Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Can We Question G-d?

8,893 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

the yeshiva.net okay my husband is actually here i know this wasn't really planned he is actually um coordinator of hatzala in union county at salah elizabeth new jersey um we just wanted to both thank you personally for the incredible work that you've been working on for this specific tragedy and for countless other small there's no such thing as small or big every incident needs to be taken care of every person is a person every person deserves our fullest of attentions and um if you want to share something i just wanted to say that i i was talking to some of my friends in miami and god bless you guys that's all miami you guys are rocking the house uh and all the pictures every picture you see there's always someone wearing a hotel vest or hatsawa shirt or something like that and just wishing you guys the most that's on everything you do and uh if you guys ever need any additional manpower or help or whatever it is i have more than enough guys ready to get on the next flight to miami and uh be more than happy to help you guys relieve you guys from some of your your duty whatever it is if you need anything feel free to reach out we're we're more than happy to to come down and help us to the best of our abilities and um and godspeed and continue your incredible work you guys are really kicking it and rocking the house and also congrats on your new uh mazel tov on your new uh rob jacobson yeah we have rabbi jacobson right here we're just gonna do a quick introduction um thank you so much yoni thank you so much jeff you can totally stay on joseph i just want to say thank you we feel the love we feel that you guys have been great we've been receiving calls from matala members all over the world i'm sure there are telemembers that showed up on a plane and just landed and said here i am another set of hands what can i do and i know i haven't met you yet but you're my brother because we're working for the same absolutely heaven and we're doing the same mission and i never understood hatsella to be what it is until you're part of it on this level so thank you thank you from all of your guys i want to tell the coordinator to the next like i said if you guys need anything feel free to call where we can get i can get 20 guys on a flight tomorrow morning and and we'll be down there ready to help we know that and we know you mean it so thank you oh i'm very serious about that okay thank you so much i'm gonna i'm gonna listen in from the from from the other side um that was a very special treat because yoni does not like the camera so thank you so much joseph and i want to introduce the world renowned speaker by yy jacobson who gives his entire soul to the jewish people by educating and giving giving all his time to educating the jewish people in order for us to connect to our core selves and connect to hashem so thank you for joining us tonight thank you for your very kind words thank you it's my pleasure and honor to be with so many dear brothers and sisters as we just heard yay okay so we have a lot of questions for you rabbi and these questions are more on the spiritual side i mean we have some technical questions that's why i'd love if you could stay with us joseph and then we have the spiritual ones for the rabbi okay so obviously um it's very very difficult to understand from a spiritual perspective as believing jews why such a thing would happen if god is so good and kind and just how how can we process the tragedy spiritually speaking wow yes you know sometimes silence is the best answer we often feel this need that we have to wrap our brain around things that we have to rationalize and justify and explain and find answers because we're looking for something to hold on to we're looking for some support for some security for some safety it's hard to live in such an unpredictable and vulnerable world thinking about you know 50 families 55 condos of people you know grandparents and parents and young and old women and men who went to sleep something we all do each night and the least we expect is you know to find our beds in place the next morning and and so we're desperately long for that type of security and safety and when we observe the opposite we want to know you know why why why why is this and and what i tell myself and i tell people is that really faith doesn't mean we understand everything it means that we understand that so much of reality consists of things we cannot wrap our brains around it does not fit in to our minds to our hearts to our expectations it's surreal it's unfathomable it's it's devastating and it makes us aware of how vulnerable we are how many things have to happen right at every single moment of the day within our bodies and within our environment to support life you know when we say the blessings every morning one of the blessings is you spread the earth over water don't take it for granted don't take for granted that i have earth to walk on the earth is above the water not below the water don't take for granted when i get into a plane it can stay in there and i don't take for granted that when i'm i'm standing on the floor it's holding me up endless endless forces of nature laws of nature that allow for life to happen i should not take that for granted the medwatch says every breath i take deserves to be celebrated to be grateful for and when we see such an event it's indeed devastating when we see such a catastrophe i spoke today to family members a friend whose parents are trapped his father and mother are both trapped in the collapsed tower last thursday you know i spoke to him just in a few minutes i'm gonna be after we're off i have a zoom meeting with a whole family that's dealing with this still you know people in their family unaccounted for and what we can do at this moment is be here for each other hold hands with each other support each other send our love our prayers our blessings and remember that we're all connected and we're all one it's a time for for for deep faith for deep hope for deep unity and also for for grief and sadness for all those who didn't make it and then prayers for great miracles but i think that sometimes it becomes an ego thing that i have to understand or it becomes this insecure thing like i need an explanation and really some things just don't have explanations we know that god cannot be contained in our minds some parts of life are just beyond us wow that was so powerful if you don't mind me just like wrapping it up so basically hashem can't be contained because he's unlimited and also we should be so grateful for all the good that we have and we should observe that instead of looking at one thing that's going wrong we should look at everything that's going good yeah listen please still really hard to swallow because it's very hard to swallow and the pain is real you know a person who says goodbye to both parents you know who died in the middle of the night in such an inexplicable way and that's that pain is not dulled faith doesn't mean there's no pain and faith doesn't mean there's no questions yeah and i want to add to that like they they like the building collapsed right then we had the stalin shoal and we also had mayron and they were all pretty like two weeks apart i believe sis in miranda was just like omar just like omar which was two months ago literally two months ago and it's literally two weeks apart within each incident is hashem trying to speak to us and if so what is he trying to tell us wow that's the billion dollar question i should say it's the priceless question obviously as maimonides as rambam teaches us as jews throughout history we really really have to be able to look at every event and glean lessons from it to say that something is random and it was just an engineering problem and some cheap people who were not ready to do the repairs that they had to do as fast as possible yes there was room to discuss that it's not just that because the building fell the other half was intact right that's the tip of the ice that's the tip of the iceberg that's how things play themselves out in natural mechanisms but there's an underlying divine message here the problem is the challenges you know i'm not a prophet and i don't know that we have prophets who could pinpoint and say you know this is it but i think each and every single one of us must look inward and become introspective and maybe two things to focus on is you know rebuilding our internal structures and when i mean rebuilding our internal structures i mean our homes our families our communities our unity with each other creating those safe spaces where we love each other where we connect each other where we banish hatred and toxicity and negativity and i would say one more thing and maybe sometimes we have to let go of some structures and i'm talking now about structures that confine us and cause us to be judgmental and dismissive we often remain stuck in the quagmire of our comfort zones and i can't transcend my confinements to open my heart whether it's to my spouse to my children to my loved ones to my own soul i become trapped in my own solitary confinement in a holier-than-thou judgmental attitude where i become dismissive and i'm not ready to really tune into somebody else's pain and this is a time to open our hearts to go outside of those structures that limit us and confine us and don't allow us to become the people that we're capable of becoming wow that was so powerful and i think i guess that the structures would be different for each and every single one of us right so now there are structures that are holy and there are structures that are confining it and both are true there's elements in life that need structure you know the structure of a family structure of a marriage structure of a community the structure of a friendship these are things that we have to maintain and fortify and strengthen the fact is that this sunday was a fast day because the structures of jerusalem were breached the walls surrounding jerusalem were breached on the 17th of thomas and three weeks later the temple was destroyed this happened 2000 years ago but we still commemorated every single year and the point of the fortress around jerusalem the point of the structure was it united the people in the city it protected them and united them when the wall was breached that protection was gone that unity was gone that safety was gone so those are structures we want to hold on to we want to maintain we want to develop we want to cultivate is there somebody perhaps that i have wronged i should apologize is there disunity in my family are there brothers not talking to each other let's make men's am i not communicating with my parents with my siblings with my sister-in-law with my brother-in-law with my nephews is their mahlokas are there is their strife in my community in my society people i don't speak to people i hate people i gossip these are things to rectify we need to rebuild the walls that unite us and protect us and surround us and turn us into a cohesive entity because those walls were breached on the 17th of thomas and those are structures that are sacred also our marital structures that have been compromised in recent times number one and then there are structures that really limit us churchill said that people create structures to facilitate their dreams and then we become victims to those structures you know we create schools to help our children and then our children become a tool for the school rather than the school being a tool for the children so sometimes our structures really hold us back it's like i say i don't do these things sorry i don't go out of my comfort zone i become a prisoner to my structures to my containers and i can't open my heart i can't be vulnerable i can't be real i can't be authentic i can't be loving i become very judgmental and dismissive so i think we all each and every one of us needs to be introspective and say which structures do i need to fortify and which structures do i actually have to let go of wow wow and someone asked right now as you finish speaking a really interesting question what about the people that are not open to doing the work the ones that are toxic so is it better to stay away from is it a better is it better to stay away from that to not become victims that's that's that's a powerful powerful question but the way i would have the way i would approach it and all my dear friends is instead of pointing fingers to somebody else i like to focus on what i can do and i could say you're toxic and you're toxic and you're even more toxic and you i can't speak to but i would say let me look into myself and see am i really living a life fully aligned with my inner divine soul am i living a life in which i am vulnerable in which i am open in which i am ready for compromises in which i am ready to be honest and authentic and to confront the traumas that have not been confronting and to be able to create new realities and to be able to allow myself to find those inner resources that i have been afraid of am i ready to really embrace my infinite goodness and share it with the world of course sometimes you have to create boundaries structures good fences good neighbors make i think robert frost said that of course we need boundaries sometimes there are relationships that at the moment are toxic and i have to figure out how to maintain these relationships in a healthy way but it shouldn't be about pointing fingers and say you're just a toxic person and therefore i'm cutting you out of my life and i don't want to see you ever again because that itself sounds a little toxic to me if you have to create boundaries create healthy boundaries but besides in very very rare occasions i am not a fan of cutting people completely out of your life i mean i know there are exceptions you know if somebody is actively and aggressively abusing you and you have to protect yourself of course there are exceptions but generally speaking as a mature adult i can create the boundaries that will allow these relationships to function in a healthy in a healthier way wow that's a lot to take in a lot because it's a lot of inner work we have to look within ourselves this is this is a lot of our work a lot of our work is inner work and one of the most beautiful teachings of judaism is that when i change myself i start changing the world you know maimonides rights rambam writes that every one of us should look at the world and at ourselves as a balanced scale and he says you know when you promote something real something good in your own life and your thoughts and your words and your actions that you can tip that scale and it has a very powerful effect it was one of the great the great uh the founder of the muslim movement his name was rabbi yes lipkin rabbi israel he was a great man he lived in the 19th century and he once said he said when i was young i dreamed of changing the world then i got older and i realized i can't change the world i'll change my country then i said that's not going to work but my city i'll change and then he says i got older and i realized it's not going to work my community and then i decided you know what i'll change my family he says now i realized i can't change anybody the only person i can change is myself and then he added and if i would have realized that when i was younger by now i would have changed the world wow very powerful it's just i don't know that like there's a there's a concept that each person is a world so really when we heal ourselves when we look inward and we do a lot of inner work we're just naturally healing the people around us because they get inspired by us indeed indeed every one of us exudes light every one of us is an ambassador of hashem a divine ambassador of love and light and hope and healing every one of us is a rescue worker in our own way and just as we have this horrible horrible devastating catastrophe that affects all of us directly or indirectly especially all of you who are on here and i know you have friends you have relatives many of you i see steve is with us and i know you have friends and relatives as i do in in that that are still unaccounted for or have been accounted for and tragically have been taken from us but every single one of us in our own way is a rescue worker you know there are people who are spiritually spiritually find themselves in a heap of rubble spiritually their lives are in disarray emotionally entangled disturbed confused overwhelmed oppressed and i think each and every one of us in today's day and age must be an ambassador a rescue worker an ambassador of of love of hope and of light wow wants to say something perfect yeah right so you began personally thank you for this amazing opportunity but you began the program with why why why so one of my great mentors teachers was representing esther young writes because she said that the word in hebrew for y is lama and the other word for why in hebrew is madua and she said lama does not mean why lama is to what purpose we believe we know that everything happens in our lives this is from doesn't mean we like it we understand it but the jew doesn't she said if you believe in hashem there's no questions if you don't believe in hashem there are no answers and said the other word for why is madura what is the knowledge so robin lipscore yeah uh sunday we had the minister of the diaspora affairs in the shoal and rabbi lipski said this very beautifully but basically he said anyone who starts explaining why this happened basically they're fools so llamas what do i learn from this that can make me a kinder compassionate person jew what can i do to help those in trouble i just want to add something you know you said your husband's from from elizabeth new jersey and i think that was and and again this is going to come out very very insensitive and for those who are in pain looking at relatives but i'm just sharing my experience my my grandmother came from europe went through hell came to america and she woke up in the morning that the kids should not go to the beach south beach staten island and i just heard the story not so many years ago and it was it was hot sweltering the heat the kids went to staten island to south beach and there was a riptide and they saved all of the children except for one child and that was my uncle fivel philip fern my uncle drowned at eight years of age my grandmother this is before they had counseling or prozac my grandmother was a very religious woman and she was having a very difficult time and the love of elizabeth new jersey was rubbed by tights and rory that's my grandmother at 39 years of age people started having kids at 39 to have another child and who was that child my mother so 14 years ago when uh we had a death in the family an aunt i heard the story from a relative how so i said to my mother i said mom do you know that you were born because of well my mom never heard the story and all of a sudden i was able to see behind the curtain of hashem's ways that if you would have said to my grandmother sitting shiva for an eight-year-old mrs gross mrs fern i know that i know you're suffering tremendously and everything she went through but you have to lose this child to have three children i have two amazing brothers amazing mothers involved i could never say this i remember i heard this from rabbi simmons jacobson once i think it was the um the sculpture jacques lipschitz robert jacobson and he canceled to rabbit and he went through hell i think in the holocaust and he was had all kinds of questions about hashem and the rebels said i can't explain to you why or i can beat you as a friend it's not my business represents it right is that correct it's not my so the point is though now is not the time to ask why hashem and the stars lot of shaman volcano nicholas london volneno we don't understand but our job right now is to understand somehow somehow we're supposed to be we have to be there for people but i see my own personal life and i'll and i started sharing that by the way with friends of mine already family members if they could hear it is this too it's it's going to be okay it's going to work out somehow but the pain is is is is beyond so wow thank you so much for sharing that steve well i think also we don't understand but it's also okay to ask hashem and personal prayer please hashem send me a sign why or send me a sign as to what i should be doing in order to improve so that we stop having these tragedies in the world but you're right we can't understand because the tragedy is is hashem being concealed in its concealment extreme concealment and rabbi please if you can add to that i know this is a very intense topic listen you know i always tell my students they say years ago they would say you know we meet holocaust survivors and the holocaust survivors often ask why why did it happen how can god allow this to happen and my students would ask me what do we tell them and i said i don't know but one thing i want you to know don't give them answers for two reasons first of all you don't know the answer and second of all even theoretically even if you would know the answer you think they're asking you an academic intellectual question they're asking you a heart-wrenching question that pierces through their entire body and their soul and the best answer for that is just empathy just to cry with them to hold their hands to to cry on their shoulder to let them cry on your shoulder and to be able to be there together and i think this is you know so critical to understand we really do so much of life that is just a transcendent mystery that i cannot comprehend and i could not fit it in to my faculties and silence is the most adequate response sometimes our response our reaction is not with with speeches and sermons and explanations and rationalizations it's just a silence and an awe in the in the presence of the mystery of life and the mystery of death and the mystery of such an event yeah and i think that through silence we get a lot of answers we quiet ourselves down we're so busy always in the hustle bustle constantly running from one thing to the other not even sometimes without a purpose just running for the sake of running doing things for the sake of doing things that we forget what our goals were and shabbos i think that's the real gift that hashem gave us shabbos the gift to relax the gift to just exhale and settle down and listen to that inner voice and that's where all the real work comes in once we hear what our inner voice is telling us our inner voice you know it's really a piece of god and and going from there if we were if we're able to master that that feeling that we have on shabbos and take that for a week that sense of peace that sense of quiet then we achieve personal redemption which eventually if everyone achieves that then every then we achieve global redemption so it's definitely a process but i do believe that these tragedies put up put us on a halt and just make us reset and completely take a new perspective on life and god and our relationship with with the torah the mitzvot a little story i heard this from professor ellie wiesel eli wiesel he was a holocaust survivor he was in auschwitz he was in buchenwald he received the nobel prize you remember he was a nobel laureate and he wrote many books on the holocaust and elie wiesel who was an articulate man and intelligent man he was a very close friend of my late father garrison jacobson whom steve knew pretty well elie wiesel he shared this himself he said he was once visiting the la bhava chiramba rabbi menachem at his office at 77 eastern parkway in brooklyn and the discussion was faith faith after auschwitz and elie wiesel struggled with god for many many years after the holocaust i still remember his op-ed in the new york times a day before rosh hashanah 50 or 60 years after the holocaust where he tells god it's time for us to make peace with each other so he describes how it's one evening i don't know two or three in the morning and he's having one of these long intimate private conversations with the laboratory about faith and he turns to the rabbi and he says how can you believe in god after auschwitz how and the rebel looks back at him after a long pause of silence and empathy and says professor wiesel or ebeliezer i want to ask you another question who do you want me to believe in after the holocaust you want me to believe in man after auschwitz after seeing what the most cultured scientific nation producing the most phds have done to 6 million innocent people a million and a half children who do you want me to believe in after auschwitz you want me to believe in man if there is any faith left at all after auschwitz it must only be in god i found that to be extremely profound and meaningful because i think what it really tells us is when we trust man when we put all of our faith in man there is terrible disappointment you know there was a mother 12 30 came home and felt the rumblings and with the mother's instinct she took her children out and then you have somebody who might know who arrived in the building right before midnight you know how do you explain these things and the answer is there's no explanation for it and ultimately we have to realize we are so vulnerable in this world nobody knows what the tomorrow brings so should i be anxious should i have faith and i say the only way i can really cultivate ultimate tranquility and serenity is when i can tell myself that i am being embraced by my loving father in heaven and the love is unconditional and i experience myself always as being in the bosom of god who takes care of me and is doing the best thing that i need in my life i think that's the ultimate only source of some comfort and solace in a turbulent and challenging world yeah thank you i just want to say also i spoke to one of the family members today just interesting he shared this with me and he said that he had a conversation today with the team that came from israel and i guess between us you know we could say the truth he told me you can completely not compare the work of the rescuers before israel the israeli team came and after the israeli team came this is a completely different level and it's very sad that it took a few days and there was some bureaucracy you know issues that had to be dealt with to allow the israelis to come and he said it's a completely different level of knowledge completely different level of professionalism he says you see a people that's trained unfortunately israel had to deal with some very painful circumstances over the years in terms of terror and war and so forth but the fascinating thing here is he told me that some of the leaders in the israeli team he asked them he said at what point do we give up hope at what point do we give up hope and this is somebody who has both of his parents trapped in the rubble and he said the israeli rescue team looked at him that one of the israeli leaders looked at him and said i want to tell you that in israel there were situations of people that we discovered who survived after eight or nine days they have survived so he says we're gonna try our best we're not gonna give up hope as long as there's even the slightest slightest chance of finding a survivor and that was in it really incredible to hear so you know we are we are pragmatic people and we all understand the stakes and i think we're all very sensitive to the realities on the ground and yet the jewish approaches and it's interesting the daf young me that hundreds of thousands of jews are going to be learning this shabbos is yuma page 83 where the mission it says that when a building collapses yes yes this shabbos me you could look it up yumadaf pay gimmel yuma 83. your mission says i quote when a building collapses you never stop the search as long as there is the slightest chance of a survivor no matter if it's shabbos no matter if it's your kipper and you're violating all the laws of shabbos the mission says and you don't even know if there's anybody there it could be that the house collapsed and there may be nobody there and he says and even if somebody is there but he says he's dead he says you don't know if there's a jew if there's a non-dream you don't know any of this and the mishna says you do not stop you continue to clear the rubble because if there's the slightest glimmer of hope you don't stop because saving a life ultimately is the greatest and most sacred consideration in judaism rabbi i was listening to that uh briefing firsthand from the commander and the commander gave examples of situations around the world where people were found after 12 days and even gave examples of people found alive after 17 days 17 days but how do they survive without water so there is water it's been raining here plenty we've had tremendous amount of rains there is water there's a kaddus baraco in the shaman and there are miracles that are far beyond our ability to comprehend wow he was giving them a tremendous tremendous hizok and like you said he was very adamant about not giving up hope by continuing to work towards diligently to work effectively to work methodically i was listening to the second briefing that was given this afternoon you had to see they came up with a a complete digitized rendering of each of the apartments they named rooms and numbers wow names of individuals of what room in each place where they are and then they explain themselves that they're working with the families to gather all of this information and he said it's very very critical for the families to come forth and to say who was sleeping in which room and where where their items may be because if they find a picture of one or they find a driver license one or something they can identify what floor they're at they can identify at which section they are and that gives them hope to be able to work around it wow they were mapping everything digitally all being supported by resources in israel and resources here on the ground uh the thought process that they brought are things that we wouldn't think about it's obviously uh i had the pleasure and the honor of speaking to some of the rescuers one of the gentlemen in the rescue team has been in the same rescue team for the past 29 years you don't get you cannot apply to the team members of the team have to make a recommendation in order to bring in individuals those individuals go into the training in order to become into the part of the team they're very very close-knit they work together around the world in catastrophic uh situations for many many years they understand each other the synergy that they have is between each other is second to none it's very very impressive to be in their presence and um they're they're very very genuinely incredible individuals that you can tell that it's not a job they're working from their heart they do realize the life they realize the value of a jewish soul and their i've dealt with them they came into our uh triage area to get iv fluids they're there for a half hour and they say finish up the bag because i got to get back out there you don't know the commitment of these people and they're they're leaders and they're driving the rest of the forces and and they're doing it it's amazing it's amazing and i want to say to all of us that i think in our own lives we should glean a lesson from them i know not all of us are trained and skilled in this type of work certainly i'm not but i think every one of us comes across souls and people who feel trapped i don't mean physically i mean emotionally psychologically spiritually every one of you knows a teenager a boy a girl a young man a young woman a child an adult an older person who feels trapped who feels overwhelmed who feels like their life has fallen apart and there's the debris flying everywhere and they feel depressed they feel dejected they feel traumatized they feel alienated and every single one of us must be a rescue worker to be able to help people clean up their own rubble and to be able to emancipate them from that solitariness from that loneliness and give them hope and give them love and empower them this is a work that every single one of us must do today especially today with so much youth so many of our youth that feel alienated and feel dejected and feel that they don't have a home they don't have a structure they don't have a school they don't have a community that really could contain them that can open up their hearts to them so i think each and every one of us today has that duty to be able to help people you know reclaim the majesty and the grandeur of their lives and their futures i just want to wrap it up really quickly and thank you all three of you from the bottom thank you and thank you so much just want to give a big shout out to rabbi yy jacobson he has his own instagram page he has his own youtube channel and he has the yeshiva.net if any of you are interested he has a ton of videos on everything just philosophy jewish everything and anything that you want to know and learn about judaism um and she does so much for the community and he continues he has a zoom call after this i mean look at the time he works around the clock so thank you so much i believe that spiritual work is equally as important you're basically doing what allah is doing on a spiritual level for the neshama for the soul and i want to also thank you from the bottom of my heart that's allah thank you um you and everyone is the best thank you yes that's all i think the best and the brightest and the holiest yes and also um i want to tell you something i said at a hot salad dinner may i i said this at sullivan i really feel this genuinely i said you know in the book of genesis cain murders his brother abel and then god says where's your brother and he says am i the custodian of my brother hashomer i'm not responsible for my brother my brother has his own life i'm not a co-dependent you know he kills him and then he says i'm not codependent later in genesis joseph is sent by jacob to go visit his brothers and see how they're doing and joseph gets lost he doesn't know where he's going and somebody meets him and says what are you searching for and joseph says i'm searching for my brothers cayenne says i'm not responsible for my brother and joseph says i'm searching for my brothers and that's the genesis of jewish history so i want to thank all of those because i can wake up in the morning and say i'm not the guardian of my brother i got my own life to take care of or i could wake up in the morning and say i'm searching for my brothers so thank you good night we should hear good news we should hear good news and we should experience the ultimate redemption this class is brought to you by the yeshiva.net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at www.theyshiva.net donate