source is this Judaism really
oh it's not true it is we have a messiah
we have a wow amazing we don't give our
children the dignity
the honor
that all of Hasidic and capitalistic
teachings and really all of Jewish
teachings gives every single Jewish soul
is only only if you live in Mumbai then
yeah nobody will be left behind but if
you went to base Rifka
if you went to a Chabad or a Hasidic or
a good Yeshiva if you have parents that
are from
done and you got no place in classroom
you shake it
that's what people learned from the Reba
I heard
hundreds and hundreds of hours of their
ever talking face to face I was one of
the people who transcribed the talks
there was not a single talk in which he
did not articulate again and again and
again that if you meet a Jew and you
don't see their infinite goodness and
godliness you you need to go work on
yourself this was a theme over decades
we just didn't take it seriously so now
when people are taking it seriously
they're being rebuked and criticized for
taking all of his teachings seriously
and applying it not only not only to
Peabody Massachusetts and not only to
Tokyo Japan and not only to Peru or
Cancun in Mexico
or some remote Village in Ukraine or in
Siberia but we're applying it to our
homes in Borough Park or Muncie or
Lakewood or Crown Heights or Jerusalem
or Stamford Hill or golders green or
Melbourne or Chicago or Toronto or
Pittsburgh
come on so tell me if tell me if I'm
hearing you correctly are you saying
that our homes and our schools and our
mices and our families in the way we
interact with our children should look
like a Chabad house style
great great question
and the answer to that is
the prerequisite of every Chabad house
is love and attachment
I never ever met the habachlia or any
cure of Rabbi rabbits in the world
somebody walked into show
and they said hey hey hey it's Shabbos
how do you get here
get out do Trevor come back the first
approach is what
wow thank you for coming come join the
Kiddush I am so gracious do you have a
place to eat why do they do it that way
because attachment breeds connection
love and then spiritual growth that's
the key
of course our homes
are founded on the Messiah and our
parents sacrificed their lives for it
and we want to continue to do that but
if my children are not feeling the
attachment they're not going to be able
to hold on to that tradition
so yes you have to figure out what every
child needs but the key is attachment
that's the key so you say can I tell a
child maybe this home is not this is how
we do things in our home and if you're
not ready for that I understand I love
you but you have to do it in another
place now if I have an amazing
relationship with my child and there's
good attachment and having them in
another home will Foster Independence or
creativity and will be better but it's
not compromising the attachment fine
wonderful the point here is of course
every child needs their own sensitivity
what's the right thing for them what's
then not what's not the right thing for
them but the key is that if we sever the
Judaism from the sense of attachment
it's not going to be successful we're
going to drive them further away and
further and further away and I don't
think as real Jews that is an option for
us and I'll tell you besides the
hashkafa let me tell you something
I know parents who have chosen this path
and chosen it very aggressively and you
know what
I always tell parents
the pain of having a child who chooses a
different value system than yours is
deep it's deep
there's a lot of tears and a lot of
grief
a lot of grief for the child you
imagined you're going to have and for
the child I have
but it does not come close to the pain
of losing that child for eternity in
terms of the relationship
knowing that this child is out of your
life
they're disconnected from you yes your
house has Integrity trust me that pain
is completely a different level of pain
because you're amputating you're you're
cutting out a piece of your heart
before cutting out your heart and
sending your heart to live in another
house be very very very careful be very
very very cautious
if the heart wants to live in another
house and it's going to remain a good
heart and it's better for the heart
because
these decisions should not be coming
from ego from impulsiveness from Anger
from resentment from trying to impress
my neighbors or my in-laws
these decisions must come from a very
deep place of connection
so let me ask you a question you know my
desire is to go in the path of emotion
and say okay my brain understands it but
my heart is struggling with it but I
think we just addressed that so let me
let me put on the cerebral hat for a
second and say so what does yetis look
like in 10 years five years 20 I mean
Michelle will be here but this is Hashem
it doesn't
where is this going to go what is this
going to look like in in we're going to
have the you describe excellent
yiddishka is going to be amazing don't
you realize what's happening what's
happening is the entire youth is saying
tati mommy Bobby zaidi give me a Yiddish
guide that is purged from corruption
from hypocrisy from superficiality from
stupidity from Superstition from abuse
from molestation from addiction from
leadership yeah that is completely
completely clueless and detached from
the conditions of people give me a
Yiddish guide that Embraces the full
spectrum of The Human Experience give me
a Yiddish guy that allows me to
celebrate my soul my heart my body my
mind my God my world my existence that's
really what's happening and we are all
given an opportunity if I could speak to
both of you how much inner work did you
both do in the last five or ten years
emotional psychological work and whose
credit is that but let's
my child it's not a question what would
have happened what would have happened
if each one of your children would be
put on a conveyor belt at age three and
you wouldn't hear from them until after
they're married and have a few children
[Laughter]
but but you're saying it's going to look
more authentic and more and more
spiritual and more yeah but you know
what else it looks like it looks
immodest and it looks um it looks not
within the it's not it's not sneeze it's
not it's not I can go on and on I want
to add to that because you you pulled a
rabbi YY you pulled a a dozen adjectives
and no one can argue with that but but
at the same time you know and I'm not
the old-fashioned guy here I'm I'm the
the you know the taviano you're the
left-wing Liberal oh exactly I'm the I'm
the liberal thinker but but I want there
to be a base mattress even even if my
kids are not in it I want there to be a
basement I want there to be a
Mississippi I want some of those things
to still exist are you saying the
institutions have to be torn down so
they can rebuild them correctly so how
does this look
how do I get to that authentic beautiful
it really depends how we see Judy is are
we insecure about Judaism or are we
secure about Judas
you know let's talk about science or
physics just as an example real science
doesn't have to be insecure about
science the laws of gravity are not
afraid that somebody is going to destroy
the laws of gravity you know why why are
they not afraid that Rabbi why why
Jacobson or Sherman Russell or chase
Taub or Avi Fisher for any other heretic
are going to just get up and give this
powerful we're gonna do a summit and
we're all together going to destroy the
laws of gravity we're also going to
destroy how the electrons in the atoms
function we're just going to destroy it
through the Gift of Gab and through
malicious poisonous left-wing liberal
Tick-Tock Joe Biden or no Joe Biden
rhetoric nobody's afraid of that you
know why because nobody's destroying the
laws of gravity
it's really an insecurity we have about
Judaism I'm afraid to say Judaism for
many of us is a messiah it's a tradition
it's not organic it's not organic it's
not God's blueprint for life it's not
the laws of gravity but the whole
kabbalistic and Hasidic approach to do
the exact opposite Judaism is reality
I'm not going to destroy the laws of
nutrition no lecture that Rabbi y gives
as talented as he may be and he may be
talented or not is ever going to destroy
the fact that if I'm eating in the
morning a lot of carbs and a lot a lot
of sugar I'm gonna be in a bad mood you
know why because the body is going to
protest it sneeze Shabbos Casius
the whole body of Judaism this is this
is like the foundation of all
kabbalistic and Hasidic teachings is the
organic essential system of the universe
when we peel away the layers when we
remove the toxicity when we allow people
to shine these are the places we want to
hang out in the river ones wrote to
somebody in a letter listen to this an
amazing letter he wrote if we had all
the wisdom and time in the world
and we would study human nature and
chemistry and physics perfectly we
ourselves would prescribe the 613
Mitzvahs for the Jewish people you
understand what he said if you knew this
sign if I knew everything about my body
and my brain and my neurons and my
chemicals and my DNA everything I would
write
you know uh to-do list my to-do list
would be 630 Mitzvahs I don't so
organically I don't say in the morning I
need to put onto villain I do say I want
to brush my teeth because my breath is
bad but my spiritual breath also needs
help so the more the more we peel
Judaism is not insecure it's like the
laws of gravity we don't have to protect
it we don't have to preserve it we need
to be worthy we need to be opened to
feel the energy the moment we feel the
energy everybody's in everybody is in
now of course if somebody has a child
who's celebrating the Yeshiva life and
is stagging and learning of course
that's our greatest joy and ecstasy in
the world of course we want to encourage
it and Inspire it the point is when we
have children who the system is failing
them
and not because of one person's bad
malicious intent but because for
whatever reason internal or external
they're not feeling the connection
they're not getting what they need never
mind if something actually happened to
them whether abuse or bullying Etc but
even if not
so then we have to realize that this is
a very serious crisis and if we abandon
them
and if we blame them instead of
understanding what happened then we are
failing our responsibility as the
transmitters of the Messiah connected
our Bonham retire I want to talk to
because I think you see the the way you
phrase something I think might get to
the core of What agitates Not not myself
but men but many others the system
failed them can't it just be that they
don't fit in the system and they were
not molested and they were not harmed
and they just don't film the system and
the system is still fine quote unquote
and it's just it's not working for them
is is there is that is that a
possibility
it's a wonderful question and for this I
quote Winston Churchill who was the
master of prose and he said
we create institutions to facilitate our
dreams and then we become prisoners to
those institutions which means the point
of systems is to serve the people the
people are not here to serve the system
so it's the question of how you define
the system you're right if you define
the system as an absolute reality and
our children are here to serve the
system I can't disagree but I see I
think that's a very very corrupt
definition of any system any system of
government and any system of education
and any system of of anything the point
of the system is to serve the people
let's remember what's the means and
what's the end now it's fear to say that
a school says
I can only deal with certain models
that's fine and therefore I will not be
able to serve you and I'm going to fail
you and I should be honest about that
but we have to be very introspective and
honest because we want to be able to be
here for everyone
we sometimes can't but at least we
should be honest about what the needs
are and stop blaming them and looking
inside of us
instead of on a very technical level
does that mean that you know what
Sherman Russell calls the autopilot
children they will have their yeshivas
and the the more edgy artsy children
will have their yeshivas and the kids
who have been molested and abused and
broken will have their
I don't know yeshivas or or other is
that how this is gonna we're gonna kind
of have to sift through and let everyone
go in the direction that is working for
them
um
I'll tell you an experiment that's being
done right here in Muncie and that is
there's a an exceptional exceptional
woman her name is nadav and she told me
directly she's a gifted gifted educator
she told me she's been teaching for
decades
in different schools in Muncie and she
said I was watching children in first
second third grade and to myself I was
making predictions
this child will not continue after
Elementary School this child will drop
out after the first year of high school
second year of high school and she said
10 years later every prediction was
right
so she went to many schools and said for
all these kids I want to make a separate
program an enrichment program some of
the schools told that we don't have this
problem we don't have this issue others
said we can't afford it others said
we're already doing it
and she actually went to one school and
they said absolutely
and last year she created this
enrichment program
and my son my youngest my baby my
youngest boy I sent into her program and
I have to say a lifesaver a lifesaver
this was an example within the system of
a school she created a program now
between you and I when I see how she
runs the classes I say all the classes
should run like this
because they're all based on
relationships they're all based on
empowering the children they're very
very much based on what hasidis calls is
which means an arousal From Below you
are you are a partner you are an
initiator you are a dreamer it's very
well adjusted to the nature of the child
and the child is spoken to not spoken at
and it's also not trying to impose
things on the child it's trying to help
the Child open himself up to his
curiosity
and his thirst for learning yes you have
to challenge you want to challenge the
child sometimes you have to discipline
and there's rules Etc but it's all in a
way that the child appreciates the
growth it's incredible so this is
literally a model that she created here
and I spoke to her just two days ago I
went to visit the school and I asked her
you must I said you must be in you
inundated with with with with hundreds
and hundreds of calls and she says no
[Laughter]
so interesting I'm like aren't there
parents reaching out to you she says a
few I said why she says a lot of people
are afraid of stigma
I was shocked I'm like stigma
I look at you and I say thank God that
you are here I'll publicize it in the
whole world I just don't want to I want
my child to have a place in your school
so I don't want to publicize it too much
so you know I really I really think that
we often underestimate how much healing
we still need as a community
how much healing how much authenticity
um you know I always tell parents and
Educators and I tell this to myself when
somebody criticizes you before you
respond be curious as to why you are
internally responding the way you're
responding because that will help you
grow a lot
if my daughter or my son tells me
something and inside I become like a
raging tsunami even though I know how to
repress it I come from Russian stock we
know how to deal with emotional
constipation we're good at it we have
hundreds of years of training and Stalin
really fine-tuned the skill to a point
of perfection but if inside I am raging
like a lunatic ready to break windows
and punch noses the most healthy thing I
could do is curiosity
what just happened
such an opportunity for growth instead
many of us we either run to our bedrooms
because we're nice we don't want
confrontation we run to our bedrooms
right we run out of the house we start
screaming about God Messiah we become
defensive
and instead of building the relationship
we we detach even more there's such an
opportunity now for healing for growth
said probably the best way to sum it up
you know
the outer Rebel one said the balatanya
one of the better lines ever said if I
could say so he said Hashem
is
good according to hilum taste and you
will see that God is good which means if
in my imagination God is evil and
Sinister it may be justified for certain
reasons and experiences sadly but it
means I still haven't touched the truth
the moment we are fighting with each
other what's right what's wrong
what's right for my children what's
wrong for my children
I think we're we're in the wrong place
we don't want to be in a place of
Confrontation we don't want to be in a
place of judgment it's more time Hashem
if you could connect to the
opportunities
that exist when there is deep empathy
and compassion and attachment and
curiosity and growth you will right away
see that your Judaism will become so
much more sincere so much more authentic
on the contrary the previous generations
will turn to our generation and ask us
what did you guys do that was so right
it's just so fascinating because
I'll just say we drank the Kool-Aid if
that's how people want to look at it
and and on something that's so Central
and essential to everything that we're
doing get us great children raising
children this those that last little
um fear that you went on to some is like
beautiful Brilliance and to others it's
like this guy needs to be you know
excommunicated because it's so new agey
and it's so so it's like it's so
contrary to the to the doctrines of of
what we know I'm not I'm not there's no
question there it's more of a it's an
emotion that's falling out of me how the
very same thing could be so beautiful to
some and tell us it could be so horrible
you know what you know what you know
what maybe I shouldn't be the one saying
it but maybe I should be the one saying
it maybe it's not so bad that we have
the supposition
maybe it's not so bad
even though I'm the one who who is the
target of much of it in emails and
backlashes but maybe it's not so bad for
two reasons
first of all
it opposition is not fun
but it challenges us to work on
ourselves it challenges us not to become
egotistical not to become judgmental
it's very good for a teacher for a
father for a rebbe for anybody to say
maybe I'm wrong
Maybe I'm Wrong maybe you have to
rethink this where the hogamar is based
on that so maybe in a way it's very
helpful
number one and number two I think it's
so important to realize that
everybody's on a journey
and often the opposition is also a
result from very very deep need for
survival
people need to survive a person wrote me
an email has been coming to my classes
and has said this for quite a few years
and he told his rosh hashiva that he
started to learn the Kutter Terror by
the balatanyas where she was in his 80s
so he writes to him if you're already
adding a sheer why in that why don't you
add a sheer in gamara in mishnaburra so
this man who's already 70 writes to me
and he's alarmed why was roshishiva not
celebrate it
so I told them Eurasia is almost 90
barah Hashem okay
if he celebrates the fact that you
started to learn by the balatonya what
is that saying about him
that means that for almost 90 years he
was ignorant to a part of Judaism that
he never really learned that means for
90 years he's learning and he's a victim
and this whole part of Judaism he never
explored that what do you want from him
like
you want him to say yeah that's a great
sheer there's unbelievable depth that
means he also has to start learning he
never learned it in his life maybe you
heard the name maybe you heard somebody
make fun of Chabad I mean that's as far
as his education goes in terms of of the
altered uh you know infinite wisdom so I
said of course he has to tell you go
learn Mr Brewer let's just go I think we
have to also empathize with that I can
understand somebody who's 65 years old
right
this this survival this is what always
what the right thing and this is what
I'm used to it's for some people that
like what so I'm 65 and I'm I've been in
FNAF or whatever it is and I've been
doing it all wrong or I have to change
now like it's it's just a very it's a
very it's a very I have to be able to I
have to be able to respect that and I
see it inside of me
there were certain things I maintained
years ago and I had to transform myself
and not because I jumped into it
life's circumstances humbles us all and
you know what I sometimes tell people I
hope you will never have to experience
anything that some of these parents
experience and you won't have to change
you know what it's a blessing I bless
you I bless you you should be able to
remain where you are and you know what
I'm not jealous you have your journey
I want to ask you one more thing
I'm gonna talk for myself
I know all this I know this to be true
I'm living it I'm practicing it and yet
there are still times
where those voices of
you should do it you're lowering your
standards you you would you you're
you're not holding any any standards at
all you don't you're coddling all the
things all those voices or or even that
accountability but oh accountability is
a big one or I'm handicapping you for
life you're never gonna have the ability
to be resilient you're never gonna be
able to hold down a job because I'm
being so nice to you or I'm giving you
everything that you want um but I find
and I know that there a lot of these
voices are coming from a place of fear
they're coming from a place of fear I
want to show up in a calm way I want to
show up in the question is how do we
stay focused on the fact that we know
Hashem that every child is a piece of
Hashem
and we know this our heart is telling us
but at the same time
we're looking at something that's so
uncomfortable to look at you're looking
at your child who's dressed not to need
a steak you're seeing something that's
it literally pulls at your heartstrings
your child's being Mahalo Chavez from
the smallest thing to to the greatest
thing to wearing jeans for some people
it may be that their child's wearing
jeans oh how I that that would be a
dream a man a man but for them that's
their real that is
for them it's really painful they heard
they hear their their voice and I had
saying I have to say that I have to say
this the razor a father came to where
his father came to me a crisis so what's
the crisis he said his son he said I
said this again movement he does he saw
that in work he doesn't always wear a
white shirt he puts on a blue shirt and
he comes to me for advice how to deal
with it anyway go ahead I'm sorry I just
had to share that yeah so I'm not I'm
not even laughing at that I I I hear it
because in everyone it's their own way
you know it could be from something as
small as your child telling you that
they have a boyfriend or a girlfriend to
something as small as um they they want
to wear jean pants
or a piercing in in a part of their body
that they don't want
even though I know the right thing to do
and I do the right thing
not always is my heart aligned with my
action and my question is is what would
you tell parents that are doing this and
are practicing it how can they
how do they tap into that part of
themselves to continue doing the right
thing even if that's happening and they
shouldn't upload because of it because
of it and they should continue doing
what they're doing and they should stay
like what kind of physics could you give
them to continue doing this even though
those those thoughts and feelings
wonderful question wonderful wow thank
you for asking it first and foremost
we all must have an emotional support
system it's critical
mothers and fathers
first and foremost the marriage
a marriage in these situations has to
become much stronger much deeper we
can't rely on the conventional marriage
of course we like each other you know we
get along we don't throw rocks at each
other we don't holler in the house
that's not going to cut it it's not
going to cut it
there's too much too much
father and mother must be able to create
a fortress together
when they're holding on together when
they're holding on to each other
emotionally and physically and
psychologically even if the hard ball
comes and the hard ball is going to come
it's not going to be a softball
they'll be able to catch it
and it'll be fine
if the marriage has cracks
it becomes so much more difficult and
that means on a very practical level
couples have to spend time with each
other work through their differences be
able to cry about this to each other and
then they'll be able to laugh but they
have to be able not to judge each other
not the husband telling the wife oh
you're so alarming and then you you
you're CR you're the problem and then
you're overwhelming me we have it's not
going to work we really have to be able
to be here for each other husbands and
wives respect each other's emotions and
Journeys and grief that that's number
one there has to be emotion but not just
the spouses if we everyone needs
emotions but whether it's a good friend
whether it's family sometimes it can't
be family but it's it's friend it's a
mentor it's a therapist it's a rabbi
it's a rabbit we must have emotional
support we need a few people in our
lives and we trust who get it who want
to see us fly and want our children to
fly they're not busy criticizing us and
judging us unfortunately it's not always
immediate family sometimes it is depends
on the nature of the family but this is
very very well that's number one number
two it's extremely important to have a
very very deep relationship with
yourself
which means a very deep relationship
with God it's so important
you have to work on yourself every day
I think such parents all of us really
you need to maybe wake up earlier or go
to sleep a little and spend time we need
time for meditation for davening for
learning for exercise for self-nurture
for self-compassion
um journaling dancing swimming massages
whatever yoga Pilates physical
psychological emotional spiritual each
one according to to their needs but it's
very important to be able to nurture
your mind to be able to be open to be
able to process your emotions because if
you if I'm not in that place if I'm not
anchored
in a Godly centered place I will be
destroyed
and when the parent becomes destroyed in
the process it's not good for them it's
not good for the children
and the third thing
and this is also very very important
real people are always open to growth
real people are always ready to say you
know what yes maybe I should change
something and that will give my children
more resilience this is not about we go
into a place oh we're loving and we
judge the rest of the world that's not
so loving and then oh my kids are not
resilient you know what we're all work
in progress we all want to learn but we
want to learn from people
number one will have experience
number two people who will Empower us
and help us not people who are going to
judge us and demonize us
and make us more estranged from our
children so we all want to learn we all
want to grow we all have areas where we
are deficient and our children pick that
up and are of course responding to it
the last thing I would say is
as we say in English the old saying the
proof is in the pudding
if this exhausted mother or father
filled with fear and getting criticism
sees
your child is healthier today than they
were a year ago instead of coming down
to the kitchen and saying
f-u-f-u-f-u-f-u-f-u-f-u-f-u-f-u
they come down and when you say hey
I bought sushi for you I bought your
favorite milkshake
and they say thank you and they go back
to their bedroom to drink it that's
progress
be proud of it give yourself a standing
ovation the proof is in the pudding the
proof is in the pudding the sacrifices
of these parents are keeping their
children home they're keeping their
children in a more safe place these
children are more protected physically
and emotionally these children are off
drugs these children or or or or less on
drugs these children are not overdosing
these children are in healthier
healthier places that is a momentous
cause for celebration and success now
think about the alternative if we would
surrender to fear
and we would sever that relationship
with our kids to protect our other kids
what would our Knights look like
would we be more calm would we be more
Serene so it's very important for every
parent to tune in and to celebrate every
day those small gestures and behaviors
and patterns and changes that are
allowing our children
Hashem to slowly heal
and heal more and heal more and gain a
certain confidence where they themselves
will feel that they could be healthy and
the moment they feel that they will want
to be healthy you want to be healthy you
want to be healthy I want to be healthy
you know why because we feel that we can
the moment our children will feel that
they can they will want to
okay one last question since I want to
respect your time what is something that
you thought you knew really well you
were definitely sure about
um with regard to anything that you
talked about over the years that after
years of life experience life marriage
children parenting teaching whatever it
may be that you've changed your opinion
on
yeah
so
one thing that stands out in my mind I'm
not going to say I changed my opinion
but I never realized the importance of
it and that is I never realized the
importance of attachment
between children and their caregivers at
the youngest age
I thought that intellectual creativity
an accomplishment and doing the right
thing and being productive can
compensate for that
and I realized from a lot of life
experience and relationships in my own
life how what a mistake that is
attachment attachment attachment
attachment is the key
I also Now understand that from a Jewish
perspective
can you explain that like what you mean
by the intellectual what is that what
does that mean yeah I think many of us
as children we did not get the healthy
attachment we needed
we may have gotten unstable attachment
we may have gotten avoidant attachment
we may have gotten attachment or no
attachment or wounded attachment we
compensate we compensate for the Love by
getting validation
I may become an unbelievable student in
school I may become an unbelievable
Troublemaker in school I may go to make
a lot of money I may become a great
teacher a rabbi and those of us who were
blessed with gifts we zoom in on those
gifts and it compensates for the love we
did not get
and for the inner core that's wounded I
never realized that with such clarity
but today it's very very clear to me
that attachment is the key of everything
it's the core of everything it's the
core of every healthy relationship it's
the core of every healthy lifestyle it's
the core of confidence when there is
attachment in other words my core was
formed with love
I feel loved I feel valued I feel that I
was seeing soothed safe and secure the
four s's I can grow up to be a person
whose talents and success comes from the
inside out rather than comes as a
compensation because there's no Insight
so it comes from the outside in and
that's really the difference without
attachment I try to gain validation from
the outside and then I convince myself
that I'm a valuable person with
attachment I'm a valuable person inside
I don't need anybody's validation I may
want to give the world I want to give
the world my light so now some of us
have not gotten that attachment and I
think
so important to be aware of that wound
and be able to work with that like David
Malik says in in tahillim in Psalms 27
my father and mother have neglected me
and God took me in so he was aware of
the fact that he needed to reinvent
himself and ReDiscover that attachment
with people later on in life first and
foremost with himself and with god with
Hashem to be able to experience that
because without that my relationships
with life are based on deep deep wounds
and trying to compensate now from a
secular
evolutionary psychological perspective
it's because when we were hunters and
foragers or Apes we needed to be
together we needed attachment if not the
lion would mull me from a Jewish
perspective it's much much deeper it's
because we are attached we're all one we
come from Oneness
so our fathers and mothers don't own us
but they model to us what it means that
we're one the world is one we come from
we are all manifestations of Oneness so
attachment is the most innate quality of
human existence we are essentially
attached and we can only be independent
and we can only be individuated when we
have healthy attachment if I don't have
healthy attention I never become an
individual because I'm just looking to
find out who I am and I need the world
to validate me
this awareness is something I had to
grow into
on the most practical level if I'm
understanding you correctly that means
celebrate our children not because of
anything they've done or any
accomplished you know if it looks like a
child is languishing figure out how to
celebrate them despite what seems like
their failure to thrive yeah and that's
at older agenda little kids of course
yeah and I think it's also as adults in
terms of our own relationships I would
say that one of the the deepest issues
in marriages is that we are not
identifying the core problem in other
words when husbands and wives get upset
at each other or they don't feel they
can trust each other they blame it you
know you're always late you're not
taking care of the house you're not
responsible those are all just smoke
screens what we really want to address
is
our our attachment needs being met
because when that's really really
addressed I think we see what we really
are looking for in our relationships I
need to feel that attachment you need to
feel that attachment and when that's
experienced almost I find that so many
things just float flow from that
so it's it's it's it's it's it's a very
Primal it's not a sophisticated
conversation it's really not
sophisticated
I grew up in a sophisticated home I grew
up in a pretty sophisticated culture
relatively speaking and
um and I always gave too much credit to
sophistication
and and Brilliance and wisdom uh
somebody once wrote I think nobody cares
how much you know until they know how
much you care right so it was a good
cliche and I said it in many lectures
and it's a nice line but to really
understand that racist Hashem
that all wisdom and Brilliance
sophistication is almost meaningless
if it's not rooted in real authentic
attachment and love
and if not we're just like artificial
intelligence and much worse than
artificial intelligence so so yeah many
of us I think we have become artificial
intelligence you know we're very
intelligent but the computers are much
better let's face it let's let's just
give life to them they'll do a better
job what artificial intelligence doesn't
have is the ability to look into my eyes
and see my pain and say I am so sorry
artificial intelligence cannot do that
you can cut this out but but I have to
ask you what would you not say that
again this could have been done in a
Kinder more attached kind of way but had
you not been pushed in the way that
you've been pushed look at what you've
accomplished being being a pleasure for
someone who's your brother you know I'm
talk I'm talking about you because I'm
talking to you but so many great people
they arrived at their greatness because
they were pushed and not always with
such love had there been so much love
they may not they may have gone the
softer lighter you don't have to cut
this out this is this is a very very
legitimate and beautiful question about
anything about pushing I thought he was
saying more about celebrating like don't
only celebrate I mean but sometimes it's
the the if you give the softer lighter
Road out the kids will take the offer
him and say yeah I really don't want to
kill myself right now it's uh the truth
is that
you know a lot of the hardships in life
I don't think any one of us can protect
our children from
things happen unfortunately we try and
try and try and try you know I know
somebody
they were so conscious of the issue of
child molestation because of their
education and they made sure to educate
their children and they protected them
and everything was so protective and you
know babysitters and camp and counselors
and rebbies and teachers you know it
turns out that it happened to their
children from within the Family itself
from people you would never expected you
know Grand grandparents grandparents you
understand
so they're giving their children to
babysit by their grandparents and this
is what happens so you gotta sit back
and say
[Laughter]
there's a different plan here that's
beyond beyond our planet that's a
different question it's a different
question that nehem is asking he's
asking a little bit deeper and I don't
know if it's that it's not softer
because I don't think we're promoting
softness I think we're promoting love
and attachment it's it's a very
different thing
I mean at least that's what I'm hearing
I just feel like we're not soft we're
just taught we're we're talking about
being connected more and being attached
more and then and celebrating wherever
they're at meeting them where they're at
and then excellent excellent you have a
smart wife
and very articulate
and then and then they can deal with the
hard balls and then they can deal with
the hard balls it's exactly opposite the
whole idea of attachment which is
theories of John bolby's Sue Johnson is
the more children experience attachment
when they're young the more they can be
detached and independent when they're
old
they can actually become adults you can
actually tell them stop being a baby and
you know what they won't be a baby
but if you always told me stop being a
baby even when I was a baby I will
always be a baby and we see it
constantly we're still babies 60 years
old I'm still a baby and you could
scream at me stop being a baby because I
was never a baby I was never a baby and
if somebody was not a baby
it's not good we need babies
so you know that's why the rabbi Sachs
used to always say it was very good line
he said the first thing the terrorist
says is not good you would think what's
the terror keeps on saying that the
world is good Hashem so the world is
good and Adam is good and everything is
good in the beginning of creation and
then it finally says not good what so
you would think maybe idolatry or
adultery or sin but that's not the first
not good the first Lloyd type is
that's the it's fascinating the first
time Terry says it's not good it's not
good for Adam to be alone that means
that that is at the core of all not
goodness and by the
ways he was a great Hasidic Master he
says very interesting he says the first
time a word is used in the Torah it's
the mother of all those words of that
word that will be used ever again is
that then in your class this week
yeah so he says it on the word so I just
thought it's also true about light Taif
so the first time the terrorist says
something is not good it's the mother of
all not goodness in the whole Torah but
you're not translating that as marriage
you're translating as loneliness
the word lavada means alone
that's what it means I'm not translating
it uniquely that plastic is referring in
marriage therefore other needs needs
needs a spouse but the point here is
that what does the terrorist see as the
mother of all the problems of everything
not the good in the world
not sin not promiscuity
a lack of attachment solitariness
loneliness today they figured out that
the antithesis of addiction is not
sobriety the antithesis of addiction is
connection there's a whole major
research done with rats incredible
research it's not for now but brilliant
research from a psychologist in Sweden
it's it's incredible that's why when my
86 year old grandmother gets morphine
for four weeks in the hospital because
she broke her her knee or it needs hip
replacement she's not an addiction an
addict to cocaine
because she has 39 grandkids jumping on
her when she comes home from the
hospital so the antithesis of addiction
is is connection attachment and it's
within that attachment that all growth
happens including moral and spiritual
growth
the rat Park it's it's a fascinating
study yeah so I think I think for many
years we thought we could communicate
Judaism
with detachment
and we said you know let the brain rule
the heart uh just be a soldier follow
the tradition we'll beat it into you
we'll beat it into you and it'll produce
much better results and you know what
the truth is hammers are much more
compliant than children I mean nails are
more compliant than children so there's
an advantage if you could turn your
child into a nail
you can build every sukkah with him and
it's beautiful and he'll become a star
of your system whatever your system is
make nails
but you know you get my point that's
what we that's what many and part of us
still says that he's a nail she's a nail
beat the truth into them and then
they'll beat this truth into their
children and you know what sometimes it
works sometimes I think I think the
reason why why we're tempted to go that
way is because it did work for a lot of
years it just doesn't work anymore of
course for some people you could even
see some people you look at them but you
don't know the the proof isn't the funny
because they don't know the results no I
don't mean no I mean I mean let's go
back you know before the war
historically well before the war more
than 50 of the Jewish people drifted
away from Judaism the the fact that most
Jews are secular today is not since
1966.
it's not since 1963 when Kennedy was
assassinated or Martin Luther King was
assassinated or not since 1969 Woodstock
didn't it begin the enlightenment The
Scholar movement didn't it start with
the United States it started in the
eighth it started in the 18th century
but it continued in the 19th century and
the beginning of the 20th century before
the Holocaust half of the Jewish people
have drifted away from Judaism in some
places more than half those are mine
staggering numbers that means if you had
a family of two children or four
children two of them would have drifted
away and maybe more in some cases and
Russia was more in Lithuania was more
right in in America was it was much more
so I'm saying 50 it's it's not it's not
even an accurate number so let's
understand that
let's understand Judaism has been seen
it didn't really work out quite that
well it's just the Holocaust was so
catastrophic nobody even spoke about it
we didn't have anybody to talk to
everybody was just murdered a third of
the Jewish people were murdered but we
have to understand Judaism has been
facing a fundamental existential crisis
on so many levels the Holocaust
overshadowed everything else because we
were being gassed you know we were not
asked to be secular we were not asked to
eat pork we were told to be we were sent
into gas chamber so once that happens
you know what are you going to talk
about you know you're going to Yeshiva
are you going to college right are you
going to the gas Chambers we were going
to the gas chamber so it's just very
important to understand that we went
through an existential crisis already a
few hundred years ago essentially one of
the fascinating things is the date of an
Enlightenment officially which begins in
England is 1698.
and that's the year the balsamta was
born
now the balshanda was born in Ukraine
far far away from the enlightenment
but in my mind it's not hard to see that
this was literally the Divine gift that
was given to the Jewish people in the
world in response to the enlightenment
did was he says we're now going to
articulate a much deeper more
sophisticated dimension of Judaism which
will actually show that Judaism is
organic and holistic and wherever the
enlightenment takes us Judaism Will
Survive and Thrive
I'm really not worried about Judaism I'm
so not worried about Judaism neither am
I
carriage ride and Hammond Shrine and
Hitler tried and they all try
like that doesn't keep me up that
doesn't keep me up at night trust me
some Jewish lecturer telling you to love
your kids
not going to obliterate three and a half
thousand years of Judaism I promise you
it's Sarah marazov said something to
raise on one of her podcasts I found I
thought it was fascinating and I'd love
it if you could confirm it it sounds
like you're basically saying that she
was saying that really historically
people have been leading the fold all
the throughout history says the only
time that we have an exception to that
is really almost exactly the years of
the rebels Macias
there was like a a good run of about 50
60 years where he had mitas where you
had all families everyone who stayed in
the fold not always there was something
but it was a very very wow
and she said that I don't know if she
thought that was fast does that recipe
he actually added to this that it was um
actually she said I don't remember what
it was based on but something to the
effect of that it was like a um for the
Holocaust right that the generation
after the Holocaust that their children
stayed um in the way and it was in a
hammer for those people that had
survived what they survived in it their
children but the following generation
the trauma continued wow very very very
beautiful and creative idea
and it also could be this host of the
rabbi you know how he said that in his
generation there would be no rainbow
because his house would protect the
world it could be that the Reb is Merit
and his presence
was such a light that it was extremely
healing for people even subconsciously
subconsciously they didn't need the need
to to to to to to run it's very possible
it's fascinating fascinating insight
fascinating insight and I just want to
thank you so much for your time and I
really really appreciate you coming on
here and sharing your wisdom with all of
us and um even letting me push back and
and ask questions that were hard
questions and I appreciate that thank
you and thank you for all the amazing
podcasts you do and for being a source
of light and hope and healing and love
to so many people
same for you with your own family
that's where it starts that's where it
begins you know I I I I will just leave
everybody with this point which I think
is it's meaningful to me
one of we spoke before about litmus
tests you know one of the litmus tests
generally if we are in a right path is I
always say humility
people who are ready to grow people who
say you know what yeah maybe I made some
serious mistakes and I would like to
learn about it and if it resonates and
if it's empowering and if it's helping
my family I'm really ready to do things
differently
that's that's a sign of real real
spiritual connection
when somebody has nothing of that all
they could say is this is the way it is
and there's no reason for you to talk to
me because I'm never changing my mind
never changing my mind and then they
blame religion and Judaism and God and
Tyra and they're rabbit for that
right away this just smells with with an
arrogance and an haughtiness is there
any truth that you don't know is it
possible that there's something new to
learn like did they ever really teach
you everything there is to know about
life and about the brain it's like
imagine a doctor tells you everything
there is to know about medicine I know a
therapist tells you everything there is
to know about emotions I know a
scientist tells you everything there is
to know about the world I know you run
away from these people
forgive me to say with religion it's
exactly the same thing if somebody tells
me anything there is to know about truth
about education about the future I know
really
I'm sorry well I don't so
I I think I think life will humble
everybody at some point or another until
they're it should be it should be
through revealed life humbles everybody
but it should be only through revealed
goodness
I think the trick is to not wait for
life to Humble if you can get the memo
to become humble without life crushing
you it's very hard then you win it's
very hard there's a sikha there's a talk
from the river the fifth of in his
safety Shalom he has a line in Yiddish
he says
foreign
he says life breaks all people
what do you have to wait
he says humble yourself work on yourself
there was another man his name was
Hemingway
and he says life breaks all people and
then some people know how to live in
broken places better than others
he didn't he shot himself
but uh I think you know in Judaism we
learned that every Brokenness is just an
opportunity to create a deeper form of
wholeness
may we all have the courage to do that
huh I was waiting for you to say you're
lying that it's through the cracks that
the light comes in not my line but it's
a good line it's it's not for me now
it's yours okay
now it's become yours but again thank
you so much Robbie Jacobson really thank
you thank you for the opportunity thank
you on behalf of our generation thank
you for being a voice of of Love of
beauty what's the words that he always
uses of authenticity of realness I'm not
gonna I'm not gonna do it as well as you
do it but thank you for that because our
children and our grandchildren are going
to thank people like you and Rabbi Taub
and all those Educators that are
speaking in the way of love and
connection and attachment because we
need to make sure that this generation
because this is a generation that's the
green machine I know it these are the
teens these these teens these youth are
the ones that are going to agree
throughout that they're going to greet
machine off
thank you that means a lot that means a
lot and I really thank you for those
words and sentiments
and even more what's behind the words
this class is brought to you by the
yeshiva.net please help us continue the
classes make even a small contribution
at triple w dot the yeshiva.net donate