Pesachim 16a: The Unique View of Reb Elazar That Liquids Always Remain Pure

the yeshiva dotnet okay tidy Eden tessai Annamma Aleph one two three four five five lines from the top the Gemara quoted a price and the bracer brought three opinions about the biblical status of beverages in terms of Toma opinion number one was Ramaiya it mayor said liquid can become Tommy min hot area doesn't the POSIX a in parish mini that a food or liquids fall in to a Kayleigh that has become Tommy from a share its meaning the Kaylee was a resigned the liquid can become Tommy but Ramaiya said biblically that liquid cannot transfer tumor to anything and anybody not even other foods that liquid will not transfer Toma practically speaking it means that if there's a Suffolk if a transfer Toma we assume the lenient perspective meaning that the other thing is Tarkas it's a rabbinic doubt because only rabbinical II can liquid transfer Toma but if there's a Suffolk if the liquid itself became Tom a then we choose the stringent path because it's a sway Coeur de rice then they Commissioner Bratton continued their beer laws are agreed with rib mayor but Shane no you're a rebel army could work then there was the second opinion other extreme W Hooda who says not only can liquid become Tommy but liquid can transfer Toma and not only to food even to vessels I'll show you sha sir but Coakley you tomorrow even a Kaylee can become Tom a from Moscone unique judicial review hoodie that a Kaylee can be a Shana me their eyes and then there was the middle opinion regulation of Shimon who say that Mashka liquid can become Tommy minute IRA it can transfer it biblically to other foods but not to other vessels and the connection to our mission of course was in a case where a carbon touched liquid which touched a Kaylee which touched a shell what would be the status of that meat rib mayor would hold its Taher minute area because it touched a liquid that was coming and liquid can't transform local tumor only rabbinic tumor a rabbinic level of Tama and therefore it may withhold that this Buster that was being burnt and becoming Tom a biblically was initially Tahoma Theresa Rebeck C disagrees and says no this meat was Tom a minute IRA because it touched liquid that was Tom a and liquid could transfer to a minute IRA and therefore it was already Tommy biblically not rabbinical II and when you burnt it with the Boston that was a rejoin it was bumped up in terms of Toma from Ashley she died right sir it became a shame he died riser and it happens to me that from a Shanee dura Bonin it was also a shiny durable on it becomes was it was Ashley cedar I said it wasn't Shana di Bona because it touched marker and mask is always a reason so therefore rabbinic Lee was ashamed about as we learned Rashi at length all the details you're right you're right if I show is me Tommy ISIL is another question and as rashly explained that this Gomorrah abuse on and would hold like the first two opinions that bicarb honest ISIL asthma Tommy ISIL which means it would become biblically contaminated you're right if you say ain't Oh Alma Tommy I shall even by Carson which is the view of rabinin that Raveena in the name of raava then it would only be rabbinic the whole thing would only be rabbinic because food with food doesn't transfer to money by carbonize two opinions hold yeah one opinion holds no by mundane food everyone holds a nice helmet a miracle by true myrrh and cotton becomes the question right a buyer says ain't no soul Metamucil by Hulland but true man kocham yes rub-a-dub Arava says ain't no helmet a miracle by : and by trauma but by kocham yes a buyer says ain't no soma Tommy I shall only mundane food but true man kocham tomotommy OSA add the burro in the name of her over says ain't Osama Tommy go buy cool and an trimmer but by Katja Mia so in this case would become Tommy ravine in the name of robber says Makura moly dabira khasa ain't oil me Tommy ISIL ISIL with ISIL is only rabbinic which means the problem in our mission of meat cutting meat is only a rabbinic problem because biblically nothing happened the whole issue of becoming tum may meet with other meters only rabbinic according to that opinion but rashly said that the last opinion of Riviera Shannon has to be according to the opinion of a nice calm autonomy ISIL by Hulan and maybe by trimmer but not by coaching my countrymen Smetana says the gomorrah says the Gemara let me ask you a question they suffered a bellossom Ashkan is lucuma bijli are you going to tell me rebel Azhar holds that Maskin can have a tumor in the world a very interesting expression are you gonna tell me the balazar holds that beverages have tumor in the world meaning they can become contaminated you said your bilasa agreed with your mayor Ramaiya said that liquids can become tommy biblically that means your bilasa agrees really there's something off here it is there's a paradox that we're encountering why vitani we have another browser the browser says your Bellas are a man ain't Tamela Marsh can call it rebel aza has an a fourth opinion liquids can't even become Tommy they have no to mokou eka Kalika means whatsoever on any level they have no term in other words even they themselves cannot become coming are you going to ask me a question didn't we learn yesterday Apothic that whatever is in a Caylee that had a share it's becomes Tommy and the PASOK said we learned in a parish mini-me call her I shall I share your cholesterol of my Amit ma any food that's eaten which gets wet with water becomes Tommy and there the home Oscar I say ich ossible cochlea Tamar and any liquid that's drink and Michaela becomes Tommy where the losses are you with Apothic explicit it's not like it's not intimate that hinted you can argue about you eat more you Tommy I got that rib mayor says you tomorrow shimmery of Yossi of you to say you Tommy I got that you tomorrow your Tommy right you could say you Tom a foods or your timer even a Kalish in salsa but how clear you coming any CLE it's me Tommy that should be heard the fine but to tell me that liquids don't get Tommy at all but they're bilasa we're gonna see learns the puffs are completely different it's just interesting to see the the extremes the way they're blows on the stands the pasta cause it's not talking about the liquid becoming Tommy it's talking about the types of liquids that can make the food wet become Tommen so it says any food that's eaten that Mayan came on it and any other liquid that drank in a Kayleigh came on it the food becomes comedy in other words he didn't go from food to liquid you're just expanding the types of liquids that could make food susceptible to Toma that's what the tomorrow get another he completely has a different meaning of a bus the same classic with a completely different interpretations well everyone holds if I scholars drive and ever became wet it's not macabre Toma so the terrorist says because attorney says what ISIL will become Tommy actually lvl of my M but Omar scarcity salsa basalt clean or any other liquid that you drink in a Kayleigh came in contact with the food then the food yet a'mma a whole different interpretation the sidess is that food that only food can become Tommy aim to meal American Kalika Haida the past success food that water comes on it becomes Tommy or any liquid that's drank with every Kayleigh parentheses that comes in contact with food yet ma why did you say it to my twice why say you okay that's a good question I'd say it's my twice for food and drinks okay we'll see I'm just by pardoning that you shouldn't think there Belleza doesn't know about a pasta right because how can you say such a thing liquid doesn't forget tummy nothing that means that means I could put a mask on share it's in a market and nothing happens the Masha can even touch a mace or a person who touched a mace or a kailia touched a mace could touch this sword to touch the mace the soil touch the mazes of viavoice a Toma and I could stick that into my water my cup of wine nothing nothing happens not an hour of narration I restraining garnished intimal Omarska it's something that can't get to me like a rock or rock can't get tummy right you know a rock can get Tommy clay of on him and I'm a couple come on huh yeah when I thought I'm a mikvah we're talking money yeah yeah hey Don the bracer continues bilasa so Sarah hey Joseph Benny as each trade there's a testimony that we have from Yosef many as a rich trader you may remember him from the beginning of prickly Ava's chapter one he's one of the earlier generations who was middle of Bayou Chene II transfer the Messiah and he gives a testimony and it's called hate because there's a Homosassa attracted in Mishnah is called tractate a dos Adria's means testimonials and these are a compilation of testimonies that were given over the generations and that's where he says this testimony Isle Isle Kamsa there's a type of grasshopper called il Kamsa that it's doc on it story it's pure it's culture in Aramaic the word doc on is the word Fattah right when the targum wants to say Terry says doc huh so we all know that there are types of grasshoppers that are kosher there types of grasshoppers that are not kosher so Yosef beignet Ezzor the man of trade has said the grasshopper called Eyal Kamsa is kosher for Jewish consumption he also said one more thing Val Marsh can basement Bahia dokkum the beverages that flow in the Butcher house are pure what butcher house is he talking about yo Ibanez I said a very interesting Halawa there was a part in the base I ministers called bass I misspoke I am the butcher home the butcher place this was on the northern side the external miss Bayer if this is the MS BAE F within a matter of the car bonus this is the east of the base--emitter so you came in this way the conditioned conduction was the West I'm just doing it for simplicity right so this would be Dharam this would be south because this is East and this would be suffered on the northern side of the wall of them is Bayer this section was called basem it pacaya on the northern wall of them is Beth this was a very important place they would slaughter animals and they would prepare their animals for what has to be done meaning skin them rinse them from the blood so there was a lot of blood in the base I misspoke I mean there was a lot of water in the base I'm it behind these are two of the classic beverages of the seven beverages that become Tommy Soyo Sabini Ezzor said he testified that the Mashka the liquids that flow in the butchering section of the basic old basement Messiah in those order of the base I made it on the northern side of the Walter buck on their Tower they're not McCobb altima they're not susceptible to Toma I didn't mean the word flow I meant the the liquids that are there the liquid now let's understand something Mashka of based on with bhai I'm a stalker what does grace have been years are telling us here he's obviously telling us that all liquids cannot become impure biblically because if liquid can become biblically impure how in the world can the shaman say that this liquid is tired they don't have an authority like that you know people on the contrary Karcham I'm a Kabul tunnel more than anything else the Tory doesn't say cut Simon I'm a Kabul Toma and the contrary acai you know eats Carson that's Tommy or anybody it's a serious is sore they're washing it both Toma doesn't have to with washing two masks to do let's say let's say somebody dies over there and touches us let's say there's a dead spirits let's say there's a Thomas novela let's say there's anything that's Tommy and it touches meat it touches drinks if it would become Tommy biblically the rabbi's don't have an authority to say something is taught you know when a person learns mission d'marie always have to remember that the core of the shaman was very limited they could make hugs area they can make a decree they can create a buffer zone but they can't cancel out a biblical or look at it and have that authority so if liquid was only Tom a rabbinical e not biblically how then I can understand that the sages said we do not impose this tournament in the base hamikdash with we're keeping it out of the base our mixers but if you're going to tell me that biblically it's time a liquid is tell me biblically and there's no point to say that it's only tell me outside of the basement it's not in the base I mean Turner never makes that qualification so you're gonna tell me that the shaman said that the liquid and the base are mixer she's tall if I share its touches it it start how could they say such a thing obviously if Yosemite has or said that the masker in the Butcher home misfired it means that the whole Touma of Moscow is a rabbinic institution like Attila it's not a biblical institution who if I made it then I could play around with it then I could say I made it only here I didn't make it here and there was a reason for the logic what would be the reason for the largest Rashi says take a look around see the second of the wide lines on Mashka basement pacaya dokkum how masking so base um it became Shabazz Oracle going hadam waha my in blood and water Shane Dawson Shane and macabre and Toma Alma - my smash Kundera Berman Oh behind me Lloyd Gazoo you could say since they're the ones who created the idea that master could become Tommy so they made a qualification and the qualification is only outside of the holy temple not inside of the base images why would they do this dr. Rashi misham have said kocham they were very very concerned that carbonize shouldn't be lost if there's no Tomas Maskin so it's a give all de cos ah even if a tummy touches the blood on a carbon or touches the water it's not going to right if you touch this blood or water and that blood and water come in contact with the carbon the carbon becomes disqualified if you can protect the Mashka from to me it's immune to Toma it saves guards many more car bonus because remember Toma was a very common thing yeah a Cayenne releases a Cayenne releases semen or there is somebody who becomes a a NIDA or somebody who becomes as of or as OVA or somebody dies right or there's a novela an animal an animal dies whatever it is the shritha wasn't good or share its any of the other Sertoma can happen in the base on McNish and as a result of that if liquid becomes Tom a it's very easy for car bonus to get Tommy because there's so much liquid there and in contact with the meat and therefore the common did not want too much Maskin to be in that area but Rashi says but that means the ether I say Komatsu bottle the Torino but if it's biblical the rabbi's can't say sorry here there's no tumor and the Toyota says yeah you say no they don't have that authority they try to minimize the possibilities of Toma spreading in the area where the car bonuses have said culture they were so careful so even though they made a gazillion that Mashka could become Tommy just like oil can become Tommy magical become Tommy but it was only there a Bennigan's Ayla this is what rebel aza testified he said that this is what Yosemite as each trade has said and from here he learned that what that master is not McHale Tommy minute item so we ever a major contradiction in our first Bryce he agrees with the mayor Ramaiya said liquids could become Tommy they just can't transfer Toma here a bilasa clearly says Mushka has no tumor and he doesn't mean it doesn't transfer tumor because he's proving it from Yosef many as who says that the Mashka in the base image behind was taller which means that the whole tumor of master is rabbinic not just the ability to transfer but even the ability become Tommy so the gomorrah says as follows Hanif but in if the tumor was minute later the curcumin don't have that freedom to do it they cannot say imagine that that someone will say from today on Pesach we don't eat matzah we start eating Matt's on Lewis your now letter listen to them they don't have an authority to play with Toyota like that people don't realize they think that I come and rabbis are free to do rabbis are the most some were the most limited their whole objective was to explain Toyota to interpret rate it to find out the truth of the and sometimes to create safeguards around Toyota but never ever to to to manipulate exploit substitute say now we're not doing this outs good that baram it's a special place i agree with you that's that's why they said that xavier that we're making on Maskin we're not gonna make in the base--emitter sh but that's only if it's their own Zehra if they may cause a lot for example there's a dinner of angels by mukesh writing the bass i mix - the usual rabbinic injunctions for Shabbos were cancelled just an example ah yeah because it's the rabona but they can't say something you know that a Duma not tire you could do in the base hamikdash you're allowed a plant on sharp is in the base I make this your letter right in the base I make this good it's the base I make this right for character sorry it says in the mystical you know I want to build on Shabbos toyota says liquidus tummy we do you have the authority that helped me it's not taught me coz it's the base of the tire says the rebels don't Ken's the rabbi's can Institute to bring a carbon on Shabbos the Torah says that the carbon a carbon that was consistent and communal you could bring on shoppers for example the carbon comment slaughtering a lamb is forbidden on Shabbos but the same trader that prohibits Shabbos allows and obligates to bring a lamb on Shabbos but that's where the trader says if the Turner would say that liquid in the base I'm Alicia story we have no problem but there's no such a pasta can homage they can't invent it but it's not true the trader does say that meat could become Tommy yeah yeah yeah tell you doesn't seem that made some mistress there's no tumor if I can't whatever we're not talking if it happened we're talking to the real line emphasis Vova base I'm at bhai I'm right but but a coin could become Tommy Colleen could become Tommy yeah yeah something a matter of I turn honey Phyllis Shmuel this would be satisfied according fish gold armor who says Dawson Willa Tommy Thomas ah hey I'm about to massage finish line shop small holes that yes have been yes I never meant that the liquids themselves automata her he mended the liquids in the butcher asana base emitters are doc on they're pure military Thomas a Hayden they will not transfer Tomah novel tumors ops money Ashlyn but they themselves I'm a cobble tumor in other words Yosef many Azhar holds that biblically Mashka is McCobb Altima even in the base of impresario rabbinical II they can transfer to other foods but not in the base I'm advice I am because the rabbi is limited there's era only outside of the base HaMikdash because the transference of trauma of Maskin is rabbinic therefore they could say it's not only based on myth behind but the mask itself gets Tommy everywhere Sharpie then it works rebel aza works when a bellossom meant said ain't Tamela mash can call a curry meant ain't Tamela Marsh can Kalika that biblically Mashka can't transfer Toma transfer and where does he prove it from the oyster bunny Ezzor yo Sabine Ezra said that in the base of it bhai I'm Mashka doesn't transfer Toma how can that be if it's biblical it has to be that it's rabbinic and therefore they could send them is about the time it doesn't transfer Toma but themselves they become Thomas according to this explanation even the base of a there's a correlation there's no contradiction between the two rebel losses ll arrived on my daughter mamas but Rahu says doc on means doc on mama Mama's pure not only ducking from transferring to Ma duck on mom-ish means the liquid itself is pure it doesn't become Tommy Michael Omaima how he going to explain this according to dr rib Eleazar proved from the testimony of Yosef Binet Ezzor that liquids are not Makabe última mean a traitor at all Shmuel said when he used the word doc on it man doc on to transfer rob said doc on means doc on mama she himself is pure because the whole tomb of liquid even visa V itself is rabbinic if so we have a major contradiction between a bilasa and the second browser blows in the first price armor ab knock my buy each took rabbinical my eun-suk wants to answer i hada in the first bride suitable as ur the prices of akane horrible of ceramic at war of rebel Asura agreed with ripp may doesn't mean you agree with everything it means you agreed only on one aspect of rib mayor mayor you said two hours remain you said that if you have a Suffolk if Mashka became Tommy or not you say it's Tommy why because it's a Suffolk Jerry Rice but if you have a Suffolk if Mashka transferred atooma you say thar cuz it's a suffocated rabona and then it says their bylaws are agree to that mayor how your own wicked war of so we have a problem Romero that Marsh charisma Kabul to him annihilated his can transfer it he says no he agreed only on one aspect when I say I agree with you doesn't mean I agree to everything you said I agreed on the last thing that you said the last thing that you said was that if Mashka transfers Toma but you're not sure it happened it's a Suffolk so it's a Suffolk terrabona that rebel Asura agrees with your mayor because he agrees that the transference of Toma is only rabbinic but he also disagrees with remain about Mashka itself so when it says he agrees with have made its akhada it's only a one aspect of what Ramaiya said but he disagrees with group mayor on the first issue Reb mayor holds if it's a Suffolk if Mashka became Tommy it's a Suffolk very right sir and there he disagrees he old that if it's a Suffolk if it became Tommy it's a Suffolk they're abundant because their burrows are holds that even mask itself can become Tommy says the Gemara it's a very nice answer Bahama Hockett var of Cardon offici take a look at the words of the beloved Saint Xavier de Blasio I'm a kid var of davara of a singular or plural devar Ava's his words not his word his words that means both statements kid var of then offici an officially means many words many things in other words rebel aza agrees she drove with both of his statements not with one statement for ID and another problem Mohabbatein Kotani the language of the Brice's deviated mayor vain horrible aza imma kill var whenever it says McCain it means and the same thing similarly rebel loser said like his words and you're telling me now not really fifty percent yes there's a very confusing way of writing it you say the mayor said this and the same thing that Belleza said no not really he disagreed on one he agreed on the other that does not that does not add up first of all it says kids Vorderman second of all that says with Kane and the Gemara is responses Kashia I'm left with a problem I'm left with a question right the Gemara will never give an answer just to give an answer if the answer is intellectually dishonest it's intellectually dishonest so the Gemara says gosh we have a question we have a problem one Bryce had taught us that a bilasa says that liquid can become tommy minute or a second Bryce theory bullosa testified in the name of Yosef Binney Ezzor that mash could not become Terminator according to Shmuel there was no contradiction because there bilasa didn't mean to didn't mean it can't become Tommy meant it can't transfer to my core in Tehran we have a contradiction and we're left with a problem we have two opposite traditions that do not match with each other so the Gemara says says the goomery-goo fear we just learned rev on my Ralph says Dolphin Amish it can become it remains to her mamas rebel aza hold Mushka became stop mrs. Torrey biblically who small-arm our dolphin will the Tommy Thomas I hate him I'm a to Mossad spy Ashland it won't transfer Toma but it becomes Tommy on its own that's what we just learned so the Gemara explains the much like this Rob our Murdoch on mommy Kesava he holds that yes have been Yasir Yasir beignets are testified that tumor smash candy rabona the whole concept of Tomas Marshburn is just a rabbinic institution fascinating liquids can't become Tommy it's so interesting the contrast that according to Yosemite has a biblically Mushka is the best thing in the world doesn't get Tommy Rabbinical II it's always a Risha it's always aeration it's just a very fascinating contrast which you usually don't have this paradox of Mashka from rebel from from the urban users perspective minute Ida it's completely immune to Tameka and Madeira Bonner it's the worst it's the worst of Toma it's the worst tumor because it's always going back to ition it never diminishes it never dilutes the tumor it could touch a Shanee irrelevant it goes back to Isha it's supposed to be Ashley she it jumps back to generations in other words you would think if it's such a weak tumor because when I told it's nothing some of the Rabanne on it should at least be a weaker tumor and if more it goes down down down it gets diluted and if it's Ashley she it should certainly be Ashley she we say no things that are biblically Tom made can be Ashley she liked rumor carbon asara V if it touches I recently becomes a shame if it touches a shame he becomes its Lucy if it's biblically Tommy if something is biblically completely pure it's good it's it's fine but the rabbi's made a tomb on Maskin and they invented it according to a Sabine user according to his opinion it because astringency that Iceland and other tumors will never have nothing has such astringency that it could it always stays addition it could be a third generation and it always is it's Yaffa carbon McCoy aha it's a just a very fascinating insight maybe we'll get back to it but it's you could see there's a lot here like what would be the rhythm here to be the other way around though but that's what turbine user is teaching us that's wrath that what Thomas Maskin dear opponent the Seger's ruler born on by masking the alma and when the rabbi's made a decree that master shall become Tom a it's only mastered Alma it's only regular liquids were masculine basements Macario Lloyd Gaza but in the Mashka in the butcher butchering section the base--emitter they did not made that it makes the decree and all liquids remain Taher over there whoosh mala Marche mall says Daka mother Tammy Thomas I hate him how about tumors apps money Ashland it's tired from transferring to me to others but itself it becomes Tommy because Kosovar he hold that Joseph in years had believed that tumor smash cannot summon is there ice it's very rice and therefore even in the base summit bohemian has to become Tommy Tommy I hate him did a bond on only to transfer is a rabbinic tumor that he goes are abundant when did I bond and mate is a der that a transfers to mer the mask endow a regular March didn't imagine basement Pattaya Lloyd Gaza and the liquids of the base I'm it's math I am they did not make this cos ADA with he Lagos Arab on on and when their abana did not make this alien based on it became it was only with Tomoya aid him to be me Tommy other is because since it's only or their abundant they could say that this doesn't apply in the base of it behind they're going to be lenient that if Marsh can the basement behind my stomach and it touches bus are the Buster remains story so they protect the carbon is the beautiful tikona Havel to must Absalon yes Lahan but the tomb of the mask itself remains Tommy even in the base of it Messiaen in other words if you want to if if if you want to ask if this - if this if this water is Tommy your tire this water is Tommy or - or tire because Touma applies even in the base of it behind this is the argument between our Rav Laurent it and how small learnt it and again the principle is that if a common cannot cancel out a tumor mandatory so if you hold that Mashka is Torre de base I misspoke I am you have to say that the whole institution is a rabbinic institution if you hold that Mashka is not tiring based on it behind but it can't transfer to man based on it Messiah it means that the whole institution that master could transfer tumor is a rabbinic institution and therefore they can divide and say in this place yes and in this place not so the Gomorrah says all malaria Brunner bar can deliver a rabona the son of Hinnom said to his son he eyeless la comedia of papa when you're going to go into ref papa romney lay i want you to ask him a question rabona the son of he returns to song says you going to visit your papa I need you to ask him a major question that's bothering me what's the question fascinating question me a marshmallow Daka could small have really believed it could small have really believed that the mask and based on mid back I am is doc on millet Amita Massa harem cannot transfer tumor to other things I will to must absolutely schlund but they themselves become Tommy but they cannot transfer tumor because the rabbi said we're not going to allow it to transfer tumor because we want to protect the car bonus really that's what's more believed Huracan how could it be not read here this plastic this is the time to insert a passage and he's going to quote a passage from vehicular pay resign you mind giving me this commission right in front of you but you could pay to exile and prosecute tests the the the the I'm gonna I'm gonna quote the whole pas sick so I you crap a rings I and prosecute tests which should be impartial South partial serve right yeah but you crap a rings re and persecute tests if you have the blue mushroom its page 302 302 partial serve love it occurs chapter 7 verse 19 take a look at the puss ik 302 you see verse 19 ah yeah let's read these words waha boss are a share ye gah butthole Tomic meat that touches butthole Tommy I would translate anything that's Tommy Laurier uncle should not be eaten parenthetically you see here right the Terry's talking about car bonus and the Toyota says that car bonus could become Tommy meat that touches anything Tom a do not eat but a she sorry burning in fire here we have a biblical commandment that if a carbon touches told me after burn it we kept on talking about how they had to burn everything burn burn burn how they know to burn it apostle if meat touches tumor burn it of a ha buzzer call taller kielbasa this is an awkward sentence which of course the rabbi's come to life in such a sentence because obviously there's a lot of code it's basically will have the you know it's its probe it's divine codes and when a programmer sees a code some people run away and programmers come to life right we're gonna crack it so this is obviously about how busser called toyoko buzzer this is too awkward for me you don't write a sentence like this you could say but a she's sorry period cult are your boss and that makes sense if you're pure eat the meat if you're Tommy I don't want you to touch the meat because if you touch the meat that meat becomes tummy and then it has to be burnt I got that what's about Buster Colt Oracle Buster okay so the answer is that so we have to understand what the waha Buster is I'm just pointing that out just how they retook him because these are right away these are telling you how office but how Buster and the meat call Torrio kielbasa which means that in this posit you have the word meat three times it's not how you supposed to write a sentence you don't write in a sentence one send in the word meat three times right and the meat that touches every time I should not be eaten it should be burnt and the meat every pure person should eat meat okay but what are we learning here we're learning on a basic level that when meat of a carbon touches any Tom a you cannot eat it you cannot eat it uh-uh-uh who can eat it who can eat it coal tar anybody who's pure can eat it now doesn't it say butthole Tommy anything that's Tommy so now if I have liquid that stomach and the Buster touches it based on this pasta would it be Tommy or not be tumbler it says behold Tommy if it touches food that's Tommy if it touches a person that's Tommy if it touches a Kaylee that's Tommy if it touches liquor with that stomach it says behold Tommy but if smooth very good so if you don't like your ass that too much mash skin is there a burn on something they realize it's not Tommy so when it says behold Tommy it means food humans utensils but liquid doesn't have add intima so I got it so the rabbis could say even if we want to impose add intima it's only outside of the temple but in the base of it battalion we're back to the biblical equations so for carbon touches liquid even if that liquid became Tommy it's fine you know I could it's not Tommy I rabbinic ly it's Tommy not in the base semester we never made this decree here we don't want this decree here we don't want Mashka coming here getting somebody we like to maintain the status quo I got it but later Allah says that Marsh key itself becomes Tommy the grade of their opponent was only that in the base of it behind it can't transfer to me because I didn't want components to become Tommy outside yeah they made it exam but not inside asks rabbuna to his son go to the pop and say how could have small said this how does he deal with this it says Baba Sasha gigapascal Tommy lawyer okay I could understand I could understand that Mashka is not Mehta made a hell of Hulan Midori rice you could say biblically liquid doesn't transfer to me to mundane food why you're going to say when it says behold Marsh crush is a super Cokely it more in itself becomes Tommy it's not you Tommy like we learned before it doesn't transfer to me to other things who when it comes to car bondage that touch it the trader says a boss are you gonna call Tom a lawyer or hell because if the master is coming with a ricer the terrorist says any meat that touches anything that Tommy is Tommy you have to burn it how could this have some and cancel the sounds how can they take it out you understand the problem if you tell me mashed is now coming have no problem that's why he's asking on Shmuel me on Marsh more how could you explain this that's why wrath must be right when Yates had been your user said that in the base of mitzvah hayan Mashka didn't transfer to me he also meant that master doesn't become Tommy that's why he doesn't transfer to me if it's not Tommy doesn't transfer even the rabbi's who said it's Tommy not in the base something further doesn't run but shoe all holes it becomes Tommy mean I played and yet it doesn't transfer outside of the base somebody - I have no problem holding I have no problem because this person is talking about auction don't tell me that if Hulan touches if Hulan touches masks in the base i make this the rabbis didn't want it should get come I have no problem with that they're the ones who instituted the tumor they're the ones who canceled it how pressure us our pressure hit but the idea that if a carbon touches something that's tum made anything becomes Tommy that's a biblical Arthur and it includes liquids also if you say that liquids are considered Tommy soba Mela you cannot say that in the base of each dish when a carbon touches a liquid that's coming minutes later the title should say it doesn't transfer that's not fear there's a passing that says the Toyota says everything transfers to met the car bonus everything whether you have a right to say not you could say who Lena doesn't transfer only rabbinical II if it's rabbinic Lee then we're the bosses we could say in the base timing condition we didn't make things a derp but this is not this is not me they're a bum and this is a demon our Toyota this is his question or a bonus question on small you understand the question strong question a strong question ok we have we have to discuss my boss Sir but let's just wanted to point it out because I like pointing out these things I like pointing out these things now you can't tell me that your suburban user wasn't talking about car bonus maybe when he said Mashka basement pacaya story to transfer it's not car bonus it's : but that would be ridiculous the whole point why they said Mashka base amid behind doesn't transfer to me is to protect car bonus and yet carbon is precisely can't get to me I mean if she berated Abedini she said the official Sunnah turbidity said really worried what's your issue media to have a Reviva Kadish it always happens this is the level of a Reviva Kadish let's face it yeah the standards answered of all the cancer we remember we have levels of tumor trauma becomes Ashley she Carson becomes a ravine okay so let's do the example a man touched a corpse yeah this man who touched the corpse is an avatar okay the man now touched a Caylee the Caylee became a Rishi he touches a metal-on-metal care the killer becomes Irish okay you have food you put into the Kayleigh collar you put into the Kayleigh or salad it got wet it becomes a Shanee it touches you eat the shallow with the salad so your howl of trauma touches the salad so the hollers now Ashley she right you got it okay now I want to have a sandwich my carbon pacer I have a sandwich so I put lamb chops on my howl of trauma that became much Alicia and what did the lamb chops become a ravie a ravine so this is carbon that became puzzle it became mallet eat it what happens if this lamb chop touches my wine of wine of car bonus or it touches meat of carbon as what's DeLuca its interrupted because the ravine doesn't transfer either past success ah no after ravine nothing no we took here Evie it doesn't transfer I deposit says her boss Riga butthole Tom a lawyer he'll a carbon that touches anything that stung me you can't eat so how does the Ruby interrupt Emma suddenly everyone is made that it doesn't transfer but you just said meat of a carbon that touches anything that's Tom a should not be eaten so why are you interrupted by Ravi if this is a review and it's Tom a so now for another piece of meat touches it it should become a commission and if this piece of meat touches on our carbon that becomes our sushi and a Sri as long as you're talking about car bonus oh so suddenly called Tommy doesn't mean call Tommy it means there are exceptions yeah so here's another exception that's what he says those eyes those eyes those eyes I don't care but you told me that you can't tell me that liquid doesn't transfer tumblr to a carbon biblically why cuz the passage says boss are shaggy gah butthole Tom a rabbis can't make an exception base of it but I am no transferring that's precisely where transfers but anything that's Tommy no no Tommy means no no Toma Toma is always back all biblical tumor is never limited to a space you know that the rabbi's could make your hands tummy biblically if the tip of your pinky becomes Tom a your entire matsyas becomes Tommy its DNA level it's it's a DNA level it doesn't every every every genome has a copy of the whole organism so Mela it's always called Tommy that's this question MIT admitted our review by Kurdish in other words from Revere you can see that the whole Tommy doesn't mean literally but call Tommy because here is meat that touches a Tom a ravie and you could still eat it so what yeah any I ain't fine but any item that stomach is a reveal Tommy yeah and if I touch it nothing happens show you yeah so thine levels but it touched a reveal which is from a and still if another piece of busser touches that ravine nothing happens or liquid touches that ravine nothing happens no after ravine nothing no if a Shanee for Shanee touches Moscone and bumps it up but if a ravit utters marsh get nothing happens yeah the end of the game so what do we have to say that when it says behold Tom a it doesn't mean that anything that has a dinner of Toma can transfer to me to meet it means that something that we know that has the power of transferring tumor then if a carbon touches it it becomes something then yeah in other words something that we know that as a power to transfer tumor if busser touches it it becomes tummy and you're now letting eat and you have to burn it so for example if the meat purchase something that we know that can transfer tumor it becomes something touches our Kaylee touches a person touches the food but if it touches a ravie or a V doesn't have a power to give tumor we exclude it i bizarre if you hold that mask it doesn't have a power to transfer tumor you bet that's what small you're anyway doing it don't tell me you just did up settle says basalt on me everybody's doing that settle because at some point they're limiting the tumbler everyone doc nobody goes after a V so you see my review but cuz she did it masky flora boshy Dabashi rejected he said no no no no Reviva coy - Lloyd ikura Tommy hi kuritomi don't compare this the V was never called Tommy we call it puzzle we don't call it Tommy we call it puzzle it's disqualified to eat but it's not Tommy in fact nowhere does it say entire clearly that our V becomes Tommy we learn it out from a cow Akane will see how the rabbi's got to divvy it may be biblical but it doesn't say clearly that if you have a carbon touches Ashley she touches a shame no religion becomes tummy the rabbis learned out from a couple summer that is disqualified to eat so therefore when it says my boss I should go but soul Tommy it doesn't refer to ravine ravines not cold time and we even call it puzzle we don't call it Tommy remember there's a difference between parcel and Tommy parcel means it's disqualified to eat Tommy means it can transfer the tomorrow but high equally Tommy but if you hold that mask air becomes Tommy me their ice it's called pop a the tirtir assessment sort of marks care I say you shall simply eat more so when it says well sorry go basalt on Mary it must include mass Skinner doesn't have to include ravie the Turner calls mask unless you hold like Raph that master doesn't get Tommy then I'm good then I have no issue with you I have no issue who doesn't get Tommy based on myth behind the rabbi's didn't let it become Tommy because the xavier is only outside miss a minute but if you're telling me that master becomes tom a minute later and you want to tell me doesn't transfer it to other things but they're only madeira bond on grant it even if they base i mixed it only with your opponent granted but if it touches carbonize we have a posse how boss are shaggy gaba called tom a if it's tom a becomes a man therefore according to this opinion if busts are torturers marsh Khatami in the base i'm at Mahim it has to become Tom a and therefore I do not understand how small can believe that Yost had been user said that there have come and let and allowed lick that touched car bonus and abasement mcian to be pure meat how could have that happened even if they say that the transferring of Toma is rabbinic that cannot apply to sacred food of carbonized it contradicts this process how then in the base emitters did they have this cancellation of Toma when a carbon touched Mashka that was Tommy in other words the plastic the plastic says whatever is called Tommy passes car bonus even if it doesn't say anywhere that it has a kayak to be me Tommy others if it's called Tommy it passes car bonus IRA V back a dish has a didn't tumor and it doesn't parcel car bonus that's not a proof Revere was never called Tommy it's called parcel and we learn it from a cover climber but mask is called Tommy so from this plastic we could learn that if Mashka touches car bonus it touches car bonus and the Gemara says Tasha another question that we have unresolved we had one question earlier the contradiction of to rebel losers and now we have a problem with how Shmuel interpreted the meaning of y Sabina Ezzor Ramona's question that he asked his son to asteroth Papa remains unresolved how could have small entertained this idea what was the mechanism that the sages used to get out of this plastic how can have they allowed us Rob makes perfectly sense they believe that liquid was not coming at all biblically I got no problem Tommy here is not liquid because doesn't get Tommy I have no issue the whole Thomas marsh cream is rabbinic in the basically Thursday cancel that fine they didn't cancel it they just didn't make the Gazzara but if you're saying like small that there is to miss marks cream in our toyota the question is if it can transfer and base them is my Simon can transfer it to car bonus since I don't know how small made peace with this position based on this boss said how what was his halawet mechanism that the sages used when they saw such a posse how did they what's the word how did they how did they get around it how how could they ignore it and we don't we don't have an answer for this this is this is Kasia I could be master could be Raviv it's car bonus pasal means you can't drink it you just can't drink it its tummy it's puzzle will soon learn well learn enough you test the car behind me they use to figure out the ravine but the point is we don't have a source to call it tumor so we're fine not calling it Tommy have a wonderful Shabbos space our Sun will resume Monday this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net slash donate