Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Once a Jew Always A Jew Explained

1,271 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] so many people say once a Jew always a Jew when people go far from Hashem and even actively work against the Torah how can they be considered a Jew if there are no repercussions for your actions and you are still part of a group and it cheapens the value of that identity and accelerates the spirit off the cliff you should write an article instead of a question this is a fantastic uh fantastic question why do people say once a Jew always a Jew that's really the question people say once a Jew always a Jew is because they are misinterpreting they're misinterpreting a ala into a something that has become a a symbol of our ignis or ignorance meaning that Allah says if a person is you know either converts to Judaism to a authentic Orthodox bedine or they're born of a Jewish mother they are considered Jewish but their Judaism their Judaism is either on suspension or not on suspension is active that's the part they don't tell you what does that mean if a Jew is a he keeps he's considered part of the Jewish people it's called your nation if he does not or she does not keep to it all depends on what violation she makes if let's say for example she's IM modest then she's considered that she's considered Wicked but still a Jew if she eats non kosher she's still considered a Jew meaning she's still considered part of your nation she's still considered part of is but she's considered Wicked she's making sins but there are sins that the Torah says that if you make those sins that Judaism that you were either born into or converted into that Judaism puts is on suspension meaning you are no longer considered part of no longer considered part of the nation you're judged as a Jew but you're not considered as a Jew and one of those sins is someone that worships an idol needless to say someone that drives on Shabbat someone that violates Shabbat on purpose there are other sins as well but the point is is that there are certain sins like these two that I just mentioned that if a person makes them they're Judaism is on suspension now that does not mean that they're considered a like a is meaning they're not considered a gentile like a gentile is where a gentile doesn't have to keep Shabbat so that's mean it's not it's not for them to drive on Shabbat is not a sin no for a Jew he's always considered a Jew in a sense that he's always going to be judged as a Jew he's going to get punished or rewarded as a Jew but when it comes to uh uh including him or her in the nation we do not include them in certain things for example if you're counting a minan you need 10 people to say kadish if one or two of those people out of the 10 do not keep Shabbat you cannot count that as a minan you now have eight or an idol worshipper cannot be counted as part of aan according to everyone not according to nothing to do with that it's this is RA this is someone that does not keep Shabbat is considered 100% an idol worshipper now if let's say for example you want to get uh married you need to have two witnesses sign yourba to be there at the ceremony if one of those Witnesses is a Shabbat or is a Christian Missionary that was born a Jew you cannot use them as a witness if you use them as a witness that that ceremony is not valid if you are invited someone that you care about to your Shabbat table and that person took the wine you wanted to be nice to you took the wine that's very expensive bottle of wine and poured you a glass if that wine is uncooked expensive wine you are not allowed to drink that wine in fact you have to throw the whole bottle out the point being abai is when someone is excluded from the nation it doesn't look good but worst of it all there is a certain Mitzvah that everyone knows about it's called now Hashem gave us a big present with this rule with this rule of someone that's excluded from the nation why because if a person says on a kosher person they could lose their one of the examples is was a big you head of the says he has no share of the world to come he is in permanently why he said so is a big deal someone saying is a big deal but the says all of the rules that have to do with are only about people that are considered part of meaning if you say against the righteous Jew that that keeps you have to do serious serious CH on that on that why because you could lose your if you don't do that but if that person is a it's not even consider why he's not part of your nation say whatever you want about him you shouldn't because it's not a good thing to do and get yourself used to saying about people but the point is this is actually a get out of jail free card for a lot of the nonsense that people talk about why because most people in not keeping and we say about them now if we say about the kosher people that's a very serious problem very serious offense but if you say about somebody that's it's not even an offense it's not even a sin such is the decree on someone that's so now when people say a Jew is always a Jew they're right to an extent where he's a Jew he'll always be judged as a Jew she's a Jew She'll always be judged the Jew even if she converts to Christianity but what they're not telling you either because they don't know or they don't feel uh the courage to do the courage to say it is that uh they don't tell you that that Judaism can be put on suspension now the problem that people have is that they have a difficulty understanding the 13 principles of faith that discuss reward and Punishment and we'll uh I wrote something up to a friend of mine a big I wrote him an answer today about the issue and they uh the problem is that most people do not understand what Eternal punishment is they think that it's not possible for hem to punish anyone eternally interestingly enough no one has a problem with Hashem rewarding us eternally though no one questions that no one says how is it possible that hasm is going to reward you eternally no one questions that everyone says no it's definitely possible reward this eternally that's forever for sure but punishment eternally we have a problem understanding that the truth is is that human logic is incapable of understanding eternity we do not understand Eternal reward or Eternal punishment we're not capable of understanding anything that's beyond just a few steps Beyond us eternity is far far beyond us but that's where we go to that's where we go to a t t says there is eternal reward and there is eternal punishment meaning if you do good you can get Eternal reward if you do bad guess what you're getting Eternal punishment for certain sins not all sins some sins it's not Eternal punishment some sins it's just temporary punishment but needless to say if a person does not keep Shabbat a person does not do cha for wasting seed they're getting Eternal punishment there's no questions no like second opinion so that's why it's important for people to know yes Judaism is the chosen people everything it's all good but that's assuming you're righteous assuming you're righteous next question [Music]