Pesachim 102a: When You Change Your Location In middle of the Meal #1

the yeshiva dotnet we are holding Duff kouf Bayes Ahmad Aleph knowing as the sugi of shinwa mahkum sheena maka means changing your location and middle of your meal changing your place and the ramifications of that in halakhah in terms of the breakfast that you have to or you don't have to make when you change your location it began with the statement of ravage small who taught us that when they make addition so Friday night and then you come home small held you have to make kiddush again because he didn't eat ensure Rav held you don't have to make kiddush again because he doesn't hold you have to make condition in the place of the meal the lockers like small according to most posts come that kiddush is but Marco him Sudha but both of them agree that you have to make a new boy a pre hug often that the fact that you made hug often ensure doesn't exempt you from making a new hug often on your wine if you're going to drink in announce another even rather says enough to make kiddush again he says when you sit down at home to eat and you want to drink wine you have to make a barrier pre often even though you made one and true and you drink but you left the shoal you went to your house and now you drink wine you have to make a new barrier Priya guff and of course according to Schmoyer you have to make new kids too of course you have to make a guff into your beer - and disagreed your relation and said that actually Shinri mahkum doesn't require a new broth even though you change from one house to another house as long as you know made a broker in one place you could continue eating the Gemara refuted european and from a bryson that says clearly that new wine if you bring out new wine to the table a different type of wine you don't have to make a new blessing the first time girlfriend goes on all the wines that you're going to drink in the middle over the meal and i should add a parenthesis that when you make a guffin in the beginning of a meal even if you didn't wash it also includes all beverages right sometimes people don't realize if you're sinning let's say at a and a SIM card anytime and their dinner and and somebody gives you a cup of wine and you make hug often on the wine and then they bring out water people make a Chacal on the water that's a Huckle is superfluous you're not supposed to make a shotgun just like when you wash for bread and you may come mighty on bread everything in the meal is included in I might see on the bread because it's all an accessory of the bread so when you eat salad the middle of a meal you don't make hard um on the salad or you eat chicken you don't make a choc alone the chicken because you already washed for bread the same is true what how might see is for food how geffen is for drinks just like bread is the staple food wine is the staple beverage and therefore all of the beverages are included in the bracha of wine but yeah on the wine how geffen yeah if you drank the one although the water no they're not I'm talking I'm talking about then of course you know I'm talking let's say a person didn't wash no a person didn't wash just a regular they're having a drink of wine so the hagafen is you might see yeah sometimes at Shabbos had a kiddush after davenic a person makes kiddush right drinks wine and then drinks a cup of seltzer right you don't make a Brooke on that cup of salsa because they ready made a brach on the wine so the Bryce is said if you change the type of wine you know have to make a new Brock but Shinra Malcolm if you change your place you do have to make a new broker and that refutes the view of regulation and well that even when you go from Seoul to your house you don't have to make a new by day a new by the Priya guff then the gomorrah quoted rabbuna the prisoner who said in the name of rabona and the gomorrah broader support from a price of ravinok or the son of ravinok who said that when do you have to make a new brother it's only from a house to a house but from a place to a place within a house you don't have to make a new bra or as many of the rishonim have a different gear synthase gamar we see it clearly from their texts not from a place to a place in the house but from one corner to another corner that only when you're going from our house to a house or within the house from one place to another place but in one room from one corner to another corner you don't have to make a new brother even though you changed the location these two gear system the texts are very fundamental the difference is very fundamental did he say from place to place meaning from room room or from upstairs to downstairs you don't have to make a brush or from corner to corner in one room obviously it's very very different halacha but these are two versions in the text most restrained in my gaiter is only from corner to corner you don't have to make a bracket but from place to place in the house you would have to make a new bracha which would be similarly to what we said before by kiddush but Markham Sudha that Shmuel used to learn on the roof and when he wanted to make kids she would come downstairs and make kid that's in the place of the meal he didn't make kids upstairs and then came down for the meal because then he would have to make a second condition even though it was one house but going from one floor to another floor is not considered the same place so if I made kiddush upstairs and I have the meal downstairs it's not good even if I make addition one room and then I go to another room some people have a foyer and they make kid that's there and then they go to another room and they eat the meal it's not good unless unless there are those postgame who are martyred that if in the place where you eating you could see the room where you made kiddush even through a window and even if you can only see part of the room right so there are those views that allow you to do the meal and not make kiddush again however if you're coming from upstairs to downstairs you certainly can't see upstairs from downstairs so therefore you would have to make a new kiddush in the place of the meal certainly if you're going from one house to another house like from your show to your house you have to make a new kiddush but here we're not talking about kidney shape we're talking about Broca's throughout the whole week so that's the price of the rabona that appear that's the brilliant that I did of his the call in the name of rabona that from a corner to a corner or from my high place to a place again the two versions of the text you don't have to make a new bra then repairs the came and introduced his own halacha and his Urlacher really puts a whole new twist in this whole stool yeah we're a priest that comes and teaches us and this is like a quite a loaded statement that the whole Halak of Shinri mahkum the whole idea that you have to make a new bracha when you come to a new place when you change locations and you come to a new location you have to make a new browser because you left the first location as Oh if you ate something that doesn't require an after brother in the place where you ate it but if it's something that requires a bra Cochran in the place where you ate it then we say even if you take the food and you go to a new place you don't have to make a new blessing even if you went to another house even if you eating a one house and you left this house and you go to another house not only next door even far away and you continue the meal there either you bring the food you bring this food there you continue the meal you don't have to make a new blessing says rip isn't even though you changed the place certainly in one house not but the whole walk of shame welcome he says doesn't apply here because we know that there are things that you eat then you have to make an after brush in the place that you ate it there are things that you eat and you don't have to make an after Brock on the place that you eat it for example bread you have to do benching in the place where you eat the bread shikaku we're in a fortress you don't have to do a blessing in a place where you eat it so the business says if you ate something that requires you to make a bracha afterwards in the same place so even though you left and middle to another place you enough to make a new Brucker why cuz what's the logic that you have to make a new brother when you go from one house to another house the logic is that when you stood up this meal was interrupted now you go to a new place it's considered a new meal since it's considered a new meal you have to make a new bracha because the old suit is stopped and the bracha was on that meal and out a new meal you have to make a new bracha even though you're continuing to eat the same food that's the Savera that you have to make a new Brock says rip his the this is only true if you stood up and you stopped eating something that doesn't require and after Brock in the same place because then when you left you interrupted this meal and if you continue eating in a new place it's considered a new endeavor but if it's something that requires an after bra in this very place so even when you leave you still have to come back so you're only left temporarily because how logically you have to go back because you have to make and after brush in the place that you ate it and even if you're gonna continue eating in this place in this new place it's continued you have to because you want to make a bracha here you have to continue eating here in order to make abraca also for the first food another do you have a choice either you can go back and make a bracha over there because you have to eat make a brach in a place to you ate or you could continue eating in this new place and then you can make a brach arena on the new food and on the old food but one thing is sure the first meal was not interrupted because even if you left you still have to go back to that place because you have to make a broker and even if you're not gonna go back you're gonna continue eating here and make a broth Cochran air when you continue eating here what is it you're continuing to eat here so that you should be able to make a Brocken here also on that food so it's a continuation to the original meal ah the key vakama harder even way you look at it I think you got to go back you can't stay here you didn't make a broker correctly yet if you made a broker crying on the first food of course you have to make a new blessing on the new food but since you didn't make a broker crying on the old food and you left you got to go back how logically you can't stay here at some point you're gonna have to come back oh you went to speak to somebody in another house or you went to Schulter davon minica or I don't know whatever it is you went to a neighbor even a far neighbor not next door you coming back you gotta go bench since you got to go bench so you never really interrupted it was a temporary thing cuz you have to come back if you don't have to make a brush afterwards in the same place that you don't have to come back you left you left even if you come back it's considered a new thing it's not considered a hamster it's not a continuation if you don't want to go back and you're gonna continue eating in the second place right you're gonna continue eating in the second place it's not considered a new thing you know why because if you want to make a brach in the new place it's only if you continue eating here so you can make a broker afterwards in this place and that's the only way you could make a broker here for the original foodtube because if not you have to go back there the only way I can make a Brockett here is if I continue eating here then I can make a broccoli here so that means when I continue eating it's not a new endeavor it's a continuation of the old meal because this is what's gonna allow me to make a broker for the old food too so it's always a continuation because it's considered a continuation represen such cases you don't have to make a new broker fascinating how long the question is what is considered food that needs abraca corona in its aftermath in that place and this is very relevant and on this distri opinions in the rishonim from very very elaborate to very narrow the Rajas opinion is very narrow only bread only bread this is only breath how might see classic breath when you're eating a meal with bread and you leave your house and you go somewhere else and you continue eating the you're off to make a new Braga but if you're eating cake you'll have to make a new bracha when you leave or if you're drinking why you have to make a new broker or if you're eating figs you have to make a new broker everything besides I might see is like burner fascist in terms of not requiring a bra Cochran in its place that's the view of the Raja and if you eat the bread in the new place you could bench they're not two got to go back you got to go back now it is true again in parentheses it's not so much together this it is true that when something requires a bra Cochran in its place look up till you're not supposed to leave till you make a Bruck you're not supposed to say I'm gonna go and then I'll come back look a pillar you're supposed to stay and make up unless when you made the brach are made so you had in mind that you're gonna continue the meal elsewhere then it's fine then you could hop Hill ago you're going to eat somewhere else and you had in mind but just to go away and say I'm gonna come back look how killer you should not do that because just like this is a type of food shelter non-arab explains us and KO phayam cast which is the sim and dedicated in this sugan Eric I'm Co fine essentials an RF just like there are foods that require a bracha corona to be made in that place and that's the prominence of the food and the bracha part of that car services that you shouldn't leave without making the Brucker just like you're supposed to be here you also shouldn't just leave even though you're gonna come back but if you had in mind when you made the brush on that might see for example I go to a semca right and I wash but I want to eat lunch at home do I have to wash again do I have to make a new I might see I don't have to make oh no I might see according to the prisoner right cuz even though I changed places since it's huh might see I'm good but what I have to do is I have to have in mind when I'm making I might see lesson that I want to continue the meal of the bread in my house in my house just to leave and come back even though you're gonna come back the common did not want a person to do that yeah even if a person says I'm gonna continue eating there I'm gonna continue eating that they should look at Hillier they should not leave this place unless they had in mind but if a person left the place and continues eating there they could bench there that's fine so that's one extreme that it's only bread then you have the other extreme which is Rashi and they rush bomb it's everything including wine and Shiva Sam in him which means even Mozilla's even figs even gray even pomegranates the only exception would be her eight sees her Dahmer's and shaco's that are not don't get a llama Thea our Jeff annihilates anything that goes into the broker I'm a meteorology phenolate which would mean wine and any one of the species with which area straw was praised figs grapes pomegranates dates olives oil shemin's a Shemin and of course cake rugelach of course I am might see anything that gets what's called a bra command Charlotte needs a bra Cochran aware you ate it and therefore if you leave you have to make a new bra so if I'm eating dates I'm having grapes and then I go to your house I don't have to make a new ha eighths on the grapes in your house but if I'm from drinking a coffee from drinking a coffee or a meeting a candy I'm eating potato chips or I'm eating an apple and then I go to the other stuff to make a new Brock on that so the rajma says only bread and nah she and her mom say everything even one and then you have the intermediary interpretation which is the view of Taurus here and that is bread yes miss anus yes but that's it only grain only the five grains but when it comes to the other fruits even though you make our Geffen our eights or I'll get from like wine over there we don't say this cloth that becomes like Chacal and it's and the truth is no and so Honora all three opinions are brought all three opinions are brought and the outer have been chosen our aha Rev gives the verdict and says from the Morgan of Rahm and he says Licata killer you should make a broth right now on all these foods in other words if you drink wine you have to make a broker know where you are if you eat grapes or fixing make a brothel car know where you are but if you left you should have make a new broker because suffering Broca's local since it's three different views and there's three perspectives so therefore like a pillow you should treat each one with the stringency of not leaving without a broker ah no bread there's no argument bread there's no argument I'm bread everyone holds that's a classic case we have to make a broker Crenna in its place and therefore if you leave you don't have to make a new broker when you come to the new house if you left if a person left what's called Bechet gig they didn't they didn't realize their yeah that they didn't better just forgot if they did it willingly so then they should go back they did it but striker there's actually two opinions one opinion is they should still go back and do the bracha if they can and one is that since they left but show you they don't have to so it's actually two opinions inna llaha both of Arbroath abroad and so tomorrow whether the person should go back another look uphill I should not leave the place where I ate if it's a type of thing that I have to make a broken and unless the exception is if I again I had in mind by how might see that I want to eat elsewhere then it's fine but if I didn't have in mind and I just leave even if I have in mind to come back it's not appropriate to do and there was a reason for it they were afraid the person may forget to come back and and and that would be wrong because they have to bench over there a and B they may even stay there for a long time to the point with the digest of food and they won't even be able to make a brach afterwards yeah even if I'm going on monastic eat there so it's good I still shouldn't leave unless I had in mind initially because part of the Kashi verse of this food is that I have to make a broker before I leave you know they're just like you have to make a broker were you ate you also have to make a broker before you leave the place again unless like a pill I had in mind cuz if I until I had in mind then this is not the place this is the place and that's also the place because that was my setting my mindset when I sat down to eat yeah if you ate cake according to the Raj but you don't have to make a brush our owner will you ate so therefore if you leave it's considered an interruption of your meal so now when I go to your house I make a new brush because it's got a new meal because it's not a continuation of the old one because the old one is gone because I don't have to come back there to make the brush right now I can play any home he's cake here he has to make a new brother okay nice cool bench yeah of course when I finish eating the new cake I'm gonna make a bra Cochran on both cakes of course I have to make a brother no you said cake did he been he didn't bench so I ain't a sinner and I went to another place which was wrong okay but I did it I went to a new place and I continued eating cake I don't have to make Amazonas on the cake because it's part of the first meal that's the point Oh Fionna intention and you'll do it then then you're not then you could if you had in mind when you made I might see you gonna continue the meal elsewhere it's no problem you could go suka hopping to 100 circus if you want then the caterpillar they should bench where they are they don't have to wash unless they didn't protect their hands if there was no hassle chaos if you didn't take your mind off mind off your hands and they're still cleaning off to wash again unless you went to the bathroom in between the question is you have to make another how might see we say it off to make another I might see that's the kiddush of replicas de are you changed your place it's a new meal so it's not a new meal it's a new place it's not a new meal we're if I was eating if I was drinking the coffee and I went to a new house and not only a new house I take the coffee and I go upstairs I finish this year I go upstairs yeah and I sit down there and I want to continue drinking the coffee right I have to make a Lucia Jaco the difference is and this is very important between a house to a house and two places in one house if you're going from house to house even if I had in mind when I sat down to drink the coffee had in mind that I want to continue it in another house since it's something that doesn't need a brush ocarina afterwards so it's considered a half sick it's considered an interruption and it's a new drinking my dad doesn't help from house to house same thing but if it's in one house fritz one houses we learned earlier with Kadesh Menachem stood the if it's in one house and you had kiddush and you your mind you decided you're gonna continue with elsewhere then you're also good you don't have to make a new Bravo ah if you could see the place then it's not then you don't have an issue if you could if it's one room or it's another room but you could see it so it's like one room then you have no issue I could go from here to another corner of them even if I don't see for example this room there's a corner I can't see but it's one room it's under one roof and the same it hits us so I don't have to make a new broker in one room we don't have to ever make a new broker even if the room is huge let's say it's a casa no hole in the middle there's there's a huge I don't know a beam or a platform you can't see the other side but if it's one room it's considered one place it's not called scenery mahkum and even if he didn't have but Dahlia I didn't think I'm gonna continue drinking or eating over there but the hill is sure that when you're dealing with bread right or cake or figs or grapes that even if you go to another house you have to make a new broker why because it requires abraca Corona in its place that's the that's the point when you're eating Chicago you could go somewhere if I'm free drink a bottle of water I don't have to make a burden to foster I have to make a burden of purchase but I could do it in my car wouldn't that be why I don't have to do I never have to come back when I left here it's for good that's the point no but this food is finished this drinking session is over you know one say you're thinking it was you it's not over because you can make it look like wine in there so it's not over when when you leave the place you have to make it here that's when it's over so will be just the opposite slower right then you still have to make another one you're not tied to this place you left you broke it how do you know you're broke it because you make chemical end of it that means you broke it however if you can make a rough winter there that's what you didn't break it not ideas as it's follow so will the quest jeana's ii drinking in the new place is it considered a continuation of the first or is it a new endeavor no it's a continuation how do you know you make a book afraid of it so it's the continuation you rely to make go in there that means it's a continuation no no I'm allowed to make abraca corona there because it's a type of food that is not so connected to place in other words that have come him say when you eat an apple you don't have to make a burden of forces will you ate it you can eat you can make a burden a fortress elsewhere right because it's tough why can't you say no either way if it's otherwise how do you lie to make no no you won't have to make to Brokaw Cronus if I take the Apple to my car or elsewhere and I continue eating it I can make a burn one burner fortunes for both I just have to make a new broker but I drove to make a new after bracha unless I first died unless of course I made a no the reason you can make a brach occur in the second place is because you don't need the place on the contrary the reason you don't have to make a bracha kroner in its place you can make a broker crane in other places because you don't need to make it in its place we don't care if the brush is done in another place but it's another place it's always another place but but it since you could make it there that means how do you make how could you how could you logic would make about for in another place you're gonna meet there because it continues the bracha kroner elsewhere is going on the food that I ate in another place grant it granted so you know if they make another book it's more so you should make another so this far now is you shouldn't have to make another one the bracha corona is going on the first food but now you want me to make a new brush on something new that I'm eating it's something new that's it that's the point it's something new the brush our own is gonna go on the first thing you're right but now I'm eating something new is this a continuation from before this one and that one hey Pierre the making here broke laughs Elena how could I do this ever my why because it's going on a fishing place so I'm saying it's just the opposite I think you're mixing up to shepard and youngnam Darrell in one place and you go to second place and drinking coca-cola what do you say what you're drinking ginger ale in one place let me let me clarify this okay I'm gonna bring up another thing and I think it will become clear a big question becomes will go back to your question a moment a big question becomes and it's a very practical question what happens a person takes a jog there's people around here take jogs with a bottle of water right with a bottle of water so you make a shikaku you drink and you put it in your pocket or you hold it in your hand whatever it is and you start running and every five minutes ten minutes the Redeem it's 40 minutes yeah as you're running your marathon you take out your bottle and you drink nope so there's a lot of in here and it's not like the second place I could see the first place I mean the first at some point you could still see it but then at some point you're going very far you're not gonna see the first place where you made the bracha what would be the hello here what would be the hell off there and it's not only a question on water ah question yeah so the so the mission of brewery and Semenko fan fests he doesn't say about jogging but the Shannara speaks about how a drokken people who walk and the capella they're eating on the way they're looking eating on the way there a person is hiking or a person is on a long journey and they can't stop so he speaks even about bread what capital are you supposed to eat bread in a place and then bench there but what happens if you're walking so then the halacha says since when you made I might see your qivana was to eat the bread while you're going so then the Morecombe of the bread is not this muck and the mulling of the bread is as long as you're gonna be walking with the bread that's like a little market just like when I make my tea and I think I'm gonna start the meal here and I'm gonna continue with there so the mark home of this meal is not only ear it's there too so that's why you could continue eating there so tell the Chancellor that sometimes the maken could be right miles from here till there and you could continue eating it the whole way and you'll bench over there at the end why you have to go back for the beginning because as long as you eating it the whole way this was your Covenant this becomes the Makkah so mr. Brewer adds a very fascinating thing that in such a case and that's talking about bread what if you're dealing with something that doesn't need a bracha laughter doesn't it abraca karina afterwards right if it needs a Brock Ukraina afterwards we say that as long as you continue eating it's all a hampshire from the first meal but if it doesn't need like water for example so he time is as follows that when you make a brother of China and you're qivana like a pillar is you don't want to drink it in this place you're gonna jog and you're gonna drink it through out then you don't have to make a new broker why don't you have to make a new broker because the whole idea is what she knew maken you changed the place but here what was the place the place wasn't here I'm a jogger I'm starting here because I didn't start yet but I'm gonna drink in five minutes and ten minutes a mile two miles three miles for miles so tall the same place it's not considered shiney marketplaces address ah the track is the place the track is the place yeah unless I sit down to have the water here and then the middle I decided I want to go jogging right or I sit this I sit in my yard to have the one that's a you know what let's take a jog then already then already as long as I could see the first place I don't have to make a do bracha right but when I go far away then I have to make a new brother because like a pillar which I thought based on this it bothered me people take a coffee here in that room or upstairs they make a shikaku right when they take the coffee because they want to drink coffee then they come into the shear right and they don't make a second shackle okay based on what we're learning La Jolla do you need a new bracha right ah so if when you made the bracha shackle you had in mind to go to another room and it's in one house then it's good but very often a person doesn't have that in mind they just make a Scirocco and then they come right people go upstairs already have to make a new Scirocco even worse is you go out of this building and you go into the tent you're getting ready for showers and now it's not even the same house not it's a now it's a house to warehouse we even does doesn't help so look lady have to make a new Scirocco yeah and this mama she have to make new stuff in the house itself from a room to a room there are posts key and the mission of Breuer finds a hectare that in the same house he says the fact that the world doesn't do this is because he finds that there's room to be mightier in one house just like from corner to corner even without das but certainly with das but you go from the house outside to the car people go with with the car my bias lab is and even if you had that it doesn't help but the truth is that there's something important that you have to realize and that is when people make a coffee here and they're going to their car right what's their das we did what do they want to drink the coffee they want to drink the coffee near the machine and then they decide no I want to take it to my car look uphill when you're making the coffee you know that what you're a jogger you're starting here you're going to your car then you're gonna meet somebody who has a good cigarette and then there's breakfast and then somebody's making a bris in other words that was just a humor look at Hillel when you take the coffee it's not to drink in that room right you want as maybe started in that room but it's not that's not will you establish yourself to drink if you establish yourself to drink there then it's a problem if you go outside you have to make a new bracha because it's not the misogynist it's not figs it's not grapes it's not pomegranates it's water it's coffee but if you didn't establish yourself and the whole onion the Kapila is you want to walk around so then it's like jogging it's like hulky drop him and then you don't have to make a new brother you don't mean barked up a practical example is if I'm sitting here with a coffee I didn't have qivana to walk around within and go from here to this year I'm sitting here it's a certain koreas and now I go upstairs and I continue drinking I would have to make a new broker sure how cool cuz it doesn't need a broker abraca Corona beam claim I what do we see from here unless I had that's when I made sure Huckle that I want to go and drink it but if I'm going outside das is also not gonna help laughs tough not by me maybe by you because you don't show up often but if you would show up often and you would have acquiesced then it wouldn't be oh why am i bringing this up not only because it's very practical but also because it's negated to the Union in other words if the mahkum lockup hill is not a mock line if the malcolmus uphill is 20 miles that's fine but if the mahkum is a mahkum if i sat down you write if I take a bag of potato chips right from the machine and I don't want to sit and eat it I just wanted I start here I start there I start there then you could tie in a very much based on this mission of brewery that you're like hosi drop him and let's hop healer the mahkum is not the mahkum you didn't want to eat potato chips here you wanted to eat it here you want to need it in the tent and you want to eat it any car and you want the needed in your house and you wanted to finish it off and evergreen in other words that you're you're in a mobile state which by the way the Casal weren't so familiar with this because they didn't live that way you understand that they didn't bar they didn't have vending machines with potato chips and you start walking around it didn't exist so they have a case of whole head Rock'em yeah people are walking that's why it's brought a contralto nara but this concept but I thought in jogging it's a very practical thing because people drink water and I was wondering people don't make new broca's because you have to make a brother 40 times huh biking yeah biking yet yeah I buy it he buys it in Starbucks he's leaving he's paying money so when he makes her Hackl in Starbucks what's his qivana is a very serious issue here sober mela the fact that I could make a Braja corona elsewhere is simply a leniency that even in a different place they let you catch up on your bra Corona it's a leniency but it's a numark crime and since it's a new Malcolm it's considered a new soda it's considered a new soda and since it's considered a new soda it's not a hamstring of the previous so them because it's not a hampshire's of the previous order so the original broker can't apply on this food the broker crane it is a leniency that in another place you could make a brackish Reiner it's a leniency that even though you're in a different place in a different location and your meal ended and your meal ended you could still make a broker Irena they're in a new place even though it's disconnected but to say that the food in the new place should get the Brock of the original place the broker owner doesn't have to have the original meal the broker is a new thing that they let me do in another place but now you want that the original broker should connect to this new meal in a different house on something that doesn't require a block my my this is where the prisoner holds it's not true and then the Gemara says that depreciations argues reputation says absolutely no difference I don't care what type of bra Cochran it is even if you're eating bread and you go out to another person's house or you go upstairs and you have to make an omelet see no difference betrayus argues with a prisoner there's absolutely no difference why because the fact that you have to come back to make abraca Kriner doesn't have bearing on the fact that there's a new suitor here you left physically Shinri mahkum is a physical fact you're in a new place and therefore it's an interruption you have to make a new broker that's the smarter of recessions where a business says it's also a new place but since legally legally you have to go back or you have to continue eating here in order to make a bracha for there so it's all one thing even though physically it's a new place where appreciation islook sat the physical geography and says you left you're in a new place it's a new experience even though huh logically you're connected but physically you're not connected and therefore obnoxious says that you have to make a new brush even if it requires a bra cocorinha a bra Cochran mm quite well when you're sitting in a car you're in one place it's like you're in a boat or in a wagon yeah because if not you're gonna have to make a brook every single second at every single five seconds on the car right again the Khazar weren't used to this not only could they didn't have cars because the concept of eating was more associated with a mahkum today it's the McDonald's era you know what I mean it's called fast-food we live in an era fast food fast fast fast fast so the these concept of comfort but a car is considered one place if not you're gonna be a serious problem whoops burn the for coffee why not okay you have to drink three or four ounces right within the shear if it's very well you have to know how you drink it usually by the time the coffee gets to the end the cup gets the lower part it's not so hot and very often the last three or four ounces you drink pretty miss missus you have to make a better version so if you talk of sipping along and you don't do a sheer Revere's right knowing that shear then tuck and so you have to push it now you have to be in Hawaii have to be conscientious of what goes into your mouth and also what goes out of your mouth what goes into your mouth and what goes out of your mouth you have to be conscientious it's called das he mein das of dough lemon iron another important to order has to do with going to the bathroom what's a locker would go into the bathroom right for example according to our appreciation you're having a Shabbos meal and then you go out to the bathroom do you have to make a new bra or a poor man comes to the door or mashallah comes and wants money so if you stay in the room it's not a problem because it's it's one room but if you go outside right and you speak to him and you give him a dollar then you come back in you have to make a new I might see right or forget let's say you're having dinner you're eating steak you're eating a piece of chicken yeah somebody comes to the door you go outside or you go to the bathroom it's something that doesn't have a bra cocorinha in its place so the further you come back you have to make a new broker but here we don't say that ah right because this is this is this is a completely different idea on our car I'll bring this now the lavash brings this out in other words here it's people have to go to the bathroom it's part of the plan in other words it's not considered a half sick of Shinri mahkum if I go out and I have a long conversation with somebody or I go to shul for example right then I come back to my dinner or I go to have a long smooth with somebody outside again outside the house or these types of things which a serious half sick then I would have to come back and make a new bracha according to the precious I might see and according to the prisoner schakal let's say on my chicken but if I went to go to the bathroom and I come back enough to make Anwar might see you have to wash your hands if you go to the bathroom right but you don't have to make a new one right so you don't have to make a new Scirocco oh you had a short conversation with somebody because this is not considered I have sickos it's like uphill a very temporary thing right just you know for a second I I took a telephone call in another room and then I come back yeah but if I go out to another room for example to have a business meeting or serious come and then I come back it's considered after the same as true people snooze off the middle of the meal Sheena's RI do you have to make anubrata you're physically there but you sleeping so again if it's Asha noskov are if you take a if you go to sleep on the couch some people go to sleep on the couch and then you come back you have to make a new bracha but if it's ashiness ira meaning a temporary short sleep it's not considered absolute because it's part of the it's part of the fabric it's not these these types of things are not called to most boys come it's not called it's not called I have know if you're in one place it's not a problem you can have conversations as long a few in one place then there's no question I even miss a digestion that's a whole different engine they have to make a broker right now before you before eco before they share digestion yeah that's true that's true but Mitsubishi know a mahkum it's not an issue but I'd have SiC the same places never initially you can have a conversation with somebody for six hours that's not the issue okay so this is the two shooters of reputation and the prisoner in this sugar in this yeah I should just clarify one thing and that is one of the reasons that tourists are used with their ash bomb there are some holes that even wine needs a brush ocarina in its place and if we know if to make a new brush and toasters argue says it's only cake or bread only not why one of his rias's because there is dis arguing with rapacious and if the rash bomb was right but it would also be arguing you said this last time with ravaged nor cuz r average small said that ensure you drink wine you have to make a new blade of prion Guffin in the house but through yayan is something that needs a broker friend of him como so if the rash bomb was right you don't have to make a new brush on wine the fact that reverence will save to make a new Brooklyn wine and it is this arguing with relations not with Ravin Shmuel is twice versus proof that wine is something that doesn't need a bra Cochran in its place only cake and bread and that's why if you would drink wine he holds that you would have to make a new broker in the new place and that is the wouldn't argue with that because we see the princess knocking with reverence for with appreciation so going to the ashram you have the syllabus is arguing with rapacious and with wrath and we're small because they hold that wine is something that you have to make a new bow - Priya - and according to the Raj mom wine you don't have to because it's something that doesn't need a bracha Corona abraca Corona BIM BIM climber another interesting aura this is marshmallow generic arrived if you sit down to drink let's say coffee and there's a certain curious and then you go to the bathroom outside you come back it's not considered a half sick why is it not considered a half sick even though I don't need a brother crying of him claim I because it was I didn't go out to be MOFs it I went out push it because I had to and I want to come back and I'm like I go to shul - Davin or I go to have a long conversation with you it was or somebody just called Misa and I came back but he says if it's the cocktail or something that the whole thing is temporary you didn't sit down for example a person takes a bottle of water yeah and they want to stay in one place they're not moving if they're moving around we said look uphill it's not an Indian but he said if there's no curious and then you go out even for a temporary reason it could be that it's a cure the first one because our I can't be okay acaba but for that you need a cover if it's a killer are I could be a strong father he said tanners that you have to make that's the much Mo's there so now what are we left with well after this huge mark locals between a pleased enter precious and the Gomorra wants to disprove rip wisdom doesn't want to it just has a problem with the priest and the problem is that we have a clear price and the Brice's says that if there was a kabura that was drinking and there was a casa Nanak Allah and they left to the cousin of the caller we said that the only way they don't have to make a Baraka when they come back is if they left somebody there if they left somebody there right and that's a very important you soy than Allah that besides everything we spoke about there's another issue and that is if I'm eating dinner from eating dinner and this chicken and I eat chicken and I leave but somebody stayed at the meal right and I come back then I don't have to make a new broker why don't they have to make a new broker because the fact that was there means the meal didn't get interrupted so here you have to remember all these are workers of Sydney Markham applied to two situations leaving and eating elsewhere or leaving and coming back and continuing the meal it's always identical you understand this is very important just like when I leave somewhere else and I eat dear we have a challah have to make a new bracha right if I come back I also have to make a new bracha why because it's not a continuation of the meal so I'm eating chicken or I'm drinking coffee and then I go out then I come back right I go to Davin let's say I come back I have to make a new Scirocco why cuz it's not a continuation of the old coffee huh even if I had in mind even a fad in mind but if I left somebody here right we were drinking coffee again I left somebody here or by dinner I left somebody and then I come back then what it's a Hampshire because he he kept the seats warm so to speak so it's not continued interruption I I don't need a brock ocarina afterwards so what didn't come i saw what but i left somebody here that is like something that needs a bracha crying a beam Carmi it's better even because it's not only a bra corona there's a person physically here so that's a very very important you soit but the fact that i leave somebody behind doesn't help me that I don't have to make a new Brock of there it just means that if I come back and offer to make a new bra here but if I go there after make a new bracha a new bracha there so the Gemara says from here you see that it's only if you left somebody behind but if he didn't leave somebody behind you have to make a new bra right you have to make a new bra so the Gemara says that's the of Rebbe hood review they had that unique - what was his - - was that it's always about how if you left somebody behind and if not you have to make a new bra but the Revlon and doner hold like that necessarily and therefore represent has not been refuted I want to point out another very interesting McCoy cos that comes up in this sugah another very interesting McCoy curse and if you'll take a look at the Russian of the bracer and that's really we're it where it comes out if you take a look kouf Aleph Emet base go follow from it base much the middle of the page the line start lavoris and mesa right mesa this is the question on a pizda Mesa I just want to read this Bryce Benes how boorish are you masoom unleash toys for a crew rag layin Lots is lacrosse carcinoid lacrosse Carla that was their justification to leave they didn't stumble leave shane Yotes in ain't torn in broccoli my Freya when they leave enough to make a bra Coronel my frame means abraca retro actively on what they ate Shane crazy ain't turning broccoli hot killer by medve I'm gonna change which I'm sucking a Scylla I have a lady who some Lusaka Malloy sila Shane Yates intern in Brussels I'm afraid uh Shane House intern in broccoli cop killer if they didn't leave anybody when they leave they have to make a broker right now and when they come back they have to make a broker with China which is a big question or a pistols he holds that on things that require bracha Crona BIM kind my they don't need another another broker right and it says aku rug lion and he ties his ocular agley means they uprooted their feet wide said they uprooted their feet meetings really they had to stay there why they have to stay there cuz it's something that needs a bra car Corona afterwards and that's where they had to stay there and yet they left and we say they have to make a new broker afterwards because they didn't leave anybody behind which is a contradiction to the pleased it would hold that if they come back they don't have to make a new broker why because it's something that required a brush uh crying up incoming it's not considered a new meal even if they didn't leave anybody that was the question answer was this goes according to me hood them but the bright Sosa said something else when they leave they have to make a bracha Corona on what they what they did already and here it's interesting how this line became a source of a major McLucas to different cities in Regina does the of the Rambam and the of toy service right here which trickles down all the way to a locker all the way down what's the big argument the big argument is that according to the of the Rambam okay then when you leave and you start your meal elsewhere yeah it's considered a completely new meal and because it complains in the please you know meal not only do you need a new bracha you also need Abraha harina on the first meal at kadai and that's how he taxes this Gemara when they leave they need a maker bracha no and when they come back they need to make a broker in China this is an Avenue meal so just like the second meal needs a new broker Regina the first meal needs a broker kroner that means let's say there was a hustle and a collar and they ran out without making a broker I know they were supposed to but they ran out and now they come back what do they have to do not only do they have to make a new broker they off the first bench on the old which is fascinating so they were eating bread they leave they leave they didn't leave anybody behind they left anybody behind it's not a problem they could continue they don't leave anybody behind right they come back after bench and make her might see a new I might see at katenka because they didn't leave anybody behind of course this is according to the schita of reputations that you have to always make a new brush even if it was bread ah if his do it hold also if there's no but if it's if it's if it's not bread if it's bread you would hold not but if it's not bread you'd have to come back right make your burden of fauces on your food and then continue your new meal AB katenka this would be a give out that's how they died Shiites in and they have to make a broker and then a new a new a new broker a new broker a shiner why they picking cotton and collar because that's the reason that they were rushing that why didn't they bench why didn't they bench wasn't some an attraction the ice-cream truck came and they ran away it was a custom Okawa and it was literally a mitzvah so you might think the tariff Mitzvah is different no doesn't have to do that sorry mitzvah but they're still they still have to make a new just love to make a new Braga and theis vez disagrees Torah says that's not the vort the Voort is when you change your place nobody holds you have to make abraca growing on the old food it just means you have to make a new blessing on the new food but the broker Karina if none of it's not a complete complete interruption but rather the broker owner could be on both that's that's the of touch either Brice's says when they leave they have to make a broccoli I'm afraid he says it's not a dinner it's an exit over it's good device why you're leaving and you may be there for a long time and by the time you come back it's already after digestion and you will not you'll miss your opportunity for breakfast Amazon so therefore it's a good eight sir that before you leave you should you should bench first but what if they did it what if they didn't and they left that when you come back you don't have to make a new bracha corona and then a broker is China rather you could just make a broccoli shiner so he teaches that that's what the Bryce a means the Bryce's says Shane Yeats into an in broccoli my Freya when you leave you have to make a broker before you go and if you did that when you come back obviously have to make a new brother cuz it's a new meal the hidden is even if you didn't even if you didn't and you didn't make a brother credit when you come back right you still have to make a new broker before before you continue before you can in this is of course all if you didn't leave anybody behind but if you left if you if you didn't leave but if you left somebody behind if you left somebody behind you're good havin mine doesn't help if you leave the house first of all they didn't have in mind they were in middle of the meal and they left but even if you have in mind right if you leave the house to another house you're still gonna have to make a new broker remembered as doesn't help for Shinri and welcome only in one house not in another house okay ah no again when I make the broker I had in mind that I'm gonna be walking around or jogging with the cup of coffee then look up Hillard there was no makan that's with the Mishnah brewery says right there was no muck but if not I sit down to drink and in the middle I walk outside yeah and I go somewhere else I have to make a new brach on the coffee and according to the precious even on the bread yes yes and I have my start yeah you're asking to Schuyler generally we say me bhai Aslam biased ours doesn't help right that's doesn't like Kadesh from welcome Sudha I'm a kid this year and I have in mind to eat a meal there doesn't help I have to make a new kiddush same thing here in welcome I this I'm eating here and I have in mind I'm drinking this coffee I've a mind yeah I want to continue there it's a very nice but I was Michonne Amaka I went to a new place yeah but med Vera memoriam if lathela there was a mahkum huh that's the Voort if like a pillar there was a mahkum if i sit down a mahkum here right and I have a mind at some point I want to go I want to go elsewhere that's called a name welcome I'm gonna need a new broker if the cap Hillard is no maken that's the vort hose he drugged him look at Hillard is not welcome look uphill I'm on the run other words not that the broker was here and then in middle I changed places but look up Hillard there was no place that's what I was saying that I think the hectare here according to this is that people who people don't have a sense of mahkum right even if I'm taking a sip inside yeah it's not like I want to drink coffee inside and then a middle I want to leave there was no established place for it so when I made the breakfast show how come the abattoir a wit which place was it everywhere here by the tent my car and my house and in my office like the jogger I think that's the distinction when you nosh all day you have to tuck it you say yeah that's the limits course that's what I think is a limits host today because a lot of people don't know these helices and they're really relevant to lockers very few people know these are lockers you see I'm trying to be Malamud silence based on this mission a brooder based on this mission a brooder let me read you his lush inside just yeah but I'm saying people jaw constantly with bottles of water how often they make sure Huckle on that bottle of water I'm asking you how often they make sure how come oh the Shulchan Aruch says if you ate bread in one place then you eat somewhere else you know you make milk some miles into the second place just like people who walk who are traveling and they're eating while they're traveling while they're walking and they see the whole time and they bench where they finish eating that's what the Shulchan Aruch says yeah and it's not a problem and the reason is even though they don't see the first place where they left they walk and walk and walk and they go so far away from the original place why don't you have them make a new brush even according to the schita that you make a new brush on bread and the answer is because they never had a place the whole feeis was to walk the cleanest ones that is no curious when we washed I made I might see what was the mindset we're not sitting down to eat we're walking and eating so we have to place the places wherever my feet go that's the place so it's a very big place so it's not called uprooting a place they're not occurring they're not such scenery welcome sheeni maca means you have a place and then this Shinri Markham there's no more come it's not scenery markers actually mean welcome yeah so you say well you left your place it's a new meal with Madeline I didn't have a place it was no place this meal was usually a meal is fixed right there's not a fixed meal what happens okay very important just what happens if they decided you know when the kids are going on a hike let's say and they stop for lunch jelly peanut butter and jelly sandwiches right so if they wash and they good the counselor says guys we can't stop eat on the way it's not a problem what happens if they sit down to eat they sit down to eat and they want to eat where they where they may have might see that and then in middle he says it's late it's late we got a go middle of the meal he says now you're gonna have a problem why because you were cavae are you caught you work over your mahkum right so I said as long as we hike and we could see the first place where we made I might see then you could continue without a Bronco this one place but if you go so far away and you can't see the original place anymore right or you make a turn or trees blocking you so then it's called shinny maken and if they were eating fruits if they were eating bread we said it's not a problem because it's according to the prisoner but they were eating fruits right they were eating fruit they would have to make a second brush and bread according to the of of Reb ashes what happens what happens if he's outside and initially when he made how might you he made her age he thought I want to eat a little bit in one place and I want to continue eating it as I walk we have 5 minutes let's start here so when you made the bracha you had both things in mind I want to start it it's not what you made the broccoli decided to eat here and then you change your mind that we said it's stream' and welcome but if you didn't change your mind that was your mind I want to start here and I want to continue on the road so he says that would work that would work even if you're walking in a way that you can't see why because if it's me bias lebay estas doesn't help if it's me bias lobbyists - doesn't help in other words you're in the bias and then you go out to another by you so you go outside your das won't help so if you start eating in the house yeah and then you go outside it's like me bias low bias that your das won't help and you would have to make a new brothel so that's very interesting you would have to make a new broker so now is a question in Starbucks right we learned before if you look at pillar outside and there's no mahkum it's not a problem even if there is a mahkum but you decided it shouldn't be a muckerman middle it's also not a problem but he tine is that if you were inside if you were inside even if you had das because you went outside it's considered a serious half-sack why because you had a serious mahkum and we said that my bias lab is it doesn't help ah the jogger was like a Killa outside but if the jogger starts here and in the morning he says in middle I'm gonna go jog we're saying you have to make a broccoli by Islah bias right my bias low bias so he brings here that the egress moisture Ramona Feinstein a moisture Phelan Bay says the this mission of brewery with the blue with the deer show say being familiar smile sure that this is only if you made a brothel when you still have to stay in the house for whatever reason you had to stay in the house or the house became the careers but if you're already about to leave the house so even though you start in the house it's like you made the brush on the path you're considered Jose de Rock'em Jose Drucker means you're on the road so if you're outside great and even if you're not outside if you're about to leave you're on the way out and you don't have to make a new broker you know if to make a new broker ah of course if you take a candy cause it's Chacal and you eat a candy a lollipop right when you're about to leave the house yeah you ever do that I'm solemn observe a lollipop okay ice cream let's do ice cream right ice cream and while you're about to go out of the house and then you leave the house and you're on the roads so he says outside you have to take it out of your house your mouth and make a new Scirocco that's the of the COS I wish that would be a Starbucks question but based on this idea that das doesn't help but according to the moisture you're okay if you didn't if you sit down in Starbucks even though you had the day it to go to your car it's such problem but if you look at the hill okay drop him there was no ma claim few years ah so again if it's back to the jogger if you're hosted Rock'em another there was no muhkam for your food the whole you side look at pillow was what that you're on the run so it's not Cheney Malcolm XI Noah Malcolm means I uprooted myself from this place so it's a new Sudha but there was no Markham to do shimmy Markham the mock him here was everywhere I'm jogging I'm driving I'm walking I'm so it's an interesting smarter if you're in the house and you have in mind to eat outside even though you had in mind right you have to make a new bracha because there was aqueous in the house but if look uphill you established yourself as a healthy drop him then - does help - does help because me by his libido me by his LaHood's since there was a crease so this is called the Shinra malcolm it's annoying even though you had a das but the das doesn't help for the fact that you interrupted it and you went to a new place but if it was the Catalan or mock crime so then there was no interruption that's the vort if there's a mock I'm my dad's doesn't take away from the fact that there's a mahkum there's a welcome you haven't mind to continue somewhere else ok but it's a new marker it's a new marker but if there's no mark I'm you say what's the difference what's them if I'm hiking if I'm jogging or I'm inside and I decide that I want a drug later what's the difference it's part of my das dancers cuz here there was a real Mach line and the shinny maca makes it a new Sudha if it's schakal right but if there was like a pillow no marco him so there's no shimmy Malcolm that's the vote the vote by a hiking or jogging is not that there was a mocking with das that there was no mocking that's the Havanna here is a practical example I'm trying to go biking every week and we go many times in the same places yeah that's very practical question down to eat something in a place because I'm sitting in a place that's meant for eating you know well again if the water you started to drink the water on the outside when you get onto the bike you take people and sit on the bike they take a sip of water and they start so then we established it seems like you don't have to make a new bracha even if you go miles and miles why because you weren't you weren't I to yourself from a mock I'm when you made the brackish Ahok oh it wasn't in this place it was you on the road you are hosting drunken that's the definition now you stop so you don't have to make another broker because you're again hosted Rock them you understand unless you eating a new food that mean if eating is cake you'll make uh miserliness and with Mozilla's then you don't have a problem with cloud cuz it's something that needs abraca corona been coined mine so even if you leave over there we establish that according to the professor according to his that's not an issue oh you mean you leave the road now and you go into a new place and you want to continue drinking the water so you're saying this is now now you make now you went from Nome welcome to Malcolm oh you sit down like you're going to al-qaeda you would have to make ah like a rest stop a rest stop then I think you would have to make an abrupt outdoors but it's cold you go inside and you want to now take out your bottle of water and drink it so you establish yourself with a mahkum so now you went from Nome welcome to Makkah so now it's a scenery from Lloyd mark coming to Makkah I think you have to make a new bro and then when you go out you have to make a new broker a third broker yeah that's the bottom line the bottom line is that before you drink what's the what do you learn from all of this be present it's called mindfulness people talk today about mindfulness this is all about mindfulness presence food in the plane so they washing fairies the ether they've got alum them he little bit they finished in London ever committed and never mention the same thing eating a lot of real come I by him still have this question by the way you know you say since you can make a bra Cochran elsewhere you never finished till you made a broker crony never finished its one otherwise you're taking a leniency you turn it into a you're turning it into a benefit the leniency is that even though your Sudha is over and you left I don't care so you're saying it means your suit is not over you're taking the cooler and you're giving it an interpretation it's the opposite of what it meant it meant a leniency even though your left and your dawn and you're finished and you're gone and it's not connected anymore it's something that we don't clear the brush grain is in a different realm you understand that's the fart it's a cooler than a common gave that even though your suit is interrupted and you left and it's completely over and you're in a different place and in a different world we don't care if you still make a broker Shriner they were fine it's a really it's over yeah it's a leniency that even though it's over as they say it's not over till it's over in other words it's over yeah that's the leniency if it's bread they didn't give this leniency because it's shikaku so doesn't have that cash evos just like the broth is a different type of broker it doesn't have that casinos that you have to remain in the place it's over and I still let you make the broker so now you're using the leniency against you understand you say the meanest time interrupted it is interrupted that's the leniency the leniency items are even though this suit is over and you left I'm letting you make a broker well letting you make a broth but it's interrupted it's over my shenkin of eating bread and you left it's not over because you got to go back you can't make it there you can't make it there but that means there's something pulling you back you're connected because you can just leave you can just go away you got to go back or you could continue eating here and make a bracha here but when you're continuing eating here the reason is you should be able to make a broker Corona on your previous food in other words you're continuing the meal so that's a separate Holika that look up Himmler you're not supposed to change places by bread unless you had big day or when you made I might see but that's a separate hour the ass doesn't help beside the new broker by by other things but das helps that when I decided to make her might see on this bread the Marco him I want to McCoy miss for this bread I want to stretch the mahkum you understand ain't a tsunami if I don't and I leave and I continue eating that off to make a new brother but look up hill of the halacha is you're not supposed to leave without a broker unless you had in mind by her might see to where to go there or another eight says if you have in mind to continue go there and eat beer and come back to bent that's also good but just to go there and eat there no no but you have to because then your now let it go there you're now going to go to a new place even if you're not gonna eat there and come back in out loud oh you have to first bench and then go cuz we're scared you're gonna forget to come back even if you're going to eat there you're still now louder if you didn't have qivana because you not supposed to leave this place without abraca the only exception is if you can decide to go there and eat there so maybe even if you can forget to come back you're good and you have been dared to come back then you're allowed or by how might see you have a pill a day at the stretcher mahkum but the piece is not talking this Nikodim with you but if I left I didn't listen I left I don't eat there you could bench there you don't have to come back Kapil you're not supposed to do that you should bend unless you had bad day about how might see to continue then you're off the bench what was the thing they know they're gonna finish so then they had but day if this is the system then it's called das if this is what I'm doing if this is if this is the derrick and everybody's doing it so then I know it even if I didn't have or another eight says I think I'm gonna continue eating there but I want to come back then it's also good how logically that's also good I'm gonna come I'm gonna go there to eat but I'm gonna bench a that's also good that's also good if you had but there to eat somewhere else by how mites you don't have to I can go to your subscriber go bar mitzva then I don't have lunch at home it's fine I have to have the day about might see look at silly it's not a problem because then the MA claim the muhkam stretched so it's not it's not you're not you're not taking away from the shivers by benching elsewhere because you're not uprooting yourself generally you eat bread just like you have to make a bra a friend in this place you also have to make a bra Karina in a way that you do it before you leave the same harsha vez of the brach of this food that you have to make a broth attorney here not there it's also that you have to make a bra right now before you leave you don't leave without it but if you had in mind like a killer that you're gonna leave so then it doesn't take away that Rivers cuz this place was not one place it was two places it's like a big room even though the room is another house yeah that's fine I understand it's the media that ya doesn't take away you understand what I'm saying the the way the way in the Shannara karov the ballot on you says in KO phayam classes anything they have to make a broker afterwards in its place because of its harshest like bread for example you have to make a broken because it's so harsh of you also have to make a brush after it before you leave just like it's kasha vez is effective in the sense that you can't bless you can't make the broker elsewhere it's harsh event it requires you to make the brachot here it's her Shiva's also implies right that you have to make a broker before you leave elsewhere just like you can't make a brothel so we have to make it here there's another detail you can't make it before you leave you have to make it before you leave don't go elsewhere and come back just like you have to make in here and not there and if you go there you have to come back there's another din and that is even before you go there and come back you should make a broker don't leave here before you finish that's part of the services to give all the Kivar are you gonna eat somewhere else and make a broker there it doesn't help because the first tehila requires abraca in its place before you leave it sound that's a service the fact that you're gonna eat elsewhere only means that you can make a broker there but you still lost the fee of to make a brush on the first food in its place before you leave so just like i have to make a brush in its place and i shouldn't make a broker there i also shouldn't leave there and come back here before I leave I should make a broker I am gonna eat there that doesn't doesn't help right it helps for the Brucker there but it doesn't help for that really really not if I already left and I eat there I don't have to go back because I really I can't fix it I left for Fallon you already dishonored the bread you're not gonna give it back covered by coming back all you have to do is you have to eat in the second place I make a brother you understand cuz once you leave you're not gonna gain anything by coming back it's far fallen the ship misses ice you left but you still make yeah stuff to come back if you didn't eat in the new place but if you had in the new place you're good but luckily you shouldn't leave without a bra unless you left a kabura there huh or you have people there what or or even if you didn't leave it if you left people there you good because then it's not called akhira because they're holding the seats warm that's one option right another option is you if you left people there so let's say it's Shabbos you and there's a minyan for minister and people stay you can go and then come back the truth is although that service Mitzvah they did let let's say the mitzvot they left i'll obtain in a minute no no but you stuff to make another brush according to that shitty stuff to make another brother again if if you left somebody if you left somebody it's good or even if you go and you're gonna eat elsewhere and you decide to come back it's also good okay oh so good and if by huh might see i had in mind that you want to eat there is also good so so good but live a mitzvah for a hassan or a caller to Darvin then you can go and bench when you come back even though you didn't leave any have a rim because since it's a mitzvah various if it's a mitzvah that's gonna pass like a carson and a cow ah we let you leave and then come back because we're not of even though you may forget but because it submits for that whom we let you do it so if it's iris mitzvah if you're gonna continue eating there is good but even if you're not gonna continue eating that you could go and then come back because it's a mitzvah various by custom and Kawa but according to that they would have to make a new broker because they hold it even bread you have to make a new broker if you hold your bedroom for making a graffitied you a lot of leave be enough to make a little bra say they says like this even if you hold that far might see you have to make a new broker this is koh phayam fest in the ballot Anya tomorrow fara even if you're the found mites you have to make a new broker like rapacious she knew in welcome is not a half sick if you come back unless you stay outside of your place for example you went outside to speak to your friend they had a long conversation right or you went to shul to Darvin or you want to do some business and it took time but if you didn't spend any time even if he did something voluntarily for example you went to the bathroom which is obviously not it's just to do what you have to do it's not called a half sick in the meal or you had a conversation with your friend even outside but it wasn't long it was just a small chat even if it was about voluntary things or he says you go out to another room in the house you go to the basement to bring something for the meal you have a bottle of wine or there's a shaman as a waiter right who's walking around the house the whole time serving so you gonna say every time he comes back yes to make a new problem that's what you're saying this is no absolutely not why because it's not considered a half sick it's not considered Shinri mahkum because he didn't so when it says it's just honor that if you go outside of the house to speak to your friend you come back you have to make it abraca he time is its only if there was a longer conversation very interesting a longer conversation and he said according to the schita that says that on bread you never have to make a new broker but I'm shocked oh yeah it's still not considered a Shinra Malcolm if you do this in a meal right in a meal as long as you work I've a on it and it's things that the quiesce is aqueous let's say you sit down to drink coffee you sit down to eat meat whatever it is and then you go to the bathroom the hef sick all right doesn't take away this to the squat doesn't take it away but if it's something that the crease is not aqueous it's just more a temporary thing and you're here and you're doing it then it's mush ma that if you would go to the bathroom you would go to the best you would have to make a new broker cuz it's a half sick so that's very interesting that's called aqueous yes sheis converse brought as aqueous it has to be something that the crius is significant like not a cup of water it has a certain achievers and you establish yourself in it and then they have Sekar I the temporary thing of going out to speak to somebody for a minute we're going to the bathroom doesn't interrupt it and you come back enough to make a new Scirocco but if it's something that the crius is not aqueous which was discussed in red should get more then you would have to make a new brush even for a short half cycle that's very interesting I think you should sit down to eat an apple to eat a little snack I don't know a little candy a cup of water and then the middle you need to go the back and you come back and make another be enough to make a new broth according to this fascinating Simon cook KO phayam s if s in race you'd give all he tells us what's called crisps and what's not called crius let's see they should give us if I love Aaron so race should give Molly says on all fruits and other foods besides bread and all drinks besides wine if two or more are sitting so like a pillar they would make that one makes a broker for everybody even though they're not reclining on their beds even in those days when they used to always recline right if they're sitting by a bell Abbas and and everyone would recline and as long as they're not established for a meal one can't exempt the other one through his brother that's by bread and wine but other things that are not so cautious you can exempt your friend even with you're not reclining but you have to be established together and today there's no reclining clown so no different in bread and wine and everything everything if you're not sitting one can't make a bracha for others and if you're sitting even bread and wine you can make a breath as long as you're sitting by one table or without a table by one by one one tablecloth or one napkin things that people sit together to eat they establish themselves like wine or similar things when they sit down in an established way one could make a bracha one can make a broth for others unless but you have to make sure it's something that what that people establish themselves to drink like together like beer or med and in some places it's brought coffee so then it would be curious it would be called crius so that's what he's saying here that if you established yourself no no that's in terms of making a broker for somebody else but in terms of what we're speaking here is if you establish yourself to eat something yours down but then if you go to the bathroom enough to make a new broker but it smashed my for something that clears doesn't help like a cup of water you're sitting if you're sitting and learning in your drinking water while you're sitting and learning then it's confuse so that's a good Shila this class is brought to you by the yeshiva dotnet please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net slash donate