Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

NOAHIDE COMMUNITY SCAM

15,251 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] I've been following you for a couple of years I feel guilty for not learning as much I am the that single father with full custody that message you before looking for no hi High Community uh well I have many many messages I don't remember everybody's messages um I think last count uh was like over a half a million messages in the last 12 months so you could just do the math of what that averages out per day um so I don't remember all the messages but I can tell you that there are plenty of people that are trying to cater to the n Jewish World to the Noah Hy world uh but with all due respect to everybody that's trying to C it to them I don't think it's really possible um you know to do that uh in a um AIC way for a lot of different reasons uh many times the noahides want Judaism but light so they want a prayer book they want a certain study regiment they want a Yeshiva they want holidays in essence they want Judaism just light and that's not allowed that's not noahide but what the people that are trying to create is typically that it's like a lighter version of Judaism so there is no no high community that I'm familiar with and the ones that do exist or whatever versions of our you usually just small groups of people here in there typically they are uh led by uh kabad schim that are really after people's money more than they are after you know people's uh because if those rabbis really were looking to do the will of hem they wouldn't even start a nohide community because they have a responsibility for Jews uh before they have a responsibility for noahides uh and that's an uh so uh Hashem does not want the Noah Heights to have communities uh you know he wants each person to do what they need to do to be a righteous no high to learn what they learn if you happen to be fortunate enough to have friends and family that are on the same boat as you Living Next To You by all means but for the noahides to start having structure definitely will lead to problems why because they're getting their learning from the Jews and they're trying to emulate and follow the Jews and it's only a matter of time before they start acting like Jews to the point where they're actually no longer noahides that are righteous because they're creating things that are forbidden you know there are a lot of things that are forbidden for noahides to learn but many noahides specifically want to learn those things uh there are many things that are forbidden for noahides but noahides specifically want to do those things like observing Shabbat and and all types of things like that so that's the thing I always tell people listen if you like the MIT if you like T do whatever you can to be a Jew that's it stop uh lying to yourself and thinking that uh you can remain a righteous nohide it's in fact it's a uh conversation that I had with one of my oldtime students just a a couple of weeks ago where he came back you know he's been with me for a while and um a few years ago I told him that uh it's you know he needs to convert to Judaism um and he said yeah but listen I could help so many noahides I could do so much good in the noahide world you know Jews already have leaders Jews already have this Jews already have that and I try to explain to him that this is a mistake uh his logic is mistake he should uh become a Jew but again I'm not I'm not here to convince anybody if you just ask me for advice I'll give it to you um but uh anyway he didn't listen to me maybe three years have passed and uh I guess he just came back to his senses even though we've been in touch this whole time apparently something happened and he came back to his senses and he realized that he made a mistake that cost him a few years of his life and almost cost him his life which is that he realized that wait being a noahide it's not just about me it's about wife kids descendants everything so now the truth is that there is no noahide Community there will not be a nohide community anytime soon that's kosher because like I told you it's always going to have issues uh and it's you're going to have you're going to be forced to do a lot of things that are going to put you and your noahide status of of of righteousness in Jeopardy such as you're going to have kids those kids will have to go to school at some point okay now yeah of course homeschooling is fantastic for those that can actually do it but most people can't do it so they have to send their kids to school and what are those kids going to learn in school in kindergarten in junior uh uh high school and what are they going to learn they're going to learn Halloween they're going to learn Christmas K Quanza I don't know homosexuality pedophilia you know Batman and Robin they're going to learn that stuff so even though you may be teaching them about God and and mosenu and all that other stuff still they're going to have friends that celebrate all types of idolatrous holidays they're going to want a tree on Christmas they're going to want a pumpkin on Halloween they're going to want bunnies with eggs of chocolate on on Easter they're going to want all that stuff why not because they believe in Yos idolatry but they want to be like their friends so what are you going to keep telling them no every year good luck with that good luck with that and staying married because even even the best spouse in the world is going to break uh when their kid starts crying that they can't have this toy because uh it's not Kosher according to the rabbi so the reality is that people understand is that it's being a noide is not just a decision for yourself it's a decision for everything that happens in your life from this Mo from this point forward with your kids with their kids with their kids kids and so on and that's why I say to people that you know to be a righteous snow height is a lot more difficult a lot more difficult than people can think and I personally think that it's much easier to uh to deal with the difficulties of a Jew and much more worth it to deal with the difficulties of being a Jew than to deal with the difficulties of being a a noahide because at least uh with the difficulties of being a Jew there's a certain uh sense of community even if you don't necessarily live in the biggest Community there's a certain uh you know there there there there structure to a certain extent there is a order there's there's there's uh there's a lot more to it and quite frankly uh it's it's it's definitely something that has more stability even though well you know we get in trouble too everybody gets in trouble but it's say uh being a no height is not as easy as people think so when this guy realized that uh you know his kid is going to want uh all of these things and uh he's either going to have to learn how to say no every second word for for the rest of his life uh or you know he's going to have to uh Abandon Ship or he's going to have to convert you know he realized that he made a mistake you know he thought that he was going to be the uh uh the the Superman of the noahide world only to realize that uh you have to first save yourself then worry about the world so no hide communities uh with all du respect to all those that are trying to do it quite frankly from the ones that I've seen the organizations that I've seen try it they're not doing the right thing by the community they're simply creating a new religion uh they're giving people they're giving people uh all types of things that are not supposed to be part of it they're they're in essence giving you Judaism light version uh and it's not supposed to be that it's not supposed to be that I'm not saying you can't be a noahide certainly there are noahides that are good noahides and should remain noahides and there's no problem but you cannot expect the uh the uh the the structure that you want because there is no among the noahides like there is among the Jews I'm not talking about Unity as far as opinion certainly you can find like-minded people but Jews in general even if we we have a uh we disagree even if we disagree bitterly about something the second there is a a test in the world a decree in the world a uh you know some type of Holocaust of some kind some type of government decree all all of a sudden forget about everything and we unite why because the spiritually we're connected whether we like it or not none of that exist in the world of Noah Heights there is no spiritual connection between one Noah height and another even if they like each other and they're friends with each other for a thousand years there is no there's no connection between the Nations even amongst each other even if it's a Arab with an Arab or a uh a Christian with a Christian one Christian is from Japan another one is from China another one's from France there's no connection among them there's no Unity among among the green so that's the thing it's it's a people are trying to create a non-jewish version of Judaism and if it was possible and if it was something that was desirable uh by Hashem then uh certainly this is something that the sages would have taught but if they didn't teach that certainly this is not something that is uh uh desired by hasem the the noahide has an obligation to serve AEM to the best of his ability and follow the noahide laws one of the uh big objectives of the noahide is also to help the Jews serve hem because the better the Jews serve hem the better those Jews can teach the noahides uh but uh when most noahides today uh that you see online and being very vocal are are really lying to themselves they're lying to themselves uh by simply pretending that they're uh you know a Jewish version of a of a noahide or all types of other things and the reason why I mentioned this is because I'm seeing that this problem is growing not because of what the people want but rather because of how they're being misled by false leaders that are after their pockets because the the these uh these uh uh groups uh you know are writing all these books and and and and having all of these forums for for noahides because they figure listen there is let's say at best 20 million Jews in the world that we know of whereas non-jews is 8 billion almost so they figure according to their logic and math even if I get you know 10 20 million noahides 200 million noahides it's a all new nation so it's a there's a lot of money involved never ever learn Torah from someone that their priority number one is money although money is necessary money is uh to for people to to do what they do to to do Outreach to uh provide certain Services the second it becomes the number one priority that means that God is two and that cannot be that cannot be God is always one of course they can tell you that God is one but I can tell you that's not possible for God to be one in their mind why because according to Allah they they're not allowed to do what they're doing if they're Jews a Jew is not allowed to teach a noahide if there's another Jew that uh needs to learn meaning before you take time to address the problem of a noahide you have to make sure that there's no Jew that has an issue that you need to deal with even more so when it comes to T So you you're not allowed to teach a group of noahides even if there's 20,000 noahides and there's one Jew that wants to learn the 20,000 Noyes are willing to pay you $1,000 a ticket that means they can make a few million dollars for that event the Jew doesn't want you to uh doesn't want to pay you a dollar you have to go and teach that Jew that's what Torah says that's what says which means that all of these people that have these noahide organizations and they focus on Noah Heights as their gig that's a problem that's a very serious problem now if you help Noah hdes uh like what we do what RI does and other rabbis do which is you know as as as a something that is also done meaning you're helping the Jews and fulfilling your obligation and when possible you also help the noahides without jeopardizing your responsibility of of helping the Jew then you can do that no problem and I have plenty of Noy students that are uh that have been with me for years and that we try to do our best to help them some to help them convert some to help them just uh have a decent lives whatever the case is that's not a problem that's not a problem and I always try to encourage people to convert because I think it's simply a better life for those that are able to do it but don't let any anybody fool you to think that uh there is a permission for me or for any Rabbi on planet Earth to make Noah hides a priority over Jews there's no no no permission whatsoever which means that by default according to the to anyone who does it is making a mistake it's making a mistake so uh I know the no high unities wants this but again you have to decide what's more important to you the word of God or the word of your preference the word of your preference so it's I know it's hard to be alone to to you know people want communities people want to be part of something uh it's it's definitely not an easy thing uh to to uh to uh uh to be in a position of uh a new Jew a new convert a new noahide it's not easy at all uh but uh you know if a person wants it bad enough is going to learn enough do enough eventually hasm is going to open up the doors don't we have no permission to force the door and break it down we have no permission to it we do our best we learn as much as possible we do as much as possible we're charitable we do we uh we make changes in our life and eventually when uhem sees we've done enough and it's time he opens the door for us whatever that door is but uh the problem is that people feel feel like they should uh you know just break down uh uh the door to the house of God and simply make decisions for him tell him how to run his house and unfortunately sometimes they have rabbis helping them e e for