Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

The Debate Between Mordechai & Esther Which Jews to Include

16,582 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

I want to dedicate today's class with uh profound appreciation and respect and gratitude to my dear wife in honor of her birthday on uh Shushampurim Cotton. She was born on Shashampuram cotton Esther of Albas Rahul Sara the wind beneath my wings and uh I want to use the opportunity to send my express my gratitude and my profoundest blessings to her and all of her loved ones with much health, happiness, prosperity from all of her our children herself and even from her husband husband. So thank you and thank you Estie for everything. So today's purim cotton which is of course called the humble purim or the miniature purim or the the small purim and the Mishna says in makis migill the first chapter that there's no difference between the first order and the second order. In other words for all practical purpose they're identical. The only difference is that in the first we don't read the migilla and we don't give matanus which means the rituals the mitzvah that we do on purim we don't do in the pur we don't read the migilla we don't do matanis the mishna does not mention a suda that we don't do a feast on the purim ken or it just mentions that we don't do matanas or the migilla so this created a very interesting debate of course among theik authorities should we have a feast should we have a suda on purim katan And there are two views in this the last of section 697. One view is that one ought to have a special and mishim just like we have on purim. And another view is no it's included in the fact that we don't do the migill. We don't do matan and we don't do the suda. The rama finishes off and he says the biggest people don't make a feast on purim ken. But he says, "But still it's good to add in your a little bit in order to fulfill the opinion of those who say you should have a feast, a special feast on." And he finishes with the words that conclude the whole from Proverbs 15:15, which means a good heart is always feasting. A good heart is always ready for a party, is always ready for a mish. So he says, "You don't have to be so particular and it's not real pur." He says a good heart is always if you could find a good excuse. It's very interesting. The whole ends on this note. You would think you wouldn't think that would be the conclusion of the entire which is seen as a book of laws and and structure. It's all about structure and laws. But he finishes off on that note. A good heart is always in a state of of of feasting of joy of openness of of celebration which is a Pik from Mishalik says that there are two mindsets. The days of somebody who lives in a mindset of poverty, the days are negative. But somebody who has a good disposition, somebody who has a good heart, they're always in a state of feasting. Even on a regular day, certainly on a day like Purum Kat, it's interesting that the Kavir who was the famous rabbi of Bratislava of Prashburg, the son of the Kamifer, he writes something very interesting. He says that since the Mishna says that there's no difference between the first and the second only reading the migill and so it sounds like we should do as I said it's one of the views in but he says that means the Mishna also doesn't say that the difference is giving he says that means according to that view pur you should be giving as well very interesting view and he explains why he says because shalakus initially was instituted according to many opinions as part of the suda of purim when people celebrate with each other you know you go out to a restaurant with a bunch of friends so you uh exchange courses you take a little bit from mine I take a little bit from yours that looks much better than what I have so he says on purim when people were celebrating and feasting together that's whereas that's why became part of the mitzvah because you exchange gifts especially you know that somebody may not have food for the meal of purim so therefore was to really give them food so they may be able to have this purim so says according to this how does it make sense that I'm pur you're doing a meal in honor of purim but it's a meal only for myself and not for somebody else so he says those who do the meal purim should also give us send food to somebody else they should also be able to have a meal it's a little bit different than the shalman that we're used to today was actually like real food not the more candies the today often says the less edible the better it is the less healthy the better it is but According to this was not just a symbol of friendship of sending something which is also part of it but also actually giving food so that the meal of Purim is celebrated by everybody with the same uh same celebration and with the same abundance and the same certainly any way anybody looks at purim cotton it's 30 days before purim so today I want to focus on one aspect of purim since we are on purim from Ken and the preparations to Purim God will also begin and Mishta Tit I want to begin focus on one aspect of the story of Purim the story of the migillah on this day in prep both because of this day and in preparation for the grand purim for the purim god coming I want to just begin with a story as an introduction it's a story about the famous rabbi of lodge lodge was one of the great communities in Poland You've heard of the community in lodge and the lodger shul and probably unfortunately the lodger ghetto ghetto of lodge as well and the of lodge for close to 40 years I think 35 years was a Jew named rebel misel he was a legendary leader both in terms of his scholarship and more even in terms equally in terms of his dedication and he passed away trees bay 1912 peseni dollar 1912. And they tell a story that it was once a very cold winter in Lodge. And those are the days, these are the early 1900s or the late 1800s. And people relied on fires that they made in their homes, the fireplaces, in order to warm their bones and their wife's bones and their children's bones on a cold winter night or a cold winter day. And it was one particular winter. We know that there are different types of winters that the coldness was simply unbearable and poor Jews who didn't have enough money to buy lumber to buy wood were literally sitting and they were free freezing. They were freezing the husbands, the wives, and the children. And Rebel Misel made it his personal priority to raise money to be able to to give everybody money to be able to buy wood to be able to build fires in their homes every night. So the story is that he once went to a very wealthy Jew who was known to have a lot of money but he was not known to be as generous as benevolent at least not proportionate to the amount money that he had that he owned. And he went to see him asking him to really assist in this urgent matter of literally saving people not just from discomfort but what could be illness and god forbid much worse. So he comes to the home of this wealthy person who didn't usually allow people into his home and he knocked on the door and the ser the servant or the assistant person running the helm came out and he said please tell the host please tell the balabay is the master of the home that the lodger the ofel came to see him. So of course when he gave him that message the man came outside. It happened to be at night and it happened to be one of the coldest nights of the winter. You know, in New York, you sometimes have the degrees. It's it's two degrees, but together with the winds, it's, you know, nine below zero. You know, those 10 below zero, you know, those nights. Just walking to your neighbor's home can uh can be quite an intense experience. It was one of those nights in Poland. And Rebel Misel is outside and the man comes out and he says, "Reb to what do I owe this honor? Please come in." He says, "No, no, no, no, no, no. I just want to speak to you for a few moments." Now, he came out undressed because he just came to greet him by the door. But in honor of thereof, he comes out and he says, "You probably know about this winter and you probably know about the fate of many poor Jews in a lodge and what their situation is. and I'm really creating an emergency fund because we need to save people's lives and this is priority number one that trumps any other priority and the RAV is talking about it and elaborating on the crisis and the poor man is tre trembling from cold and he says can we can we please come in I have a comfortable home I have a wonderful fireplace we could sit in the in the salon in the family room or the dining room he had a big house he was a he had I mentioned come in. He says, "No, no, no, no, no, no, no. I don't want to go into your house. I don't feel worthy." He says, "Reba, it'll be an honor for me." He says, "No, no. Let's let's let's stay here." And he he plays dumb and he's making himself oblivious. And he goes on and on and uh and he says, "You know, God has blessed you." And the reason he's blessed you is this money is a picadin. It's a deposit you should have for yourself, but the amount of percentage of it, 10%, 20% you give away to the poor people. And he's elaborating on the situation and he's telling him stories of women and women who just gave birth and young children and older children and young adults and older people, senior citizens who are suffering. A second time, the man says, "Reb, can we please continue the conversation inside the house? It's freezing." And he says, "No, please. I just want to stay outside. I'm soon going to finish. And finally when he concludes he comes with the sak with the punchline and he says this is the amount of money I need for you which was an extravagant amount that he wanted from him. So the giver thought and he said okay I'll give it to you. So he said now I'll come into the house and we could continue talking. So he says to him why didn't you want me to go why didn't you want to go in the house in the beginning? You could have said everything. He said, "I could have said everything, but you would have not experienced anything I spoke about. I need you to I needed you to viscerally experience what I'm talking about. Not as an abstract concept, but I need you to feel at least for 10 minutes, I needed you to feel what it is to tremble in such cold night after night after night. And without knowing that the door is right here, and just a few feet away, you're in a warm home." I needed you to taste from the experience. Now that you tasted, now you understand. Now that you empathize, you don't only understand. Now I'm happy to come into your house and we could smoo for as long as you want. I say this as an introduction to one of the to one of the major themes we're going to be addressing today. We all know the story of Purim, but the story of Purim is so multi-layered and so multifaceted that it's really an endless story. Like every story in Tyra, there's layers upon layers and there's nuances and details that sometimes you don't realize until you study it again and again. It's like you could read the same story. How many times can you read the story of Ysef and his brothers? Every year you could read it again and see a new dimension to the story. And sometimes the way it is with always always in Tyra that a small detail captures a fundamental theme. It's like we spoke once about the fact that it says is compared to a organism to an adm to a person. Today we know that in each of the cells there are around 60 or 70 trillion cells and in each of the cells there's a double copy of what they call the genum. This is just a discovery of the 1950s. And the ginum contains within it the blueprint, the manual of the entire organism. It contains within it what we call today the DNA, the DNA molecules that contain a blueprint of how the entire body is constructed. So one would think that this type of material, this type of genetic code, you can only find in the brain. But the truth is even in saliva, even in a nail, even in a strand of hair, every detail, every nuance, every crevice, every prat, even the tiniest part of the body, you could say it's it's the the the the here on the on the pinky or the toe. You have something in the leg or in the toe which is not so significant, not so essential that also contains the blueprint of the entire body. And the same is true with Adam that sometimes in a small detail you have a picture of the entire collective reality. When Mardai finds out that Hmon succeeded in convincing the Persian monarch to execute his plan of genocide against the entire Jewish people to literally exterminate every Jew, as the says to exterminate every Jew from young to old children, women, men, no difference, all in one day. So we know Mardekai immediately puts on a sack. He comes close to the portal of the king. He can't go in dressed this way even though he was a prominent guest in the palace and he summons he sends a message to the first lady to Queen Esther and asks of her pleads with her to go speak to her husband to the king Akash to nullify to another decree. Esther is very hesitant. She sends back a message and she says that there is a rule and the rule is that if somebody comes in to the king uninvited without an invitation, you go out with a headshorter. I was not invited to go to my husband to the king for 30 days. You're not dealing with a normal person. You're dealing with a dictatorship. You're dealing with a tyrant. You're dealing with a monarch who's an absolute dictator. Even his own queen. He killed his first queen. He could kill his second queen. So Mardai tells Esther in his famous words, he tells her, "Don't think that you're going to be saved in the palace," the Jewish people will be saved regardless, but you and your father's home may perish. And who knows if this is not the reason you became a queen. And when Esther hears those words, she tells Mardekai, she consents and she tells Mardai the following message. And that's your first source. It's in McGill chapter 4. or Esther and the messages she says Esther sends back her answer to and what's her answer you have it also in English translation go assemble all of the Jews who live who are present in Shushan. Shusham was of course this capital and let them fast on my behalf. Don't eat, don't drink for three days, night and day. In fact, me and my my assistants, my servants in the palace will observe the same fast. And then she says, "Then I shall go into the king though it's contrary to the law. I'm not allowed to go in. And if I am to perish, I shall perish." This is the message Esther sends back. Mai didn't speak about gathering the Jews. Mordeai told Esther, "Go into your husband and plead with him. Tell him what happened. Tell him to nullify the decree." Esther said, "I can't. I'm going to die. I'll be killed. So Mardai responded and said, "This is why you became a queen. This is your moment. This is your mission." So Esther now responds and says, "Okay, you go gather all the Jews in Shusham. Initiate a fast for three days and three nights. I will also fast together with my maid servants and then I'll go into the king. If I'm made to perish, I'll perish." And the Per continues. So Mai passed over and he did of Esther. He did everything that Esther has commanded him, has instructed him to do. And that's how the chapter ends. And then the migill goes on with the story of Esther going into the king on the third day of her fast. She dresses up in royalty. She goes into the king. She invites him to one party, invites him to another party. And ultimately salvation happens. Now you right away see here just parenthetically it's interesting I think the Maharal of Prague writes the Maral has a commentary called the new light it's a commentary on the migilla and he says that when one fasts for three days day and night it comes out to 72 hours right 24 48 58 68 right 72 hours so he says that's the gamatria of is so you have 50 60 70 just huh right very good thank you so he says and with this with these 72 hours of that's that's how he explains the I want to focus on one detail which you may say is not significant at first glance, but as we'll see, it's extremely significant. It says Mai passed over. What does it mean? He passed over. What did he pass over? He passed over and he did everything that Esther told him to do. Could have just said did whatever Esther said. He gathered the Jews. He initiated a fast day and that's what he did. But the migill says, Vavver means he was over. He passed over. This is a question that the Gammorra asks. It's a very strange expression. What does it mean he passed over? What did he pass over? It could have said he went and he did. That would have also been super said he did. So if you take a look in your next source sheet, migillas, this is Talmud Gmorra McGill page 15. And there's a debate. Omar Rav there's a dispute. What does it mean Mai passed over? Omar Rav Rav one of the greatest sages says it means he passed over the first day of Pes with a fast day says in the migilly comes from the word a mard did so to speak in a there was a sin why he transgressed the obligation to rejoice on Pesak by instituting a fast day which was of course Esther's instruction And as Rashi explains, the decree came out on the 13th day of Niss. That's what the migill says. So when Esther told establish a fast day for three days, it was niss the first day of PES and what we call here the second day of PES or in the first day of. So that means y they're fasting instead of eating. So was he transgressed he violated so to speak the mitzvah of pes the mitzvah of y by creating this fast day that continued the medish that says that the fast day started they fasted the same day still would begal rashi says in the in the in the migill was and on the third day of course Esther went in to invite her husband to a party. So the third day was she went in, there was a party, she invited him at the party for a second party. That would have been Zion. It was a party of wine. So Esther, of course, got to drink the four cups of wine with her husband. He didn't know. He didn't know that she's drinking four cups of wine. But she made sure there was a lot a lot of wine. He got tipsy. Hmon got tipsy. And she did what she had to do at her seder. She drank her four cups of wine. Then she invites him. She invites him to a second party. Taz of course at the second party she spills the beans and she tells Akashes who she is and who Hmon is. Hmon falls on the bed gets angry suggests that he hangs Hmon and that happened to Zion at night. says to Zion in the evening the second day of PES in the evening it's even brought in that the second day of PES we should add something to our meal our lunch meal to to the party that estimate for on that second day of PES when the whole Yeshua began the night before of course the king couldn't sleep also the night of but however you organize the fast days he was on the mitzvah of pes say that said if there's no Jews you don't need PES if there's not going to be a nobody's going to eat matzah nobody's going to drink wine you don't need a pes so that comes first whatever his consideration was the migilla makes sure to say that's the second opinion is crossed over a stream of water in order to bring the message to all he goes goes out from Shusha. He goes out from the pal. He was talking to Esther. He was communicating with Esther through a messenger through As. And now he needs to implement what Esther says. He has to gather all the Jews. So it doesn't just say he did what Esther said. He passed over. What did he pass over? Apparently he had to go over a canal or a river or a pond or demay is a stream of water. He had to go over that in order to implement what Esther said. Now this interpretation is very difficult. And if he why don't you say he had to cross a street and he had to go over a park and maybe there was a forest. What's the let's say let's say some of Faram say that apparently in Shushan there was a river or a stream and it could be that many of the Jewish residents lived on the other side. So Mardai had to cross the river or cross the stream in order to invite them. Okay, granted but the migill makes a point of saying it which is very strange because why is that relevant to the story? What if he would have to cross a street and what would we have to cross a few streets and what would we have to cross a park and what if we have to cross something else some landmark? It doesn't seem to be relevant to the story. You could have said Mardai did what Esther said but it somehow the migill wants to tell you that he had to cross over a canal of water that's vaya mard. Some say that in Shushan itself there was a division and the palace was in one part of Shushan and Mardekai had a right to live there because he was close to the king but most Jews lived on the other side. So to gather the Jews he had to go to the other side. Granted but the McGill makes sure to emphasize this Krumadaya. Now in order to appreciate this let's go to Esther's words. If we go to Esther's words Esther tells go and gather all of the Jews who are present in. And here the question is what does Esther mean with the word? She could have said it much more succinctly. Go gather the Jews who are in shusha. Mardai was the managor. He was the leader of the generation. He was the head of the Sanhedrin. Mardekai was considered the spiritual leader of the Jewish people. So if Esther says go gather the Jews, obviously Mard would go gather all the Jews. Why would he ex exclude some Jews? But Esther says go gather all the Jews who are in shusha. Why would it m would go gather the Jews? He would start pointing fingers and say you yes this one yes this one not. Why? Why would we think to exclude anybody that Esther has to emphasize? Now you might say Esther wanted to tell him I want everybody to be gathered. But practically speaking we understand that you can't always gather every single member of a nation. You have somebody who may be old. You have somebody who may be frail. You have somebody who may be sick. You have little babies. You have a mother who's just gave birth. Not everybody could come to every gathering and you can't force them. And even though Makai is the head of the Sanhedrin, they're in exile. They're in a foreign country. Whoever could come is going to come. So obviously there's going to be people who are not going to come. So what does Esther mean when she says now you might say that's how you speak. Maybe that's how you speak. But the truth is it's not so simple. There's a there's a track is called it has to do with how we evaluate. When a person says I want to give I want to donate to the Bish the value of a particular person there's different numbers different ages different. It's a it's it's a whole track of Mishna is based on the par and in the Mishna there begins with the word everybody everybody can evaluate everybody can be evaluated and the gor unusually spends three dapim three pages diml I think dalot to go through the whole Mishnas wherever it says the word hak and say why does it say everybody you could have just said the obligation and if you don't exclude anybody. We know that it's everybody. If a teacher is saying tomorrow the class is going on a trip, that means the whole class. If you want to say certain people are not going on the trip, specify. So you might say maybe Esther didn't have to say it, but perhaps in wording sometimes you articulate yourself verbally in a more elaborate way to specify what you're saying. Perhaps. But the fact is that it's transcribed in if it's transcribed in every word is precise and every word is considered divide especially the the considering that and Esther had other conversations they're not recorded in the migillah because they're not relevant here this word is recorded and in the migill it's even more emphasized because you have to hear every word so if somebody has is hearing the migill they have to hear the word ky and if they don't hear the word ky they're missing the migill they're missing something essential in the every word is relevant. So the gammorra for example gives an example in the due many of your husbands or children began learning this week or actually last week Friday shabas Friday the opening of everybody all Jews are obligated to come see the mik three times a year now the mission goes through those who are not obligated women who sometimes have to stay home they have little children are not obligated to come and sukus and slept tiny kiss at the b I mean they could come if they want but they're not obligated somebody who can't walk who's lame Mishna says they're not obligated a child who can't walk is not obligated even in kinh says if he can't ride on his father's shoulders he's too small he's not obligated says no even if he could ride but he can't walk himself holding his father's hand he's not obligated even for somebody who can't see is not obligated it. So the asked the first question, why do you start off? Why do they hackle everybody? Who do you want to include? You want to include somebody. If not, you could have just said Jews are excluding these. You could even start off these and these individuals are excluded from the mitzvah. We understand everybody else is included. So if Esther is not excluding anybody, everybody is included. And the garra goes through dozens. It's interesting dozens of example and the whole Mishna is wherever it says the word hak. What are you trying to teach me? Something is fishing. And here the garak says they're teaching that even somebody who only has eyesight with one eye according to this Mishna may be obligated. That's the hak or another opinion is it's a slave. So usually slaves are not kay to come to the bd but he's he was bought by two partners and one of them emancipated him. So 50% of him is free. 50% of him is still enslaved. Is he? So that's why it says even that half a slave you would think he's excluded. He's also included. The Gmorra says everyone is says what's says you would think women usually are not mitzvah that are connected to time. Migill is connected to time on the obligated migill. So when it says even in Mishnas or in Bryce or in Gammor which is precise everybody is always including a certain category that you would have excluded certainly in where every word is even more precise and meticulous when Esther says not there's somebody she's somebody or some group she's referring to that murder would have excluded. So if she said go gather Jews and you would think okay that's everybody. Why should mai exclude anybody? If she wants to exclude she should say besides she didn't say besides it means everybody. That wouldn't have been enough. Makai would have excluded somebody and Esther understood that. So there was a subtle contrast here a subtle debate going on. And if you want to see how meticulous this is, take a look how the PK speaks about what did Esther here again we have a superfluous word. It should have said did what Esther told him. Now if Esther would have told him to do 49 things, right? So when a woman tells her husband, a wife tells her husband, I need you to do 49 things, she makes him repeat. And there's a good reason for it because, you know, we have discussed it in the past. Male brains are like waffles. Female brains are like spaghetti. In waffles, every waffle is self-contained and you do not allow the maple syrup to go from one waffle to another waffle. Everyone has it square and there's a big makita in between. And they shall not meet. With spaghetti, every strand is interconnected and integrated with many, many more. So I understand if Esther would have given him a to-do list of even 15 things and you say Mardik I got it all right. You ever see guys shopping in evergreen or with the list and then they call right? I know for myself they call and they send pictures. Did I get it right? One item. Okay. Two items. And if a guy if he the truth tell me if he comes home with 40 items and they're all right, you can make a there's usually something off. So of what did Esther tell him to do? Esther told him to do one thing. Gather all the Jews and they should fast. So could have said he did what Esther told him. You want to say he did everything that Esther said, says this word is brought in the migill another two times over there. I understand it says that Hmon had the scribes right in the decree everything that he suggested to in other words not a single Jew is being saved and when reversed the decree the scribes wrote everything that and Esther said every detail how the Jews can defend themselves that's very clear here the says like everything that Esther said but the truth is we understand why because Esther said, "So what did do he got that point? He listened to the of Esther and that's what he did. The question now is what group of Jews would have been excluded and why did Esther then have to have to say and the answer is um And the answer to this or one of the explanations to this was shared by the labbrean after purim shabas parishes kisa tzai and other tshin lammed alf 1971. There was a group that murdai would have excluded. So when the gmorra says it says who do you want to include? Esther was including a certain category. Who would Mardekai exclude? And the answer to that is Esther told them go gather the Jews of Shushan. Now the Jews of Shushan had a complicated history because we know you could look in your next source migillate page 12. The students asked why did the Jews of that generation why was there a decree of extermination against them as a good teacher said why don't you answer the question because the Jews enjoyed the feast of that wicked person let's remember on the third year of his reign threw a party for 180 days. That's a half a year. 180 days. He made a party of all of his ministers and all of his servants. For 180 days, the man was drunk. The beginning of the migill when the 180 days were up. He still didn't have enough. You could think muat the guy was partying for 180 days. That's a half a year. A year is 365 days. This is almost a half a year. It wasn't enough. The made a feast for the entire nation, not just the people who worked for the palace, all of his subjects in the capital. He made a feast for seven days in the courtyard, in the garden, in the house of the king. And the story go and the migill goes on to describe the details of the feast. what was served, how it was served, the types of materials and fabrics with which he decorated the feast and that's when the story with Vashi happened. He wanted her to appear and ultimately excuse me, she was removed as a result says the Gar that the students of said the Jews enjoyed the feast of that rush the say so that's an iss of eating is not deserving of extermination. So there's many different interpretations. Those who say the rash says they ate fat and blood which is an which is a penalty of kurus. Others say because made this party to celebrate the destruction of the basikt he made a calculation that the 70 years since the destruction have passed and the Jews are not going back and they're not rebuilding the new basikt and he even used the vessels of the basikto and he displayed them at the party. So Jews enjoying such a party is a completely different case. Others say because hadn't told them not to go so they violated the commandment of the Sanhedrin. Others says finally their enjoyment came from the fact that invited them to the Shushan White House and he took a selfie with them and their picture was published on the front page of the Shushan Times. And from this came their dignity. Finally, we made it. We're not anymore the distinct weird archaic tribal nation of Jews. We're finally integrated. were assimilated. The king has us rub shoulders with him in the white house of shusha nanu. It's not that they they enjoyed it. Not just they came after the king invites you, you come. This became their identity. They rais on the there's different explanations in the commentaries. So the students so so the students asked him if so the decree should have been only on the Jews of Shushan not on any other Jew. That's what he asked them. So they said there was something else and that the other Jews in the other countries were engaged in idolatry in the time of some decades earlier. If this is the case, we could now understand what Esther meant when she said thought to himself, Esther is telling me to gather all the Jews and gather them for what? Gather the Jews and gather them for what? The first thing is Jews should be united. That's what my explains. Jews have to be united. When there's a challenge, when Jews are united, everything is different. That's number one. It's like a fortress. When Jews are united, you create a fortress and nothing can get through. If Jews are disassociated, if there's a lack of cohesion, if there's a lack of unity, so it's like a city has a fortress and there's breaches everywhere because we're not together. Bring the Jews together. Besides that, Leo means bring them together like Pessus to Davin, to pray, to learn, to Davin. And then she says, "And fast," which is a concept of chuva, returning, introspection, reinvention, transforming yourself. So this is Esther's task. So Morai is thinking to himself, who should I go invite? I should go invite everybody. I'm going to go invite those Jews who for seven days were rubbing shoulders and eating and drinking and enjoying the bik especially Esther wants that they should fast for three days and three nights. people who didn't stop partying for seven days with every conceivable drink and food in the world as the migill describes in such detail. There was endless drinking. Everybody could do whatever they want. The party was literally endless and infinite according. And now you're going to have these Jews fast for three days and three nights. At best, you can influence these Jews that they should start eating kosher. Before they eat, they should make a bra. After they eat, they should bench. They should acknowledge that God gave them the food. But to go from one one extreme of a party of seven days without a sign of Yiddish to the other extreme of fasting for three days and three nights, it's not practical. It's not conceivable. It's too much of a radical transformation. Mikai may be thinking, how can I go to those Jews? Furthermore, we have a principle in Kate. We know that the prosecutor doesn't suddenly become the defender in a law in a law in a in a in a courtroom. You don't ask the prosecutor to start cross-examining one of the witnesses to help the defender. That's not what the kagger is paid for. It's not what he's interested in. We know that the kipper didn't go in with garments of gold into the kaides. Why? So kazal say because the gold is what the Jews used for the for the golden calf in parisa this week's par and you don't take the golden with simple clothes made out of linen kipper the rest of the year he had cold here is also taking the Jews inside into avoid pim into their pimus it's a moment of misn so mai is thinking to himself I can't go to these Jews who are the greatest prosecutors, they are guilty for the decree if they're guilty for the decree. And that's why Esther wants us to fast. And he wants us to fast three days and three nights parallel to the days of Akashesh's party excluding Shabas, which is six days. Three days, three nights. So you're going to take now the people who are the kagers to become the soners. It doesn't make sense. And generally says that the way of living is you go the middle path and say if somebody goes to extreme one extreme then you have to go to another extreme follows the straight path he doesn't deviate he wants to deal with Jews who are good Jews who are righteous Jews who are Esther understood this so Esther understood that if she tells Mai go gather the Jews without one word and his own logically and rationally would have excluded certain Jews. These Jews who were engaged in and those Jews in Shushan who were certainly engaged in prostrating themselves to idolatry. Here is where Esther comes into the picture. Who is Esther? The Gmorra says in it's your next source page 17 139b what's the source for the name Esther and it's a strange question why do I have to find a source for Esther and the Gmorra answers it says Rabenu in his final day speaking to the Jewish people and parishes he says Hashem says, "I will hide and eclipse my face on that day." The word Esther originates in the words because the word Esther comes from the word hester which means concealment. Not only that, the Gmorra says inact Yehuda says that Esther wasn't her real name. Her real name was Hadasa. Esther was a nickname. And why did they give her the name Esther? Because of Esther was very discreet and confidential. She was a hidden modest person. She didn't express where she came from. That's why she got this name Esther. But that became her classic name according to others say her name was Esther and her nickname was Adasa. Rabi Huda says no her name was Adasa. Esther became the name that becomes attached to her because of this discrete quality, this quality of concealment. What's the idea of what are we looking for? A pik that uses the word concealment. This p is not just a word that says. So we connected to Esther. It brings out the the uniqueness of Esther. Esther understood that sometimes in life truth is concealed and truth is so concealed that it's her very name. They say Churchill once said that in a time of war the truth is so precious you have to protect it by bodyguards of lies. Esther understood that sometimes what you see at the surface is far from reality. Don't judge a book by its cover is not just a cliche but it's sometimes a path in life. I'm going to hide my face. So if you look at the surface all you could see is Hester hiddenness. But as the BMP of one said aster even in the aster is also the eye is present even in the concealment. This Esther is the one who could perceive that became her very name. She's the one who tunes in to such an error. And she says that there's an error where there is concealment. And you have to be able to know that it's concealment because the only thing that's worse than concealment is when you think the concealment is revelation. when I think the concealment is absolute when I don't know how to see beyond it. Esther is the person who teaches that you have to be able to learn that there is concealment and truth could sometimes be deep down beneath the surface that it has to be excavated. It has to be extricated. It has to be revealed. And therefore Esther had to teach this also to Mardai. You want to exclude a certain group of Jews because at the surface they're responsible for the gazer. They're responsible for the calamity. They could never be inspired. Let them be who they are. We're going to focus on a certain group. Esther is the one who says you have to understand what is beneath the surface. And you have to understand that sometimes truth is very concealed. That's the of Esther. And therefore we have to look deeper and let's see what Esther is saying. The Gmorrah says in the next source the Gmorra says the migill describes how gorgeous Esther was how appealing Esther was says and it's a very strange statement. I want you to know that Esther's face had a greenish color to it. Ius in Hebrew means greenish as the mafaram say like a hadus like a myrtle like a myrtle branch what we use on sukus or people use for shabas sometimes that's what it looked like. So why was and everybody was so overwhelmed by her. So Yeshua says there was a a thread of grace of that was extended over her. There was like a halo of of light of graciousness of that was on her and when people saw Esther they just she imbued them with that sense of of comfort of ease of graciousness of that's what that that's what says what does he mean and why do you have to say this about Esther says Esther was was was amazingly appealing so he says it was a special cordo who was one of the greatest cabalist he's known as the ramak he authored a famous work called tomed and many other works he lived in the 15th in the 1500s he passed away 1570 he's buried in those graves that are died with blue near the raak was a reba of the passed away shinlam at 1570 so he writes in of pardis that Esther was the of basil we know through two schools of learning bashame and basil of course many generations after Esther. Esther lived before the second Bameik. Bashami and Basil lived a century before the destruction of the second Bamed few hundred years after Purim. But Bash Shami was a school that was stringent and Basil was the school of B the school of hill is lenient. The school of Sham is stringent. It says in Zoya that the souls of Shami the soul of Shamay and his students came from Gur and the soul of Hill and his students came from. Soak says this is the view of Bil. To understand the depth of this, let's see one argument between Bash and Basil when it comes to a wedding. Now, you going to know half of this argument because it became a Jewish song. But for some reason, the authors of the song cut out from the lyrics most of it. And you'll see why they were smart for doing it. They wouldn't have become so popular. So, you know half you know you know this song, but it's only half half the story. This is a page 16. You have it also in English. I don't understand. I don't understand why she was greenish. In other words, he was saying that physically Esther's face was greenish. Nonetheless, her appeal was so powerful because it was a pretty I didn't use those words. I didn't say she wasn't pretty. I said she was greenish, which is not usually the color. Huh? What? Her complexion was greenish. Yeah. The vilon actually writes the Vagon writes it says in the migill that Hanara was was was was so beautiful and vatisa everybody who saw her was was enamored. So he says that initially she was but her agony of being by changed her complexion and that's what caused this. He says sometimes when people are not feeling well there's there's a greenish color and he says but still the was so powerful it eclipsed everything else and people were just enamored by her. That's how the vagon explains it. What is this? What does it mean? There's a means a thread. So it's it's a metaphor obviously. A very interesting expression. The strand is like a thread of of that's extended. It covers her. It encompasses her. It's like it's extended over her. What does this mean? So the second chapter of how do you dance in front of the kala the school of shama says you praise every bride according to who she is. You emphasize her good qualities. [Applause] Says, "No, there's something generic." You say it to every bride. The bride is beautiful and gracious. She's gorgeous and she's full of of grace, of kindness, of goodness. This is where it gets a little interesting. says to excuse why do you have to encourage people to be politically correct and not say the truth? Find what she's good at and talk about that. You don't have to say about somebody who's short that they're tall, somebody who's a little overweight that they're skinny. Don't do that. I know you want to be nice and I know you want to be pleasant, but it takes away the value of your words. You just say the same compliments to everybody. Nobody takes you serious. You know, you're crying wolf wolf. And the person says, "Your food is always amazing. Always." Yeah, I know. Your food is always amazing. It has to have meaning. When I was a yeshiva, there was a joke. They used to say the kabad boys in the summer with God on what's called small communities to build Yiddish kite over there. So, Rabbi Khadakov was the Reb secretary. He'd always give them a prep talk before. And he always said, "You're going to eat in the RV's house or whoever's house." After the meal, you go over to the kitchen and you thank the Rebbitson for the food and you explain to her how you enjoyed the food. So one of these boys was a real yeshiva bak a little abstract. So at the end of one of the meals he went over to the rebbitson and he said the labre secretary said I should tell you that the food was very very very good he followed instructions. Yeah platitudes could be empty and bame gets very dramatic. He says sometimes and he uses two examples. somebody who's can't see, somebody who's lame because he wants to talk about visible things. Something is visible. He says, "Why are you going to get up and say here is the epitome of beauty? Choose other things." Helen Keller said, "The only thing that's worse than not having eyesight is lacking vision. Don't talk about the eyesight. Talk about the vision." And he uses the words follow me. I said figure out some ver every person has virtues. talk about that. It's like the shhat, you know the joke. There was once, maybe it wasn't a joke. There was a shhatan who offered an older girl to go out with somebody and she described the described to her that he's galdic. He's a gavald. Anyway, she comes back from the first meeting and thehat says to her or thehat says to her, "How was it?" Now this was he was still there was uh they came back to the house and he was there dropped off whatever. So she whispers she says to the shot you're a dirty liar. He says why am I a dirty liar? She says you told me he's smart. The guy is as dumb as it gets. You told me he's handsome. He's mama is the opposite. You told me he's tall, he's short. You told me he's slim. He's fat. You told me he's refined. He's actually grotesque. She's whispering. The Shatan says, "You don't have to whisper. He's deaf, too." So B says, "Find the mileas. Don't exaggerate and don't dramatize." This is his question. You see why in the song they took out the view of Bama, right? Kate said, "But B doesn't hold that." So now listen to Basill's answer. Okay, let's follow your way of thinking. Okay, you are the honest people. So you always say things the way they are. We don't dramatize, no empty compliments, no vain platitudes, authenticity. Granted, somebody went shopping and they bought a mech would mean an inferior acquisition. And I should add a parenthesis and they can't return it. There's no return policy. Somebody's wife comes home, somebody's daughter, son, husband comes home, they bought something, they spent half of their savings account on it, you can't return it, and you look at it and one look and you want to faint, but they ask you new. What do you say? So, should you tell them how ridiculous it is? How they squandered and wasted the money? Remember, they can't return it. Or you should praise it. Of course, you should compliment them. They're wearing it. They come to shul. They come to their daughter's kasa all dressed. You would have never bought it in 1.1 million years. So you tell them how horrible it is because that's what you think. Of course, you say the nice thing. That's his answer to Bish. What's the answer? That's B Sh's issue. My issue with you is that your compliments mean nothing. You just always say nice things. So you're a nice person. But the says, but this is answer. And the Gmorra finishes from here. The sages learned a lesson. A person's disposition should always be integrated with people. What's that? How is that connected? The sages didn't know this. From here, from this debate, they learned the lesson. The lesson is don't live in an ivory tower. Mis be mixed up with people. Mixed up means integrated. Call all Jews are guaranurs for each other. Said also means like all Jews are famished. And then means also this right make it sweet is sweet in Hebrew arim there sweet what's the argument between it's a very interesting argument at surface it would think yeah bash says let's just all be py smile be politically correct they know you don't mean it it's fine it's just how we do things and bish Shame says I'm sorry says basil didn't know about the argument between and is a very fundamental argument it's not just about this it's a question about life and the gar says about says you have an interesting argument on shabas shabas when you light a candle what do we says in 8th chapter you don't say that you say hashem created the light of fire we say he creates the lights the illuminations of fire everything we have to argue about so the garra says b shai says there's one flame says says, "No, no. Look at the flame. You'll see many colors. You ever looked at a flame? There's white, there's orange, there's red, there's green, there's there's yellow, there's black, there's blue. Like, I want to ask you a question. You think B didn't know flames have many colors? I look at a flame, my child looks at a flame, your child, they see many colors." Bama didn't know. There's a fundamental question here. Bash knows that you could look deeper, but Bash says relates to reality based on what you see. Basill says, I know there's what you see, but it's always important to be able to take an X-ray, to be able to take a CAT scan, to be able to go deeper and see what is beneath the surface. B Shamay says you can't law. You're at a wedding. Speak truth. Basil is not saying to lie. Basil is saying you came to somebody's wedding. Take off your glasses and put on the glasses. The chose this person as his wife. There's a famous gamar in. In a good marriage, a woman adores her husband and a husband adores his wife. Why? Because it's his. She belongs to him and he belongs to her. It's mine. The night of a wedding, Basil says, "You came to a wedding." For him, she is the most gorgeous, greatest, most gracious woman in the world. You may have different opinions, okay? But you're at a you're at his take off your glasses. Put on this person's glasses. You're not lying. You're just understanding that for this she is the most no matter what the external features may be from your perception. And that's why he says this person went and chose this kala. The kala went and chose this because a marriage has to be consensual. We learned from Rifka, right? Rifka had to agree. She chose this. He chose this kala. We're talking about a real choice for him. She is the greatest gift in the world. I went to the so of course but there's one condition you have to be integrated with people. If I'm sitting in my own ivory tower and deciding reality then I'm lying. But if you understand who people are, if you could see things from people's perspectives, it's not a lie when you tune in to the inner world of another person and you could describe reality from their perception. Even though in your world there may be different perceptions and different ways of determining reality. Ah knows there's many flames says you see a fire, you're enjoying the fire. Basil says, "No, look at the various features. Dig a little deeper, analyze, dissect, and then you'll see the various colors, the various flames. Get into the be nuanced. Be nuanced. H wants you to be nuanced. There's a fascinating, aren't you? Fascinating story in Gmor and Shabas track Shabas page 31 there were three Gentiles who came to Shami they wanted to convert the first one said I'll convert but only I don't accept so bishame threw him out the second guy said I'll convert on the condition that you make me a god so bishame threw him out the third one said I'll convert but you have to teach me the whole toyra standing on one leg in other words I have 40 seconds for conversion lessons So Bame threw them out. They all came to Hill and Hill accepted all of them and they all became Gavaldim and they say the three people came together. They were already Jews and they said if if we would have remained if Shamai would have been the only one we met, we would have been distant from the Hill is the one who saved us. So the question is when Shamai seems right. A person comes and says I want to convert but I don't accept 90% of Allah. In case you're not serious, I have nothing against you. Teach me the whole toy on one leg. Thank you. Imagine somebody comes into Harvard Medical School. Teach me everything there is to know about medicine within 2 minutes. What is this? A mockery. Teach me everything there is to know about science and physics and mathematics within 10 minutes. People are dealing with this for 4,000 years. Are you making a mockery out of Judaism? I want to be the kind god. Who's right? Bashame was right. But Basil was right. Bashame was right because Bashame listened to their words and their words were inappropriate. But Basil says, "I know their words are inappropriate, but listen to what's behind their words." They're good people. They just don't understand. They may be ignorant. They may have been misled. They may have misconceptions and indeed Hill started to teach them and Hillow said olive bay he started teach olive bay the next day he said okay we're going to learn the olive bay bay olive the guy said yesterday it was olive bay so billow said ah hill said even for the alphabet you have to rely on me so for the whole 30 you're not going to rely on the sages who taught it okay it was over he became a geti except the other person he heard he learned Even Mosherenu can't go into even a holiest Jew in the world can't do what Aaron said. He said ah even a Jew can't even be a god. It's not racism and discrimination that you don't hold from people who are not from the he was in basil saw you have to listen to what's behind people's words comes and says Esther is this kala if you would have looked at Esther what would say you can't talk about the complexion is very different but everybody saw Esther they said because there was something in Esther that emerged. Esther says that is what's the ability to see that which is hidden beneath the surface. Okay. Spiritually, the Jew is lame. Spiritually lame. He doesn't know what it means to mitzvah. Spiritually erect means the Jew both of his or her legs are healthy spiritually. Their arms are healthy, their legs are healthy. As the mission says or spiritually a person who has no vision, they don't see reality. There's a a person who has vision sees the difference between nighttime and daytime, between light and darkness. Person who has developed taste buds knows the difference between bitter food and sweet food. You know, people that everything they eat, the bitter is sweet and the sweet is bitter. The Rambam says it's true spiritually as well. That's what it means, sum. So, they're talking not just about a kala, physical wedding. They're talking about says you look at a Jew and you see how could you say this Jew is beautiful? How could you say this Jew is gracious? I didn't make up a lie. This Jew has a blemish. The Jew is a Jew spiritually may be lame or lack vision. So B says find out some nice qualities and talk about it. I don't mind. comes and says went out of went to the marketplace and he chose this soul. Hashem chose every Jew as his kala verstically as the very I betrothed you to me saying from the Hashem went and chose this kala. Now you're at the So what should you tell Hashem? This Jew is beautiful or this Jew is ugly. What do you think is the right thing? You should here at the should you tell bad choice. You should have called me before the wedding. You should have called me. That's what you should tell Hashem. I say I'm looking I don't see. So told, so Hashem told Elu looked at all the sons of David of don't look at the external feature. But there's one condition. You have to be integrated with people throughout they always find a by Jews. They always have what to say. Don't give them the they did this wrong. They did that wrong. So it says in that soul tell the malim come down to this world. They're sitting in heaven. They look and they say these are beautiful people. These are gracious people. These are sinners. Suddenly you send a malik down to this world and you see even a small mitzvah they can't keep tells them even you couldn't keep by they come down to earth with it's a whole different story only prevails in this world if you understand people if you could see things from people's perspective from other people's perspectives if you understand the journey of an is in a goof if you Understand of if you understand the trials and tribulations that people go through emotionally, psychologically, physically, financially, spiritually, internally or externally. If you appreciate the fluctuations and the vicissitudes of a person's soul and their journey in Haza in often a challenging life with the stress and the anxiety and the obstacles, etc., etc. Basil says, "You're not lying. You're just looking beneath the surface, you'll see it's not just colorful, it's full of colors. You have to be able to look beneath the concealment. So Esther knows about the Jews that she's the one who tells. And here it goes one step further. And the Gmorra continues that would dance with a front of every and he would say and the hadus is of course that color of Esther. So he would dance with and say because the is not like bish the is like basiliz says when Mashiach comes the law is going to be like bish in everything. Why? Cuz when Messiah comes, then you could talk a pascan like Bashai. No problem. When Msiah comes, there'll be a seamless flow. The inner and the outer will be one. Of course, you should pass like B. But in in a time of gulos, the is like Basil, not like Bash. There is dissonance. There is a dichotomy. My soul is sometimes trapped and concealed. My brother once shared with me a line. Somebody asked Michelangelo how he managed to sculpture David. His sculptures are brilliant. How he managed to do it. So Michelangelo said, "I saw the angel trapped in the marble and I chiseled away on the marble and I set the angel free." Esther understood that the angel is trapped in a marble. That's what hast a means. There is concealment. And when there is concealment, I could do one of two things. I could become part of the problem or I could become part of the solution. Part of the problem means I surrender to the concealment. I I create even a deeper concealment. I cause the darkness to grow or I can actually shine a light and reveal the various lights, the various illuminations that are beneath the surface. I could put on a deeper pair of lenses and say earnestly there's that grace that you could see on that person you say yellow green I don't like the spiritual complexion it's not my taste but Esther fulfills something much more Remember where did Marduk live and where did Esther live? These Jews came to a party of the king for seven days. He invited them. What happened? They stumbled. They failed. They ate non-cooser food. They celebrated in a party of Arussia. who understood their test if not Esther who was living for years in a non-Jewish environment and understood the Nisan of eating kosher food in such an environment never had such a test was a sad Mai lived had yes was when Mordeai came to the palace they gave him Rabbi Lando But Esther couldn't say she was a Jew. If Esther would have could say, "I'm a Jew." So would have arranged a catering every day. The caterer would bring in breakfast, lunch, and dinner. She probably get sick of it after a few days. But fine, he would make for her a kosher kitchen and hire kosher chefs. Akashes had money. But Esther couldn't say she was a Jew, so she couldn't ask for kosher food. So what happened? She ate kosher for years without anybody knowing that she's taska eating kosher. How deep was that test? And how difficult was it for her? And how much could she empathize with a Jew who in such an environment does surrender? And furthermore, we see in the migilla something quite surprising and startling. And I'm going to ask you to look at the next source after that's the same page where we spoke about Esther's complexion. The PK says Esther was brought to the king and there was a fellow Hagi. He was in charge on all the women that were brought and he saw Esther and he deviated. He gravitated. He made changes for her and her maidervants in the positive. What did he do? Rav saidi he gave her kosher food even though they didn't know she's Jewish. The mafaram say they knew that she was raised by Mardai. They thought Mardekai raised a non-Jewish girl who was an orphan but she said I grew up in a Jewish house. I'm used to kosher food. So he gave her kosher food. The Benay says she claimed that kosher food is healthier. So they gave her kosher food. He was the rabbi of Baghdad and he says that he heard that the queen of England eats kosher because t comes from illness so she doesn't want it. That's what he writes. He passed away in 1900 and I never did the research. He says Esther could have said I want to the Jews know how to eat. They have good remember there was the tisian by Jews. They're good with hygiene. They're good with they they they kosher food is healthy food. She got away with it. says when it says he treated her well in her his mind a go mind how do you treat a girl well he gave her the fat of the pork of the kadi the kaziri is the shum the fattiest choiciest parts of pig he gave it to her that's what happened so Esther in the palace was given and then he gave her Legumes and sprouts. What we like, millet and peas and sprouts, all the good things. Now look at opinion. I want to ask you a question. Did she eat this pig fat or not? Take a look in Rashi. Rashi says it's the fat part of the of the swine of the pork and because she was anus she was starving. She had nothing to eat and to refuse it she might die or the king would kill her or they would kill her because she's supposed to be a potential queen. This is before she became a queen. So she ate it and loa there's no penalty for it. She was an is like a person who's starving. That's he served it to her. Hey guys served it. But she never ate it. It's an argument between Rashi and how you learn the Gmorra. The fact that she was offered that's not a question according to what she did. Rashi says she ate it. She didn't. Now I want to ask you a question. Why did theam have it that Esther would eat according to the she could have asked him for another food? Apparently it didn't work. This is what he wanted. She should eat and she would have starved or been executed. But the hash had Esther eat this food. Even according to she didn't eat it but she was tested according to she ate it. What happens? But now we can understand Esther is more when Esther thinks about the Jews who she doesn't understand them. She feels them. She empathizes with them. Even according to she never ate it. But she understood what it means. And according to everybody once she became a queen it says in Tigum Sheni she didn't even eat bishel. Forget about eating t. She didn't even eat. She was completely kosher without telling anybody she's Jewish. So for years she understood the nissan of being in an environment where there's no kosher and what it means to fight. She understood those who failed, those who unfortunately stumbled, those who unfortunately who surrendered. She understands it's something Mikai can't relate to because of his amazing life experience. And in fact, if you ever learn safer denil, you know took from Jerusalem young children and they became his top advisors. Dilan Michets put them all on a very very rich protein diet of meat. Dilanaria asked the maltzer, asked the cook, the chef, please give us zyim, give us sprouts, give us legumes, give us these types of he said, I can't. Wants you to grow well and healthy. He's going to kill me. They said do it for 10 days and we'll see. He fed them for 10 days these seeds and they look better than the other ones than the other servants. So that's what they continued to eat. This is in Tanakh and they said they're Jewish. They were taken from your so finally the king understood. You give them kosher food. Esther couldn't say she's Jewish. So it was one long battle of being the queen being at every party. You know how queens are especially in the Persian monarch. You have to be the hostess. You see what the king wanted from Vashi, but she can't eat non-cooser. She understood the nyan. And now here is the deal. You cannot help somebody really if you don't experience what they're going through. In fact, when Mardai first sends a message to Esther about the he says he it's a migillah says that he gave over to Marduk to Esther. What happened to him? Didn't happen to him. It happened to everybody. The answer is if it didn't it didn't happen to everybody. It happened to him because only when I feel it on my own flesh only when I feel it in my own guts and my own blood can I really really experience somebody else. Can I help them there's a very profound story that occurred with the son of the balata. He's known as the rebar in Kabad. He was the second rabbi the son of the balatana bear. They called him the the rabbi. He passed away on tes tesis. He was once seeing people on. Jews were coming for counsel for blessings. And he was counseling. He was giving them advice. They call it a personal private audience between aid and ab. After a few days, somebody came in and he spent some time there. And when he left the Reb, the Mitler Rebba locked the door and he said he can't see anybody. And for the next three days, he was in a tiny. He didn't eat. He ded, but he couldn't see people. And he wouldn't see people. And be behind the door, they heard him say to him, and they heard him crying a lot. And after three days, he opened the door. He broke his fast. And what happened then was he asked that they bring the person back. And he continued on. When I say he fasted, he he ate something at night, I believe. But during the days, he had a tiny. So his son asked him, "Reb." And he said something unbelievable. He said, "A Jew came and he shared with me something he did." Whenever anybody shares something they did that was destructive that was inappropriate I don't give them advice. I first find that action within myself even if in a more refined way I find it within me and only then can I help them. This person came and his crime his sin was so heinous. It was so beyond comprehension that I realized I cannot find it in myself. And then I thought but Hashem sent him to me. That means I could help him but I can't help him. So for three days I had to become truly introspective until I discovered this quality that was hidden inside of me and then I can help him. What is he really communicating here? The depth of what he's communicating here is that if I do not feel what you're going through, I can't help you. And it's not something that we intuitively understand because we think I'm smart. I have experience. I may be a therapist for 69 years. I know all the textbooks. Of course, I can help. It's not true. Doesn't work that way. I had a conversation a few weeks ago with Dr. Bessel vanderkulk who's considered one of the top world experts on trauma. He's not Jewish. He wrote the book The Body Keeps the Score. He's been a doctor for many years, but he's he's he was cons he's considered like one of the top experts. He lives on Trump. He lives in Massachusetts. And uh I asked him, it was it's on the web. I asked him if uh from all of his years of experience he's he's in the medical mental health field 50 years or more when a person is choosing a therapist or a professional to speak to who what field what type there's so many and everyone you know I I was asking like you ask a you know where do you begin and and how do you know if the person is good and how do you know if it's successful people are often so vulnerable in such a state you know they need desperately help and and what form of healing? There's so many different forms of therapy and different models of healing. What model would he would he suggest from all of his abundant experience? And he said something fascinating. He said, "It almost makes no difference." I said, "What makes no difference?" He said, "It almost makes no difference the level of education, how much they know, and what form therapeutic model they're using." I said that's coming from you. He says I'll tell you what makes most difference. He said of course you need to be educated and of course you need to know what's going on and of course you need to understand the variables. That's not the most important thing. I said what's the most important thing? And he said these words, the most important thing is that a therapist should be a worked out person internally so that they don't bring in their own issues into the healing so that when they're sitting with somebody, they could completely open their heart and become a containing presence for the other person's journey. And the only way you could become a containing presence for the other person's journey is if you know what's going on inside of yourself. He used a word that I'm not going to repeat. He says, "If you don't have your spaghetti worked out, you will never be able to really heal people if you're coming from a place of I know your problem. I'm I'm coming from a place of authority." I said, "But that's what all psychiatrists do." He says, "Yeah, many psychiatrists are psychiatrists, but they're not people." I'm like, "What are you telling me?" He's saying, "Very often people are just textbooks. You fit into my textbook. Here's medication. Next, he said, "The key the key," he says, "Sometimes you need medicine. Sometimes it saves lives. But the key is the key is that I could really really tune in to your life, feel it, experience it, and I become like a womb." You know, the maral says that the the word for womb comes from the word rakim, compassion. What what what's a womb? I feel uncomfortable preaching about this here, but what is it? It's it's it's spiritually I'm talking about. It's containing the child. That's what it is. That's its whole tough. I'm not here to judge the child. I'm not here to decide what type of soul the child has or what type of body. I'm here. That's what is. I'm here to contain. But how do you contain somebody else? I have my issues. Can I contain you? I come with my mind. I come with my issues. I come with my distraction. Especially if it's your child. There's so many expectations. That's where it becomes really difficult. But in the world of whether it's in a school or in a house, this is the of an educator or of a parent because what happens when you have an educator who may be brilliant and maybe a very good person and idealistic and really good and they mean well. There's only one issue. They don't experience what the student is going through. They never had to. They don't know what it is. They know it maybe from a book but experientially I can't be on you with your journey and if I can't be with you on your journey automatically I come from a more judgmental place I come from a place of distance from superiority authority not that I mean bad I may be a very nice and good meaning and a person but when that child or that boy or that girl feels that womb they feel your presence. They feel that emotional energy that you actually get me. And now I can actually be here with you without judging and with full love. And like Esther, I don't allow the concealments to distract me. I don't look at you and say, "But but after this session, you got to be normal. Snap out of it, girl. Snap out of it, boy. Come on. Give nakas to your parents. Those are normal human emotions. I'm not judging any of those emotions. We all have them. But that's not where healing comes from. All healing comes from. And this understands that he has to find this. And I have to tell you, the sin that this person did was not that he forgot my what it was. I'll tell you the word in English. I'm not going to elaborate. It was necrilia. That's what he came to the Reba for. But he wanted to do chuva the rebel misel understood if this person doesn't know what it is to be outside on a winter night he understands saddaka who doesn't understand to be nice but I have to feel viscerally the cold I have to feel the pain that this child is going through and if not I have to be humble and say I don't feel I don't understand. That's also a madrega. So Dr. Basel Vandal told me he said, "Rabbi Wi, I'm telling you the level of education is nice and important. That's not the key. The key is how worked out you are in yourself. Do you know how to suspend your ego? Do you know how to suspend your expectations? Can you notice your own anger? Can I notice my triggers? Can I notice what's happening inside?" In other words, my main work is not here. My main work is here. Here. Can I notice it and see if it's controlling the conversation? The put it brilliantly in a says in a who's not obligated in the mitzvah can't fulfill the obligation of somebody else. If I'm not obligated to blow for read the I can't do it for people who are obligated. So he said the word is the word we translate as obligated. It really means guilty. If he's not guilty, he can't take out the rabbim from their guilt. If I am not part of your experience in any form or fashion, if I cannot find your flaw inside of me, if I cannot find your pain inside of me, if I cannot find your mistakes inside of me, if I cannot find your struggle inside of me, maybe in a different way. It doesn't mean that I'm a copy of you, but it means that I can relate to this. I can feel what's happening inside of you now. I can really be there in your world and help you see your light because I help you see your light from your darkness. Esther had this ability because Esther knew what these Jews went through. She found it in herself. She ate the Kazeri according to Rashi or she had to fight against it according to. So when Hashem tells Mosher Rabenu that the Jewish people created a golden calf the words that he uses the two words is le go down. So of writes and also the kamb writes in he says hashem told you're on the mountain you're going to have to go down into their space in order to be able to lift them up. In fact says and the commander says that's why Mosha broke the lus. Nobody knows why did he break the lus. If the Jews were undeserving of them, hide them. Give them back to Hashem. Put them away. You don't. The Lucas were not. It's like you're you're angry. I understand. So when you're angry, you take something that's worth $100 million and you break it. And this was not worth $100 million. This was priceless. There's no substitute. Let's say you buy your husband a gift. You come home. He's giving you an attitude. You're in a bad mood. So you destroy it. You put it away. Hopefully there'll be a better day. sell it on eBay, whatever. Says something astounding. He says, "The Gmorra says, "Somebody who breaks utensils out of anger, it's a form of idolatry." So he says shocking words. Hashem told me, "If you want to lift up the Jewish people, you're going to have to go down." But Mosha had no connection to their sin. He was on the mountain. So he broke the most expensive utensil out of anger in a very very subtle subtle way. He now had a connection to them and from that place he can uplift them. And you'll say but why why can't I just sit on the chair and look at you and give you advice? And I can't explain it but it's anybody who's who's involved in this knows the experience of it. That's how all healing happens. All healing happens from that energy where the person can experience you believing in them from amidst that place because you know what that place looks like. So Esther comes to Mai and says I know what you might be thinking. Go. Why call? Because will naturally exclude a certain category of Jews. So Esther says those Jews that and those Jews that yes, invite them to fast for three days and three nights. Bring them into the gathering and you know what will happen says the tree is felled from the wood of the axe that's taken from the tree. And that's why the prophecy about the defeat of As came from was a descendant of As because you take the wood from the tree to create the axe to cut the tree. These Jews that they'll create the transformation. This tree, their fasting will be the true transformation that will make this. So in Kabala also it says comes from the world of a world where there's no evil. Esther comes from the world of Malus known as the worlds of Bria. When Mardai wants to gather Jews he gathers Jews from he gathers Jews from the holiness. Esther says every Jew. One more detail. Look at her words. She could have said gather the Jews all of them. She starts off with who do you start with? She starts with these Jews of because the gar says in a tinus that does that doesn't include the sinners of Israel is not a tinus. That's why in the 11 herbs we included which doesn't have a pleasant foul. So if you want, she starts off with start off with them and from them all Jews would be saved. This is what Esther says. Now comes the second [Applause] didn't just do what Esther said. He understood the coil of Esther. He took her word serious. He went and he gathered every single Jew and every one of them successfully joined like Esther for saw because she knew the pibus of the Jews. She knew she knew she knew what they went through. He went and did it. And indeed the transformation happened. It's not just Hmon was defeated. Batila Esther the house of Hmon was given to Esther. There was a transformation because there was a transformation by the Jews. He didn't just go to the Jews who initially are in a space of light. He created a transformation of and that created this that the transformation that base on Esther. Ah so the migill uses the words [Applause] passed over. Rav says he transgressed the mitzvah of Pes. So the kamer writes mosha broke the to go down. Mai also had to do vay. He also had to descend. But then comes the view of says the second view. He passed a stream of water. And who is this? Yeah. The same shel who said that Esther was fed the kaziri when she came she was given pork not because she chose it. It wasn't but it was her experience and says she had to eat it says she didn't need it but she dealt with it. She struggled with it. The same shel says he crossed a pond of water. And the question is, okay, he crossed the pond of water. Very nice. But the migilla has to tell me. But of course, as the maral brings when a was going to the we know what happened. The sultan created a whole sea, a whole river. What does that represent? Stop. Don't go further. You're going to drown. Generally, an ocean, a water stream, a canal, a mikvah, something a person can't live in. Water is a dangerous place. We're not fish. We're not amphibious creatures. Passing into water. There's a concept of somebody who goes through a because represents you going into a new world that's not inhabit. It's not a place that human humans can inhabit. So the gamarra is explaining here a deep remai had to pass through a gulf. had to pass through a river, a sea, a stream, a canal, a schloo may a place like when a is going to thea you feel like I can't this is not for me go back the intimate sentiments the inner sentiments of mai are saying why should I go over this this is too hard this is too difficult I'm going out of a comfort zone I'm going to a group of Jews that don't belong to this I'm not going to convince them to fast for three days and three nights this is the obstacle that The water here represents especially that you have to pass over the water a Jews who are so disconnected from the of but listens to Esther. He went out. He went over the water. He went over this obstacle to do in every person's life. A person says it's still a time of gull. I'll worry about myself. I have enough inner work and inner perfection to do. Comes Esther and says no. Never ever give up on a person. Go gather every single Jew. And even in a time and a person that represents concealment, have the ability to be able to really see through it. Don't become part of the problem. Always be part of the solution. Don't become engulfed by the darkness. See the light and become that person who helps them see the light. Because only when I could see it can I help the other person really really really see it. But it takes so much work because it's so easy to be trapped literally to be lured into the external trap. The ability to say is so much inner work. It's being anchored in that space of infinity that sees the light in every mitus in every reality. And when I gather that call beginning with those people who are closest to me but without distinction. So then what happens? It's not just they're also saved. Mai is saved. Esther is saved. It's those Jews that ultimately allow the transformation and the salvation of all of the Jewish people. Have a wonderful week. Thank you.