Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Shedding Light on Taboos with Rabbi YY & Eli Nash: Webinar #2

8,930 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

the yeshiva.net alright welcome everyone to tackling taboos number two and number one um a few taboos tackled us we tackled a few other ones what we've decided in this one which is the second of a three-part series the third one will be March 16th Thursday two weeks and one day from today March 16th at 8pm so again if you're watching this live then follow up by YY or myself wherever we are and you'll see a link to sign up for the third one if you've signed up to this you'll automatically be signed up to the next one if you're watching this on YouTube sometime between March 1st when we're recording this on March 16th then somewhere in the comment section should be a link to sign up to the uh the third one the format for tonight we'll be discussing uh solutions for addiction as much as we could in uh 20 or 30 minute discussion then we'll give a more comprehensive um um our words will will cover more on the subject of homosexuality we'll do our best again in a limited time and then we'll go to question and answers and we'll start with the question answers from last time that we didn't answer so even if the people aren't here if their question was there and we've reviewed them and they're relevant some we combined together then we will um go to through those first also in this Zoom you'll see two formats if you're on YouTube Don't Put we won't see it so if someone's watching this Live on YouTube any questions there or comments we won't see here so be on the zoom itself and don't use the chat function use the question and answer and those who are watching this participating if you upvote a question and it's towards the top it's more likely to get answered but we'll get to as many as uh as possible Rabbi y welcome welcome thank you for uh yes welcome Ellie and thank you for the opportunity and the privilege for putting it together and thank you for everybody thousands who joined us last time and are joining us this time it's really it's very meaning it really is able to have all of you here um one of the things that happened and the feedback I have to say the feedback that Ali and I received over the last two weeks was really astounding and I also want to thank all the critique some therapists some colleagues some educators some lay men and women from all stripes and walks of life have emailed either me or Ellie you know various points of critique and subtleties and enhancements and important important ideas and observations so it's really very meaningful because this is really an ongoing conversation about life and you know we're sharing but we all need to grow and we all need to learn more and we all need to be able to be open to every type truth that is out there and in here so thank you everybody for all your feedback including and it's one of the reasons we're doing it live right is to uh for it to be an interaction what I I didn't make a commitment and I don't think you do either I don't put words in your mouth to getting everything right but to be open-minded to everything we hear so I did receive certain critique especially in the sense that we covered homosexuality so briefly so some pick their part words and some picked apart the fact that we covered it so briefly and said hey like this topic needs to be discussed and uh said okay put your comment in the form of a question and uh we hope to uh we hope to yell to address it that is the intention okay so in term oh there's one thing that happened actually between last one and this one which I shared with you Rabbi someone reached out to me and um they said they were on the webinar and a couple of days later uh their wife found them with a um their backpack with uh some alcohol there's nothing necessarily wrong with um alcohol but it's a problem of riding alcohol and uh he said based on the webinar you know who to reach out to and he reached out to me and I recommended um after speaking to him some 12-step groups and he went to his first meeting but what actually surprised me from it the reason I wanted to bring it up is because here was someone who was dealing with something that I don't think is so taboo and alcohol addiction and he said that he didn't have who to reach out to I don't know why like it's not even the topic that I uh I I typically um address so whatever that meant that he didn't feel that he had anyone to reach out to and he was grateful that he had heard the webinar just before I think that whatever is being done we have to add um a lot more to it yeah so and it just underscores the truth there is so much shame inside of so many of us and for good reason there's a good reason why there's shame there's so much stigma there's a lack of empathy and compassion and understanding and people feel you know I need to get my children into the right schools I need to marry them off I'm an upstanding member in the community I'm going to go to a group who's going to be there and suddenly this guy he may be teaching gamar at five o'clock in the morning I don't know you know he may be you know he may be a one of the most fabulous teachers in in a great institution Lakewood or Muncie or Borough Park yeah who knows where what he's doing the other day I didn't ask him but he actually did mention that at the end of the meeting so this particular meaning that he went to everyone puts their arm on their shoulders and they say something in unison and from what I imagine they say is the surrender the Serenity Prayer God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change courage to change the things I can and the wisdom to know the difference right and he's like what's that Mantra they do at the end I was a little bit uh uncomfortable I said don't worry it's been cleared by uh by rabbis you're allowed to get healing don't worry it's safe it's safe you didn't uh you didn't violate anything by talking about uh by asking God to Grant anything and saying God in the English and not in the Hebrew it's okay you're fine you're fine it's been cleared it's it's just so important it's so important to be able to open up conversations for people to feel that there is a lot of support out there there's a lot of support today you can't trust everybody that's true and you may have confirmed in Europe's life that you can't trust people but there are there are people you could trust and there are a lot of healing methods and models today so we all need to be ambassadors of healing this I think each and every one of us has such a sacred Duty for our family for for friends for colleagues for strangers there's so much opportunity there's a special Society of healing now I take issue a lot of respect to therapists and those in the healing community and those with licenses and who've studied different things but a couple of years ago when um there was some controversy around the mic drop uh talks which I was involved in so one of the criticisms are who are we to help people share their story we're not therapists and to my mind Everyone's A Healer everyone every person has the capacity to to heal the only prerequisite is that we first heal ourselves before we heal others but we all have the capacity to uh to heal so should we jump in okay you know and I think I I just want to say this because it's beautiful you just said we're all healers and I think one of the deepest ways we become healers is through cultivating real humility and a lack of judgmentalism and a lack of arrogance you know that I know everything like as a rabbi as a teacher people ask me a lot of types of questions and I once asked a mentor of mine a good friend who's also a very experienced therapist and I said to him you know I feel very often that I don't know the answer and he said that's perfectly fine you don't know the answer you know who to reach out to to be able to get perspective the problem is when people become arrogant and they decide that they know the answer when they don't they don't even have the humility to say you know maybe this is something I don't have experience with but they'll give advice that's that's unfair we all need to be very very humble you know the worst therapist or doctor you want to go to is the one who says everything there is to know about the brain and the body I know a rabbi who tells you everything there is to know about truth and God I know all right who said The only thing I know is that I don't know the the expression for a real Titus scholar is he's a student of wisdom he may be 95 years old starting his whole life he's a student of wisdom talmud always a student the moment I'm not a student anymore I'm not allowed to teach I'm not let a share it could be dangerous my my status my need to get validation my need to control can take over and manipulate and exploit very vulnerable people and that's very very dangerous people have to be very careful I know it's not our topic but I do have to say this because I get emails constantly you know there are some rabbis who are amazing people there are therapists doctors ordinary people who are amazing who are full of kindness and empathy and truth but some who are who are so broken and they break others they break others consciously or unconsciously and you need to be very very careful even when you're vulnerable don't allow somebody to take advantage of you don't allow a therapist don't allow a rabbi don't allow a rabbit son don't allow you know a mentor don't allow to take advantage if something is not feeling right if somebody is not bringing you to a place of of more connection of more confidence of more love of more Serenity you know ask tough questions I just think it's so important for people who are vulnerable and they they give their life to somebody and just be be you know respect yourself it's a tough thing because we have to open ourselves to heal and the opening process but we have to open ourselves I'm just closing the door because of a commotion we have to open ourselves up to heal and when you find a person you trust be humble be vulnerable let go because if not I won't heal but always always ask yourself you know is there was there were there boundaries crossed you know was I taken advantage of did somebody exploit Me Maybe physically emotionally psychologically spiritually you know there's a situation now of women who are going to see a particular spiritual master and the way he took advantage of these women sexually and emotionally this is horrific the women were so vulnerable they were so vulnerable and he groomed them correctly and this is you know on on this is something that we cannot tolerate and we have to all be cautious and aware and be there for people no I understand why I'm just mentioning I have a friend I throw it out I'm a friend who is sexually abused my therapist he went through to deal with the fact that he was sexually abused so as a as a child his parents found out went to a therapist and was sexually abused by the uh by the therapist you imagine like how does that person open themselves up again for healing where did they find the uh the trust again take whatever take the story in Israel with high and Wilder Ryan Wilder was considered one of the top top therapists and experts on education for all of Israel in the religious community he wrote one of the most prominent essays every week on pedagogy on education his books we all had we all had his books and our kids loved his books he was a brilliant man in many ways and had a lot of he had he understood empathy and for 25 years the most complicated sexual abuse situations and challenges in benebra another place was sent to him he was the man we don't even know how many people he molested whether it's doubt we know dozens but we don't know if it's hundreds or more until he committed suicide so and and the story was out there but nobody believed it nobody believed it I can't be not him not him you're gonna believe a woman a woman instead of him and then Revel Yahoo the chief Rabbi of svas you know he told me I had a conversation with him personally and he said 24 women 24 women with children married someone grandmothers came to testify 24 normal women don't destroy their lives just because they have something against the fact that we even needed 24 years and then people sided with him right and then people started with it so the reason I'm pointing this out is just all of us have a responsibility to be able to encourage people to to challenge the silence because that's where evil lives in silence and evil lives in stigma we all need to be have mouth and ears not to stand by idly as the blood of our children spill in the presence of predators of all types and forms silence does not help anybody besides besides the perpetrators and the murderers they love silence they love two words somebody that's walking around with a gun murdering children that's not I'm sorry 100 I'll tell you story from last year anyway no it's good you already got my blood boiling you already got my blood boiling intervention it's too early too early so last year when we did the conversation and we're going straight into the healing of the addiction so there was a young boy who reached out to was between 18 and 20. I don't remember he was young and he had become a balchuva five or so years before and one of the first things he saw so he reached out to me because he saw our talk on the shame of addiction where we focused on porn addiction and he said that he's been struggling with porn pretty much you know since it's since puberty I don't know 13 years old 14 years old and one of the first things he saw when he came from was a video on YouTube of he just told me his fartic Rabbi who was railing against um like spilling seed and all these things and he said it stuck with him it like completely stuck with him so and every I tried to talk to him and say listen you're doing amazing you're 18 19 after all he was and you care about this thing and you're working on it you've a few days you got clean congratulate yourself why are you beating yourself up and he couldn't hear my words he kept going back no how can you say it how can you be understanding how could he said you heard her by why I talked you I said not only me that's saying it like you heard a rabbi there and say and show compassion and empathy for someone who was um as for someone who's who's gone and you know fallen in those behaviors it's not so simple we don't just uh we don't just bash some someone a couple of times he heard me and then he would fall back you know a week or two later but one of the things um that I said to him which I want to share here as I said how old was this gentleman this rap I don't even know who he is how old how old was he said I don't know 50s 60s I said okay no one who's 50 or 60 no one who's that age can speak to a teenager about the problem with porn because today I'm 37 years old and what I grew up with and what I got sucked into is nothing compared to the challenge that children that kids have today I was 22 years old when the iPhone came out I got hooked on porn from magazines and from dial up desktop computers in my house imagine what my life would have been like had I had a super computer or whatever you you know these things that can access the internet when I was 12 13 14 years old never mind all the algorithms and what they're feeding us and everything else so for anyone to sit there at 56 years old and judge a kid who's 18 years old today about his problem with pornography has no right he's not he hasn't hasn't even been close to his situation you're telling a starving person about not eating not eating non-kosher food this this kid is up against the biggest machines and he's fighting back he deserves to be championed and not put down at all especially by someone who has no way of understanding him so now I got fired up also okay to the solution so first of all I want to say that from my standpoint I'd love to hear your thoughts so I'll speak in the in the context of porn addiction because that's my story but I think healing applies to everything is number one no one's going to hear anything tonight that's going to be the Magic Bullet I'm still working on on on my healing all I'll say is this is that we're trying to rebuild a person which is probably more complex than building a house and there isn't one person you can go to you can't call a general contractor even and say get me everything from my house because he's gonna need to know what did the architect say what did the designer say and you're running around to stores picking up sofas and furniture and all the limitations that each one of these people have the same is true we're rebuilding a human being this is not just how do I get rid of porn porn is built on belief systems and any negative behaviors is built on belief systems it's built on our identity our personalities our traumas all of these it's this whole foundation and on top of it the tip of the iceberg is this Behavior that's getting our attention pornography so when we want to heal it we got to go to the bottom of the iceberg and start chipping away at those things and understanding it so there isn't one person you're going to call and say okay call them and everything is going to be fixed it's not like this we need a team we need a team we need a village in order to heal so that's kind of the first thing uh I want to share on that topic is that this is not a simple thing people go to rehab four five six times make certain progress and still relapse and still go back and this is true with any of these things we're rebuilding a person it's a difficult thing to do it's a challenging thing to do and the person who's most responsible for it is the person themselves first thoughts on that anything you want to add or should I keep going you keep going and also share with us if you can you know you you have so much experience with your own life besides advice you've given like what were like what were the the key like if I were to ask you Ellie you know what were maybe four or five moments or or moments of awareness and experience that really changed you and and and and got you into a life of awareness of recovery of of Transportation so let's just say there's addiction and there's addiction right someone who's watching porn once in a while or using alcohol once in a while not necessarily the category of addiction how do we know something's addiction is the progressive nature of it it somehow keeps amping up so in my case um I found that I was going to more and more and more dangerous behaviors more Reckless more I was pushing the envelope constantly and one of the experiences I had was a I got into a relationship and for the first time I was forced to lie in a way that I never had to previously I was able to till then I was able to you know have my addiction and secrecy and silence like you say suddenly had to lie to another human being the woman I was dating who eventually became my wife and that made it much more difficult so the shame act defined what was interesting is the addiction progressed even worse than it didn't get better because that it got worse much worse fortunately I was already working on some things and this is what I had and hopefully some of what we can offer tonight I had an address to go to because prior to my dealing with addiction I was already dealing with the fact that I was sexually abused as a child so I had the address of a therapist I had a number I had some language around it I had I had who to call so while I was struggling this in one moment right you have to catch that person in the in the moment sometimes so in that space of feeling to Total demoralization I reach out to a therapist and he put me in touch he said Ali I we've dealt with a lot of things this I can't help you with alone this you're going to need meetings you're going to need a support group you're going to need a system not meeting me one or two hours a week it's not going to be enough for this so he gave me the number of an individual so I had this guy who was a person in 12 steps he was recovering from his own addiction he was 20 or 30 years older than I was at the time so in his case when his addiction came to light he had cheated on his wife and his uh his um children were teenagers so they knew about it and it was a massive source of Shame was much more than what I was dealing with then which was just hiding something from someone I was dating just in any event in this context I found that one of these behaviors and I don't want to get too graphic in these conversations because we're talking about sexual addiction but my addiction progressed Beyond pornography so often that I said the progressive nature addiction and there was a certain experience that I had and I said okay like when I'm exceptionally stressed I'll go to this experience this experience will soothe my soul in some way and I went there and it didn't do anything and the fear I felt walking out of there saying what's next I knew there's a next because I you know it's like I If if we had to measure Now call it's like okay I drank a bottle and it got me to a certain place maybe this time if we take a bottle and we take you know A Fistful of weed gummies this is maybe going to take me to this uh State that's going to feed me and sex addiction it's the same thing and suddenly I was saying okay if this didn't work and this was kind of the the place that I said I call it a top shelf experience this was experience that I held near and dear to me and say I'm never going to go there um unless I absolutely need to and I went there and I felt nothing and I felt total fear and fortune that moment of feeling total fear remember walking out of the place now I called this guy who was in 12 steps and I said just help me tell me what I need to do and he directed me to 12-step meetings I continued with my therapist and you know a whole uh Evolution unfolded but that was one of the key moments for me the the sweet willingness of a desperate man calling someone and just utter humility tell me what I need to do I'm willing to do anything I don't want this life anymore wow 27 or 28. 27 or 28. and the addiction began at what age so it started the first time I remember um like the obsession with uh the female body so to speak was probably about 12 or 13 years old uh when catalogs would show up through my um house and whatever it was it could be something innocuous like a a lens end magazine or something like like that in the back was a lingerie section and it started there and then it progressed eventually we got a computer in the house and then it turned to pornography and then friends in school you know a magazine here or a magazine there and you know it it kept progressing but it started 12 or 13 by the time I was definitely by the time I was 14 it was a full-on Obsession a full-on obsession so you're talking about 13 or 14 years of a full-on Obsession until you really reached for help yeah and um it that was my first meeting was pesach in 2013. that was my very first meeting I went to and I seen a therapist years before it was pesach of 2013 but when I got sober like the sobriety date I mentioned our last conversation that that sobriety date doesn't exist anymore because I slipped once but that started around New Years of 2017 roughly beginning of 2017. so from 2013 till 2017 I was walking on quicksand even though I was desperate I was looking for help I was sweetly willing I was tell me what to do and I was following Direction but I still kept slipping it takes time this is not something that's that's overnight and I think the same is true whether addiction is what we're discussing but it doesn't matter what we're what we're talking about I think it takes several years three to five years for someone who earnestly starts the process if they're dealing with something we're talking about someone who's dealing with something three to five years to feel like they're on Solid Ground why why does it take so long you think from my ex from your experience the the hardest thing to get to are the beliefs because we have beliefs that we think are facts and we it's so hard to know that these are not like you start talking to someone you say what everyone doesn't feel this way like this is not this is this is not the way it is I had so many beliefs and so many thoughts I mean they were just and unwinding it that we spoke about one last time right which is I cannot depend on people to have my needs met I mean we can walk through life with this thing that Independence is this virtue and it helped me in so many areas right I started a business at 19 20 years old was it I I achieved some financial success I'm sure a lot of that was the independent streak I wanted to be independent I can't rely on anyone so I'm going to do it myself I don't want to call someone for a dollar I don't want to call someone for a hug you know like I don't want anything from anybody so I'm done with him you're done with Humanity and that belief to realize that that's a belief not a fact it's a belief that I chose to believe chose I needed to whatever it is it's a belief so I think that's kind of like the deepest part of it and then there's trauma trauma sits inside of us um I I know we're going to talk about um plant medicines on a future experience but um there was an experience I had under plant medicines which was as I I did everything for my anxiety if I tell you everything I had anxiety from the youngest age much before my addiction before the abuse is as far back as I can remember I had anxiety and so much so that if you asked me you have anxiety from what age what age probably from like two three years old I think there always was anxiety but definitely my child there was always a lot of anxiety a lot a lot of anxiety but I didn't know it was anxiety I didn't know it as anxiety I if you would have asked me 15 years ago Ellie are you anxious I wouldn't have used those words because it was the Natural State you know give someone a backpack to carry their whole life you know what's with the load you're carrying what am I carrying anything what are you talking about it just feels like part of Nature and I did a lot of things tons of breath work and tons of other modalities to heal but there was still this anxiety that's out with me and I had an experience under plant medicines where right Jason I'd love to you've helped me process some of my other experience in words it felt not if the experience was as if there was a a spirit living in my lower abdomen which I always kind of felt something there living in my lower abdomen that left me in that experience it flew out of me I don't have any way to say it is there some is there some Jewish basis for this and one second it wasn't just a spirit that flew out of me and that was that since that date two or so years ago I have never felt anxiety like that since and during it before it before it left me I felt the most intense panic attack of my life under it which was very scary thing right then we'll talk more plant medicines in the future ones but there was an entity that was inside me that flew out that's what it felt like under the experience and then when it left I never felt that anxiety again afterwards and just before I felt the anxiety in the most intense way I ever felt in my life so a little bit before which is so fascinating he said Ellie are you ready to let go of things I said why why am I so scared why am I so scared like grown man why am I so scared so he says don't ask why we don't ask why just ask just ask how do you get rid of it so I guess he saw an expression on my face and he said Ellie are you ready to get rid of it said am I ready to get rid of it so he said don't ask me ask yourself and in this state you can ask yourself said am I ready to get rid of it and I checked with myself Ellie are you ready the answer was no and I held on to it from the 10 or 15 minutes and then I said now I'm ready so he said ask how to Let It Go and as I started letting it go whatever that process was that's what it felt like is there any basis for a traumatic experience to live inside us almost as a spiritual as an entity as a as a formist within Judaism there's not just a basis for it I don't exaggerate when I tell you that kabbalistic and Hasidic literature is saturated with the notion that there are Clippers which we use as a mystical term but it's really a very very relevant term it means literally entities that are defined as Darkness as blockages as traumas as things that quarantine and Exile our soul and distort ourselves to ourselves and they really can saturate us and by the way I should say you know everybody grows up with this idea of Canadian and gehenne you know you're going to Paradise a Purgatory what is really means cleansing ourselves purging ourselves from these types of of entities that literally block our light our our love our Infinity our Oneness with with our creator and therefore with with the world and with humanity and and and you know I know many of us know that urging it is because the way it's this experience which it didn't come out through vomit but it came out right it was more of but it was a purging it was a shaking of violent shaking um it it was a scary the most scared I ever felt in my life yeah yeah so this is really the word Purgatory guy that means purging the cleanse you know people think it's like this Vengeance of God who's gonna punish you or destroy you it's really the exact opposite it's really the Blessed opportunity to be able to embrace the me pre-trauma the me pre-abuse the me pre-anxiety what a gift what a gift because my my my Infinity may be in Exile and this is a concept that saturates Jewish spiritual literature saturates the words the words are ancient words but but they can't and I have to say that today with all of the models of healing we we we could understand these sources so much so much better when I learned Tanya today I've taught Tanya for many many years but I have to say the way I learned it today is with so much more nuance and subtlety and and sensitivity and I'm like wow how did he know all of this but uh but yeah so it's really an incredible concept I want to ask you this anxiety that you describe it was not only in Social sense it wasn't like a social anxiety that was something else that I dealt with but at this point it was already resolved it was more of a social anxiety is that social anxiety this was a um the words I gave it so first of all the way it felt was a thought would enter my head and I would go into doomsday scenarios or sometimes it was something on the outside that I would see and doomsday scenarios would enter and I'd be captured by it completely captured and that's the way it felt in this moment in the moment during it it's felt like first it started off a very pleasant experience I was enjoying it it was good I was having different insights and information and suddenly a thought came in my head that what I'm doing is dangerous it's terrible I'm never going to get out of it whatever some thought right the Doomsday scenario this is over I took a a discomfort and turned it into catastrophic thinking if you've heard the term and would take over I would feel it in all of me my arms would get um like tingly I so in that case it became very extreme my my breath got very short I said I'm leaving I'm leaving I'm walking out the more I walked and the more I tried to distract the worst it got so finally I lied on the floor in a fetal position and I said what is this what is this what is this one of the things that I felt in that moment which um I don't know that I fully understood yet was that the fear of the underlying fear beneath everything was a fear of feeling Joy so what did I connected to it was like as things were getting better like when things were good as things were getting better this voice would come in and say oh you're gonna feel like you're gonna feel good right now but what if and then these scenarios would take over and it was a real I mean I've had many panic attacks over this like it can it was spiraled Way Beyond just a uncomfortable thought so the point you're making here is just to to some of the point is that the hardest part of dealing with addictions is the underlying belief system or beliefs that sit in our bellies yeah maybe unconsciously and dictate our behavior on a daily basis and that to get to that point is really takes a lot find out what it is and we'll find out what it is is really it's really hard there's you know safety layer safety layer and even when I find out what it is and even when I find out what it is you know my neural Pathways have already have already been fixed to be able to think that way so so to challenge that even if I know a lot of us you know knowledge cerebral knowledge and experiential implementation and we spoke about it right imagine someone is sitting there with this belief right they like you spoke about right a high mortar kind of situation that everyone who's trying to help is really in it for themselves no one is sincere I can't trust any of them right so they're sending this belief this is not a belief for them this is a fact and it's proven out by life experience and the most dangerous thing for them to do is to try to get help so that how are they supposed to go from there yeah it's tough it's 100 you're chasing your own tail they call it in Psychology confirmation bias confirmation bias you know this boy you know who who got 60s and 50s at his test at his test and he decided he's a failure he's a he's stupid and you know nothing will disprove it and then one day he gets a hundred and he says oh the teacher cheated for me because he felt bad and then you have another kid the opposite you know I'm a brilliant kid but you got a 50 yet because the teacher is a and he's dishonest and he doesn't know how to ask questions now you know you grow up you try to get into a relationship those confirmation biases are so so deep and I don't even see it because for me it's a reality I'm a stupid child I'm a brilliant child so it's uh so so so to to to to come so when we talk about advice for addiction I think Ellie if I could sum up what you're saying and and just uh maybe sharpen a few points that could be relevant it is so important it is so so important first of all to be able to have yourself compassion to be able to understand that addiction no issues I don't think addiction is different I've spoken to people with all sorts of issues and the rules apply the same rules apply all right and it's liberating when you could when you could know you're not in an eightly evil and you're not at an eighth addict your soul was not born to be a slave to addiction there's there may have been things that happened or things you're struggling with from inside or from outside and the addiction was your brain's way of somehow surviving somehow making sense of a very chaotic life and to be able number one to have compassion to really really have compassion because the shame is such a killer that shame like you said so much more drives us more into addiction and number two number two it's so important to have a support system we need people that we can be open with we can cry in their presence we can laugh in their presence we need good mentors good friends camaraderie we cannot heal in solitariness it just does not work when we go back to our loneliness all of the biases and all of the anxiety and the traumas are reinforced it's so important now I know you may be living in a community you may be a rebbe you may be a Russia Shiva you may be the guy by of a big rabbit you may be a tycoon you may be the biggest bounce stalker or you may be just a good nice man or woman and it's who are you going to open up to who are you going to open up to you have Russia your Rabbi but I tell you fine find somebody find find a mentor find the therapist start opening we must have support we must 100 people live in secrecy for years and it doesn't it doesn't work and I think another very important element is we need guidance from real experts we need people who are experts in this field get guidance and if it doesn't work for you ghost go somewhere else not everybody works for everybody and remember when you fail don't let your failure completely derail you right I mean said failure isn't inherent to this process because the addiction wasn't created in one day you know Rome wasn't built in one day it's not destroyed in a single day it's really it's really a process the awareness may happen in a moment but the execution of it can take a very very long time and have compassion for the fact that you may fail because you're dealing with some some serious obstacles one day they may not be serious but right now they're very serious and and it's so important to be able to celebrate your successes and to celebrate your victories and to be able to have that transparency and to realize that there's life beyond addiction there is a self that can be liberated that can be emancipated your soul is not contaminated at its core it's just impossible the soul is a derivative of divine Consciousness and therefore it's just not contaminated it is not broken it is not a piece of junk and garbage you are not the scum of the earth there is scumness that has attached itself to you and and we all have to work right that's that's one of the things that's interesting about the shame is oftentimes we feel shame and we say we feel disgusting right because we did the such Behavior but the fact that we feel disgusting by the behavior means it's not us like us beneath that otherwise what would be what would be disgusting you know jli shared a video today of I don't know who the gentleman it was a gentleman was it was a short video um but he said that he mentioned it was a Harvard study where they tracked a bunch of people to see what was the single um most uniform determinant of success for people and what it was was having one person that they can generally reach out to and ask for help those situations meaning even people who have good lives and do well they don't have major mental health issues everything else at some point in time they're going to need to reach out to someone and say the three hardest words are to say in the English language I need help and not having that is almost a guaranteed um almost guaranteed that we fail and that's why this silence is so damaging because someone is struggling and everyone's going to be struggling in different ways and different points and not having that address or someone we can call and say I need help right in my case the fact that in that moment when I felt so demoralized I was able to call my therapist who then gave me the number of a second individual who when I walked out of that place after that top shelf experience which I described and I said where to from here what does my addiction want me to go next but I had a number to call and say I need help and I felt his compassion I felt his care when I called him that was uh that was important if we can give a couple practical things so let's say with porn addiction specifically so with porn addiction it's a little complicated because a we have to understand what is porn addiction and what is not a guy called me he says you know I feel terrible I watched porn again and I promised myself I wouldn't I said okay when did you watch last week one time when was the time you watched before six months before I said congratulate yourself and move on there's nothing to talk to me about like there are people who are uh who are struggling in very very real ways so for those you know um I think there's a website guard your eyes right which offers many different people um tools for porn addiction they have an assessment that they offer fairly thorough assessment someone can go through say how severe is your porn use if we're suffering in silence we don't know what severity is go there answer your questions they'll tell you where you're at for a lot of people going to 12-step meetings is not necessarily the answer for me for example I went to 12-step meetings and my problem was beyond porn like I said it people prostitutes and other such things so the meetings did good for that but porn was viewed by most people in the meetings as something that was almost a harmless um situation most of them were much older they didn't they weren't raised into boy like raised by porno sex education wasn't from porn like it was for myself and even more so for teenagers today it was older guys who had struggled in different ways and they said okay porn is kind of uh this this harmless thing these other behaviors with people which are much more dangerous sometimes even illegal like those are the ones we have to worry about so there wasn't really a space I can go to to talk about porn use I I would think like if someone just had that problem should they even come to this place so I know there is a 12-step meeting porn Anonymous or something which deals just with those Pro those problems so it's sometimes difficult to get your arms around um around this issue like where do I start in the process but if someone knows that they have a true addiction then in my experience something like the 12 steps and that support that it gives you is amazing the 12th step has its limitations it doesn't do anything for trauma it doesn't anything for that so we also have a uh a therapist in the last week or so I was introduced to what seems to me like a and a therapist and a therapist 100 percent a lot of trauma and we're seeing it more and more now is that talk therapy has its limitations it's it's good in a way can deal with the symptoms and it can help you with um you know several weeks ago I did a breathworks session with uh with mayor K who's a uh a recent addition to the breathwork therapist scene and I sat the group of 30 people and I saw the process like we went through and me I've gone through so many breath work sessions and psychedelic experience and everything and what it did for me in that space and I have no shortage of people to talk to and everything else but it's like that kind of somatic healing that can enter the body and uh and allow us to heal what I do want to say is this group I I met just last week uh they were nice enough to share this um event with many of the much of Their audience and some of their this audience came from them um their name is okay Clarity and what they do is it's really nice within the Jewish Community people reach out to them and they help them find the right therapists for them like for myself people reach out to me it's the call I get more than anything else and I have limitations if it's uh someone dealing with exactly my issue I probably have someone to direct them to as long as they live in the place that that I know but suddenly they don't so I was I was very happy to see that there was it's actually a business which I'm a big fan of businesses sometimes tackling problems and not just non-profits which does this they don't charge the patient but they actually guarantee to someone like hey we vet our therapists we look through it so to me it's a nice tool I've been sending people to it recently okclarity.com to say go ahead and like have that uh have someone you can talk to can help you find that right space but the number one thing to do my opinion that one thing to do is anything we want to solve find someone who's done that so sometimes there's a bachar who's struggling heavily with porn addiction you're going to go to your mashpia it's nice to talk to him but don't take the advice too seriously unless he tells you that he struggled with this problem and and he's looking to get out of it so for myself as an I can't I can't answer everyone and I do as many things publicly so if you can hear some of those thoughts but if someone feels a need to reach out to me by all means on Instagram I is one way ellenash gmail.com reach out and I'll do my best to uh to help and Direct in the problems that I have uh that I have experience with but I think that's so important is and I want to take the I want to take the moment I didn't ask permission to salute Ellie on behalf of everybody who's watching or is going to watch because here's a person he does not get paid for this but he literally took all of his experiences from anxiety to child molestation to to Serious addictions and today has turned all of these dark experiences into a catalyst and a springboard to help not hundreds but thousands and thousands of people who reach out to him by email or Instagram or Whatsapp or phone or these webinars and I just want to salute you because here we have an example of you know talk about transformation thank you thank you it's wonderful exactly he gets paid and Spirits yeah and by the way it's one of the aspects one of the aspects of staying sober so I my my motives weren't completely altruistic it's possible that I pushed the uh push the boundaries of this a little bit but one of the ways we stay sober you know they say in 12 steps they say we keep what we have by giving it away and some of the times it's a crazy advice but try it when we're really like in our head about something sometimes we call someone this is not a first step process this is not like the first step as we're further in we get caught one day in a situation sometimes we want to call someone and ask for help instead reach out to someone who's struggling and then listen to their story for 20 30 minutes but really listen truly listen take them in and see how you feel I have to see how you feel afterwards but not the first step but not the first because unfortunately there are way too many people who are helping others to avoid dealing with themselves so it's not the first step but it's in fact in the 12 Steps it's the 12th step it's the 12th step is service I would also I would also mention we talk about practical Solutions I think one thing that we could right away begin is addiction leads very swiftly to lying and deception if you are lying in your life that is feeding usually something lethal when we could tell ourselves I'm not gonna lie anymore I'm done I'm gonna have to face what is happening in my life this becomes an impetus to be able to deal with situations when you stop lying in your marriage you stop lying to your employer your employees your siblings your parents friends classmates Partners etc etc it puts you in another place 100 Genesis of recovery and there's something else you may come to somebody and talk about addiction maybe the head of your Yeshiva or your Rabbi or a friend and they may say you know what start learning Gamora every day start learning muscle every day start learning hasidus every day diving with a minion have more kavana by davening say to Hillary which are all amazing and beautiful pieces of advice that we should all enhance and grow in but unfortunately two years later you see it hasn't helped it hasn't helped because sometimes it's not about that it's really not about that sometimes there's a deep-seated trauma that is poisoning your entire system and all your tire and all your diving and all your Mitzvahs and you'll tell them and all the muscle it's it's all beautiful but it's being experienced through the lens of a deeply broken human being and God tells us go to people who are experts 100 I think people turn can give you the confidence and the fortitude to trust that God is with you in your journey and that you're not tarnished in your essence but it's most important for people to understand because to have an extra sheer is amazing but sometimes that's not dealing with addiction and we need to be able to turn and get the right help the right help yes if I'm turning to porn one hour a week and maybe boredom you know what if you can exercise if you can create a good schedule for yourself if it's working it's working that may be eliminated but if there's a deeper addiction it's working it's working great you know go to a Shear at that hour and wonderful and don't go home this way or go don't go to sleep at this out whatever it is you'll figure it out and then it's awesome but if it's not don't delude yourself and don't become hopeless don't become hopeless there are deep-seated beliefs compassion empathy honesty authenticity and uh I just want to say something you know people often say oh it's just the eight Sahara it's just the yatesahara we all have a yetara why are you having a webinar to say it's horror we have an evil inclination haven't you heard that Rabbi why why you never learned the Gomorrah and brothers I believe we have a it's our in fact I also have a yet Sahara and not such a small one but all of our conversations here is are not to eliminate the idea that we have a etah it's to understand the eights are it's to understand if I have an opportunity to tell my eight Sahara stop stop okay I'm stopping I'm stopping I'm stopping make a look higher and you're good but some of us have it's a Horus we have tried to say stop for 20 years didn't listen stop stop stop we rewarded ourselves we screamed at ourselves we punished ourselves we hated ourselves we embarrassed ourselves we mortified ourselves and guess what the it's hard didn't stop you want to understand this guy and you know what you'll find out you may find out that this year Sahara developed not because you're bad but because something happened to you maybe in second grade and you know what you'll discover then that the real eye is not an addict the real eye existed pre-second grade the real eye is actually the most beautiful innocent kind-hearted generous happy child and then wow you could look at the HSR and say so this addiction is not the only identity I know and if I can start experiencing that in my body in my visceral system in a somatic way and retrain my brain just imagine how liberating it is so this is exactly the path to deal with the it's Sahara this is not a path to absolve you from responsibility this helps you take responsibility because suddenly you're not a Slave you're not a monster you're not a barbarian sick meshugana narcissistic self-centered careless husband or wife or father you have a serious problem something happened let's find out let's identify that and let's see the beliefs that were created by that event and then say you know what maybe I could challenge those beliefs if I could see that that event is what created those beliefs it's I don't have to believe this about me I'm not the ugly ugly grotesque person who does not deserve to exist who does not deserve to be loved who is Sinister and evil I'm not wow this is how you heal your age Sahara you transform your Yates are or at least at least you maybe not be able to transform it but at least you can quarantine it it doesn't take over your whole life it's not the only me do you know how liberating that becomes this is the path to morality this is the path to yiddishkai this is the path to yirushimaim you can actually say I could be in a relationship with God because I am not a slave to the prostitutes I am not a slave to the gambling I'm not a slave to the alcohol not a slave to pornography one of those you mentioned 100 one of those words I have here just as reminders right the things that I wanted to mention as um as uh as it relates to the solution for addiction I can say some of those words and commitment honesty she mentioned work gentleness humility service and spirituality so I think we addressed the first ones but spirituality you had mentioned that this is the pathway to Hashem in some cases it's literally the only way and I want to say this to the rabbis who are listening and some of them who question why are we doing this why are we talking about these subjects say Russian horror it's knees why are we bringing these topics out to this to service maybe we're invite we're introducing it to other people I don't know who's meeting uh I don't know what people are seeing on YouTube that's you know that's uh better than this you know I mean it's like it's YouTube we're talking about we're advertising most of these on Instagram I mean it's not exactly like we're putting these in uh and flyers and Haider you know breaking into mayor sharim to to get people to listen into this like you're talking about people there's a reason why there's there's a reason why we're we're doing it I get it again and in my own case having gone through the Yeshiva system and everything else right so seeing seeing that way of pushing everything to the side and the only person I heard talk about porn or not porn even masturbation when I was a teenager was you that was the only one I heard I got my sex education mostly from pornography and then the students um this student the the students around what they knew right all the ignorance they had and then we can share ignorance together but you had come to my achieve when I was in Montreal and spoke and it was so refreshing for myself and for others there that here's someone talking about what we're actually struggling with so you're learning every single day you're learning the tire you're learning this but my day-to-day struggle that I'm going at night going to sleep at night feeling terrible about no one has spoken about and then here came my way to uh Montreal and mentioned that those terms it wasn't it wasn't as clear as we're doing here in this webinar but it's also different today a different time and I'm sure you have a different understanding of the size and scope of the problem but it was something it was there like hey this is a this is a problem that exists but as part of the solution what I needed to get to myself is a relationship with God 12 steps they said we need to believe in a higher power this is what it is and I found that if anything more difficult more difficult to cultivate a relationship with God in the beginning stages because of my upbringing that there was some sort of religious trauma religious abuse associated with it when I saw the word God I shuddered I don't want anything to do with this I already had all of these messaging so some rabbis had living messages we have to be careful is that people are saying it as you said in last webinar as the word of God not of the word of this this Rabbi as the word of God and then there's then later on when the solution that is needed is a relationship with God they say I've tried this I know God that's why I always remind myself and uh I learned this in Yeshiva actually we were woken up and we're in uh in in Mexico for Yeshiva with nine Wagner someone used to wake us up in the morning and say time is good right it's a taste and you'll see that God is good so I always tell people I say in recovery all the time are people who are starting to say I understand you know everything about Hashem you know all the songs and you've learned everything this God that you think exists or doesn't exist or have a problem with understands him okay he said timer tasting you will see that God is good whatever this thing you're tasting is it good if it's not it's not God keep searching okay so that for me was something I said okay I'll keep going I'll keep going it's not it's not there yet I'm going to taste some deliciousness some beautiful experience and this I haven't tasted yet so keep an open mind so for some of the rabbis who are saying like you know maybe some of these things shouldn't be said and they're probably talking more to you than to me but maybe some of these writers are saying it understand that some of that messaging is what needs to be undone for someone to eventually relate to Hashem in order to heal because relating to Hashem is not an unnecessary component to Healing it's not like okay once you finally re you know figure your porn addiction out through your alcohol addiction or something else then good you'll come back to show no this is so essential so essential to our healing is that we're given this is a relationship with a higher power with God personal relationship I should just say that most rabbis today that I'm in contact with are at most are very supportive of these types of conversations because everybody has come around to see the profound damages to families and to individuals when people don't have a place to address this and when Judaism is not accommodating the authentic struggles that we're dealing with you know I'm putting on fill in every day I'm keeping Shabbos I'm eating mats on Payson I'm learning but the true fabric of what's of My reality what's happening inside of me if Torah is not addressing this so what people do is you know either they they create a a rupture between their religious self and their so to speak Emotional Self and their religion becomes dead or numb right or really they become very disillusioned and cynical and very negative or they force themselves not to feel and become very cloistered and inauthentic and all of these can be catastrophic or what often happens is they're projected as anger and judgmentalism and vindictiveness and really you know Movado the reality of Toyota has to be able to address every aspect of the human condition and of society especially in today's generation things are moving so so so fast you know if our Judaism remains stuck in a narrow little corner where anybody who who's dealing with something you know they they can't they can't find the conversation there I think we are depriving our people from from the infinite richness that they're that's been my experience especially over the last it's very very important you know I'll tell you something also you know Judaism has parts that for many generations we were told this is only for the mystics for the sadikkim for the sages you know when you're 40 you'll learn it when you're 60 if you finish Charles you know if you're a brilliant mind if you're a great Sadiq okay khabar doesn't have this struggle but there are many circles you know you just keep you're just a good Yeshiva boy you have been tell you to learn good morning learn a little Miss Alicia shout and whatever which is beautiful and amazing but I feel in today's generation the challenges and the opportunities are so expansive and so deep you're talking about healing models he's talking about psychedelics you talk about trauma you talk about meditation and all the experiences that people are exposed to and everything that's happening you know LGBT challenges transgender transgender challenges we need to up our truityism we need to find the infinite depth in Judaism and make it accessible to the masses we really need to make it accessible to mass and even people who have you know nibbled before and touched on on what you would call Kabbalah the soul of Terror that deals with spirituality and Transcendence and the Oneness of the universe many Jews ran to Buddhism to be able to experience Oneness and meditation not knowing that mystical that core of Judaism is is all about Oneness and all about finding Oneness but today we really we we this is I would say one of the Urgent calls of the hour to be able to revisit our deepest parts of Judaism the core of Judaism and make it accessible and show people how the message we received at Sinai can truly can truly accommodate not only accommodating rich and invigorate and Elevate Our Lives to the true true light that our lives we could we can become true embodiments of Divine Light in this world within our struggles and within our issues so it's a very very unique times in that sense very promising but also you know I think there's a great great obligation on all of us someone shared with me recently you can't dumb it down anymore don't give your children dumb down Julius they're too smart they're too deep and they're going to hear too many things you know if a person is experiencing plant medicine or a person is going has gone to 12 is going to 12 steps or person is in therapy for many years or you're into somatic or or breathing or you're struggling with with sexual issues you know these are very very heavy realities and awareness that people are coming to if all Judaism can tell you is stop this is evil this is good you know just be like your older brother and then stop disturbing us we lose most of our people and we lose the best and the brightest and the deepest and the most sensitive and the most sophisticated and the most spiritual and the most and and those who have who have the deepest pain but it doesn't have to be that way because tire is really the blueprint for Humanity but we have to for this open ourselves up to the full truth of Terror and the full truth of Terror is not just technical red lights and green lights that's important that's critical it's the essence of Allah but Toyota is a holistic Universal infinite approach to literally every aspect of the universe and every aspect of the miracle of of The Human Experience every one of my 70 trillion cells can be can and needs to be addressed by the full Majesty are you saying that are you saying how are you how can you as a rabbi other rabbis not be teaching Torah in a way that relates to the depth of the human pain which means we need the depth of the Torah experience like the the depth of Torah to meet us there as well yes exactly so if people were not dealing with pain or not dealing with trauma or not exposed to all of this and there are such people you know let's call it you know more sheltered more structured fine with the system doing well happy wonderful amazing but but listen I'm not exaggerating and you know this to be true I know this about you I get literally approximately 200 between 2 and 300 letters a day not a week not a month a day sometimes a little less sometimes a little more and these are from men and women and teenagers from London to Paris from Melbourne to South Africa from Crown Heights to Lakewood for my own little neighborhood here in Rockland County to benebra can curious safer and Jerusalem and everyone and Los Angeles and Brazil of of teenagers and women and men who are all dealing with stuff whether it's theological emotional psychological spiritual I can't just tell them all you know you're not learning enough you're not religious enough you're now in nutritious enough go say to heal them or just tell you it's hard to stop and they're they're coming to me many of them have gone to therapists so they go to therapy because they're they're Jewish and they want the relationship with Judaism what does Judaism have to say to me when I became aware of something maybe that happened to me terribly sexually or emotionally have to say to me if the only thing Judaism says is respect your father and mother even if you grow up in the most dysfunctional family and they abused you I can't have a part of that Judaism if all the Judaism tells me is that this is the way that God wants and every other way is evil and therefore I'm evil and Sinister you cut me off people need to be able to feel a Yiddish guide that really really is so comprehensive and thorough that it's the blueprint of the universe so if there's a development in plant medicine if there is a development in any healing model if there's a development in science in cosmology in physics and psychology and biology and realize that these developments are happening in a pace that the world in the next 50 years is going to change more than it changed in 5 000 years it already changed in the last hundred years more than it changed in five thousand years more in the last ten than probably in the last one if we believe what the Madrid says nazare says that God used the Toyota as a blueprint to construct the universe and that includes construct all the plans to construct the animal kingdom to construct every frog every reptile every fish every mammal every bird every Bush every shrub and every biological system and the blueprint of that is Taira where does Tyler address all of this and for this we must we must excavate What's called panimia satara the full infinite core of Torah that for Generations we were told is is not for us but this is a generation Rashi says that mashiach is going to reveal the deepest secrets of title the beginning of the song of song of the rambam says that at the time of the goal of the whole world will be occupied with Divine awareness because all physical Comforts will be there the number one understood about artificial intelligence and he knew that in a few years 99 of Labor won't be needed anyway so what is everybody going to do all day see the rambam says everyone will be occupied with Divine awareness because the the Qantas with infinity is is an infinite occupation so to speak and I think the development of history is bringing us it's almost forcing us into this era you know what is God what is Toyota what is what is Mitzvahs it encompasses every aspect of relationships of of of identity of self-actualization of spiritual growth of authenticity and if Judaism is demanding from any of us to close ourselves off to experience to self-awareness to self-compassion and to self-actualization in the deepest sense we are selling a Judaism that is amputated that is distorted that is that is um um you know the uh the song we used to sing and she was Emma Sai kasimar so they sing it at all the way when are you going to come and he said wrote a letter he wrote a letter to his brother-in-law it's an unbelievable letter and he says Rosh Hashanah 1746 he had aliasama now nobody ever knew what aliasana means today we understand it a little bit means you have an experience of your soul not stuck in the physical embodiment so it's almost like your soul has a vision of of of of a pure reality like it was pre-birth knew how to go to those places internally organically was incredible knew and he writes to his brother-in-law I had an experience and my soul most of us like these words were so just I'm just just an example like aliasama right most people just looked at it okay I'll believe the boss I believe but you know it's I can even talk about it I can relate to it my soul doesn't go up my my soul I go to sleep maybe but that's it but today we all know that you know these experiences are things that are breath workers people are experiencing something that definitely feels like it resembles that the the real Challenge and this is what the balshevitov taught and this is our real challenge is integration because the real challenge of Judy is what we're going to do in our third webinar we're going to be dealing with the real challenge is to make it part of who I am right and and this was one of the most profound contributions of Hasidic spirituality and Kabbalah was the integration of these truths which today we have the words and the modalities to help us really integrate it that it becomes part of our internal Consciousness which is incredible is that the song the way it was the way like the few words it captured was when is mashiach Gonna Come when your teachings will be spread forth and it's like okay we got to go out and spread the teachings what does it mean I don't know print it we'll publish it a Tanya in a new community in Kenya which never had a Tanya that's what it means and then when I saw the whole thing I think was Project hasidis like put a video out of the whole letter I was like hold on there's a different there's a different aspect to the story here so now it's incredible about the most summative rights I went into the Chamber of mashiach and I asked them when will when Amos when are you going to come which basically means when will the World finally heal and he said so when your Wellsprings will spread out and disseminate outside to the furthest corners of the universe and the river used to say that sometimes the deepest is in in yourself to those parts of me that are outside the dirty Parts the traumatized Parts the broken parts those parts that make me feel like an alien I'm a foreigner I don't give a hoot about any of this and he says when you're light when your teachings will be able to be brought into this place will come why why because that is mashiach it's not two separate things it's not like oh you spread the most symptoms of teaching will snap the fingers and the donkey will emerge with Messiah that's a little bit immature what he was saying is that is Redemptive consciousness mashiach has a state of consciousness the prophet ishaiah says the world will be filled with Divine awareness like water covers the sea there'll be Oneness in humanity there'll be Harmony within ourselves we'll be able to experience our Oneness with each other because we're one with the Divine we'll be able to look at the world from a microscopic spiritual perspective and we'll see that the world is divine energy that Oneness is our organic state it was only through a monstrous reductionism which Kabbalah calls dim sum that we we experience the trauma of ego where I'm protecting myself and you're protecting yourself and you all know there's moments when that ego dissolves so what he was telling about Hashem is when this Consciousness when these teachings pervade the universe in an integrated way which means it's not only when I go on some trip but it becomes integrated that is what would that is what Redemption looks like this is Ellie our historic opportunity now you know people are discussing the conflict between Judaism and healing is taking away from religion this isn't missing the point no all of the healing opportunities is to be able to help us get to the core of Judaism and and bring that to the world and the whole world will heal that's what the Jewish people were chosen for don't don't be afraid this is it this is this is our greatest opportunity you don't know what Judaism is that's what he was telling them you have the Wellsprings because revealed this type of Consciousness the whole Judaism by the mashemtaf was really an opportunity of celebration of Oneness the greatest Miracle of the balshamtov was that his teachings are trauma free and I'll tell you something I grew up I grew up at the feet of excuse me the rabbit the rabbit lived through the trauma of our parents and grandparents right Stalin and Hitler he lost much of his family and I would say one of the greatest miracles of the lab was that whenever I heard him speak I did not hear trauma I did not hear trauma I don't know how that happened because she had a hard life and he you know there was there was a Gullah energy in his words it was like from a place that is beyond trauma faith in humanity and he wasn't naive I've seen the rebel many years he was not a naive man he was not naive you couldn't fool him he knew very well corruption he would talk about it he knew very well about cynicism and disappointment but he just he his soul like the balsamta was rooted in a place that was really trauma free and growing up I could cry when I talk about this because I had some difficult experiences as a child but for me till today that's like an anchor of safety an anchor of safety where I feel innocence and Purity and love and it was it's it's a it's amazing because there were people that sat in 770 by the rebels fabrangians and they were you know they were some of them did really bad things yeah 100 like in every community so so but to be able to be able to have that so those are the Wellsprings that I think are are you know really it's it's and I should just say not everybody who claims to learn hasidis is in touch with these Wellsprings because I'm not talking about mathematical spiritual gymnastic equations of spheroids and worlds and lights I'm not talking about that that's all good I'm talking about the the visceral experience of infinite Consciousness I recall that people will understand I think or letters and as a way to access Direct yeah they'll make they'll make you Hood them like you they're going to unify the world just like you do the suggestion of directing the world like a direct experience of meaning this idea if I think listen you know I don't think this was everyone will be exactly the balcony of there are uniques we spoke last week there are souls that are just have certain gifts obviously just like people have different talents there are souls that have different gifts but something something of this relative to who I am to each and every one of us is going to become even to be able to understand the terminology is important I want to say one one more thing before we get to um homosexuality that's part of the conversation is that you know through my journey of reconnecting to Judaism right which today is a strong connection it's a connection based on uh um free choice full choice I wouldn't always have Choice was guilt to ashamed It Was Fear there was this it's not based on anything no guilt no fear based on food it's 100 choice I love this I do this I'm you know I'm uh I'm proud I consider myself a messenger of the uh just like just like others and I reconnected to that through my process but there were Forks in the road that could have gone the other way so 100 forks in the road and I say this story often and I want to repeat it I want to repeat it here as well is that one of my sponsors my early sponsors was a Christian Monk and the reason it was recommended to speak to him was because it was a Jewish fellow who I was who was my my sponsor who didn't quite have the spiritual sensitivities that I felt I needed for my healing he kind of said like hey higher power God okay your group will be the higher power he was more of an atheist Jew and he found that and he found healing in that way through that I needed something different I needed spirituality so a friend of mine and the program who I was you know kind of at the same time you know you have different people in these groups you have people who kind of came in together and then you have the old-timers so I was talking to him and sharing with him this about you know some of the difficulties and challenges I was having in the program and he said I think you should talk to my sponsor he's a very spiritual guy and I think he'll connect with him so I speak to this guy and he was in fact had a real depth of spirituality where did he get it he was a Christian Monk and he had his issues and he had his addictions and a full-scale Christian Christian Monk and with this individual he took him to church and they would pray together and they had all those things and for whatever reason he told me and I was open I was open like a humble desperate and tell me where I need to go he said to me Ellie you will know your healing has taken root a moment you'll know your healing is taken root when you reconnect to Judaism and the reason I get emotional when I share that is because heady invited me to a church I would have went there and and that's the risk that people are playing with that's a risk is that when people don't get it within the Yeshiva system when T people don't get it from voices like yours and the others is that they step out because they still need it that's a that's a need that's a need for certain people and when they step out that can go in any direction because they're open and in that space I knew what I needed and if the same is true with a lot of other modalities people have opinions on 12 steps people have opinions on plant medicines your opinion does not matter people who are going to go for healing are going to go for healing if you tell a person who's suffering from anxiety that it's not okay to do plant medicines because you have an opinion that is Zara they're going to go anyway they're going because they need the healing so do and the rabbit talks about this in a secret about Transcendental Meditation open your own centers I think all of the chauffeur was a travesty of all travesties I don't know what happened there I don't know what it was but it was shut down without offering an alternative obviously there were people there who were desperate desperate for some sense of Peace of inner peace of freedom from the traumas and struggles that were going they were going through and they find up home and they find a place and rabbis go and shut down the place don't shut down the place without opening another Center that gives just as much of the solution you want to do it in a Kosher Way do it in a kosher way but what you're saying Robert Jacobson is so important is that Judaism has to meet people at these places and has to be able to offer these solutions to these people and if there are problems and I've been part of Plant medicine ceremonies that are problematic and we'll talk about it then I felt like there were things that right didn't wasn't for a nice Jewish boy but I wasn't a nice Jewish boy anymore I also had all of this trauma and all these experiences so great letters of condemnation against this or opinions about this are not going to help anyone do it set it up in a way that's completely kosher and invite everyone there because people are gonna go people need their healing the same way I needed it I I and I needed I just want to get to the I want to get to the belief behind I want to get to the belief behind it okay and this is where we need so much humility many rabbis parents teachers mentors they mean well if you do not understand the suffering that somebody is going through be curious educate yourself frankly there are people they communicate with me every day they mean well they're trying to serve God they do not understand what it means that a person is broken at his core they just don't and you know what good for them thank God they don't you you have to understand the levels and magnitudes of suffering that people are going through people who wake up every day with incessant anxiety as we heard from Ellie before people who walk into a wedding and they have a panic attack because of social anxiety people who cannot connect emotionally with their spouse or children people who cannot perform sexually they can't have understand the suffering be empathetic be curious you can't just tell them stop stop stop stop you can't you just can't you're not talking to them you're not addressing them they're going to look at you and say okay there's nothing that Toyota has to offer to me so be very very very humble and don't try don't try to impose your comfort zones on Judaism and say because this is my comfort zone so this is all that God has to offer maybe you have questions legitimate but be humble understand and be sensitive to struggle and if you're not be humble about that as well say you know what thank God it's like it's like people you know a lot of people today have children who who are leaving Judaism and they go for advice and they always tell the parents get advice only from people who have had children of Love Judaism or they have experience with hundreds or thousands of teenagers who have left Judaism don't get advice from a father or a mother who don't understand what you're going through and they'll just say tell him he has to put on a yamaka tell you she has to take off the the the talent wow brilliant tell her as though she hasn't been in this house for 17 years and she doesn't hasn't her ten thousand times the word sneas tell her tell her tell her it's like telling you it's Sahara stop stop it's it's they mean well but you no that's why I was so clueless if it wasn't a um if it wasn't an invasion of privacy I would say like stand read my phone read my emails read my messages sit in on my conversations and you see what people are experiencing the people I say I speak to yeah yeah and you you need to be humble and if you don't understand find out ask but don't these are very sensitive things you know there's people who commit suicide on a daily basis there are people who are overdosing there are people who are getting divorced and families are becoming broken because there was nobody to help them I'll tell you a story so so realize we're not just talking about a theoretical question about an ax Goring a cow and we're not sure if the cow gave birth before the Goring or after the Goring and you're responsible for this or not for this we're talking about literally issues that affect people's lives and the opposite of Life 100 but for Generations so before you impose your very holy agenda on Judaism and on everybody else you may be right but be curious be empathetic and don't believe that everyone who says the word trauma is trying to run away from responsibility that is a very very very unfair accusation you're talking about people who have been trying their best to live good lives for 20 30 40 years and they try to work with the ASR and scream at the at Sahara nothing helped a guy who comes in and says you know he's having enough fear with his secretary for years and he's trying to stop and he's crying and he's crying to his therapist help me stop help me stop I don't know what to do help me help me he went to the Christ silly went to me run he went to charister he went to uman he went everywhere but he's having he he can't help himself his sexuality is is Meshuggah it's chaotic what are you going to say right stop you're evil and if you could and if you could show him if you could show him that in second grade maybe you can help him find that in second grade I'm not telling you a story I'm not telling you theories this kid started to be molested by people in his family from five till nine from five to nine suddenly you know what you do for this man suddenly he realizes and he discovers that he's actually not a monster it's actually something that happened to him and if it's something that happened to him then maybe he could find the me that existed before it happened to him which is still there because your power is always present even if it's an exile and for the first time in his life he could talk to his yet Sara and he could tell his head Sara I know you developed when I was six years old when I was five years old but you know what I'm a big boy now and I have value and I'm not a shmatter and suddenly he can fight his Atara don't don't be you know you're talking about people's real real lives I've seen it there was someone who called me a rabbi okay and you know he was looked up to and everything else how did he call me he went to his mashpia so she is struggling sexually he was cheating on his wife he wasn't able to physically have sex with his wife and he had a relationship with someone else the rabbi said listen I don't know much about this I know Ellie a little bit then he gave my he gave my number so I spoke to him and as I was speaking to him the guy had no hope zero hope zero hope he wasn't even asking me for help to stop he was asking me for help to stop obsessing he's like I can't stop I can't like this is my life at this point that I said you don't say you're putting your family at risk of putting your community at risk putting yourself at risk like there's a lot not writing on this he couldn't understand me at all nothing it was like impenetrable he just why because he was hopeless he didn't see another way out he had tried for so many years a certain way he's like this is working for me the only thing is the obsession I cannot stop thinking about this woman I'm having an affair with I want to be able to give my classes and be with my kids without thinking I said okay unfortunately I don't know a way to to do that but when I saw that I wasn't able to get through and there was such so much at stake I said listen I reckon I know a guy in Costa Rica I recommend you fly down there yeah for a plant medicine experience like ASAP right the risks are High I mean he's playing a very Community his family his health is like pretty serious stuff he called the rabbi back and he told his his must be as Rabbi and he said I'm recommend that I recommended that he go down to Costa Rica for for this uh experience so fortunately like I said listen I don't know anything about it but I'll call Ali so I had a conversation with him and he said do you think it can help him he's like I don't understand this it's not something that I ever think about but I recommended that he speak to you you're telling me this can help him I said I'm not guaranteeing anything but the guy's mind is not open he it's not open and there's a chance that this will open his mind so fortunately he gave this Rob I gave him the okay he went he had an experience and what came up in his experiences how many times he was sexually abused as a child and he had never dealt with it so he's sitting with an infestation inside him multiple times of sexual abuse had never had never addressed it had no capacity to address it then fortunately from this experience it showed him one plus one equals two that the experiences he went through as a child which he worked so hard to suppress is creating the issues he's having today what does this mean it means the only way for this guy to stop these behaviors like it's similar to what you're saying I'm just adding to it with an example there is no learning that's going to get this guy to to remove his obsession he was sexually abused and has massive issues he cannot physically have sex with his wife one of those reasons I don't know if you've heard of this uh term I think it's called the Madonna complex if you've heard of this it's a complex where people view women as one or the other like either as a mother or a prostitute meaning they can't imagine that um a decent um woman will have sex so any woman who's available for sex is not decent and anyone who's decent is not available for for sex and it makes sense how this conflict can be created because if someone is introduced to sex at a very young age in a very shameful way so they so the association in the mind is shame and sex sex is a shameful practice but the body has needs so he goes and finds it in a way that can't be his wife but he loved his wife he cared about his wife and it was precisely because of that that he couldn't be intimate with her and he needed someone who he looked down on in some way but that's where he at his knees but then he was caught in this Obsession to such an extent I'm not saying this person had that complex but I'll give you an example of it it's there is no way to solve this without going deep looking at those experiences and removing the trauma wow can we talk about homosexuality wow you know Ellie I have an idea I think and I want to I think if we should do now because 10 o'clock have another maybe we could do now questions for a half an hour and in our we have a webinar in two weeks we could do so let me get to the first question it's about homosexualities let's let's we'll address the question it's the first question okay okay so I think this is related to some of the wording which we used last time it says why is homosexuality something that we need healing from it seems that you're trying to address the people whom in their lives grapple with their attraction to the opposite sex but my question is why why is homosexuality looked at as a condition that requires healing your thoughts would be greatly appreciated okay yeah I think it's appropriate for you to answer because I I think they're they're touching on Words that they felt you used in the first um discussion I can answer it if you want me to but I think they were touching on words that you used so maybe it's a good idea to okay so it's first of all thank you for the question and for the candidness of the question and I don't want to be here abstract and cerebral I want to be very very practical the main function of our webinar here is people who are struggling with it in their mind they're struggling with it in other words if somebody decided that he is homosexual and he's fully fully content with it and he's fully satisfied with it that's a discussion it's a fair discussion should he be challenged why should he be challenged why does the title prohibit it it's a very fair question a legitimate question and it should be discussed but I feel that the main function of our webinar here is people who do feel that it's a struggle for them they would rather have not been dealing with it maybe they want to get married maybe they are already in a marriage maybe even if they don't want to get married they're very very committed to Tyrant to Judaism and they feel that this is something so negative that they're carrying and that's the people we're trying to address so these are people who feel that something is so so challenging in their lives and they want to have some support yeah what I was going to say is that who is reaching out to you about this who's reaching out to me about this like where does my information around homosexuality come from and where does yours so my guess is my assumption is that people who are reaching out to you are reaching out towards trying to figure out how to resolve their Orthodoxy with their either homosexual experience or their homosexuality whatever that is it's those two things why would they call you otherwise right they're calling a rabbi for his opinion how to resolve this this conflict so that's where your experience comes from in my case who are the people that I talk to about these subjects are mostly people who are recovering from addiction and the addiction had an element of homosexuality attached to it and oftentimes not all the case one of one of my sponsors I've mentioned my sponsor one of my sponsors is gay I've had sponsors who are gay and live that lifestyle not Jewish and live that lifestyle and you know there's there's nothing for me to comment for them I'm talking to people who had um who have homosexual attraction or have had homosexual experiences and that is tied up to their addiction and oftentimes their specific shame attached to that so that's where I'm coming from so if there's a language that sounds like that who am I talking to I'm talking to the people that I see suffering and the way I've met them and then I want to say to them for example someone's struggling with porn I spoke to someone not long ago struggling with porn and I S he's like I need to speak to a certified sex addiction therapist I said a porn addict I I don't know a certified sex addiction therapist that I can recommend why not go to a 12-step meeting because the kind of porn I'm watching the kind of porn I'm watching I said what is it is it gay porn is it transsexual porn like what is the issue that you're having such a hard time with accepting about yourself so he said in fact the transsexual porn I said brother I've been there too I've been there too it's okay and so I have many people you want to sit there and figure out exactly what the attraction means from now until the end of time busy yourself I don't know what to say you want to get help go to 12 steps look at the size of these categories online most right look at these sizes there are many many people watching these things to figure out exactly what it means we can spend Freudian psychology right we'll sit on couches and dissect us till the end of time you want to get help in healing let's go I know a place I know a place we can do it not to not to denigrate any of the work that certified sex addiction therapists said but here I had a recommendation and I saw what was the struggle a specific shame around this attraction a specific shame around this who am I talking to someone who's struggling in that way someone who's wondering because they had an experience in Yeshiva with another boy and here they are married with five kids and am I really gay what am I really gay or what is this thing what does it mean am I really but there's so many of these ideas are introduced into the language and into the way we talk about these things that if someone did something or someone had a thought then it is their identity all the way until from now until the end of time when in reality sex sexuality is dynamic it changes it's I'm not saying it changes from orientation to orientation but there's different people in different times and different things and you know relax relax we don't need so much shame attached to these subjects let's heal let's all heal together and that's who I'm speaking to right so I think the same thing my language is always going to convey the type of people that I spoke to about these subjects just like your language is always going to convey the type of people you've um spoken to I am not a rabbi I'm not talking from Allah I'm not a scientist you're not a scientist you're not talking we haven't done all evaluations who is and who isn't we're talking from the people who've reached out to us no and and we all need a lot of humility and when we talk about this it's very important humility no judgment no vindictiveness you know you never judge a person if you're not sitting in their space if you're not experiencing what they're experience there's a lot of empathy around this yes as somebody who's a Jew and adherent to Judaism the Torah prohibits homosexual intercourse that's a Prohibition but to see the struggle as evil and to stigmatize people who are dealing with struggles they didn't even choose they didn't even choose is equally abhorrent yes I believe that the creator of the world as a blueprint to life believes that there's certain types of relationships that are not good for you and not only in the next world but also in this world but so much compassion and empathy is needed here and it's completely not a contradiction and we need a lot of humility somebody asks here how can God say homosexuality is not allowed if people are born this way it's not fear you know that's a very very heavy statement you just said people are born this way it's very important to know that a lot of the scientific research about homosexuality has been stifled because politics has become very very major factor when it comes to the LGBT issue it's just very important to understand this is the least studied issue in science because of the tremendous pressure from so many different angles and perspective so we all need a little humility before making any blanket statement I believe I have asked some I went to a few scientists because I don't like to come in more emerge as ignorant and I am ignorant in many areas has there been conclusive scientific evidence that a person has absolutely born that way and it's just not true there's so much ambiguity there's so much sensitivity here we may be born with certain dispositions with certain sensitivities and then with other factors happening including sometimes very traumatic experiences or not traumatic experiences can bring it out can actualize it so it's just it's such a subtle subtle subtle thing and it's important to be able to go on a journey and ask myself what is going on inside of me what happened to me because then you may discover a lot of very interesting things I think that the suggestion which a lot of people are resistant to which I understand is that um that homosexuality came about because of abuse or something like that who knows who knows any of these stuff and maybe some people are born that way who understands that in certain things we can have a question mark someone once showed me I forget we're at a barber now something like that which uh used in Hebrew terminology that even if someone had this for even if even if they had this from when they were born I can try to find it meaning let's say there is the possibility that someone is Born This Way okay I mean that doesn't change being able to have a conversation around uh around a certain topic I know that it was like a rabbit it was a rabbinical question I'm more addressing like this this link but how do I know do I know if my abuse turned into my important addiction I don't know I can tell you for myself my own experience and everyone can do with this what they want I was abused by an older man and I was eight years old and this guy was 15. so as a 15 year old um be I'll be some somewhat graphic it was the very first time I felt a um a uh a penis of an adult right apologies for being graphic but it is what it was and after that there was this Intrigue around that and I connected to that experience right that experience tied to that to that ex to that I never felt Emotional Love towards a man I never had that I never felt the um like the the Romantic feeling towards women but that ex that was a link that I made direct that was a link that I made directly but obviously from that jump we can't say someone else who feels the emotional pull towards women and many people I've spoken to by the way say emotionally they're drawn towards women physically they're also drawn towards men or only drawn towards men or something like that right there are all sorts of Dynamics there at play we don't know what's abuse and not abuse but these always and never I think are very destructive for these conversation because we don't know we don't know what I do know and who are we talking to is people who are struggling with this and just say it's okay brother come home come home it's okay whatever it is relax the shame you're not alone there's seven billion people but there's not seven billion problems there's anything you're dealing with there are hundreds of millions of people dealing with the same thing you're in good company as soon as you find the right person to ask for help and they understand you you will have a connection that's much deeper than the shame you feel this connection from the shame you feel come home everyone is welcome everyone is everyone can heal there's there's there's space there's there's space for everybody there isn't these these things that we have to put in boxes that no one can talk about and no one can say anything thank you next question regarding the masturbation how can I get away from it the media is all filled with provocative images how in the world am I supposed to get away with from it I don't know what to say if you're if that's what you're experiencing in the media then get away from from the media I can say for myself my own experience at the same time I was getting sober and the Google search bar was very very triggering for me just that seeing the Google search bar was triggering and it happened when I say triggering what happened sometimes was that just I saw the Google search bar and it and a search went in that right maybe the name of someone or something else right the name of an actress or something like that and the search went in that would often populate pornographic images so I had to lock down my point my work computer so Google Images wouldn't be accessible to me and if I was working on a power PowerPoint presentation for work and there were times where I wasn't I wasn't public about the fact that I had a porn addiction for those five or six years I wasn't I'd go to someone in my office hey can you snip a picture of this and this and email it to me I'm having trouble on uh with my computer it's not working and can you do this for me so that's what I needed to do and I didn't have a phone and I didn't have an iPhone for a while and when I did it had all sorts of locks on it sometimes we need to do that in order to distance ourselves today fortunately I can work without these restrictions but if someone is finding that experience that the media is full of um these kind of images then they have to change the media for a while they may need to distance themselves foreign excellent somebody asks a question here last week two weeks ago at the webinar I felt something that you said and I got very upset and that is the way you spoke about LG l g b t people you intimated that it's bad it's gross it's problematic you called it a trauma that's a harmful response to LGBT Jewish people who just want love and acceptance they don't want people judging them and their sexuality picked apart why is homosexuality such a taboo we are normal people like everybody else It's upsetting that the religious community is obsessed with it nobody follows all 613 Commandments we're taught to love every do Jew and not to judge anybody but as an LGBT person I have been judged my whole life for it I hear it wow um one thing I would say is I I don't believe we mentioned transgender in the um in the last I don't believe we mentioned that I'm saying transgender so it's not it's not all one and the same thing we spoke specifically about homosexuality we didn't speak about bisexuality so I'm not sure we're Plumping but there definitely seems to be a a trigger there that the person is sensitive to what I understand that and I think that to someone like that I would answer we are your ally in the sense that I I unlikely it's unlikely that I agree on certain things right then I pointed to my out because unlikely that I agree on certain things necessarily but that doesn't mean that there's any less room for an understanding of their lifestyle completely or for understanding of their choices or for acceptance of who they are as a human being and for the recognition that this may not be something that they struggle with but understand this is that and I'll speak a little bit for for Rabbi Jacobson in this case you're coming onto a webinar with a rabbi a rabbi is going to have to like he's not going to bend the Torah in order to make someone feel more comfortable the Torah says what it says about these subjects it has certain opinions about about sexual behaviors but what I often say for myself is how I can there were periods of time where I was less observant or Shabbos and I I never felt like I needed the rabbi I was going to if I went to a home for Shabbos for a meal to tell me it's okay that I'm driving I'm driving on Shabbos I didn't want him to suggest that I'm struggling with Shabbos because I wasn't I had no interest in keeping it at that time in life so I wasn't struggling with it and I I understand I could have been offended if he suggested that but obviously that there was no suggestion there was nothing he could have thought that on a higher Dimension my soul is struggling with Shabbos I imagine that uh any good Rabbi does think that but he never said he never said that and I was fine I was there I didn't ask him to change the laws of the Torah for me and to say no but is it okay that I come on tell me I really want to drive on Shabbos I can't imagine doing it and I didn't feel not accepted just because I chose to drive on Shabbos and I think that we have to be from both sides right as for those who are from is to say okay this is the person's choice and we accept and this love and there's a place for them at the table and for those who are choosing to live that lifestyle it says there's room for from people to be from and obviously they haven't they they have an opinion on certain behaviors but the opinion is not all the way down to your identity and who you are the opinion is the same as it is for Shabbos all Jews should keep Shabbos all Jews should live certain live in a certain way fine it's it's a beautiful it's a beautiful ideal but it's not putting anyone down in any way whatsoever and I don't I would hope that this person can recognize that the gun they're holding is much bigger than the trigger that pressed it nice thank you Ellie for your beautiful words which I concur to I just want to add maybe you know just uh add just one or two details and that is you know I'm sorry if I came across as judgmental in any way and I want to stand corrected I'm not obsessed by it I'm not obsessed with condemning this sin more than any other sin because as I said it's so important for all of us to be very humble to be very loving to be very understanding of people's Journeys and as it says in the ethics of the fathers don't judge another person until you do not reach his space or her space and this was and you will never reach their space and I say that to everybody including myself and anyone dealing with this or any other issue but I do want to say something and please take this with a spirit of of Love of love and not non-judgmentalism and then people who know me know that I'm not a judgmental person and I deal with this all the time in a very very compassionate way please if I believe in Terror if I believe the terror is true you may not which I'm not judging you either but if I believe that terror is authentic I believe that God the creator of the world gave the Jewish people and all of the Nations a blueprint how to live and God says that there's a certain behavior that is not good for you and it's not good for me in this world and in the next World in other words it is poisonous for me and for you just like he would tell me about stealing or about adultery or about murder or about violating Shabbos or about eating on Yom Kippur right and I see somebody doing something poisonous I'm not going to be kind to them if I say oh I don't judge Behavior if you want to eat poison eat poison that's cruel that's cruel if I care for you and I love you I'm going to tell you that this is not good for you I'm not judging you and I'm not feeling Superior to you trust me I'm not feeling Superior to you but I'm going to tell a Jew eating onion Kipper is not a good thing it's not a good thing I'm not talking about if you need it for for health reasons and committing adultery is not a good thing and engaging in another act that may be immoral according to Tara is not a good thing and I'm gonna say it's not a good thing and it doesn't mean you're evil you're not evil and the struggle I will never judge ever judge ever never judge or the non-struggle I'm not being kind if I do even the non-struggle you won't judge let's say so I'm not struggling or they're not struggle I'm not I'm not judging the non-struggle I'm not they're not struggle but I'm I'm not being honest and I'm not being kind if I just say you know I think it's perfectly fine and it's as a legitimate relationship as any other relationship I'm being dishonest with you and from from from my belief system I'm also being being unconscious and I think and cruel now what does that mean practically for you if you want to discuss that we can discuss that what are you supposed to do great question but just I want you to understand where I'm coming from and I think this is very important and Ellie with your permission I just want to say that I'm doing a special webinar exclusive on the topic of homosexuality with a few therapists and a few people who are who who are who deal who've dealt with this for many many years who want to share their Journeys and experiences and it's going to be on March 12th four o'clock P.M you have to register and for the information to register you can you can go to the yeshiva.net my website and this webinar on the bottom has the information how to register or you could email us info at the yeshiva.net in order to register to register to the webinar in homosexuality March 12th Sunday 4 o'clock P.M over there it's going to be a full few whatever time it is designated exclusively to this without with people who are been dealing with it for many many years both from a professional perspective and and from a personal perspective but I really I really thank you for what you said and I hope you can understand my words coming from not from a place of negativity at all not willing to be replaceable if somebody comes to my house for Shabbos right every Chabad house is people who drive to the that's what Ellie is saying right they drive to the to the Chabad Rabbi or to the aish rabbi or to the any Rabbi on Shabbos right the rabbi doesn't want him to try Shabbos right but the Rabbit doesn't get up and say get out of my house you're you're you're you're you're a horrible person the rabbi knows if he may have If he if he grew up like this person they may have also been trying on right it's a journey it's a process and we need to be able to educate each other and then in this word of personal responsibility and my personal responsibility I mean is more as a community is that once oftentimes when someone feels so profoundly rejected they're desperate to feel fully accepted so they want to be accepted exactly the way exactly where they are so in many cases I think members of the homosexual Community are saying you've rejected me completely meaning they didn't feel like their behavior wasn't accepted or that it's against the terror but you know so are other things and everyone is welcome here right right be strong and say hey but accept me fully accept me fully accept me fully so exactly it and that's our that's what that's what I think there is some truth to the the question is that the first move is again it's the first the the for the community to be fully accepting of the of of of individuals whatever that struggle is and say there is room for for everyone and then people who are dealing with whatever it is not wanting to keep Shabbos or not wanting to um or not or not wanting to be with someone of the opposite gender then they won't they won't want that they won't need that but I think the next move is actually on the community to be more understanding and more accepting and one of the things that I think will happen possibly from these discussions and others is the number of people who are dealing with this and I'm not talking about the people who are um who've accepted that lifestyle right who've that's that's where they are I'm talking about the number of people who are dealing with homosexual experiences in childhood males and females or as adults or watching gay porn or any of these things the numbers are very high the numbers are not like we're not talking about one or two percent of the community and when it's understood on a larger level just how many people actually have these experiences and have these struggles like for example we're so quick to reject the person who says proudly that they are in fact I'm homosexual but the person who pretends to be from but is sleeping with male prostitutes he's accepted but there are many of those there are many of those and I know that because I know some of them and I I I know I I know I know these experiences so once we understand how prevalent this is we can be more accepting of everyone who's dealing with any of this and dealings not the same as struggling I know just any anyone who has this and say okay right you're accepted you're fully accepted and some of these behaviors of course I mean Judaism has a rule book and the an ideal book right these are the ideals and just to sweat to sway from the ideals then go to any Rabbi and feel accepted why do you need a rabbi who's committed himself to all the ideals to say this ideal is not necessary but the next move is on the community I want to point out one thing you know we mentioned a lot tonight addiction abuse molestation I think in most scenarios Ellie and I used the word he was abused it's just very important to emphasize that we're doing with an equal amount and maybe many more females girls young women who have been abused sexually God forbid psychologically emotionally spiritually physically so it's very very important we use the word he may be as a Freudian slip because we both happen to be men for whatever reason but I just want to just pay tribute to all the women and girls who have been dealing with this and who are heroes Heroes you don't give up and you're searching for healing and and your journey should be successful and we're here to help it any way we can I just want to I just want to mention that I also want to mention about homosexuality and that is over the years I've dealt with I could say hundreds of people who came to me or wrote to me and still write to me constantly I get every week a few emails about this usually sometimes Anonymous sometimes not Anonymous and these are people who are tormented these are people who are tormented and they tried everything they tried they tried and you know people who can't get they don't feel they can get married or they're in a marriage and it's difficult or anywhere in between and it's so so so important number one not to condemn yourself and call yourself an evil monstrous horrific person who God hates and you're gonna burn it you're going to burn in hell because I know your story you have shared it with me and I know that one person not one of you who believe you believe in Torah and you don't want to engage in this Spirit some of you have never engaged in this behavior and I salute you every day for that courage and you know that you didn't choose it you know that you didn't choose it and I I just I just want to say that it is so important in today's world where there is so many so many modalities of self-exploration and self-discovery to be able to open yourself up honestly to everything that is going on inside of you what the results will be exactly sexually in terms of gender I don't know and I'm not a prophet but but I do know that such exploration of self your history your background your childhood may have tremendous tremendous consequences in the area of sexuality I'm not now giving a black and white scientific statement about anybody or everybody but I'm talking from a lot of personal association and experience you may find and discover tremendous gems but it's going to be scary and you have to understand we live in a climate where this is often discouraged and that's a crime it's a crime and the reason it's a crime because just like I cannot make a scientific statement one way nobody should make a scientific statement in the opposite way if somebody feels that they're struggling with homosexuality they say you know what your struggle is that you struggle your struggle is that you struggle just accept yourself your normal normal human being and you were indoctrinated by the religious fundamentalist Christian Orthodox Greeks that's Dogma too that's indoctrination too that's indoctrination too let us explore ourselves and you know what if you find out that at the end of everything you're the same homosexual granted you may also find out a lot of very powerful truths about yourselves on many levels let's be open let's be humble nobody has mastered the full secrets of sexuality I know you uh you have a 10 o'clock this had a couple of things that um none of what you're saying as far as you know my understanding of your opinions and these discussions we had is suggesting in any way something like reparative therapy which some of these therapies have actually hurt people to try to knock it repetitive therapy to try to pack a attraction out of someone you know my my advice to myself and I shared a little bit of my personal experience here there's obviously more but I'm being sensitive to some of the people in my life but not going too far and too many details but my advice and my experience does not compare to other people's experiences one of the things I said to myself I said hey there's so many letters that people use for their sexuality so I said maybe there's a letter that only includes me it's like I'm the only one in the population that has this letter and I accept myself fully whatever this letter is this is only me I don't have to be in anyone else's box not the G not the B not the T not anything else although there were times I thought I belonged in uh in different ones possibly I don't belong in any of them maybe I belong in my own and I first accept myself whatever I find and then I explore if we explore conditionally it's very difficult when I say explore I never explored my sexuality I just accepted it I never I just accepted it and then from there you know for myself heal everything heal everything and see what emerges and for many other people heal everything and see what emerges one other thing because it was a gentleman who called me and he reached out to me several times he said I know you're doing webinar homosexuality and I want my voice to be heard I want you I can't speak not in my situation he's a he's a rebbe he said I want you to share my story so he's has a number of kids he's been with other men he's um he's been with other men he struggled for a long time gay porn and everything else and he said pretty much every single Rabbi he's spoken to every person who went for help did one of two things either they minimized it completely come on it's not a big deal it's not a big deal like this is nothing or they suggested in some way that if he cannot control this in any way and he chooses to go in that direction then he's he's not accepted at all and he said he felt like 18 those two was just it was horrible and he says to minimize it it's he said I've been trying it for years he said I've been trying to minimize this for years it's not a big deal it's not this it's not me stop exactly that's the same thing it's that yelling at something to stop it's not going to stop and then the suggestion that who knows he he didn't want to and he had children you know since losing his family but there was a part of him that we felt that he felt like and anyone people have like a sexualness iron if it's unmet that it's more than sexual sometimes it's romantic and it's deep and for it to be completely unmet is very difficult and if this person chooses to go in that direction to say he's written off completely it's very difficult so he wanted his voice to be heard he's a from person he's a teacher he's doing everything he could he said we don't have to be afraid we don't have to write up we don't write off why don't we write off secular Jews today the answer is why should we every Jew is is divine and holy and every Mitzvah matters and every Mitzvah counts and you never out and even if you actually wanna even if you feel this person is making a genuine mistake in their actual relationships and you want to actually help them you can't help anybody today by by by throwing them out they don't say oh I'm so sorry build a relationship have a have a conversation on the contrary empathy is the path to all transformation if if if that's really even your objective you want to really help the person right right if you don't want to help a person then why are you talking to him and if you want to help the person even closer if you really believe you really believe that this person chose the wrong path right so become closer what does every every cure of Rabbi habachlis and the world do for the Jews not eating culture I'm never talking to him again throw them out of the flowers you become close understanding more show them what kashras is show them what chapters be a living example of love so and the baby now this is very sensitive this is very deep but connection not no alienation Judaism doesn't have to be afraid of these things we need more confidence if God if you have to protect God from any criticism the truth doesn't need our defense the truth doesn't you know what I mean if tide is real if God knew what he was talking about if he built if he built this universe if he knew about sex he created sex and he knew what he's talking about have confidence you could listen to questions you can even be challenged you don't have to be apologetic truth is truth is truth and I have seen many many people and again this is not a scientific statement I've seen many people who have followed this advice and have explored their deepest deepest self and they have seen tremendous tremendous developments and Evolutions in their sexual consciousness am I saying am I suggesting reparative therapy no am I suggesting there can be a person who will completely liberate himself from any homosexual tendency no and I don't think that's even necessary we don't liberate ourselves from sexual feelings about other women and we're very happily married we're very happily married so there's people they may struggle with something still but they could be very happily married it's so important though not to not to you know we dig in our our heels and our claws into certain positions which are often very political and very very black and white and and very judgmental and we all lose from it we all lose from it I never heard anybody soon I never heard any scientists or politicians suggest that if somebody was raped 10 years by his father or brother or uncle or babysitter or teacher or counselor he should give up on the ability of having a healthy marriage nobody does that even though we know that his marriage is going to be destroyed but we say there's help there's healing try try this try this try this try this try this even though we know how disastrous it is so for somebody who believes in Toyota and believes that a homosexual relationship is forbidden but you're struggling with it and for you it is a struggle suddenly here there's nothing to do whatsoever nothing neuroplasticity out the window expansive Consciousness out the window exploring trauma out the window that doesn't sound scientific to me my dear friends if somebody's really content okay it's a whole other discussion yeah I think everyone has the right the the right to choose to heal how they want to heal and to choose to live the lifestyle that they want to live and this is someone I alluded to in last week's conversation and and to and to know and to know that there are options and to know that there are options there's people maybe that will are very vindictive and they they alienate you but there's people who are not vindictive and I I am connected to many people in this community the LGBT community who do feel it's a struggle for them and I need to respect them too for me to say it's not a struggle you guys are brainwashed you guys are brainwashed who made marriage some marrying a woman marry a man you know I could say it's not respecting them so you say oh the only reason they say this is because the religious people brainwash them don't be so dogmatic maybe some people are homosexual they have Tendencies and they really don't want it don't impose your view on somebody else it's also not fair it's also not fair respect the fact that they do feel it's a struggle respect maybe for you it's not and respect the fact that they do want to explore things about themselves you know it's like the Dogma works on both sides and let's respect the fact that some people do feel it's a struggle I get hundreds of letters and they're actually very open people but there's something inside of them that says you know what I want to build a family I don't know how can you help me Rabbi why why and for me just to sell them get over it get over it just marry a man I feel I feel that so disrespectful even without the Torah it's disrespectful certainly from the position I come from believe that I believe in the terror is true so there is a lot a lot to explore here and there are people who can be helpful not dogmatic people and not people who think you could scream stop and and you'll become heterosexual in a day and and we're happy to continue this conversation I said we're having a special webinar uh March 12th uh four o'clock P.M you could email us at info at the yeshiva.net to register about this topic of homosexuality Ellie are you going to continue taking questions okay let me see if I should have a lot of questions and we'll go from here okay I think you can continue for another 20 minutes I I I have to apologize because I have to run okay but you're right I'm sorry the time flies when you're with people you love at least a very good conversationalist so yeah no there's a lot to talk about they're trying to the truth is a very close person to me a very close person to me called me after the last webinar and said very good but you hogged the mic and Ellie also doesn't hate the mic yeah so uh I told that to Ellie so he said guilty yes accused I soaked myself I didn't see it but uh listen it's here people are watching they're watching people he sat down to uh to listen to this that's when I for we're not forcing anybody and they're the only ones who are forced to be here is U.S Tyler and Taylor end of shmuel on my side but uh but thank you very much Ellie's going to continue with the questions two weeks Thursdays right March 16th 8 PM March 16th 8 P.M psychedelics homosexuality right you know if we want to go more if there's more you know if there are questions we'll address it there's obviously experiences and I don't say like mine is limited right the number of people I've spoken to but I think we have to invite this conversation a little bit more so that more voices are heard mine is also limited to so many people and everyone has a different story and journey but I I do have to say that I have dealt with hundreds and hundreds of people and I've heard many stories very personal stories and special people by the way I want you to know these are some of our greatest souls okay that's a it's a well-kept secret these are some of our greatest Souls their sensitivities their kindness and their spirituality is sometimes unparalleled I'm not making a scientific connection here I'm just telling you from the experience of hundreds of people something special about these nashamas we lose by not having a relationship with them and I'm talking about females and males struggling with this males and not struggling with it and not struggling with it okay and not struggling no it is keeping me on my toes it is thank you thank you thank you I understand I understand sending my love and blessings to everybody and I'll see you later thank you for uh yeah we'll go for another we'll go for another 15 to 20 minutes unless you're a single pilot for the for the 20 minutes of Landing we gotta be a single pilot thank you thank you thank you so much so a question over here I'm bipolar and my girlfriend is a victim of sexual abuse and has an eating disorder in The Firm World they say that this marriage would never be able to last I'm confused if it's true or not okay actually I'll leave this question for you why why because it's actually addressed him right why would you take on this should we stay together or not someone asked over here if someone at a later stage of Life can find out that his father raped him doesn't that put psychedelics in a really scary scary category so I think this question is asking can psychedelics bring up um terrifying memories and the answer is yes it could but it's not going to create anything that's not there so if someone was raped as a child they're dealing with that every single day the opportunity of psychedelics is to deal with something head-on because when we're forced to deal with something indirectly it's often much more painful and its tentacles are much more far-reaching it reaches so someone was raped like in this case by their father it's affecting most likely every area of their life so for the opportunity to enter a psychedelic space with the help of an experienced facilitator and it may take more than one and to face that head-on and heal them while it is scary it also has the potential to be truly healing someone asked does it mean if I'm addicted to sex and porn I suffered from trauma that I don't know about so my understanding of this is that previously this was understood to be the case that if someone was um addicted to anything that they suffered pretty severe trauma I think in today's day and age especially as it relates to porn we're dealing with a different category of addict and that's someone who is introduced to pornography at a very young age someone perhaps could say this is a trauma but if someone at 12 or 13 or 14 years old was using pornography on a regular basis then they may be addicted to pornography as they get older even though there's no obvious other trauma physical abuse trauma or things like that maybe a good example for this would be things like video games someone who had a decent life but the only thing we did is introduce them to video games at a very young age could come into adulthood with a very severe video game addiction that's not based on any sort of trauma but typically when we think about drug abuse when we think about um alcoholism when we think about severe sex addiction we're talking about someone who's traumatized Gabor mate in his book in the realm of hungry ghosts says that at least amongst the hardcore addicts that he worked with right then he was he had a clinic in Vancouver who dealt with the most severe drug addicts in the population people who often had little chance at um at getting sober Gabor said that very often the only thing to do with these patients was give them clean needles or take them from heroin and put them in methadone but these these people's lives were ruined in many ways by their drug addiction and he said 100 of the female drug addicts this level of drug drug addict that he met was sexually abused and every one but one male had a memory of being sexually abused so I think that does say something about the link between um abuse and addiction that being said because of the proliferate proliferation of smartphones and the internet I think there's a new category of addict which is someone that's just growing up into addiction another question here about addiction how can we make people aware that they're actually having an addiction and shouldn't just blame others but go for help I I think we can start by not blaming them I mean the question is filled with uh a fair amount of blame right how can we make people aware that they actually have an addiction and shouldn't just blame others but go for help um in my experience if we notice that someone is an addict not my experience in the big book of AAA which is the um the Bible so to speak of the 12-step programs all of them really but specifically Alcoholics Anonymous it has a chapter on there of what to do with someone who's an addict and really the only thing we're trying to do is let them know that there's an address for help because a person is not going to call a moment before they're ready so to sit there and put it in their face and say go heal go heal go heal what does it mean go heal it means that they have to go deep into their inner recesses of their soul in order to heal what's there so that you want you want them to do it on your timetable no they're going to do it when they have the willingness to do it so what do we want when they're in that state of willingness they have an address to go to for help so I recall speaking to someone who I understood was dealing with a very severe sex addiction and when I brought it up with him I noticed a lot of resistance and this is normal because a um an addiction needs Denial in order to survive part and parcel of the addiction is the denial meaning the same way there's a drive to have the drug there is a drive to deny the fact that there's a problem with a drug it's part and parcel of it this denial and what I said to him was listen I said it is my from my experience I believe that a recovery program could help you you're obviously not ready and I'm not going to impose anything on you the only thing I want you to know is that you can call my phone at any point in time um and I will never say I told you so there's none of that if you ever need help related to this and he felt that for me and it was sincere and I told him that me myself I knew I had an addiction I wasn't ready to work on it until I was ready to work on it so there's absolutely no judgment if it turns out to be the case that I am right I will never say I told you so three or four months later the gentleman called me up he was near suicidal from his addiction so I think that is the offer that we have to to put to people is just let them know the address that there is so one of the recommendations um in the Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous is actually leave the book around at this point in time I think most people know a 12-step program exists but then it was saying just leave the book around in other words give someone an address to go to so in that moment that they have that willingness that often comes from desperation they're not desperate without a solution and we just want to meet someone and be available to them there and too much judgment and too much harshness will make someone less likely to come forward to you to whoever the person is that puts that blame on them because they don't no one wants to hear I told you so it says what what direction can we give children in addressing pornography and masturbation during their teenage years when there's a natural desire for sexual exploration but clearly has issues with sexual exploration until marriage you know as someone who is in this position not so long ago I was going through Yeshiva system 20 years ago I wish there was someone who I can speak to comfortably about this realistically speaking can a teenager who's going through that level of um you know the stage of puberty and the intense sexual desire that that often comes with the intense sexual Obsession sometimes that that comes with can they abstain from important masturbation completely maybe not for many of us maybe not it certain it wasn't the case for me but having an so first of all maybe we have to relax the perfectionism standards right you say is a is often ideal it's not always you know I'm not a rabbi I'm not coming from that place but we don't have to pull back the ideal just to be accepting of someone we can still okay Define the ideal this is the ideal the ideal is not to use any point of masturbation when someone goes there especially in today's day and age where these images are are so out there between film and social media and pornography like it's all out there people are being stimulated sexually as well it's going to be difficult to abstain for many of us and there should be an Avenue to speak to so I think the best thing we can do for educators or for parents is to give an Avenue for people who um are struggling to talk to about it I think one of the fears and one of the reasons we don't is because we don't want to introduce anyone to the concept first of all the body is introducing the presence of the concept it's there number one but even if there was a time and place in society where it made sense to not have these conversations let's say until marriage and today's day and age is not there I mean it's simply if if you're watching this that means you're on the internet in some fashion most likely your kids are on the internet in some fashion and if that's the case then they have access to all of these things as well and there needs to be the Avenue for um for discussion a sex education is happening so in the if there was a time and place where no sex education was happening and you could say okay we can wait till marriage to get that sexy education I can't say whether I agree or disagree with it but it's it's all hypothetical because it doesn't exist today however in today's day and age whether someone is getting a sex education and the amount of teenagers and this is not a Jewish problem this is not a religious problem this is across the board the amount of teenagers who get their education primarily from pornography is an issue so we have to step out of that and that's part of the reason that I think we offer some of these conversations in a public format is because there's so much else in the public format so what are we going to do keep these things in secret amongst three people and have conversations when pornography isn't is the number one most searched uh content on the internet doesn't make any sense it says what I think the first step is towards fixing porn addiction the first step is admitting we have a problem number one but even before the first step in many we have a problem is also the willingness to stop it and I don't know what to do for willingness I think willingness is a god-given gift and if someone doesn't have that willingness to stop and hopefully they have the willingness for the willingness or something there there were periods of time where I lost my willingness I was working on it then I slipped and I slipped enough times back into pornography and I lost my willingness and the only thing I did was I would pray for the willingness to come back like please give me the willingness to uh to to fight for this and then after those things are done ask for help you know I mentioned the beginning of this conversation um my own email address that someone can reach out to Instagram message me I can do my best I have on my podcast in search of more I have conversations the first podcast I put out there was called escaping porn addiction I go into much more detail on those subjects I also reference guard your eyes which is a resource people can go to and then the the other resource okclarity.com where people can meet um therapists or a specific person who can help them in their location who has a sensitivity to the Jewish Community who can help them with these issues but it's those three things the willingness the honesty and the courage to ask for help over here so many suicides go misreported families do their us utmost to explain it away the other kids it prevents closure it's untrue and selfish it's 2023 while contagion is a thing suicide is not catchy this goes for all matters we can still have measured responsible and Frank discussions while still protecting the vulnerable what steps need to be taken so that mental disease is treated like any other so for this you know the different questions here and specific to Suicide it's certainly something that's frustrated me in the past that someone who's died from a suicide or an overdose in the family has chosen to keep it quiet I don't blame the family because we created an environment where it's difficult for the family to do so of Remy garari who's a uh a close friend of mine who lost his daughter to suicide has been public about it then I think it took a tremendous amount of Courage for him and his family to do that him and his wife dinian the children to be open and honest about what happened to their daughter and I think more people doing the same and sharing that hey this is actually what happened whether it was an overdose or a suicide or something of this of this nature I don't think the data shows that it shows contagion in fact what I've heard I've heard from liafi who runs along Short Road an organization that's dedicated to training and awareness around Suicide Prevention what I've heard from her is an expert on the subject is that speaking about it in mature ways is most likely to make people who are struggling with suicidal ideation more comfortable to ask for help so the best thing we can do for prevention is actually to speak about it in mature and responsible ways and let those who are struggling with the thoughts because no one wants to struggle with those thoughts those who are struggling with those thoughts to have a destination they can go to for help and know that that person is going to receive them sometimes it's not because of judgment but because it's because of overwhelm some of us get overwhelmed by these subjects so I think that knowing that the person they're asking for help won't get overwhelmed is um is important but you know for myself I didn't wait for the leaders in the community I didn't ask the rabbis to do anything Robert Jacobson joined me on this and I'm grateful um that he did but I didn't wait for a rabbi to say something before I started speaking I started sharing my own personal story and obviously that came after some healing and there's timing for everything and there's a way we do everything but I think that those who have these questions can are obviously seeing a problem and instead of pointing the finger towards someone else to solve it maybe look if they have the um resources both internal and external to be able to do something about the problem you know in the place where there is no man be the man and I don't mean that necessarily as a man many women are doing this work as well people need to stand up where they see a problem and not wait for these supposed leaders of the community to to do it the leaders are the people who stand up and and say so everyone can can take that upon themselves and make this world a better place and I hope that um many listen I hope that many who are listening tonight who have the resources internal resources external resources to be able to do something about that that they that they do Tyler do you wanna bring up a few questions the ones that came in this evening and ones that are related to addiction or things that I can handle myself and not necessarily to religion or rabbis yeah we got a few um I'm gonna pair two in one because they're similar uh so happy to hear you talk about plant medicine our community needs and is ready for True healing where do you see opportunities to be women for ambassadors for healing in the community and how can I find a reliable Shaman in order to heal through plant medicine okay so two different questions one was about um women and healing I think there are ones who are um who are doing things I mean a lot of the people who publicized um this event are women who are who are in this publicized it she has a um an Instagram account where she talks about some of these things her own plant medicine experiences and otherwise a light herzl she publicized it she speaks about it okay Clarity who I mentioned sterna Suiza I mean there are many women in the community not necessarily related to plant medicine or not but who are talking about um or talk about healing I would say that there's probably more women than men in the um in the conversation in terms of finding a reliable um Shaman so the the situation is important it's like asking where do I find a good therapist for who in what situation and what context what sort of Medicine I would reach out to an individual who you know who's experienced this and obviously we have to be sensitive to the laws are changing in many places but they aren't fully there and even in many places where it's decriminalized it's still not um licensed in a way that our therapists and a licensing board for these things so the best thing to do is to do a little research and to speak to people who have these experiences and see if your needs are similar to them and to um and and to see if the people who help them are people who can help you and if not keep asking and keep searching but it will be found and I think pay attention in the sense that more and more people are talking about this it's becoming more and more common but but I do want to add that it's not it's not inconsequential who the facilitator is on a plant medicine Journey there are there are many things that they do both in preparing a person for the experience and during the experience itself and after the experience in order to help um you know reap the the fruits of the experience that it's not an inconsequential decision who won uh who one works with so do your research and I trust that you'll find the uh the right person and like I said the number of people speaking publicly about it so reach out to them and if their situation seems similar to you reach out to them and see if they're willing to uh guide you in a specific Direction is it is porn bad for women to watch as well I keep going back to it but I don't know why so ashamed to bring it up in therapy sexually abused as a pre-teen to my mid teenage years so the first quite the first part of that question whether or not porn is bad this is not a question for um bad for women it's not a question for me to answer maybe Rabbi Jacobson will obviously have have his opinions that's not the relevant part of the conversation of the of the question from the relevant part of the question for me is more about the shame and that someone is afraid to bring it up in therapy so I want to say to this person that there are many women who watch porn and there are many women who are addicted to porn if there were only women in the population then and there was a porn there was the same exact porn problem we would say that women have a porn problem the only reason that it's not addressed is because it's less than men it's much less than men but it's not you're not talking about one or two percent of women who are watching porn or addicted to porn it is common as as things are common this is one of those that are common so there's no shame in uh um in bringing it up either in therapy or or with another uh or with another person and that's where the conversation starts and once we're able to relax the shame around it then we can see how detriment how detrimental it is how damaging it is and things like that obviously Robert Jacobson would talk about it from a halach perspective the the damaging nature of it uh for me I'm looking at more through the lens of addiction and while they're ashamed there that needs to be rooted out and just uh I guess another comment on people who are in therapy the the job of the therapists is to create environment where someone feels safe to speak and doesn't mean the therapist isn't doing that test the therapist bring it up meaning the therapist if they're somewhat competent understands the need to be receptive of someone who brings up an issue so if if you're happy with the therapist otherwise then I imagine they'll be very um understanding when you bring up this issue but if there's a reason I talk more than any other it's to relax shame around topics and as any shame that there is around women who watch pornography there's only so much I can do to relax that shame but I can tell you as someone who's spoken a lot about pornography that many women have reached out to me and it is a topic of conversation for many women how can I as a child of a recovering sex drug and alcohol addict not take on all the skewed beliefs that my parents have passed on to me I don't think that question is um limited to someone who's has a sex drug and alcohol an alcoholic parent I think that everyone has to ask themselves those questions how do I not take then the um negative parts of my parents the negative parts of my upbringing and carry it into adulthood right how do we end generational trauma how do we not pass the worst of ourselves to our children is the question and I think that once we become adults then we're the parent in the room so we're not looking to our parents anymore we're looking to ourselves to create the environment that we need in order to give a better world for our children because if we're going to excuse that that we don't have the responsibility to deal with it because our parents imposed it on us then who says our parents have that response that had that responsibility at any point because it's very likely their parents impose it on them in some way I doubt someone who became a sex addict a drug addict an alcoholic had a perfect childhood and perfect parents so we don't absolve any adult of the responsibility but now that we're the adult we're not we're not either absolved to the responsibility and it's us who have to become the parents to ourselves and to create the environment within our own world that we want to pass on to our children or want to give to ourselves I grew up with no religion at all I'm trying to join Chabad but I don't really know how to so I just read and try my best help hahaha okay I'm not sure when this uh question this webinar but if someone's asking about Chabad go to chabad.org put in your ZIP code I'm sure you'll find that about house pretty close to you reach out to the local Rabbi local Chabad Rabbi and uh I hope you meet someone who's amazing commenting about rabbis are all right on that note thank you all um for attending for joining and for this opportunity uh in the last 25 minutes or so to um land the plane that's right why Jacobson mentioned for those interested in more of my own work I have a podcast called the In Search of more by all means you can check it out release episodes weekly both interviews both on my own thoughts uh we talk mostly about mental health healing spirituality Etc this class is brought to you by the yeshiva.net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot the yeshiva.net donate