Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

A Tale of Two Questions

2,607 views
Rabbi YY Jacobson avatar
Rabbi YY Jacobson

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

it was a few years ago before corona i was giving my morning sheer to men and there was a man there 45 years old and he's looking at me and i see he wants to ask a question but he's he's having trepidation he's nervous he's anxious so i encourage him i say frank fleck asked no no i push him ask i want to hear your question man that's a stupid question i'm like i'm not continuing this class till you ask a question i love stupid questions because they're usually the most brilliant questions so you asked a question it was a good question i answered the question we went on at the end of the class i said i'm just wondering do you know why you were so afraid of asking the question everybody asks questions i don't mind i like questions so he says yeah i'll tell you the story and he says it in front of everybody he says he was a boy in grade two and they were learning parsha's boy and para tells moisherabenu that the women and the youth he should leave in egypt the elders can leave so moshe says we're going to go with our youth and with our elders and then he says with our sons and with our daughters nailer will go why does it say twice nailer in the past i could have just said one sentence the teacher who didn't have such pedagogical sensitivity says all these questions you'll ask for the seder this is not a question you ask it's a foolish question and he told me since then whenever a child asked a question and they wanted to make fun of the question they would say binary biscanani i never asked a question again in my life so this is the first time i asked a question in class at the age of 45 that's why i was hesitant [Music] at the sheer sitting the custom last night the straw lamb is his name mazultev to the lamb and mises family and he says let me tell you my story he was learning here in muncie and he said i asked a question i was also in second grade and when i finish asking the question the teacher says israel come with me to the principal's office i'm like oh yeah now let's ask questions i'll get you punished it was an innocent question i'm like oh what did i do he brings the principal's office i go into the office and he tells the principal this boy asked the question it was such a beautiful question i was so inspired by it i wanted the principal should hear ask the question again and he asked the question again and the principal gives him a big piece of chocolate for asking such an amazing question and yesterday looks at the class he said and since then i didn't stop asking questions it's one word that shatters somebody's dignity or builds somebody's dignity it's so important especially people in education don't be stingy with warmth [Music] the yeshiva.net