Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Been Down So Long , How Do I Get Up From Here?
24,567 views
Faith in Times of Anxiety - Lecture to Chabad of NJ Mental Health Initiative To sponsor or dedicate an upcoming class click here: https://www.theyeshiva.net/donate To watch more classes & to read Rabbi YY's articles visit: https://www.theyeshiva.net Follow Rabbi YY Jacobson: Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/c/RabbiYYJacobson Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/TheYeshiva Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/yyjacobson Twitter: https://twitter.com/YYJacobson Linkedin: https://www.linkedin.com/in/yyjacobson/ Telegram: https://t.me/RabbiYY
Categories:Torah/Chassidus
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Rabbi Claws shared with me earlier.
He said that one of his community
members
phoned him and asked him this question.
I have been down so long.
How do I get up from here?
And he said this was a question and a
sentiment
shared by many people
who feel simply down trodden.
Dejected.
Sometimes surrendering to despair.
All they can see is darkness, a lot of
fear,
a lot of uncertainty, a lot of
confusion.
And people are living with very deep
anxiety.
Some people experiencing profound
trauma.
And the trauma from the past that's been
triggered.
This week hasn't been an easy week for
anybody.
Never mind the last few months in the
last year in the last two years.
And that's why
there is a certain awakening.
Let's face it. There are conversations
today that are happening
easily and smoothly that have not
happened in decades.
You know, my my wife tells me she's on a
WhatsApp group here in Rockland County.
So,
one of the women asked if anybody knows
of a particular type of mental health
professional for this and this type of
problem.
She says in the past till you would get
an answer from somebody,
it would take time and the answer would
be shrouded in mystery and cold
language. And here right away there was
a conversation. This one is struggling
with this mental challenge and this
one's child is struggling with this
mental mental health challenge.
A lot has emerged
over the last year and a
in the mental health field.
And a lot of that is positive. We are
now given an opportunity to deal with
things
that we did not have to deal with, we
could not deal with
over all these years and maybe
generations because things were
relegated to the subconscious
sellers of our psyche. But now,
history and providence has caused
so many truths to emerge to the fore,
to be brought to the fore of our
consciousness, in ourselves, in our
spouses, in our loved ones, our
children, our families, our
grandchildren, our friends.
And in that sense, this is a tremendous
opportunity.
It's an opportunity that comes with
pain.
It's an opportunity that comes with
crisis. It's an opportunity that comes
with heartache and with tears,
but an opportunity
nonetheless.
I'm reminded of that unforgettable
scene.
Maybe one of the most important scenes
accountable for Jewish resilience over
4,000 years.
It's in Genesis, Jacob in the middle of
the night
is struggling with a mysterious
adversary.
And they struggle all night.
And this mysterious adversary tries to
defeat Jacob. He can't. He mames him. He
dislocates his sciatica.
And at the end of this fateful
struggling night,
this adversary turns to Jacob and says,
"Let me go
because dawn has broken."
And Jacob says, "Lo, ashalechcha, ki im
berachtani."
I will not let you go
until you do not give me a bracha, until
you do not bless me.
Until you do not
bless me, I will not let you go. How
strange.
You're battling with somebody all night.
They're trying to kill you.
And at the end of the night, you ask
them for a blessing? What in the world
is that about?
Jacob was teaching the Jewish people.
Every time you face adversity in life,
it is insufficient
for you to just emerge
from the crisis and go back to the way
you were before. No.
I will not let you go until I do not
emerge from this encounter more blessed,
more authentic, more real,
more deep,
more powerful,
and yes, more invigorated,
and stimulated, and empowered.
From this, the Jewish people learned
over the last four millennia that when
we face adversity,
individually and collectively, it's
insufficient for us to say, "Let's get
rid of the adversary and go back to the
way we were before."
If that's the point, then why did God
send this adversity in the first place?
No.
The message must be much deeper. Lo
ashalekhaka, I will not let you out of
my hands.
Ki im berakhtani,
only after I will emerge more blessed.
Now, that's a tall order.
Because what this means is
that within each challenge
lay
a potential
for a new reality. Within each crisis
lay the seeds for opportunity.
Within each experience that confuses us
and overwhelms us
lay the secret potential for rebirth,
for renewal, for a renaissance, for
rejuvenation.
And therefore,
I don't just turn to a crisis and say,
"Get out of my life." Yes, I want the
crisis to leave my life, but I must go
one step deeper, and that is, "I want
you to get out of my life, but I will
not let you go
until I will discover how you have
caused me
to grow in unprecedented ways, how you
have made me a new person, how you have
molded me and crafted me,
and allowed me to discover parts of
myself that I never knew existed.
How you empowered me to go into places I
was never ready to go, to get in touch
with emotions that I thought would be
repressed or suppressed till my last
breath,
to get in touch with my true dreams and
yearnings and longings and pain,
the way I have never done before.
And then, it will turn out
that you did not only constitute a
crisis,
but you also became
an opportunity.
There's an old saying, "Why are the
Chinese around for 5,000 years?"
It's because the same character that
they have for the word crisis, they have
for the word opportunity.
But with Judaism, it goes one step
deeper.
We have a word called mashber.
It's a Hebrew word, mashber. Mem, shin,
bet, resh.
M a s h b a r. Mashber, it's a Hebrew
term.
It means a breakdown.
From the word lishbor, broken, shvira,
brokenness, a breakdown.
But you know what it also means in
Hebrew?
When a woman,
traditionally in the days of yore, would
sit on a birthing stool, it's called in
Biblical Hebrew, isha yoshevet al
A woman sitting on a birthing stool.
Funny.
Juxtaposition, because in Judaism
every time something gets broken, it's
really an opportunity for rebirth. Now,
I have to say
I don't mean to come across here as a
preacher and a pontificator, cuz I'm
not.
This is painful. What I'm saying is
painful.
Somebody who just says, "Oh, there's a
breakdown, yeah. It's just a new birth.
Oh, there's a crisis. It's just an
opportunity. Oh, this angel, this
adversary is trying to kill me. Oh, he's
going to bless me."
This means I spaced out. I'm not feeling
the pain.
We have to address this from a very
vulnerable place.
This is an awareness that comes with a
lot of tears.
And with a lot of grief.
And with a lot of pain.
And yet
it's the secret of our story.
It's the secret of our fortitude. It's
the secret of our resilience from the
days of Jacob. Proof is that at that
moment Jacob received a new name, which
became our name.
His name used to be Yaakov, Jacob.
And at that moment, after that
encounter, his name was transformed from
Yaakov to Yisrael, Israel. And that's
our name till today. We are called Bnei
Israel, the children of Israel. Am
Israel, the nation of Israel. Our
homeland is called Eretz Israel, the
land of Israel. And our Torah, our
religion is called Torat Israel, the
Torah of Israel.
And that adversary changed his name,
said, "Don't call yourself Jacob
anymore. Call yourself Yisrael,
because you have wrestled with God and
with people, and you have prevailed."
It's when we wrestle with our own demons
and our own skeletons, with our own
darker angels and our own traumas, with
our own fears and our own insecurities,
with our own difficulties and our own
challenges.
When we wrestle with compassion, but
with conviction.
With deep kindness and sensitivity, but
with unwavering faith and commitment and
resilience.
That we come out from the encounter more
blessed.
And I say to each and every single one
of you.
Here with us this evening. This is a
time.
When in the middle of the night.
Each of us in our own way.
Has encountered.
An adversary.
Or adversaries.
That threaten us. That overwhelm us.
It sometimes feels like they want to
kill us and destroy us. Or maim us,
wound us. They sometimes dislocate our
sciatic nerve.
Not just physically, but mentally,
emotionally, psychologically. In which I
lose my my posture.
My sense of erectness and pride and
dignity. My full posture is compromised
as a result of these forces of toxicity.
But it's also an opportunity to emulate
our forefather Jacob and say, "I will
not let go of you until you
do not bless me. I will not let you go
until I do not emerge from you.
More blessed. More deep. More real. More
authentic.
More wise.
More empowered.
And more focused.
But friends.
How do we do this?
How do I do this?
Or to quote again Rabbi Clark's friend.
I have been down for so long.
How do I find?
My way up.
How do we cultivate faith in times of
anxiety?
What do I do when I feel
that darkness,
despair has overwhelmed me. What do we
do in those moments when we feel that so
much of our life has been snatched away
from us?
When there is this tremendous pain
coupled with fear, coupled with anxiety,
coupled with insecurity,
coupled with uncertainty,
coupled with challenges that we did not
expect, curveballs that come our way
that we did not anticipate,
whether it's in terms of your own
emotional health, your own mental space,
your physical, financial, spiritual,
social standing,
your physical health, whether it's
facing loss and grief and tragedy,
whether it's facing pain, physical or
emotional, whether it's facing a
challenge and a crisis with your own
child or children,
or in your own marriage, or in your job,
or with your family or friends or
community.
Internal struggles or external
struggles, struggles that people see and
many struggles that most people don't
even see because they happen in the
inner recesses
of your heart and my heart.
And I want to give you this evening
a brief but powerful blueprint
that Judaism
has articulated millennia ago,
but it's always been fine-tuned and
developed and crystallized
through generations of sages and rabbis
and rebbetzins and teachers and mentors
until this very day.
Let's begin
with step one. So, after we established
the baseline, and the baseline is
Judaism's approach to adversity is that
message of Jacob, I do not let you go
until I do not come out more blessed.
Great message, but how? What are the
tools? What are the skills to get there?
So, I'm going to go through Judaism's
program, or at least a few points in
Judaism's program towards reaching this
state of consciousness and implementing
it in our lives, and then we're going to
open the floor
to questions. And I just want to say all
questions are welcome, no taboos,
nothing off limits. You can either
unmute yourself or ask your question
live. You could put your question in
chat so that I can read it.
And we are open to every single type of
question, and of course, as good Jews,
objections
as well.
Step one.
One of the most powerful teachings of
Judaism that touches me every single day
is the idea
that
despite any abuse you have experienced,
any trauma you have endured in your
life, and when I say trauma, I mean
trauma with a capital T, you know, that
traumatic experience or event that only
you know of or some people besides you
know of, but also trauma not with a
capital T.
Those accumulative
experiences in life
that cause us
to be timid,
to remain locked up in our own bubble
and cocoon,
not to trust anybody, to feel isolated,
lonely, misunderstood. Anybody knows
what I'm talking about?
Those experiences accumulative in life
may be of neglect or our own deep
sensitivities.
Those experiences as a result of nature
or nurture, as a result of epigenetics
or environmental influences, education,
parenting, our home, our family, or just
our own chemical
and genetic physiological makeup,
which causes us ultimately to grow up in
a world that is difficult for us.
We're confused. We're overwhelmed. We
may be suffering from a mental illness.
We may be suffering from a real mental
challenge.
And you know, the only people I know who
are perfect are the people I don't know.
The only families I know that are
perfect are the families I don't know
well. The only marriages I know that are
perfect are the marriages I don't know.
Each and every one of us struggles in
our own way, whether it's with ourselves
or with people very close to our lives.
And yet, Judaism comes and says
that you have to always remember that
your core
remains untarnished.
Your core is invincible. Your core is
indestructible. Why?
Because the core of your being, of your
body and your soul, is a fragment of
God, in the words of the Tanya and the
holy writings of the mystics.
And because you are a fragment of God,
just as God is invincible and
indestructible, at your core, you're
invin- invincible.
Your essence is filled with infinite
potential,
with infinite confidence, with infinite
promise.
Nobody and nothing
can crush and stifle and obliterate
your innermost
beauty, your dreams, your passion.
Your passions, that inner child that
remains pure, always remains pure. And
even if that child endured unspeakable
trauma or abuse,
or abuse and trauma not of such
grandeur, but nonetheless experiences
and encounters that came from its own
genetic makeup or from its relationship
with others that cause us to shy away
from life. I learn to space out. I learn
to detach, or I become so aggressive or
passive-aggressive, or I'm angry, or I'm
miserable, or I'm always doubting
myself. I could never be calm, relaxed,
cool, collective, happy.
Despite all of those truths,
Judaism teaches, in the words I was
saying it today in the prayers and I it
was so true I was thinking about it the
very emotional words. We say it in the
morning prayers King David says, "Al
tigu b'mishichoi uvinvi'ai al tere'u."
Do not touch my anointed ones, my
mashiachs. So the Talmud says in
tractate Shabbos 119,
"Who are the mashiachs? Who are our
anointed ones?" Elu tinokos shel beis
raban. These are the little kinderlach,
the little children.
Every one of us has a child inside
that is defined as mashiach, God's
anointed one.
It's the child in us that is filled with
so much innocence and so much joy and so
much trust.
And yet,
as we grow older with the
disappointments of life and the
disillusionments of life and the pain of
life
and the feedback we experience in life,
you may think that that
little cute angelic piece of heaven
lingering inside of you
has been tarnished, has been abused, has
been affected. So we say every morning,
"Al tigu b'mishichoi."
Nothing in life can touch, can tarnish,
can affect my inner little mashiach, my
inner piece of God. You must trust that
part of you.
You are deserving to be free because at
your core, your soul is emancipated.
You are not in shackles. You are not
inhibited. Yes, I know my thoughts tell
me I'm inhibited. My neural pathways
have been formed towards a inclination
of slavery and subjugation and
depression in the spirit. I know that.
But those are all thoughts.
Those are all emotions, visceral
experiences that I'm having. But they
never ever
can deprive your essence
from the freedom that is its inherent
and innate quality as a fragment of
heaven here on earth.
As a spark of God, as a ray of infinity,
as a piece of Hashem,
your core remains forever forever free.
And that faith
in your core
must always
be present even if viscerally I am
struggling with it.
There's a fascinating interpretation of
the Midrash of the Midrash.
Moses before he dies,
he calls God Kel Emunah, the God of
faith, at the end of Deuteronomy. The
God of faith asks the Sifri, ask the
rabbis, what does it mean God is the God
of faith? That he believes in himself?
God has faith? I understand when you say
this person has faith, they believe in
God, they believe in a higher power,
they believe in a consciousness of love
and unity. What does it mean Kel Emunah,
God is a God of faith? Who does he have
faith in? Himself? You mean he doesn't
doubt that he exists? God is not an
atheist? That's an interesting question,
right? An interesting Can God be an
atheist?
That's what the Midrash seems to imply.
Kel Emunah, God is a God of faith.
And the Sifri says, and I quote these
beautiful words in Hebrew,
sheha'emin ba'olamai u'varo.
What it means,
what Moses means when he says God is a
God of faith is
he has faith in me, in you, in the
world. He believed in the world and he
created it. And he never becomes
disillusioned.
Nor should you become disillusioned in
yourself.
The definition of creation was God's
faith in you. God's faith in me.
So that even if you're struggling with
your faith in God.
Never ever doubt God's faith in you.
Even when you don't believe in yourself,
he still believes in you. Kayla Muña
Shimon
we fact we say it every single morning.
It's the first Jewish meditation and
mantra right when we wake up when we
open our eyes.
There's a beautiful meditation that Jews
say.
I thank you
eternal
reality
for restoring my soul to me with great
compassion. And then we finish off rab
Muña Shimon. Your faith is great. What
does this mean? What we're saying each
morning is your faith in me is great.
You have given me back my soul. I do not
take it for granted. I don't take
anything for granted. The fact that I
was given another day of life and
another opportunity to walk the face of
this planet is a demonstration of you
saying to me that I matter.
That my day is significant. That I am
not a prisoner
destined to surrender to the shackles
of the pain of life. No.
That I could be happy. That I could have
an incredible marriage. That I could
have a great relationship with my
children. That I could have a splendid
relationship with my grandchildren.
That I could have a good relationship
with myself. With my parents, with my
siblings, with my friends.
That I can let go of at least some of my
traumas, some of my anxiety.
That's step number one.
Step number one is acknowledging every
morning that invincible core.
Which brings me to step number two.
We all need support systems.
Everybody needs a friend.
Everybody needs a confidant or
confidants.
You need somebody in your life with whom
you can be completely open. It's too
difficult for you
to keep everything inside. Proverbs says
in your
heart, when there's anxiety in your
heart, you have to be able to
communicate it to others.
You we have to be able to have one, two,
three, four, five people in our lives.
At least one
with whom you with whom I can be
completely open with.
Somebody with whom you can share
everything. You can think out loud. Now,
of course, it has to be a person who's a
confidant, a person who's confidential,
a person who cares about you, a person
who's wise and perceptive and
understanding, somebody who understands
you, somebody you trust. But we need
such people in our lives.
We are all vulnerable. We are all mortal
humans. We are weak. We need to be able
to connect. The first thing the Torah
says is not good. What's not good?
What's What do you think is the first
thing the Hebrew Bible says is not good
in life?
And the answer is not good for
Adam alone. The first thing the Bible
Hebrew Bible says is not good, it's not
good for Adam, it's not good for a human
being to be alone.
It's not good.
We all need attachment. We all need
connection, and today many of us are
suffering from attachment disorder. We
don't have healthy attachments. We are
alone in the world. We need to be able
to rediscover our ability to attach
ourselves. Now, sometimes it's very
scary. I want to become a victim so that
I could say I'm alone, nobody
understands me. Everybody backstabs me.
Everybody betrays me. Every time I go to
the synagogue, they're talking about me.
Nobody respects me. Nobody honors me. I
am the victim for eternity. I am the
loser. I am the nerd. There's a song by
the Shteeble Hoppers. It's called the
Nebach of the Shteeble. I'm the Nebach.
You know what Nebach is? I'm the Nebach.
I'm the victim of the Shteeble.
But we have to realize that those
thoughts of victimhood are
are become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
There's a part of me that is not a
victim. There's a part of me that's free
and I want to open myself up to it.
I don't need to escape into victimhood
in order to avoid the pain.
I have the power to be able to confront
it and the first step is to be able to
share, to be able to connect.
The antithesis today we know in research
that the antithesis of addiction is not
sobriety.
The antithesis of addiction is
connection.
People who are connected don't run to
addiction.
People who are disconnected, they are
alone in the world. They run to
addiction.
Which brings us
to another very important point.
And this is a teaching of the Baal Shem
Tov.
The Baal Shem Tov teaches,
this is a verse in the book of Exodus.
The Jewish people have left Egypt.
They have come to the Red Sea
only to discover that the Egyptian
troops are pursuing them and they're
caught
between a rock and a hard place and they
don't know what to do next and they cry
out and they're desperate and some Jews
say, "Let's jump into the sea." And some
say, "Let's go back to Egypt." And some
say, "Let's fight." And some say, "Let's
pray."
And then Moses tells them and he says,
"Relax. Stand here and you will see
salvation."
Because as you see Egypt today, you will
never see them again. Kasha eat them at
mitzrayim hayom lo tosif l'rotam od ad
olam. The way you see Egypt today, you
will never see them again and the
commentators struggle with this message.
Because you see Egypt today you will
never see them again. What's the
connection? Moses could just say don't
worry you're never going to see them
again.
They're gone they're gone they're done.
He says no since you see them today you
will never see them again and the Baal
Shem Tov gives us an extraordinary
interpretation. He says only because
you're ready to look at Egypt today
you will never see them again.
If you close your eyes now
you will see them again and again and
again.
But if you're ready to look at them now
you will never have to see them again.
The Baal Shem Tov is teaching us
never to be afraid of confronting any
emotion inside of us.
Don't be afraid of your trauma.
Don't be afraid of your shame. Don't be
ashamed of your shame.
Don't be scared to tackle what is inside
of you. You know why?
Because you're bigger you're larger and
you're stronger.
Your soul is a piece of infinity. It can
it can contain any emotion that comes
your way. You do not have to close your
eyes to any emotion inside of you. What
a teaching of the Baal Shem Tov 300
years ahead of his time.
It's because you're ready to look at
Egypt today
that you will not have to look at them
again. You will finally be able to spit
it out from your system and you won't
become defined and trapped by it. But if
you're going to close your eyes because
Egypt defines you so much that you don't
have the courage to be able to look at
it
then
it's going to become repressed or
suppressed in the sub sellers of your
psyche and it will emerge it will come
out through all types of unhealthy ways.
It will leak out from your system
through passive aggressiveness through
anger through resentment through
frustration, through hate, through
stress, through anxiety, through fear,
or another host of difficult and
challenging experiences and emotions.
Don't be afraid, Judaism teaches, of any
thoughts that you go inside of you, any
emotions inside of you. You are bigger,
you're a struggle. Like I used to tell
the kids, my tatty is bigger than your
tatty. And I say, your soul is bigger
than any emotion that comes your way.
Don't be afraid of it. You define it so
that it does not have to define you.
Your infinite soul can contain it. Don't
be embarrassed by it. Don't be
humiliated by it. I know we are
embarrassed by it. That's why we repress
it. But the Baal Shem Tov says,
you don't have to. It will not kill you.
Because the you cannot be killed. The
you is a piece of God. Nobody can
destroy God. Nobody can destroy you.
Which brings us to the next step.
And this is known in Kabbalistic and
Hasidic writings as midas harachamim.
The attribute of Jacob, we have to
cultivate the attribute of compassion.
What does compassion mean? Compassion on
others, but also compassion on
ourselves.
When you're dealing with a difficult
thought, a difficult emotion, a
difficult experience, when your trauma
is being triggered, and you find
yourself
in an abnormal state. You literally
cannot react from a sober, sensible,
logical, happy place. You find your
deep, deep anxiety being triggered,
sometimes in inexplicable and dramatic
ways.
You can't always get rid of it.
But don't judge it.
Make space for it, and have compassion
for it.
Just have compassion. Feel bad for it.
And you know what?
Acknowledge that this may have been your
survival skills.
Your survival skill.
This attitude that I developed that
causes me to run away when your spouse
says this statement to you, you just
check out emotionally. You're not
present there. You run away. You run
away to China.
This may have been your survival skill.
At 4 years old, this was your way of
dealing with your challenges. You had no
other way.
This is all you can do, run away.
Or get angry.
Or check out.
Or get depressed. Or become a victim. Or
go into isolation.
This was your survival skill. This is
how you lived. If not, the pain would
have been too overwhelming and too
overbearing for you to survive. You had
to develop these skills, which now as an
adult are paralyzing you and not
allowing you to have deep, meaningful,
and fulfilling relationships. So,
instead of criticizing these emotions,
and instead of criticizing these
experiences, and just causing them to go
deeper into hiding,
can you have compassion for them?
Can you cultivate rahamim?
Vayishak Yakov l'Rachel vayevk. Jacob
meets Rachel and he weeps. So, the Tanya
chapter 46 says,
40 45 chapter 45 says,
this is a metaphor for life. Jacob
represents in the Zohar and Kabbalah the
attribute of compassion. Rachel
represents the soul that goes in
to emotional exile.
And Jacob teaches us, you just have to
be able to have compassion.
Compassion for what you went through.
Compassion for the strange survival
skills you developed. Don't judge it.
But look at it and say, you know, thank
you. You were here to protect me. But
now I do not have to be defined by you
any longer.
I will take care of you, my survival
skill. Don't worry, you don't have to
freak out. I get you. I have compassion
for you. I love you. I cherish you. Give
it a little kiss. Vayishak Yaakov
and cry with it.
Just cry. Just sit with that pain.
And then it doesn't have to define you
anymore.
Then you could say, "But now I want to
choose
to react from a place of freedom, from a
place of emancipation, from a from a
place where I do not feel inhibited."
Sometimes some of us are so locked up we
cannot do any of this.
I am experiencing so much trauma and I
know that I'm just closed up.
I can't connect. I can't open up.
I don't even have
I'm going to take questions at the end,
okay? Another few minutes.
Sometimes
I'm experiencing
so much pain
and I know I know for sure there are
things inside of me
that are reacting and I do not have
control over them.
And you know what?
They are hijacking my life. They have
abducted my freedom. They have abducted
my relationships.
And it's so important to acknowledge
that.
Not to deny it, not to run away from it,
to have compassion for it, to realize
that that may be happening because the
more you have compassion for it, the
more you can quarantine it and not let
it define you, rather you define it. And
usually in most cases we need help from
a real professional who can help us
identify the traumas
and then
help us release those traumas at least
to some degree.
It's very important if you find yourself
paralyzed, if you find yourself always
getting angry at your spouse, at your
children, at yourself, at your parents,
at your siblings, at the world. If you
find yourself always reacting from a
place of such deep
disturbing
places.
It's so likely that I really have no
choice. I am so much a prisoner
to my own experiences and I don't even
know how to live in any other way.
And information won't help. You know,
sometimes people people have been to
talk therapy for decades.
They have gone to rabbis and mentors and
teachers and they tell them you have to
read more good books about being ethics.
Learn more musar, learn more ethics,
learn more chassidus, learn more
kabbalah, learn more chummash, learn
more gemara. Learn more.
And this is beautiful advice. It's good
to learn more. But you know what? It's
not addressing the problem.
I want to be a good person. I want to be
a good father. I want to be a good
husband.
I am traumatized.
Sometimes you meet couples.
He means well. She means well. They just
don't know how.
The guy makes a resolution, "I'm never
going to lose my temper again."
And then he loses it the next day.
He is responding from a place where he
really doesn't have choices.
The poor guy is a victim. He is
responding as a 6-year-old. For him,
this is survival or for her, this is
survival.
And if we can help them identify their
trauma and help them release it and help
them see that they can make choices, we
can save lives and you have to take that
responsibility for yourself.
It's not going to be always about
information. Be a good person. Be a nice
person. CBT, sometimes brilliant.
Cognitive behavioral therapy is
wonderful. Other forms of therapy, but
sometimes it's just much deeper than
that, and that's why today there was so
much conversation about trauma therapy.
The body keeps the score.
And we need to be able to find those
professionals who can help us release
the trauma.
Whether whether whether it's EMDR
whether it's somatic therapy
or other treatments
being administered by real trauma
experts that help people get out of the
prisons that they have been in for 10,
20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70 years.
You just want to make sure you have real
people, real experts who are guiding you
and mentoring you, and they are familiar
with the cutting-edge developments in
this area. This all these different
types of treatments including various
substances that are being used today
with mental health professionals and
doctors and therapists and so forth. I'm
not the experts. I'm not telling anybody
what to do and what not to do. But
there's all these conversations about
ketamine and ibogaine and cannabis and
ayahuasca, but you need real
professionals. These are not things that
are that are valueless. These are things
that have real consequences, and one
really needs a top mental health
professional who is a trauma expert to
guide them in a path that will be
productive and meaningful, but don't
sell your soul to anybody. You
ultimately have to take responsibility
for your life and be the captain of your
ship and go to people who are here for
you and who are helping you.
And I'm going to make three more points
and then open the floor to questions.
We have to realize
that some people's trauma is not coming
because they had bad parents
or because they were abused
or because they grew up in a horrible
dysfunctional family or community.
Yes, nobody grew up in a perfect
situation, but some of us are simply
sensitive, and what traumatizes us more
than anything else is existence.
Just existence. Yeah.
Waking up in the morning and facing a
world of differentiation.
You see, before we came into this world,
the soul experienced oneness.
The whole world is one.
It's all pervaded by infinite divine
love and oneness, but existence is about
differentiation.
The part becomes detached from the
whole, and I don't experience the whole
anymore. And you know, for some people
that doesn't mean anything. Some people
don't even understand what I'm talking
about. But for some people, this is
trauma.
The trauma of experiencing a world that
is fragmented, that is broken
is very difficult for many souls. And if
that's the trauma you're facing, you
have to realize this. That my pain may
be coming from just
facing existence. Facing existence means
for some souls facing trauma.
And the ability to work that through and
to be able to understand the sensitivity
of living
and the need to be able to bring in
light into that space of darkness.
That's the remedy.
The understanding that life itself is
broken.
In fact, the word in Hebrew for evil,
for bad, is ra. Ra doesn't mean bad. Ra
means broken.
Ru us ru ach ko es ru or means broken
because the beginning of all toxicity,
the beginning of all negativity is
that I feel that I'm broken. I'm not
part of the infinite
oneness that pervades past, present,
future
and all of the universe and beyond and
connects all of us
into a singular entity reflecting the
oneness of the divine.
So, we have to realize
that some of us are are really sensitive
to that. And we have to acknowledge
those setbacks that we have each person
in their own way.
Mental, spiritual, physical, financial,
trans- transcendent setbacks.
And don't blame yourself. Just realize
those sensitivities that may exist in
you and in your children, what they call
today HSP, highly sensitive people.
And highly sensitive people react to the
world in different ways. What for you or
for me means nothing for them
could occupy significant space and
really throw them over the top.
And just tell them, "Oh, get over it.
Just be like me." is is is cruel and
it's and it's irrelevant.
Another very, very important point.
And that is, you know, sometimes when
darkness takes over,
it feels like it's absolute and it's
never going to end. You know that
feeling? You're in a difficult marriage.
You're in a difficult relationship with
your kids. You're in a difficult
relationship with yourself.
And things are so dark.
And you just tell yourself, "This is
never going to end."
The darkness feels so powerful. It feels
so absolute. It feels so infinite. You
don't feel any glimmer of hope and you
could read things and you can hear
lectures and you can watch Rabbi YY's
clips. And you can come across wonderful
websites and you can see wonderful
people.
But that inner darkness that has set
into your heart is just so
all-pervasive. You don't feel there's a
way out.
It's like these dark clouds are never
going to pass. The sun will never shine
again.
And there's a beautiful teaching
among the Chabad spiritual masters about
this.
You know why
you feel darkness
is infinite
it's because in this darkness lay
infinite opportunity.
And because every darkness that we
experience contains infinite
opportunity, the darkness feels
infinite. It's not because the darkness
is infinite, because in that darkness
lay an infinite light.
And if I only have the courage to stay
with it
and to remain intact
and to remain anchored in my unequivocal
and unwavering faith that infinite light
will emerge and bring me to infinite
places. So next time you're feeling that
absolute sense of overwhelming confusion
take a deep breath
and meditate on this. The sense of
infinity, the sense of
absolute hopelessness is coming from the
fact that there is an absolute infinite
opportunity here
that you have now come across.
And in that very thick darkness lay that
infinite opportunity.
So don't be afraid.
Don't be scared.
And finally
people have always wondered why in
Judaism
the day begins
with the night before.
Wouldn't it make sense for the day
to begin with sunrise or with daybreak?
As the dawn breaks or the sun rises, a
new day should begin. Or at least as it
is done by us in America, midnight.
So the first half of the night belongs
to the previous day and 12:00 a.m. we
begin a new day. So those who wake up
2:00, 3:00, 4:00 in the morning are
already part of a new day.
But in Judaism, it's very strange. The
day begins at nightfall of the previous
day. So, when you come home exhausted,
tired, fast asleep, exhausted, it's been
a long day, and the sun sets as it's
setting right now on us, this is when
the new day begins. Come on, this is not
when the new day begins. This is when
the old day ends. It's time to go schlaf
eat. Time to take a shower. It's time to
eat supper and relax.
You know, read a book, have a drink, sit
on the couch, go go to sleep, whatever
it is that you do in the evening.
Join a Zoom class.
But, it's the day is coming to an end.
But, in Judaism, that's not the case.
The day always begins with night.
Nightfall, this is the beginning of the
day. As it says in Genesis,
day one is a composite of evening and
morning. Night and day creates the day
always first with the night. You know,
sometimes you invite people for Shabbat
or Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur, they
make the mistake, they think Yom Kippur
starts in the morning. Shabbat starts in
the morning. They don't realize Shabbat
starts Friday evening is the beginning
of Shabbat, not Shabbat morning, not
Saturday morning. Saturday night is
already out. Shabbat is over. It begins
Friday evening.
What's the reason for this?
So, there's a practical reason and
there's a spiritual reason. The
practical reason is, you know, people
come home from work, and they're often
at their worst behavior. I'm hungry. I'm
grouchy. I have a cold. I have a
headache. I had a long day in the
office. So, when I greet my spouse and
my children,
sometimes my lowest angels are emerging.
So, the Judaism says, "No, no, no. When
you come home at night, this is the
beginning of the day. This is when you
have to be the most fresh and the most
invigorated and the most inspired and
the most stimulated. This is your
morning. When you come home from work,
5:00, 6:00, 7:00, 8:00, this is the
beginning of the day."
Operate on your highest level of
consciousness, your best level of
behavior. This is the beginning. It's
not the end. When you come home and you
loosen your tie, and you plop down on
the couch, this is not the end, this is
the beginning. When you meet your spouse
and your children, it's the beginning of
your day. When you go into the office in
the morning, that's already close to the
end of the day.
There's also a very deep spiritual idea.
You see in most cultures,
the day begins when? Either midnight
or sunrise.
In Judaism,
the day always begins with night.
And when does it end? It ends with day.
And then sunset, nightfall begins a new
day.
What Judaism is teaching us is
that when we face the world and we face
time,
we always begin with darkness. We always
begin with night.
But that's the beginning of the day,
it's not the end of the day. The end of
the day is sunlight.
Because the purpose of life
was not
just to find light. The purpose of our
world and our life, the meaning of
existence is
that we live a life that is essentially
a manufacturing company to transform
darkness into light. That is what life
is about.
The meaning of life in the Jewish
perspective is we are the manufacturers.
Manufacturers don't take already make
made product and keep it already made
product. That's not what you need a
manufacturer for. On a manufacturer, you
need to take raw material and to change
it into a new product. God did not put
us into a universe that is filled with
light. We are manufacturers. We take
material and we transform it into
another material.
We were placed into a world of night, of
darkness, of confusion,
of vulnerability, of uncertainty.
And that's how life begins. Each and
every one of us faces
some form of darkness
because you are a manufacturer. You're
not a victim. You are a co-partner in
the work of creation. And what is your
job? Your job is to manufacture darkness
and transform it into light. Our day
begins with darkness.
And then it becomes transformed
into light.
And then a new day begins with a new
darkness that we transform into light.
So, when you're facing, my friends,
darkness,
when you're facing a trauma,
when you're facing a difficult emotion,
a difficult experience of the past or of
the present,
whatever you're facing,
don't surrender to despair.
Don't give up. Realizing Realize this is
what it's about.
It's about taking
this experience, this toxicity,
and looking deeper, digging deeper,
and transforming it
into a source of light and enlightenment
and inspiration. Vayehi erev vayehi
voker, it's only from the transformation
of darkness into light, yom echad, that
we discover the true oneness of life,
the true oneness of existence, the
oneness that pervades both darkness and
light, infinity and finiteness, heaven
and earth,
body and soul,
until the great moment when all the
darkness
will be revealed, will reveal what it's
really containing inside of it,
which is
the infinite light.
Thank you very much.
We have a lot of comments and questions.
So, let me begin.
If you want to unmute yourself and ask
your question live, that's fine. Right,
Rabbi Clark? But, in the begin In the
meantime, I have a lot of questions here
on the chat.
So, I'm going to
begin.
Question number one.
All that you said sounds very good, but
there seems to be an implied if.
If you do X, you'll get Y. It seems a
little too transactional.
And I really I'm confused by that.
Because it's all transactional
and everything has this if. Fill in the
blank what this X is, but only when you
fill in the blank will you get Y.
Well, I think
What What you're saying is putting on
fillin, lighting
Shabbos candles, right? I mean, and
that's fine. But, you know, say it. Say
that.
Putting on fillin is a wonderful idea.
Lighting Shabbos candles is a wonderful
idea, and celebrating Shabbos is
certainly a wonderful and divine idea.
But, the way I see all of
But, if you still do those things,
you're still feeling the dread and, you
know,
But, actually
it wa It's like a magic bullet. Did you
hear my lecture? Cuz I didn't mention
any of these three things. Right, but
it's implied, right?
Well, I think it depends how we see
these mitzvahs.
I see these mitzvahs as opportunities to
go deeper into ourselves and really
cultivate a much more profound
self-awareness and alignment with our
divine core.
But, there's no way that these mitzvahs
exempt somebody
from doing the emotional work
that requires self-awareness. In fact,
that is what filling is.
Filling is the work of really dedicating
my mind and my heart and aligning them
with the ultimate reality. That's what
prayer is about. That's what Shabbos is
about.
So, I think these mitzvahs are actually
divine tools
to be able to go and challenge
ourselves.
But, I don't think it makes sense to say
that
a person who's doesn't do any self-work
is not interested in any self-awareness,
and just the mitzvah itself
will cover
for all the issues and will eliminate
all the problems. Sometimes mitzvahs
accomplish incredible things, but as the
sages say, a mitzvah without intent
and without spiritual work is like a
body without a soul. So, the mitzvah
itself has infinite value, but for the
mitzvah to really accomplish its full
goal,
it must come with an internal openness
and readiness.
Next question. I still cannot get
the concept of Moshiach.
Number one. Number two.
They say God helps those who help
themselves. We can't rely on external
factors.
So, why do we talk about this Moshiach
who's going to come and save us?
Great question.
But, really the concept of Moshiach
is really
not looking to some person who's going
to come to save you.
I spoke before about altiguy de
Moshiachoy.
The real idea of Moshiach is
that each of us
emerges in our full splendor to save
ourselves.
There's a famous expression in
Kabbalistic writings that every Jew has
a spark of Messiah.
And when every person brings out their
own spark of Messiah, all the sparks
create the collective Messiah that
liberates the world. So, Messiah is not
about some
foreign
human being or angel who invades our
space and says, "I'll take care of all
your problems." Messiah first and
foremost is a state of consciousness
in which you and I discover our own
infinite divine potential
to be able to see the world as a place
of infinite love and oneness. And when
each of us brings out
that inner consciousness to the fore,
so then the collective Messiah emerges
to be able to transform all of humanity.
How does one differentiate
How does one differentiate between the
truly very sensitive people and the ones
who pretend to be very sensitive when in
fact they're just using their
sensitivity to control the situation, to
to manipulate people around them?
And there are people like that.
So, how do you know if they're really
sensitive or they're just using
sensitivity as a tool to manipulate?
Very interesting question that is.
So, the truth is that I have not met
such people, so I don't know. I don't
know how to answer that.
In other words, I don't think this is
something that's easy to fake
because people who are really sensitive
are not choosing to be sensitive. It's
not easy.
There's a famous expression in Proverbs,
"Yosef das, Yosef mach." King Solomon
says, "The more perception,
the more pain."
It's not something you choose. I don't
choose to be more perceptive, to pick up
energy that other people don't pick up.
Other people go to a wedding or a bar
mitzvah and they come home unscathed.
And I go to the same events and I pick
up the energy of so many people. It's
not something you voluntarily choose.
Either you have it or you don't have it.
So, I think I don't think it's something
I can feign or fake. People who are just
sensitive, they
there's a lot going on inside of them.
They're constantly processing things
that other people don't have to process.
There's a stimuli that they're detecting
and absorbing and it's creating and
wreaking havoc in our brains.
And and they can't sit still. They would
like to. They're not trying to make
other people's lives miserable or their
own lives miserable.
It's just something that they are really
experiencing and we have to respect it.
We have to create space for it. We have
to Those of you who don't understand
this, we have to understand this. You
may not be dealing with this. Wonderful.
Great. You know?
Enjoy life. Enjoy life. But this is not
something that people fake. I don't see
it. I don't see it.
Light at the end of the tunnel. What's
Judaism's perspective about that?
It's like somebody once told me, "Rabbi,
why?" Well, they said, you know,
"They tell me there's light at the end
of the tunnel. The problem is
that I don't got a tunnel."
So, what I would really say about this
is Of course, there's light at the end
of the tunnel.
But I think what's more important is to
realize
that the tunnel itself
is eclipsing a very deep light.
I think it's important to remember that.
What would the Rebbe say
about the situation in Surfside,
Florida, the collapsing of the tower and
the horrible tragedy?
It's a a important question, but
I'm not the Rebbe. So, I cannot tell you
what the Rebbe would say. Obviously, our
thoughts and prayers are with everybody
affected by it.
Of course, with those who have lost
loved ones and they have been confirmed.
And our thoughts are with all of them.
And of course, our thoughts and prayers
are with all the families who are
eagerly waiting and anticipating a
miracle.
And they're still searching and
searching and we pray and we hope
that there will be
survivors and that miracle will unfold
in front of our eyes. It's a very
difficult and surreal and and and
devastating moments and we just have to
be here with each other and for each
other holding hands together in unity
and in faith and in prayer and in deep
camaraderie. I am going to be giving
tomorrow morning a lecture at 9:45 a.m.
about a fascinating 4-hour talk that the
Rebbe gave in 1932
about never giving up on souls buried in
the rubble. He dissected a Talmudic law
instructed Yuma page 83 and I'm going to
be addressing that tomorrow 9:45 a.m.
You could tune in. It's going to be on
theYeshiva.net on my website the t h
e y e s h i v a dot net theYeshiva.net
9:45 you can tune in to a fascinating
talk of the Rebbe 1932 never give up on
any soul that may be found in the
rubble.
Um please help us out by filling out
this anonymous survey. There's a survey
here, so fill it out. You could see it
in the chat. Next question. Can I ask a
question? Sure, please. Hi, my name is
Miriam Kornitzer. I live in Clifton, New
Jersey. I'm actually a therapist. I've
been a therapist
from Clifton. Thank you. Thank you. And
So, I am a therapist and I specialize in
anxiety and eating disorders and
addiction. I kind of see I see teens, I
see adults. Right.
Kind of see kind of see everything. And
um
I So I'm I'm talking to 35 anxious
people a week and I do try to
incorporate some faith-based work to
like help my clients to cope.
Um I used to be Lubavitch. I'm not
Lubavitch anymore like religious
anymore, but I still am faith-based
person. I do believe that God loves me.
But so what I teach my clients is that
suffering is inevitable and the people
who find themselves so much anxiety is
because they want things to be wrapped
up in like a pretty little bow and they
want answers and they want to know it
and they're so afraid. They're so afraid
of living. So by me telling them like
suffering is inevitable, God didn't
bring us into the world to just have
this easy carefree life. We were
suffering was part of it.
So have some expectations about that in
life.
Is that a kosher thing to say? I mean
you know, I I always would say to rabbis
like punishment is in the Torah like
sometimes we can be punished and they
would say no, it's not true.
But
I don't know. Like is that is that part
of it that suffering is just inevitable
and that we are just going to be anxious
throughout our lifespan?
It's a great question. It's a great
question. As a therapist you're saying
for those who didn't understand um that
you teach your patients that suffering
is inevitable and this anxiety is part
of living and don't be afraid of living.
So
I think the fundamental idea you're
trying to convey is is noble and
important. But maybe the phraseology
could be a little more fine-tuned.
Or to quote paraphrase Dr. Edith Eger
you know, Dr. Edith Eger is an Auschwitz
survivor.
She's a 96-year-old practicing profess
practicing therapist in La Jolla,
California.
She published her first book at the age
of 91 called The Choice, and then her
second book The Gift.
And she lectures around the country, I
mean, at least till Corona.
And she has a line, she was in
Auschwitz. She lost her parents. It's an
incredible book. It's it's worthwhile to
read. The Choice The Choice by Edith
Eger.
And she says there,
uh she says, "Pain
is inevitable.
Suffering and victimhood
is a choice I have to make." I'm
paraphrasing. I don't remember if those
are the exact words.
And I think the main point she's saying
is, every one of us
confronts things that are painful.
But it's my reaction to it that really
defines my quality of life.
Anchored in faith doesn't mean
that I'm not experiencing pain.
But it means that I am not a victim.
As Joseph said, "I was not sold.
I was sent.
God sent me into this situation in order
to learn more about myself.
And in order to bring light into this
space of darkness.
So I don't have to fear whatever I'm
confronting. So I think that sentiment
is extremely noble. When the Torah
speaks about punishments, the
punishments should never be understood
as punishments coming from vengeance
or God, you know, losing himself, so to
speak, or bad impulses, or I'm going to
show you who's boss, you know, and I'll
teach you not to start up with me.
They're punishments that are there
to help the person
reach their ultimate potential
and fulfill their mission in this world
and in the next world, even if sometimes
we don't understand how and why.
So there's always a love behind it and a
meaning behind it and a purpose behind
it, which doesn't mean that it's easy.
Doesn't mean that it's rosy. It doesn't
mean that I'm living in La La Land, but
it means that I can anchor myself in a
source of faith and connection and
alignment with infinity that allows me
to look at my anxiety and instead of
surrendering to it in despair,
I ask myself, what is this anxiety
trying to teach me? How am I going to
grow from this? How am I going to emerge
from this more blessed?
I think this is a quintessential Jewish
idea. And thank you for everything you
do for all of your patients every week.
Thank you.
Rabbi, I have a question.
Yes, go ahead.
My name is My name is Yana Nesos and I'm
part of the Rebbetzin community people.
Okay, you're lucky.
You have one of the best rabbis in the
world. One of the best rabbis in the
world. And I'm also belonging to Reb
Vogel in Rochester, New York.
Um the word Thank you. The word rah
is bad. About
a million
people
friendship. Beautiful question.
A schmucky question. Wonderful.
So everybody understood the question.
The question was the word rah
means bad, right?
But the word rah is the same at the It's
the same letters as the word reya, which
means a friend.
Lereyacha kamocha.
Reya means a friend. In fact, the
Maharal of Prague has a book in his
Tiferes Yisrael has a section there
called the path to Ahavas Reya, to love
a friend. We say in the Sheva Brachos
when a couple gets married, we say, you
remember?
Ahava v'achva, shalom v'reut.
Love and brotherhood and peace and
friendship.
Beautiful question.
And the answer is listen very carefully
now. You remember what I said earlier in
the lecture that the real meaning of ra
is not bad?
The real meaning of ra is brokenness.
In tractate Bava Kamma we have an
expression koisel ra'uah.
A flimsy shaky wall that's wobbling,
that's not steady, that's not firm.
The word ra comes from Ecclesiastes,
Kohelet, hakol hevel ur'us ruach.
Broken spirit.
Because the genesis of all negativity
and evil is
the fact that I feel alone. I feel
broken.
I don't feel part of the whole. I don't
experience myself as part of infinity.
That brokenness is the beginning of
loneliness and trauma
that causes the toxicity
that allows me to engage in whatever
behavior I engage in. Now, here is the
point. The brokenness is part of life.
What do I do with it? I can go two ways.
Either I could find a friend, a re'ah,
or I can go to a place of ra, which is
addiction. You remember what I said
addiction?
The antithesis of addiction is not
sobriety. The antithesis of addiction is
connection.
So, there's brokenness in this world,
that's ra. What do I do with the
brokenness?
Either it cultivates, it inspires me, it
stimulates me to find friendship. Lo tov
hayot adam l'vado, it's not good for a
person to be alone. I want to be
attached, and that's how I help the
brokenness in the world, tikkun olam. I
repair the brokenness by creating
relationships, which allows me to become
back connected to the source of oneness.
And that's the idea behind marriage, and
that's the idea behind family, and
that's the idea behind friendship,
"V'ahavta l'reacha kamocha." Or, from
the same brokenness comes loneliness,
pain, victimhood, trauma, toxicity,
addiction.
It's a response to the same condition of
brokenness. The question is only what I
do with it.
Choice.
Um
Rabbi? Yes.
My name is Elisa. I I find this lecture
Hi. I find it extremely um
amazing, and I'm learning a lot. And I
do agree with everything, but I do have
one question for you.
Sure.
I'm a hypnotist and a life coach, and I
have been doing a lot of research on
uh
personality disorders, uh narcissistic
personality disorder, borderline
personality disorder.
And I was just wondering, when you said
that somebody who's been traumatized
doesn't actually have a choice, I would
beg to differ that through all my
research and the different readings that
I've done,
I would just disagree with you and say
that actually I believe that often, and
I think always,
the person actually does have a choice
um because if we take the stance and the
stand that that person is a victim
and doesn't have a choice, then we give
that person our power instead of
empowering ourselves. If somebody has
traumatized us because they play the
victim role, and they have been a
predator to us,
then we actually lose our empowerment,
and we give over all that power to the
person who plays the role
in the in the disguise in the guise of
being the victim. And I think that
that's what happens in the courts. I
think that's what happens in
relationships. I think it's a lot about
control and powers. I was just curious
about where you got that information
from because I also used to believe and
I'm not saying that I know your beliefs,
but I used to think
because I have so much compassion. I'm
an I'm an empath that
and working with different people that
the people who have been traumatized,
well, they need help. They can't help
it, but I actually believe and I think
it's important to take the stand that
um people who play the victim role
actually can make a conscious choice and
they are making conscious choices even
to actually do harm. And I don't think
that they should be let off the hook, so
to speak. I think that we have to
actually address this and especially in
the case of traumatization, uh abuse,
etc. So, I was just wondering what your
response to that would be.
Okay. Sure. Thank you, Alisa. So, for
those who didn't get it clearly,
Alisa was saying she's a hypnotist. She
works with a lot of different types of
people including people
who have suffered from trauma including
mental illnesses like borderline
personality
cases, etc., etc.
And she is taking strong objection with
what I intimated or said
that people with trauma have no choice.
Okay. So, thank you for the opportunity
to clarify. I don't think we're
contradicting each other.
What I meant was
that there's a trauma that it may exist
in me or in you or in another person
that I did not cause. I have no choice
in the sense that I have to confront
this trauma.
The moment I discover though that it's a
trauma, then I give myself the
opportunity to make choices.
In other words, if I deny that there is
a trauma there, then I really am a
victim to it cuz I have no choice. Cuz
this is just coming up and I don't even
know that I could react differently. I
think this is who I am.
This is the color of my eyes. This is
the color of my hair. Like people say,
"What do you want me to be? Not me?"
And it's interesting that a lot of
people, until they learn that it's a
trauma, they are actually complete
victims of it.
It's paradoxically, you get what I'm
saying? When I could learn that it's a
trauma. In other words, it's not me.
It's not my essence. Right. Something
happened. Huh?
Right.
If the person has healthy self-esteem to
actually Right.
Right. I could say, "You know what? You
know what?
I'm being aggressive. I'm being angry
now. You know, I have another choice.
There's a choice. I was I was not born
to be this angry, vindictive,
oppressive,
cruel person.
I was not created to be a narcissistic
person who can't create space for
anybody else. No, it's a survival skill
based on traumas. So, now I can actually
make a choice and say,
"I don't want to live by this trauma
anymore."
I may still have to deal with it, right?
You get it? You get it? That's what I
meant.
Yes, thank you so much for your time. I
appreciate Sure.
Sure, thank you for the question. Thank
you.
And this is so important for people. You
know, so important for people.
Right?
For example, there's a person
who has a difficult difficult marriage.
And
part of his trauma is
self-righteousness.
Alisa, you deal with these people all
the time, right? In their mind, they're
doing God's work.
They're torturing their wife or their
husband or somebody else, but in their
mind they're telling themselves, "I'm
doing God's work." Now, that itself is
literally their trauma playing out in
the most powerful way.
They are such pathetic victims
of their own patheticness that they
don't even realize how they're
destroying themselves and everybody else
in the process.
And I say to them and to me and to all
of us, if you could really get the help
you need and see
that your reactions are abnormal, your
reactions are destructive. They're
destroying you, they're destroying your
spouse, they're destroying your
children.
It's really your trauma. And when you
can discover that, you will be able to
make choices. You won't have to be an
eternal victim
to that horrible trauma that is
paralyzing you.
Correct.
They need to own it. It's own Own it.
Exactly. Exactly. You can own it. It's
difficult, it's painful because you are
triggered and the trauma is there and
you may not be able to eliminate it
until many new neural pathways are
developed in your brain and that may
take time.
But you could still own it. You could
still say, "You know what?
I'm bigger than this. I'm more powerful
than this. I'm more blessed than this.
I don't have to I don't have to be
locked up. I don't have to behave like a
criminal. I don't have to be so
vindictive. I don't have to let the
anger rule my life and my relationships.
I can give the anger compassion and
space, but don't let it take over your
life." Or my life.
person is mentally stable and aware,
yes. Of course, if the person is
mentally stable and aware, of course.
That's a prerequisite.
They have to be in a state where they
could where they can hear this. Thank
you for all your work. Any other
questions? Yes, Rabbi. Go ahead. Hi. My
name is Astra Lamb. Thank you. I've been
following you for a long time.
I love your lectures. Um
I wanted to first of all make one
comment and then I ask you a question.
So the comment is maybe it's funny but
it's from Batman. It's about pain and
something I remembered. I don't know if
you ever watched Batman. But there's a
part in Batman where like the servant
guy that you know is is talking to Bruce
Batman and he says why do we fall? And I
always think about this that the
tsadikim they fall seven times they rise
and he says you know only to rise again
and that like from pain expands
consciousness.
And
you know I've been going through a tough
ordeal with my family for the last six
weeks. My father's been ill
and we've had so many challenges but
then for every challenge Hashem sends us
like this great Yeshua and I feel like
we're like going through these levels
levels is like how are we going to react
and it really has solved a lot of like
crazy things in our family unfortunately
that it's been through this method but
um
So I had this moment like deep moment of
realization and it was like parallel to
what happened on serve side and maybe
you could answer this question you know
it seems to me that we wake up from our
slumber when we go through these
challenges you know then we find time
then we find compassion then we find
awareness then we stop judging then we
come together.
So what what can we do
to not have the you know to merit to
have this level of consciousness without
having you know to fall so many times.
What do we do on a day-to-day basis? Our
Rabbi Solomon just walked in as I'm
talking about this. So what what do we
do you know not to have to go through
these moments and to be able to you know
be on this level without um Excellent.
Excellent question. Excellent question.
Thank you. Thank you for your uh quote
from Batman and thank you for your
question.
Uh
So,
it's really
I would say you saying, "Why do we have
to wait for a crisis like a Surfside
catastrophe to be able to
bring us together, make us more refined,
um a tragedy in Iran like Baháʼu'lláh,
tragedy in Carleen, uh coronavirus?"
And I think, you know, we are creatures
of habit.
We easily resort back to our comfort
zones,
and we forget. We forget.
That's why
a major part of Judaism is
that ability
to create sustained
to to make sure that our epiphanies
at moments of great revelation
are sustained
daily through small acts, thoughts, and
words. For example, there's a daily
blessing we make every morning when we
wake up.
Thank you, God,
for spreading the Earth over the water
so that we have solid ground to work
walk on. Now,
what's that supposed to mean?
What it's supposed to mean is, can you
stop every moment for a few every day
every morning for a few minutes?
Can I stop and take a breath
and realize how many millions and
billions and trillions and zillions and
sextillions of things have to go right
for me to be able to walk on the face of
the Earth and live?
How many trillions of cells, 80 trillion
or 70 trillion cells have to function in
my body
to be able to create every day the
miracle of life?
And when I get into a plane, the fact
that the plane goes up.
When I walk into a building, the fact
that the foundations are functional.
The earth is on top of the water, the
water is not on top of the earth.
These are daily meditations to be able
to put us into a mindset
where we don't take life for granted.
Where we realize that every breath is a
miracle.
And that if one detail was not
fine-tuned perfectly to be able to
support the systems that allow for life
on our planet, nobody could have existed
for more than a split second.
You know, we just take it for granted.
And then when something goes wrong, it's
like
nothing is supposed to work. The entropy
principle teaches us that everything is
supposed to create chaos. But it
doesn't. We are alive.
But this requires ongoing sustained
meditation. So, what I would say to
myself and to all of us is, when you
have such a moment, don't let it become
a fleeting experience that passes.
Create rituals in your life
that allow you every single day to
become anchored
in a place of deeper awareness. That's
what prayer is about. That's what
meditation is about. That's what study
of Torah is about. That's what mitzvahs
are about. But we have to do it with
attentiveness, with mindfulness.
Take a few minutes every day and anchor
yourself. Go into that place of soulful
awareness.
And I want to tell myself every morning,
my reactions today are going to be
reactions that come from a place of deep
mindfulness, of deep spiritual
awareness.
So, that we don't need a crisis, heaven
forbid,
to make us the people that we want to
be.
Rabbi,
thank you so much Rabbi. Thank you very
much. That was very beautiful. Rabbi
Solomon says hello.
Rabbi Mendy Solomon?
Yes.
Thank you. Hello, this is this is Yana
again from Rebbetzin Lauren and Rabbi
Litz community.
How did is how did the the people of
Israel sin?
And why do they have to pay the price of
having Ishmael's people in Israeli
government?
To talk about the Israeli government No,
Ishmael's No, Ishmael's
uh netzigim in the Israeli government.
How could that How could that How could
this happen after all those years?
I don't know what to tell you.
Uh
This is pain and suffering.
I hear you. I I don't know what to tell
you.
But I do know that Israel has survived
on miracles.
So, the miracles will keep on coming.
Goodbye. Ben Gurion once said
They say in the name of Ben Gurion, who
was who considered himself an atheist,
by the way.
He once said, "To live in this They live
in the Middle East and you don't rely on
miracles, you're not a realist."
You know?
It's a lamb a lamb encircled by 70
wolves. Israel is a lamb encircled by 70
wolves.
How does a lamb
encircled by a pack of 70 wolves
survive?
But that's how it's been
for
3 and 1/2 thousand years.
We just have to be open to that miracle.
Yes. Rabbi
Thank you so much. I really have enjoyed
this. I was in education for 40 years
and a counselor and therapist and
um in in in some Thank you. In some of
my studies
um I came across the unpublished works
of Abraham Maslow that his wife had
published in a a journal for humanistic
psychology. He never finished it, but he
he came up with such a It's exactly what
you're talking about. He said it was if
you could just use this particular tool
in situations that might be precarious
for one reason or another where you feel
that you are emotionally losing it
um to get back into the moment because
that's basically we know what we're
talking about. But what he said was that
when you're in the situation, imagine
that this is the last time that you will
be speaking to this person.
Now, maybe it's the last time because
it's going to be
last time you see them the last you're
you're not going to continue to live or
they're not God forbid going to continue
to live.
But the point of the matter is
after having read this, it changed my
life because all those days that a
student would appear at my door when I
was a counselor for almost three decades
just doing that. I also was a teacher.
But
transformed into you know and and and
I had
more interest in being more of a
counselor, but when they would appear at
the door, I would say you know you know
like maybe you have 50 reports,
somebody's waiting on the phone, and can
I speak to you? Well, that might be the
child that's contemplating suicide.
So, I thought what do I What do I want
to do if this is the last time I'm going
to speak to this child? So, it became my
modus operandi.
And then I took it into my personal
life. And
my mother, God rest her soul,
you know, it was one of those days I was
picking her up. She lived in a senior
place.
I had to get home. I had to make dinner
for my husband. I had to to you know, it
was just 5:00 and and she I told her to
be downstairs. I told her to you know,
we're going shopping. I I have to have I
only have an hour.
And then all of a sudden it dawned on
me.
Make believe this is the last it like
make believe that this is the last time
you're seeing your mother.
Mother. Wow. And I looked at the window.
She lived on the second or third floor.
I looked at that window and I literally
went into a state of meditation where I
said, "That's where my mother used to
live."
And I got to a point
where I realized that that was going to
be reality, whether it's going to be my
passing or her passing. But there will
come an end to this relationship.
And by the time she got downstairs
and took her coat in and knocking on my
window because at that point I was in
such a deep state of gratitude of the
fact that my mother was alive and I had
another opportunity. And she said,
"Marian, are you okay?"
And I said
instead of what would have happened 15
minutes before, like why were you late?
I told you blah blah blah. That deep
dark part of myself,
I forgot myself.
And I completely became aware of the
moment and I looked at her and my words
were, "Mom, you are so beautiful." She
says, "Were you crying?" I said, "She's
just looks so beautiful."
I said, "I'm so happy to see you." And
then she went into I'm so sorry the
elevator I said, "Who cares about an
elevator? All I care is No,
my mother is gone. My mother is gone
15 years already. God rest her soul.
But I look back and I was transformed.
And I will never be the same because of
what I read. And
as a convert to Judaism
I have found
Jew as
uh I would when I was studying I wrote I
studied with Rabbi Clark, I studied with
Rabbi Leaf. We came across something
that was um
it was Aristotle's uh
Aristotle wrote a letter.
And the letter was that he would have
burned all of his books
had he found the Torah first.
Because it is in the Torah
that all truth is. And everything the
world is just upside down. Everything
that looks bad is good. It is Hashem
working in mysterious ways. Wow.
How many years ago did you convert to
Judaism?
Uh
just two, but I Wow. I have I have an
interesting story sometime I'd like to
You grew up you grew up in a Catholic
home? In a Christian home?
Wow. But I I was a philosophy and
religion major and I was teaching
Judaism when I I mean I'm
in my my 60s and I was teaching Judaism
in my 20s in in Union High School
because in the sociology department and
fell in love then I
fell in love with a 3-month-old
baby I when I was first married we lived
in a an Orthodox community in Elizabeth.
And we were uh the only Gentile.
Rabbi Tites, yeah? Yeah, Rabbi Tites.
And Rabbi Tites was my neighbor.
And Rabbi Pinchas Tites.
Yeah, so I don't want to
I the story is so long that it's it's
not for tonight, but
Okay, that's amazing. Thank you for
sharing. You you are a source, Marianne,
you are a source of inspiration and
enlightenment to all of us.
Well, right back at you, Rabbi. Now, you
you you mentioned Abraham Maslow
and his insight which changed your life.
It's worthwhile to note
that Maslow, Abraham Maslow, passed away
while he was jogging. He suffered a
severe heart attack while he was jogging
unexpectedly
and he died in June 1970 at the age of
62.
In California, this was. So, his his
observation when he said, "You never
know
if this conversation
with this student or with this friend or
with this parent or with this person
might be the last one."
You know, sadly, he just
he was just taken suddenly.
So, it's so important to be able to have
that mindful mindfulness and not allow
such a you're
that's beautiful.
I just want to say thank you for
everything that you have given. You are
you've been such an inspiration to me.
I've been listening to you for years and
years and you are a big part of my
conversion.
And I I and as as Rabbi Clor, Rabbi
Leaf,
and uh
I just can't thank you enough. God bless
you, your family. Baruch Hashem for you.
May you live a long, healthy life and
dance at your great grandchildren's
weddings.
Amen. Amen. That means so much.
Same to you and thank you
for being such a source of light and
serenity
and faith. Baruch Hashem.
Thank you.
Okay, Rabbi Clor, you want to uh
say goodbye to all of the wonderful
kindred spirits that are gracing us here
this evening.
I I felt
when we all decided to invite you to
speak that this was crucial. I don't
think there's any more important and you
did such an amazing job.
Everybody has to hear this. So, I'm
going to push this uh this recording of
this class for the next long while. I'll
make sure all my kids see it and all my
friends and anybody I care about.
It was uh really wonderful and so
helpful and um and the questions that
came up from everybody, it just it's
just wonderful. I thank you all. Thank
you.
Thank you Rabbi Jacobson and um Thank
you Rabbi Clark. Thank you Rabbi Leaf.
Thank you Chabad of Montclair. Thank you
Chabad of Essex County. Thank you all
the Chabads and everybody gracing us
here from New Jersey
and from all the communities wherever
you are. Sending you my love and light
and blessings.
Chazak, chazak, veniskhazek.
And may we together hold hands always,
be connected with our souls and with our
deepest infinite light and with God to
be able to transform
all of our own darkness
and the darkness around us into a
catalyst and springboard for light and
reveal that infinite light of Moshiach
that exists in each and every one of us
until the whole world
will be transformed by that collective
light
speedily in our days. Thank you very
much. Good night.
Thank you. Thank you so much.
This class is brought to you by the
Yeshiva.net.
Please help us continue the classes.
Make even a small contribution at
www.theyeshiva.net/donate.