Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

When I Nurture My Struggling Child, How Will It Affect the Others?

9,061 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

the yeshiva.net [Music] thank you welcome rabbi russell welcome to everybody those who are here for the first time and those who are can we raise the volume okay clear okay so welcome to everybody so let's get right into it the topic that by russell and myself want to explore with all of you today is the basic issue of the family unit even if you follow everything all of the advice of real experts who are sensitive and empathetic and understand the situation and understand the consequences you're doing it all you didn't you do what you do with messier snefish and you do it with conviction and with commitment and with love and you have a support system so you're really doing everything right but you have another six children you have another eight children you have another two children some parents some families have one struggling child some have a few struggling children sometimes there are children who are so to speak following the trajectory that you plan for all the children and that balance is often extremely difficult both in terms of yourself in terms of your spouse in terms of the children themselves and then there there's the whole other element which has to do with often that there's very little support there's a lot of shame there's stigma there are neighbors there's always an uncle who knows better some of you are lucky to have mothers who give you perfect advice some of you are lucky to have fathers who are clueless some of you are lucky to have other people who tell you how wrong you're doing things especially when you invite that person for shabbos you ever had that and sunday morning your shiver or shrieker or somebody else says i have to have a meeting with you you know that meeting they sit down with you at the meeting and they look at you and they tell you how much they care for you and then they give you unbelievable genius advice they tell you that you should tell your 17 year old daughter that in this house sneeze is a requirement it's like wow wow that deserves a nobel prize never thought of that one that never occurred to me she also never heard it before so anyway this is the sugiya answer shimon says the sugiya or the parsha for those who learn tereshabiksav it's the parsha for those of the terrorists whether it's departure of the sugi it's complex that we want to address so i'm going to open up with a question to rabbi russell and here's the question this is off okay let's go one knees okay but i have one of these okay so the question of shimon that i would like to raise is the following scenario should we mention that we're going to open up for questions yeah yes at the end towards the end of the program we're going to open it up for questions so anybody could share any question you would like if you want to do it pixar anonymously that's fine if you want to raise your hand and speak up that's perfectly fine remember that in this room you will not find judgmentalism because as they say everybody's in the same boat so you know every story has been hurt and experienced and wept with by empathetic people so you could bring up anything you want even a very extreme and difficult situations you can also give it in the salve if you want on a piece of paper as you wish women and men feel comfortable so first question rabbi russell is there's a beautiful shabbos meal happening in the house or a wednesday evening or a sunday evening dinner yankee came home he had a sitter party he's excited to share with you what he learned about avraham avinu dvori is seven years old she's saying abraca with a lot of geshmak and she wants to make sure that she did spheres last night so she shouldn't forget and in walks your teenage son who's not wearing a yamaka and you're afraid you want to be nice you want to be welcoming you know not to say get out of my house until you put on a yamaka you've already exercised that genius piece of advice you have been around the block the only reason you ended up here is because you have done a lot of other things and they didn't work right if other things would have worked nobody would have been there nobody would go to the shipment nobody would go to avi fisher you would do what you know what you think is the right thing so you've tried it so you know that that doesn't work but you have all these little kinder locks sitting at dinner sitting at shabbos you're trying to say advantage and you're afraid you're really afraid you know will these kids grow up and take over their yamaka what's the right approach what are you supposed to do that's it simple question such a simple question so okay so to address this question we have to come to terms with the basic fundamental principle that you waited far too long to address this question you cannot wait until your kid walks in and all this beautiful stuff is happening at your table and it suddenly dawns on you oh i have this problem we're all aware [Music] and we watch unfortunately our kids beginning to struggle so to to know how to get to answer that question we need to build a bit of opinion we need to have an approach a mahalak that makes sense to us and once it makes sense to us nobody will have that question it'll be so partial what you need to do at that moment to explain this to someone who's never seen this pasha never been through this pasha never had a struggling child it won't make sense how you say what you say the first and foremost we have to have a relationship with our children all our children where we talk to them where we stop being shy about what's going on in our families we stop being embarrassed and ashamed and kind of hoped no one noticed that yankee doesn't wear yarmulke anymore and somehow we didn't like you know no one's paying attention trust me the kids know before we do the siblings know before we do what's going on they all know something's going on and the power is that no one told us that we're meant to sit down with our children long before you have that problem at your table and talk to them openly about what you're doing what the problem is in your home how you're approaching it how you're dealing with it and open up for all your children communication where they feel safe to come and talk to you and when they where they will understand when things happen why you took the approach you took we have to let go of this like idiotic approach forgive me that we're kind of hoping you know they won't notice we're kind of tolerating him but pretending to have the same kind of family i want to say something that i think sits at the bosses of all this this whole subject and we have to we have to bring this across in a way that everyone can embrace this it's difficult to hear what i'm about to say but i think that we need to hear it and then pause all of us just for a moment and let it sit let it sit when you have a child in your home who is in crisis who's probably almost certainly gone through some sort of traumatic experience and unfortunately at this stage of their life have rebelled against the fundamental principles of your home your ash gothas and your values you need to shift your home to a different style of genuchi you need to take your whole home somewhere else and recognize that the chances of you somehow maintaining the exact same type of yeshiva with the same values hashgraphs everything working just the way it did and do crisis with this other child the chances are zero it's not gonna happen and i think it's really important that we accept that we let that sink in and understand you're not gonna get like find a clever happy way to deal with yankee without the yamaga while maintaining everybody else in the exact same way they always were that does not mean you won't have a beautiful toyota cajon it simply means that the style of your own the way it was cannot continue and unless you understand that there's aid so there's no there's nothing to say i cannot tell you what to do at that table if what you really think you're meant to be doing is the same how did you describe it yeah the the same parachute and the what was it you said these beautiful things this is you know whatever it is the same islamist may not belong right now at this table and maybe after the meal it may be separate it may be in a different place but it may not be right now and can we accept that see if we don't embrace the what we're what we are setting about here is a is a sugar of suffix we are going to try and change to save this child's life unless we see that none of this is going to make any sense the question won't make any sense why are we compromising the other children the fact is the compromise is only in timing the the compromise is in the exact surah of what your director is of your home and your your parents and your zeida the kind of still what the the picture we have in our heads of how we should be running this shabbos table this yanta table you have to let go of that picture we can have another picture a beautiful picture you can't have that one once you have a young kid and if that's something you can't accept well there's very little for us to offer to help you with because the the attempt to maintain the exact same rule hashkarfa's values you know the same surah and do this that's not possible that's not doable so people say to us you should sacrifice this child the all the other children that so if the answer is it's the surah you're sacrificing not sacrificing any children you're actually giving all your children what they need and you'll give these two but it's not that surah what we need to do the first thing we need to come to terms with all of us is to talk to our other children without communication we're not going to get anywhere we need to imagine i asked about many many years ago what do you do this this exact question god i asked him what do you do yankee comes in here millie is sooner and yankee walks in and puts a light on you know turns afflicts the light in front of you curses you out takes his yarmulke if he has one flicks across the room he's like until matzo storms out the house what do you do shiva told me you're meant to gather the other children around all of them when he's not there you don't do in front of him that's not nice it's not kind but when he's gone you gather the other children around you put your arms around them and you say listen your brother is struggling he's hurting we don't know why we don't understand it but he's hurting he's in pain we his family have a thief to love each other to love him to create an environment in our home that's so loving and warm that he'll want to be here that's our here that's our responsibility so we have to the first step i think i i'm trying to answer the question you know everything is opinion you understand but the first step is communication can we come to terms with that please go home and talk to our kids sit down with them explain to them if you're not sure yet what you're doing tell them you're not sure yet if it's it just you know it's happening under your nose and talk to them we're getting advice we're getting guidance we're not certain but open communication with your other kids so that when you have to compromise a fashion sheet that's in the middle of happening because the yankee freaks out can't handle it and it triggers him they'll understand why and they'll also understand i'll do it with you later don't worry we'll find time later just now isn't the time so you're suggesting if i just may clarify that a lot of the challenges of many people is the fact that they're not ready to accept a paradigm shift that's it in their entire marriage and family i can tell you what's for us it was for my wife and i early on we were still attempting to run the exact same type of home while being tolerant you know of the one that was struggling it didn't occur to us yet that we needed a paradigm shift not a shift kasperson away from toronto but a paradigm shift in how we were expressing our devotion to torah mitzvahs in a way that could be inclusive and include the struggling kids too but it's not going to be the classic yeshiva the you know it with the same surah you know the surah we would all like of our kids coming dressed in their i think matching shabbos outfits right it's going to be matching right so they should all be looked the same you know it that surah in our soog is gone let it go there's another surah so it's a different paradigm it's just as authentic by the way and it can be beautiful and enriching and spiritual and nourishing but it's not that it's not that there's a beautiful void from the ishbitsa the holy ish but saying this week says literally it means don't make for yourself a molten god you know don't craft god out of metal so he says which meshugana thinks that you're going to make some metal toy and that's going to be god she says don't turn god into a particular structure oh in other words sometimes what happens is yiddish guide god becomes synonymous with that seer this is what god is everything else is antithetical to yiddish sometimes circumstances in life shimon is saying challenge us and elevate us to really become connected to a god that is beyond surah how do we make images today of hashem nobody bows down to statues anymore right as far as i know i know where i live in muncie i don't think anybody bowing down to statues but we bow down to different types of statues exactly we bow down okay that too but also we bow down to spiritual statues what what yiddish guide is supposed to look like what my child is supposed to look like maybe your schlichtas is to have a different type of home maybe the rebena shalom want something else so that takes a lot of humility doesn't it oh gosh yes i it looks like you're talking from experience i am confident to believe that with the gifts hakaris brothel gave me i would have been a very big bulgari if not for my children i'll be honest i think i would have been judgmental and about guys and as on the contrary it was uh precisely the challenges with my children that helped prevent that and that's also one of the fundamental issues that we all have to embrace that this problem that we're dealing with we have to come at it from a perspective that this is called kuloi rodzan i you know we nod our heads forgive me and i i think we should address this just for a moment if we can we nod our heads theoretically i think we all agree a person cannot stop his big toe in this world elohim can unless amalek and what do we do with that you know we sit there as if this whole sugya shouldn't be happening to me no and i was in logic in torah and i think we all agree that else has been a shamayam what i'm going through is not a mistake it's not an accident it's rats which we will have we will help the whole story when we get up there we're working out why but if again if we don't if we just keep that externals like a if that's just you know a thought in our heads but it's not in your nervous system it's not in your heart if you don't live that then when yankee walks in with that yarmulke and you're trying to do a pasha sheet trust me you'll do the wrong thing you'll feel he took something from you that you were entitled to instead of feeling now the moment he walks in i have a different given a different approach to the beautiful sharmas that we're about to have or they're in the middle of it just changed that's all and takes something from me he took me to a different place and how to rejoice and enjoy charles again if we don't see that what's going to happen is yankee is going to know extremely well that he is one big fat disappointment to you one big fat disor you know he just you're sick of him he's ruining my shadows and we're going to lose yankee yank is not in the way that's tyre from ashkaf satyara yank is not in the way and i think that's a challenge that we have all of us is to not just darshan but to live to take these beliefs and accept it fully inside and by the way that includes a little can we call her layla doing her parsha sheets that includes why is she in your family why did they wish the buddha there has ever dawned on us that all that music of our other children put into this family also minister might have given to us what davis did didn't know what was going to play out he didn't know that they were going to get exposed to yankee maybe the very way we as parents respond to dealing with yankee is teaching our other kids something so profound and is precisely what they need for their ticket which is why they're in your home let's see that's the paradigm shift we have a picture as if we got to make this cookie cutter thing this home like i say the the uncle moishi version of shabbos right no yeah i mean it's it's it's primitive rabbi size primitive it's great for kids you know but we shouldn't actually take that seriously what's uncle shimon's version of charles i'll tell you what uncle sherman's version which song does he do hashem is here oh definitely for sure he's there whether it's good or bad the way you want it to be hashem is there and hashem is everywhere even when yankee walks in with yamaka and i have to stop with the parshishi because he aggravates him and let leila know i don't why we'll finish it later don't worry we'll do about sheet and you bring up a topic and a conversation that includes yankee that he wants to be there too and hashem is with him and with all the others and all the other children i think it's anyone who disagrees with this you come talk to me but it cannot be the way i see life and the way i believe khazal expressed life to does that it's a mistake that all these kids are getting exposed to yankee right now that was a mistake they must have messed up on that one give you a no you see it's ludicrous everyone loves you should laugh it's partial foolish which means maybe the gift to your children the other children is watching you as miradic the hybrid of parents loving parents deal with with an embrace yankee and they watch and they nourish themselves their spirits and their neshamas by watching you that will come out later in their lives as murder payrolls they will define their very lives in this world because they watched how you handled it so rip shim and this is all beautiful and very eloquent but somebody asks in reality the older one who left yiddish already influenced another one so there's two children now who left does that mean the next four are going to leave judaism and i should just say this is a wonderful mission watching all my children leave does one really influence the others is that how it's supposed to work and you say yeah that's what it is so i say like this like it's another what i believe see if we had money if anyone's rich by the way please give me a lot of money so i can do research that i won't take any of money i just want to do research because it is my humble opinion and if we could do the research we just need a lot of money to do it properly there should be ms digger research you have yankee see has a younger brother a year and a half younger than him and he's so partially he's falling in his footsteps you see what's going on with him but i believe if we did the research properly what we would discover is that his brother for the last 10 years has been having a problem eating away at the soul of his life his nushammer distancing him confusing him conflicting him and now that your bar hashem learning crisis and being tolerant and accepting to save yankee this one feels safe to let his soros emerge out of him yankee didn't cause that young he didn't sit down and give a speech you know convincing them yankee and your approach with yankee allow the next one if it happens for his problems and struggles and issues to emerge so that we can deal with that too and we can help them too so we don't have to worry about the influence again we got the wrong wrong idea here if you have children in your home who were never traumatized never experienced any form of drama that means they don't have any learning problems because if you have any learning problems you will be traumatized you'll have learning trauma we've talked about this many times they don't have sexual trauma they don't have learning trauma you as parents are no better or worse than anybody else that means you're not vicious mean horrible people who beat up your kids angrily every day right the kids are just gazun to regular learning kids happy kids without any form of trauma not only will they not be hurt and influenced by young in this process but you will enhance their lives the yiddishkai the torah they'll probably become therapists you know someone like kashuv in the community helping children because they witnessed how you helped your yankee and saved his life enkei all the other struggling kids for example i'll give an example the most common one i ever see is unfortunately the tragedy and it's not always the explanation it's not there are many many things but let's take a classic simple model where unfortunately the older kids in the family are molested they get molested by neighbors become molested in school they get molested and unbeknown to anyone in the family because you never heard of it and unfortunately we're still in a culture where we're just now beginning properly to have open education to all parents about prevention of sexual child abuse it's only beginning now after 25 years of me talking about this it's now beginning the schools are having kinussium and educating their parents are warning them and teaching them the signs and how to protect their children from sexual advice just happening now last two three four years this is it so what happens in a family where no one ever told you no one it was never amanda was never discussed the question of protection of sexual childhoods never it was just something that we didn't talk about in our world the nebu the older two kids got molested in school and come home and molest four or five other kids in the family common story common story you end up with six kids ten you know out of ten you you end up with five four three who get molested yankee then starts struggling because he hits 14 15 and he starts struggling and you have to tolerate some blah blah blah so comes home we as parents are completely oblivious we are blind that any of this happened utterly blind no one told us about it no one cautioned us we don't know what the signs are we don't know how to prevent it we think when your daughter you know your 14 year old daughter is locked in her bedroom a long shot this afternoon with her best friend because they're for the first time ever learning homework together and they don't want to be bothered by the rest of the kids no one told you locked door because she's worried about the kids coming in not true hashem your athena what's going on in that room no one told you this and you're happy she's not running around the street she's learning small aleph with a friend no one told us these things and before we know it you've got a family where the hidden painful traumatic secret of abuse is systemic in the family comes along yankees 15 and he goes off and then the next one starts going off and all the aposky you know a lot of posca here are ready to commit that they know for sure you see the bad influence yank is having on the next one do you get it how absurd that is how bizarre that is yankee didn't affect the next one and not in the way that we're talking about because we were tolerant and he dressed that way the rest are hurting like crazy inside and as they see parents who are more tolerant and accepting and understanding or as they get older they plants one after the other they seem to have these problems and really what you're looking at is systemic molestation something to do with the exposure and if i had the money i would do the research and i'd prove it i could tell you anecdotally just to having done the work for 30 years i can tell it's a fact and hariah how many times i've spoken where parents of people have come to me parents and other people and told me how they grew up in such a home they have parents just like i described who hung on to their kid and they became who they are from precisely because they modeled themselves on parents who were saving their sibling we all have that the exposure alone does not cause kids to go off the nerve it's not true if a kid is happy productive successful learning well treated properly by parents loved feels loved and cared for and productive they don't go off it's a challenge but they don't go off and all they need is for us to open up a conversation with them and say to them one day shay fallon this must be very hard for you and they'll cry and they'll tell you it is hard for them but there's no shinkansen going off but it is hard for them to watch and again we have to open up communication with our children to reach inside their struggles and connect with them we don't do this sugy of christ is gonna look around them we talk to them we help them share we give them language to express their struggles their issues but the simplistic notion that the exposure to yankee alone when you've got eleka loving caring parents that that suddenly is going to make him go off with no other cause is not true except what is happening is that because yankee is struggling and maybe because we provided safety and they see we love him that they feel more safe and secure to expose what they're struggling with too because they maybe they dare to believe that we as parents might be interested in helping them maybe they feel safe with us finally that we can actually help them so let's uh yank let's leave yankee along for a few minutes let's go to mati so mati is sitting monday night at the monty's a whole different story and of course he's a very sensitive boy we're not as we know and therefore he loves the underdog and every new left-wing policy becomes the new deity and he's explaining to his 14-year-old sister how real freedom is about expressing yourself homosexuality through homosexuality through lesbianism lgbt is the best thing that ever happened to humanity since who knows when since the big bang and um and this poor 14 year old girl who's struggling with her own identity and her sexual identity suddenly learns that being a lesbian is as dignified and maybe more dignified than uh not being alive and leave it to mati explain how the whole idea of marriage is uh you know institution of bigotry sure repression and look what your parents produced through their marriage so the proof is in the pudding right the misery their walks goes around in this house and you don't you don't want to argue you want to give monty love you you don't want to explain to mati you know that his brain you know his amygdala has taken over one day he'll come to question off she maybe and learn about his amygdala so so what do you do at that conversation okay so so again somebody told me at his chamber's table you know uh i don't mean to offend anybody but you know this is a family that's very into israel and all that and you know this guy is comparing israeli soldiers to uh to the you know well i know unfortunately there's some religious jews who do that but it's repulsive and this person he just burst out against this child he didn't mean to but he couldn't hear it to call a jewish kid ss you know sure well that male 1 doesn't affect themselves but we talk about homosexuality and all these types of things so i'm the father i'm the mother what do i uh okay so so again everything needs abyssal to jump in on mati as if to answer that without a framework it probably won't be very helpful and here's the framework i'll tell you a story i'll tell you a very painful story this goes back some 25 years ago probably about 25 years ago we were the beginning of our journey one heir of shabbos friday afternoon we got a phone call from one of the stats ask on him who i knew well in lakewood and told him told me it doesn't matter what you're doing but you and your wife need to come over now that's by the way never a pleasant phone call with our hearts in our hands we went over to the house remember do you remember this we went over there and we were treated to a description about one of our children and he was just telling us because he's my friend you know how this kid is about to be thrown out of school if we're smart if we're wise we'll get him out of town to some other you know city just get him away from here again said russia letting us know you know that hassan had been up to no good things whatever it was wasn't proven we didn't know oyster it wasn't true there was no business there was no nothing there was just good old-fashioned this call it what it was but meanwhile we were threatened and terrified we were young parents with a young family and told you know this is what's going to happen your kid's about to get killed you know ruined get them out of them so i this is about 25 years ago we came home i probably felt like i was dead inside i didn't know i had an amygdala in those days but what i did know was that my entire being was shut down i froze i went into real freeze i was as close to dissociating as as you could be and still be present somehow like a dead person i made kiddush i must have sounded like a funeral you know i was saying kill molly rather the death of someone i could when i get like that i don't thank god anymore but when i did my voice would go low i could barely get the words out they hear the very evil king this wasn't a very uplifting kindness i must tell you i remember going through the meal frozen couldn't talk couldn't really make eye contact with anyone benched as quickly as i could and went up and went to sleep and just lay there frozen in bed somehow i must have pulled myself together next day you know but this kind of thing happened to me in those early days before i learned anything about the sugar how to understand what to do and i went into this free state so later that week i remember i was talking with one of my other children who was struggling herself at that time and i don't know how it happened but we got into some which i now know reflectively i can refer to as an idiotic conversation where i was giving one of my incredibly meaningful drushes about how amazing tyra mitzvahs is this is the best life and i was convincing her to give up her wayward ways with an amazing drusher almost as good as one of his that's how good it was when i finished this joshua she was silent and then she said something that killed me and changed my life because she said to me you know you're giving this joshua this speech about how amazing tyra mitzvahs is it's the best way of life it's the greatest way of life and she said to me i have to be honest with you it doesn't look like that it doesn't look like it's really working very well for you she mentioned that last friday night and many other times when that kind of thing had happened she said straight i don't know it just doesn't seem to be working well for you i don't know why you think it should work for me and she walked off what was painful about the moment was i knew she was right i knew she was right and she killed me with her truth which she gratefully did many more times during our journey together but i stumbled across this truth you know winston churchill they have this saying from winston churchill that in the course of life sooner or later everyone stumbles over the truth the problem is most people pick themselves up dust themselves off and walk off as if nothing happened well i was determined not to and i did tremendous amount of soul searching from that moment on asking myself if i'm so thrown off in my yiddish kite because of the challenges and struggles then i think i have the wrong relationship to yiddish i must have missed something somewhere in the education the shivas whatever i got i must have missed something somewhere which i realized over the years i really did miss we spoke about this when we did that program about the three changes that i felt must be made in the system since ashore mentions the reason we're here in this world nasa's mitzvos hashem most people don't even know the third one it's paladin the third one is la made binisayan to be aimed at and i must tell you i never heard that before i read that mr lesher many times but never took it to heart never once in the country i suffered with sheva brushes disorder you know that is right chevy rotten disorder it's where you should sit at shepherd brothers and you believe everything they're saying shiver brother's disorders move around i mean the brothers are beautiful i'm not from the bronx but the picture that's painted is simply never true i was once sitting with a certain resheba the shepherd brothers they were doing this stuff he nudged me and told me shimmer get up and say the truth i said no i can't he said no you have to he said and i said like i was embarrassed and suddenly he stood up and clapped and said if she was going to speak so i got up and i said i'll tell you the truth you both look like beautiful young people horses nice color you look like you actually love each other did anyone tell you you're going to fight i said to them watch the heads of all the married people in this room because i'm about to describe marriage to you and i went forth my usual mahalo that we all struggle and fight we work it out and we build that's how you build yourself uh i'm at venusaion there's no such thing and never was a marriage couple who didn't fight everyone goes through their struggles their fights that that's how we meant to grow and when to work out how to do that respectfully do it lovingly but no one told us that this world the third of the big three islam had been isaiah we should be ahmed ben isaiah no one told us that so we're utterly unprepared and therefore we get terribly to broken when we suffer from shaming brothers disorder we treat that by the way if you come i have a specialty in german disorder i can get you over it so you become realistic about life actually we're doing group therapy on that right now all right we can all let it go if we could get over it and we could understand that being uh saying is that we're going to have very swear in this unis that they're going to challenge us and be difficult for us then we don't get subragan when they happen that means we stay centered we stay positive people ask me very often how come you're always so happy people ask me doesn't make sense and all these struggling people who know me you could ask there are people who know me at this audience for years many years and they will attest am i right or wrong generally speaking i'm a happy person yeah my wife says yes we agree on something but we have to find that centered healthy place of being happy and positive so the when let's get back to mati mati was in mati ah marty is a 15 year old brilliant dashing epicurus yes where he's holding right now and he's infecting all the children with this but guess what the children are really watching you us and when they see we're not flipping out we're not freaking out we're not looking like death warmed up we're not frozen and bitter and angry and here's the kin the the key we're not threatened by mati and then when we talked to them later they observed and witnessed that we were not threatened we were relaxed guess what that tells all the children it tells all the children don't take it so seriously there's another side to this this wasn't the right moment to start up with marty so i let it go don't think i'm threatened by these ideas i could fan for it we'll talk later you're conveying through your body language your facial expression you're conveying to your children don't take this so seriously you know why because i'm not because i'm not and you have to reach that place where you attack and not friend because you can't fake such stuff you can't fake it you have to really actually not be threatened and when you reach that place where you're not threatened and the kids witnessed and observed you were not being threatened they absorb that they get strength from that and later on if you wish to it's fascinating again if i had the money for research if we were able to do that father and mother shabbos table mott is darshaning about you know whatever it is and the parents and the kids are watching you don't think they're not watching you trust me your children are watching you and when they see you're relaxed you don't take it so seriously if we would do the research afterwards and ask the kids how seriously did you take all that they would say to you yeah not so seriously interesting but because they learned it from you and you never had to say a word not a single word but it demands that we get to that place where i understand that the seeing this is part of life and struggles are there and it's why we're here and i can actually not be like i was with my daughter when she put me in my place good and proper and pointed out yiddish to your yiddish guy it doesn't seem to be working very well for you we don't want to be in that place we want to be in a place that regardless of the nissanese and struggles that get thrown in our face yiddish kind is working actually very well for me you know why because i believe [Music] it's all good it's there for my better i mean i understand exactly how but it's all for me i'm going to work it out and when my kids when i live that do you understand your amygdala doesn't go off like crazy and you don't freak out you stay real calm and ruined and your children will watch that they will see you and learn more from your silence and your acceptance and you're not getting reactive than from any direction or protection and what do we do instead foolishly we leap up send shamati cover his mouth you know if we had a submachine gun we like run after it with a submachine gun you know terrified about what he's saying what do you think that tells our kids it says that what he's saying is powerful and profound and we're scared of it that does far more harm but i need the money to do the research to prove it what do you tell the mother what do you tell the mother whose daughter is really really dressing close to adam and java before the tree you know her grandmother comes in or her aunt comes into the house you know it's purim it's purim it's a chevy broker you know that grandmother produced 14 kids can i know that there's three hundred eight o'clock every other night each one's a rush of shiva and it's just that shame that shame or or the husband's rash yeshiva walks into the house or walks into shoulder comes into the house and the father feels like averting his gaze from his son emotionally this is certain this is not my child for that moment there's so much shame yep for the father of the mother in front of personalities who they respect who they grew up with who they look up to and who are going to judge them or at least they think they're going to judge them what would you tell them emotionally so i'll tell you what we did one of our fasteners about her daughter abouts she had been struggling for a long long time she's the one who's not from presently and um probably closer to us than any of our children probably the closest right the youngest when she got married she was married she'd been divorced married and divorced when she got married up until then she was very much not with the program and close to harvard before the head on many occasions she's the one that we loved it when she came to the shabbos meal in a unicorn unicorn onesie because everything got covered it was the best thing out it was great her best friend prior to getting married was a guy a homosexual guy who worked in the local wawa in jackson am i correct saying right i don't usually get these things right but i'm saying it right her best friend was a homosexual guy which we were kind of happy about because you know for obvious reasons this was like ain'r you're redmi not sure thank you hashem on one occasion where he she actually bugged out so badly one hour of shabbos that she said that's yeah i'm going to him for shabbos i'm not sure what that means i'm going to do four shabbas whatever it means and we my wife and i packed up a whole shop as a cat and bottle of grape juice a bachelor we gave her some coogles some food remember we packed it all up said you need food for shabbos we sent her off the shops to the homosexual boyfriend imagine the hype in the shabbos they must have had she came back mozzie sharpest everything was good we even put a bench in there showed her where kiddish was i'm exaggerating i think we put that benchy okay poetic license kitsa at her wedding the nidden came up you know i have a lot of like very nice from friends who come to our weddings and i must tell you in those days we weren't so open i don't think with everyone about what we were going through but the ninja came up for my wife and i what do we do with the homosexual boyfriend what was his name i'm about for his name a good gesunder guy so we then was what do we do with him all our friends are upon him you know i was like connected person you know people came covering him and um so we decided i guess all her girlfriends knew him they knew him she was part of the hebrew so we invited him because i told her you know you're getting married it's like a pseudospray there you know you're gonna you're kind of a boyfriend and a husband so you're going to say goodbye and he should understand that so we invited him to the wedding and we sat him on the ladies side with the girlfriends but bakitza we invited dylan it was a pseudospreader it was her best friend and i don't think she ever spoke to him again i think that was it i think that was the end maybe once or twice and that was it but it wasn't like a long lasting what stops us with this is obvious is we're just so done embarrassed that's what stops us because i'm guessing that everyone in this room you know now you're sort of introduced to crisis you understand what we did was the right move but to do it that you have to overcome your ego that you have to understand you're doing god's work she is closer to us as close marry and my rights are wrong as any of our kids closest every day she wakes up every morning first thing she does in bed is zoom or whatsapp video called my wife where she's lying in bed or has a coffee shmoo i come up to you they're close like anything and that was our job our job is to keep it close but we have to overcome that and realize your priority your god our god-given priority is our children we we gave birth to them and we owe them unconditional love even at the expense of being embarrassed in front of and i can't tell you i i don't remember being embarrassed i don't what yeah no i don't i that story with her i don't remember being embarrassed i remember my ears nearly bursting my eardrums where at the end of the castle they went into some loud rock thing the hustler turned in some rock concerts at the end and it was like whoa no one want me to bring earplugs you know i needed that but our commitment is our kids not the neighbors not the grandmother not everyone else we know we should be a hazarious to them when they say to us the classic time-honored line the famous this need in the hall of fame of bad lines to say this is the one most abused how could you let her do that how could you let her if any of us had any control or power not to without being a music without destroying her life we don't let we live with them in the hope we can repair their attachments and over years and decades they will stay with us return to us live a life a meaningful life by us repairing our attachments with them and i have to tell you if it comes to my worry about the rash shiva walking in or the grandmother i'm happy to sit down and have a conversation with them later i'm not mean i don't ignore them i offer them a conversation but just not now just not now because my priority is my child so you feel when the father emotionally disassociates even for five minutes from his child because he wants to fit into the charade the ambiance he's sacrificing his child on the altar of his ego that is beautifully put so that avi fishoff will be sending that around in fact you probably received it already your phone's going probably centered it usually since two in the morning oh my phone yes that's exactly what it is is there somebody says is there other room your sister's making a wedding and your son is going to show up maybe without a yamaka or maybe in a bathing suit your daughter is going to show up however she's going to show up is there room to say we'll cover the casa now the cover the symmetra zadie's going to be here this maybe it's good thing i didn't have lunch or i'd throw up okay there is no room our loyalty is to our child and if your sister or sister-in-law calls you or your brother epis you know i don't want to like you know i hope you won't be you know the lady but you know because bobby because of bobby you know it's because of bobby right you know if she could just come bobby has poor borderline personality your answer is i totally understand and we miss we'll miss you and we wish you mazel tov but we won't be there wow so the parents themselves should not show up absolutely not and you tell them gently i'm so i understand you can't handle it i got it it's embarrassing for you but we won't be there because you want to show your child that they come from absolutely yes [Applause] and i'll tell you something else i asked the sheila the sheila to upon him many times because i told this to people i was working with and then suddenly someone invokes the time honored cuba of the aim clause and lets you know that you're over on cubit of the aim because either you know you have to come he wants and bobby needs the picture with all the you know today you can photoshop in afterwards anyway i said you could photoshop clothes on her then what's your problem it's the big deal if that's what you want but they evoke this cubit of the aim clause designed to make you destroy your child i got news for you in halakhah it has no place says you take care of your child first if you're forced into that corner then gently and respectfully you reassure yourself that my priority is my child even at the expense as gently as you do it of quebec receive many many times from that that means we don't be sorry we can't be angry we can't you know you don't create a scene you just share the facts i'm so sorry we won't be there it's all of us or none of us and you need to make up your mind and if you can't do it we're fine we respect that we respect that my child is my priority it's probably helpful to remember the alternative you may show up at the wedding your child will be forced to be in a way they don't want to be but the result may be somebody cutting their wrists yes yes exactly somebody overdosing absolutely the concept we're not just dealing with we're dealing with yes that's exactly right we are dealing with korchner and therefore we side with our child always under any and all circumstances especially when it comes to shame and embarrassment and we say so i won't come it's fine and that includes khali ka parties that includes where no one officially is allowed to talk about the fact that her uncle molested her and no one's allowed to say this because he's been struggling his whole life and now he's sort of getting it together and we don't want to destabilize him we don't mind if your daughter is in a psychiatric unit that we're okay with but we don't want to destabilize him i don't want to get into the lumbers and the the inequity of it all but there is a woman that her father molested her for years she doesn't go visit she can't and her sisters tell her kibbud you're killing mommy and tati by not showing up like the rest of the family what would be your responsibility supposed to be short please go to mommy and dante and tell them as soon as tanti makes amends for what he did we'll be happy to come let him make amends first that can let him make amends but until he make amends no sorry sorry so just to clarify the concept that kibbut of aim comes at the expense of your health and your children's health is a very corrupt concept as well well when you say yes it is i mean is it often clearly i mean if you say to me that uh my health i don't want this to be misunderstood if my health temporarily i find it difficult because my parents want me to come and move a cabinet for them a closet to another room which they can and it's a bit strenuous i go do it right but what we're saying is like this if i'm putting myself or my child into a sophic which you would be if you're going to force your child to dress properly to go to the pasta especially where they know they're not wanted or respected or loved the reaction to that is and in such cases and your partner from kevin of in that moment when is the point that a parent does know that the attachment is good enough or that the child's prefrontals are functioning to the point that you could nicely tell them to do something number one how do you know that you're working through the side i don't care how well your prefrontal cortex is functioning we don't tell them to do something ever ever we don't tell them i don't tell my kids to do things and my kids true or folks are incredibly respectful to me true or false i never tell them i would never tell my kid to empty the garbage i would ask them schaefeler do you think you could empty the garbage if you could i'd agree if not don't worry i'll do it and i'm more than happy to do it what about none in crisis i do the same thing i don't tell my kids what to do that's why they will respect me i said truthfully am i barry mommy truthful not i probably took most of the garbage out of it he was with us for yandere i probably took out most of the garbage i asked them but you know who took it out momo his 15 year old son my oldest grandson and what 15 year old wants to take out garbage i mean let's be real you know unless you're crazy what 15 year old boy is going to slap from the fourth floor walk all the way down and then down the street so the big thumbs up what age do you stop telling them to do anything i i don't i ask them i never tell them i never tell them i always ask them schaeffler would you mind what about a seven-year-old a five-year-old time to go to bed that's different i'm asking to do something a favor for me and regular henov i might tell them because they have to it's bedtime but er by bar mitzvah for sure but i miss the bus mitzvah over that age i don't tell my kids ever what to do i ask them i talk to them and guess what right or wrong they more or less are compliant includes everything especially homework i think homework stinks [Applause] homework is a magic it's not as bad as parachutes but it's a magic how are we doing great i think we should open it up to the quickest open it up now to the crowd anybody can ask any question please keep it direct and concise to the point and go ahead stand up and speak loud so everybody can hear because we're not going to be able to hear oh maybe we have a microphone we can pass the microphone if anyone wants to ask a question please we have microphone oh here here here hello but she asked first to just let her she asked first kaisema basiakov [Music] closer to your mouth the question was about children you said about children we don't we they're supposed to be in the family they are supposed to be exposed to the older sibling and um or younger sibling whatever it is uh what about grandchildren um my personal experience my older son answer shiloh my married son he said um he can't bring his children if if my son does a verus in front of him and that means like not wearing a yamako so i'd like to know about that well i'd like to speak to israel that's all i mean i just like i mean listen i'd like to speak to israel it's the wrong basket i'd like to understand the uniqueness of his story i understand it at times the parents their haircut could well be their children who are of a tender age where they can't understand what's going on it could well be i could hear that i could understand that but that's the whole question was that her son who was from and is married doesn't want to bring history yeah i know i go to the house because yeah i got it it happens frequently i like to talk to them and i do talk to them frequently but again i it's i understand there may be a certain uniqueness for your son and his wife with their children that even in halacha it could be it's not so partial that they have the responsibility to expose their children he for him to develop the hashgraphers we're talking about here would take a long time for them to understand it so it's it's you know i don't know the answer to that without speaking to him in his wrath but i i want to reiterate this thing is we reach out chicken in this world we reach our chicken in one of two ways we could either elevate ourselves elevate our year shaman work meets to work on ourselves to become the people we have to become fix our clippers problems because every neshama we come back you know people say we come back to tikkun the shama is not exactly accurate is we come back for ticking the clippers on our new shamans every morning but we have to go through we have two options we could either take tyra mitz was so genuine and serious that we work on it in a way where we refine ourselves we where we understand the tikkan amidas is the bosses le colitar kulai like the gun says we could understand that that that's my primary job where we've become is my you did nephesh rabbi schwartz roshan if he's here right now but my didn't have always says we need in this door to be the khazaneshniks where we're tremendously sensitive and working on us we could do it with santa toby in a positive way we could do all the chicken and louisia we don't for whatever reason the backup plan is that i couldn't sparkle will bring us schverinicianus and through those this units will have to do that chicken anyway one or the other nani started be nice if we could do it the positive way but in this store i don't think that's very likely for most of us but what's meant to happen is that kurdish brock was meant to test us and give a schwerin this units and he does we're meant to grow from them and work out how to deal with them go go ahead stand up stand up my question was answered already thank you oh wow somebody somebody texted in a question she says you do this my issue is not parents or siblings my issue is my own husband he's not ready to embrace our child and he doesn't recognize that it's his own trauma and his own ego and his own insecurity that's being triggered so he adds to the chaos instead of diminishing it i'm a woman alone in the house not only watching my children struggling but a husband who was a child himself and completely incapable of realizing how traumatized he is any advice you can give me i it's a very what you've described is a incredibly challenging problem that needs a very very sensitive to pull if the husband in case here is so traumatized as the text says that he's too traumatized to even understand by the way i think that's just inappropriate language usage because my experience has been that in the right way in the right setting with the right support in hadraka we can bring to the attention of someone how they trauma interferes in their lives it's not easy but it may be doable and i would strongly strongly strongly encourage this wife not to give up seeking counsel for herself for how to reach him i've seen it take years many many years but i've seen it done where eventually you know we get it and we can heal you support that child and your other children when we do crisis we have committed ourselves to fully support and care for and love our children in such a greater way than any of the hurts that happens to them from the isolation that they experience in the community because they have a struggling sibling we commit ourselves as parents to either move we moved we you move to a place that's less hostile that's more accepting and or you commit yourself to giving of yourself you and your wife to give more time love effort involvement caring playing with them talking to them you commit yourself to more until things can shift you cannot change the outside but we can always change the inside and the inside is the environment of love and support and i'll say one other hero we can walk around self-righteous i did it that's how i know it's true we walk around self-righteous knocking the neighbors being angry with them and i promise you i did it i did it until i stopped doing it because it add up too much space inside me it was it was hurting me to have such resentment such anger but the worst part of it was i saw it began to be picked up by my children and just created more negativity more reactive negativity when we as parents facing this horrible messiah of being isolated by neighbors relatives or friends but we as parents acknowledge it look away from it and we dedicate ourselves more to either moving to another place or to giving of ourselves more to our children but our children witness us not getting bitter or cynical or angry about it or frightened about it then the kids pick up that i can deal with this i can deal with this because they witness us dealing with it but if god forbid we are angry and falling apart because of it they hear that they will not deal with it well at all i think barry will have a question uh clarification uh question when you said before about talking to the younger siblings about the sibling that's in crisis what stage does a parent know that a child is ready for that conversation the younger children are ready for that that kind of conversation i think it's um it's a very good question first of all thank you thank you my honorable and wonderful son-in-law [Applause] the answer of course the question as it sat cannot be answered because the question of when are they old enough to talk to them the question is to talk to them about what so to talk to them about your sexually active 15 or 16 year old sibling at five they're probably not mature enough for that conversation to talk to them at that age about why he's not wearing a yarmulke around the house they might be so the first thing is to clarify each question demands a different level of maturity and age and i think it's a matter of trial and error that we talked to them you know communication i started it's very interesting because we're coming to the end but i started with this and i want to finish with this and then something else i want to say if that's okay but communication is the key this was the mistake we made in the early years where on the country everyone kept everything very quiet you know you pretend it's not happening in your home you don't want to talk to the other kids they shouldn't know they know they know more than we know we're certain by the way the neighbors do too and your friends and your relatives everybody knows you know we think we're high it's just a joke but the painful part of that is we let down our little children our younger children by not preparing them in advance in a mature and confident way that we're dealing with this we can deal with this there's a way to deal with this we must talk to our children age appropriately help them understand we're not blind and we're not dumb and we know what's going on and we're working with it and open communication to our children that if you're hurting or confused my door is always open my door is always open come talk to us it's crucial it's absolutely crucial this whole you know framework you know i used to say can i have i say something like funny okay so i used to say like no i shouldn't knock the hungarians we got any hungarians in the room i don't know okay good thank god they're not here so i can say my hungarian joke so i used to say why do hungarians only have rugs in their houses and not wall-to-wall carpets the reason is just in case there's a problem we need to sweep it under it doesn't work if there's wall-to-wall carpets so you need rugs that we have moved very far from by the way some of my best friends are hungarians my wife for example there's a hungarian she's hungry okay mrs london okay okay i understand that there is a time when a child is in crisis and there is no asking in the house whether to give in to their needs as then needed for example if they need a friend over the weekend in order to tolerate whatever is even though they're not keeping shabbos or in the moment they need a pet or whatever it is we we condition the family and train them and teach them that this is the need of this child right now and we're here for them but then comes a time where the healthy children it takes so long it takes years and the healthy children start to feel negated or not seen or not heard and it hurts their attachment when is the time when do we know that is the time to shift over to asking permission of all the healthy children to training the kip but before you bring your boyfriend for the weekend can you ask the kids in the house and see that everyone is ready for it when is the time for that for that shift to happen do you reunite the family okay so there might or might not be a time if the dynamics of homes are different some homes there will be a time because the child in crisis has developed with your help and love and they become more mature and you feel you could have these kind of conversations the the time would be for you to go and test the waters if you really believe your child is there go talk to them take them out and sit with them and explain to them and talk to them and see if you really feel they might be ready then i encourage you take them out for dinner sit with them and say listen if i'm wrong i'm asking michaela if i'm hurting you with this question help me understand that but if not this is a question i feel i must ask you wait until take them out and talk to them about it it absolutely does happen as they get older that they can have that sensitivity what are we working for these years and creating attachments if not to exploit them at some point so you don't say that's the whole point no i'm serious so when you get there just take them out and test it with them first okay does that make sense and we should all know that we could do that that is why we're working so hard on attachments so we can get to the point we can have an honest conversation i want to tell you it works so well that eventually i've had i've had conversations that was so painful and difficult about the lifestyle of one of some of my kids that they didn't want to talk to me for a while but they came back afterwards and we made peace and we moved on because although my you know i wasn't sure but i trusted my judgment and i we were patient i said tomorrow be patient i think it was a good move let's see we still make you know the phone calls and we'd call and it all healed because we'd worked so hard on attachment that it was painful but they bounced back because that's the point of working on attachment is it creates resilience which is bouncing back a woman let's say a woman or a man was molested or raped they're calling a school they have an employee who molested them and the school says i don't believe you what do you do i i must tell you i find the the question is very painful because the research all shows us that the numbers are so tiny of people who actually make allegations like that the untrue the proponents of all the research tells us it is true so that's horrendous and quite honestly i personally have encouraged people to take the school or the rov or whoever it was you know the community ask and take him to a dintario take her to denturia and i i listen if you're going to tell me which i know you are and so let's not do the dialogue now because what people say when i say that to them is but we can't do that because the kids in the school and the family and then i have nothing to tell you i don't know what to say i'll dive in for you i'll doubt it for you i really will but i'm begging and hoping and trying to get people to go to a dintara there's a mahalis take them to a din toy room that's what the toy is for let them know we will we will be going to it entire meanwhile you wanted to so again this is an interesting question um conversation i would start with conversation and exposure to families who have done it i know found i have a family do you know minches yitzhak that road in in new challenge it's a pretty froomed streets would you agree pretty firm street men coz i know a family there that saved the child who has a dog and the the father takes out his granddog for a walk in the street we actually have a marga home that says i love my granddog we have two grand dogs three we have three granddaughters mazel tov thank you thank you i actually went to a russia revolution wise shlita he's like my robin lee on him and i told him i have a problem he said what's the problem i said the dog loves me he said why is that a problem i said they come for shabbos they bring the dog and the dog's all over me the dog loves me he just loves me can i touch the dog and jarvis and he told me went through the sugar he said this is not the dog they were talking about all this foreign be careful enjoy the dog have a nice shabbos expose them to fam there are many families who have had to do it because it was how tallest in the fortress so there's so many people you can go to expose them to it they will see it and understand it and then move to the edge of town okay we have another 10 minutes go ahead go ahead what would be the correct response to a grandchild that asks bobby safto whatever um talking about her own mother who's talking i'm terrible at this my wife will attest who's talking about what to whom sorry i wasn't being clear no i lost you it's me the grand the grandchild did by the way did everyone else understand what she was talking about oh my gosh no no the women understood the women no no the men are clueless unbelievable i feel so validated thank you you saved my shalom bias yeah yes thank you wow by sessions we are in the amygdala level so we don't we're just trying to survive deep trouble beyond the amygdala okay yes i'm sorry great news for my husband yes both of us so let's start again one second so i can track you okay let me concentrate the grandchild there's a girl is asking me the grandmother is asking the grandmother about my child which is her mother oh i got it now how come she's not doing so-and-so shabbos properly it's nia's whatever it is she's asking she's waiting for me to respond what's the correct response you say shameful it's just a lovely question did you ask mummy yet [Applause] he didn't think of that now in all seriousness and that was serious by the way she may say to you i can't ask mommy that's why i came to you bobby in which case you have a conversation with her and help her understand and that's a complicated conversation but you need to talk to her yeah but the first thing you should honestly ask is can you talk to mommy and if she can't i would go to your daughter and say your your daughter came to me what would you like me to say to her what would you like me to say i want to protect your dignity but your daughter asked what would you like me to say we always go back and ask we're respectful we're not judgmental we understand and we go back and we try and tune in and ask her help me if you could guide me what you'd like me to say you're welcome a mother texted my challenges my child is in terrible emotional pain he's not ready to acknowledge it he's blocked off from receiving any form of attachment he says he's perfect but his heart is shut down what is my role what is my husband's role love and patience this you see this is not a manipulative suggestion crisis isn't a clever intervention that we do that you know like achieves a predictable outcome within a predictable timeline crisis henna i see obvious here twisted parenting having he didn't send down the texture it said you'd send it by now you hear the great line we had a great line here you should have said there's unbelievable but christ is kind of twisted parenting this approach is a way of life it's a way of life to reconnect what happens with that when how where that's a process of its own circulation you understand it'll happen in the right time the right place the right way that's not a we have time for another one or two questions anybody raise their hand go ahead yeah okay if you really truly believe that your child who is embarrassed to go is really and truly okay because it will draw less attention to them and their struggles if you go because if you don't go it will so to speak highlight why not and more people will be talking about them when the child asks you please please go i can't deal with it i can't but please go it's likely they actually want you to go because it creates less of a tummy what you do if you're wise is you say if you're not coming schaefer i'm happy not to go but you what you may well discover is they actually do want you to go because it causes less of a problem for them less highlighting the problem okay but just check in with them what i've said time and time again check in with your child talk to them compassionately tune in okay i just have um continuation to what she has stand up stand up in continuation she asked before knowing my knowing my daughter if my granddaughter would come to me and ask me something about her mother and i would tell her did you ask your mother and and she might because she's a you know talkative girl and she's she's not shy and she'll go and ask her mother her mother will pra or on the same note if i would go and say by the way your daughter came to me and asked me about this and this what should i answer exactly like what you said she would probably turn around and just get angry at my granddaughter and say like why do you go behind my back and talk about me or don't you know i do everything right and just because bobby does this mommy does that that kind of you know you know i'm so sorry did i not say you have to ask her first who i'm so sorry no no let's re-run what i said before for the tape okay okay you always have to ask rachel's first your granddaughter comes to talk to you did you speak to mommy no i can't i couldn't is it okay with you that i go speak to mommy right i'll talk to her about it okay first check in with your granddaughter no my granddaughter would say yeah you can ask her fine she would give me permission then but one day i got it and your daughter will blow up probably the next chavez your granddaughter will come and say bobby i need to talk to you about how mommy reacted so we're in the next level maybe so would you like me to talk to mommy about how she reacted okay so and then she'll say sure i'd appreciate it and then you georgia blows up even more right probably and you and you say to your granddaughter would you like me to give you some skills how to handle that better okay care about her just tune into her i you can't fix the unfixable right but you can connect in a loving and kind way and be there with people while they're going through the unfix right and by the way i had a cat until my son got married ah she's got a cat and a son of marriage i'm saying he took it with him when he got married okay one last question got married no the son got married i don't follow ladies very well i'm sorry i thought they can't go married i didn't understand okay yeah rabbi rabbi russell is going to give two or three minutes of closing remarks yeah because we will have more time to talk hopefully over shabbos but all good things come to an end we have to finish for now but i just want to read something to share something with everyone i together with a client of mine we wrote a letter she needed it this client she needed to hear this because she was in so much struggle and pain with the difficulties she was dealing with and she needed to know if this was authentic and i wrote this letter together with her i then took it to one of my rebbers of oshawi shlita you shall i and i asked him if this letter could be authentic you're going to see in a moment i'm going to read it to you could this letter be authentic is there anything wrong about this letter and he read it carefully we discussed it a few moments and he said no that's an authentic letter and i want to read you this letter because this letter is to everyone in this room this letter is to you each one of you dear mr and mrs x let me make this perfectly clear in his infinite wisdom puts you into this situation it is not just a bad mistake from shamayim this is exactly where you are meant to be right now it is no different than anything else you are called upon to do as a believing jew i unequivocally feel that your kiev in this situation is to do everything you can to keep your child close to you and that you should do so with humility but in a fearless unapologetic manner with full con confidence to the full extent of your ability yours truly a goddale battara this is a letter to all of us this letter we deserve we need to know that what we've learned in crisis twisted parenting what you've learned you must do with humility but in a fearless manner with full confidence to keep your child close to you to keep your child fully loved that's your letter i hope everyone has the most amazing charms [Applause] this class is brought to you by the yeshiva.net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at www.theyoshiva.net donate