Pesachim 16a-17a: When Chagai the Prophet Tested the Kohanim

the yeshiva dotnet we're up to test Sian Amidala f-- four lines from the bottom occlusion me Mac Sheeran okay Tessa and I'm an Aleph four lines from the bottom or portion me Marshall so in the previous share in the previous Gamora on to Zion Ahmad Aleph yeah we explored the argument between Ravan small in understanding the famous testimony of Yosef veneza ish trader who said that the liquid that flowed in the butchering home in the butchering section of the base emitters were pure Roth said mom is pure no tumor whatsoever mom is mom is pure which means is the Gamora says that he holds at the whole tomb of liquid is only rabbinic and therefore the rapper's can be selective and say here yes here not them that based on mixes were canceling the entire concept and therefore the liquids in the base of mixer in the butchering section the base I'm it back I am are not going to be Tommy wow that's like a big finish so that means even if Toma touches the blood and touches the water it does not become Tommy which of course saved so many car bonus from tumor because the liquids cannot become Tommy this is the of Wrath and the of Shmuel is that yes Ibanez it was not so extreme what he was saying is that in the base of mixers the liquid would not transfer to me the liquid itself can become Tommy but it can't transfer to me he holds that the transferring of the Toma is rabbinic and because the transferring of the tumor is rabbinic therefore the rabbi's can be selective and say in the base of mikdash not in other places yeah but the tumor itself of liquid is biblical because there's a passage for it and therefore they cannot cancel that in the base emitter and the Gemara explained that the pasta does say in parish mini that any food or drink that falls into the Kaylee of klaris where there was a debt Jarrett's becomes Tommy but Rob the possum differently he doesn't say every food that is eaten becomes tummy and every drink that is drunk and every vessel become stomach but rather it means every food that is eaten that gets wet with water or any drink that's drunk in every vessel and it makes the food wet it becomes tummy in other words the term of Marche Canada Terrier is describing is not the mask in themselves but the fact that the mask makes the ISIL susceptible to Tamar and the goomar explained what's the eat my ultimate Weiss according to our Kurdish moral I understand why it says yet my Atma to separate Thomas there's the tomb of ISIL and there's a Toma of mask and of course even a court is small we need to use the words to teach us that every liquid could make food susceptible to Toma because how do we know what not only water other liquids as well and the answer is because the plastic says McCullough Oh Salah Shaka all the food that gets eaten actually Yuval of Mayan that water is on it or missile Marsh gosh are you sure suppose all clima and any liquid of every K any Cayley will become Tommy so teaches me two things number one that any other liquid can also make it susceptible to Toma but the youth may at the end teaches me that the liquid itself can become Tommy but according to Rav know the to hit Mars are all to tell me different types of water that can make food susceptible to Toma there's water that's connected meaning water that is in the natural reservoir of water and a cistern or in a wellspring or a river or a lake or a brook or a canal or a stream this is water that's connected so to speak to the ground to the earth that's called medical bharat which is the natural habitat of water and you may think that is the water you need to weten the food to make it susceptible to duma because that is water in its natural distinct and unique place that's where it has its car shivers that is its natural organic place if the water is in a Kaylee detached so to speak that water cannot make the oil be coupled over or you could say also the opposite that when it's in a Kaylee it means that I really chose it and idea for took it out from its natural place and I really want this water but if it's in a natural if it falls into a river say my cherry falls into a river even if I wanted that it's not ready for my cobble to mother kabbalah stoma that's why you needed to hit Mars the first year - mom I am the ice colossal Shiva love Miami Tamar and then the Hamas cosh adjustable sulkily each ma that what and even Mashka including water in a Kaylee which is detached also allows the ISIL to become common okay ask the Gemara or solution me ma Sharon do you really believe that detached water can make food susceptible to Toma so that means if I have water in a cup and I throw my grape into the water or I pour that water on the grape do you really believe that that grape is susceptible to Makabe Toma that's really what you're saying that by maíam even Klum works what's the problem and let's note the question is on water because by water there's a difference between water and its natural habitat and water that's attached from its natural habitat other liquids we don't have this question because there's no natural habitat what's the natural habitat for milk in the other it's solution it's in the order of the cow right or honey in a beehive right or oil and an olive and you press it I mean it's not like so therefore it's always detached so to speaks over there over there there's no there's no distinction and the Torah says that other liquids make food susceptible to a couple tumor the question is on the question is on water what's the problem Bob you're right yeah yeah yeah soda are you gonna tell me that Lucian Omashu vomit a very similar brown in a rebel she said in the name of canina a fascinating how La Marche can basement micaiah the liquids in the butchering section of the base emitters LOI Diane Shane doc are not only are they pure they remain ritually pure Elish a machine in WIC says it was such a radical situation that the liquids that flowed in the butchering section of a stomach make food susceptible to be mockable Toma so if there was a piece of meat that got wet with water or blood say over there in the base on McNish that meat could not become to me because it never got wet it has to get wet from a different liquid not from the liquor liquid in the base amid back I am now one second if detached water can make food susceptible to Burma Kabul Toma biblically how can the rabbi's cancel this Halak and the base of McNish so you have to say that biblically only water that's attached to the ground could make food susceptible to Kabul Toma it's the rabbi's who added a decree and astringency that any water even detached water could make food to septal hematoma and then we can understand that in the base hamikdash they said we're not doing it but if it's a biblical halacha that all water makes food steadily hepatoma the rabbi's don't have a power to cancel that and eliminate a clear biblical bits are in the base-emitter shuts off with you don't have permission to do that they don't have that spiritual authority to change our locker so we have to assume that the whole notion that water that the detached could make food susceptible to Toma is a rabbinic notion and that's where the BAC says in the base of McNish it didn't exist we have a pasta that Watts the pasta the passage says me call her I shall I shall I shall I shall vial of Mayan water what type of water I don't know okay if we come Oscar I sure you shall see but Coakley mask and any liquid that's drunk in any Caylee in a kale eat in a vessel get MA so we learned two ways either you can learn it means it becomes Tommy or Rav said yet Amami is what it makes the food Tommy and I've said that the second yet my teaches you that even water in a Kaylee makes it susceptible to Toma asks the Gemara there's a floor head is a problem because the town area BOC taught us that the liquid to the base ominous can't make foods except we make apple Toma that means that water that's detached making food susceptible is only a rabbinic Zeta it's not a biblical thing if that's the case my implosion would not be something that makes Uncle Tom a Minotaur it doesn't make oil acceptable terminator if that's the case then the second you tomorrow has to be interpreted like small that the liquid itself becomes Tommy Mashka becomes Tommy now you're only left with one you tomorrow to teach you that what that water makes food susceptible to become Ultima and you're going to say that water means connected water not detached water says the Gemara no because if you say the second year too much like small then it works perfectly any food that's eaten that water is brought on it the food becomes Tommy that's it you have which water but which water muscle Boram mr. Baum this day sir Surya I've said you have a second you tomorrow why do you need a second you tomorrow to teach me my inclusion but I'm proving to you that to loosen is not me they're nicer so what's the second you tomorrow that liquid itself becomes Tama now that it makes Oh Sultana so this is a further proof for small and a rejection of Wrath and cavaldi Cariah that the mask in the base a mixed dish was not being mastered food to be my camel toe sock demerit areum al damn it's not a question you can translate the words of rebel you see referring to blood not the water the water does make food Bhima Kabul to me even if it's detached it's dumb force Epis why this distinction I'm gonna be a robber maybe I should appear the son of a percent Naval Aviation on me now you know damn costume Shana max here how do we know that blood of sacrifices cannot make foods acceptable to two machinima the plastic says about blogs the plastics is about blood loit iceland who don't eat it al ha Orestes pisano Comorian don't eat it what should you do with it pour it out on the ground like water why does have to say like water a lot Orestes person who come on pour it out on the ground don't need it come on like water why so we learned from here celebration are fascinating Allah who listen to this damn Shan ish become I am only water that can be poured out on the ground like water only blood that can be poured out on the ground like water meaning you don't need a catch it in a vessel there's no use for it that's moksha that's blood that makes food susceptible to Toma but damn shame English come I am but blood that cannot be poured out like water you know why because it's the blood of carbonize and the blood of carbon is you need a vessel to contain the blood because you need to sprinkle it on the altar a name a sure that blood does not make food susceptible to be macabre to mom in other words our Orestes pasando chameleon you know when blood is like water blood is like water if you pour it on the earth though is a fascinating Iloka we compare blood to water it's one of the seven beverages that we compared to water so he says don't eat blood pour it under earth like water when is blood compared to water when you could pour it on the ground what if you have to hold it in a Caylee it's not like that car bonus car bonus you can't just let the blood flow out to the ground you have to catch the blood because you need to sprinkle it on the blood so Dom that's Nishka maíam Dom that you could let get lost like my M which means damn cool in regular blood of a mundane animal you don't have to receive it in a Kayleigh when you Shack the babe that blood is compared to water and therefore if it's compared to water just like water makes food susceptible to Tama this blood owes but damn shade and it's become my blood that does not get pour it out and lost like water like of cotton which you have to receive in a vessel and put on them is bass ain't a masher it cannot make food source applicable Tama that's where the plastics is Allah or its dispassion oh c'mon you know when blood is like water when you could just let it pour on the ground and get lost you know just move trickle down and dry up but if you can't let that happen it's not like my am it's not like water Allah orestes Pisano chameleon it's like mine because it's dispersed annual audits damn consume there's no chispa's annual or it's you stand there with a vessel that's the source for the ocean on skiddish that what that damn kocham are not moksha oh i buzzer e-rep yabba-dabba canina makes a lot of sense when he said that the liquids in the base are mixtures don't make the food susceptible to Toma he means blood because blood the turret excludes explicitly but water whether it's attached or detached could make food susceptible to trauma biblically even in the besan mixers the rabbi stuck and didn't cancel that you know why cuz it's a biblical OWASA i blood blood the Toyota clearly excludes blood damn Coxon but my in the Toyota doesn't exclude ayats Talos it's detached but Rob believes that even the attached water makes food susceptible to be miserable too much huh right we're comparing dumped to my and beautiful but when what type of damn what do we do with water what does it turn describe about water yeah you just let it pour on the ground and nothing happens you don't have to hold on to the water so that's the blood that you compare to water that blood when you check the regular animal the blood is just mechanical might mean nothing do anything with the blood and therefore that's the blood that you compare to water muscular I'm small Bahrami small Bahrami asked a big question hi ray dhamma campuses Dinesh become my in vain a machine there is a blood called dhamma Tunxis what's da Matanzas da Matanzas ah is the blood that you cannot use for the MS baya this is the trickle of blood the way he translates here in English is dama Tunxis is others translated here there is the blood that trickles out of an offering before and after the jet of live blood that unique current of live blood if the blood that trickles before and after the jet of live blood this blood could be spilled on the ground like water why so the halacha is when an animal is slaughtered there's different stages in terms of the flow of blood the blood that trickles out of a slaughtered animal is not suitable for the MS baya it's not suitable to place on them as male only the live blood which spurts out in a jet that's called the live Blood Diamond Efes that blood that spurts out like a jet that's the blood that you could put on them is baya not the Dharma Thompson which trickles out before and after it trickles out before and after the jet of live blood that that spurts out in a jet that blood is not kosher for them as mayor the reason for that is like Rashi tells us the plastic says in vyak rocky Adam who Bonifacio per for the blood that is of life that's the blood that atones the blood P Adam Reuben fr the blood that is of the life atones what shot only the blood with which the life leaves the animal the blood with which the life leaves the animal is suitable for Khepera so the blood that trickles out of an offering you don't have to receive in a vessel it could be spilled on the ground like water which bloody after receiving a vessel only the blood that spurts out in a jet right that's called the blood with which the soul leaves the animal that blood that when that blood flows it represents the fact that the life of the animal ended that blood so to speak which carries the soul with which the soul leaves the animal that you put on them as mayor not the blood before and after which is not called the blood with which the life leaves the animal that's the fat hadam who by nefesh Harper I guess when it starts to cut there's a trickle but the soul didn't leave with that blood and then there's deject of that's the lifeblood with which the nephrons goes out so that's the Dom that you bring on them is baya so the Dhamma Thomas what's the halacha snitch become I mean it could be spilled on the ground like water nonetheless vena moksha but it doesn't generate susceptibility to tumor when abusive Rebecca nina said that the liquids in the base of mid-back iron don't make the food susceptible to McCampbell tumor he didn't differentiate between blood any blood that's there any blood that's on the Behaim and that means even the dhamma Thomas but this blood is Nishka mine cuz you don't have to put it on the MS baya nonetheless what does he say it's not math sure it's part of the master base of its books I am so you can say that that's the reason we explain the reason that the Dom is not my shoes cause out the artists expression oh c'mon this is not to treasure no kamae but this is de mr. Schmucker no Kamiya if it's expression okay maíam so then why is it not mark sure unless you say of course because the whole idea that water or that's detached water that's detached it's not Marsh row so what's the source for this idea I'm elated Zeta hammock Adama Thompson's the fellow Bakula na mila Marsha leave we'll go the Dhamma thomas's even by Hulland wouldn't be Marsh Wow even by a regular animal why he blew my name is mo Bahrami small bar ami received the explanation from the musée de la marijuana the Gator says in volume recyclable th Allah damn Kadam wanna fish be strong don't eat blood you know why ha damn wanna fish the blood is the sole meaning the blood is the lifeline of the animal so we learned from this damn shun nefesh Yeats Aboy kuru dom dom shannon officiate sabina corrida the blood with which you could say that the soul leaves the animal with this blood the life of the animal ceases with this blood that's called blood ha damn who on average which blood are we talking about the blood that carries the soul that spurt of blood that jet that spurting out of blood with which the soul leave the life leaves that's called blood had dama one effort damn Shane and officiates Abeba dammit comes is the blood that trickles before and after anal Carter damn that's not called damn if it's not called damn so then it's not doesn't make food susceptible to be macabre to me doesn't undo with Karcham dam attempt this is add-in in all of car Bonus Dhamma Thomas will not make it to central capital of why because for dam to make something acceptable to be likable Toma it has to be called dam how do we know that the other liquids make it susceptible to tumor because the terrorist says vocal mask any liquid so we have to have references in Tanakh what is called a mask so the Casals scan the whole Tanaka and they found six liquids that are called masks that I refer to as liquids for example honey dew oil milk huh blood blood it says in vadym halal Mishnah he will drink the blood of the slain so we learned from here that usually drink but this tough pass it tells us a hitter's what's the definition of dumb definition of dumb is that it has the soul in it so to speak it's the lifeline it's the lifeline and when that blood leaves the soul leaves with it that's the definition of them and therefore another damn doesn't have the definition of them who are nefesh would we say that blood on it and their photos doesn't have the definition of Mashka which is when the Turner calls something damn what's called Dom not Dom attempters and therefore it's not moksha so dammit tomten under with car bonus bicarb honours the idea is a large dish foreshadow Comorian that what's going on the MS BAE F is not called Dom it's not like my man is not that's the hollows of Ribisi this a lot of Dom attempts this is a different I love the Dhamma Thompson is not called damn so remain low revs position could still be maintained that what detached water still makes food susceptible the macabre Tama I based on it Bahama doesn't that's a unique a lot about Dom that attorney excludes specifically damn attempters anywhere and damn cotton regular damn damn one average biker bonus because it's not just oka maja Madurai I searched seems not there nice it seems that dumb is not the problem good question we call the Dhamma Tunxis I guess we call the Dhamma Thomases in other words you need the blood with which the life leaves the animal that's considered the blood Don Juan nefesh of Hulan yeah yeah no that's any blood by a high and annoyed is a separate in of kisi Adam any blood anyone right Dom attempts is not right right right right right okay so the Gomorrah maintains rouse position to be maintained touch MA however we have another proof that challenges arrived that liquid is not susceptible to Timmerman our Toyota RAV believe that biblically liquid is not macabre Toma certainly can transfer Toma rabbinical II it's McCobb Altima but biblically he behold it's not macabre to me when the plastic speaks about liquid it's only talking about making food susceptible to tomorrow the Gomorrah is now going to raise three challenges to Roth from Bryce's that are all similar that deal with a particular unique reality that sometimes happen in the basis of McNish Ralph's position is that liquid biblically never is Makabe Toma it can't be my capital it's something that's immune to Toma rabbinical II it could but not biblically I the past success liquid in every Kaelin should become Tommy meaning liquid and a Kaylee makes the food Tommy if it gets wet with those liquids or with water detached water retention the liquid itself is not macabre Tommy minute that's Rav and they're from the base--emitter it was completely Taher the liquid it never became Tommy even if somebody was mamma's Tommy even if it was a share it that touched the liquid it wouldn't become Tommy certainly wouldn't pass out to me nothing happens that was around I the rabbi said it does become Tommy not in the base some extra because they wanted to protect the car bonus from Toma as much as possible that was Rav Shmuel had a different Ajmal said no biblically doesn't get Tommy it just can't transfer to me minute may not tell you only rabbinical in the basis of McNish they therefore made it more leaning that it shouldn't transfer tum it becomes Tommy but it doesn't it doesn't it doesn't transfer Toma they wanted to save car bonus have said coach on well for example you have a miniature mixed with oil right if the oil gets Tommy so that's done you can't eat it but you're eating oil it's mixed yeah if it's mixed with a liquid then I would were disqualified so it's a much greater protection we have a very interesting halogen Owen as sits maritza sits Marat sameen's there was a what does it call that sits the how do they translate it the head plate the plate on the forehead of the Cayenne well Mandira Bonin with the rabona you're right only Madeira Bonham okay but Madeira Bonham is a serious Toma even Rav holds that mask leave a couple to mommy their opponent does not mean a Toyota so Ralph Holden the baser mixtures they completely canceled it that there's no tumor in order to protect the courtship in the car bonus no based on Midler's but outside of the base I met Visayan there was two men Mushka in the base of mixers that's how he touches the rabbi's did not make this Zeta in the base--emitter right right the trimmer that becomes something would be outside of the base semesters the Kohen Gadol wore what we call its it's a head plate okay the pasta about its it's something very very interesting in parishes to Java and that is I'm gonna quote the pasta because this is gonna be the context behind the next piece of Gomorrah for hi-yah mates of Aaron it says impartial sat Sava it should be on the on the forehead of irony a head plate it was a golden head plate that was tied to his head it was under his tefillin on the forehead it said two words engraved Kadesh lash em engraved in this gold and the Turner says something unique about this garment that he wore this head plate this piece of jewelry that vanassa aaron as a vain hikakin with this erin carries the sin of the offerings actually a condition a is sure which the Jewish people sanctify and it should always be honest forehead waha yah mitzvah atomically Rutzen lam the finish am to be a will to be appeasing for them create will for them before god this is purchased at savvy parity of Cass plus ik para Kafka's pasa calamitous numbers 28 verse 38 the rabbi's now have to tune into this what does it mean that the head plate carries the sin of offerings what sin of offering what does it carry carry means like it atones like somehow there's a sin and thats it says don't worry no sin what does it mean there are things that Toyota for example punishes with curries somebody eat spiegel a Korean has a thought while he's doing a carbon that he's going to sprinkle the blood in the wrong place or in the wrong time it disqualifies the carbon or I'm going to eat it in the wrong place or in the wrong time or I'm going to burn the fat in the wrong place or in the wrong time I'll sprinkle the blood tomorrow instead of today right or sprinkle the bread and Bnei Brak instead of in the base I'm ENGLISH or I'm going to eat the offering in a week instead of tonight or I'm going to burn the fat in three days on them is beige instead of today all this disqualifies the carbon you now let eat it sometimes is even a serious penalty it's not forgiving and I would eat it you know so what is exactly me if a coin is Tommy it says he's now that eat the carpet if the meatiest Tama is now that eat the carbon we learned how boss are so eager but hold on baby sir what is this sin that it's it's atones for what what type of sin what are we talking about that you could just ignore it and move on what is this something that that since does and they were looking everywhere well the Turner says you now go to do you now how to do you can't say it was canceled one thing what is that one thing if the blood becomes Tommy if the blood becomes Tommy you're not eating the blood but you're sprinkling it on them is baya so the finish is that even though the blood is Tommy and the cayenne sprinkles it on the altar it's Tommy Ditka blood nonetheless the carbon is valid that's what it's it's creates the Nasser Savoy in our culture that sits creates this tremendous kiddush that even though the carbon was offered with Toma meaning the blood became impure and you sprinkle it on the altar it's not a problem it's a fine carbon you fulfilled your obligation you can burn the fat on the MS baya you can eat the car bonus and you could take blood it's a good value you could take blood it's Tommy and you could put it on them as baya why because that sits is Murata that's the avoiding a country that that sits is Marat so for that's the kiddush the posix says Muhammad SAW are even OSA irony Savona car traumatic disabilities role will hold Martinez cachet and Ohio mr. Tommy Lee Watson Lam Lavinia deny numbers 28 38 so what is this what is this teaching it teaches me a unique kiddush that if the blood becomes Tommy you would think it's all over throw out the blood the carbon is disqualified and go bring a new carbon no this is what it's it's atoned for you could take the blood sprinkle on them as back and the whole carbon is caution once you sprinkle the blood you can burn the fat on them as may if you can eat the meat that you have to meet it's all good partial stirred Sava Oh I said numbers I'm sorry Exodus Exodus I stand corrected Exodus schmoes okay the mhmm said an interesting Zahra and that is the herkiman said that if it was done willingly then they made a penalty on the person that he shouldn't eat the meat even if the blood was sprinkled if it was done willingly if the tumor was done willingly or the spring cooling was done willingly just two ways of learning it they made a cos that he shouldn't eat the meat because it was done willingly the tumor was done willingly okay they still didn't make him bring another carbon that they can't you know why because that would be making him bringing Hulan Lazzara because if he's youngster with this carbon and you haven't bring a new animal you're offering a mundane animal as a carbon that had come and can't do that what they did do was they said don't eat the meat in this case in other words we treat it as though that the carbon was disqualified even though what a tone from he doesn't bring another carbon so that the Gemara says Kozma if you have damn blood chanita Mars became impure who's Erick I wish I gag and the Cayenne sprinkles it inadvertently hurts the carbon is good and the person is atoned and he can eat the meat because that sits covers the problem but the method if it was done willingly let's say he made it Tommy willingly Leutze then you now let's eat the meat anymore not good I mean I tried it still good by the way the hakama made a penalty since he made the blood Tom may be amazed it that it disqualifies him from eating the meat or anybody from eating the meat even though he sprinkled the blood on them is bare and biblically the carbon is good which is why they will not make the person bring a new carbon because that they don't have a car for the rabbi's can tell you to take whole in and make it a carbon and be mockingly submitters because that's violating mom ashram it's from the turn terrorist says you now let it do it and they say no you're allowed identity says you now let each closet they say a lot of you thousan toyota says this carbon was good you know if to bring another cop they could give you a not to eat the meat for doing it the mazes that yeah that's the challah what do we see from here right away we see from me right away that the blood became Tommy he says Dom should knit my blood became Tommy one second which blood was this this was Dom of car bonus mashkov based on mitzvah Higham is Makabe tumor why cuz obviously liquid is susceptible to tumor minutina I it's based on myth Messiaen it's still Tommy why cuz it's biblical the rabbi's can't cancel tomb of liquids Iosefa D as I said mask of may submit which I am is not Tommy obviously he meant it doesn't transfer tumor but it becomes Tommy itself you see that the blood becomes Tommy here this refutes the of Rev that Yosemite has it held that blood is not macabre torment because it's sir it's Kabbalah smash skin tumors only Madhubala the kymaro says you have no proof Medina born maybe this Bryce is talking about rabbinical e the blood became Tommy Medina Bonner who Deloitte EOS piñas Irish trader and this tunnel that even in the base I mean battalion it remains Tommy not like here a subpoena as you say who said that they saw someone did not make the blood in the base of it which I am be susceptible to trauma he owes that the blood could become Tommy and by the way the camera could have also answered as toaster says that this Bryce sir follows the that Marsh can could become Tommy minutes later so it's fine even when I thought it'd become stomach you could say that also there's that right the of rip mayor actually becomes a minute later but the Camaro wasn't even according to Roth who owns that mask is not the Kabul to Merman our Toyota this wish that this browser still works that DOM is macabre to my Madeira born on and that's a problem and that's why they told you if it becomes Tommy but maser don't sprinkle it and don't eat it and they give you a canasa if you do sprinkle it not to eat it but it's all matter up on I mean I try to you're right it would be not Tommy you're right so even according to rob this Brice of works the only thing is that unlike Ravo said that you're submitting has said a dumb is not macabre Tom at all and base up its bhai am here we see it as my Coble Tommy even if it's the rabbi's the rabbi's did impose the term and the base--emitter according to Roth only MIDI robotics here right ah so you want to know that since is the high union of biblical that sits Marat say right is biblical that's a good question wait a moment wait a moment toss me another Bryce of iiterest question O'Brien says el martes it's maritza what does it's it's a piece for what does it's it's atone for our Adam blood our boss to meet our Shayla fat chanita which become Tommy Bambi show gig unwillingly babe amazing willingly bein Bahrainis whether was by owners meaning was coerced bein Bharat's in minute with you with Co volition bein be offered whether there was a individual carbon bein with sabor it was a communal carbon in all these cases that sits does a tremendous function of atonement that what that if blood becomes Tommy that sits allows me and says go sprinkled abroad like a pillar right the rabbi's said don't sprinkle it like a pillar don't the rabbi said Don because it became Tommy but that's it says manator that it's fine but the ever did sprinkle it that sits is Murata and the carbon is caution so I mean I tried even if it's it's if the sits is there and the Dom is Tommy it works the rabbi said don't sprinkle it if you did but the of it the carbon is kosher and you can eat it when it comes to meat and fat meat and fat that's not essential to the carbon right in other words what you need for a carbon to be successful is that the blood should go on the altar one of the blood I was in the altar you fulfilled you fulfilled you fulfilled the carbon nobody's gonna say that it's it's allows that if the fact became Tommy you could burn on the MS BAE AHA or if the meat became Tommy you can eat it the trader clearly says that you're now letting eat meat that's tummy you cannot argue with that nobody says the meat becomes Tommy you can eat the meat what we say is if the blood became Tom a man out tire you could sprinkle the blood and even Mitarai Bonin if you sprinkled it in the oven you could still eat the meat but if the meat Kame Tommy then you have a problem you can't do anything with that meat if the fat became Tommy you can't put it on them as Bayer that's--it's will not allow you to cancel out that tumor but you know what it doesn't make a big it's not a big deal why because offering this meat eating the meat and offering the fat are not essential to the carbon they're just accessories so you're done once the blood is sprinkled even if the meat became Tom may I fulfill the mitzvot the main thing is that the Dom went to the MS bath and that's what it's dis accomplishes that's--it's atones for that which without it the carbon would be pasal which is the sprinkling of the blood that's what it's it's does once the blood is sprinkled the carbon is fine I can meet this tummy so don't eat it I the fattest tummy so don't be mad corundum is Bayer but the main thing is that now the carbon is good you don't have to bring another one why because the blood was sprinkled on the MS BAE and if you did sprinkle the blood on them as mayor the carbon is good but the event was you have it sits and you don't have to bring you don't have to bring a another carbon when the Brice's says that it's it's atones for the buzzer and the hail of that becomes Tommy Rashi says it's talking about there was a of rabbi Yeshua there be sure held that if you don't have any meat or fat left let's say it all got lost somewhere or it went out of yours shall i omit went out of the it went out of the mijita then your now let us sprinkle the blood and there's no carbon we're sure were held if there's no buster and no a moment they got lost or went out from the place where it has to be let's say the meat went out of yours shall I am with a fat one out of the Hazara so then you can't sprinkle the blood so the Bryce is saying that that's only if they left they're confined when they got lost but if they got Tommy that sits will still do the job that what it's as though there's fat and meat that you could sprinkle the blood that's the finishing so what do we see here that if the blood becomes Tommy that sits at tones even if the meat becomes Tommy and the Heylin become stomach all of it don't think it means that there's no meat there's no Haley we can't sprinkle the blood there is because in terms of tumor that sits accountant does it not only that you can eat the meat but it atones that what that you could sprinkle that blood mean I try to you could have killer sprinkle the blood of a carbon and it's all good even the how common the how come him said you shouldn't sprinkle it but if you did you're good if you did it amazed it if you did it amazed it then they made a class that you shouldn't eat the meat but the carbon is still good that's the hidden of sits me rots and as we see here its Bashar gig it's been mazing it's bonus it's been rotten its Yakut Seaboard no matter what the previous brightest we said only but show you can optimize it so Rashi explains you could learn it at two ways but show gig would mean the tumor happened by showing it even if the sprinkling was amazed it so it still works that's what amazed it means or the other way around that the tumor happens but may is it even if the sprinkling has happens by showing it in other words you could learn when did if I come and give you the chaos if you made the tomb of amazed it that's the bottom line but if the tumor was be showing it I don't care if you sprinkle it amaze it that's what it says Mesa there or you could say the other way around there's two ways of learning it that what if the sprinkling was Bashar gig I don't care even if the tumor was amazing the sprinkling was amazing then I care there's two ways of learning it to reconcile the first Bryce in the second glass but what's the bottom line in everything the bottom line and everything is Dom is macabre Toma we see from Adamas macabre tumor and therefore Tomas Martinez minute Aida and that's why even the Dom of Koch him in the basement box I am is macabre Toma not like Roth who said the Dom is not macabre to them and based on with behind Koziol does not monitor so the Gemara says again no Madeira Bona you could say this is rabbinic or Deloitte koyasu ben yahzee trader and again not like Yosef who's he holds that the rabbi's didn't make eggs area of tundra in the base I'm ignition here there is Xavier of tumor and the Dom is only Tommy made a rub on them back to your question so what do you need us it's for if the whole dinners are did they are born on so what is the Torah to speak about it's it's when the Toyota is not even God is that is a Toma in the base hammock there's a coin god the worid huh even though okay so the Moses touch MA vanassa Irina Savona kocham here's the actual posit that I was quoted ayran will carry an atone for the sin of khartoum the bracelet says ASA of I know no say tell me which sin does Aaron atone for with it sits let's go through it over Antigua the sin of piggle meaning if I bring a carbon and while I bring the carbon I haven't thought that I want to do it outside of the right place I will sprinkle the blood in Bnei Brak I will burn the fat in New York and I will eat the meat in Borough Park Hara and my lawyer a rut sir there's a posit that when somebody has this much of a lawyer erupts and this carbon is not atoned tire can't contradict itself and says it is a talk okay next a my very no sir maybe if I have a thought that I'm gonna leave it over I'm gonna eat it in the wrong time or I'm gonna sprinkle the blood in the wrong time where I'm gonna burn the fat in the wrong time had a crime I'm a lawyer huh chef Terry says in Paris our lawyers harsh if this carbon is not considered of any value that means that it's it's cannot atone for it so let's go through the scenarios what does it's it's accomplished if I disqualify the carbon through negative thoughts do it in the wrong place doing in the wrong time the toyota says disqualified maybe it means maybe it means something else maybe it means let's say a call Eunice tummy and he eats the carbon heats the carbon is that really what's happening that the Quarian eats the carbon tummy whose sin is that it's not a sin on the carbon as I said on the Korean rap she says it says I've very not caught him a sin of the car but not of the Cayenne okay so it's give me another time another idea the meat is Tommy and you're allowed to eat it because there's no sin of carbon as even though it's Tommy but the Toyota says clearly boss sir that touches tell me after burn in fire you can't have Toyota contradicting itself what is the sin of a carbon that Aaron is atoning for tell me what what happened there what happened here if the Cayenne did it in the wrong way the tire says it's not good to know what torment for it not good right if we disqualify the carbon evidence rinkle the blood all these things what is this sin something happened here and we cannot figure out what it is so the browser says Ella Irvine Toma one thing it's divine Toma a vine Toma means that something became Tommy what is it that became Tommy the event um what's a vine Toma that the blood becomes Tommy Voss Epis why would this tumor suddenly be atoned for why would the blood becomes Tommy is it atoned for why did this not become a serious thing so he says show who drama club it's a blur because we see that with Tunga the tiger takes it out from the regular prohibition when it comes to the zebra whenever there's a carbon sibour if most of the Chi in him and most of the zebra Tommy you could still be at my crib it's called tumor hood sherbet zipper even without it sits to Mehrotra but zebra means that when there's a carbon sibour a communal carbon you can bring it with Toma for example the carbon pacer if most of the Jews are tummy most of the car in my tummy they can go into the base on McNish there can be Mac rivet bit tumor they could do everything but um how could you you're not allowed oh you're not little walk into the Masonic - you're not little be my time with the blood you know a little bit more time with the meetings are only sort of the answer is tomorrow timber timber we learn out carbon tamid carbon pacer who it says been my other you have to do it in the right time of my addiction that you always do it even if that's a blur and the K&M are coming in that time if most of them are Tommy so we see that tumor is a unique type of prohibition that sometimes the Toyota completely cancels out the problem of tumor that's why there was a view that you could be marked with a carbon paste of this man as if you build them as mayor I we don't have the para Duma but since the Holt Sybaris Tommy so you get a Cayenne he's Tommy and he's Mak of the carbon payers and he goes into the base high McNish and you do everything connected to the carbon pesos to malhotra bit simple carbon-based has a carbon saber fascinating Allah so therefore Gupta McCulloch but sabor since the Toyota by Thomas says that bite Cebu you can do it even without its its so by carbon your kid even though your now let it bring it but um but it's it's helps that what that if it became Tommy if what became Tommy if the meat becomes Tommy I don't care burn it if the fat becomes tell me I don't care don't burn it but if the blood becomes thaw may I kind of a carbon because you have to bring it to the altar that's the key the Hadees of that since is it's still good it's still good you can apply it you could be at my crib bit tumor no my life what do we see from here Tomas damn that sits is Marat so which to me says tumor which tumor tumor of the blood which is the part of the carbon that you need to be Makarov and you would have a problem not the meat the meat defeats Tommy you don't need it but it's full of good carbon I bring a carbon the meat gets Tom made by mistake right you burn it it's fine nice to meet another car if the sale of the fat gets Tommy I can't bring them as big have to bring another carbon but if the blood becomes Tommy and I can't put it on the altar that I don't have a carbon because that's what makes the Caparo of the carbon that's where the terror says so the hitters would be that the blood even though it's Tommy you could be Matt refer to me why cuz there's a finish of this why do they choose tumor what's the Havanna because to me bite sibour is completely canceled so even by your kit even by your kid is that sits that creates the ability to be at Makarov got it that's tumor okay Michaela but what do we see from here okay should I be a sewer holds that if there's no buzzer at all and no Caleb at all meaning they left the confinements of where they have to be or they lost then he hold that you cannot put the dam on them as mayor that's what he owes that sits won't help but the finish is even according to him if they only become Tom a that sits helps they're still there because they're here that's why we mentioned before the Toma according to his opinion but what do we see from here isn't the Bryce you're talking about Thomas damn cuz that's the salic that needs richer that's the feeling that needs Khepera without that the carbon is gonna be pasal a maryam and boss no say no no this bomb is not Tommy we're talking about the hey l'amanda busser food could become Tommy no but we know you don't need that for the carbon so you don't need it'sit's for that even if there's no seats if the meat becomes tummy you don't eat it but you still a good carbon so you have to say that they were talking about the tomb of Dom and that's where the trailer is talking about tomorrow damn that means liquid is Makabe tumor mean a tighter armor if Papa hello to Muscat sim what's to mask Madsen what blood was for an animal the fistful of flour was for meal offerings right if you brought a meal offering let's say from flour from wheat a minute call it's called the Cayenne hazard there's a vessel filled with flour mixed with oil he takes a fistful of the flour it's called camisa that's like blood so to speak so to speak what do you do with an animal you do with a meal every he puts it on the altar and it burns on the altar that's what what happens if the claimant gets Tommy that's I fell that's not Marsh care that's ISIL so what would you say the carbon is finished so that's that's it's that it's it's allows you to put the climate's on the minica if the rest of the flour gets Tommy okay you don't need it to burn it but there's no Raya that what that oven tomb is damn raft could hold damn is talking I'm a couple termina Toyota that mission deposit is talking about the oven of to Muscat 'some because it's not my carpal tunnel man I tried Dom and that's why your ISA Vinny as I said that even the rabbi said in the base of meters there's no tumor minatoya so the Caparo of the min is tall Louie is depending on the burning of the claimants on the altar just like the cut part of the animal depends on the blood on the altar since its food they're not liquid it's Makka ball Toma and what happens if before you burn it on the altar the climate's becomes Tom a a dead mouse falls into that into the client's hand with the climate's what happens you need it sits that if you burn it on them as mayor the minister's kosher and you can eat the rest of it you could eat that's the finish of the chicken again the command didn't want you to do it but if you did it it's kosher and if you did it but mazes they gave you a class that what that you shouldn't be allowed to eat the rest of the flour does amazing mean you made it tummy be amazed it or you sprinkled it amazing you put it on them is very amazing that is debatable this true shitless of the army right ah so with the blood if you say like you have that damn is not macabre Thomas it never happens never an issue I don't care what happens you can have a coin whose as of you can have a covers air you can have a debt share it's it falls right into the kale here i'ma call you now shafted it you're holding a vessel of blood and a dead Sheppard's falls right into the blood Ralph says nothing happened now they haven't get rid of it and sprinkle it it's pure the kiddush is if you hold that it's amicable to my minute Aida then the DOM is Tommy then you need it since you need it since that if I take this blood and I sprinkle it it's a kosher animal because according to DA via could say for the Komatsu the Gemara of course also could have answered that it's it's works for the carbon we spoke about a beer sure that if all the meat gets Tommy and all the fat gets Tommy right and he holds if that happens the carbon would be pasal even of the Damas culture and that's when you would need that sits but that would be only one opinion the gomera ones that the brightest they should be according to all the opinions and therefore uses Kotzen cuz Komatsu it works come on some works for everybody so therefore rob was salvaged all these prices that tell me about blood being tommy including the last one which is explaining the hummus it's explaining the human shits biblical the other ones you could say i rabbinic but this is biblical like your question it still maintains one last question are off one last question are off touch ma come in here here we come to a fascinating moment in Jewish history and the background is the Jewish people have forty two thousand Jews have ascended from Babylonia in the second Aliyah with Ezra forty two thousand Jews came back from Bovo that's a very small amount they want to rebuild the second base on McNish and what happens is it's not an easy Perisher the reason it's not an easy Perisher is because cyrus first gave them permission and then the permission was retracted and the jews were stuck and then there was a king named diary of age from the persian empire and some say the son of Esther not Irish but that's a debatable issue and there you've aged gives permission to the Jewish people to rebuild a second base on McNish one of the prophets living at that time this is the early bias Shanee period his name is Haggai he's from the last prophets of Israel hey guys sorry Malathi and his prophecy is recorded in a book Haggai which is in TRAI sir in the Tanakh and Haggai in chapter 2 speaks about the history of the time and that it was the second year of the reign of Darius and there you've aged gave the Jews permission to again continue and finish the completion of the second base emitters and get back to life in area to stroll the way it was during the first Commonwealth car guy has a prophecy and in the prophecy he's told to give an exam to the coil to test them to test them about the laws of two Montara to see if they're apt if they're competent if they're capable of starting the avoider so he does a double exam he does a double exam basically it's fascinating it's like mom is a teacher testing his students he does a scenario because that's how you're supposed to give a test not ideas but you know reality and that's what he does here he gives them a scenario and he says you give the verdict most people don't know that in turn a few actually have this he's giving a test he gives a scenario and you give the verdict and this is the test we're now going to learn the gamar is going to quote this and this proof try to disprove ral from this what does Haggai say we now quote the words of Haggai the pasta the Gomera quotes the whole pisaq hog returns to this client M&E says here's the question hey nice arcaders but not bigger somebody is holding on he's carrying sarcoid ash which as we're going to see Rashi says sarkodie doesn't mean sacred meat it actually means defiled meats sarcoid it should mean defiled meat why because the word kurdish means designated separated it could be pure and it could be impure right what's our word for a harlot Lycia kadesha she's not a very holy person but Kadesh could mean two separate things so it's it's designated for impurity yeah so better like you have a passage become Kadesh how your bar is there was impurity in the earth and in Malacca Malafaia ki adalat so sarcoid ish Rashi says here is meat of coitus meat of tumor and the class exam would be a dead sheriff's you have a debt share it's one of the eights rots in its flesh as Tommy and basically he start college but not big day a person in his cloak at the corner of his cloak the rim the edge kunafa is the house is a Knopf big the the corner of his cloak is carrying the meat of a share 'it's vinegar Bertrand FAL Elohim and with this with this cloak with his share its with his share its in his cloak he touches bread okay they'll hang knows it the bread touches a cook dish okay Valhalla the cook dish touches wine Val chemin and the wine touches oil Val call Michael or any other food Hayek gosh does this oil or any other food become Tommy Vienna wakaya in value mu and the Cayenne M said lie okay and now we have to do a quiz were they right or were they wrong so let's go through the scenario okay we have a share it's sarcoid is posture of tumour to share its is a Nava to mer right it's in my cloak it touched bread so the bread becomes a the bread becomes a are we sure the bread touched a cook dish which is now Shanee the cook dish touched wine which is Ashley she right would be Ashley Xie the wine touched oil so what's the oil a ravie wine touch oil became a revi or any other food which became a ravie should this be called Tommy or not the Cayenne M say it's not Tommy they say it's not Tommy the last stage the Revere is not coming ah right so you mean the Becket itself you say there's another level okay so the way Rashi is learning it here is that the the the Naga be kunafa means he touched to share it to the bread in other he touched with the sheriff that's in the Cunniff in the bread that's how he learns in other words you're saying we're not go but cannot for years the beggar touched the bread right so that would mean Kamisha that would mean commission because the beggared would be another one that share its will touch the bed and the beggared right right so rash he learned that the share its itself touched a breath okay that's what he says so they said it's all good they said it's all good but on my Roth and Ralph commented on this story and he said established Connie X they lost they lost the test establish Connie they made a mistake why they make a mistake they said the oil is pure and really the oil is impure that's the end of the statement and the story and RAF's commentary on it what do we see from here what do we see from here what happens in this puss ik what gets Tommy the bread touches a dish of food good the dish of food touches wine wine touches oil the wine is Ashley she the oil is a Revere app said they made a mistake you know why cuz its tummy when douche Lissy and Revere's become Tommy regular wine and oil become clichés and Revere's only which wine and oil kocham true man caption right true man culture so this was obviously wine of kuchen like a wine of trauma or custom and oil of custom for example Monaco's right I have oil I mix it with the flour it's in a Kaley it's holy it's gonna assume be burnt on the altar or was it ready burnt on the altar the leftovers whatever it is this is carbon ice and it becomes Tom made because it touched it touched wine which touched a dish which touched the bread which torched the sheriff's for one second didn't Rav tell me before that Maskin in base summit bhai I'm the liquids in the base our mixer shall not Makka both Toma at all they're not susceptible to Tom the minute and even the rabbis who said that it's Tom a only outside of the base our mixer but not in the base of Mukesh so what is going on here first of all this is a plastic and ID is this biblical to me rabbinic Toma it's in the Tanakh right so it seems biblical Toma that already I knew that oil and liquid in the base I make dishes Tommy wet its tummy minute later its tummy minute later and he tells me liquid is not coming here we see it's coming mama told me even if it would be outside of the base I make there she would say she ravine doesn't work but here solution he does workers to me some English and it's taught me how could what if he does it recline I made a mistake why they make a mistake cause this tummy so maybe you're gonna tell me maybe you want to say you know what I have an idea how guy was the beginning of Bayou Chene e Hager was one of the unshaken SS Angela maybe the tumor smash skin is not minatoya maybe Rob is right biblically nothing but maybe some Xavier is there a bond and most of them happened during by his Shaney but some could have happened in the beginning of Bayou Chene it could have happened at the end of virus Trisha for example to Monsieur died in that we learnt about that if you touch a carbon without washing hands come some slow marmella Moksa comes before two times of governance like so maybe you're ready by then the rabbi's imposed Tamar liquids and that's what hag I was testing them he wasn't testing them on Biblical tumor maybe he was testing them on rabbinic - man they failed maybe that would work the oil and the wine was Tommy only Madeira Barnum let's say that happens let's say it was not a biblical exam it was exams alls I'm right but one second didn't you have say that the i7 yessir said that all the marsh can based on mid-back ayam is pure completely because the rabbi's also didn't impose to them in there based on McNish only outside of the base i'm making it but this is talking about the base of meters how do i know because it wouldn't be the base that mixes the oil wouldn't be tell me they wouldn't have been making a mistake so it's obviously oil from caption but oil from kocham should be tired biblically for sure and even rabbinical ii ralph said that Yost had been years has said that mask of a submits messiah ms-dos on his pure with his duck on me not like small small said doc on means it doesn't transfer rafts edwards.com in itself remains pure he's mamas undermining himself his mom is contradicting himself now you're going to tell me that watch maybe the posix says it's coming me there are bond on your right and yes have been yeah yes it wouldn't work cuz yesterday as it says there's no Toomas much gonna be some weakness week spread before the de prices are not according to your soup in yasser the previous bryce is that the dom becomes tummy so this is also not a quality i submit yes but you can't say that you know why couldn't i seven years or argue with a pasta canal guy he can argue with another tanner he can argue with another he can't argue with a pasta can hog i he doesn't have that authority the pasta can't a guy says oil is topic and yes to me as it says no it's not zazen rabbinic but you have quoted yosemite I said that the marsh can based on with Poseidon is completely tired so say oh this is a plastic it's not yo seven years you can't contradict the pasta doesn't have that authority so however you want to learn it we're stuck if you want to learn that it's a commentary ricer it's a serious challenge you're telling me that I said there's no two men Mashka if you want to say it's only when there are born on and by far guy they already made it you're still stuck because Ralph quoted and said that in debates I McNish they didn't make the kaziri and you can't tell me a seven years has a different and it doesn't work with this Bostick he can't argue with a posit there's a cyst Walker no time in the world can look at a person can say I have a different opinion doesn't work that way you can explain a plastic differently but in the history of Judaism it doesn't work that way the Navy made it a Comanche necessarily made it that corner and by a solution you're obliged by it the isoprene yes it doesn't have the authority to say I'm not making it a cone of Thomas Masjid he can't do that he doesn't have that authority I'm not complaining it's cold it's it's it's an it's neva fine but he still doesn't have the authority to argue with the gazelle yeah just let's finish the answer well I'll get a girl answer says the Gemara midday who time ll arrive you're asking a question our Rob Roth bait basket basement bhasayate Ani Roth was talking about the liquids in the base of it but I am the liquids we're in the butchering section of the base oh my gosh the blonde and the water where they would rinse the offerings Mashka babies behind me Tommy but the liquids of them is Bayer the wine of libations and the oil of Morocco is that go on the MS BAE are they become Tom a and they can transfer to madeira bond on in other words there's no issue there's two separate issues here Rav spoke about masks abasement bhai we're talking about masks a baby the bajalia basement bhai is the butchering section of the base--emitter dish over here they rinsed the car bonus with blood and it was water here I've said there's no tournament biblically and the rabbi's didn't imposed him a why they wanted to protect the car bonus this is where all the meat was being prepared this is where they were skinned and prepared and rinsed but the liquids that went on them is baya that was a different category it was very focused it was much less it went on them as bad the oil that they poured on libations the oil that was mixed in monoculars this they never dismissed from Toma and therefore here there's a dinner of Tommy madeira bond on and by we understand that this can only work with the Rabanne own because if liquid would have been minute IRA if the impurity of liquids with women Authority can't make all these distinctions between MS and based on it but I would all be Tommy but I've come can't take away a term in our theater like we learned they can't cancel it but obviously this is all me they're born on so there's no contradiction I was asking the Cayenne them if they know about to Madeira Bona the rabbi's already imposed a tomb of liquid in their days which included wine and included oil of carbon as that went under miss Bayer Yosef Phineas is talking about something else magical basement behind there the rabbi's didn't post him and therefore RAV is salvaged and with this de cámara finished challenging the ROVs explanation of the testimony ELISA beignets ER and his position can be maintained with intellectual integrity without any problem be occupy Masari ok different places this is based on mid-back ayam this is the MS BAE accustomed and we can understand the logic of it the rabbi's didn't want to just eliminate Toma they wanted in a place where there was so many koi in him there was so much action there was so much blood and so much water you have a whole different thing that section do you know how much blood there was did you not much water that was there if that master would become Tommy even with her a button you would end up in a very drastic situations where country would be ruined here you had a cup of wine that the Cayenne poured on them as Barack was called Nyssa hi and every day and you had oil that was mixed with a miniature minute it took oil he mixed it with a minute and he offered it on the altar and then they baked it it was very controlled it was tight and therefore we're not so worried if it becomes Tommy it becomes Tommy if the oil becomes Tommy becomes tell me fine you do what you have to do well he says yayan and chemin yah in and chemin didn't apply to a regular yeah Wiz oil and a regular carbon Dominica has oil and wine comes with mr. kyon that that's not based on MIT's bhai him he spoke and keeps him speaking about Mashka basement bar higher base hamid bhai m is called the butchering section like Pettyfer is called sour haha Balkan taboc is a butcher basement bhai we're talking about mid Berkshire mid the bahá'ís Ms Barch in Aramaic this myth Bahia and mid Bahia and mid-back Iowa that s is Taba as a butcher butchering section with the meat was prepared mid Bahia is the actual altar where everything was offered with a fire was burning with the wine was poured with the water was poured on suckers with the meal offerings were offered with the cabanas warford etc so that could become coming Madeira burnin according to rob and yo Ibanez er of course according to many others biblically and therefore car guys talking about a biblical Toma but according to Rob's interpretation of your opinion it has to be only rabbinic Toma which would mean that Tomas mash creamy their abundant comes from an early stage in Jewish history not from a later stage in Jewish history come on Madeira bounine cragger was testing about a tumor Mindi rabona on them is bear on the oil the oil that cuts the wine would touch the dish would touch the bread which touched the sheriff's which was there for Ravi share it's I've left him reshoring right dishes Shanee and yaw in his Lisi and chemin is reveal or another food or another Michael that's detached water you it Kate oh no Nyssa come I'm actually not it came from a well oh but now it's in a kailia oh now it's in a Caylee of course yeah yeah yeah according to Roth biblically it's never McCobb altima nothing no ma him no Dom nothing and certainly can't transfer it doesn't become Tommy the hey this is that the rabbi's imposed Toma yes yes according to this interpretation we have to say that this term of marsh Madeira Bonin comes from an early stage in history not later right because a lot of Thomas come from later Ultima say then now you can have a peaceful day I hope it's nice cooler combination if it's whatever this mask will be a recent Madeira bomb on your right no only the market the touches are shady becomes addition only the market touches are shaming yes Lucy Divina so the yayan touched the nose it's already not yeah the left him was edition the nose it was a shaming are you're saying interesting you're saying when the Naza touch the eye in the ancient become a vicious so why is it call the reveal it's not right but the thing is that the triggers that mash can becomes a Russian that's much later that sailor was much later yeah that happened on the roof the Gomora says in massacres Shabbos and the first period that happens on the roof close to the end of Bayou Chene e times abyss Hillel and Shammai so you have to go hundreds of years later for that tumor hundreds is there that's why it's not equated here that's why it's not born to the equation a good question he's asking why is the mass cannot reach time the yayan becomes Irishman because it touched a nothing left him was a recent and as it was a shame does it touch the end the ancient jump to reach and it's a marker because here we're talking chaga yeah all dura Bannen that's not a question that nobody argues right right because it so there are born and this other are born on this is an early dear Obama that was just for smart guys so he tested the Chi in them and they failed the core into ROM they failed he himself Ezra Ezra why he's the one who was did the testing this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate