Pesachim 101b-102a - Arvei Pesachim #5

the yeshiva dotnet dr. Haley Kamara deaf cough Aleph our mood bangs around 10 lines from the top the line starts Mass Nyssa Loy schmear lay so let's just recall the flow we spoke about the McLucas of Wrath and Schmuel if you make conditions shown you come home you have to make another kiddush Roth said you know if they make another kiddush but you still have to make a new brush on the wine even if you drank the wine in Sheol and the reason is because she knew maka you came to a new place and even if you had in mind that you're gonna drink wine when you come home but the hug often over the wine and the soul does not apply to the hug often that you does not apply to the wine that you want to drink in the house you have to make a new bracha on this new drinking of wine in the house the first drinking is interrupted by leaving the house and going home from sure Shmuel says you're not even you it's the kiddush even the kiddush doesn't workers and kiddush Ella from Arkham sued then the Gemara supported that with many a Miriam who also agreed your horn and raba quoted by a buyer that inky - Alabama come soon rebuking and had a third [ __ ] and that is it enough making a broker on the wine when you get home because the buchanan olds that shinny machermo so it doesn't matter as long as you had in mind that you want to continue drinking wine you could go home and continue drinking why enough to make a new burger pre-alpha not on the year it's the kiddush even you said the wine with the gomorrah refuted reputation on because the Brice's says suck if you change the wine in the middle of a meal and you bring out new wine you'd often make a new broker but if you change the place Jimmy Markum you have to make a new you have to new make a new broker and then rip is the quoted rip owner who said that this is all if you're coming from one house to another house but if it's in one house then you don't have to make a new broker with Jimmy Markum and as we said that summer was showing him a gyrus that it's not in one house from room to room but it's in one room from corner to corner has obviously very profound a locket implications and the gomorrah quotes a price and it says Ramona didn't hear that price and that's why Ramona said it on his own even though the Brice absolutely supports what Ramona said if you have to make a new bra that's what gives you that's not the case you're asking they're not arguing because that's what kiddush is making a new bra Friday night that's not kiddush you're talking about Shabbos day kiddush is abraca but Friday night kiddush is abraca hug often and a special brother called breakfast a kiddush Shabbos afternoon you're right Ravin Schmo wouldn't agree cuz he would agree because if you make addition so when you come home and you make another hug often you're ready made a new kiddush so it's the same thing but Friday night making kiddush a second time in the house is a very significant thing according to Rav you come home you wash you may come might see and you want a cup of wine you say boy your prayer guffin and you're good to go according to smoke no no no no before you wash you have to take a cup of wine and say boy you're pre a coffin and Barakat wash and wash I could the son of a [ __ ] was over at Saban over some biscotti Bava over Rutzen in Solano and we finished off Barak atomic khadisha Shabbos you drink and then you could drink the rest of the wine but all of the meals that becomes a significant difference because according to Roth kiddush doesn't have to be but McComb soda and according to small kiddush has to be in the place of the psuedo the Gomorrah now continues the prisoner saying AHA Walker in his own name till now we said something in the name of Ramona then in one house in one house there's no Sheen remark you can go from one place in the house to another place in Taos or from one corner in the room to another corner in the room according to the second years in the text and you don't have to make a new bracha when you change location within the room or within the house the zoo furthermore your civ River Susu means and again Yosef replicas de was sinning with commish made an option and he said something in his own name the previous lesson was in the name of her Puna but now he's saying I walked in his own name meaning he's saying this and taking his own responsibility he's taken responsibility this is what I believe and he says something fascinating hard the arm Regina Malcolm sorry Oliver when do you say that when you change places in middle of the meal you have to make a new broker lawyer modern this is only said element Werdum shame to own in brothel aquarium and climb on things foods that do not require an after bracha in the place where they were eaten foods that you eat and when you make the brush after the eating what's called a Brock arena right the after bracha it's not required to make that blessing in the place where you ate the food that's called the varam should aim to own and Brock allaha random climate will I get the translation of the words things that don't require an after broker in the place where you ate them evolve are in mattoon in barakallahu mmm come on but those things that require and after Brock in the place where you ate them ain't Soros lavoris you don't have to make a new broker if you changed location what is it resistor telling us there's two types of food in Halawa there's a type of food that when you eat it you have to make an after broth in the place that you ate you can't go to another place and may clear the bra Cochran will soon see what types of foods but that's one category there's another category of food then you don't have to make a broker afterwards in the place where you waited you could leave and make a bracha I'll swear that's fine again we'll soon see what types of foods this is the distinction of krishna makes when you're eating things that you don't have to make an after brush in the place where you ate it and then you take the food and you go elsewhere and you continue the meal the food you have to make a new bracha machinery mahkum part if it's something that you're eating that requires an after bracha here even though you change locations you don't have to make a new brush in the new location my timer why my timer why why if I can in you eating this food in a new location don't I have to make a new broker the Kiva , hador because he is returning how does he translate he's returning he's returning to the original setting to the original courious to the original established setting meaning the continuation of the meeting in the new place is considered a perpetuation of Hampshire a continuity of the original eating of the original setting it's like I'm sitting at a table and eating for two hours you don't say after two hours after make a new bracha you're sitting at a sharpest table are we sitting at a regular table a regular dinner you don't say you'll make a new broker watch and I could work I'm sitting here at the table you don't make kind of records no even though I'm not in this place I went to another Kiva karma harder I'm returning I'm continuing I'm continuing the original setting that's what Rabb is the tortoise mesh may wish made enough shame what is it pleased at telling us when after my kiddush now when I don't get it I went throughout the whole week stomp ruckus regular food throughout the entire week Shabbos Yom Tov or a regular Sunday or a regular a regular Thursday let me explain I'll explain what he means I'll explain what he means what anybody will give up the full picture when anybody eats a food or drinks a drink we know that we have to make a Brokaw Corona afterwards it's called an after Brock condition is that you ate a Casillas if you eat a little little piece of cake a tiny big enough to make an after Brock you have to make a a what so called a broker Hashanah what's the word for it a preceding broker not an after bro but if you ate a Casillas or if you drank a Revere's which is approximately three and a half between three and four ounces of liquid you have to make a broker crane the difference varies if you ate bread you have to do brick or some other [ __ ] if you ate Mozilla's from one of the five types of grain wheat barley spell oats rye or you eat one of the fruits known as Shiva Simon in one of the seven types of fruits with which artists role was praised for example grapes or figs or pomegranates then you have to make a broker crater which is called bracha a cos may aim shalosh which means it's one blessing but it encompasses the three blessings of benching which we call al hama thea if it's missingness like a cake or a leg FN if it was wine or our ate swap re8 if it was a fruit not an orange or an apple or a Kiwi but if it was one of the shiva Simonon for example great grapes figs dates pomegranates one second this is a bracha corona after you eat what's what was unclear one second the brokers are honest after brokers have two categories one category is what you would call prominent brokers that the common obligated the person to make the broker where you ate it for example benching after bread when you eat bread I can't go and say I'm gonna go upstairs and I'll bench there I have to bench in the place that I ate that's one type of after bra another type of after broker they did not require you to do it in the place where you ate you could do it also elsewhere for example bite in a Farkas rhombus if I drink my coffee now I could go upstairs and make a burden of fosters day I don't have to make the burden to Fosters I have to make a burden of arches because I drank a Revere's but it doesn't have to be in that place car appears then teaches us a curve all the kiddush the whole Halak of shinee mahkum only applies to the second category not the first category meaning if you ate of food that doesn't require and after broccoli in its place for example drinking coffee and then I take the coffee and I go upstairs so I go to the tent or I go outside I have to make a new bracha why cuz I changed location and changing the location interrupts this meal and it starts like a new type of meal a new type of a new type of drinking and the original broker doesn't apply to it the original broker doesn't apply to it why doesn't it apply to it because I changed locations that's only if I ate a type of food that doesn't require a brush ocarina in its place so then the piece de says if I take this food when I go to another place or even if I don't think this food right but I eat another food yeah even if I had in mind to do that I have to make a new broker on the food that I took to the other place or the new food that ain't in a new place I have to make again a brush a hackle in the new place but what about if I'm eating of food that requires a bra Cochran in this place for example I'm eating bread we have to Benj now I take the collar and I go outside to the tent to have to make our new home I'd see comes up shake his then says you don't have to make another I might see go to another place usually you finish benching day ah not that Mister holds not you don't make another how much we hold it if you mash them you know someplace else and you bench why you grew up like this fine watch come on some no not that I'm more pascal's I can produce to know why you don't make smoke is there a bummer South American there are more there's just fight them and Ashkenazim we'll see in a moment you know if to have us you know if them pass I washed here for breakfast I ate Carla I take makalah yeah and I go home I live on 9je court and I continue eating it I don't make another how much but if I take my coffee home right then I could I make another schakal form eating potato chips it's a burden of washes right and I go to the tent and I continue eating it after make our dama by the pre-adamic but if I'm eating hollow bread then I go to the tent or my house or anywhere else I can fly to Miami I can get on a plane and fly to Miami eat the Falla Miami you don't make up might see that's a good question what if it's a new halwa that question is even if I'm sitting at a table let's say let's say I eat an orange I make a AIDS right and then somebody brings an apple from the kitchen do I have to make a new one ates that's not a question of Chenier mahkum that's a question even in one place the answer to that is if when I made a brush on the orange the Apple was in front of me on the table I don't have to make a new Brock on that if the Apple was in the kitchen but I had in mind that I want to eat the apple I also don't have to make a new Brock but if I didn't have in mind when I ate the orange when I made a Brooke on those I want to eat apple an apple comes out later as a surprise it's a new thing I didn't have in mind then I have to make a new brother that's even in one place because there are AIDS didn't apply to the Apple cuz the Apple wasn't here and Apple wasn't in my mind the Apple was gone if I'm sitting as a guest by your meal and I don't know what's coming out so then the Kapila I have in mind whatever you're gonna bring out cuz I don't know so then it's I don't have to make a new bracha but if it's my house and my meal and I plan to eat oranges not apples then I have to make them so that's a question even in the same place you understand that's not a question of SHINee maka certainly if I go to a new place I have to make a new brush on the Apple that's not a question but the kid this year is even the orange I take the orange and I go home after make a new boyar pre-aids that's only an orange but what because an orange doesn't require a brush ocarina in the place we waited I can eat the orange here and make a brush chakra in the tenth right but if it was something that requires a brother who are in its place like bread we have to bench in the place where you ate it comes up his Dan says that lock of SHINee Malcolm doesn't apply even if you go far away to a new place or close in the same house we're not the same house not the same as you go to another house completely you would have to make a new broker you would think so you don't have to make on a bra so you don't make a new I might see you continue you continue to eat without a bra no no yeah I'm eating this color.i now take it somewhere else I don't have to make a new broker even though I change location you don't have to make a new broker that's the point what's the reason for this what's this Maura the reason is what's that what's the logic you would think the other way around you would think this is much more harsher if you change places you have to make a new bracha that's what you would think logically it's not like that why the reason that when you change places you need a new broker it's because ah in halakha the best definitions are in South America RAF the definitions hog Doris literature Doris just I'm gonna go just just to get the house borrow KO phayam cash Iraq I am you were sitting in one room and you took the food in your hand and you went to another room to eat you have to make a new brother why I'm just gonna quote it Shakira Ahmad waha wakil amok amok here I mean does say zoo he Gomorrah he lost the zoo akela a heresy unibrow cattle since you stood up you interrupted the eating and you went to another place not in the same room another location in the same house or another house so when you stand up you basically made a statement I finished eating eating has to do with location with space in America it's hard to understand because it's a McDonald generation my life negate my Ahmed is people are eating in the car as people are eating you know you know people are eating everywhere always non-stop in every situation but really eating is connected to a place it's not something you eat wherever you are you eat sometimes a person eats walking so the chapters when I stand up it's a statement than Allah what's the statement the statement is I stopped eating I was eating I was sitting I was present eating is a presence of mine I'm I stood up to standing up is a statement just like if we're having a conversation and I stand up to leave it means the conversation is over I stood up it represents the Gemara of that Fela now I went to a new place and I happened to continue eating because I took the food there so this is a new I Fela even though it's the same it's the same piece of it's the same potato chips the same coffee it's the same Apple right it's the same snack whatever it is but it's considered a new I feel and therefore this one needs a broker the broker that I did 20 minutes ago or 10 minutes ago even a minute ago when I was in the other room doesn't connect to this eating it's like a new active eating it's only he don't come back uh-uh-uh-uh-uh one second even though I didn't have her cicadas meaning I took the coffee I know I want to continue drinking it it's not like I I went to do something else nonetheless nonetheless after makin abraha step 2 even if I come back I have to make a new braja meaning I have a coffee here yeah I take a coffee and I leave and then I come back and I want to drink it once again it's considered a new aquila and therefore I have to make a new Scirocco when I come back again this is not in one room one room even from a corner to another corner even if it's a huge palace a huge auditorium doesn't apply but we're talking about two rooms in a house and you can't see them from each other and also one house to another house now we can understand what it is they're saying this is or if you don't have to make a brush our own in the place where you ate but if you have to make a broker cryin in the place that you ate so when you left there's almost like you're connected to a rope the force of gravity is pulling you back because you have to come back you left but you have to come back so therefore if you come back and you continue eating the bread it's not considered a new aquila and even if you continue eating the bread elsewhere its continuing to consider a continuation from this place there's no shiney markham and therefore you could continue eating elsewhere and you'd have to make a no bracha that's what he says Leckie vakama Hadar you're coming back to the original setting you have to go back to the first place you're not done when I'm eating potato chips or drinking a coffee and I get up I'm done why am i done because that locker says you're off you're gone you know if to make a burden of fosters here you could do it there so I'm considered an interruption I'm gone I I decide to come back you decided to come back it's a new thing so therefore it's a new I feel it's a new tree you have to make a new bracha and if you eat it else for yourself to make a new bra but if I have to come back to notice make abraca right now so then even when I left I didn't completely leave because I logically I still have to return to make an after broker so therefore the evening in the second room or in the second house is considered our Hampshire to the first evening because I never finished the first the first key is because I still have to come back to bench it never got interrupted so it's considered one continuous meal that continued in two separate places and if we don't the Meccan abraha that's prattle akiva comma Hodder the answer to that is do you have to could you bench there could you mention it so if when you washed and you made the brach on collar you had in mind that you want to continue eating it elsewhere so then you could continue eating it elsewhere and make a broker Burke Osama's in there right for example I could wash this rule for the kiddush somebody's making a kid dish and I can have in mind that I want to continue the meal in my house and then I could go my house and often make a new broker might see as we explained and I could continue eating challah there do banishing there because you because I had in mind because I had in mind the capella that I'm not gonna eat all the bread here but if I don't have that in mind then before I leave I have to bench if you there already and you don't eat bread then you have to go back to bench but if you could eat if you eat over there then you could bench there then you could bench there because it's in it these are things that need a bra karna beam come on you understand so if you're ready there you have to eat there in order to bench but in order to be allowed to go there and not bench you have to have in mind when you made the brach on the bread that you don't want to eat it only in this place you want to continue eating it somewhere else yes but a new bracha here we're talking about the first broccoli you'd have to make a new first bracha right why don't you have to make a new first bracha because it's not considered an interruption you shouldn't have to have if you wrote the whole story that you retired the original home didn't know the mine helps for something else the reason you have to have in mind there's not much how the first bracha it's because the Cohanim said that red needs a brother her in a beam come on so how you a lot of leave without a bra cocorinha because you've always title here that's this far oh yeah but you oh you never leave there sort of that's why you don't make a new breakfast right but what we're afraid and the person could leave and forget cuz they have to date men who may not come back but if you had in mind and it's fine most of it that's the case no no no the question is are you allowed to leave the space without a bra karana when you're supposed to make it here right he's supposed to make it there so if you have like a pill in mind then it's fine cuz that was your whole das if not you should first bench and then leave as far as another breath you don't know but another broccoli don't have to make without that side no connection of das it's fine really you should make the broker i know where you are but if the person forgot if it was bisciotti not amazing it's much like Michonne my vasila if it was amazing you have to come back if it was Bashar you're not if they did it willingly unless I'm gonna digest it and by the time I come back I won't be able to make a broker colonel then you have to make wherever you are but if you willingly left and then you decide to become a ball truven in the car you have to go back but if you forgot then you just make a broccoli you ya believe you go to that come back and make another brother if it's something that you don't have to do according to that so that's considered because you say we do that you don't have to make another one when it's not been claiming so you eat something it's a good question about the bathroom we'll get to it it's a good question okay so so what's the new so what's information what did it is that teach us if you don't have to make a brach our own in the place where you ate so then when you left that place it's considered an interruption of the eating process why because you never have to come back again you never have to see that place again right you also don't have to continue eating in the second place to make a bracha Reiner there because you don't have to make a broker or another place that you ate so when you left this place this aquila is finished you don't have to come back here because you don't have to make a brothei here nor do you have to continue eating leer to make a bracha right in Iran the first meal why because you can make a bra karna in the place where you didn't eat so you don't have to come back nor do you have to continue eating so how logically what is it a complete end of the meal it's all over what happened is finished the chapter of eating has come to an end there's nothing that's connect connecting there's nothing that's continuing because I don't have to come back how logically nor do I have to continue eating the potato chips to make abraca hurry up dears because I could make a broth right upstairs without eating there because it's not something that needs a brush right now B McCoy my in its place so therefore how logically when he gets up we assume that the first situation the first story of eating has come to an end now you decide you want to continue eating okay make a new brochure like you sit down for a new soda you decide you want it was a new broker but if it's something that you have to make a broth right now in its place so if you leave without making a broccoli and it's not considered that you finished eating why cuz you have to make a broccoli and the place that you ate so therefore when you leave you didn't finish yet the process of eating why didn't you finish the process of meaning because you still have to come back so it's like I have a chain it's like I'm holding you with a chain you still have to come back in order to make a bracket or you have to continue eating in the new place in order to make a brach of there because you have to make a broker we're you ate again you have to make a broccoli actually either you come back or you continue there so now when I continue eating in the second place it's not called on a hillock a door it's not called a new act of meaning rather it's a hamster of the Koreas it's a continuation of the setting of the first night he law and therefore depreciation of his this says you don't have to make a new bra now the important thing here is to quote them are collectors between the rishonim what are the things that require a bra Cochran in place we ate it and one of the things that don't require a brow chakra in the place that you eat it generally speaking there are three opinions of course everybody agrees that bread needs a bra Cochran in its place which is benching everybody agrees that burden of fascists doesn't have to be in its place it could be elsewhere that everybody agrees that means coffee is Dover shade Tom Brokaw Krenim coma or candy bread collar is double shift on bracha lockeroom can the McLucas however happens on the things in the middle and there are basically three opinions the opinion of the rajab is that the broker main shall wash doesn't have to be said in its place meaning if you eat cake or you eat pomegranates or you drink wine it's not something that needs a bra Cochran in its place which means in all these situations you don't have to make a new brother if you continue eating the cake or drinking the wine or eating the the PAS the Shiva Simon infirmary stroll in another place that's the [ __ ] of the Raja a second sheet is and that's the [ __ ] of Thai service and rush and other is showing him that our mithya does require abraca corona in the place where you ate it because people archive a Asuna Mazzone is bread Amazonas bagels or cake people are conveyor Sudha they establish a meal on it and therefore you have to make a Brock crane and this place but not wine and Shiva some in them wine and sugar some in him in other words our Geffen or our age doesn't require a broth occurring in its place so this is already more stringent that even Mazzoni nurse has to be in its place but not wine and Shiva some in that's again the [ __ ] of tourists and the rush and around in the bottom or the miry and other is showing them and then there is a third [ __ ] any food that has a longer brach Ukraina besides burden of washes which means cake wine and fruits for Mary to stroll with which I just always praise our America our governor lights all of them require a broken corner in the place that's the [ __ ] of rashly that's the [ __ ] of the Rajah bomb and then chicken or of all three opinions are brought and this has very practical ramifications I eat a piece of cake down here and then I could Oracle cookie or a cracker and then I go up there do I have to make a new brush or I go to the tent or I go home to have to make it Abraha according to the first opinion the opinion of the rajma it doesn't have to be done in its place which means when I go there I would have to make a new broker if I come back again after make a new bra according to the second opinion however Allah mithya is like bread so therefore if I take the cake and I go outdoors and almost to make a new broker and according to the third opinion even if I'm eating a fig or a grape or a pomegranate if I go out there I don't have to make a new broker why because I had to make a broth right in the place where I ate it so therefore when I go out there my eating is not finished because either I'm coming back or I'm continuing in other words whenever you have to make a Brock arena afterwards in the same place there is a mechanism and halakha that says you're not done what's the expression it's not over til it's over okay it's not over til it's over okay as long as there was no brush our Korean it's not over so if I'm eating my grapes and I take my grapes and then I go home cuz he give me a bag of grapes it's not over till it's over it's not over yet I didn't finish eating grapes what happened to you're broke right now you say oh I brought ready I'll do out there you can't do a broccoli now so you gotta go back Oh see you never really left you left but you're on the way back you there's too many strings attached so you never left so if you never left right and you continue eating elsewhere you're still connected to the first place either you got to go back or you got to continue eating a deer to make a bracha Craner so this thing didn't come to an end yet and it's gonna come to an end yet the process still applies because there's a mechanism and I was sure that the process is continuing but if I don't have to make a brothel cryin in this place and I got up it's done everything is done what's the issue a line to a new place you don't have to come back you don't even have to continue drinking now you want to continue drinking in your house no problem it's your choice you want to start a new process start a new process it's a new bowling game you have to make a new bra that's thus far of ripest and as the hallux authority say shows on our car brings that little filly with McNamara according to all three cities that we make a broker her inner for all these three things where we ate it meaning figs and wine and miserliness and of course bread on the other hand Suffolk brockless logical so therefore if you take grapes and you take it home you don't make a new boy to create because it's a Suffolk according to these three opinion so we go locals you don't have to make so the only thing that you would make a new brush if you leave is burnishers because the other things is a smarter to say that what that you need to make a broker crane in the place where you ate it and if we enough to make a new Brokovich in amok that's the view of rep mr. fascinating finish of the prisoner and this whole hollow corruption and welcome to distinguish between these two opinions just to emphasize and this is very important you know please do one only say this if you ate enough to be McCoy of abraca corona then it would work but if you just ate a little piece of cake less than a Casillas and then you go outside you have to make a new Brock why because the whole reason you have to make a new brush is because you got to come back to make a broken render but if you didn't eat enough to make it they're happy in Clearbrook occurring and then you're like a choco so when you get up you actually finish the meal why because you don't have to come back if you want to make a broken corner so you have to make sure that you ate enough to be much who live in a broken corner and then if you're Martha crying in this place it's not considered a half unimportant are it's a different type of broker market inning to be how do you make one approaches it's something that you someplace new you're thanking our shams for the food for the tie to the original place not original not touch the original place you talked to the brother yes didn't you're tied to making a broccoli yeah you're not tied to the place and if I have to come back to make a broccoli right now so then even though I left its temporary it has to be temporary I have to come back before I digest the food which means within 72 minutes after me back so it's a temporary transition right and even if I'm not gonna come back I'm gonna continue eating there let's say I washed and I had in mind that I want to continue eating in my house right that's fine but I'm gonna continue eating there because I have to bench there I have to bench where I eat so I'm coming back or I'm continuing eating there but I'm not just leaving it in fact you I'm not just saying the meal is or what I mean the meal is over we gonna bench we gonna bench here he the meat so you gonna continue waiting so the meal is not over and I'm gonna go back okay so you going back so you gonna so now so the halacha now translates into two different ways if you continue eating somewhere else and if you come back remember in both cases you have to understand this halwa when it comes to a burden of washes and you eat somewhere else if to make a new bracha if you come back yourself to make a new bra because this is considered a new experience why because I left when I left this is done now you come back and you want to drink in Ganga's don't take to make a new bra but if I'm coming back to cake then I'm not coming back to a new experience why cuz I had to come back when I left I never really left it was just a temporary transition because I have to come back or have to continue eating leer to make a Brussels render this it's one of the two but this meal here is not done either have to continue eating here to make a bracha kronor there I can't just say I'm not continuing this MEP continuing this meal or I have to come back to make a broth I burn the freshness exactly exactly when I leave and then I come back it's a new experience there's no Hampshire your typhus shakes on my appreciations disagrees Patricia says echo deserve a huzzah Sarek lovara I disagree no difference if it needs a bra Cochran afterwards or not you have to make a new broker that's the view of reputation and the fascinating thing is that there was no halakhah established here so this is like one of the examples where there's really two different chitosan halakhah the Rambam and what we would call some of the Sephardic school embrace the precious and that's what the show generic embraced but there's the whole other schita tie service d-rush the Ashkenazim embraced her pisda and that's where there are ma embraced intial Honora so it's really two completely different shifts in halacha and Shannara semanko fan fest do we follow the prisoner and then it's much more lenient or do we follow the precious and then you're always making a new bracha even when it comes to burden of even when it comes to bread and and cake and so forth so the gomorrah says now mesa they asked a question on a prisoner the Brice's says fascinating question arises says Binet have were shahu you whom is superlicious there was a group of people who were drinking for up uruguayan they uprooted their feet in the middle of the meal interesting expression they uprooted their feet it's like their feet were attached and they uprooted it lotsa slickers Carson and the Kris kala to go welcome or greet a groomer a bride Shaheen Yeltsin when they leave ain't torn and broccoli ma Freya they no need to make a bracha on what they drank chain hoist urine into an umbrella her killer and when they come back they don't have to make a new broker in order to continue to drink so when the Carson and Karl are coming and they say let's go out to greet the Hudson and kala they don't have to say wait wait wait let's make our Geffen when they come back they don't have to make a Newberry Priya guffin they could leave come back and continue as is without any broker afterwards or any broken before my med varam amore and when says the Brassica she need some zucchini cola if they left in the group an old man or a sick person it doesn't necessarily mean that it just means somebody who can't go out to greet because why wouldn't everybody go to the coastal mikawa what's your Excuse you gotta have a good excuse so that's what he says a sucka North Island the point is somebody remained behind an older person and a sick person or anybody that means that when they left they still had a representative who stayed symbolically this meal is not off of a law you knew who shall come below what if everybody left Shane Olson when they leave to an umbrella I'm afraid they'd have to make abraca kroner Shane chosen when they come back to an umbrella with the left to make a broker or show you know what is this Bryson teaching us we learned that when you change places you have to make a new broker but we're not talking about a play here you left you went to a new house and you ate deer like we're talking till now rather you left and you came back to continue your meal till now we were talking about a situation primarily where you took your food and you went somewhere else and you continued eating here they didn't take the food somewhere else they just left in the customer column and they come back and they want to continue eating but the concept of Shinri malcolm applies here too because just like if you change places and you eat in a new place you have to make a new Brock or why could you interrupted the first meal and you started a second meal if you left the new place and you came back it's the same thing you started a new meal in the old place but it's the same concept of Shinri Malcolm writes a pink Kanan Constitution a manga say a person is eating dinner and then they get tired I'm drinking a cup of coffee it's 12 o'clock at night and then I go to bed I wake up 6:00 in the morning I come back I want to continue drinking my cup of coffee I'm drinking the same cup of coffee in the same place but it's called Shinri Malcolm the coffee didn't change places but I change places right so I would have to make him new bro why cuz it's it's a new ideas coffee I made a broker that was yesterday before he went to sleep now you change places even if I didn't go to sleep I went out to the Hudson and the collar and I came back it's a new experience of eating it's a new experience of drinking says the Bryce it's only if everybody left if everybody left when you come back you have to make a new Brock but if you left somebody there if you left on sucking or a Hilah so that means you didn't interrupt the meal why cuz when you left there's somebody sitting there what does that mean why is he sitting there he's waiting for you guys to come back in other words this party is not over yet so that statement means that they left but it didn't really leave they just left her brother coming back so therefore the price it says when they come back enough to make an uber to Priyanka enough to make a new bra that's what the price is set now what do we see from here me dick Tommy akrura glia since it says they uprooted their feet what does it mean they uprooted their feet why doesn't it say who they went when we approve what their feet would akrura clay and they uprooted was it uprooted how does this a accrue Ragland uprooted okay they uprooted their feet what does that mean so what means the Gemara is gonna say what does it means it means that they were actually established here yeah they were like glued here they were they were fixed here and therefore they had to uproot uproot themselves from this place in order to rush to the custom on the collar why would you say that they were they were fixed here so he because they were drinking exactly but no this is very important what's the Suvari why thumbs things need a bra cochran in the place and some things don't need rough event in the place so we all understand this right away again it's a little hard to understand in america but everybody understand what's the drinking the difference of eating a bag of potato chips right or eating challah what's the difference the difference is one by definition is not connected to a place one is a meal on the go it's not you don't say we're gonna sit down to have a family dinner and we take out potato chips some people maybe do it but that's not you don't sit down you don't sit down to have candies or lollipops or popcorn again I know American culture you do sit down to have popcorn and Pepsi Cola but it doesn't relate to the place it's it's it's something transient right you're eating an apple you take an apple you eat it we don't we're not gonna now sit down to eat apples it's not it's not it's not connected to the place so therefore the bracha Kroners also not connected to the place the point is you ate an apple you have to say thank you so you say thank you you say it here you don't say i ate apple there I make the brachot of it what's an apple is not connected to here I happened to be here there's other foods you don't happen to be the place is part of the food experience you understand the location being in one place is part of the eating you can't compare a meal on the go to a meal in one place yeah you're gonna say let's all eat and we're running around and eating that's not the meal a major part of the meal is that you're sitting you're fixed the place becomes part of the meal experience so mailed abraca has to be in this place just like the brook has to be in this food the Brock has to be in this place because the bracha is connected to this food when you're eating bread bread is you don't just eat bread yeah it's possible to eat it on the run but the way it was designed was that you sit in one place you establish yourself it's a social event it's a relationship even if you're eating yourself certainly when you're eating with other people it is a connection there's something around the food it's a rap battle it's about the place the location becomes significant because the location becomes significant I can go elsewhere I make abraca the bracha osa has to be in the location that's why you'll say ah crew Raglan they uprooted their feet what does that mean it means something that requires abraca Corina in the place where you ate it and because it requires a bracha creme in the place where you ate it why does it require Rafa credit because you were fixed because your feet were fixed when you're eating an orange your feet are not fixed with even if I'm sitting but it's not connected to the place but certain foods it's a connection to the place the place is part of it that's racist McDonough accrued ugly and MacLeod the bit vandemataram Baraka like random climbing our skin ah no this taste means wine means wine yeah miss Subin wished ice there was a drinking feast the rush bomb says lugar sin unleash toys because the rush bomb holds that that would charge by me talking about he says hey assume digital correctly we've seen a later scene in the onion there are those who are not going to solicit us for very simple reason they hold that every drinking even wine is not something that requires a bra Cochran in its place and this Bryce is talking about even wine and I told you these three [ __ ] tests and this Bryce is talking about something that needs a bra Cochran you'll see in a moment mid dick Tony Hawk Uruguay and McCloud with Varma to nebula klaymen klaymen our skin on we're dealing with things that need a brush ocarina in its place that's why it says akrura Glen in other words really they had to remain there they had to remain the in order to make abraca corona that's why if not for syphilis Hudson and Calloway Rove never left and that's why it's called uprooting their foot because it's a type of meal in which you're serious you're set you're established that's the whole idea it's a meal that happens around the place and that's why they have someone said you have to make a brush a crane in that place so when you leave that place it's called a crew rag layin because the middle of the meal you're not supposed to leave for two reasons first of all it's not the nature to leave and second of all how logically you have to make a brush a corona that's what we say they uprooted their feet like they detach themselves from a place where they were supposed to remain why do they do it because of symphysis hasan and kala so that's why it says occur all the time and what's the reason they don't have to make a new braja when they come back it should have said because they anyway had to come back to brush our hands not what he says time of the new shams or kanahele they left an old man there who - a noise an internal Brooke Lemar friction resonate - no broccoli cop-killer that's the reason they don't have to make a Brucker when they leave and make a new Brock when they come back like in a Kyla but if they didn't leave anybody behind thanks Shane you're a Chunin broccoli my fractions do the broccoli cop-killer they would have to make a new broccoli when they come back Kashi little because this undermines the repairs the hold that if it's something that needs a bra Cochran in its place and even if everybody leaves when you come back you're off to make a new bra Kauai because you never interrupted your meal because you have to come back for Branca kroner this Bryce it clearly contradiction is there and you can say the price is talking about potato chips why because the prices as a crew rag lien how you miss uber Lister's if you hold that wine is something that needs a bra Cochran in its proper place so then it's clear it was wine and that's why it says aku rag lien because they were cavora it was something that your cave a I'm not going for it's a type of food or drink that you crave am welcome when you have to uproot yourself from it and you have to stay there for the bra karana and that's why they were drinking wine according to that sheet ah that wine is something that stony barakallahu random crime according to the [ __ ] is that why not only bread or Amazonas you talking that Garris least ice that's why you're not going to solution toys because listeners wouldn't work because little ace would be something like burn a fascist because wine would also be that so therefore the whole car sure wouldn't work she attacking that goodness the union of Lycia toys because wine according to those gears says doesn't need a brush our ina beam climber and the Bryce is talking about things that do need a bra Cochran but whatever your gear says up to rag Liam shows you that this was not a regular movement they had to uproot themselves it's like you're sitting at a Shabbos dinner and somebody leaves they say we're going why you asking we're going were you going we just sat down for a dinner right but if we're having but after a chakra somebody serves some schnapps and herring right and I take a piece and I say have a good I go don't nobody says where you going why because we didn't sit down for a meal we didn't sit down for a meal it's just the it's on the run it's a different type of meal it's a snack we call it a snack and that's where it doesn't need a broker thrown it into place because the place didn't become part experience this foods where the place becomes very important and this food where the places just the happenstance is just incidentally understand the difference and the Casal were very sensitive to this so but mainly here we see that it does need a Brock Reiner than kymo that's where it says accrue and still and still they don't have to make a second broker but why only because they left somebody behind this mama SH supports a precious that you have to always make a new bra unless you left somebody behind that's very good that means you're coming back but if not I don't care that you have to make a new broker and we could understand why the fact that you have to make a new broker I know you have to come back is a halawet concept it's not a physical concept I said before it's like you know it's like there's a rope tied to your foot pulling you back how logically but not physically if there's somebody here so there's a physical presence that this meal didn't get interrupted if the fact that halacha says I have to come back reputation says that's not enough that's what the price of supports she's teaching us that if you're taking a snack and making them yeah but he says miss Subin Lister is varrock arugula ham but that's a deceiving but that's deceiving because if the pista was right the bracer should say this in a situation where it's something that doesn't need a bra coroner in its place that's what it should say say people who are sitting and drinking water they're sitting in jury or they're not sitting there standing and drinking water right they're not sinning that's not something you sit with and there's a cousin in kala and they leave and they left somebody behind and they come back enough to make a new shark oh very good that would support her pisda doesn't say that it says they were drinking wine they uprooted their feet don't say they went out they uprooted everything what does uproot of their feet mean it means there was a fixed situation it's something where they were supposed to stay they almost like had to force themselves to leave like they have to get out of it what what if they get out of it what you're glued what you must leave to stay there the answer is cuz it was a type of meal that requires a bra Cochran I've been calling my so two things first of all practically it's a type of food where you're fixed you don't move and how logically it's a type of food where you're not supposed to move till you make a broker cry now you understand what I'm saying and then they left and that's when it says you have to leave Bonet kabura according to the prison that's not true you'd have to leave anybody even if there's no suckin and Kaila you could come back and not make a new braja so the bryce clearly contradicts of wisdom it supports from fascias for stay still in it does support you precious no but it works very well with it doesn't support him but it works very well with them cuz he said that you always have to make a new broker and this bryce is teaching us that there was an exception if somebody stayed behind you don't have to so the gomorrah says i'm reppin asking by instagram Malcolm I instruct answered we'll finish with this with this Montana Akira's Reb you hood because that has no problem you know why he gave this Bryce a name an author he knew this Bryce it was not said by everybody was said by W hood because it was said by W hood there is that doesn't have to contend with it he agrees to be hood that disagrees with me why did why would he place ruby hood his name on this Bryce about the wine and the Bonet kabura leaving he says because the tiny we have another Bryce take a look at the other Bryce how very macabre it means Tommy they have come him they're called friends sure how you miss Subin again they were eating together for a crew rag alayhim Layla the basic NASA syllabus I'm a douche they left to show were to study hall Shane Watson ain't tuned in bra Kalama Freya Shane hoisin in tune in broccoli capsule when they leave they don't have to make a bracha right now when they come back they don't have to make Abraha Regina here again they're eating they're eating something that requires a bra Cochran in its place because it says accrue reg lay him there cold curve areum their friends at home at the hub they go to shul they come back they don't have to make a new broker till now is very good with replicas de beautiful they don't of to make it a broker why not why not because it was something that requires a bra Cochran's place on Myra Buda amad more in memoriam is man Cheney who shall mix Escovedo monly if you left some guys there have a line issue somewhat just cover him if he left nobody there train yo its internal bra Kalama fresh and frozen tuna block a little filler then you have to make a new brush in other words review the argues with the first opinion the common withhold that word that they don't have to make a new one w-who this says they do have to make a new bra unless they left some of the friends there this means that the price that we just quoted with this cousin and Carla it's going following who it's following rabbi yehuda that's what he says Montano curious Reb you who there but there's a common withhold that you don't have to make a new bra huh so the business says what do you want from me on the contrary I have the support of the majority of the sages don't come to me and say I'm I'm contradicting a price on the contrary that prices review hood the trailers on you not on me the car come hold like I hope that'll come him you see clear from the car coming that they don't have to make a new brush even if there's nobody left why because the broker crane is in its place the broker crane is in its place okay no no the bread bread yep oh you mean cuz it was the Ayad ask ask what's Forex top feed obviously do ya later [ __ ] to that yayan is Dover at Table Rock a locker of him como so Ravan small you're saying would disagree you saying late that [ __ ] ah not cakey saying about wine this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net / donate