Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

LIVE FIREWORKS DEBATE: SHABBAT Vs Idolatry and Murder

2,919 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

I wanted to understand um you said breaking Shabbat is worse than murder right k i well to us said I just repeated it right and a is not allowed to keep Shabbat so if a keeps Shabbat murder well the the r writes that a that keep Shabbat is considered a thief why because the says in says to I have a big present in my treasure chest and its name is Shabbat go and tell is that I'm giving it to them which means that Shabbat is a it's between and this is a present that gave his children he didn't give it to the world he only gave it to his children so when a keep Shabbat is what happens he's taking the present of am is and using it for himself so the rambam says that a deserves a death penalty according to the Torah if he keeps Shabbat because he's a thief why would a thief if you steal as a Jew all you have to do is return twice but but if you steal as a you're violating the seven noahide laws and the Seven noahide laws even though they're all common sense and they're all much easier than our mitv the punishment for violating any one of them is always a death penalty so meaning that when a steals whether he's stealing five do or he's stealing Shabbat then the actual in heaven they say that deserves death penalty go keeps it it's like theft they're not the same je doesn't keep Shabbat it's considered idol worship it's considered as if he's serving an idol ah so you meant like the sent the violating Shabbat is worse than murder it's not like murder it's worse than murder the murder is the sixth commandment and Shabbat is the fourth so violating Shabbat is worse than murder and the it's considered idolatry it's considered as if the person is considered like an idol worshiper because what happens is that a says that when you keep Shabbat you're testifying that I created the world in six days and rested on the seventh when you violate Shabbat you're saying you don't believe that I created the world and rested on the seventh which means that if you don't believe I created the world you believe somebody else something else created the world or like some of the fools in the world you think the World created itself or always existed which means that's a form of idolatry so if you violate Shabbat on purpose that's a form of idolatry it's considered an idol worshipper now it doesn't mean that you are now not allowed to keep Shabbat it just means that you are classified as an idol worshipper according to Al meaning if an idol worshipper touches your wine your uncooked wine you are not allowed to drink it anymore and the reason why is because go that are Idol worshippers part of their idolatry is to use wine Shake wine and give it to their Idols so if a if a idol worshipper touch your wine you don't know if he touched it to drink it or he touched it to serve his Idol so once he touches it it becomes meaning it's a forbidden wine you have to spill you can't even sell it you can't even give it to your dog you can't do anything with it other than to destroy it anything that was used for idolatry must be destroyed there that's the only thing you're allowed you're not allowed to benefit from idolatry that's also why we're not allowed to benefit from let's say for example people that wear wigs today A lot of times they don't realize that these wigs come from temples in India and they gave their hair they donated their hair as a form of idol worship so when a woman wears a wig she's benefiting from idolatry unfortunately now if the wig came from a kosher place which is almost impossible but let's say it does that's a different issue but if it came from India you have a very serious problem because not only you have the issue of the wig as far as modesty and immodesty but you have a different issue you're benefiting from idolatry now I'm sure people are going to say yes but that means that it's over a million religious Jewish women that are benefit from idolatry yes there's also 15 million that are violating Shabbat just because there's a lot of people sinning doesn't mean it's not a sin so now as far as once a Jew violat Shabbat Al speaking is treated as an idol worshipper as far as Al meaning you cannot use him as a witness you cannot touch his wine you cannot have him do the k for you and you say Amen he's treat he's still obligated to do the mitv which means as soon as he stops sinning and he does Chua she does chuva they're full-fledged back into being a Jew and a beautiful Jew and a perfect Jew and the rambam says there's no one in the world that hasem loves more than a balua that's how much hem loves Bal Chua so he comes back he doesn't have to go through a formal conversion process it's just that when they treat themselves like an idol worshipper then hasm treats them like a ID worshipper they're putting their Judaism on suspension if you will their Judaism on suspension until they put it back into play so but when a non-jew keeps the seven noahide laws he's considered a righteous non-jew when a non-jew is an idol worshipper then he's an idol worshipper if a non-jew keep Shabbat he's not considered an idol worshipper he's considered a thief that's two different things by Jew breaks Shabbat is considered Idol worshipper not murderer and a who keeps Shabbat is considered Thief so why is a thief death because the we have 620 laws 613 from the Torah seven rabinal laws kanuka and so on now the 620 MIT each have reward and Punishment and they're all different if you steal and you get caught you have to pay double if you kill somebody death penalty if a different sins have different punishments different Rewards but for the because they have much less mitv they only have seven noahide laws and somewhere around 50 Common Sense laws like honoring their parents because they have much less responsibility in the world their punishment is much more severe all of the things violating any of their mitv according to is death penalty they don't have as much responsibility don't have as many mitv and as much responsibility to learn to as the Jews but their punishment is much more severe just like for example if when I worked on Wall Street we would invest into companies but part of the investment was finding out who the CEO is why didn't I find out who the janitor is why didn't I find out who's the secretary she might be nice he might be nice why don't I find out who's the clerk that gives the mail to all the desks and the cubicles why because I don't care about those people as much as I care about the CEO why he has a a much bigger responsibility that's why anytime you see a major company go through major crisis first thing first thing the shareholders want fire the CEO fire the chief why he had the most amount of responsibility he also had the biggest paycheck too the clerk is getting $40,000 a year CEO is getting 40 million a year so his reward is much much bigger but his punishment is also bigger the clerk the janitor very rarely they ever get punished very rarely even if he doesn't clean the room you don't fire him for not cleaning the room if he doesn't deliver all the mail you don't fire him for not delivering the mail it's like Hey listen Steve please next time deliver the mail please next time clean it's not a big deal if he messes up but when the CEO messes up the whole company fails that's the difference when a Jew messes up all of creation gets hurt all of creation gets hurt he has a big job he's a CEO he's supposed to be all AG green he's supposed to be a light to the Nations when messes up he's more hurting himself than he is Humanity the analogy is exactly opposite of what you said before I'm not following okay the janitor doesn't get big punishment right the CEO is the one who gets punishment he's supposed to be the or the COO I'm assuming is the analogy to the Jew right and the clerk and the janitors like the in this example but he what you said was the opposite because the Jew has more responsibilities the punish punishment is less and because the guy has less responsibility the punishment was more it's exact opposite it's not it doesn't fit like a glove the point what I was trying to make is the uh is that the uh CEO has a bigger responsibility and therefore he gets paid more that's the point the Jew has a bigger responsibility and therefore he gets paid more his Heaven is bigger is the significance of his MIT bigger and so on the janitor is has less responsibility and therefore he gets paid less that's in essence the biggest part of the point that's most relevant as far as consequences are concerned there's a lot more that a CEO can get away from actually if you want to make it fit like a glove you can actually say that the CEO can get away with certain things that the janitor cannot get away with for example if the CEO decides to shut down the kitchen and not let anyone in because he feels like having a dinner only him and his wife he feels like it no one's going to Care why you didn't affect everybody you just affected you and a few people got annoyed but that's okay so we're just going to let you go but if the janitor does it he's getting fired why it's the same crime it's the same crime but it's a bigger punishment for the janitor quite because he doesn't have as much significance so it can fit like a glove if you really want to make it fit like a [Music] in [Music]