Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Life After Divorce - Part 2

4,052 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] dr silva foreign works with high conflict couples and families he also has a daily share on youtube spotify and authors a daily blog titled psychology of the daf which discusses the daily dove from a psychological perspective so called gracious for coming on tonight last second please open it up thanks thanks for having me you know i think about people that are going through such a difficult time whether it's divorce or the aftermath of the divorce or custody and um one of my uh favorite uh sayings from khazal which is really a mission and conduction is to shiver off from the gahannam which uh you know it's quite a quite a statement the best of the doctors are basically going to go to hell um and the reason why it's one of my favorite statements is because um you know what it means to me is that any time you're involved as a professional and and truly you mean well i'm not even talking about uh malpractice or or quacks or people that don't mean well you know even when you mean well and you really do and you really want to help people the fact of the matter is that oftentimes um you might miss the boat and and cause a lot of hurt feelings and they say this by way of introduction tonight because um i don't know if there's a way that we can talk about this topic without somebody in some way feeling this characterized or hurt and you know i just say that i just say like because l didn't say don't be a doctor they just they just warned you that that's what's in store so um we're gonna do this because i think i think our intention is the right place and hopefully we'll have we'll have seattle in israelia to do more harm if you're doing more good than harm um but i'm just saying that it is an important thing to think about so in advance forgive me if in some way i mischaracterize something or don't have sufficient empathy because it is very a very difficult topic um and you know on that topic what i wanted to open up with is to conceptualize divorce as as essentially an amputation um we know that medically there are times where you have to have an amputation to save the organism it's sometimes clear-cut sometimes it's a judgment call but ultimately nobody wants to cut off their limb um they do it because they feel that they must and it's no picnic and there's a lot of side effects the fact of the matter that it was a good thing to do ultimately and that it saved you doesn't mean that you're going to be immune from a lot of the difficulties and pains and the metaphor really holds true amputees have phantom pain they actually feel pain in the limb that doesn't exist which goes to how far that is and i suppose people that that that go through divorce you know they have all kinds of pains about a relationship that no longer is in existence but then again when you share children and you share um assets and other aspects the relationship necessarily is still in existence so i did just want to open up with that that concept that we really uh uh you know divorce is a necessary thing and you know berkshire we do see that that the torah has the ability uh to take into account a lot of different parts of the human experience including the need to get divorced and it's there for a reason so here we are talking about that and trying to do the best we can as human beings stumbling along trying to figure it all out all right performing a beautiful opening and um i'm going to turn over to rubber while i think to give a everybody i'm not trying to cut you short but you you know what's going on over here it's wild sorry bro have you yes thank you so so much thank you to my dear friends rab usher thank you coach manasseen thank you rep for joining us and thank you and to the hundreds and thousands of people who have joined us last time i think we had 40 000 views in last class right more than 40 000 views life after divorce series number one and now we are embarking on number two so as an opening i want to make three brief and sharp points number one to pick up from rip simpson's words the gemara says in kedushin from legend the best of doctors goes to gahannam goes to purgatory so rap simcha gave one interpretation i want to give another interpretation which i heard from a great doctor and he told me he said turf should be roy from legend the best of doctors goes to purgatory you know why it's not talking about the next world it's talking about this world because because a real healer a real doctor who's there with his or her patients and empathizes they experience gehennan in this world of course a doctor has to have a certain objectivity to be able to do his job well but nonetheless we are not indifferent a pathetic unmoved a real doctor experiences some of the plight of what his or her patients go through and therefore they experience getting them in this world and i think it's so important when we're talking about this and i'm sharing this with not i'm sharing this with myself and all of us and all the people who are watching this or will watch this who may not be divorced and that is it's so important to have empathy you're sitting at a shabbos table and there's a divorced man a divorced woman don't stigmatize them they're not strangers they're not foreigners they're not aliens we are all people we are all jews we are all brothers and sisters everyone has their own journeys in life don't stigmatize them and divert your eyes and ignore them and become uncomfortable with them they're people who have gone through their journey just like you and i have our journey and each of us has our baggage and our struggles and our challenges it's so important to be able to relate to them there's an expression in hebrew big govai nayim govai naya means heart to heart face to face you don't have to start feeling awkward and uncomfortable and not knowing what to say just be real be authentic be empathetic we have so many organizations and moistures to help people who are sick and poor which is incredible and amazing but show empathy and show compassion to somebody whose marriage has been terminated for whatever reason and just be there for them communicate with them with your heart with your soul in a straightforward way if you're not sure what to say and how to say and how to be helpful don't ignore and don't become awkward if you're close you can have an open conversation about it and i say also to those people who have been divorced who are in a process of divorce don't accuse your brothers or sisters or cousins or friends or neighbors of not knowing what to do they may be confused and if you're friendly with them share with them how they might help you but it's also a responsibility on all of us to be able to reach out you know how can i be here for you how can i be here for your children you're in shul there's a child from a divorced family his father is not there he's there with his mother you know be in the caribbe be be specially kind and sensitive and empathetic to to to this to to to these individuals it's so important it's important with every single person especially important with people who are going through the challenge of divorce even again if it's a lifesaver and important so that's number one number two is another message i think is extremely important some people you know you build families and in our communities and in judaism marriage and family is so important it's like the foundation of claudius education and children and marriage and a bias bistro and then suddenly you know all your dreams have been shattered and we spoke about that in in the previous session with the marshall the breaking of the lucas and i think it's so important to remember something you know in this week's parishioners the dream of the promised land is shattered it's shattered the jews were supposed to go into the promised land they never make it in there and moisture himself never makes it into the land flowing with milk and honey but they're 40 years in the wilderness but those 40 years are not wasted those 40 years are the foundation of all of civilization the foundation of all of the jewish people and all of judaism because it's alpine because god guided them even after the dream of the promised land was shattered they were on a journey 40 years and nobody's going to say that much 40 years were wasted those 40 years with maestro menu are the foundation of all of history and of all of morality and of all of tyra and of all of you described including of yamasa mashik it all goes back to those 40 years in the desert and what i say to you is we all have our promised land that we hope to go into and everybody should go into the promised land our promised land collectively bakariv and individually but every one of us has journeys that are unexpected don't think that your future is bleak embrace your future with an open heart with a positive attitude and with good spirit because god is holding you throughout this journey don't despair because your promised land dream has been terminated because every one of us has a journey and we never know what exactly our promised land is the third thing i want to say is a letter i received from somebody yesterday he listened to the first session and he just shared with me a letter and i got a similar letter from somebody else i want to combine and i'm just going to read it almost verbatim i just thought it was very meaningful dear rabbi jacobson i was married for 14 years painful and difficult years my former wife suggested that it's time to split we both agreed our marriage was just miserable therapy was not helping it was not working 14 years of pain a few hours later we called a reputable besdon with good and empathetic judges they gave us an appointment a few days later we met with the rabbis a few times once twice three times and then they realized indeed a divorce was inevitable i divorced her i gave her a get on friday night after the meal we asked the children this is the week before i divorced we asked the children to sit down comfortably on the couch and then we shared with our children our plans that we're going to be living in different homes it's sad i can almost cry but it's very moving and we told them that mommy will remain your mommy forever and ever patty will remain your tati forever and ever tati and mommy love you all forever and ever we will always be here for you but we came to a decision that it's better for us and for all of you that we're not together in the same home and then we let them ask all kinds of questions for hours they were just asking questions and we answered and we reassured them and we were friendly and civil to each other and i want you to know it was so difficult at the moment years later my daughter once called once came in to me and she told me she so admires how me and my ex-wife handled the divorce and then when she realized other kids from divorced parents and what they go through one of her friends she told us expressed to her that she never knew that a divorce could be peaceful and that people could be so mentioned to each other until she saw how my daughters parents who were divorced related to each other and until today whenever one of our children needs a doctor's appointment or needs a therapy appointment or needs clothes or needs help educationally or socially psychologically or spiritually we just make sure to know that even though we we cannot get along with each other but we communicate with respect and civility for our children it made a world of difference and i beg and plead all my colleagues despite the hate and despite the vengeance and despite everything this type of arrangement is possible it's what we owe ourselves our souls and our children thank you very much and i look forward to a very meaningful meaningful evening with all of you all right beautiful beautiful opening um we're going to go straight into questions um we have a lot of questions here and again everybody's here tonight the point of this year is to really ask your questions you could be vulnerable here we have reverend why why we have and we're here to just have a very open conversation we discussed already i'm going to read you know some of the stuff we did we know what we're what we're going for we spoke about some of the initial hurt the fighting investment we want to cover a lot of topics like feeling abandoned by former family friends feeling restrained from communities navigating the children's journey through the hold of divorce we're going to deal with parental alienation we'll touch on the topic what we're told to get the appropriate time to explore dating remarriage and now we're getting second marriages whatever we can cover of that tonight let's try to cover i'll start off with the first question we'll start with that and then hopefully um people are want to ask please text me right over here i'll sharpen this and we'll try to get your question on again a lot of questions go first i know i'm getting tons of questions but whoever could ask live first well i would ask i will go first and let's do that okay let's start with the problem you can go live without showing your face they can go live without showing their face all right change your name to my ex that's it or you could say you're asking for your friend that's right okay let's start with the first question when i was married i was very close okay so we're starting we're holding my family and friends turning us but let's we're gonna open it up to everything but let's let's start with that when i was married i was very close to my husband's family and even when we were there we were separated throughout the whole thing they were super supportive to me of being with me as the years went on they turned their backs to me and it hurts and they actually hurt me and my kids have bad-mouthed me where can i put this pain in my head well uh you know i i it's hard to understand what all the circumstances are but i would i would i would wonder if there was a change you know and it really means something still you know there's always the idea you could just walk away but if if somebody seems to have some kind of time on you if the narrative changed it might be worth asking uh perhaps it's it's it's very contentious i i don't know but the you know there's no way to get to the bottom of something without asking maybe you know oftentimes in families there's sort of one person that sort of is the go-between somehow able to stay connected to both sides it might be worth asking it seems as if there's been a change there's been a change in the air have i have i done something have i heard anybody is there something i need to know which i don't think is the same as admitting you know weakness or or admitting that you're wrong i mean obviously if you're wrong you could admit it but inquiring what people are upset about is to me you know a sign of strength and and decency um i i don't want to presume there's so many factors but when someone's out to get you if there can be civil enough that you could ask them what's going on it can be helpful yeah no i completely agree with hip simcha i would only add that you know it's important to reach out to the right person you know who is more mature who may have not been poisoned there may have been poison you know somebody may have fed some information right information or or wrong information and they have poisoned the family against you and it's very very sad but it's important to reach if it's possible if it's possible to reach out to somebody you know who's more who's who's mature who's intelligent who's who's empathetic and and say you know what you know did i do something wrong what happened what changed i agree and i would just add one thing and that is you may painfully find out that at the moment there may be nobody to talk to they may have been poisoned very badly there may have been some terrible terrible misunderstandings there may be contention beyond your imagination you may not immediately be able to find an easy solution and just go back to square one and that may require a certain form of grieving for precious relationships that were lost but remember whatever the response is you'll be doing the right thing by reaching out and trying to create peace trying to create at least some understanding and that you should be confident about and feel good about doing that what the result and how their response will be that we have to see if they don't if they don't answer anything if they were poisoned what would you tell this person to tell himself when he gets home well you know when bad things happen um in any type of relationship the best you could do is is uh ask yourself is there something you should have done and there's something you still could do and if there isn't then accept and it's you know the famous uh uh you know serenity prayer you know you you try to change the things that you can and accept the things that you can't and that it's important to understand that family dynamics is no such thing as non-communication non-communication is communication it's it's a very unfortunate form uh and highly problematic but the people refusing to talk to you the sad truth is that somebody feels that the problem is so bad or you are so bad that you can't be spoken to and i'm not trying to suggest in any way that those are the facts i'm saying those are the facts of how people feel and when that happens the best way to respond to communication is to hear it so if somebody's saying that that you are so bad that they can't even talk to you um you might try one last effort i think after a while not right away and say i get the sense that you feel that not somebody who you could talk to or solve any problems with because the closer you come to where the other person's at and what they're thinking and saying the more likely you can have a civil conversation you know there's no guarantees we don't know what's going on on the other side you can't account for another person's behavior but it is communication to not communicate all right that's what we talk about sunday communications exactly the share the learning communication there's one other thing i want to mention i have a live question on but there's also that concept of family blood stick in the water at the end of the day sometimes even if the person might know that you're not so bad or this net but there's you know they're they're they're your ex-mother-in-law what what do you want them to do you know does that like i have to deal with that is that that concept but they don't have to stonewall you they don't have to stonewall you i mean there's something called civil relationships i may not be we may not go out for coffee every wednesday afternoon right well but you're raising an interesting question um usher i'm wondering if if you know it's really hard just from a small sentence to to construct the whole cases but since there was originally some closeness and then it fell off it is a bit of a clue it could be that some other let's say the other child and you know instead of the child in law the child somehow felt like they weren't being given enough love and respect and there was some kind of like jealous like you either choose me or the other person and you know that's possible it might not be fixable at this point but it is an interesting thing that originally everything was smooth and then it went off it's definitely data something happened here okay let's go to some live questions a lot of people are interested please let's make it interactive you're on hi hi um okay um this is my question um um thank you everybody um when i was when i grew up my parents got divorced when i was much younger um and i have a lot of history in my family with that kind of stuff and my whole life i was very aware of that and i always you know like was like i don't want that to happen and then you know i got married and got divorced a few months later and i just wanted to know like three things first of all how do you live with yourself when you know you look back and it was like your your fault um that's my first question my second question is how do you not be like angry at god you know just yeah why couldn't make you in a different situation and my third question is how do you not feel cursed you know if like because these things tend to in certain families they just tend to keep happening over and over and no matter how hard you stop you know they can be continued thank you very much robbie whiteway i love your shiro thank you wow maybe take it i mean it's good i have both of you because there's questions for baldi rabbi can you can you go first please yeah um at least at least one response to this first of all i'm sorry for all the pain it's very difficult but let me just you know put it very bluntly and succinctly precisely because you feel that your family was and i'm saying this quote unquote cursed with this trauma and toxicity that's playing itself out generationally this means that this exactly is your mission it says in swarm this is a very big topic in kabbalah and hasidus and the musser that our souls have been here before many of our souls my soul comes down again how do i know for what and i have to see that which is the most challenging when i know that something is important for me and it's so difficult for me this means that this is part of the reason my soul came down to this world so i say to you my dear friend i know it's difficult but this is your chance me a day you have an opportunity to confront all this pain all this trauma all this dysfunctionality and ask yourself powerful questions with compassion and that is what can i learn from what happened in my childhood what can i learn from my own marriage and my own divorce what issues within myself do i have to confront and have the courage and the resolve to not surrender to any fear or shame and instead of using the tragedy to keep you down and to paralyze you and to make you feel guilty and hate yourself don't become a victim to that see it as an opportunity for unprecedented growth and renewal and rejuvenation ask yourself these questions okay let's say it was my fault i simply did not know how to be a husband and therefore it's my fault what am i going to learn from this what lessons can i glean from this and you have to be able to forgive yourself you have to be able to treat yourself with compassion walk away from this a new person with a deeper lesson you did your best you were given certain tools your tools were limited it's not all your fault you were given very very limited tools you came with a difficult package here it's part of part of it is a divine plan and therefore the most important thing is to take ownership of your past and your future you can't be perfect but you can be accountable and create a future with resolve and with courage in terms of anger at god what i would say very briefly is this is a big question a difficult question and we all deal with it and i say two things number one be honest with god like you're honest with your best friend with your closest therapist with your closest mentor talk to hashem like you talk to a friend share everything whatever you're feeling you put on the table you don't have to suppress or repress any emotion the presence of hashem you'll have a much healthier relationship with hashem and number two you have to understand with hashem as he told moisha you'll never see my face you'll see my back the cypher says it's very very hard to understand life as it's happening sometimes we can understand life you know 2020 hindsight is 20 20. sometimes we can understand life from hindsight and the point is it's very difficult to try to make peace at the moment with your journey when the journey is so painful what i would say to you is the anger is part of the normal human emotions but also remember that god is infinity and infinity by definition is not something i can wrap my brain around it doesn't have to make sense in my brain our journeys are so mysterious and our missions are so mysterious but can you trust can you just trust that somehow in all of this pain there is some meaning there is some purpose which you may not understand now and that's fine but you can just trust it and therefore tell god listen i really don't know what you're doing and why you're doing but i am trusting and help me just move forward and use my crisis as an opportunity well it's a there are a couple of things i i was just listening to what rally uh jacobson was saying and the you know it's fascinating how a lot of times like there's concepts in in in mysticism that are reflected just slightly differently in psychology but essentially the same it's like you know a base two numbering system or base ten numbering system like you're using different symbols to express a truth and it's it's interesting because you know what you talked about like whether it's you know on the on the level of gilgulem or it's just on the level of like this is your nissan um psychologically speaking there's something called the repetition compulsion which is that people unconsciously not because they want to fail see this is where it needs to be understood carefully they seek to recreate many of their past relationships because they want to do it again and do it right there's a very strong urge uh it's just a part just like people need to sleep people need to eat uh people need hugs there's a very strong drive deep within the human psyche to want to master to want to succeed and so that people oftentimes do unwittingly walk into situations that are very similar to past relationships but here's the but there is a a possibility to do it differently and oftentimes it works and sometimes it doesn't because human beings don't always succeed the first time at what they want to do you know chevy you both have to become but the point is that you may very well have sought out um at least in your first choice uh consciously or unconsciously somebody or some situation that has similarities to your family origin and it is the tickling you know to go through it um of course it'd be ideal to to go through it and and not end up divorced but you know no one really knows no one knows what happened no one knows all the circumstances the point is that there is some truth to that the other thing i would say which is also of an interesting combination of the you know the psychological and the spiritual we have this idea um you know that somebody does that if they do chuva you know completely sincerely uh then not only are the averages forgiven but there's there's and the truth is it makes no sense at first glance but psychologically it makes a lot of sense if i could take a minute to explain why that we are nothing uh right now based on our past we are simply what we are right now whatever we are right now is what we are we're not what the future is whatever the past is our consciousness and our sense of self is is something that's happening immediately and in in many ways we're constantly recreating ourselves granted we're using certain anchors from our past experience to tell us how we should interpret what's going on in the present but in reality the past simply doesn't exist and that the the issue about feeling guilty you know the quote uh we messed up i messed up with this i messed up with that i regret for this it's it's ridiculous because we simply are not what we were we're just not we are what we are right now and that this is um there's rafa colin which says something similar except again he's not using a psychological sprout but he says he says that basically when the reason why an average turns into digital when you do when you do chuva me alva is because if everything happens is god's will anyway so ultimately even though you're supposed to try as hard as you can to do the right thing if something in the end happens wrong it was god's will so the only thing that's missing is he didn't have the best of intentions so he says once you you know reach a certain level of drekus hashem then you had the right intentions so it turns into a mitzvah but listen that's a very complicated theological point but what i'm trying to say is psychologically speaking it we we define ourselves a great deal based on our past but it really means nothing it really doesn't you are exactly what you are right now for better for worse i already quoted mission conducion earlier there's another famous mission that all the you know famous bodily muslim you know quote where it's a person says uh uh you know the gomer right the mr says even if he's a russia we believe maybe he did shiva shemahira vachuva so it counts technically it's a marriage because he at that moment we don't know even though we see him eating a cheeseburger afterwards he was you know he really was a tonic and all the you know the london asked what do you mean and what about the three steps of chuva you know you know how did he do that in one second so the answer is it wasn't he wasn't forgiven he just was simply a different person at that moment at that moment he was its addict and if you can understand what i'm saying regretting the past is only useful it's it's an instinct like any other instinct like when you come near the stove and and it's hot and your hand pulls away or or like when your nose is tickled and you sneeze but it also you know you can have terrible allergies instincts can go awry and get overly triggered regret is a very important instinct because it gives us the ability to look back on our decisions and trying some way to throw it into the into that big black box up here that we have really no idea what's going on trust me we have no idea what's going on we throw more information in there and hopefully the next time when when we ask for input a wiser answer comes out hopefully and that's all you got that's all you have so you you might have done mistakes um and you could feel bad about that if you'd like to for a bit but the most important thing is what you are right now and life is truly dynamic whatever's gonna happen based on the decisions you make now is far more important than anything that that happened in the past far more important regrettable possibly but not really important wow beautiful okay we have so many questions here let's go you're on live hi okay i just wanted to first of all thank you it sounds like an amazing prep for what i'm going through my question is in my in my case i have children that are um they're they're they're going through a really really difficult time during my divorce um i would say that my ex and i are not on the same page he did not want the divorce i had to get out because i was getting very sick in the divorce uh in the marriage and now he's you know he's he's sharing to our friends all kind of stories about um why we got divorced and people come back and tell me this is what he's saying about you and you know it kind of pinches but it's okay i'll i'll be okay but the things that he's telling my children really hurts me and i find that it's kind of breaking them so me as the parent chooses not to talk about him and why i got divorced how do i how do i give them strength how do i get them through this time so that they're not breaking and they can get by this difficult time i i don't mean to presume to speak before you rabbi jacobson you you want to comment on that okay all right so you know i think that some situations are just regrettable and unfortunate and you can't control um what your spouse is going to do but i i will say that in the long run a lot of these things are about the the long game versus the short game and maybe later tonight depending on other questions there'll be more to talk about that whole long game short game mentality but the bottom line is that you want to communicate to your children um you know that that you have a relationship with them and what goes on in your relationship with them is sacred each one and nobody else has any say in that for good or for bad just nobody else defines that relationship oftentimes um differentiation which is a psychological term but you know a very quick uh cliff notes version of it is you know the ability to see each person distinctly and not to get overly anxious in the presence of somebody else or needing to make somebody else into something that they're not because it makes you uncomfortable and and differentiation is a very key psychological skill and it would be no surprise that people that go grow through divorces if their relationship wasn't all that hot to begin with even if they were the picture of mental health if their spouse wasn't many many years of emotional development were lost during that time so it's a really tough thing to be able to differentiate but you can communicate that to your children and say listen what we have is between us and nobody gets to define that except except for us and that i'm not comfortable uh defending myself i'm not comfortable putting anything anybody down i just want to have the best relationship with you i want to have the best family with you i want when you're here in my house for you to feel the safest i want when you go out into the world that you feel my love with you things that i can't control i can't control and i would just thank you of course i second that i would just add probably the obvious and that is it's so important two things number one you have to take care of yourself it's very important you need all the stamina and the vigor and the well-being physically emotionally psychologically you know don't see it as selfish and narcissistic you know give give your children a strong mother and and a strong person whether this includes you know your your your habits your exercise your your schedules when you wake up your hobbies but just pursue a lifestyle that that nurtures your neshama and your body and your mind so you could really be emotionally present for yourself and for your child because and your children because there is a challenge here and i think it's also so important to be able to give your children the confidence and the space to be able to know that in your presence they can just share everything and and you could be there for them to listen to them to validate them and not to judge them to be able to create a safe space where they can really manifest and express all their emotions all their feelings and you'll tell them i can't fix every you can't fix every situation you can't change your ex you can't change their father but what you could do is you can create a a womb that contains them and contains their emotions and contains their feelings and and remember they're gonna get older and and that relationship and that powerful connection um will not be forgotten wow okay there's a question that came in this we have neighbors going through a terrible divorce courts fighting police we really like both of them the issue is i'm having is that when my wife reaches out to help her she talks about all the horrible things about her husband and when i reach out to the husband he tells me everything about her how can my wife and i continue to help them without getting pulled into this whole fight yeah and i would say this is a great opportunity it's a great opportunity in a way and i know that's not your objective but to mentor them explain this to them you know you could maybe both sit down with her with him both of them perhaps separately or together that i don't know that depends on the relationship and really say listen we love you both you're both good people like all of us nobody is perfect this marriage is not getting along but we really don't want to take sides for us this is not about a fight and a contention we want to be here for you we want to be here for you and especially if these children that are so vital is so important so make sure that you create the proper boundaries that they should understand that it's inappropriate to pull you into a fight that is really negative and undesirable and toxic and and i think by by being firm kind but firm you'll be able to help them step away from the mindset of of vengeance and i'm gonna i'm gonna i'm gonna get justice you know one of our our great mistakes it's a normal mistake what great mistakes is that we fear that in the divorce i want to get justice i want justice to be met i want fairness to be experienced and really we can't always get justice what's more important is i want to create a bright future for me and my children i want to create a bright and the best possible future that is the key creating the best possible future beijing hashem for me and my children and by the way that means also for their other parent because children love both of their parents and if we could help them get into that mindset have good boundaries and remember don't get schlepped in let's not become the people who take sides and get enmeshed and entangled in a fight where both people are right and both people are wrong hey it's okay it's okay i'm gonna jump to the next question but i have another question also okay you're on live hi um i have to preface this by saying that i'm single i've never been married i don't have children my question is um i'm an older single too so in my age cohort um many of the men are divorced and i'm wondering you know like the the shirt the first fish shirt like the second soul mate by marrying a divorced man would i be missing out on my first soul mate would i be his second soul mate um how does that work thank you rabbi oh lucky me uh listen you know there's a beautiful expression in hummus honey staros la shemelo keno van nicolos londo which means there are elements in life that are really true but they're infinitely mysterious and you're touching upon one of them i i don't know that most of us certainly i can't make these calculations you know are you missing out on your real soulmate is this not your real soulmate did you have another soulmate and what happened with that soulmate these things are so mysterious exactly to know how god's plans with shidduchim and life this is a very very you know challenging question but i think it's beyond certainly most of us and as the famous expression that one of the great mystics said those who know don't say and those who say usually don't know well so so i don't know and i'm not going to say because i don't know but i think the most important thing is you know you have to ask yourself the real questions and relevant questions and that is is this a person with whom you feel you can hold hands for the rest of your life and build a beautiful home together is this a person who has good medicine is this a person who shares your values this a person who can compromise is this a person who's accountable who's real who's honest is this a person who will who you want to go on the journey of life together the fact that he was married before and he went through a divorce that could mean a hundred thousand different things you know maybe he became a better person as a result of that uh maybe he became much more self-aware maybe he's gonna be much more vulnerable and honest maybe not so i think you should really you know take it for some situations people marry divorce people and they have incredible relationships incredible i know them sometimes it's the other way around there's no one way to judge this and to define this so really you know examine the relationship and the person in a thorough take it easy take it slowly and and it may be a wonderful wonderful soul mate for you i would not just rule it out i just want to say one email i got this week i think it's relevant to this question and then we'll move on but it was very funny somebody sent an email and they said they read some place that the neshama and it goes up to ilum haber whom shia comes will be back with the original first person they married she writes rabbi why why how am i supposed to i couldn't live with him down here i kind of live with them up here up there so i wanna it's a great question i wanna make everybody aware that part of meshiach's coming is that everybody is going to be truly blissful and happy so don't worry god is gonna make sure that any soulmate that you have you are going to be blissful and overjoyed don't worry about it mashiach is going to have big bigger problems to solve and he'll certainly be able to solve this really don't don't be anxious about this okay the next live question you're on okay first thank you so much for this much needed discussion now robert jacobson spoke about being nice and not stigmatizing um divorced people what about helping someone who is not doing the right thing like he got upset that he needs to give a get and he's withholding it for no reason just for being mean how about people supporting such a type of person and being nice to him are you allowed to enable him to support him i'm sure you're waiting for me to answer the question right obviously do you want to speak first i mean i have what to say i i i would just say you know when if somebody's doing something they're obviously doing it for a reason that doesn't make it right but it means this person's involved in some kind of state of war they're holding on to something that they think is vital unfortunately war is a is is a very common human experience both on the micro level and on the macro level and people claim to never want it but for something that we never want we sure do a whole lot of it um so i'm not trying to tell you that this person's um innocent but it might be worth saying to the person listen you know your behavior on the outside seems quite inexplicable you know there's a there's a seer of that upon who are telling you et cetera et cetera i know you you know i'd like to think the best of you um you're violating the office so i can't really think the best of you but i'd like to understand you at least um and you know that might be a helpful conversation to have with the person because it might help them discharge some of their their frustration perhaps in having them talk out their position they might reconsider or realize that they're being a bit ridiculous whatever the case may be it's certainly worth doing um giving is an art uh the the there's a there was a talmud of refined beloved wrote a safer case casa roche about all the honors of of uh of rokheim and one fascinating things requirements says he says that that if you can't give tohoka nicely your potter your onus and his owners are going to patre your carts are from giving to if you don't know how to do it nicely the point is to hack is a complex arrangement asking the person why he's doing what he's doing telling him you'd like to understand because you'd like to judge them favorably is a very fine tokaja you know without telling them that they're that they're doing something that's really morally reprehensible anyway those are my thoughts and i would just add yes i agree with rip as the missionary tells us have he done his color adam lakovskos it's always important to be able to give people the benefit of the doubt and have a conversation with them and maybe listen to their frustrations their grievances um help them release as he said some of their anxiety and so forth and maybe that can bring things to a peaceful closure however sadly and i say this very very sadly sometimes there are good people therapists rabbis friends neighbors confidants who have tried this i'm one of them who have tried this with certain individuals for months and months and months listen listen listen validate but somehow certain individuals will stubbornly stubbornly cling to their position and will refuse to give a get to their wife sometimes it's the other way around i think most times it's one way around but sometimes also the other way around i don't want to you know stigmatize one gender or the other gender and this is a very tragic situation why is it maybe it's mental illness maybe it's some crazy deep trauma that is unresolved maybe there's just so much pain so much pain the person can let go of it you know sometimes narcissistic person i'm not here to i'm not a psychiatrist i'm not going to diagnose but sometimes could be real you know real narcissist narcissistic personality disorder or a combination of many many different things but sometimes literally there's nothing nothing doing and it's important to be able to acknowledge that and then i think it's critical it's critical to follow through with the community joining forces according to the guidance of and not becoming an accomplice to this type of abuse i have in my show somebody who has not given his wife a get for more than five years and i'll tell you by nature whoever knows me knows i i don't like i've tried to avoid conflict like the plague worse than the karo like a pandemic i try to avoid it in my personal and communal life and this guy came to every class he walked six miles on shabbos to come to my class usher that's good for the ego right feels good somebody walks six miles shop is morning to here to hear my class and a great student he would ask questions it also tells you he's one stubborn guy and if he puts his mind to something he'll do it so it tells you the need to go both ways exactly and a very wise student and i knew he was separated and then i started to hear the story and i listened for months and months and months and i validated and i was malama so and i thought rabbi why why with his you know with my skills i'll be able to peacefully get it done and everything you know i'll get it done and then i realized i'm also being sold to brooklyn bridge and i had to make a very difficult decision and i phoned them one day and i said listen i'll be the first one to give you a hug and extol your virtues from the pulpit after you give a get but till you give a get do not step foot into this shoe and do not step foot into my classes because i will become an accomplice of tormenting your spouse and tormenting your eight children who all stopped speaking to you because none of them have closure and between between us i feel that it's often a shanda and a disgrace of many of us rabbis teachers pedagogues community leaders activists laymen and lay women who don't want to take sides and want to be nice with everybody and we often stand idle as we watch the blood of innocent women and sometimes innocent men being spilled and that is unforgivable okay well you thought before you continue so where do they go now when they are dealing with this mental illness and this heavy heavy situation what i would suggest is first of all i just want to say one thing since i started to talk about it a bunch of people they don't stop bullying me rabbis i say this to all my colleagues rabbis teachers community leaders activists regular lay men and lay women lay leaders and all of us don't be afraid of bullies there are people who will bully you and threaten you i have been threatened and threatened and threatened i don't even mention names but i've been threatened with every conceivable threat in the world remember the balshemptiv's words that he heard from his father on his deathbed when he was five years old israeli don't be afraid of anybody or anything in the world but hashem and love every jew with all your heart those were the pillars that allowed the bolshevik to change the jewish world for eternity two teachings he heard from his father moments before he died don't be afraid of bullies the community must join forces all of us become accomplices to evil when we are passive and silent yes you have to make sure that right investigation was done don't dismiss people just because you're in a bad mood always be down the kaf's hosts make sure what's being done is according to with a real reputable besdon or dying we follow toyota we follow hashem as well it's not about personal vengeance but once the truth has been established the person walks into a bagel shop they should know they're not going to be given a bagel they're not going to get an alien show they're not welcome to the dinner or to the bar mitzvah or to the sherbrookes or the best even if they give the shul and the yeshiva a big check we all of us together can do this and just on a very practical level i would suggest to every woman and man who is dealing with such an impossible situation which i'm telling you it is so painful i i hear sometimes stories and i speak to the men they speak to me and i just i finish the conversation and i can literally start crying for half an hour feeling what this person has gone through in their marriage and now when they're trying to move on after their marriage it is so it is so it is so disturbing it is so tormenting and i would suggest on a practical level every woman deserves this she should have and we have to volunteer for this every woman who's struggling with this should have a committee it's not fear that she has to carry the burden after 10 years or 20 years or 30 years or six years of marriage now 24 hours a day she's being tormented by ah by either a psychopath or a child nephesh or a russian merusha whose cruelty or blame it on trauma whatever it's not here about judgmentalism but the cruelty is unbearable don't put it all on the woman she suffered already for 20 years she didn't have a normal night with this guy we all have to be there for i think every woman deserves a committee on that committee there should be a rabbi a therapist a lawyer an activist a community leader and anybody else and they should put their heads together and they'll get it done every woman deserves such a committee that focuses you can meet once a week once a month put their heads together you have different types of heads different types of expertise you have a businessman you have a lawyer you have a therapist you have a ralph you make sure everything follows and together every woman deserves such a committee we should all volunteer volunteer for this to every such type of woman we put our heads together and hashem they can be emancipated and released from the chains of oppression that have been holding them down for so long i just want to mention two things that somebody uh somebody deals with this a lot mentioned to me this week said also a lot of times with holding the guest sometimes is used out of contact they said there's a process in between that once the woman does her parts and let's say lets them see the kids those are things the best and possible time to give a gift it doesn't mean because the woman has forget that they got to get there's a process and we've got many questions here for a while i'm very familiar with this that uh people have wrote in you know my wife hasn't let me see the kids in a year that's true we have to mention that we have to mention that sometimes there are women who sadly are manipulating the situation they will not have the allow the husbands to see the child in years in years and his only leverage is to get so he has to really discuss this with a real competent besdon and diane to make sure he's following it's very very important so yes let's not just put the blame on one side sometimes there are women who their behavior could be very very very inappropriate in the sense and the husbands are desperate i have a man who came here sat here for three hours on my porch weeping he hasn't seen his child in years in years he gave a get actually he gave a get so i understand and i i'm really not being judgmental of any individual and not being naive to different cases and different situations but we have to remember as rabbis as jews all of us the main function of yiddishkeit the essence of toyota is as hillel said to be empathetic to those who are oppressed not to do to somebody else what we would like to be do what we would not like to be done to us and our children this is kolhatta hatarakula so the essence of tariq is to be able to be there for the vulnerable to be there for those who are being abused for those who are being tortured for those who are being changed for those who are being tormented women or men and the moment we start ignoring this and we talk about everything else in the world we are forfeiting our main role as jews which is to stand up for justice to stand up for compassion and to stand up for love and affection and to put a stop to all forms of abuse and torture i'm sorry to mention one more thing then i want to move on to the next question but the lawyer we had last week actually i had a talk with her afterwards she mentioned that she felt that a lot of women sometimes are so desperate again they give a lot of concessions in the divorce itself just to get that again she said like she just you know yeah you realize you're gonna get it again at the end of the day most people give gets you know you can't really do anything with that again unless you're not from but to give up concessions or money or whatever you want whatever you need just gonna get she just i just want to put it out there that's a red wife whatever and i think it's i think i think it's also important to understand it you know unfortunately and i'm going to say this bluntly and those people people are going to be upset at me but this is the sad truth and that is sadly there have been a number of rabbis who have behaved in inappropriate ways rabbis have to stand up for ms nothing else and the moment a rabbi allows corruption or bribery or agendas to seep in he not only forfeits his own right to be served on the rabbinate he desecrates the whole terror how many women and men have lost their trust in the rabbinate in yiddish guiding i get dozens and dozens of emails because they have seen so much politics so much corruption so much corruption the trade is all about ms and i want to say to everybody we cannot fool god you could fool me you could fool him you could fool her you could fool half the world or most of the world but the reborn is shalom nobody fools and when you torture a jewish woman you're accountable directly to hashem and every single one of us has to face god without lies and without without deceptions i think it's also important to understand just again for the sake of integrity it's important to understand a woman says i want a divorce she comes to them i want a divorce that doesn't mean right then she's a naguna you know if the husband says to the woman or the husband says maybe we should go to therapy let's work it out and there is good will and they're both willing to do that of course president has to investigate and see what's the appropriate path divorce is the last resort however when it's been established that divorce is inevitable for whatever reason but this marriage is non-salvageable and now the guy is holding back a get we all know what the rambam says in hilharyshin that there are situations in the time of the sanhedrin that they would physically physically coerced a person and there was a reason for it so today we don't live in that generation we don't live in that milieu but as a society we have to do whatever it takes to be able to stop this crime against humanity i'm sorry for my passion about this but i have just seen and heard too much and it's really extremely devastating and painful especially coming from people who are supposed to represent toyota you won that a woman should speak to irav and she should see in thereof a paradigm of somebody who will fight fight for those who are suffering and those who are vulnerable until his last breath and when you see the exact opposite it's extremely disheartening and we all have a part to play in reversing this this injustice let's get into the let's get into the kishkas now from club this is we're gonna get into the real uh real things that people deal with um we got a bunch of questions and conversions we try to really convince them let's just start with this a lot of live questions let's really try to get to it i want to say quickly but let's there's so much there's so much content here the question goes like this i'm the reliable parent i tend to each and every one of my kids needs as their children the father takes them once in a while let's not do the following but look at let's just say the father takes them once in a while i was fine with this up until now as they're getting bigger and have more demands and needs and wants they treat me like i owe them everything and instead of appreciating how much blood of my life have given to them they started telling them to ask their father i i started telling them to ask their brother to spend a day shopping or arranging some of their needs i feel like i'm the losing martyr what could i do now should i the question is basically i did this over the years that has to get bigger since she's the balacharias they turn against it because they expect everything from her so how should you deal with it what the heck is it that you can get from that hearing the story sometimes when you're in a situation you feel that your situation is unique because of what you've gone through like if somebody uh you know has corona and then they get a headache they say oh you know i have this headache because i had corona which could be true but actually some of what you might be describing might happen in very typical nuclear families that um you know as as your children get older you're you're coming to reconsider perhaps in some way you cater to them too much and now you're trying to figure out how can you develop a more of a of an adult reciprocal relationship with them and that i'm not so sure i mean obviously there are going to be many complicating factors uh when when there's a situation divorce and also the way it's being described is the other parent is kind of the you know the one that just swoops on in and buys the you know 400 sneakers or video games or whatever but i think that that might be helpful to look at it instead of from the perspective of this is a unique problem for somebody who's divorced and look at it as an actual negotiation process it probably happens with a lot of parents and children and particularly mothers who tend to be more nurturing you might reach a point in your life of your own emotional development that you're realizing you know that you um maybe two people pleasing or it could be that what you gave as a lot of reflexive unconditional nurturing love when the kids were younger you were hoping somehow that would automatically like morph developmentally into them realizing that now it's time to pay it forward so to speak and maybe not and maybe those are really important conversations to have to say that that um not in a you know there's a fine line between complaining and problem solving uh you know you can almost use the same words but they can sound so different right like i feel like i'm treated for granted i feel like you know i'm just a walking atm machine i feel like i'm the maid um you know those are all things that certainly are legitimate feelings but they're not the best way to go about problem solving the way to go about problem solving is look you're getting older and soon you're going to be accountable to other people to bosses to a spouse and we need to talk about what it feels like around here right now it feels to me like i'm doing a lot of work and that you're not appreciating enough you're not working with me enough we need to talk about expectations and also i'm very open to hearing i i you know if you think i'm being unfair or you think i'm withholding something that you're deserving we should talk about that too of course there's complications because there's two parents and maybe i feel this one is your is your father's responsibility to you know to to manage and i might need to put my foot down there but we should talk about it so what i'm trying to say is to make a long story short is i'm not so sure i'm sure it's more complicated because you're divorced but this may be a a a rather common theme that a lot of parents particularly mothers have to go through with their children as they you know progress through adolescence uh hi all right first of all first of all i have to tell you a huge thank you and that you give khazak to many people me included um so i'm wondering when i went through the divorce process i desperately wanted it to happen in the friendliest way possible specifically because i have always been very close to you know my ex's family siblings and parents and all that and um for reasons that i'll never understand they have decided to completely shut me out and uh you know sort of treat me as you know invisible whether it comes to joint events like a kid's graduations or simchas or you know to the extent where a young child of mine was able to leave one of her possessions in my ex the stronghold's house and there was no way i was getting a bag because you know messages and this get ignored so on a two-prong question and i'm curious how do i deal with the with the grief and the loss of that when people they used to be close to completely shut you out and then it some way affects the kids because they see it how do you deal with that well you know i think that obviously to some extent you can't control what another person is going to do and i i believe you if that helps any i believed you that you wanted to make everything as peaceful as possible um unfortunately this it's hard for some people because ultimately even if the divorce is under the most you know friendly circumstances it's very injurious emotionally um it's a huge rejection for you as well even if you even if i have no idea your personal circumstances even if you were the one who initiated or even if you were the the one who was relatively healthy and just just needed to be done the point is it still is a terrible terrible injury emotionally that that that people suffer and that leads to sometimes some really you know spiteful behavior because people are trying to get back uh their dignity get back what belongs to them and there isn't i don't think that there's a lot that you can do i mean you could of course ask and and hope if there's a way that things could be more cooperative but you if the person you divorced you had to divorce for various reasons that they couldn't manage and communicate well and then on top of that you you also have tried to keep things very you know it's very cooperative and it still doesn't work it is just something that is is probably more more that you have to accept and and it is awful you could always they're trying to say listen i'd love things to go better do you have any grievances are there things that you feel that that that are still owed to you you know sometimes fights are continued because people rightfully wrongfully feel like you know they deserve something still something was stolen from them you know do you do you feel in some way in other ways i was unfair to you and that's why now you know you're dragging your feet when it comes to the child support or or when it comes to something else and you know you're not you're not obligated in any way uh by the way to you know to do that because you're divorced you know you don't have to be so nice and so accommodating but you could ask it might open up some doors the person might be carrying some old resentment that you don't even realize or felt that something was done it's a tough it's tough i wish i had easy answers in these situations and sometimes i would just say sometimes you may even do that you may open a door for for a conversation it may be rejected maybe shot in your face or it may open up of a catalyst for for for you know for some type of relationship even if not you know the warmest and the best and then sometimes nothing works and we really have to grieve and grieving is is is part of the process it's part of what we go through in life when we lose something that's very precious like dr foyer said earlier about amputation you know if i ever if i have a close relationship and that relationship is destroyed and crumbles there is grievance grievance i you grieve and you cry and it's painful and it's sad we we lost something we lost something very precious they're sweet memories it means a lot to us and i think then from that grievance and from that pain without avoiding it and without ignoring it we feel it and we have compassion for it and then we say and now what you know i i i go back to the metaphor of the broken tablets you know the marshall says that the reason we break a glass under the hoop is because maisha broke the luchas that were the marriage contract between the jewish people and hashem and what did they do with the broken pieces they didn't get rid of them they didn't even put them in sheamus the broken pieces were placed into the holy ark and the kaido shakodashim and the holy of holies and many of our luchas break and that's our marriages our relationships with our in-laws our ex-in-laws brothers-in-law sisters-in-law nephews nieces and it's it's grandparents ex-grandparents it's very difficult it's it's a part of life that may have been very sweet and very promising especially if they're nice people and it's been broken and and and you have to be able to grieve we all have to be able to grieve and you don't judge grieving it doesn't have to look a certain way it could look very painful and very sad and then from that space of honesty and compassion and grief we pick up the broken pieces and we place it in our holy of holies and we realize that from this we will have a new awareness and a new calling about how to move on in our life with with deeper sensitivity and deeper empathy and more love and more light as we embark on new relationships and new friendships and we open ourselves up to new opportunities okay there's a question that came in here how do i best support my child when they're experiencing rejection from their parent who doesn't show up for scheduled visitation without sounding negative about their appearance it's a tough one and it's a and it's a uh not uncommon i think that there's a statistic that after five years after five years of divorce i think that only 40 of dads have a continued relationship with their children wow that quite a number i i hope like many other things that i hope that in the firm world that's a little different but that is you know that's a powerful statement um it's tough you really you know a lot of times when you're going through divorce and you're divorced you're you're alone and if the urge is so strong to want to um get some support from your children have them at least you know understand uh understand you and and and see you as not the bad person and here you know it's not even that here my gosh the the evidence is right in front of your face it's it's hard not to say something but you know all you can say is that that is that um we we have each other you know we love each other we take care of each other we're a family i don't know what's going on with with tati or mavia again i'll try to keep a gender gender neutral though you know we can we can understand how it might be more towards one gender than another for all kinds of reasons not necessarily bad ones um but the point is that it you know we can't i i really i really can't explain it i don't know how to explain it i can just tell you that we have what we have we have our love we'll always have it and if he's not here tonight and he's not showing up let's let's plan an evening let's let's let's move on and and have what we can have that's that's it and if you know the child complains um no you really can't shut a child down but it's quite a temptation for you to do more than just listen but you have to do your best to say listen that is really tough i really cannot explain tati's behavior i i wouldn't i just would say i know it's tough and and again we have you have me and you have our love and if you have your siblings you have your siblings sabotage bobby's 80 whatever yeah that's that's tough one and then then the other side claims parental alienation because when i don't come to pick them up they go out for supper right you have to be careful you have to be careful first of all they're real legal uh ramifications parental alienation is considered abuse um in in some situations actual abuse um but you know it makes a very big difference you could communicate that you're here to support the relationship in every which way you communicate that to your spouse you say listen if you go a half an hour late and and shloimi is an inconsolable mess i'm going to take him out to ice cream i'm sorry that's what i have to do but if you want to make a makeup you know i'm not here to to be some kind of um uh uh you know overly captain type of person the main thing is your relationship with slimy i'm here to support it i i can't if he you know show up half an hour late and he's falling apart i got to do something you know and but i'm not out to hurt you and you really have to communicate that even if you want to hurt them it's perfectly fine that you want to hurt them but you can't communicate that and not only that if you really try not to because there is a line alienation is alienation there's a difference and and you can't do it and um it's very hurtful to the children and it's um it could end up you know even selfish they could end up biting you very badly too because it can be proven it takes time but it can be proven a pattern of alienation hey i have a lot of life right why would you like a live one yeah okay you're on thank you so much for this panel this is truly amazing i've been divorced for about seven years now and i wish seven years ago a panel like this didn't exist um i have a question which is similar to the alien nation question now what do you do if you're being accused of parental alienation and you're really trying to do the opposite uh help foster positive relationship with the other parent and it's really the other parent who is who has a lot of changes in their life that is affecting the way the children are behaving during the visitation or refusing to go to these visitations um if you've tried more than once communicating with the other parent trying to give them um helpful suggestions as to how they can improve their relationship or reconnect with the kids but the parent keeps insisting that the problem is in them the problem is really that you're convincing them not to go you're the you're the problem um when in fact you're really trying to help foster that relationship i'm going to say a couple of things um don't construe it as legal advice because i'm not a lawyer but some that might border on on at least things that are common sense legally you'll have to treat the fact that you know it's being alleged that there's parent alienation and also the fact that there's a dysfunction right whether or not it's alienation you're describing a dysfunction with the other parent and and your children you have to treat that like there's a hole in the roof of your house when you have a hole in the roof of your house um you don't sit around and say wow we have a hole in the roof of the house that's a really awful thing we should call the fire department we should call the police we can call lawyers you fix the hole you get mobilized and you say this is unacceptable because you can't let the rain come into the house now i'm not suggesting in any way please that that you're not doing that what i'm saying is you need to communicate with a lot of vigor to whoever's involved if you have professionals involved if maybe there's a therapist you're working with who could contact your spouse or to contact the spouse directly if you can that you are not okay you are absolutely 100 not okay with a filled relationship between your child and your spouse um the the you know the spouse might feel you're being passive aggressive somehow you're unconsciously sabotaging the relationship you can get into all that we can explore all that um i i'm doing everything i can for that not to happen there are things you don't realize you're doing you're disappointing the children you're frustrating them you're scaring them whatever it is i've seen it all you know in my work but i'm saying you communicate that you will not accept this that this is a problem that must be solved not that not that there's alienation and not that your spouse has a problem because either of those two are too accusatory but you say this is a problem that you cannot successfully have a relationship with with our children and we must fix it we must do whatever we need to do i'll go to two therapists together with you i'll go to six rabbis i don't care you might think i'm alienating i don't know i'm open to input but right now the main thing is you should know is i will not tolerate it just like you won't tolerate it just like i won't tolerate a hole in the roof of our house reigning in i will not tolerate any anything that stops you from having a relationship with our children you've got to come across strong and there that might be hard to do because you might not have a partner uh not a not a self-aware partner but it's important to try but i think yeah no i would just ask what if the guy is say has a real personality disorder or as a real trauma victim or has a mental illness nobody speak to i'm asking right so obviously there is nobody to speak to it's like it's not like we're having a conversation he's like no you're you're you're the worst person you're the worst mother i'm gonna see you in court and sue you for nine million dollars yeah listen there are all kinds of people and and certainly there are going to be extremes you know even personality disorders are they're not like it's it's not like a disease like there's an antibody test as if even the antibody tests are totally accurate but it's not even though there's like tests oh this person has a personality disorder people operate in all kinds of ranges of behavior and all kinds of times most people at least some of the time can be reasonable so i'm saying the energy that comes across when you say i i am aggrieved that you don't have a relationship with your child i don't want to tolerate it is helpful is the other the other person's you know a maniac if they're not negotiable well you know you just make sure you're taking a lot of notes that that you're doing all this and you say listen i'll go to your therapist i'll go to your rep i'll do whatever we need to do i want you to have this relationship i'm you know there's stuff i got to tell you i got to give you feedback you do things that scare the kids you do uh you know if that's what it is we can talk about it but i'm not here to stop you from having this relationship and you know if the person really is is out is really unbalanced i i suppose it needs to be discussed in you know some kind of co-parenting in some kind of a therapy environment where it could be assessed and dealt with and it's not easy um but the end is you know short of the children being abused obviously if they're abused you know you have to go through whatever channels one does to to to make sure they're not being abused and to document that but you know short of that listen you know when you're married children have to put up with some kind of crazy parents also i mean all of us at times might be crazy parents the point is children are very resilient it might not be the best visit um it might not be great but it also might be still apparent and so long as it's not really putting the child in danger it still might be something you need to encourage and do your best to you know to support and check to make sure the child is not you know suffering incredibly but of course these are challenging situations but i would say you know everybody thinks that they're that their bar plug is the most unreasonable sociopathic you know crazy person and i can't say it's not true some of the time but you have to be aware because it's a lot less it's a lot less true you know than if then it feels a lot of time travel i'm gonna go okay there we go can you hear me yes um thank you for taking my call um i'm i had a good marriage um the last seven years of my marriage was um i was a caregiver to my husband who took mentally ill it was a sad um divorce because of that um i've been divorced now for five years three years ago i moved to a um a base an army base on top of a mountain in the middle of the desert and so there's no community around me at all so my my question is um i get very lonely at times and i i almost feel ashamed to say that at times i feel that hashem is not enough for me and that i need i need something more and i don't know how to reconnect to god when i feel melancholy like that where because hashem should be enough for me i don't know why hashem should be enough for you all the rest of us humans need lots of friends and family and love and support um no offense to hashem uh in any way i just you know obviously i don't know your situation but it sounds like you're awfully lonely and it sounds like you know if you needed to do this work um uh serve your country i don't know whatever it is sounds amazing um just as soon as possible you have to be realistic hashem is not enough no it's always enough if you're a model but not if you're a human being you need a lover you need a friend you need your family you need your community i mean as as as soon as possible even if you can't solve it now to know that you're canalogy and that's a real need and that you're going to move towards solving it i mean that's vital why yeah i mean again i don't know your arrangements but maybe maybe we had say once a month or twice a month for shabbat you can go to a jewish community and and maybe be with somebody's home i don't know if you have family or friends or old neighbors or maybe relatives or you could no i'm i'm i'm in the middle of nowhere right now so for me to to go anywhere it would be you know minimum of a three to five hour drive to get to a community that was could you like go once a month maybe like like maybe a shul a community a haban house another community that works for you maybe relative i don't know like once a month maybe just to be able to rekindle that uh human touch but it's more than just a human touch i mean i i can go for a um a holiday for chivas i could go to to the you know i could drive five hours spend the weekend but yet it's not it's not filling me up and that's why i am saying that there's there's something missing and i i don't know how to get that back right well do you like people do you like people or you never you you're always fine with god alone no i i like people i like being around people i was a i was a social butterfly before so maybe as soon as possible like rip somehow said you can try uh moving in that direction but even before then even before then you know don't give up on yourself you know maybe pursue a hobby maybe write a journal spend time in nature discover the art of prayer of song of meditation maybe communicate through zoom on the telephone email whatsapp social media communicate with people create a blog create a social become part of a social community i mean i myself have classes on zoom a few times a week you're welcome to join there's a lot of people live there you're welcome to join the coach menachem and usher every sunday night there's a lot going on there's a lot going on in on zoom they say gum zum letova so seize the moment even before you could physically relocate seize the moment and hashem should guide you in the right direction and find the peace and fulfillment that you need okay let's get into more questions over here there's so much more to cover everywhere you ready yeah grab my tip right away i take a leader on this one if you don't mind my ex-wife uses the kids as pawns all the time it goes something like this tell your father you don't have enough clothes if he loves you he would give you more money to pay for things she plays all these mind games and then the kids repeat it to me i'm not sure the best approach to handle these kinds of attacks coming directly from my children to me wow so first of all i'm sorry this is this is tough so i would just i would just give three messages message number one is it possible in a kind but very authentic respectful but firm way communicate to her either directly or maybe through a friend or through a good messenger who will get the message through and that is you know you may have you may have very very negative opinions about me and i'm not judging it at the moment you know whatever you know between our marriage didn't work out after everything said and done but you know i'm just thinking about myself you know if i would find out that my father doesn't like me and my father doesn't love me it would be so painful for me like let's think about the children it's really so not good for the children to really feel that their tati doesn't love them so even if you know you have so much against me and and maybe you're a thousand percent right maybe you're not but can we get that message through to her like just of the kind there you know what are they gonna gain by feeling that their mother loves them and their father despises them could somebody get that message through to her i mean that would be wonderful number one number two um i think the bottom line is as follows i can't control her i could try to persuade i could try to influence and we should we should try to influence in a positive way but i ultimately can't control her so i would say generally be the best parent you can be don't get involved in any dispute or competition with your ex i can't stop her or in other cases him from doing what they do i cannot keep the kids away from the other parent and i don't want to unless they're being abused so i have to leave it but i want you to think about the possibility of being an amazing parent giving it all you got with with stamina and vigorous sincerity create a deep closeness with your children and hope and pray that your kids make the right choices but don't stoop down to your ex's level and make this a fight you'll show me i'll show you i'll get even with you i'll get justice i'll i'll i'll i'll take revenge i'll show you who's stronger i'll show you who's more powerful i'm tempted to do that we're tempted to do that we're human we're vulnerable we're frail we get outraged we get overwhelmed it's like i want to do xyz i got that but it really doesn't help us it really doesn't help us i always want to focus on my target what's your target keep your eye on your ultimate goal what's your ultimate goal creating the best possible future for me and my children creating the best possible future for that they need an amazing parent they need a parent who's close to them who listens to them i'm gonna try to influence her myself or through a friend to be able to stop this venomous talk about me because it really doesn't help but till that point and even if i can't get through i can't always change the other person i'm not gonna fight back i'm not gonna besmirch the other person i'm not gonna have them lose their father and their mother but i'm gonna i'm gonna be there from i'm gonna be there and i'm going to be an amazing amazing parent i may have to sob at night for the pain and the grief and i'm going to open myself up for them to be able to feel secure in our relationship and that they can vent and express whatever they need to express and i'm going to create i'm going to create space for that if i may i just wanted to add something i think that's very important and it's relevant to probably a lot of other questions too which is the other side which is talking to the children i i think it's fair to say to the children of course you know we're painting a very broad brush there's different ages different ability to conceptualize but in in in a pleasant but firm way to say listen if you need something i have no problem with you asking me for something respectfully and you know if i can give it to you i will genuinely give it to you if if i cannot i'll tell you if you really feel strongly that you still should get it i could we can discuss it i'm not comfortable with you delivering messages you know from from from tati or mommy that that doesn't work for me and it's really not healthy for you either if you need something ask yourself is it really something that you need and that you want and of course if you didn't want something i'm always interested and we could discuss that but be very careful not to you know say it in the other person's name because it's not really about that it's about what you need or not need and it gets very complicated and i think that that's something you know obviously depending on the age of the child that you could start to communicate and set those boundaries and say that it's not uh the child is not the person in between say i don't want you to be the person between you know if if mommy or tati thinks you need new shoes that's fine they could speak to me about that if you think you need new shoes think about it and ask me for new shoes and let's talk about it okay somebody just texted me these questions another alienation question but i want to get into that a little bit a lot of people are texting me these different things how do i explain my kids without losing respect for me that their father or for me that their father is trying to desperately make them believe i no longer examine existence i can't text them call them or email them because he just ignores me i'm blocked from his phone and he doesn't read my emails one of the kids told me that he's trying to make them believe that his wife gave birth to my kids how do i explain this to the kids without killing them the ultimate alienation i'm trying to understand the scenario the kids live with the father the father is remarried and it seems like the father has mostly custody or they live by him full time and any time she tries to reach out whether via email or phone or whatever she does she seems like she has very little contact and the father makes it impossible and basically trying to convince the kids the mother doesn't exist well you know how can you explain that to the kids you have contact with the kids i'm a little confused not trying to be like uh you know uh giving out a glib answer i think she does it but she has very little contact very she has very little contact okay during those moments how should she handle it like assuming she has they think that she doesn't want more contact basically right they think he's alien he he's she's telling them that she's not interested in them besides let's say once once in three months that's what i understood i i suppose it would be to find out what the children genuinely want say listen do you want to have more contact with me if you do i'm here for you if you don't it's probably not the best thing for a child to have no contact with their parents so the adults might think differently uh but i first want to know what you want do you want to have more contact with me that would probably be the most important thing to say and then to figure out how that gets solved i mean some of this just sounds like legal um sorry to say it sounds some you know like if you're being deprived of your rights but on the other hand for some reason legally this is what was engineered that's awful um i i hope or maybe or maybe maybe there was no legal procedure and you have to find out what are you legal there's a lot of parents whether it's a father mother usually the father that have minimal contact with their kids for whatever reason it may be whether he went through a hospitalization or he he lived out of town for a long time there are parents that have that scenario so let's say in such a scenario where the other parent is really trying to fully alienate the parents trying to really make it impossible when you have that little moment with the child how do you make it i mean as i said you start with the kid you say listen i i uh there's a lot going on over here not all the time i'm able to see you but i want to start with what do you want do you do you are you satisfied with how much for a meeting do you want to meet more and like i said there's a difference between engaging and collaborating with the child versus giving over control like if the child says no and whatever you do is you could say well let me put somebody live on now okay okay sure hi i was the one who asked the question yes um okay it was a little misunderstood we have we have joint custody i the kids live by me and they go to him for visitation we have that the problem is that any type of communication um is not done if i ever have my kids will ask me could you just text him could you just ask him and how do i tell my kids um i really can't because i'm blocked from his phone i really can't because i can't communicate with him he doesn't answer me um anything that he wants to do he'll just do directly with the kids communicate directly through them and as if i just don't exist i do see my kids i'm very close with my kids we have a good relationship but this has been coming up lately a lot more since he remarried and like one of my kids told me he's trying to make believe his new wife gave birth to all of us and we don't exist anymore i don't want to i don't want to kill them and i don't want them to disrespect him to judge to judge him a bit favorably which is not to say at all that i'm judging him favorably what i need to say is to understand his motivations as something less than completely maniacal and unhinged it might be you know that he's struggling very much uh to create you know this bond with his wife and that his wife somehow another is threatened by you or finds you to be intrusive and again i'm not saying that's true i'm saying that it's it has a little bit of that feel there might be a way somehow for some intermediary to defuse it and say look if the issue is that somehow your wife doesn't want me communicating with you that that this creates some kind of you know discord no hasta shalom i don't want to cause that you know you should you should live and be happy and be married you know over another 120 years somehow though i do need a system of communicating with you so that we could have an orderly uh you know process of collaborating on the parenting if you want to limit it to email if you want to use some kind of uh designated middleman or third party but to communicate you know that that that you might be willing to understand that there's something going on here because it does sound like there's something going on you know does that mean let me it makes sense let me just add he is he is an addict and he's an alcoholic so there's not the the brain function is a little bit you know distorted over there um in terms of communicating you know you said via email i spent thousands of dollars with an attorney last summer for hit up he wanted to set up a specific email that that's the one that i should use we went through our attorneys and we set it up and within a month he let he let our mediator know that he's no longer going to be using that email to communicate he's not very um cooperative when it comes to anything like that i do have a phenomenal attorney she was actually on here last week um and she you know we're trying she's trying maybe through the court system i i hate fighting and i hate going to court and i have no interest in this my my bigger concern is my children how do i make sure that they are okay through all this without getting killed by it i i see especially my son he does idolize his father i never talk bad about their father to them i believe that children as long as the parents aren't abusive children should have a relationship with both the mother and the father so i and i encourage that with my children i really do but seeing this because we are you know my son will come and just when i want to hear from my wife so far on this let's globalize because alienation is a major topic and i know a lot of parents here tonight go through this in different variations and forms first of all it's very painful you know i know you don't need to hear that for me but it's very very painful it's it's difficult and yiddish is an expression sir is the hearts it it it tears one's heart open it's very difficult and you know i think you're trying to do whatever you you can through a mediator it sounds like you know you're really going above and beyond and you're very peaceful and civil as you said the last thing you want is a fight and i think sometimes we just have to trust you know we have to trust our children and trust god like our children are going through a traumatic event it's difficult and i think you know what we can do most is just they should feel that we're here for them and that we have no answers and solutions to all the problems but that the relationship is so powerful and what we know today i think in healing is that when people know that the relationship is so powerful consciously or unconsciously it gives them the physique the strength to know that they could withstand the tsunamis that come their way if i feel deeply connected how do i give that over to my children so i think you give it over to your children in two ways number one by just consolidating your relationship with them as much as possible that they should be able to feel safe in your presence that they should be they feel understood that they feel your pride in them on unconditional love and an unconditional pride in them they feel you know how much you you validate them and and it's a really safe space in your dalaramis in your presence and that relationship itself when it's strong it just gives them an internal compass and an internal stamina and an internal spine and backbone to be able to deal with those things in their life that are in flux and that are not stable and obviously if this guy's an addict there's a lack of stability there and to be able to talk about the fact that you know mommy doesn't have the solutions to all the challenges you know i go all of us go through hard times but but we're here for each other forever unconditionally and you know all of your needs i'm here for you i'm trying the best you can if you have a suggestion or you feel something could be done this way you know let's do it this way but you can be honest that i don't have a solution for all the problems but you know we're doing the best we can and you know let's just try to communicate as often as possible direct as possible and whatever your needs are you know please articulate them to me and i'm i'm just here for you i think that's uh that's that that's so that's so important and and really trust their resilience you know a lot of times and i want to say this generally divorced parents especially often the couples the the the husband and the wife who are now divorced drift away hashgraphically religiously sometimes the husband becomes secular it's very common or at least a lot less religious than he was sometimes it's the other way around and parents are so worried you know we had a unified home and a unified front and a certain type of and the house at certain standards and now suddenly there's two homes with opposite standards and i can't change that i can't change my ex-husband i can't change my ex-wife i can't force my standards on them and we have to realize that these children are open to things that other children are sometimes not open to but their yiddish right is also going to be much more real and much more premium and much more authentic because they are not going to be able to just you know the conveyor belt you know just fly through the system they're really going to have to work things out it's going to have to be real and genuine and we have to trust hashem we got to dominate we got to believe in these kids we have to be able to communicate to them openly and we have to realize that their journeys are different journeys just like our journeys are different evening sharma has its journey and we want to hold on to them and give them all the careers that they need as they grow up they should be able to make the best choices for their for their future and trust that and and have bettah and realize that we can't control everything and that's that's part of their journey and it wasn't our choice this is part of the they their have their journey but you know what they're going to emerge on the other side often much stronger much deeper much more authentic and let's face it the future leaders of the jewish people are people who have been tried and people who have been tested and people who have endured trauma because let me ask you anybody who really really helped you in your life and anybody who really gave you empathy in your life were they not people who went through pain themselves so it's these types of children and these types of people who go through pain who become leaders and mentors and beacons of light and ambassadors of of resilience and love i think we'll go to the next live one to follow up on this one then we'll get into it you're on live okay thank you so much for taking my question um i guess just to preface it i have two incredible children which almost and um and personalities are really incredible and very inspiring to me um but uh every so often um they'll go come home or they'll call me and they'll tell me about how you know their mother gave them non-kosher food or they went on vacation they had this non-kosher food um and i guess my question is is how how do i react to my children they're not yet barbaso mitzvah um and so i know that their mother is responsible for them but at the same time i don't know how to be honest with my children um i tend to just brush it off or say you know it sounds yummy or just tell them that i love them so much no matter what um but i don't know if that's the correct approach to uh to it and in addition to that in our parenting agreement it does specify that we're supposed to raise the children orthodox and in a kosher home we did so when we were married and you know all their our entire extended family you know lives in uh from lifestyle so when when approaching the the um our parent coordinator um again the rev pretty much said he wasn't sure really what there's much to do the mother's gonna kind of do what she's going to do there's not much we could do to control it how would you uh how would you suggest to approach my children and if i should how to approach um my ex i just wanna i just wanna jump into here this we got this question in many different versions just letting you know like you know one parent became not from dealing with it psy and one of the questions also about i want my kids to have nothing to do with them i want to alienate the kids because the person's not from so this is a global question everybody if you can go first and rip some cliff you can follow up if we could do it that way yeah this is a difficult one as usual we always try at the onset to be communicative and to try to create the best you know ideal resolution and that is is it possible for you or a mediator or a friend of the family or somebody who is wise and sensitive to be able to communicate to her you know it's difficult enough to raise children even in a married home where everybody is married it's not easy to raise children on any day you know even on a good day certainly when there's a divorce there are more challenges but at least if they can be given you know values that are more unifying whether in terms of yiddishkai tyre mitzvahs shabbos conscious it's just a little easier for them and now to create a new point of contention you know it's really contrary to our agreement and is this really what we want to you know split the children in half you remember i spoke about shlaine muhammad saying let's split the child in half it's not just physically sometimes it's emotionally and i'll split them cut them between two different lives is there a way of of persuading her of just understanding it's not about i'm not trying to judge you and i'm not telling you to be froome and i'm not telling you what to believe and what not to believe but we're trying to raise children you know what's the best thing for these children in school they're learning that you have to eat kosher and you have to keep shabbos and you can't mix milks and flake chicks and then they come to the house and and you know it it it's just not it's not fear to them can we communicate that to her if we can't or it's going to be ineffective i think we come back to that which we can do as parents and that is be an amazing parents based on your own values your territorial values your ash kapha create create the deep closeness to your children allow them to ask their questions when they get older especially they're going to have a lot of conversations with you about yiddish guy then why does mommy not believe this and i don't think you should besmirch her in any way i don't think it's helpful but you could discuss the fact that you know we live in a world that's confusing and we live in a world of uncertainty and we live in a world where we have to make choices and for thousands of years our ancestors are here because we made these choices to hold on to maimed harsinai and that's why we're still here and we're strong and we're surviving and we're thriving and hope and pray that they will develop the resilience and make the right choices i would also just add one more thing and that is i think i mentioned i got a le i got a call last week from somebody who told me that his wife was schlepping him in court for years and years and years and apparently she had all the money in the world and the court case would just not end and uh at some point you know people advised him to continue but he decided he's not fighting anymore and she completely alienated him and he told me something very interesting he said it was so painful and this is what he did he decided not to fight he created an email account for each one of the children for each one of the children getting an email account and almost every day he sent an email with a picture to each one of the children i think he had around five children he would go to the zoo or he would buy a soda or an ice cream take a picture i wish you were here with me and sent it to the email and when these children got a little older they came to him one day and they said tati why do you not want to have any relationship with us why did you alienate us why aren't you interested in us because that's what she fed she fed him she fed them and he told me he gave them each the password to their email account they opened it up i can cry and they saw 10 years of emails a few times a week with pictures and little notes to them i love you yankee i miss you i wish you were here with me in the bronx zoo i wish you here with me shopping for a sweater i wish you were here with me for a slice of pizza now you can't invent 10 years of emails in a few nights and he says in one day in one day it was over they embraced him now i'm not suggesting this exact format to anybody and you have to know your legal rights and i'm not telling you to wait for them 10 years till you see your children what i'm saying is i was so moved by the vision of this person he decided he's not fighting but he invested in those emails and you know what all of his children all of his children today they're older but they're with him they live they have an unbelievable unbelievable relationship he did not only think short term he thought long term so just remember that as a paradigm you know the seeds we plant they produce trees maybe not tomorrow but they produce trees it's painful it's painful it's hard we don't understand why but don't stop planting those seeds well you know first of all that's brilliant uh more credit to him the the the issue of long game versus short game is so important and when it comes to the religious issues that's extremely operative too my father is the front of the rapha was very fond of saying which loosely translates as the torah requires no nurse made you don't need to protect the torah zor can do a good job of protecting itself and you what that means is i i i think you know in this situation i don't think you should take its um sitting down i think if your wife is giving the kids on kosher food sometimes i think it's an issue but how you handle it is very important and you know today in general we're kind of blessed with an environment where um kids don't even need to lie to us anymore about whatever they're doing wrong because there's so much chutzpah and there's so much freedom that they're actually doing us the favor of not fakely complying and on the inside doing whatever they want or sneaking around us they simply don't even need to sneak anymore but the truth is that it's a big favor for all of us because we have to get real and your children just have to grow up a little bit faster but i would doesn't you know it doesn't matter the age almost i would explain to them look this is what kosher is this is what we believe this is what i believe i believe it's good for your soul believe it's good for your is good for your body keeping the mistless and the torah is a part of our family it's what we do and we we know it brings good things for us and you know i'm not here to ever beat you up if when you're with mom you go you know have a have a known kosher dorito or whatever i'm not interested in in in shaming you or being angry at you for choices that you make uh you know when you're not with me and when you're with another parent but i do once you realize that you have rights and that choosing to keep kosher is something that any child can do at any age um and that you don't have to accept that and if you don't want to eat something on kosher you don't have to eat it and it's very important you should communicate that and not get into you know your wife is wrong she's terrible she's that just just speak for what you believe in don't make it too crazy but but be firm that's what you believe in and say that if you want to talk about it more you feel conflicted about it or sometimes you want to do one thing or the other i'm here for you but this is what i believe and i believe is very important you know never to eat something it's not kosher wow beautiful wow what about to share why we didn't touch two topics dating marriage the blending should we do down the road we'll do a third session we'll do a third session beijing convention down the road we'll do the third session i think we covered most of the basic topics and the the third session will i guess include when's the right time to start dating that whole parsha dating right and the blended family second marriage all those complications so we'll get to that let's go to closing and then uh we'll get some closing or somehow they're remembered again i want to give a go to your strength forever jacob center before him coming on tonight especially the last second i'm sure you go to sleep every night at one two o'clock in the morning so it's not a big deal this is regular for you right i'm sure so we appreciate that um you know maybe we'll do something you know what's your shabbos i have a program at 1am if you're available actually i'm working pretty hard once you travel this is a good time gopher hey thanks for coming on be my kazakhstan crowd i think tonight was a very uh personal share people were very uh open and vulnerable and i think we got a tremendous amount of physical if everybody's watching this later um i hope the thousands of people that watch us should internalize like i said the beginning of the first year you know people that are happily married and watch it be able to give physics to the people that are going through this your family members and friends people that have the hard marriages or you know contemplating divorce please watch this entire series i guarantee you're definitely not going to get divorced so quickly and if the people are going through it um i'm sure a lot of this stuff is very relevant and i hope you're getting physic and some so much raja with it again we have to share every sunday night this is the zoo share code with 10 o'clock next sunday june 6th coming up in a few days we're going to have mushy norman a good friend of mine he runs quality families in lakewood together with um his friend dr yeoman dr binyamin tepher i'm going to be talking about the solution to most relationship problems and learning the subtitles of communications really want to really delve in communication how to communicate to spouses to children to friends and things i i believe we believe strongly that communication is probably would solve a lot of problems that people have and um hopefully we're gonna it's gonna be a very dynamic session we're working on it and it should be amazing everything here tonight's record it's gonna be available on monaco.com if you have any questions please email coach manafort from gmail.com if any you know hold forward emails throw up some clothes remember why why and uh hopefully when they have time they'll respond um if anybody wants to hear this share on the phone it's share number 57 it's gonna be on the phone number eight four eight seven seven seven grow and again i wanna thank our advertising sponsors the lakewood scoop robbie and if hazak kyla california summer from the jcn again a special thank you to sasha freeman from california as a dating coach and to survey cone for helping putting together the questions and really uh making this amazing and the trend we'll get back uh i'm on the schedule when we'll do part three with rabbi yy on when is the right time to start date re-dating and second marriages and blending families is a huge topic i want to go to closing for my host coach monacom father of symphony thank you very much yes it was a very very powerful a lot of information and i know a lot of people sometimes feel when they come to the zoom and they uh throw out their these crazy questions and then the answers are pretty like logic and uh what they should do and it doesn't always cover everything but i think it's very important like we discussed to have a committee i believe the committee they said everybody needs to have even after divorce how important is to have your your people around you that can help you whatever it is because to carry all of this on your own can be very very hard and you're going through enough so i'm not sure which organization or where you can find this so i'm sure there are people who who know is you know we can share it where you can pick up and uh form such a committee and it's a big i'm humbled to be part of this to be able to have the discussions and it's a big host for hashem and i want to thank you robert jacobson and rabbi dr simcha foreign to be with us tonight thank you very much just closes one uh one of the most powerful sayings from uh a preeminent uh early psychoanalyst carl jung that applies to many many of these situations which is it's a very deep idea which is the degree that you're going to influence others is a degree to which you are willing to be influenced any negotiation any parenting issue any anything that you're dealing with if you're not going to come in ready to hear and listen and be impressed and be influenced as much as you're able to do that that's as much as you'll be able to affect others it's not easy but that's that's what the work takes wow that's powerful is a special man let me tell you a lot to read if anybody wants to study up on him he was quite he's one of the few religious psychoanalysts a very devoutly religious person say that freud they say that freud sigmund freud with his heaven there could have had a minion for mincha every day the problem is the only one who believed in god was the guy young so you're the only one who would have a minute by the way by the way just an interesting little trivia i read an interview that somebody had with dr young at the age of 80. and the man asked him where did he get his most basic ideas about spirituality and the collective unconscious and his entire philosophy of the human mind and his answer was i kid you not i was shocked i read it black and white he says the foundation of all my teachings comes from a man who lived in the 18th century and his name was rabbi dave bear and he was known as the magid of mizritch yes yes and in a recorded interview they you can get you can hear it on youtube they asked him um does he believe in god and he said i don't believe in god he said i know god yeah right it was quite he was very interesting man yeah yeah yeah so that's an amazing insight of his to the degree that you're ready to be changed you'll be able to affect and change others i would just uh thank you i would just add also another i think very important point and uh this comes from one of the great hasidic masters the beauts hook of varka varka's a city in poland and he once said a very very powerful line he said where is friendship mentioned in the toilet is there ever a friend mentioned in torah we have spouses we have parents and children we have siblings constantly where is there the concept of friendship and the answer is once impartial parties vaishev yehuda leaves his brothers and he encounters a friend a friend from a place called abdullah and his name is hero wow he's the only it's the only friendship described in the in the tanakh you'll have david and you're innocent you'll have other friends but the only friend as far as my memory uh as far as my memory goes and he said why he said what happens in this friendship what happens in this friendship is we know the story yahood at some point is together with tamar and then he sends his friends with two goats in order to give it to tamar because that was the price that he agreed on and this friend can't find tamar because of course she was not this regular promiscuous woman she was the tzadekus tamar so yahudah says to him just forget about it pennies you know we're going to get embarrassed here this is going to be very disgraceful if people find out what's happening let's just keep the goats and she'll hold on to my collateral you know my stick and my seal and my belt and the whole continuation of the story and the beautiful varka says what is the terror teaching us here the definition of a friend is somebody in whose presence you could think out loud somebody in whose presence you can talk about everything somebody who's presence you can talk about things that are very embarrassing very vulnerable very humiliating very shameful you're not comfortable hanging up signs or putting it on your what's up status these are things that are really very very personal very intimate but that's definition of a friend and i think it's so important as all of us go through our lives journeys that there is somebody you are completely open with somebody you are completely honest with not the whole world not everybody in shul not everybody is your best most amazing friend be nice to everybody we like everybody we love everybody but you have to have that one person two people three people assaila harav somebody you are really vulnerable with all my mistakes all my sins all my transgressions all my failures all my let downs all my setbacks all my fears my insecurities bring it out to the fore discuss it with somebody somebody you trust somebody who's a confidant somebody who can hold your hand somebody who can be there for you hopefully somebody who can challenge you somebody who can stimulate you and especially those of us who go through divorce it's a very lonely place because you know in a good marriage hopefully your spouse is one of your best friends or maybe your best friend when you're divorced by definition you're going into a very lonely place your parents may be judging you your siblings may be judging you certainly your ex's parents are judging you your friends don't know how to relate to you you're really really alone and when we're alone we end up we end up often in the abyss so i say to all of you wherever your situation is just connect to an individual or a few individuals with whom you could be really really open with people who like you people who forgive you people who will challenge you but they cherish you and people who will help guide you in the right path in a very very vulnerable time of your life thank you oh yeah yeah thank you remember why why thank you somehow and we'll see everybody it's june 6th amazing good night everybody thank you this class is brought to you by the yeshiva.net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at www.theyshiva.net donate