Rabbi YY Jacobson: Pesachim 8a - A Candle or a Flash Light - Gemarah Pesachim #40

the yeshiva dotnet tough customer Dolloff one two three four five six six lines from the top customer now the Gomorra quoted the reason there is this explanation how the mission a new that we use I read on air but see if I'm at CMHC from crippled skippers from crippled skippers from natives natives from ney and then a bracer from the achieve of Rabbi Shmuel which supported this premise and then a third price which once again quoted this Lynwood but o also introduced the negative the you can do particular come it's not with the Sun not not with the moon and not with a torch only with a candle and even though there's no Raya there's a savior from all these Masuka and the price also added the words were pleasures are nearly off elliptical because the earth our name is the right thing from dhikr in other words it's better than everything else so our happy sister schleimann a this doesn't only teach me you could use natives it's a good hippos it's a cultural hippos but actually you should use you should use Nader's it's interesting stahma Hara the cheapest of Yosef sbeitla was not done with a candle because it says her boy here or vahanam Soho it was morning so proud full he was done by the light of the Sun so actually we're learning with SIA from its SIA its SIA from hippos and keep us from natus but that hippos was not necessarily done with an aid it was the middle of the day and as well actually said the middle of the day and half now at the middle of the day a candle is not so effective for karat Iran Air Marshal because of the Gomorrah is a stronger but here in my honey when you have a candle in in a lit up room especially outside they were outdoors because they were on their donkeys they weren't in Doris so we heard over there they use the light of the Sun right so you could say okay it was his oh so Benares but it's not only been a discuss over there wasn't Belarus I doubt the person of Yosef took a candle he had to light a candle on the road in the desert whoever they were and then start looking they were outdoors they won the dog they weren't indoors they were traveling they left the city says hey my UPS ooh they left then he pursued them so was outdoors obviously used the song don't use a candle outdoors the middle of the day was that night May listen up boy girl I was in the morning so Roetzel ahoy there you can't say he poses only with a candle with it says but it happens obviously not with a candle that's the Headless of this bracer that it says aim both kill Erica not just nervous is earth good when it comes to predict his comets it staff cabin iris south Cuban ATIS Kappa sister schleimann aries Nader shemish Mossad employers that's the way to do it right say but we went through the very happiest of McKay's we went through the very happiest of mccade soberly here the cheapest is not bananas that's interesting huh by lovin look I know so not very happy as well a matzo yeah I love them with a dosa not know if it would save deer before would say bring the pasta cover there then he was macapa s' with the light of the Sun lawyer hi yo him then the koi that we would be stuck because we're learning from you could learn that hip puss is law in her yard right but it doesn't say there so you can't say prove that you need you need air in her yard since we're learning from another pasa that matrix is a good campus so maybe we can save a particular scum but snare this is a good hippos this Brice is adding not only it's good it's the best so I'm gonna give Martin hi lawyer a comma hey she dummy you're telling me that you shouldn't use the light of the song what do you mean the light of the Sun will whether you want to use the light of the Sun what what are you referring to email me do you mean how to help say you mean pressured the courtyard the courtyard that's what you mean in other words you went out from your home into a Hudson Hudson was like what we would call a yard there was no roof it was surrounded by walls and that was a courtyard naturally a lot of homes opened up to a katsu yeah like you have an apartment building yeah people have a backyard and they all play they and they used this yet a thought said that was shared by many homes that's what you mean and obviously just how much there so you do particular summits so you're saying you want to use a Hama see saying don't use it that's child can't be how am i rather of a taught huts in its little quarter doesn't addictive nature every Matsuri shop because the Ravens or other birds are commonly flying around and therefore we trust that they aid up any comments that you put this so your attacker might have comments there cuz kids play around and people sometimes eat deer whatever it is so they may be bred they're fine so for this you have all the birds who fly freely and cut sabers and they're gonna eat it up so therefore you don't need meticulous if you don't need thicker then you don't need say you're not using the light of the Sun you're not using any light so you're gonna tell me Bach sadhya Ella backside when the time is said you can't use Arahama obviously has to be talking about a place where the light of the Sun reaches if there's no light of the Sun then there's no half a minute to use the Sun so you might be talking about on a Cassandra Cassandra is what we would call you have an arts core what does he say a pavilion a pavilion okay asada is basically the term that has all used for a section that has a roof but it doesn't have walls at all or it has only a few walls so for example ah it could be like a porch but but a heart is also like a porch so it's a little different I thought there would be like you haven't excited let's say in a garden what do we call it we call it a casita yeah okay see but in this case it's not a Kazee but with walls it's just pillars and there's only a roof so therefore you have the light of the Sun there because it's not surrounded it has a roof so if it rains you could sit there but it's only based on pillars there's only a modem there's normal citizens that's one type of excitement that's like in a garden or in a field that they would have itself there was another type of esada which was actually an extension of the home it was an accelerator you have this very often in the surface a ravine and suka and I said there was an extension on them like a foyer of the home and it may have one wall like the wall over the house or maybe two walls or maybe even three walls but one of the walls one of the machetes is completely open so therefore it's under a roof since it's under a roof you don't have the Ravens and the birds roaming there freely and eating so we're there you do need whiticus comments and here naturally you could use this Sun because one wall or two walls or three walls are open or maybe there's no walls McClelland is just pillars but even if there are walls could be one wall completely open and therefore it what so is like a pavilion you came out of your house and you have that can extension from the house he still had a roof right he may have had a wall the wall of the house or another two walls but one side was completely open so it's like a UH this is called an oxide nobody you do particular comets and you can do it Larry rahama so the price it says no Frank the Gemara that doesn't make sense because our my Rover again drove the tortoise oxide you load and if decklist an ox ahdre you could be by tech to its light meaning you could be avoided by day with the light of the Sun the attack could don't need the light of the candle Raschi says Lauren if Dec has the second eye she custom and olive will earth shall on Eve decorous you could be by the canucks Agra pavilion with the light of the Sun vein sorry la valeur iran air by lila you don't need a light a candle for that side there but why what was rover's point rover's point well it's so light it's so bright don't bother with a candle the both could be right both could be right you could be invited by day and be inviting my day with the Sun so then the brides can't say invites can let her come in Avenue and look how any when Ashley says Boyd caballo him he doesn't mean wait till you die admission because the shaman gave us man of Nicholas comets at night but he means you could do it earlier before the night of indominus and the day of you'd give me listen if you want and you could use a I know that you could wait at night and use a candle but Robert said you don't have to use it no person editor shortage of a candle he had a bigger house whatever it is he didn't have enough candles so you can do it by day wait ha Laura hammer from Rachid smash ma lipstick killer they could do the hula that a traveler Sanibel Island I don't need an herbal alley to do a pillow by Y the Rambam and he'll cos comets Matt separate ways and Shannara its Marshman that the chapter the gomorrah is that even an exciter you should do the night of the 14th lauren a because that's what the cause all of a sudden it just means if you forgot to do that cetera then tomorrow morning you don't have to bring a candle you download listen in the morning you could just use sunlight when you boil it your house you download listen in the morning let's say you forgot to do particular comments so you got stuck somewhere and you arrived at in the morning your dowel danube dickens how much was a candle if you didn't do because how much then even the middle of pace if you do it with a candle but that's all indoors outdoors i said you could do it later huh but in any case you could do it with the sun and for the Gemara lights larger but the beside he was talking about Aruba I rube a skylight a skylight in a room it's indoors and you have a skylight skylight means there's an opening in the ceiling right and you have sunlight coming in Aruba is like a window we call it a skylight in the room that's what we're talking about because there's a window sunlight comes in so now if there's no window for sure you have a can't what are you gonna use but since this is our window so you could think you might use the Sun that's what the rice is saying don't use the strength anymore what do you mean ela Baha'i Aruba if you're talking about right under the skylight in other words the place where the sunlight is reaching directly I know what's address what's determining that in a pavilion what serious a cost of a pavilion yeah and a room not if it's being illuminated by the Sun the Sun is coming right and who cares we buy the same idea and that means what Snowden means the sides of the room which are not directly being hit by the Rays of the Sun because the light of the Sun doesn't brighten up that place directly so the light of the Sun is insufficient of Dicker's comets and that's what the Bryson was saying you later Nick yeah she says oh the hate the A's are more complicated loss angle inaudible what's the problem where's the light of the Sun of the skylight not sufficient he named Allah had the Aruban negative mama mamas parallel to the opening to the hole I my why not look my lawyer I know Oksana and well my let's dog initials were on the sides of the whole chorus are opening the hole over there you don't use the rock huh frack the Gemara so even though I didn't do it at night and I want to be by the key your dollar in the morning cuz let's say I forgot so I want to use the sunlight and you say no the corners of the room the sides of the room you have to use a candle or a nail yo Philip dick as the Gemara will explain why why are we so busy with our honey and we have arrived from the silken a composition - iris nourish ammunition frag the Gemara a Vocaloid the Brice also said no sunlight no moonlight and no torch why not why not enough hook on my rather rather torus might exceed the posit says in half a coin this is a who a prophecy by the times of Messiah and the prophecy is a labyrinth but it's all to bring at one point then enough hookah is a wonderful source of light and much better than a flame much better than a single candle as we explained in our book is a large flame a torch or many wicks interwoven together on my rubber Maddox of the passage says vinegar Katya the no authority amines Noga is the light no I mean shining right no you guys shining sofa no God the light that is going to be experienced by its addiction by the world in the future is Katya it's going to be like the original light that I sham created on the first day of creation variations bara elokim is a shrine bizarre it's vorich I saw you of a value by amarilla Kim Yi er ye art is gonna be like that are you that's what we call early Shiva seemed a beret shoes the original owner of the seven days of creation which is not to confuse with our light our light that we have today is sunlight which comes from where from the Sun which was hung up which was created when on Wednesday ano movie he he made his beauty a shaman what about the owner of the first it says my ikura vaya vaya vaya morality me a very high right by our elite team SRR key toys it was good vibe doe and he called her yo him and Herschel I'll abut the sub was created on Wednesday this has I'll explained was a source of light and it was a light that is different than the light of the Sun has I'll say on this light that with this light you could see from one end of the world to the other side under the world it wasn't a light that we're accustomed to it was a type of light the perception like people sometimes described I saw near-death experiences right ah a clarity and their soul like they'll watch their Sunday buildings don't block the slide it's a different type of light it's a type of perception that pervades the entire universe tomorrow cuz I'll say so I sure miss tackling but miss tackle by me so for oil on that side this air was hidden it was hidden this is called the original error Shiva Salman or shavasana Mauritius so the Naga the light of sending asperity carnelian the race car nine from the word Quran like moistures face was like car name the race me or they will come from his hands from Hashem Loy to him to the topic Hashem is going to cast his light on the topic of a shaman the pastor continues the sham but there by Hashem heavier in whose eye is hidden its strength meaning the real strength of the light is going to be by Hashem so the Gomorrah says Rob explains that the MOT tsadikim diamond to finish Alina - what can you compare the bright faces of the tsadikim in the presence of the face of the Sheena can urban a Avoca like a candle in front of a torch that's the comparison so even though no guy is going to be go val de cartier economy or daylight but nonetheless for some heavy a new sign that the light of the Sonic is Canaan Tiffany Avoca like an a in front of that VUCA so what do we see from here you can't compare the nee to the hooker now who cares like the marshal for the stream it's Hashem himself our shams light and the name is a derivative the name is the rays of light that come to the south which is gevalt ik it's gonna be like the urn of Shiva sniper Asia's butts at dick epiphany ice cream I like a nail which may evoke why then would we dismiss the hook writer for my raava who cool off the limits with minimal when it comes from dollar a book is a midterm and I'm of course the best thing to make Barry Maria H by half dollar on an Avoca like we use a half dollar candle which is many wicks so flocked and gets locked and they're woven together to make a flame because it's a much greater light both of these statements have rather teach us that the light of the book is far more intense and far more powerful now it's interesting the more asked to bring two riders that I've hook is greater than a liar from carvaka and I you from half dollar the Santa's are I'm just the harder they focus better than an a everybody could see it he brings Alaia Alaia from robert to rise that i book is greater than an answer it's just interesting i don't know the answer I'm just wondering why the Gomorrah it says Bonet dress by your schlong it says behind it is one of the two cards yeah yeah you're right in a Konami yeah that's really good mark explained that natus is a much smaller smaller light who doesn't want to find all the small sin just want to find the big ceeze I'm rip knocking by each circuit mathematic answers you're right but I'll tell you this shot is a yahoo likeness in the foodimals documents any election is local news doc which means a candle you can bring in two holes and Tezuka stuck in our cracks what does he say holes and cracks holes and cracks on a hookah torch it stacked a much more light but you can't bring it in two holes and cracks why because it's a torch to pick a torch in a candle which is a smaller flame lends itself to be able to enter into a crevice a little hole little crack and be able to search for the comets over there so that's why they wanted Africa are near this is the black macaques part according to this reason it would mean if you happen to have a state-of-the-art home and there's no cracks and holes in your house because when you ball a Buster sees a crack it immediately gets fixed within a mess less then lock Ida wouldn't be a problem when I book it would be great wonderful the problem is most homes I've heard him is Duncan so that would be the sweat of the maximun that's not goodbye it's okay right it lips we'd says no I'll tell you another reason is that oh you're the fun of is a relaxer of a nail gives you white in front of you on a Vogler gives you light and back of you meaning because it's so much light it's actually blinds you in front of you for the back of you it's actually very good because there's somewhat of a separation your body creates a little bit of a partition between the intensity of the light and that which is behind you so actually if you would be walking behind yourself or let's put it this way if somebody else was holding on a vaca and leaning the way and you're doing particular comments behind them ribbons it says it works well but that's an unusual situation that opportunity is not always available you're holding the torch yourself and you not being pointed behind you keeping boy dick right in and it's sometimes too much light too much light doesn't do the job and that's why you need a are in her name because their focus to blinding to blind further way ahead it's good and for behind you it's good for behind you right for behind you it's good that means that according to the observe it even in a house where there's no holes and no cracks which are courted of naphthalene you could use in a hooker the observe it says I have another problem my problem is not holes and cracks my problem is even the regular territory in the house they would not do me well of evanov okay but Accord there's two people doing it and you're holding the torch and I'm doing the thinkin it would be good so the Gomera game is a third race wrap-up armorer purposes and of Jakov you said this reason and i think it was yesterday two days ago hi boys myeloid boy is person holding the torch is scared it's a big fire and you're very conscientious and you're very cautious and you're very worried last thing you need the night before basic is for the house to burn down cross for Salah but hi Lloyd boy is when you're holding a candle it's not scary and therefore because a person has to be focused on particular Komets not on protecting his house because then you can't focus up the COS comments so therefore the cars all said use a candle and do not use on a hookah do not use a torch so what is your puppet telling us even if you have a torch that's not so blinding even if you ever torched it not someone let's say a smaller Avoca still if it's a torch if it's a larger flame than an a with this fear you should not be using it for vicars comments according to your papà local area if two people are doing the COS conference it would also work just like it observe it because if you're holding the torch and you're focusing on the protection of it and I'm doing the bedico then you could say a quantitative popper it would also work like rubs it for a different reason then comes the last one the question is also well you all know we do an air I mean it's much I see some fabric or something so it's certainly pro forma my doorman only thing worse is differently but what's how is it any less of a fear just because it's less of a point still it's just much more containable I think because of its size right they just would do a massacre because how much they wanted it should be with something it was at night right you're asking about today using a flashlight a very interesting question I'll discuss it in a moment I'm gonna mention something let's see the fourth answer a Vietnam Raveena says hi Masha heard of a high magnifica tophi the light the flame of a candle is consistent the high magnifica tu fais where the light of the torch jumps around did I translate it correctly what does he say what's Myra the light of the torch flickers that's mixed afect fa and the light of the candle is much more steady because the light of the candle is just it is what it is it's a steady flame the light of the torch increases and then decreases it flickers it dances and therefore it's harder to be buoyed Nick and what he's basically saying is that the nature of a person's eye is it expands in darkness and it shrinks in light and that's how we can absorb the light in a proper way because our our eye nose to shrink here when it's light when I'm using an Avoca and the light is flickering bigger and smaller so therefore what happens is it actually affects my vision so Raveena says that's why a name is actually better than on a hook Rashi says are you a liar of but other markers in the fun of hoo boy dick kills Elena for the bedico bias Monsieur is like a Vanessa by Israeli by lambda K alpha hi Marsha Schneider oh darn a ninja who made him coma Maynard don't look like fetus doesn't jump around so to speak Ella knock the mahkumat God it's serene it's restful in one place Victor Fink do free NIF citric offered stomach it's always jumping and flickering Russian are quite similar work and therefore Raveena says not to use it so we have for reasons of national says because we want to get it into the cracks you can't use a torch which says because you're being by dick what is in front of you not a ball is behind you and then a hook is more blinding wrap up it says and a hook it creates fear and you won't concentrate on the beaker and Raveena says because the light is consistent and does not flicker the light of the flame is steady the question that came up in our generation was a flashlight could a flashlight or a similar source of light has all the milos you can get it into the holes and the cracks right there's a crack you could look and it doesn't blind you and it's consistent you have a battery and and you're not afraid you're not afraid it's gonna burn down the house etc so it's interesting question and a lot of the poisk of talk about it I saw for example River Valley ISIF was Martin it a lot of the pipes can say it actually works the qualities of the Gemara describes of RNA actually works a lot of place come on my to it I think most of them add though that nonetheless since the COS album a second or even a so even though would be a coach to predict his comets and you wouldn't be transgressing anything on the contrary it works perfectly well but since the Kazama Sakon are made and they have all the sukham that the gomorrah brings narration is therefore it's hard to say don't use an air anymore and just use a flashlight but essentially there are those who argue that you shouldn't but i think many many points can I've seen various troopers where they were completely mater at bhisma NASA and others even say there's a mile because as you said with a candle you're busy with the wax and you're clumsy and you're still afraid and even though it's not on a hookah I just also want to describe you after on the stamp lickers comments them was now up nichols comment today baruch hashem many people live in very big houses and even people who live in small houses relative to the houses can it's considered a palace and a mansion and you go from room to room and there's a lot of things to be void that can people are Voytek even things they don't have to be boy dick their boy dick yeah you have to understand the particular comments for many many generations it was a much more simple process if you had a house with one room or two rooms it was a gavel the kitchen dish generally a home with one room was already a luxury the gomorrah says a wealthy person as somebody who has a table and nearby as a basic you said is considered a wealthy person today that's not considered wealth and the furthest stretch of the imagination they have a bathroom near table but I'm just describing the nature of things so you went with a candle and you went around yeah and you know the storage rooms and the closets that we have and walk-in closets and drawers galore and shafts and bookcases and china closets and bookcases and drawers everywhere and more closets and then more closet ending at more closets etc it's just you know with a candle that you can also get that's why we have hotel cords are the question is a flash much would have been then with kazow lima sock and flashlights upset yeah and they say you could use it some say a lot of place come on Martin it it's just in some are not but a lot are yeah there's a picture of Avadh yourself we just clearly Martin in an others even though some argue but I think many of them add that still could die to use the arguments from because of many because of what's gonna be them more right it sounds like based on the qualifications of the Gemara that tennis it's just because the Gemara is so into the pursuit comic opposition line by neighbors Amana repeats it three times and over the it snare so therefore it seems like the early honey has some significance and sometimes it's not only on a physical level when it comes to our locker there's also spiritual dimensions as well you know what I meant I know personally experience you can see that's what he's saying you're saying you experience what observe it set if you had a stronger light you're not gonna see the crumbs okay so if you put on the light in your room you put on the light in your room you're not gonna see it okay we are your crumbs with we're they don't clean the kitchen before so you actually do a real boudicca's comments you do have Commons and you're saying for the crumbs the candle is much better what about a flashlight not the same say to turn over the lights and use a candle that way I have seen that because then the candle becomes effective while others say that they find that to be ludicrous because the light the room is bright and for that obviously the light will show you everything however if there's places that the light don't read the light doesn't reach right so then with that go the candle you know maybe under the bed where it's dark or under the bookcase which dark if it's a place to mechanism by comets over there the candle will be effective to shut the lights but others who finds comets you same but slow who finds comments about how much you right now you don't need you're right if it's a rumor there's no comets and there's not a status comments not even a chart you know if to be both it you're right you saying this just as a secular magician K NASA Hiller but you here a pilot's Minh finds crumbs that's why I was shocked where do you find Chrome we have to talk to your wife though doesn't mean he finds no he says he finds crumbs and he likes candles cuz they cast a shadow on the crumb me if you have little children you can find he doesn't chase out the kids for the kids do you do it now you just make something Raylan you never supposed to embarrass your wife you have to figure out a way of doing the right thing without embarrassing your wife sitting in the basement in the corner three weeks four days yes yes we all grew up that way yes we all grew up that way not you but some of us grew up that way and the Shabbos before pace I forget about that I remember that Travis yeah yeah some people are year before places from Tishri but club what our dining was made for they're not made to use space earth is coming it's just what you sell the house you want to say there's a nice dining room you shouldn't be using a dining room for food too many hazards call a house is a problem also well it's a halacha to used in there but what they're saying is that the characteristics that the Gemara attributes to than there you have there - it's a hotwalker they have to use a man [Music] no so they're saying since the Gemara gives the reason it's not stopped so therefore it's a very interesting discussion others argue others say no Paul the meaning by most Jews I think is to still use an air right even if it's mutter even for just for nostalgic purposes and also it brings out something yet yeah it's interesting that that's no I'm just thinking the tsadikim by the shin are like an urban a Avoca what what's the meaning of this like what's the point what is it over trying to say that they're not like the Sheena don't think you're gonna be like God God is the torch you're only a candle okay say that it's a much deeper idea it's explained in Safari especially inspired I'm off my shava caballo considers when you have enough hookah when you have an ale near enough hookah when you have a huge bonfire right then you bring a candle close what happens the nail gravitates the valve okay and it gets subsumed it becomes Nicola becomes submerged in the Avoca right if if you want to retain the Nayar as a separate entity you have to go far if you come close to the hookah fire gravitates the fire and it gets absorbed in the larger fire now hookah here is represents to Sheena that's the infinite light that light encompasses everything but then there's an air what's an air the navy's did individual neshama which is a hail akela kami ma mama Sh but they get so to speak separated from that hookah and it comes into a body and it comes into the world and now it's a self-contained neigh-neigh Hashem knishmas Adam the way it becomes a neshama of a person it becomes a nail which is so to speak separate from the hook and that's why it could be an a because it's separate from the hook the hook is the huge flame that's infinite the neighbors so to speak how it separates that's why it's called then someone is called a Kayla Kelly common mountain so people ask a question of Shem has parts Kayla Kelly calm me mouth a part of ourself what's like he cut an apple I understand you take an apple kids are fighting over an apple or a birthday cake he cut it into part you get a hey look I get it well couldn't show miss Kayla kill akame mom in all the smart him hey look Ellie common mouth hey McCulloch LSMs parts hello Kim there was a Jewish philosopher Menasha Ben you surely as a safe initial mask I am he blast the term Chanukah likami mom he says it's clear and happy courses and Minnis it's heresy he was a great Jew but he didn't know about this story to play me satire it wasn't his thing but in all this were Micaela gonna come him out to showing him a shrine him a Kabbalah the shot of course says doesn't mean a Shem has parts the muscles would be like a child with a parent a child comes from the seed from the sperm and the egg of the parent before the egg and the sperm became an embryo it was all part of the of the father and the mother completely one with them what shot that child gets developed an embryo develops and a fetus grows and it gets born it becomes separate what does it mean to become separate it's not that the father and the mother a part of them is cut off it means it's the way the essence of the father and mother is transported into a new reality Brock Kyra Devore a child is part of a father and a mother forever you care about your child's owners more than you care about yourself but it's the way yourself comes into a separate and distinct realm the neshamah scaler calico me mount a vehicle it's the way allah chose the way godliness enters into a nail a self-contained entity which is called knishmas adam Bashar's the nail comes bhisma Haruka when the nave comes in the presence of the hooker then the neighbor comes completely bottle it doesn't find separately cuz it's really part of the hookah and that's what naira Shemesh Masada means like the negra 8/8 to go back to the hooker and if thou hookah was we present and manifested there wouldn't be separateness it would be only one us but doesn't that analogy fall short because there he is yeah indeed yes understand what in one detail yeah right right yeah right right yeah so that's recess that Saavik before the shimmer that's the name which comes from the hooker it's a derivative from the volca and when it's in the presence of the hooker there's no near enough okay it's completely one that Sabich who is a person in this world represents the nail which is the way the divine enters into the consciousness of a person who's living out the divine light in their modality that's the concept of a name if so it could be that that's where the Gemara brings it the chimera could have said and I book is stronger you don't need your other to bring me up sup Asik that on a hook is bigger it's antique instrument but they were is also explaining it on a deeper level thickest comets you can't do with enough hook here think has come as have to do with an a because in the world of our Booker there's no comments the whole concept of Dicker's comets means what's comet's comets is egotism yesh is inflated arrogance and the world of the VUCA there's no comments in the world of the Evoque it is oneness in the world of the name that could be boudicca's comments so a focused like a greater light but that explains go for why in the world of that book it is no comments for half-dollar rava says you need an Avoca when you have an advocate is automatically abdullah the separation what's light what's darkness Mitsu man i'm over $5 but it's how much you trying to find the comments so you use your day you don't use in a book I'll cope on him so the Gemara established why you have to do with lawyer her name and Africa later and they're not the Sun not the moon and not even the or how hook something tomorrow call Malcolm Seamus listen Muhammad saying sort of Boudicca any place we you don't bring in homage the Mishnah continues right calm welcome Shane Mohonasen my comments any place that you don't bring in comets you don't have to do Boudicca that's what the first mission had told us right after lawyer named Greg the Gemara como Komatsu you're my why does it say Col Macklin what does coma command the mission er could have said earlier boss the brightness of comments light on their mahkum Shane Magnussen Bahamut it's called mark a place where you don't bring an accommodation on him because every place could've said a marker every word in the mission is precise as we explained that the time to put into the words of the mission of the whole depth what does the word call teach me call mark in any place so become our answers that from here we see that displaces that they would not be included in welcome Shane Mohonasen muhammad's if it says a place where you don't bring in hummus you wouldn't include those places and therefore you would be boy dick and that's what he says call Markham he's trying to add a particular location that wouldn't be included in makan what is that call what is it what is he trying to teach us so the demurrer says last suya to include how the tundra Bona that which is stated in a Bryce but the Bryce estate said explicitly and the Mishnah intimates it through the word call maka the bracelet tells us hire a bias when you have holes crevices in the walls of a home he'll join in by throwing them those that are higher and those which are lower the holes which are on top they're very high so it's hard to reach them and they're very low so it's uncomfortable to reach them because you have to get down those holes whether they'll join them they're higher octane them they're close to the ground so it's not easy to reach them because if it's very high you have to climb and it's a ticket to get up there and if it's very low meaning you have to get down on your feet so therefore it's not a comfortable place to use of course we're not talking about of this children who are hanging around and you know putting their cake and candies into those holes then it changes a little mat a house where you know that that's not the fact with that's not the reality so hooray about the innovative toilet next the God how you'd SIA kaga at SIA is a yacht SIA is a storage room a room that was storage and it usually had a roof that was slanted it wasn't a flat roof so therefore you don't want to put things there because it's gonna fall the Gaga Migdal Gaga Migdal means the roof of a tower which means you have a very large piece of furniture where you usually put food there you put dishes there but the roof on top of it it's migdal it's a tower meaning it's very tall right from the word goggle so therefore again it's not a schmuck it's not easy to put things that you have to bring a ladder after climb or FS r FS bucker is a stable huh a barn for cattle Lulu Lin is a coop a chicken coop reffers bucer is a barn for cattle like cows oxen lu lin is a chicken coop Oh mcvane is a storage place for straw vitro's CIN and storage places of wine vitro's Chambon and storage places for oil insert sim ticket none of these places need liquor why the holes on the top and and the bottom are inconvenient to use so therefore we don't assume that is how much they're the gaga at SIA the slanty or the Gaga Migdal again people don't put things there commit so therefore we don't have to do particular a cattle barn or a chicken coop you don't do particular cause even if this come is there we assume that the chickens or the cattle have eaten them up and the storage places of wine and oil we assume there's no particular because people don't put in how much this it's a place of war in a place of oil it's not a place to put bread or other comments that's why the Mishna says coil to include all over these places if the Mishnah would have said a mock line Shane Mack listen by comments you would say a chicken coop is a place where you do bring in comments you feed your chickens RFS is a place where you do bring in comments it's not a mahkum Shane Mohonasen muhammad's so that's why the time has to say call Malcolm Shane McNamara comments because every place will you assume that the animals ate it like a place where you didn't bring in we didn't bring in homage the same is true with the holes on the top one on the bottom you could say since this is a room where I always bring in a summons it's my dining room it's my kitchen there's a hole there I can't say it's um welcome Seamus listen boys I'm welcome to Mike listen make comments because the room is a place that you bring in comments so therefore you have to say that what that the holes are maybe not included in the tour of dhikr let's just call mark line what's the call that even within places where you bring in comments but you can assume likely and all likelihood that you didn't use those wall also again we're talking about in a case where there's no children or others who may have used don't use those halls so then you don't have to do padukas comments it same is true when it comes to the roof the slanty roof or the roof the twhirl roof or the places of a wine and oil all these places all these places I can't say mahkum Seamus listen but comments why I may walk into my wine cellar with bread eating a bagel it may happen right but since it's not it's not likely to happen so therefore it's included in the call that's the finish of the cup yeah yeah yeah you can assume in their feed off to do because comets in the chicken coop or the cattle barn again if you see comets there we're talking about if you have to do dhikr if you see how much there you can't rely on it but you have to do big if it's a flat roof in the house that's not so high and it's convenient to use then you have to do particular indoors from indoors no the gonca at SIA or you're asking if it's a gog outdoors solenoidal might have come in there because animal depor the birds come very good it's probably some reassuring them say it's talking about indoors the at SIA the storage room is indoors yeah like some type of some type of storage room with a roof on it not a roof outdoors then you're right yeah yeah that's one way of learning it yeah then it's indoors yet the Birmingham the alignment Emile says metre helices potaka bias if you have a bed splits a room into two helices means it splits the house into two so basically the bed like creates two bedrooms use one side for one purpose another side for another purpose Omar Seca's and the legs of the bed are tall so therefore there's a partition between the bed and the ground and the earth Sushil Nicholas needs particular this needs a particular in other words when you have a bed the middle over the room and you use both sides of the room and you have a bed to create a match it's our partition why so you want to use each side for a different purpose so since you're using both sides of the bed and the legs are tall so there's space so therefore we should be cautious that comets has come under the bed and therefore you have to do dhikr it would seem that if it's in the corner of the room and you're not using the place under the bed then the halacha might change unless you know otherwise that's why it seems from Russia she's talking about a bed that splits the room and to do in other words you're using the area around the bed because both sides you want to use for a purpose it's not just that the bed is quarantined in a corner drag the Gemara veremey no he's not the reason you right right comets and even if you're the bed is in the coroner you have to look yeah especially have a children child's bedroom with the children coming to the parents bedroom take a look in Rashi halfway like us my MIDI noise of a mock image it's all a solid cushiony share bias for animal sonicate he's just saying the common the common situation Mitaka la coneja bias he's trying to describe that that's the that's the that's the common situation ah right mitah helical Boudicca bias in other words because because usually you put a bed in the corner of the room you don't put it in the in the middle when do you put it in the middle you put it in the middle in order to split the room into two massacres yes have said when shall l the car Velma Martin Vera min who asks the Gemara we just learned this whole price sir that was included in the call but we have another Bryce the Bryce is a scholarship and other motivator if you have a hole between one person and another person in other words our homes share a wall and there's a crevice in the wall and the water hole goes through and through the problem is it's a thick wall because it's a thick wall so I can't be buoyed it all the way to your side I pressure can't fit my hand through the hole all the way it's a thick it's a thick wall she says that boy they got Malcolm Sheldon my gas and it's a place where there might be humus so your boy did kill where your hand reaches was that by the cosmic I'm shutting my gosh he's boy till where his hand reaches a shower what about the rest there's still place in the middle lovato label it boy each of you should be atma bottle in your heart in other words it may be that a piece of Commons has rolled into that location and you have not done the particular because your hand can reach there so it's far common didn't say you have to go and find 80s you just do bittle and that would be enough because since your hand can reach there obviously you're not using that place because you can't get there so you don't need Boudicca you don't need because you don't put comma stay because you can't get there LMI we're afraid that maybe a piece of comets rolled into there without your initiative so you could just do pitiful this is a specific bit or is it including clothing you're doing anything this is the bit though we're doing anyhow won't clued this basically in the bit till after padukas comments will say all the comments and I have not found and have not seen is lavato this include this type of comments to say that you use it for comments you don't because your hand can't get there how do you boo use it for comes but you may have put on a piece of bread and something may have happened it rolled over so both of you do bit tool and you're good but that boy the god knocking shutting my gosh don't worry about it you have to do they could tell where you could reach if there's a piece of homage there and it says in acronym so even if you know that there's a piece of comments there but you can't get to it right so you could do pittle that would be enough worry about your neighbors woman's don't look into their phone yeah yeah I once saw a heart one of the Safari I think a car Lena Vaart Colinas they silently says that the Gemara also speaks spiritually sometimes there's a between a person and his friend there's a whole basically uh you know a vacuum the relationship goes sour there's a hole in the relationship as you say it gets pierced the connection gets gets pierced she says naturally everybody blames the other one he says no you b-boy to catch the other my gas you be by their side let him be by they kill other side and then the rest you'll be move out to LA don't wait and say the other person is guilty he's the one who's responsible is that by the government you take responsibility for your part let him take risk you take responsibility for your part and the rest you'll both then the rest will get bottle it's a shame of art ah it's a shame of art and lemon Zeb boy the cardema gasps don't say it's your problem it's your whole you'll be boarded you'll be by the way you came a little bit vertical Callie Navarre silent Mia the Birmingham Lea limited monopoly all says meet our collectors potential buyers if you have a bed that separates in the house of eights above autumns Durham tech then you have wood or stones on the rhythm of seconds and it separates in other words the legs are tall so there's a partition in its receptacle it doesn't need the cap so the bryce is basically explaining you have a bed and it separates a room into two and under the bed you have world and you have stones and the legs are tall so there's a placemark seconds between the bottom of the bed and the ground so you don't need to be you don't need Boudicca in that place flag the Gemara Kashi Amit Amit Takashi hood una hora ii bryce contradicts the first one bed on bed and holes on holes why this bryce is telling us the places that don't need particular so time a comma says the hole between you and your friend you don't need Boudicca after we your hand reaches but till yeah where your hand reaches does needs as the bottom of the bed if there's wood and they're stones also doesn't need thicker why you could do bit hope you don't do Dickon asks the Gemara cash to meet amid the cash exciting exciting I'm gamble in the first Bryce has said when there's a bed you have to do particular here he says you don't have to do with it cash inside and outside in the first Bryce he told me that the holes don't mean decay he said the whole dunya take as long as far as your hands can reach so the Gemara says no fair enough I don't like a hobby law but a toy hobby mitzi first Bryce he was talking about the higher holes on the top the lower holes on the bottom this is talking about the holes in the middle of the wall which are very easy to use and therefore it's kind of empathic initially we thought that the second Bryce is talking about all holes who doesn't make a differentiation you just says her should be nothing like of a day so we assume any hole in the wall so that would be a contradiction to the first price so the Gemara says okay no the second price is talking about holes in the middle of the wall but if it would be a hole on the top of the wall or on the bottom of the world that would be awkward uncomfortable to use it I don't need it even in the beginning of the hall forget about the middle of the hole where it's too hard to get so that's no contradiction right in me Tammy to like ash from the bed on the bed there's no question how the medallion the first Bryce is talking about Medallia the legs are very tall and it's easy to go under the bed and put things they're hardly met Atari the second price is talking about a lower bed so therefore again this space between the bottom of the bed and the ground is much less and therefore it's much more cumbersome it's uncomfortable to put comments there which is why he puts in eighths in valve on in his Durham doctor that there's wood and their stones there why does he put that in because he wants to basically say that it's already stacked up with stuff in other words is much less space so to go and put it to use it as a place for how much it's not an easy place and therefore it doesn't need it doesn't need thicker because he wants to bring up that there's only a little a little space because if you fill it up with racks it's a storage place for lumber for logs and rocks and stones it's going to be a place if the space is not going to be left large so again look up till there the Gemara thought he's talking about even if there's a lot of space nonetheless it's popped it from dica because there's eight Simon I've owned him there so he says look lighter you could still use it for summits and that's what he says that this space is very small again if you know that you're using it for comments you have children who have built who have built the private locations under the bed hideouts obviously everything changes but we're talking about the person doesn't know you don't have to assume that this hummons dragged the camera by its giant insiders but it can the first Bryce it told us that storage places of wine don't even think about Tanya ever Bryce are you saying sorry disseminates arctic storage places of wine do need thickest comments only shortlist of oil donate dhikr with the first crisis says that the yeah it also doesn't even thicken and for the Gemara Huxtable my ice cream and there's no need to create arguments it's all circumstances how could my skin of a Miss stopping the second Bryce is talking about a case we're it's a type of wine cellar from which you supply yourself with wine in middle of a meal in other words if the wine is finishes on the table you're going to send a child or a waiter or a servant to go get wine from the cellar that type of storage place needs but Iike why because if he goes in the middle of the meal he may go in with a piece of challah a piece of bread and leave it there and forget it there when he's looking for the wine and if we need the customers that's why it says it's true science r.a.dickey in the second rise it's different different type of wine cellar but if it's a place of a seller of wine where you don't go in middle of a meal it's a different type of idea then you don't even see how here bizarre chemin Ami if you're talking about a case where miss topic will you may suppose it as a supplier middle of the meals and an oil to people used oil of middle of a meal to say yeah answer this interesting answer chemin when it comes to oil yes come on Sheila before the meal you know exactly how much oil you need yeah an Inc valassir when it comes to you I in you don't know for sure the appetite grows with wine so may look for oil the person who prepared the meal knew how much oil there is and you're prepared on the table you're not gonna be using more oil when it comes to wine sometimes it's time for another bottle of wine in college see you so may lady like send them in the middle of meal that's why it's Rochelle men simply practically usually not a place where there's going to be comments were saying you have to know what type of Idi Amin's excellent question so that's what you have to see what type of void sir it was what type of wine storage room it was usually they have to dilute the wine yeah they loot the wine but you can have barrels though already diluted or barrels that were not diluted yet totally clear to peer said also oysters shaker but Volvo coaches are embarrassed welcome is topic the Cohanim of Volvo considered storage places of beer storage places of beer in Babylonia now this doesn't mean beer made from grain because then you have a much bigger problem than bread this is made from FIGS right or dates or figs ah so it's not comets but they treated it like storage places of wine and eggs it's all been this topic meaning when you have a storage place of beer made of figs and you use in the middle of the meal for a supply so these eight Souris need thickest comments before Peyser closed in above L just like a narrative straw they would drink wine in the middle of the meal in Babylonia they would drink the shaker middle over the meal and therefore they gave them the same halakhah and thus you need liquors comets in these storage in these storage places no no no it's not comets if it's comet then you have a much bigger problem you know finish here is that since they would constantly drink in the middle of the meal so we say Inc Valusia just like buy wine and aerosol you say you can't know before how much you're going to drink sometimes you drink more sometimes you drink glass in the middle of the meal you say we want more so in bubble it was the same quality when it came to shake her there was no clap and therefore you would need dick yeah that's the problem the waiter the shamash is gonna go right he's going from the meal you say please do me a favor get us a a bottle of beer so he goes with the collar with a bagel or whatever he's eating the lasagna and he puts it down he finds the bottle and he forgets gotta feed him - yeah on fight sir it's not full of my polis if it's covered with straw with stones yeah but here it's a regular storage place it's an organized storage place than the staff so they made me promise if it's a place where you bring in comets and there's even our stash that you bring in hummus right it's not like you say this place there's no comments unless something happen though so then yeah nothing love my pointless yeah yeah ya know what bus means let's say there's a wall falls down or there's an earthquake because it's so much stuff there it is if you're cleaning out a room and you're gonna fill it up with straw so that's gonna be like a my brother's you're making it up yes you're gonna fill it from there to the roof it's an organized place have bottles of water this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net slash donate