Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
okay hi everybody thank you for coming I
apologize for being a bit late for some
reason the buses were very slow today
today uh first the sh tonight is
dedicated ra
to and
margit may they
have and may our Torah be for a for them
and for all in
addition
fori and um Henry lvin the brother
of Lori Poston lvin and Ray Lavin uh he
was nifter he passed away this week
after a long illness and uh may he have
a a wonderful share in Ganan and may our
learning beo Nish in addition s bzra
Hali whose yard site is the 26th of a
and this is the mother of Jeremy and
Jillian Bernstein again we hope that the
learning should be
at uh we are uh in the period of 3 weeks
uh we just we had the fast of of the
17th of Tas this year on the 18th of
thas because the 17th of Tas was on
chabas and there actually is quite a few
connections between the paraa and the
three weeks and I just want to talk
first a little bit about the three weeks
in general and then we'll Zoom down into
the details of the of the
paraa ruk of
Lin uh in different places in hisum
offers three different perspectives on
the three weeks there three related
observations although they can in fact
be connected uh the first observation is
let's talk about the 17th of Thomas you
now the 17th of Thomas originally would
have been a very very joyous day that
was the 40th Day from Matan Torah that
was the day that mosha Renu was in fact
did come down with the
luos the tablets that would be given to
B Israel that in fact was what he
brought down but we lost faith we lost
confidence we were afraid he wasn't
going to show up we worshiped the golden
calf so as a result instead of the 17th
of tamas being a day of Matan Torah it
became a day of
Nishu and that in turn led to a whole
bunch of other tragedies in the course
of time uh y being broken into and the
cessation of the carbon tet etc etc but
at least in potential the 17th of tamas
was supposed to be kind of a day of
redemption a day of GAA p is the day we
left MIT shivu is the day we heard the
Ten Commandments shivas would have been
the day that we physically got the luos
from Hashem that represented the Torah
so it was a potential day of Joy a day
of redemption a day of freedom because
tell
us there was no one who is free except
one who was connected to the
Torah has a fascinating correlation he
actually says that the three weeks which
start from shivas
SAS and then they culminate in
Tish represent so so he counted three
weeks plus
Tish correspond to the four leonos of
redemption when God took us out of MIM
he utilized four stages of
Redemption the three weeks and Tish
above are four stages of estrangement
and distancing they're kind of like the
if you remember the old cameras before
they were digital cameras they're like
the photographic
negatives of the four Lonas of
GAA that if the four Lonas of GAA are
progressive levels of
closeness nearness to God the three week
on the ninth of is distancing from God
but here is the thing the same way you
could ascertain a photograph by looking
at the negative I look at the negative
and I I know what the photograph looks
like so too it is the process of
estrangement that simultaneously is
bringing us closer to God everyone knows
the famous saying I think it may be from
Shakespeare but it's a famous English
proverb absence makes the heart grow
fer it is sometimes an awareness of how
far we are from
God that stirs up within our heart a
yearning and that yearning can be the
deepest
closeness that can exist Sook says on
one hand the three weeks and the ninth
of are the opposite of the four Lon of
GAA because the four Lon of gula are
levels of closeness and these are levels
of estrangement and
distance but at the same time it's a
mirror image because estrangement and
distance can generate a passionate
yearning for closeness and that itself
creates the closeness that creates the
closeness the yearning to be close to
God makes you close to God that's how it
works because God yearned
simultaneously I remember reading once
uh not that uh she's any type of source
this uh was a novel by Anne
Rand uh this probably the first time
I've ever mentioned an ran uh but not
the famous ones not Atlas Shrug and not
the fountain something that she wrote
the
alusa uh it was about life in the Soviet
uh Soviet Union it was like a novel
against the oppression and it talked
about two
lovers who were arrested and they were
sentenced to life imprisonment
and uh the court system was so cruel
that they wouldn't even allow them to
kind of be imprisoned in the same place
they had to be imprisoned 500 miles
apart and they're on their last train
ride the last ride in which they will
ever see each other
again and they made an agreement that
every night at a certain time we will
look at the Moon together at the same
time you're one place I'm in another
place and in that way we'll be connected
on some level
now you know anran later gravitated to
all sorts of different philosophies
objectivism selfishness I'm not going
there but this is a very powerful
imagery it's the imagery that sometimes
the deepest closeness you can
have is when you're apart and that's
what the three weeks in the ninth of a
is it is the closeness that comes from
distance in a more humorous vein when
rev hoodner came to erisel towards the
end of his life so somebody had the ask
hutner was there anything that he missed
about so he said yeah the great thing
that he missed about was the
yearning to come
to because once you're here you take it
for granted you take anything for
granted but when you're there you're
yearning you're thinking about it and in
some ways your is making the point you
were closer emotionally to the idea of
erel than neb when you're here as
strange as that is there's a lot of
Truth to that observation a person could
be in and be thinking every minute oh
I'm yearning and I'm hoping and I so
want to be here when you're here you
know either you're not thinking about it
or sometimes you're thinking negative
things about all the different
inconveniences and the like so that's
observation number one that it's
precisely as we experience how far we
are from Hashem
we actually simultaneously and
paradoxically become much much closer to
a god in that process that is the
meaning of the famous statement in the
gamorra that mashiach is born on
Tish now that doesn't have to mean that
the flesh and blood mashiah has a
birthday on
tiab obviously um kabad cannot take that
position because the Reb's birthday was
in the month of Nissa
right but but again once again the moral
himself says that the gamari does not
mean the birthday of the human that's
mashia or will be mashiah is Tish but it
means the kak of mashiach enters the
world through the yearning and the sense
of distance that we experience anti of
as I realize how far I am from God that
creates a yearning and a
connection and it's that yearning and
connection that brings the power of
redemption into the world okay that's R
sadok's first
observation R second observation is that
the concept that we need three weeks to
prepare ourselves to mourn for the B
mikdash corresponds to the idea that the
BAM mikdash was destroyed because our
heart and our soul was no longer a
dwelling place for god let's go back to
the very first time a Mitzvah of
building a temple is discussed this is
about the mishan in the
midbar so Hashem said to
Moshe they shall make for me a temple a
Sanctified
area so I God will
dwell in them in them and point out it
does not
say I will dwell in it rather the Hashem
dwells in our heart and our soul so when
you have a bikash that is simply a
tangible
sign that God's presence is in your
heart and in your
soul so why does the temple get
destroyed because when God is no longer
in our
hearts the symbol is no longer
meaningful God takes it away like the
symbol would be an empty symbol I mean
what is the temp a nice
building the Temple is a
symbol of the sh that lives within
us when the does not live within us no
Temple so says we know that there are
three although give specific
a says there are three essential
character
flaws which Drive the divine presence
from our heart and our soul and this is
encapsulated pabos at K jealousy
Envy begrudging The Good Fortune of
other people
Kina TAA insatiable
Lust For
pleasures and Cav out the need for ego
gratification self
agisent these negative character
flaws they take take a person out of the
world and the alter of used to say it
doesn't only mean you lose your world to
come that's for sure but it means your
life in this world becomes an unending
frustration Le the same floss that we
attribute to bams students
or uh yes yes as a matter of fact they
are the same ones although they're
they're expressed in different
vocabulary but in point of fact they
match up uh those three match up the
K even says
that matches up to the three
most in inverse order he says that
jealousy could lead to
murder TAA can lead to improper sexual
offenses and he says kot can lead to
self idolatry which is a form of the
greatest form of AAR where I worship
myself I look at myself as the center of
of all existence and and alike so he
connects the three weeks with the three
factors of
kavod and that leads into the students
of bam and that can lead to the three
most which of course are indeed the
cause for theb of the first base amik as
the gar says in Yuma so we need three
weeks so to speak to work on these three
mid
of that's his second take on the 3 weeks
the third observation he makes is also
very interesting and it's based on the
ha torus we know that our enacted that
on chabas and on yam when after you read
the Torah we have a section of the
prophets that are read and that's called
the ha Torah when I was little I think I
said this before I came up with thees
when I first heard the phrase oh well
the reason why you call it half Torah is
because it's the half Torah because the
prophets are not not as important as the
Torah so we call the prophetic reading
the half Torah that's how I understood
it that's a pretty good that's a pretty
good terce but uh but when I got to
havala that I I couldn't I didn't have
an interpretation for that one so I had
to beiser uh but ha just in terms of a
verb actually means to announce is to
announce we have a prophetic uh section
now kazal for the most part do not tell
you what Theus are it has to be
connected to the par or the and that's
why they're different
Asim Italians yakis hungarians many many
different choices for H Torah and all of
them are Kosher it's not possible that
one is right and one is wrong because
the gamar itself does not
mandate what the haor has to be other
than connected to either the par or if
it's a yum connected to the yff and the
like right that's why there are
different minhagim and it's not not a
question of one is right and one is
wrong from time immemorial there always
were different local traditions for the
h but kazal did enact that three weeks
before the nth of a we must read three
half Tyrus dealing with
tragedy and then for seven weeks after
the ninth of a which takes you all the
way to rashishana we have to read seven
hav Toros dealing with the theme of com
three of
Calamity and seven Haus of comfort which
actually takes you all the way to
rashash we will talk about the Haus of
comfort when when the time of comfort
comes and hopefully it'll get her before
Tish
even not then we'll talk about it after
Tish but the three halfus
of uh the first of them is going to be
this
chabas uh the first two are from the
book of yahu who is the prophet of
Destruction and the third one the one
right before Tish is from Isaiah
yes the vision of yes yes is by the way
all the Haus of comfort are from yes yes
is the big big Nai of the most Comforts
in all of tanak but the last ha of
tragedy is BFA from yes
R Points out if you just look at the
first word of the three h tyus you see a
very very interesting pattern the first
ha this
sh which is chapter one of saer yo
begins div y the words of
Y the second T which is peric BAS of
yo the navi is talking and he says
sh here listen to the word of God and
the third ha which is right before Tish
that this year it'll be on on Tish on
the nth of which is shabas
is the
vision
of so just look at look at look at the
first three words of of Theus you go
from
speech to
hearing to
as if to say speak no
evil hear no evil see no evil and R
sedok says that during this period of 3
weeks we are we try to be
misaking our various sensory
functions we
start with learning to
recognize both the positive power of
speech
and the negative power of speech to
be
the of
debor and then we try to
move to not just using my speech in a
proper way but to try to avoid even
hearing negative things about
people purify what we
hear and then finally we change our
vision we change our perception again
this is actually a very important point
I think I made this point many many
times I'll say it quickly again and that
is Lan you know everybody today and
Brash it's a good thing CL I mean we
still commit the but CL Isel is very
very
conscious that there's something bad
about saying derogatory things about
people lanara is on the radar whether we
fully keep it or not is another question
but people are aware of it they take it
a religious person at least takes it
seriously and I'll tell you the truth
even nonreligious Jews there's a whole
school of what you might call
non-orthodox muser out there in which
they learn muser books and they they
they try to incorporate it's actually a
good thing they try to incorporate mid
toos even though not all of them are
keeping the mitzvos in a literal way so
this type of Consciousness about not
being negative about people is something
that permeates uh people's minds but you
have to know that ultimately lanara is
it's not about speech it's about
perception because if I look at people
in a negative
way and I but I control
myself at some point I'm going to
explode like a pressure cooker you can't
constantly look at people in a negative
way and never say anything bad about
them so the real
goal
of in lashan Hara is not simply to
control your
mouth but to change the way you see
things
to change your vision to look at people
in a kindly way in a favorable way in a
loving
way and when you look at people that way
it's not that you'll become naive you'll
still see the problems but you will
literally lose the desire to say bad
thing I just don't have a desire to put
people
down it's like you know let's say your
son is not doing something uh the way
that he should be doing you know you you
you don't have a big desire to kind of
talk to people about it I mean unless
you're seeking help but just uh
humiliate your son humiliate you're
you're you're humiliating
yourself every
Jew fact this is a fascinating little
thing I uh there was
aant who was the again interesting name
he was the rash V he died recently and
he left behind a very uh controversial
Memoir it was never published now
whatever it is that he has all sorts of
interesting strange stories uh very very
fascinating but he recounts a very one
little V that's really very good that
one time in brisk uh they were
denigrating Ru cook know he Zionist he
was too close to non-religious people so
somebody had theah to ask one of the
brisk Ras you know you have your cousin
at yiv
University yoseph Jo Sal who's also a
Zionist and you never say anything bad
about it how come you never criticize
Rabbi yose do
salv so the brisar Riva said that's
different that's a family now Family you
don't criticize so the person said back
to the brisar Risha well rev cook looked
at every Jew as family so even if they
weren't religious he didn't critic do
you're criticizing Ru cook for not
criticizing Jews who are not religious
why don't you criticize your cousin the
answer is my family I don't criticize so
of every Jew is his family he doesn't
criticize same thing what's the T right
so R elephant records that the brisker
rashash Shiva was absolutely silent
after that that particular uh response
so this is the progression you start off
controlling your speech and your hearing
but the ultimate goal is K change your
vision change your perception when you
change your perception then everything
falls into place you're not struggling
anymore not to speak lanara or to
embarrass people you just lose the
desire it just goes
away because you look at people in a
very very different
way is the ultimate goal not just
control your speech and control your
hearing change your vision change how
you look at things so it turns out
though that the first week of the three
weeks this para this haa coming up is
about the power of
speech and we need to think about the
power of speech there is a verse in
Proverbs famous verse
hes death and life
are in the hands of the
tongue said this the
med explains the P quite literally it
says that once the different organs and
limbs of the body were debating I'm not
sure how they conversed who is the most
powerful so the leg said we're the most
powerful because without me the body
can't go
anywhere and the hands and the arms say
we're the most important because without
me you can't grasp or do anything
and the Brain said I'm the most powerful
because without me there's no thoughts
and no actions so finally the tongue
said I'm the most powerful so they
started laughing at the tongue the medra
says because they said hey tongue you
don't even have a backbone you can't
even like stand up you know you're so
insignificant and the tongue said okay
you'll see how important I am uh what
basically was that uh all of this took
place in the body of a servant of a king
a non-jewish king and and uh when they
when the servant reaches the King's Room
so uh the tongue causes the Declaration
hey King you're like a dead dog or
something now there was the tongue says
something derogatory so the king said
kill this person off with the head so
all the limbs are frightened and they
beg the tongue do something about this
you got us into trouble so the tongue
said oh yeah I come from another country
and in my language the words that mean
wretched dog in your language actually
means glorious ruler in my language and
I apologize I was using my language and
I should have use whatever it is this
the bottom line of the story is the
tongue says you see I could get you
killed and I can get you saved death and
life is in the hands of the tongue but
you have to understand something very
important that life and death does not
just mean
physical
survival we have to know
that death can occur in many different
ways you can kill a person's
Spirit you can take away their hope you
can rob them of their
Courage by words that are cruel
hurtful
humiliating and that's death also but
the other thing is important as well and
here this is where I have a little a
teeny little bit of critic criticism on
the f Fus on lashara because lashan Hara
is always focusing on how destructive
speech can
be and that is true but remember there's
another side to this schom doesn't only
say death in is in the hands of the
tongue SCH also says
life is in the hands of the tongue in
other words
speech can give a person
hope can give a person optimism can give
a person a sense that they're wanted
that they're needed that they're cared
about words can
destroy and words can build
up you see they tell the story that you
know the wrote books on lanara he was
the one who really brought the laws of
lanara to the consciousness of CLA
Israel and it's interesting that that
the early part of the K's career a lot
of even rabbis didn't really believe
that he could truly live up to his own
standards so they would send spies to
visit him now people would come as
rabbis or guests and they wanted to trip
him up in different ways so one of these
spies reported an interesting exper
experience he says he came to the and he
expected that the would be very austere
never talk never say anything except
learning and dobing but he noticed that
was a very talkative person he would
talk he would tell stories he would ask
questions but sonin-law was indeed so
super
righteous he would never say a
word unless it was daving or
learning so the person said I spent that
chabas there and I was much more
impressed with the
son-in-law than with the because seemed
to be a loose
fer but then I
realized how absolutely great this
was the son-in-law avoided the sin of
Lara by basically not
talking said well wait a second God gave
us speech in fact speech is considered
to be the unique quality of
man famous taramas God breathed into man
a living soul the tarum unus in a very
rare non-literal addition because unus
is normally very literal says
r a spirit that can
speak so there's no point in just
covering up my power of
speech I have to use it for good
purposes to build up build people up you
know the old adage that maybe we were
told by our parents
sticks and stones may break my
bones but names will never hurt
me is unfortunately not very
true Sticks and Stones can break your
bones but you also heal you know young
kids tend to heal pretty quickly when
we're a little older it takes a little
longer but you know even older people
can can heal very
often but the names the insults the
humiliations even as we get as children
can stay with
us the rest of our lives sometimes the
rest of our lives I mean I remember
hearing an
interview with Richard Nixon after he
had left the presidency of the United
States and he had been through a lot
obviously he had been as vice president
he had been through the Cold War and
then uh the engagement with China as
president and then of course Watergate
and leaving the presidency in utter
disgrace right the only well actually
until well okay actually with Trump he's
not unique anymore but what whatever it
was and yet what was Richard Nixon
talking about he was talking about the
playground
taunts in the fifth and sixth
grade it's kind of scary that people who
are making decisions that can blow up
the
world are thinking about what happened
when they were in sixth
grade so he tell your sixth grader to be
pretty careful how he treats his
classmate he never knows where that
classmate's going to wind up in
somewhere
so this is what speech
is speech can change a person for the
good or for the bad and when we think
about this first week of the three weeks
R sok says we're thinking about a
t of the
now what is amazing is there's a direct
Connection in the para
itself to how powerful
speeches the paraa
begins with the concept of making a
Ned a
vow or a
shua an
oath helically these are different
verbal formulations so a vow is object
focused an oath is person focused let me
give you an example let's assume I don't
want to eat apples or CH maybe chocolate
more realistic I want to go on a diet I
want to be absolutely sure that I don't
eat chocolate so if I say all chocolate
is forbidden to me object language
that's called n if I say I swear I will
not eat chocolate that's called
the but either way whether you make your
commitment in the form of n or or the
form of sh the Torah
says you are not
allowed to
desecrate your words if you eat a piece
of
chocolate after you made a nether or
shua it is as bad as eating a piece of
bacon it is trafe it is forbidden to you
you're over and
isera for which you could get
lashes now what's interesting
is you see from here the extraordinary
power that God gave to human
speech to create spiritual
realities that otherwise would not
exist
God In His Infinite kindness did not
declare chocolate to be
trfe one of the hasem right so chocolate
I I mean we believe especially with a
cabalistic perspective that when you
weat tra you know you're affecting not
just yourself you're affecting the world
you're bringing impurity into the world
so that's a certain Dynamic there's a
certain cause and effect that these sins
affect the Dynamics of the
universe chocolate does not have that
power and
yet once
you by the power of your
words made that chocolate
prohibited you have vested in the
chocolate all of the destructive
negative powers that God put into the
Peace of kazer or whatever it is so if
you think about it NE is quite an
amazing
example of the power of
speech to change
spiritual
realities again we're not going to give
a there are ways of annulling vows going
to a Bas and Etc there are ways of
getting out of vows but you have to go
through a procedure meaning if you don't
go through a procedure The Vow remains
binding no matter what now generally
speaking our sages discourage making
vows even if you want to go on a diet
don't do it through a vow K very much
discourage it but sometimes people do
make these vows and they need to know
that it has to be taken taken very very
very seriously and I would suggest that
it actually fits R sok's analysis that
the first week of the three weeks is
about recognizing the power of speech
the kak of debor that speech creates
reality now I know I know I'm going to
get the comments on this so I I will
preface that I'm say I'm going to tell
you something now that some say was a
madeup story and not proven I know that
so you don't have to write and tell me
this but I I'll tell you the story as it
was reported and to repeat I am aware of
the fact that many many people have
questioned the accuracy of the report so
I please don't write me to tell me this
uh and that is uh they showed under an
electron microscope an electron
microscope is a very powerful microscope
that can actually see things at the
molecular level and even below that uh
and they looked at water molecules just
GL a glass of water so water is H2O
right a molecule of water is two atoms
of hydrogen that are bound to one of
oxygen and when they're bound together
in a certain way that creates the
liquids of
water so they basically said that the
molecules themselves assume different
configurations based on whether the
speech in the room was angry or whether
it was kind meaning when there was angry
speech the molecules rearranged
themselves in ugly
patterns and when there was kind and
gentle speech the molecules arranged
themselves in beautiful patterns can I
say some have said that this is not a
true story but even if it's not true on
the electron microscope
level I believe it very much is true on
the ultimate spiritual level of the way
the universe functions right so whether
I have the empirical proof from the
microscope is actually a secondary Point
uh the point of this story does not rise
and fall on whether you could see this
in the
structure of the molecule but it is
certainly an element of the spiritual
world that we
inhabit and people talk about this
speakers talk about this I feel The
Vibes in the room it's a common thing
right I mean I I exper it uh what does
it mean I You Feel The Vibes where you
getting that we do have I mean some
people are more psychic than others
that's a gift that is distributed in
different ways but almost everybody kind
of has a sense of emotional energy
that's being generated in a room in a
crowd and that affects us in various
ways and speech is one of the primary
conduits for that emotional energy Okay
so I think the para ofed and shu is a
very good example of the kak ofb but now
I want to derive another aspect of this
now that not this is not in this para
this is actually in next week's para now
now most years we actually would have
read two paros together we would have
read Matos which is this week and
masi this year we're splitting because
this is the uh the opportunity for the
people in to catch up because the people
in are one par
behind so this week they're going to be
reading
Pinas we're going to be reading
Matos next week when we read masi they
will read
Matos and after three months we finally
caught up so in order to giveus the
chance to catch up with us we actually
split two paros that most years are
actually read as one big par so I'm
going to take the homiletical license so
to speak to borrow something from Paras
Masai Paras
masi and this is not the only place in
the Torah we had it earlier the Torah as
well talks about the special rules that
apply uh for accidental homicides we'll
call them
manslaughters right non-intentional
killing of people so we don't give the
death penalty for that but what we do is
there's a City of
Refuge uh where a person stays and this
is a very indeterminate sentence a very
strange sentence he stays in the City of
Refuge until the cohain God dies and
when the Cohen godal dies he then goes
free so if the Coen godal dies one day
after his sentence he goes free after
one day if the Coen gel dies 50 years
later he goes free after 50 years if he
dies before for the Coen gutle he is
buried in the City of Refuge not to be
taken out until the Coen gutle
eventually dies this is really a very
strange sentence it is an indeterminate
sentence and the like but nevertheless
the
RO remains in the year miklat until the
Coen God dies the missionary records in
Mas
makos that the mothers of Coen
godles used to bring the roim in the
year mikl care packages cookies and and
Foods in order that the roim should not
pray that their sons would die because
if I'm stuck in a near mikl and I would
like to get out I might pray to Hashem
that he caused the coing GLE to die so
in order that I shouldn't pray that the
Coen gutal should die the parents of the
Coen GLE or the mothers that says would
bring gifts or food to the RO right this
is a
mishna both the B and the
USI ask the same
question the implication
is that if the roim were to pray to
God that the Cohen GLE would
die there is a
chance those prayers would be
effective because if there's no chance
the prayers would be effective what are
the mothers afraid
of so
apparently their prayer might
work so the gorra says how could that
work if the coing godle is a righteous
person why would he be
vulnerable to the prayer of aak that the
Coen GLE should
die why would such a prayer work can you
just pray that somebody should die so
listen to the so both the B and the you
me ask the
question but they give different
answers the B's answer is it is
true that if I pray that a blameless
innocent person should
die my prayer is not going to work I
can't just pray that an innocent person
should
die but the Coen guttle Is Not
Innocent the Coen GLE is vulnerable to
somebody praying that he should
die because the coing gutle is at
fault for not praying as a spiritual
leader of his generation he should have
prayed that such
homicides would not take place under his
watch therefore if such homicides did
take place under his watch he didn't
pray enough he didn't pray enough he
becomes complicit he becomes blameworthy
Ergo he would be vulnerable to the
prayer of the RO and that's why the RO
needed to be
bribed now let's think about this a
little bit the rule that a roak goes to
an near
mlet does not refer to every accidental
homicide I mean if somebody is standing
on a roof of a building and the roof
collapses and he falls on somebody in
the first floor and kills that person he
does not go to the a mlet that's an
unavoidable action
he had no reason to suspect it's very
important to understand ear mikl is not
for every accidental
homicide ear mlut requires
negligence carelessness you went through
a stop sign you didn't stop at an
intersection you backed up without
looking to see if there was a kid in
back it's unintentional you didn't
intend to kill anybody but you were
careless you were indifferent
you didn't care enough about the
possibility right you threw uh garbage
you threw heavy items out of your window
trash and a kid gets killed with a pot
or something now here's the thing can I
pray that God please don't let negligent
people be careless please help people be
more careful you see the problem there k
say everything is in the hands of
heaven but the decision to serve
God I cannot pray that somebody should
be righteous because that's their
decision it's not God's decision God
does not
decide if people are righteous or
Sinners right I've mentioned before my
my rosh yite rman of
maryell was just this past week the 14th
of of of uh Tas
I post and help we make a video for n
Isel about this and one thing which I
did not mention in the video was that at
the beginning of every we would go to
the Riva we would ask him um for a br
and he would say are you going to learn
well this
man and uh he would say we would say we
would
say if God's God Wills we will learn
well and his answer is God certainly
Wills but it's not up to God the
decision is up to you you should say if
I will I will learn well so the question
on the B is this how can the B
assume that the Coen God's
prayer would have stopped the
irresponsible
behavior of the
road so says the
Kish there are other ways of learning
this but I'll just go tonight with the
K that you see from here that the power
of prayer is so
great that it overrides the principle of
free
will that yes I can pray that somebody
should do chuva I can pray may my
careless brother-in-law be not as
careless when he
drives I can pray I that's free will and
God doesn't interfere with free will in
the context of prayer he does and the
Kish actually says you can
pray that Hashem should make an evil
person into a sadic that is the kak of
prayer and of course uh the Kish has a r
from AAR in Bros if you remember rebbi
mayor had enemies that he wanted to
curse we talked about this and uh breur
his wife said why should you curse them
that they should die
pray that they should do
chuva so what do you see from the garish
like the Kish you can
pray that somebody does Chua now I had
mentioned that some learn this very very
differently some learn you cannot really
pray that somebody does cha you can only
pray that Hashem put into their lives
inspirational people that will bring
them to Chua that's the alternative and
that's what the mar isma but the
actually says cut and dry you can pray
that a Russia should do chuva and uh
this is what the is telling us the co
God could have prayed that the caress
driver will stop at the red light even
though that's a function of B now that
is what the B says thei asks the same
question
why is the Coen GLE
vulnerable to the prayers of the
murderers that the murderers have to be
bribed so the so the B's answer was
because the Coen gutle has culpability
that he didn't
do Yi says and this is even scarier that
the power of prayer is so
great that it can work even against a
person who's undeserving meaning other
words a person who is undeserving of of
being punished meaning you can pray that
a righteous
person would die and Hashem might listen
to the prayer so the point I'm making is
that both according to the B and
according to the
Yami right our talk tonight is about the
power of
speech so one aspect of the power of
speech is the power of
prayer and you see from both the B and
the
Yi the tremendous power of Prayer from
the bav perspective we see the power of
the prayer of the Coen
God from the US's perspective we see the
power of the prayer of the RO that they
could get a CO even though he's not
guilty of anything right the Yi is
taking the position the co is not guilty
right so the power of prayer so we have
to
recognize the power of our daving but
once again one has to be
realistic davening does not mean
you get whatever you
want if I could quote uh so I had Ann
Rand and I'm going to quote MC Jagger
strange uh assortment of of sources
tonight uh that's when people ask me for
a sour sheet you know why I don't give
it I'm not going to give them you know
MC Jagger and an rant but um MC Jagger's
song You Can't Always Get What You Want
but you get what you
need and that is a very profound that is
a Rel
religiously deep truth although MC Jager
probably did not intend it in that way
and that
is amuna is not
panish I would love a new car I'll just
pray to God for a new car and I'll have
that new car in my
lot no maybe you won't maybe you will
that can happen too but that's not
there's no guarantee about those
things but I will give you what you need
and sometimes that refers to the
resilience and courage of being able to
go on being able to
rebuild being able to recover from
tragedies there's no
guarantee of what will or won't
happen but
every has a power the power of your
speech coupled with your
heart brings down all sorts of blessings
the greatest greatest of
is your
relationship
withes let me just end with one further
garar kadan the kadan gives a very
strange story it's hard to understand
how literal we should take it that a
certain city was being baguer by like a
seven-headed demon like this monster
demon and that was hiding out in some
abandoned building and and it terrorized
the population particularly at night
and no one knew what to do this was a
very powerful demon so a certain great
Rabbi was coming to town and one of the
rabbis of the Town recommended hey
nobody should offer the rabbi
Hospitality so he'll have to sleep in
that ruined building and for sure he
will take care of the
demon so the rabbi needs accommodations
nobody offers him anything so he goes
into this abandoned building and of
course this horf Dragon demon seven
heads comes and wants to eat him up or
kill him or burn him whatever the demon
does and every time the rabbi davens and
one of the heads fall off he davens head
one falls off Etc he davens he davens he
davens seven FAS all the heads right
they have been decapitated the Demon's
dead and everybody's happy so the next
day the rabbi goes over to uh the guy to
the other Rabbi who set him up this way
and said you know you could have killed
me there you you how could you put me in
a place where my life was in danger so
the rabbi's answer is I knew your life
wasn't in danger I knew you could do
it so the
mara asks a very good
question even if we assume
100% that this Rabbi was so great that
there was a virtual guarantee that would
be a miracle so even if I could even I
I'm allowed to make that I'm allowed to
say you're so great I know a miracle is
going let's assume I could make that
assumption but there's another problem
here that is he who benefits from
Miracles loses a share of his habah
meaning is a spiritual reward so the
physical things you get in this world
don't take away from your Haba because
there's no
comparability between the physical and
the spiritual but when you're getting
Miracles you're getting special Divine
connections good that'll save you and
save other people but you're going to
lose your because or at least your is
going to be diminished because you're
n from m n right anyone who benefits
from
Miracles gets a
diminution in
his okay so for again I mean of course
of course that's a problem but but the
gamar means to say
that you know we don't have anyone of
that Madre today but for someone who
really really really really really all
right you're it's going to happen
that's so here's what the Mara says the
Mara says it's true that if you benefit
from a
miracle youra is
reduced but anything you gain from
prayer is not called a miracle because
it's the nature of
prayer that these good things happen and
therefore since this Rabbi was saved by
the power of
prayer that's not called n m it reminds
me actually of a story which again um
don't write me I know that so many
people say it's apocryphal but it's a
story that that's been reported in
different in different places that when
the G
the
IM was saved from the from warsa saved
from the warsa ghetto so some say again
I I know the history is questionable
that he was brought to London for a
while brought to England for a while
before he came to AR
Israel and uh Winston Churchill was told
there's this very holy Rabbi who's here
and would Churchill like to meet with
the rabbi for Spiritual advice during
World War II so the G rebbi comes to
Churchill and obviously Churchill
doesn't know yish and the g rebbi
doesn't know English so there's an
interpreter whatever it is and the
conversation goes something like uh
Church ask the re you know we're being
bombed by the Nazis Etc you know
was what do we do like how can we get
God's grace how do we get God's mercy
God's compassion so the Reby said do you
want to know the natural way or the
miraculous Supernatural way so church
will say said well first tell me the
supernatural way and then we'll talk
about the natural way so the rby says
the supernatural way is you get your
Army Navy and Air Force organized enough
to repel the Nazi threat that would
truly be a miracle if that will
work the normal way is take it to hel
take a book of Psalms and pray to God
and that'll be the the natural way
you're going to as if to say what
happens through prayer is actually more
natural than what happens to all of the
different tias so so be it as it may uh
we're in this period of time where we
think about uh the B mikdash and most
importantly we think about how to make
our hearts and souls a dwelling place
for Hashem and uh by thinking about the
power of speech the power of prayer and
the power of speech to build up
relationships to create warmth to give
and encouragement as I say we have to be
aware of the destructive powers of
speech that's for sure but it's very
much only half of the picture to think
about the bad things that speech can do
we also have to think about the good
things that speech can do how it can
literally change people lives for the
better by the friendly way that we can
approach them to build people up give
them give them
encouragement and in that way we're
taking giant steps towards making our
hearts and souls a dwelling place for
ourish have a good week everybody and
thanks for coming
[Music]