Pesachim 9b-10a - Are We Afraid You Will Eat the Chametz You Find on Pesach?

the yeshiva dotnet okay the few damnit BAE's the Mishnah this is the third mission and Sock'em the first mission we learned that he of of Dicker's comets the night of 14 the second mission we continued to say that we're not afraid and we don't assume that a weasel or a rat or a similar Road and dragged comets from one part of the house to another part of the house from a part of the house that had hummert's to a part of the house that was already clean or from one house to another house we do not consider that to be a legal valid authentic concern that we have to tackle we just don't do that that's a magician and now the Gomora continues to discuss the time limits for the curse comments review who died murder be hooda says Boykin you check hamed's or you download the night of you Dalit the night of the 14th of Nisan who bu dollar chakras and then you check on you download in the morning IRA paces in the morning and then o Bashar Sabir and then you check Bashar Sabir which means during the time of the disposal of comets which is of course the sixth hour because min hitori we know that the Mitzvah Bisou disposing the Hammad's begins in the beginning of the seventh hour right which would be approximately in a day that starts at 6:00 it would be twelve o'clock p.m. but there's a come and pushed it back one hour said you have to burn the Comets in the beginning of the sixth hour sir from particulars change which would be eleven o'clock a.m. so that's called sha Sabir the time of the disposal of the comets sir Buda says you do them because comets now it seems like from the Mishnah here the reviewed is saying in Duke Nicholas how much three times three times which is fascinating you duplicitous comments at night you do because comets in the morning a new because comets in right before the afternoon Bashar Sabir you do again knickers comets in your house which would mean according to the simple interpretation that review that really feels that you can't rely on one buddy come because people are human and they make mistakes and they miss they might miss commits so therefore they're how come an obligate you to do it three times again and again and again and hopefully what you didn't find the first time you'll find a second we didn't find a second you'll find the third and there are three periods the night the morning and late morning 11 o'clock a.m. rashad sabirah that's what grabbed you hood the thymus fascinating fascinating okay fascinating come in my room come and say no no this is not the way to understand it no you bought that car you doubted you be you doubt if you weren't boy dick on the night of your doll ignition then you could be marshalling and you could should be boy dick on the day of the 14th when we passed us in the morning right Lloyd bought that could be you Dalit if you weren't boy Digby you Dalit on your dollar on the 14th you've become my it you should be boy dick but I saw Maya what does but I saw my at me we might have thought but I come ahead means the middle of yum tips around she says but I come by it Bashar she she's sure who my aid Jabir what they mean but I come by it means in the sixth hour which is the designated time for disposing comments why would Rashi learn like this but I saw my it I think it makes sense it I think it makes sense that Robin Hood of it one of the restraining tides this annachi and it makes a lot of sense that the cumin are paralleling ruby hood then review the city of three by dick three times at night in the morning and late morning Bashar Savio so the Hawks column said no you got it wrong if you didn't do it at night do it you darlin if you didn't do it you die would do it but talk about it so ration is learning that they're paralleling review hood if you didn't do it at night do it you doubt it in the more and if you didn't do it you're dialed in the morning then do it you dial it with cameras which means in the designated time of disposal which is the six hour that's when you do it don't do boudicca's come it's three times it's three alternatives if you didn't do it the first you have a second chance a second chance you have a third chance that's how there's a comment I'd should according to an hour she betrayed karma it means Bashar shishas lie but I come on what if you didn't check how much but I hammer it in middle of the my aid which according Tadashi means when in the sixth hour then you've like our hammer it you should be worth it after the designated time of disposing comments what does this means are gradually laughter a MyID mache show you solo my exit a shock from six hours and up until it gets dark meaning until nightfall so they'll come and say we're gonna add a fourth period from Dicky's comments if you didn't do all of the above so now ishe show you salam ila after the time when disposal ends when does disposal end Rashi says at the end of six hours the seventh hour begins now you should still check comets until nightfall the night of the seder until Pesach awed chatter shocked that's when you do it this is right right right right okay one moment so this is our Raschi learns the two review this s three times thicker that how come him saying no one time to dakar if you didn't do it once you do second in the second day the third didn't do third you can do it throughout the day the Mishna finishes boom our shamaa shyar whatever you leave over from the Comets after the bedico yeah mayhem abit sinner the lock is you have to put it away in a private place meaning in a secure place conditionally it sort of decocker off so you shouldn't need to do another boodikka for this comets that you put away what does this mean it doesn't mean first the Gemara earlier you mentioned this initially we thought they always have to do particular why because maybe a if if you yo have to be concerned that a rat took your comets and spread it across the house but as the kymaro explained that's not what the Mishnah means the Mishnah means you can have to do dick it in case you see that a weasel comes and takes the Comets away in front of you if you don't hide your comments you just leave it somewhere in the corner and you see a weasel come and drag it away you're gonna have to do another bedico or even if you put down ten pieces and you find nine pieces you're gonna have to do another bedico so that's why and it may be very difficult you may not know this how locks are you may forget so therefore the mission is telling you are how locker not just as the place can say not just an eight sir but a locker that you have to put it away in a secure place so it shouldn't come to that that a weasel shouldn't be able to have access to it for example you put a Kayleigh over it you hang it up in the ear you put it in a private draw you lock it up and of course this is not only about rats and rodents it's also l'hospital about children and babies and infants you have to put away the Comets in case you're going to see somebody drag it away are you going to find uh crumbs you're going to find a mishmash you're going to find the problem and then you're gonna have to be brightness and you may forget to be my nickel you may not know this a locker so therefore youngish a know bits in here is a very important I service of an emu Lloyd bug that Mitaka Myatt if you weren't by thick vitarka Maya give the camera my parish my country's finish I couldn't be sure she she's Maya does the sixth hour and her comments say you could do it after the sixth hour till it's night the Casa de la w-who the correlation Sabir but llama she no Lashon I if Rashi is correct why would the command change the language Reb you who they called it sha Sabir the time of disposal so the Hakam should have said like bud that beard Allah give that bashar Sabir why do they call it but I saw a Mayan why did the language change to become ayat in middle of the holiday so rashly says it doesn't mean the middle of the holiday means in the middle of the designated money it means designated the designated time for beer comments why they change the language if they mean the same time fascinating question element I saw Maya dining with Gila Sheva at sofa pestle but alkaloid literally means in middle of the young toothpaste on how am I saying if he didn't do Bleeker if he didn't do bicker at the beginning of the sixth hour you can do it from the beginning of the seventh hour until then throughout the entire boil until the end of pacer so if I didn't do because comets right let's say I get stuck somewhere on the road whatever and I come back it's called a Moyer I have to do because comets one second very good excellent question Ola a car hammer it what about after my boy trashy laughter I'm a it means what from the seventh hour till nightfall but according to this laughter a mind he says here that you have to check why kadai shallow you sire of like how Mitchell is super shall head to Viet Leno so that prohibited comments shouldn't get mixed in with permissible comments and you should eat it since we have a hollow that how much over a lava pesos or if I have comets in my house that I left in my house for whatever reason I'm not talking comments that I sold to a gentle that wasn't mine but comments that belong to me that I left in my domain or do owns a grocery store it happens and he doesn't get rid of the comments right if he sells the store or fine but if he doesn't sell the store that comets is per for bidden after the Pesach so the halacha would be according to her comin you have to do bigger summits in your house after paisa why so that you shouldn't come across that comets and you may come to eat it you'll buy new bread from the bakery after pace up here a lot eat but you have old bread frozen pizza that stayed pay stuff in your house in your nominee then you may come to eat it because it's gonna get confused with the frozen pizza that you're allowed to eat so may they have to do a ludicrous comments after you very good question you want to know where it be who this says you now don't do this if you this says the last time 50k is the sixth hour we'll soon see the much like us they require you to do another petechiae middle of face that's how Isis learns yeah yeah yeah how much over Lopez he never allowed to eat yeah that's why you got to get rid of it that's what toys was to say we're - she loaded up - laughs Irish came and placed besides her actually didn't want to say this you know why relationship eaters but mission at the birth comes Leo who hi-yah because back to that original mush like this is like the axes upon which much of the first panic revolves in the first mission that when it said both units are coming soon as she said credential allow row by row by Yahtzee why don't we do because comets not to transgress the prohibition of having comets and you have some pace place we said why do we do thickest comet scheme' yo voy loss well you may come to eat it Raschi says he do because come it's not to be able to buy a robot you must say so toy says Iraq she didn't want to say what I'm saying in the Mishnah why because if the purpose of the Islamist is not to be able to buy a rubber you might say does it make sense to be buried in comics after Pesach after Pesach there's no Easter by a rabbi you must if you save Dickens comments is that you shouldn't come to eat it even after Pesach you now that I eat comets sure overall of a person come as that was in your house on pace says that you didn't get rid of you now that eat so mainly you can do particular comments have to pay sir but rashly doesn't want to accept this interpretation cuz he owes that because conferences for by you robbed by your mom say that can apply ever faced it can apply Arab basic in the afternoon but it can't apply after Pesach and that's why now she says betray somebody it means in the sixth hour after I'm a it means at the end of the six hours all the way till nightfall which is after post a designated time for disposing the comments I should just mention that I think their fiduciary around says why does taka how does rashly explain the fact that that have come unchanged from Bashar Sabir TUBITAK hammer it the answer is because according to W who the that's the only shots a beer because you know what I do because comments afterwards but according to the have come him since you a lot of the big has come it still might fall so therefore shahe beer is not only the sixth hour shall Sabir continues throughout the day if you if you didn't do particular comments of course shot sabrina is the sixth hour but if you didn't do they say you should can do dick as comets and get rid of it so therefore they're sharks RB or somehow extent that's why they changed from the terminology shall Sabir to take somebody that's how they round explains why Rashi believes they changed the lawsuit which was placed versus big question which proved to him that patella Mallya doesn't mean the sixth hour it means the middle of Pesach which is why that haven't changed from Bashar Sabir to petition my wise election what Judaism doesn't football instead of shallow if I'm gonna say it should not become he should not be seen let's say show me this Oh what's why they use the word ballet instead of Laura you think since the Homer says liar all of her comment Leela Sheba shall masala whatever tell him so why do they use the word Bali a raw value a value matzah she used the word lawyer raw you sink I don't know I don't know it's it's an interesting aria I have to look it up I don't know they just saying why they changed the would you know to bow say over below a row no not bow means not but you say why it's a good on I don't have to look it up yeah suck the Gemara my time at LMU hood what's the reason for every hood what's the reason for every hooter to say that you need to do three ridiculous his developer abouna dammit revive his their rabid the son of Ramona both say the same idea a fascinating answer can negate shush-shush bosses schibetta review who the believes that this parallels the three languages of disposing comets that the toyota introduces throughout the whole machine language number one the PASOK says in the end of passions boy Laurier raha comets later all the hot oil comets and yeast should not be seeing to you they shouldn't be seen to you next also in Paris by earlier she Vasya uh Yemen so although you must save ever taken for seven days yeast or sourdough should not be found in your home and again in passions but even earlier after beyond my restraint I should be sue so remember take them on the first day which we explained to me Arif paste as we learned on that a Dalit underfae but yeah maybe she's at her face if you should - should be sue you should eliminate the comets the sourdough from your home there are three languages that the trailer employees regarding elimination eliminating the comments as well as she says so large buses show us was showing us a large buster Rita MIT SIA flash busting you shouldn't see comments come it shouldn't be found shouldn't be present and you should eliminate you should destroy you should get rid of that should be sue you should exterminate the comments from your home comes W who then says the fact that turned employs three languages is to teach us something to indicate that there are three times from Turkish comments there's the night and there is the morning and there's the afternoon some cipher says beautifully then it's not stop three and then we make three times it's actually connected with the three terms why because he must say applies to nighttime because we learned before you remember that both units are somewhat slower honey why do you use a candle so we said because we learn Mesilla from its SIA its SIA from cheapest cheapest from nail now Zion amid maze suppositions line binaries ordinary Shemesh with Southern Conference had revolted and inator is Val I'll assume it's SIA you find through a candle and that's only by night because by daesh rag of a tear in miami a candle is useless by day as the Gomorrah says a candle during the daytime doesn't help you because you don't see it solo you must say to make sure that it's not found you use a candle which is night low year I don't see comets when do you see we have bytes it's Asst says o de sim ice ice the Gemara says Pratt Lexus from here we learn that what you wear at night doesn't need census because it's not as amount of seeing when you could see today we see at night because we have Edison or con Edison but but according to the natural nature of the world before the technology of having besides a few loose candles but generally you don't see at night solar year or applies to the day then you have touch missile when by the day the morning the when the Sun comes up and you could start seeing things like the field of senses that's the time of year so we say law a law you shouldn't see so get rid of it because if you don't get rid of it you're gonna see it's because it's they thought at night you're not gonna see it anyway even if you don't get rid of it you're gonna find it but you're not gonna see it finding you could do at night also cuz you could look for it with a candle but seeing naturally seeing without looking and I'm gonna do during the day because during the day you don't need to find it you're just gonna see it so mail in order not to see it you have dupe Dicker's comments and then there's Bisou Bisou is it says asked by immigration asked by emulation means my choice the beginning of the seventh I was looking with a six hour so from here that be hood they learn new because so much three times one is connected law you might say which is at night one is connected later which is the morning and one is the time of FBI monition there's be super cheese Bashar Sabir at the beginning of the sixth hour then I tried in the beginning of the seventh time I made there but in the beginning of the sixth hour that's what kept in i'ma grab a burner wouldn't explain why the BI she said right of you that says you've do because comets three three times the sukham is interested he goes backwards he starts with the later then he goes with the earlier then he goes with the earliest it's interesting he goes backwards he starts he goes in the order he goes in order but not forward but backward he does it in the order but the order is backwards because layered allah muhammad SAS myspace passions by Pericles Gitmo PASOK Sian right shiva celery is parakeet basic your tests and after my emulation asperity basic test so it's actually going backwards you wanna know why he doesn't go forward not in it in the Torah level he goes backwards so it makes no sense number one and thinks that the second thing is you should first start with Zia Melissa then all of the time and then there's bees right you wanna know what this why he does the circum in this order it's a good harder may civil abusive abusive asked the question and the Brice's says should be who died me rebuking says Cole shall I bothered much like Shiprock Kamala Lu Xiu en a Boyd if somebody didn't check commas during these three periods which three periods the night and the morning and 11 a.m. the beginning of this hour you're not biting again Sylvania boy dick in other words he says this is the end time this is deadline Alma what do we see from here but mechana vanilla Hooda Pleakley it sounds that the only argument between a build and the Hakam is only if you could do it after that time it's not a much locust how many times you dupe the customers because then the Bryce I should have mentioned two arguments argument number one is you got to do it three times versus one argument number two is you didn't do it during these three times you can't do it anymore so it sounds like that a bit then there's some are only arguing about one issue and that is the deadline of when you can't do particular Mertz anymore mizutamari hace mizuna explained and taught the question of Rabbi Yosef in a different fashion much stronger much more emphatic massive an abusive my sutra quoted Rubio Yousuf as follow the following repulsive asked the prices review dime interview that says culturally but that the ephod militia praça mauá low savannah boy dick if somebody was not boy dick in one of these three periods he's not boy dick anymore Alma we see clearly brush of a neighbor thick who deeply gay the only argument is if you could be by dick after the designated time of the beginning of the sixth hour in the first browser a viewer that says if you weren't boy dick in these three periods you're not boy dick again you could touch in one of these three periods or in all of them so still go two ways but in my soldiers Bryce said that he had in his tradition its clearly w-who this says he only have to do it one of the three times so this whole premise they're gonna be who the city of new boutique has come it's three times and a prisoner and robber the son of rebel abroad looking for it is untenable according to this bracelet which says that of you the only argues about the deadline for it occurs comets not about how many times you do because comets so the Gemara therefore concludes that we understood the Mishnah erroneously l RW dena me my bother comma W Hooda also does not necessitate three times because comets review hood that means just like this how come him if you weren't boy dick at night you do it in the morning if you didn't do it in the morning you do it they're doing the time of the disposal well how about how come it's laggy the argument is one argument not how many times the argument is this my stubborn mules Mikami surah in basura Lloyd the only time you a lot of duplicates commences before the time when comets becomes prohibited to eat which is Erev Pesach by cuts Iseman hitori de and the car come him said that the easter of comets should start an hour earlier meaning that's already the beginning of the sixth hour you can't benefit from it and you have to get rid of it bah sory sooner but after the time of the s or lawyer you're now let it do because comets anymore even though you never did why would I be hood to hold this I'll tell you why Zahra Dilma Aucilla maihama name we're afraid if you're doing but it has come it's Arif pacer in the afternoon you may find comets and unwittingly inadvertently you're going to eat it rap on and sadly their opponents say like a surgeon and we don't make this Zahra and therefore you could be by the Comets even after this man of the Easter of homage begins so as a she told us that how come him say you could be by took a whole day till nightfall but here there was the McCoy curse of Rashi and Isis rashly holds one spacer comes you wouldn't be allowed to be by the Comets and we would already be able to understand the nice word here because one spacer comes the Easter of eating how much is chorus the Easter of eating hummus is death penalty by heaven it's a much more serious issue we're doing Erev Pesach in the afternoon there's no is sir chorus for eating comments so therefore - you know that even the common mold that you're allowed to be by the comets the whole area of patient until nightfall review that says no because he's afraid you're gonna eat it the Cobham say you could be voided but nonetheless they're afraid I'm Pesach to me buddy however toy service holds clearly that even the middle of pace after her column say you could do particular comments and you have to do because comments why we're not afraid that when you find how much you're going to eat it the Gemara will explain soon more the smarter of the command why they're not going but this is the mock Lycus which means everybody holds your body that come it's only once the three periods we spoke about is only if you didn't do the first you do the second into the second you do the third the only muck like this is what happens after that if you didn't do one two three Roberta says fatherland there's nothing to do anymore no more boudicca's comets and the Cohanim say that you should continue to do because comets in other words even though there was Bittle even though there was Bittle and if there was Bittle you're not gonna be overrun by a robot you might say that's the Vaart nonetheless you continue to do comets they afternoon you continue to dickens comments a whole day Erev Pesach even though you're now letting eat hummus and we don't mind that you're gonna have contact with comets because you're doing it to get rid of it not to eat it whatever you heard this said no your end time is over you have reached a deadline from Dicker's comments after the sixth hour once twelve O'Clock hits once the clock hits twelve o'clock p.m. no more because comets for you it's the people who choose everybody has excellent question you want to know what we're gonna be who this says is it there's no comma said it was a good question these were all members of the Sanhedrin they were members of the Jewish court how did the Jewish court decide these things they used to vote so there was a vote this is the vote Roberta said there's a reason you're right and he was a minority and therefore that was like the hum you're right the view there's a minority most of the sages disagreed with them they said we're not worried about this and therefore there's a few of Dicker's comets even after it's exactly what you're seeing what you're seeing now is a video of the of the debate of the Sanhedrin and these debates is what created the whole office of Terah Shah Baba this happens to be what we call the genre of X Aras meaning those things that the Cohanim did in order to create fences to make sure that there is a buffer zone that people don't violate Tyra for example because comets that we shouldn't come to eat comets or vicars comments we shouldn't be overrun by you know by Mattel every attach it and the question is can we do because comets error faces in the afternoon could we do because comets the middle of Peyser the home said absolutely yes we have an obligation to do because comets it's not nullified just because you're not eat comets interview Hooda argued the view they said no more I'm afraid you're gonna do particular so much which is a rabbinic mitzvot beautiful and what are you gonna make the person end up doing eating comets which is a biblical prohibition so do me a favor the whole point of rabbinic mitzvos is to protect you to create a fence that a person shouldn't violate Toyota right it's like around a nuclear plant you make sure that there's a lot of security that nobody gets close right you have a dangerous dangerous source of electricity in a house or outside of house you put a fence so kids shouldn't touch it right you have a dangerous cliff you put a fence that's the whole point of the Gators they're abundant to make a fence and what are you doing as a result of your Mitzvah the new potatas come it's what's gonna happen the person is gonna find comets in the afternoon he's starving there's no food in the house there's no food in Jewish homes there of cases he's starving he finds a piece of marble cake he's gonna eat it he's gonna be over on the eastern of eating commentary of pacer so they for a Buda says please two minutes can't harvest let's not do the COS comments because what you're doing is you're gonna be Marcella drew in a seminar toys we're not sure but maybe thickest comments at ninth is the best time to do it or in the morning go in the beginning of the sixth hour which is the SHA Sabir so very good this is exactly the vote of the Senate sources it's not cara's but it's prohibited as we're gonna see later there's gonna be the next sugar Gemara it gets not as far as no it's it's it's it's prohibited minatoya but it's not a penalty of chorus no no it's not a zero-sum emits an instrument I tied it to eat comets error peso can they afternoon so there be who this says therefore there's no cube because comets done yes yes yes yes yes yes no Buda said you now let a do because comets Arab basically afternoon exactly we're the ones who made this tikona and this tikona is canceled in this situation it has a time limit with the hello me say no doesn't have a time limit it continues till nightfall and according to touristic continues throughout paces and continues after pace right right so that to go Mars gonna explore what he was told me and what he was holding the Mars are going to get into it because right right but we're afraid it's Arif pacer from the afternoon three o'clock in the afternoon you didn't do predict his comments right so you go check for comets and you gonna find you may find and unwitting unwillingly unwittingly but shy gig do not buy it not not amazing you're gonna just eat it because you're used to eating it so Oh so before we could be think we're not worried about this because comets at night I don't care if you eat it cuz I'm dead get rid of the Comets eat it that look if you heat it up let's be aware of basic in the morning but here you know let these comets anymore if you do because comets in the previous times it's normally then you see doing it because you know any right no no regular fair you asking your question optical some which is not to eat it no that means like this very good question he's saying the whole because how much is not to eat it according to toys for what serve you hood it doesn't know that can be hood it means you can eat it right now usually we say you gotta get rid of your house from comets before Pesach so that through outpace on when you may come across comets you shouldn't need it right remember without boudicca's comets they could be comets on your counter because it was bottle like midday license so you come down color made in the morning you see a bagel right and you don't even think you eat it by doing the COS hummert's so a whole pace that he won't come to eat it but review this harshest something else during the dick when you find it when you're hoping you're hoping it your have it in your hand right and you may yet will soon see the Hammond really this vehemently disagree with that for an obvious reason that the Kumar is going to explore so it's an interesting argument but the Gemara is now gonna do the rest of the suger basically till the Mishnah is compared review who deserve you and the rest of shafts in other words we're gonna dig out we're gonna dig out from our knowledge all the Mishnah swill review hood that argues with the Summum about similar situations and the gomorrah is gonna struggle with this because what's going to appear is that of you that actually had the opposite view in other areas what we're learning here is as follows when you have to do a mitzvah there are Bannen a good thing but it may bring you by mistake to violate an assumed annotator ruby hood is saying no don't do it that's a how am I saying I'm fine the camera is gonna now bring up one case after another case after another case where this premise is being contradicted so we're now gonna be this sugar is gonna be dealing now with other issues outside of Pesach to see what W hood this view is because we always assume that the tannot Liam it wasn't much they had a debate and like I'm in the mood of of of saying Oscar moves the they had perspectives they had a Mahalo that pervaded their whole life it was a it was a sack I am how they looked at everything how they looked at Halawa and it wasn't only animosity was really in Russian it's also it was a that this time I had that time I had you know there's not every much locus in Shas is an isolated self-contained issue they'll be hooded today this is in a very stringent mood we're making the missive today it didn't work it didn't work that way you know like come as you know today your teachers in the is in a challenging mu don't start our class McCallum it's ridiculous to assume that that's not the size of Toyota which is he Hamas will been a scam Laennec alarming there's Omaha lattissima Hollis there's a Derek there's a way you have to understand it there's a perspective you could go deeper and deeper and deeper and that's what the Gemara is now gonna be struggling with me Gaza of you who there is this really the profile of review hood was of you who they're really reviewed it really makes a de that you shouldn't deal with forbidden food why Dilma Aucilla make lemonade because I'm afraid that you're gonna eat it that's what we learned review this says no contact with forbidden food cuz you may come to eat it that's clearly what he believes here that's how you he doesn't say it clearly but that's how the Gemara explained his for it we want to explain what a sweater was nebulous said he now let it be buoyed that after the sixth hour come said you have to be my dick what's this farted as far as he's afraid you may come to eat it I'm saying it not afraid you're gonna come to eat it so that's that's our deal Marcella met Martin and we have a mission the Mishna says very interesting story we Chikara Vollmer ones they were mock rib the carbon dimer the Olson you can go out that day you might soon shook you shall I'm and you find that the market places of your Chilean hey Malayan chemic are filled with flour the Kali Kali is oven roasted grain grain that was roasted in the oven you find it in your shall I am shall I be Rutzen shall come him a niacin but this was a fact but it was not the desire of the cumin deviated mayor will be hood I am a beer up somehow coming my you I see it was absolutely brats on Hakam it was absolutely no problem in other words the mission and miss Ackerman are cos the sama Sian is describing a sociological fact which used to do work which was basically this everybody knows that on the 16th day of Nissen there was an obligation as an obligation and tired and Pasha cemre you have to bring a unique type of carbon and that is you take the new barley the new barley that just grew the new crop of barley you take and that barley had to be grinded the kernels have to be grinded into flour this is barley flour and it had to be refined again and again and again 13 times that's how refined the flour had to be and then the Corian took a climate's a fistful of this flour burnt it on the MS baihe and the rest of the flour was eaten by the cayenne him in the besan McNish and the moment that happened the moment that happened all the new crop and the whole area strong some say even hood florets became mutter and this is called Kadesh right others before this happened I'm now that I eat my new crop so if I go to my field and there's wheat and this barley and there's oats and this Ryan is spelt I'm now let a harvest it and eat it why because I have to wait for the carbon layer to be Nikolov in the base emitters which was on the 16th day of Nissen the second day of Pesach and after the carbon ointment that's when I can eat the new club dish till that point I have to eat the old stuff not the ones that grew right now from the earth that were planted after last year pace so anything I'm eating is things from the old it's called the ashram the Kaddish is forbidden comes the mission and says you would go out that day yeah 11 o'clock in the morning to the streets of your schlomit the first day of Kalama and you found everywhere fresh flour and and and and grain that was already roasted in the oven Colli Colli they would take grain they would roast it in the oven so that mayor says the hum were very upset about this why were they upset about this because in order to have flour from the new crap it means you have to harvest it before Yom Tov you have to grind it before Yom death yet the period before Yom Tov and that means people were hand handling with Kadosh before it was mustard to eat review oh this says it was perfectly fine why did it either say it's perfectly fine what's the issue here so the Gemara says below the like a gaza w of the de la silla metalman a the main issue here is what's the problem the problem is are you gonna eat it ripp may your holds if you harvest it before and you're handling with it you may take a kernel and eat it people used to eat grains as snacks this was part of it when it's soft you can eat it you take a seed or you take the grain and people with munch on it it was a snack like we do oddish oddish these comments so what the question is what was the difference this is a sir and this is uh sir but w hood this says that a common were fine I don't care if you're harvested as long as you don't eat it and the moment cutters moment cutters becomes butcher the flower is ready we see here that if you hood this is you're not afraid that people may come to eat it you trust them that they're going to remember and be conscientious not to eat it monkeys is a no-no how much every patient is not chorus it's a laugh and publishes allows that's both a love if he's afraid by others yeah absolutely yeah it's not chorus it's not chorus remember like trashy even the common sayin out little b-boy the criminal of Pesach cuz of chorus right but we're talking on at a face it's a biblical a view now let's eat let him the Kali vikarma low so sloth and some I Emma's am after the carbon I know you're allowed to eat it no no not a carbonate just a lot Malka Malka yes yes yes yes it's a lot man I'm tired I know same a biblical prohibition to eat huh - before the time yeah before the time yeah and after the carbon based on Mick - there's no carbon armas you have to wait for the day to finish you have to wait for two zyanya you have to wait for two zyanya and they couldn't use those you could never use cottage for baking matzah unless you baked it the second their face then you good the flower for Kaddish you can't use yet to use the old flower yeah anything that became mutter from last colors is good but if you planted your grain in the month of Tishrei for - or the end of the summer right people plant the grain or the wind through the fall that new crop of grain you couldn't eat even though it grew until after the second day of Pesach when there was a carbonara that's called hush when you go to the stores and you see your song ha - that's what they're talking about they're talking about when you buy a babka cake and you'll say on it your tongue it basically means that it's the old grain it's not the new the new crop of grape yes Oh rubbish was the question is was huh - astronauts Lord so not that's a McCoy curse Italian so they had to wait till the end of the day right they have to wait you're right yeah right right right right on my rubber position it's a much like this if it's not even close large or not if cutters cut it so nice yeah on my rubber rubber said you right I'll explain to you the difference shiny oddish oddish is different meat I shall are you tired - loyal ally they kid tofu's aha they didn't just allow them to harvest it with a sickle they obligated them to harvest it before the carbon armor with their hands and that's a whole different story than using a sickle when you're harvesting it with your hands it's a tremendous a share you're going to remember that it's uh sir and therefore you won't come to eat it that's why W Hooda was fine with it because there was this reminder right there you usually use a sickle but till they brought the oiler they were not allowed to use a sickle and the reason is because there's an expression in the Flemish there's an expression in the himesh if I have a semi summer raesha Syria Malakian the first harvest you should bring to the client so we learned from here that the oiler has to be the first harvest so you now let it cut grain stomm unless you don't cut it which means you don't use a sickle if you do it with your hands it's a Shenoy so then they allowed you to do it because they allow you to do it only with your hand because if you do it with a sickle it's forbidden because the Toyota says and indicates that the first cutting has to be brought to the coin which means you now let us thumb cut not only and I want to eat you now that even caught you now let even go the first cutting has to be brought to the current I can't stand in my field and caught forget about eating so the only way they allowed you to do it is if may not tire it's not called regular cutting which means you do it with your hands not with a sickle it's a tional so when I tried it that's not called Kira because it's just like tearing it out so therefore you're allowed to do it because that scheana is demanded then we're not afraid a person is gonna harvest it and eat it so rabbit we're comets that doesn't happen you find comets and it's a regular piece of summits and inadvertently your hunger you gonna compete it Oh Malaya bye yeah bye you tell zarbor excuse me tinder but if this works while you're harvesting but he never called the michael Omaima you finished harvesting what happens afterwards you thresh it right you take a flail and you beat like we learned earlier you beat the stork and you separate the colonel's from the chaff and then you take the kernels and you do what's called tina tina means you grind it into flour and then you take the flour you do what's called hard cada you sift the flour now forget about the sickle now there's no ization now you could eat it so why would w who they allow it mela Bashar skipped off during harvesting there's something to remind you but not during grinding and sifting so much as challah kasha it's not a question because Tina Burnett hired the yacht here too they did it with a deviation when they grinded it they used a hand mill rather than a water mill a hand mill is much more complex and more tedious than a water mill they used a hand mill and her car the sifting they did alga benefi on the back of the sieve they took the sift and they turned it over and they did it upside down and therefore there was a deviation also in the process of grinding and sifting through out so now we're not afraid a person is gonna come to eat it because everything was done in a unique fashion to remind you that you're now letting to eat it and therefore w hood that says it was a problem we're comets he is afraid the Gomora says one second that's the point that they used to harvest the the the remember people needed on edge in economy you need an edge so they used to do it before with machinery and they would prepare flour and everybody was very excited and remember who she lion was filled with customers oily regala yeah exactly and the supply was smaller than the demand exactly and it did well and also the people needed if they wanted food they wanted food and sometimes the old crap maybe there was a shortage whatever it is so that's why they used to do it it was very good for business it was good for everybody was win-win so the mayor says yes they did it but they didn't ask permission they would they would they were bad boys they were troublemakers and immunise said absolutely not you're wrong become him completely we're fine with it so our buyer is telling us why I mean rob is telling us why because there was a she knew therefore this doesn't contradict you to be hooded by summons review there is afraid that people are gonna eat he is afraid here is not afraid because he's forcing their enforcing deviations that make you conscientious and cautious not to eat it may it probably feels that despite the shimmery and the hunger people will still snack have made is more stringent yet it made is much more stringent which which will soon see the problem with that because it may it is the main disputant of review hooda remain of you are the two colleagues that usually argue so whenever the Summum argue with review hood it if mayor is one of those people it's just remain has more people on a side so we're gonna discuss that in the in a moment that mayor is also contradicting himself because in our missioner that mayor says you're a lot of duplicates comments which means I'm not afraid you're gonna eat it and over there he is afraid we're gonna get to the mayor in a moment but now we're focusing gonna be hood drag the Gemara Alejandra turn on one second a buyer continues his refutation of raba your answer is really very limited because we have a mission er quoits you're in base our solution base our schlosser means a field that cannot live off rainwater it has to be gain in my hand by human intervention it's called base our slogan there are fields that the range suffices there are fields that you have to irrigate by hand meaning you have to arrange for water to come through canals to irrigate to water your fill that's called base Epsilon you're allowed to harvest grain of such a field before the carbon diamond but shebar muhkam grain and valleys have a location but you can't make piles of them you can harvest them at pause and these are harvesting without us without a without a deviation meaning you could do it with your hand what's this Safari here you could do it with a sickle not only with your hand what's the smarter this sweater is a very interesting smarter take a look at Rashi shall base are mahkum - vaca de louvain are muck grain that grows in the valleys in in deep places the shale base are mahkum vishal baisama the time emma furnish the reason is in Mishnah in menorca Zion Aleph cost of effort Omer we have a contradiction one-pass success and it's really the same pasta can purchase Emmer one parsec says I'm going to quote deposit key savour you all the arts are shiny noise and lehem lucas artemis kathira but have a sim as I'm aeration seriously Malakian when you come to the land that I will give you you should harvest its harvest you should cut the grain and then bring an Omer the beginning of your cording to the Cayenne we have here a contradiction very subtle first it says when you come to the land you should harvest the grain and then bring an Omer to the coin which means you harvest the grain and then you take one Omer Omer it's not a big measurement and I'm here is a tenth of an eighth which is the volume of of 43.2 eggs right that's what it is forty three point two eggs and and somewhere between 8 and 12 ounces depends if I am nor the cause I wish but somewhere there so you caught it and you take a dimer to the coin what does this sound like you cut everything and you take a diamond but then the pasta continues but have a sim as I made racial series of alikoya the first cut should be brought to the kyon which means that's the first cut you know at a cup before that's what Rashi is saying consolation I'm excited to miss Cassie river basin caught and bring alma mater liquor called employment you could cut me for the carbonite cost of a diamond in Malaysia series of the Mishima should item the call cut sir this is the first harvest rockets at how do we reconcile so the Mishna says me Malcolm shot the may be a Mary at the Coit sarcoid employ from those fields where your ladder bring the Omer from your now little harvest before the carbon Obi Malcolm see yet then maybe I am at the coin set but from those regions where you can't bring the carbon I'm air you're a ladder cut what's not but pay to color carbon as we learned in Monaco's a movie and Silas lemon sir you can't bring flour for a carbon minister to our chef including the carbon diamond lemon base has fallen knots from a feel that needs fertilizer let me buy such locking knots from a field that needs irrigation by hand but let me base our Malcolm that's from a field in the depths of the valleys Malaysia to I shall not in Amman I move her because the grain that grows is not choice it's not very good and for a min come we want the best what do we see from here we see from me that they were filled that you're now letting use a sickle you could only do it with your hand those are the fields from where you could bring the carbon where there it says racial scripture fields where you can't bring the carbon armor even though but the evidence from there it's yo-yo sir but like a pillar you can't bring over there you're allowed to use a sickle and you don't have to use your hand because the tire clearly indicates that there are places where you could cut the harvest before they armor and the camera continues I buy it who Kim Nicola and the gemara says that this mission is following rabbi yehuda in other words w-who the whole that there are places where you can harvest the OMA without your hands you can use a sickle so there's no she nuit and still he says it's perhaps uncommon this completely undermines what rava said that the reason by Omer he satisfied is because it's done with such a noise Michael Omaima what are you gonna say the mission it clearly says your latter harvest these fields without a deviation so you can't tell me that it's talking about another whose make oh it says clearly that's going to contribute even eating this food would be a sir till after the carbon nightmare and it's according to W that means of you that says you allowed to deal with food without a deviation and we're not afraid you're gonna eat it with contradicts is perspective here we actually says my Ecola maimie how let go are some she knew you you can't say over there that is a she knew it is notionally the hockey rink Donnie it says you can harvest which means boggle with a sickle for like us women Dilma asila medical welcome Allah he could have you heard the rumor sacks terminals medically Bhishma the Gemara they proves that this mission of follows immune the mythical Tommy's safer because it says in the end of the mission er actually reflect on the flamer the people of Yuriko used to cut before the OM ever like me could be other common and the holland did in protest from marina man Chamath luda my miserable initial review hood the Gemara proves over there that this Mishnah follows rabbi yehuda so therefore raba answer seems refuted by this Mishnah Elham Arabi is our bias says i'm gonna explain to you there is a different smart others boggle been a comet sly bottle mean a that's the difference new grain that is a sir a person is separated he's detached from it comments he's not detached what does it mean others is us or all year it's uh sir a whole winter a whole order my whole fall till spring till the carbon diamond it's uh sir people are used to the fact when you see grain you have to stop and say i'm now let a snack from these kernels its colors bubble mean a were detached there's only a few months that it becomes permissible but comets 365 days a year seven days a week besides the seven days of pacer you're not detached from it so there's a much bigger trash that inadvertently w that says when you bite the comments two hours ago you were allowed to eat comments right two hours ago you will not eat the comments now you're hungry you see a piece of comments boy did you may come to eat it that's the whole Suvari here that's the research it's not that my father's desertion we even when there's no shiney we're not rebuked is not afraid or my rather other says what second the review that review the cache it up on another ravana my kasha you focusing on the argument interview hood the in consistency what about the rabbis on the rabbis meaning rip Maher was one of the people who would argue with ruby hood red mayor says you are conscious by others that they're gonna eat it that's why celebrities are coming so why buy comments Israel mayor unconcerned not concerned he says you lighted up comets looks like a mother fathers which they're not the tact which they detached from he asked Susan Mayer certainly comets so Rover says let me at you missing one point he's telling his friend that by you missing one point Rebbe hood a tribunal Akashic Edition enum review hood is not contradicting AB you know like you said which I agree with that others people are detached from its people are not detached that Abunda there Ivana na mele Akasha I'll explain to you why the rabbis are not being inconsistent and here of it says the famous Laura who acts my Matt hazard a loveless certified mail calm in a what because comments what thickest comments what are you doing when you do him thickest comet you walking around with a candle and you're looking for comets why MIT has it all over the surface you're trying to burn the comments are you really afraid that the person is gonna come eat it maila by Kadosh what are you doing you're harvesting grain in order to make flour which you want to eat here I'm afraid that by mistake you're gonna forget that you're gonna eat a kernel you're gonna eat a piece of grain you're gonna munch on it ain't gonna be either by comets that may it was tiny that abundant are saying what's the point of Dicker's comets it's not like I'm walking around in my house and I find a piece of comets and I eat it I'm doing biggest comets and you'll ask the person what are you doing I'm looking for Cummings why are you looking for how much you want to eat it that's me show them I want to burn it I want to get rid of it I want to throw it out of the house I want to be my characters Bisou so when a person is whole objective is the whole purpose of what he's doing is all palaces the sci-fi I'm not suspicious I'm not afraid that he's gonna forget and eat it because if he's just the we're unless he's in a comatose state if he's just aware of what he's doing his whole function is to get rid of the Comets not only not to eat it to burn it so we are you not sure that a person hasn't come to eat it because of course he could come to eat it by mistake but the whole Indian that he's doing it is to get rid of the Comets to get it out of the house so ksama not kosher and yet to Buda is questions reviewed is saying even though you're doing because comets to burn it you still have to be afraid of my mistake you can eat it but met but we see clear there is no contradiction between Kadesh and comets why is not a contradiction for a beholder like a bias said because car there's bubbleman a comet's like bad omen a and for the helmets not a machinery because other she may come to eat because why not you just harvesting it you may forget but comets is the whole thing you're doing is getting rid of it so therefore we're not afraid that you're gonna come either - she says who actually macaws at eye level the surface I forgot about our magazine on Padova tschosik my shillelagh peeve even though usually we're afraid how come a my refrain that when you're handling with something that's forbidden you're gonna put it in your mouth we are afraid and that's why by kibosh we forget we did not want them to harvest it Huckabee because comets lack allure magazine why the whole apps Michael iske is a bahamut's any element has a little surfer because the whole Macias of looking for comets is only to destroy it aim because it currently is sir god Alesha you don't have a better seeker and a better commemoration something reminding you better that you now let it eat it you know that you don't need a sim and how you do it when you do it the hole in your hole the whole reason you're touching comments the whole reason you're looking for comets is to be an item in our shoulders to get rid of it so a mikasa currently is sir Gotham is it that's the whole new code [Music] apparently w hood the fields that people could really be here in the dreamlike state the holes are how this is motor so we said why cause her this bad omen a so no no bottom in a whole year bottom in a whole year and others others people are afraid of but comets let's have different part but comets people eat a whole year right the first case cuz it was a shiny it's long ago the whole reasons he's holding a candies in that the scenery that's the shimmer that he's holding a candle you saying like the first part but the first word will refute it their first verse is not a must the first one was refuted that's before we brought up the of their opponent right that's before the bullshitting Obama is there's no yeah because some sofa tiniest is Arashi mastectomy knockers who says that acquainted that how come you have to be buddy to come at the middle of Pesach which is not like Rashi says here so people struggle what's rashes opinions income surfer says that once the gomorrah introduces this samara who acts my Mikasa de Lovelace sorry free uncle calm ma then rashly understood that the haben could say you could be buddy to come it's the middle of Pesach how so even if it's an issue chorus because because the whole Union of dick is homage is something that will prevent you from eating it according to the hakama Tom I thought there is a interesting McMichael between mu hood and a feminine comes to Shabbos about the vagina miss Calvin la vache name is Calvin according to Doug Shipman is mutter according to w hood it's ah sir which means as follows let's say on Shabbos I do something completely without intent completely without intent you're schlepping you're schlepping a bench in the bungalow colony and you make a far you can make a furrow in the earth but it's not my purpose I'm trying to get a bench over to your house I want to eat there but I'm putting it on the sand so it may make a farro right what's the UH what's the halacha that losses like rip Shimon dovish animus Calvin is motor unless it's procedure which means it's inevitable it's we're all gonna make a farro but if yes sir not that we walk on grass is it possible that the grass is coming and of course it's possible but everybody does it you don't think twice why it's called over Shana Moscato review the disagrees if you go halts right yeah okay maybe who the holds that over Shana miss Calvin is actually uh sir which is a big finish that loss is not like that that looks like a persimmon that over Shana miss Calvin is mud - that's the halacha today but over unless again if it's secured a ship it's much inevitable so then it's part of the Kevon but if it's a diversion a Miss Carmen tibideaux holds that it's it's also similar McLucas is Malacca Shana triphala goofer repealed or holds you higher on meaning I Milazzo where you do it but you're not interested in the goof of the Malacca you have a side that gender for example there is a mouse in the house it's dead and then you throw it out to your sister album you're not interested in carrying it right you're not interested in the goof I'm a lock you don't want it to me just want to get it out of your house similarly the to block ashamed circular goofer so rip Shimon holds that I mean I try to your pottery hood this is not your hiya we have to be in the carbon crafters even blockage in the circular goof oh yeah okay there's a store this is a buda yeah maybe hood this says dauber shana miss Calvin is awesome I mean there are bottom but it's also yeah it's not much the same eclectic more changed a little but it's on the same Mahalo choice was compares the two and moussaka Shabbos we have a story in my sector Shabbos llama death chemo famous story that a few tannoy was sitting and speaking about Rome right so W Hooda started to praise them he said they built off beautiful cities there's bathing houses everywhere there's bridges there very good the Romans are very very good they did wonderful things your persimmon said please they did it all for themselves they're self-centered narcissistic hungry animals who are just want power and tyranny they did it all for themselves of shimon sir and a BITC was quiet so what happened they said rejoice yes to go into Edna's olive Shimon has to be killed this is where should be and he ran into the cave for 12 years and you'll be Hooda whatever either they've sublimated yeah you see the taiga shoving all this huh the question is when you do something without qivana will you do something without intent okay take Rome yeah they're my cloak is about Rome is the same as like this my sector Shabbos yep Shimon says daughter Shaina mascara motor you know why I couldn't care less if there's no Kevon it's nothing if there's no come on it's nothing if Simmons says Rome I don't care they did nice things that Cavallo was horrible it's worthless if you this holds no lovers animus Cavan there's still a sir why because you did it the iki is the my son at the Kurama but mainly even though there was no you made a furry didn't wanna I don't care but you made it says it's awesome Malaka change circle of goof I don't care why but you did I'm a walker rabbuna says if the shiniest of the mulatto was the air it's good it's a real Bellanca they're free could praise wrong david ershon is covering us okay so now you're doing Dickus comets you doing because comets right according up you do we haven't been serious it's not much the same lakota I'm just comparing it in other words the thought is to say Thomas Shannon is Calvin rabbuna says you doing they go you're not even the home say what do you mean you do in particular so much how you gonna eat it your whole qivana is Mikasa over the surfer that's if you look at the qivana if you look at the curve ordinates a joke the guys trying to get rid of calm but she's gonna eat the comments that's if you looking at that at the curve one of the close calls if you look at the my sir what is he doing he's picking her bread he's picking up bread so mainly to be who do who says that the Kabir miser and the qivana is really doesn't affect it because even though vache name is Calvin on Shabbos is still awesome why because I acknowledge that am I so without a Kevon is still a significant myself so the mice of the kiss comments itself that's the Makuta and even if a person is not thinking much it's the result because comets may their beauty is harsh its cartridge for hey look a cup on them like a Doody huh the merciful wrong verification say yes yeah yeah yeah yeah my sucker sucker okay no cuz I I was thinking I learned the gun when I was thinking why would you target so good Savannah it's such a powerful swallow Sony doesn't ring c'mon you know it's not it's not a constant over Shana Miss Cavanaugh because we're gonna predict his comets it's not about Kevon of maka because begin the kuda that our Meister without qivana by w hood has the whole Tychus according up shimon without qivana the mice is not a miser it's not called a stockholm Alessa Shabbos ah Shipman was Plumas a tailor muttered to safer now sire he looks at the qivana yeah looks at the come on ya know the thick is the plumie is the Kevon of it if it's top agenda miss Calvin it's not a dollar not a Dover it's not a molester shabbos because it doesn't have that surah doesn't have the prettiest of it you did everything but that's not nicaya shake it shook hello gopher over there you had qivana but you didn't have qivana for the mulatto it's still motor I mean I told her it's mommy scooter you did mommy's the Malacca but not for not for that person you shot over the light because there's a high low can't sleep somebody can't sleep just please shut you shut the light according to the view hood then you're high even attacked me on carbon Tatas Accord they were shipping your party your party why you did them alongside yet come on man it's even more but because you didn't need the Milwaukee you weren't interested in the Milwaukee you're ready you're ready putt-putt travel ah sir so dobry Shana miss Calvin is much more because over these how they want to do the Malacca so with its motor but it's even their abundance motor contraption there's a word is a word from the balsa drum I think the SAR Shalom one of the I saw that it says myself Asuka that Shimon says if I only lift her as coal oil and cooling Menard in I can exempt the whole world from din from judgment says why because if Schumann holds Dover Shana miss Calvin Wilton if Sherman says that ultimately any Jew who doesn't have a de it's really dovish animus Calvin in other words deep deep down he's not interested in the availa he's looking for some enjoyment he's looking to namah Spain he's angry is upset the creamiest the pen amis of a yield wants to do are shams rots like the ramble says locals garish and Paraguay's so Meili says ultimately snobbish animus Calvin so the Rasheeda biscuits he could dismiss everything and so he says hey schmuck of heart that's economy cetera the Buda holds the mice is they can am I so weak the mice say that's the truth that's the vault I don't care about surah so melaka I care about the samurai melaka and the truth is as we'll see later so I don't know if it's math simpler this Suki Mahmud I'm just putting it together I'll cop on them as we call it we do D but but we'll see later in the mcleod case review hood then the common about beer hummert's will see how this manage plays out in allahu la mesa what touch me so mins we'll see well well see in a later sugar that maybe hood there's going leshiy toss a and a lot of issues a lot of areas yeah some Hedren continued till almost the end of the Gemara yes energy show indexes shawl and above all that I didn't want it to go the so song yeah yeah yeah yeah but by the time of Ruby who don't have mayor there was a real functioning son had room it was after the base-emitter it wasn't New York shall I am anymore they said hadn't won at the gulls went from you shall I am Teavana it went it Sepoy he went back to a van went to a lot of places there's a whole saga nourishes Shana but there was a some hydrant was Anderson hadn't continued for another few hundred years but then it couldn't be sustained anymore they have a son hadn't yet have Smith the issue appears from i shouldave know yet amid them it was just xavius the jews were getting scattered they couldn't do it anymore so they were move out too late yeah yeah yeah so these debates are not stomach as debate somewhere in a corner these were the dates of the happiness and that they were members of the Sinatra every month like it's usually yet this was an argument of Hoffman son Hunter I mean was it the argument right before the vote was it an argument previously but there was an argument that and and they had to pass can Liholiho yeah we know of the names you had the Nazi of the son had a burden of the son hundred yet 71 people who had to make every major decision but there was a decision about halacha should we make this later should we make this zero is this the shot and titers this not the shot and Toyota should we make this Takano chronica candles we'd like to the son of - I'm reading the Megillah all these things do it they would tack these with a calmness that is under what they weren't do at the base don't eat chicken with milk gravy I see ugly the cameras hasn't fallen he held your line with no he ate chicken with maque he said the Seder is a fool it doesn't make sense there was a vote nobility said Lily used to eat chicken with milk the Gemara says cool you're not eating chicken with multiple our Toyota he felt that there's no need to compare chicken to me a common felt not chicken is by people considered meat then of chicken if you do chicken burgers chicken cheeseburgers you can end up doing meat cheeseburgers but this was a real Marcus same thing when do you stop any comments yes say my collectors have made of you or the one when when the issue of Commons begins does this your comments begin yeah yeah yeah they had to debate yeah yeah yeah the fish no then there's later generations everything changed because then it's local stuff once the Sun Headroom was gone everything became localized she'll have in this country you have this in this country it's not there was no any there was no sensual body through the Messiah Claudius on they couldn't do it anymore so kidney is in the Middle Ages - Kinnison assert kidney is on pace right like beans and rice legumes what's called they answered it because their fields they used to grow together with wheat and they saw a lot of problems despite the communities never asserted so that's when I got a problem with rice if it would have been by the Sun Hedren then it would be everybody there's no mid sea as the Sun had written said something because comet is on the Ashkenazim those are the thing thickest comets is Fe jus why because it comes from the Sun headman comes from the tunnel yet all the Tacomas that come from then you'll have every jewel be Makai of every doodle never be differences anything that happened post that for example davon Inge you'll have no subscribe no sir gosh can ask because it doesn't come from then there were no different they could be no they could be different min Hagen if the Sun Hedren didn't pass him right it couldn't be no you were sucking mama if you if you went against he was sucking mommy what didn't have a place in Aloha be Shama basically argued once that looks like they still you have to follow some heavier most of them went son had it depends but most of them yeah in the 400s in the 5th century a Bayern rava yeah and by the way kiddush ahoy dish went the kiddush asteroid this was the same thing there was no calendar as long as it was a Sun head and they had witnesses testify for the new moon same thing they didn't use calendars yeah once the Sun Hedren was the was dissolved so Keisha Kurdish was dissolved they couldn't do it anymore so not they had a calendar that's what we use today the Sanhedrin was dissolved and the whole system changed since then there was no Mitzvah that the rabbi could make that's Messiah of Claudius no there's no such a thing anymore there could be man hug him they could be humorist OCONUS even I've been against him all this tack honest you know about marriage and this it was Makai of his careless nor all the other killers faster derive is rabhasa destroyer you follow the best in but there's no one best and that's Makai of Claudius or no such a thing anymore they can't do it you can't do it anymore because for the Sun heading to function you have to have that level of intensity and cohesiveness and and unity that they couldn't sustain anymore you know talmidim who sit with years by the rebels and they have smith it was a whole system that they couldn't do anymore to keep the Sun headin alive would have been a because if it would have been hijacked it's the end of it the fact that they dissolved the Sun hadn't really saved the Jewish people just imagine in the 1800s right if there was a Sanhedrin and say the reform movement hijacked the Sun a dress what would have been done what would have been it would have been the end of halacha they would have made a tack on an exit who would have been the end because there was no Sun hadron so odd that Yama's and nobody can hijack you disguise it was tremendous thing because even if if country after country falls to the reform yeah if this once tattle is one shtetl with a rough and calm with him in a ship with Herschel tomorrow if they're not changing and that's what happened that's nepoleon napoleon forced to juice to make a Sun hadn't but there was a fake thing I mean they did it the Karen order yeah he wanted it to be matter intermarriage and they had to do they made us an hadrons to appease him but it wasn't a real thing it was he made us inherently otherwise yeah intermarriage should be motor Eric ceased role is not part of the agenda Napoleon wants him to change a lot of things and then he would accept them and they had they one of the great early had arrived of with the the Karen one of the big boys camp he went and he basically ran it as I play that he played a game he played a game he made us and hadn't but he knew it wasn't real it was just like in the early 1800s but the fact that there was no Sun Hedren protected the integrity no because if you haven't sent us you might have had some people but you didn't you didn't because because there was an immune system cause he who got Smith's at the beans and then he had to get Smith from a previous generation and those people had real tired Authority whenever he was giving you Smith huh yeah when it may is giving you Smith sure these were people who got submission from the previous ones all the way back to much Moreno they didn't have submitted to a torque they gave me to the people who were going him and years Shema him and so forth can there be once in a while somebody was corrupt yeah but the system was a very holistic system the system work it anti Emma's aunt works have you no respect in this even today you'll see it works let's say there's a rubber Orthodox show a real ordinal and one Shabbos he says today we're bringing in the piano right and instead of filling on Sunday were putting on tefillin on Shabbos yeah he lives in America nobody can do anything but what's gonna happen nobody's gonna take him seriously anymore as it as a thority of allaha because it's a shelf America let's see even cross mussalam 10,000 rabbis go corrupt and they decide to change I love it it's not gonna affect you this kite as long as as you have the books it means this guy is not interested let's say each slept with him a million people that's what they reformed it they slept millions of people with them it didn't affect it I mean it affected it in reality of course for millions of Jews but it didn't affect the purity and the integrity of Allah as long as you haven't we could trace back every minute you go back to the price can we go back to show Samar if you go do the tour you go to there and mom you go to there is showing him you go to the Gemara you go to the Mishnah you go to the zoo can you see it I can't change it somebody who come tomorrow and say there's no sea of Nicolas comets anymore towel on the night of before pacer we're changing the water it's gonna be a joke I mean you could say it but it's not it's not real the immune system of our lhasa is one that can't be broken by anybody because they wrote everything down if they wouldn't have written down nobody didn't only write it down they showed exactly how it developed exactly they didn't just write down this is the hollow Kiev doop knickers comments yeah the Gemara pointed out why when who said we're why a candle why not a candle why by day what you understand how they did it and they we know the names we know who said bitte Lou said thicker when how what everything is with names so they you can't you can't Forge it you can't Forge it a guy today could say I'm being my vassal I walk it's not gonna be taken seriously yet there before they do it but but there was no argument to it the Reform said it's a new age we want to be accepted yeah they didn't have a real argument to it what do they refute what do they refute what they said well you ought to be McConnell Shabbos what Shabbos is Sunday what they didn't you understand and I was saying this is right so even if somebody wants to change how lawsuit today it's not gonna have value because the the system is so clear everything has a source you can trace it back all the way to the generations there's nothing you can't play games with it anything we do what we don't do we know exactly when it started and how it started why it started by whom it started now are you with that if you can argue with that fine yeah there could be arguments that they they'll argue today about kinwa what's the brush on quinoa fine that's a real argument are you allowed to eat quinoa on Pesach okay those are good arguments right those are real arguments things that come up today electricity questions IVF these are new things but ah so by they had to dissolve the Sun headed by dissolving the Sun Hedren and writing everything down in detail everything is secure now nobody can play games with it what am I gonna do burn every Gomorrah in the world burn every shunoros in the world it's just that that was the power that's what they did the vision was unbelievable how they did it because it's secured it secured the Eternity when you had a real Sun Hadron happening you didn't need this because you had live communities and it was fine it was very good now Buda I'm now see already saw the beginning of the end so he wrote everything down in Machias with why did he mention all the McCoy Gerson because he wanted everybody to understand this is this that's that of a Hooley your typhus very important this how it worked that's why that's why the mastoid Kison are so important people wonder you learn all these much like listen like what do you want to tell me what to do no they don't tell you what to do if they tell you what do I can also make a book today and say what to do thank you very still they don't do that they never tell you what to do I'm gonna tell you everything and you'll see what happened you rather we see that it's MS it wasn't stuff a Roth got up to say today we would mean by the comments will be doesn't work like that who are you who comes to why did you say what was your source did anybody argue with you and then you can say this amyloid cause there's a halakhah that's why this system of Gemara is so intricate that everything was recorded there's no loopholes there's no like somebody you know creeped in and did his own thing nobody made their own melaka Malka here everything is documented recorded yeah even if you that you say then what's your that you really hold like this you don't hold like this everything is is is is get judgment to the deal because then you could trust it such a thing you could trust you see that nobody is manipulating the system there's nobody who has a little money who has a little cover that has some buildings and he's manipulating it there's no manipulation of what it would him it what are you manipulating right and you see it constantly but the Gemara finished it went on to the next level yeah they were showing him they did exactly the same thing they wrote everything the arguments and then after item and that's how they did it it's it's it was a very very powerful way of maintaining the MS of it and it's it's indisputable you know you could say I'm not interested in it that you could say but if you're interested in the truth this is the truth of how you described elip it's not like there was no it wasn't a half Cavell where somebody sat down and decided we're making new mitzvos today we're making new our lockers today we're answering this while sitting that it doesn't work that way you don't ask her things oh who was then [Music] what's gonna be century stuff yes yeah they saw they saw it says a slicer /mf a rotary circle turn about but was not supposed to be written down because they wanted the living connection between Reba and Tom made them it was very alive but he realized if it's not gonna be written down then ultimately you'll have charlatans and con artists and it's done your Yiddish guide is done I'm Yankel smart guys gonna get up in his place he's gonna make his here this minute he has my Sawyer miss Sawyer the word mr. Woodman Sawyer me the tsardom means I want to see them as sorry you have to see the Messiah if you could show it to me it's Messiah sir doesn't mean I'm gonna bad mood I'm in an angry mood I need to get rid of my brother or get rid of somebody else I have my own traditions doesn't work that way then it becomes tyranny becomes an exercise in power and people don't trust it the reason people trusted halacha and rub on him and buzzed in is because the integrity there was a commitment to a mess I'm not here to make my rules I'm not trying to control my community try to do the right thing it's this fighting at the source be a very micro Associates of mine every three that's why I'm very much been on sources always I just feel it's it's it's it's much more respectful when there's a source for everything you could see yeah oh yes and then yeah and then you could say and this is an idea that I think based on it fine but you know you know what what's what's what says what doesn't say what's quoted what's not called what's your that they knew the responsibility because they knew the responsibility that's why they didn't cut corners they didn't cut corners take the system they could have written the night before pay stuff you do but in his combats and you use a candle no how do you know a candle why by night why do you have to check what Hiba call us to check do bitl I mean all these things believer hooli there's nothing mom has taken for granted even even this thing or we learned today they sold flour in Eurasia lion Ramaiya said it was against the rules nobuta says it was pro the rules even that there was nothing they ignored is it right to sell flour in your salon or not Reb may you said it's not a good thing they don't have permission W this says you're wrong it's your opinion it's not true that has come with various we're very happy about it now remember they can argue about this cuz they lived after the base of McNish they lived after they lived a hundred years after the former base time weaknesses they weren't there by the carbon diamond right yuusha lion was already nobody was new Schley many more people were there but it wasn't that same thing so they were arguing a hundred and fifty two hundred years ago maybe others said it was fine it may I said it wasn't fun it wasn't a gala la jolla MYSA for them but even then they're arguing about seems like an insignificant thing people are selling flowers selling flower W that says it's fine it mayor says no it's officer you see it's sister and everyone has a reason for it I say this you say this there's a reason not stung I decided it's a good thing it's a bad thing I don't like you so Mellie a flower becomes also such a thing there's no agendas that's enough think how do you know there's no agendas people have agendas yeah I don't like you you owe most of the groceries I make the the flour awesome so it's a joke it's a joke don't do with God's done so that's why it's very very important that everything was documented with a reason with us father how it developed : you could trust it tarnish about Tyler it's something you can trust because they it's all open you don't believe it investigate those who think as I as I as I investigate there's nothing in Yiddish kite not even a minute a minute I'm not talking about my cigars and that people have cigars Amish agasa and even they sometimes have a mocker maybe a little distorted but there's nothing in Yiddish guys add that you're amazi three and half thousand years later that you can't document and trace back to the exact date time place person nothing much nothing much nothing even the smallest things that seem insignificant we think and if attack it can't be so then you know that it doesn't there's no source for da and people and it's important because people don't know the difference of a dirty dice but they're not born on a mimic a homra I hate learn a mishegoss OCD obsessions they don't know the difference yeah they think if they don't do this it's already like being makalah Shabbos and eating pork and eating on Yom Kippur and and intermarrying and converting to Catholicism yesterday so Muhammad is a daylight so there's another bond there's a myth summative research room there's a meaning there's a pack corner there's a home road is a Heder there's a home run for one community wasn't the father community okay it's a bazaar especially when it comes to Pesach basically Pesach is the the Yom Tov of homra yeah so in Rob's best in Roth Baskin this is how he did it this is how his best and did it this is what the people around him did I yeah and Schmuel past cañazo and that he did but then they had to take a vote no he didn't Shawna Shawna and he did it and he did it dr. faith I'm Gamliel and a Bo shoe had an argument when Yom Kippur is right and they become real totally sure come on him keep it with your money and you stick and you're back and what did he do he came on my jammy-jam lil vanastra Elroy's shine he kissed him on his head and he called him Rob IVA Tommy Dee you're my Talmud cuz he did what I said but you're my neighbor because you know more than me uncle yeah and it said to be sure was a depressed mate sorry was very upset and he met rabbi akiva over Cuba told them a llamar - a machete crew ISIL Amaya de Alta kuwasa mala attend Adama fellow show again after my film is Adina thermofilm Italian the same rabona Shalom who made the moon said that Yom Tov is based on Bezdek Gamliel is the Sun Hedren if son Eden says this is Jim it's not Yom Kippur it's not the tenth day of Tishri it's irrelevant because the whole reason you're doing Yom Kippur is cause detector isn't listen the better I do say best is making a mistake it's still Yom Kippur as long as the mistake is l'chaim shamayim in other words if it's a mistake because they start not interested then they're not better they're a bunch of crooks you understand but if it's a real burden they made a mistake according to you they made a mistake maybe you're right maybe you're wrong it's irrelevant so that's exactly a case there be assured disagreed and he still followed him damn Leo because actually rabwah hot toys if the if the best day would have voted not like that they wouldn't have been the cottage designers and they wouldn't he wouldn't have listened and if your kid is the one who told the term without that there would be no system the terrace is actually a table hoppers if you if you can't follow the majority of the Sun head and everything would be a McCoy kiss forever well after the Sanhedrin was dissolved there was no more one big vegetable but there was a Sun head ring they could convene and decide a bunch of stuff but yeah when the Sanhedrin was dissolved it went to different cities yeah like the Supreme Court Masai of the whole country the whole nation yeah the Rambam in his introduction to Mishnah Toyota and Mathias has a whole whole irises the history of mission attendants a fisherman is this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate