Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Is it Better in Judaism to be Strict or Not LONG VERSION

1,329 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] I'm going to tell you guys something very interesting we're going to answer the question is it better in Judaism to be more strict or no now my dear tamid initially said yes more more stringent you heard Naomi said no no he's no good yes good everybody's confused why because one an it's good to be stringent we heard from the story of he was stringent in regards to shaking hands it's good thank you but but sometimes it's not good one is it not good we heard a different story yesterday somebody came to him one of the came to him and said Rabbi can I uh from now on get your permission to wear myin all day so I can study while I'm wearing fing all day like the says no why no even though it's aah even though it's fantastic he says if this addition this additional stringency will make you think in your heart that you're better than everybody else in the K one time your whole life it's not worth it why would you think you're better because you have 500 people in the and you're the only one that's put on feel so dist it's going to be distinguishable so in essence even if they're not saying anything to you you're going to see yourself you're say wait I'm wearing nobody else is wearing you're going to feel good about yourself if you feel good about yourself that you're better than anybody else one time in your entire life and that's Essence that that dust of Pride enters your heart it was better off you never added dist stringency why because that's how much Hashem hates Pride so we see that stringency has a time in place now the interesting part is that in both cases there's a permission from the torat to do there's a permission from T not to do meaning the came to his Rabbi says it says in the T to do it but the rabbi said no why because he knows a student in essence the rabi is right for saying no at time of there is a leniency to shake hands but the Rabbi said no why could it and so on and so forth meaning that it's not black and white but in both cases you see that there is it's not just the black and white law there's also something called D the opinion of the Tor based on this specific situation what happens when you do not seek the opinion of the Torah and you seek your own opinion I mean after all created you In His Image no it's so special your opinion should count for something no after all you're smart you finished a few some people even call you Rabbi your opinion oh says someone that does not seek the assistance of a rabbi meaning someone that does not ask is Rabbi questions and in Ence becomes their own Rabbi page 109b says who hates this person why because in Ence they're so Pride proud that they think they know everything and we have one of the stories that you can listen if you understand what I'm about to say to you you may have to grab out your chairs some time ago I told you of a story that's in page 4B it says that there was a certain woman that the Satan decided to take out of the world but by mistake mistake BV one of the T was friends with the SAT Satan likes s so he came to him he says you want to you want me to show you what I do he said yeah so the was shown by the Satan how the Satan takes out so uh Satan tells one of his servants go bring me the uh of IAM the caretaker go bring me and the servant goes brings a is Miram Satan tells her hey it's the wrong Miram I didn't ask you for this Miram to wrong mil okay so should I bring this one back goes no this one leave it anyway go bring the other one anyway we have to bring it it's time for out to die so it's a peculiar story and then we go into the detail dets how who what when and hand but we're not going to go into that because we've already discussed that in the past but just remember now who is this Mam and why does she deserve to die I mean we should know her name is mentioned if it was just some woman that it doesn't matter who she is then why the mention her name if it's your name is mentioned there's a reason for it meaning there's significance here of who and what and how who is is this you're not going to find that inage you're gonna find it somewhere else you have to go to last page page says what are the appropriate ways for a woman to behave and for a husband to let a woman behave he says there are some husbands that the way they eat is the way they treat their wife in essence and some people that if they see a fly in their drink fly in their drink they take the uh fly out and drink the water he says that's normal that's a normal husband that's a person that allows his wife to deal with regular people not to Bent her around and start talking to every guy on the street and so on but if it's family if it's friends if it's hello it's goodbye General basic Behavior he's the bank teller here's the money uh thank you very much basic stuff normal necessary conversation this is what it represents because today any one of us sees a fly in our drink we throw it out but that's because we're all rich in comparison to the people of 2,000 years ago back then you know if uh if you weren't Rich you weren't going to throw out the water right away so someone that just saw that something is flying their water they would take it out and drink it that in essence makes them normal representing a normal husband a normal husband which in essence he allows his wife to act normal if there's a uh let's say uh uh UPS guy comes to the house she's able to answer the door all thank you very much goodbye takes the Box no problem it's allowed to take the box she's not hugging the guy she's not saying hey how's your friend where's your kids where you guys vacation no that's not allowed but just basic conversation thank you very no problem that's normal normal behavior no problem says then there's a guy that's a rash what's this guy that's rasa gu it's that allows his wife to go out without modesty sleeveless and without and he doesn't care he doesn't care even if she goes into a bath house and there's still men there he's like a guy that sees the fly and drinks the fly with the water he doesn't care about nothing that's but then there's a guy that sees the fly throws out the fly and the water together he throws out everything says that's extreme fanatic Behavior like who like a person by the name of papus Ben Yuda who's papus Ben Yuda papus Ben Yuda lived at the time of thear it says the papus Ben yud saw that his wife was one of the most beautiful women alive something special and he want he says there's no way that people are not going to look at her no way so for modesty reasons for modesty reason honey whatever you need I'll get it for you go on amazon.com order whatever you want you don't need to go to the store you don't need to go to the mall you want something I give for you but you're not allowed to leave the house not to leave the house no store no Deli no not no work nothing whatever you need I'll bring it to the house no problem and Pap Pap would leave the house and lock the door behind him not allowing his wife to leave the house the most she can do was look outside the porch to see the the outside and thear says this what you think you think she's mest because of this you think he's aik because of this says look what happened on on y Pap's wife the same from says she's had it Papu says to her I'm going to sh fasting pray all day see you tomorrow he leaves he leaves this this guy called ysf P Noti as the husband left and he knows Miram from back in the day goes Miram Miram when are you ever going to come out and Miriam says she's so annoyed already she hasn't been out of the house in so long she says yph when are you going to save me he says today climbs to house takes out of the house and they run away together and sin adultery on now we say what happened from the sin what happened from the sin is they had a son their son who is their son their son don't jump the gun yet don't start naming names yet don't start naming names it's not nice their son is named in theb but if you read unless you know what wrote in his all the comment from you're not gonna know what why page 104 B says are we allowed to draw on our hands draw on our hands make marks on our hands with our fingers is that violating shabat is that considered writing and it says well it should be considered writing because they um there was a person by name of benata benata he wrote all types of Witchcraft on his skin wrot all types of Witchcraft on his skin and uh because anytime you would uh get the Witchcraft the Egyptians would catch you at the border and they would want you to take the the Witchcraft with you because that's their in essence that's their possession that's their stuff so so he couldn't write the spells on paper so he wrote it on his skin say oh so he wrote it he wrote on his skin and it worked says no no we don't learn we don't learn from crazy people says who's this Ben who is this Ben Ben means Ben the son of the Wayward woman who's the Wayward woman the s says the Wayward woman is the same Mir that cheated on a husband papus Ben yud with ysf Ben so who is the son okay this is the way the Wayward woman she cheated says of a lifetime who's the son yesu that's how he came to the world from what from his mother cheating on our original husband with some that's how yesu came to the world where they come from modesty as a modesty is in who asked you to be that M you lock yourself in a house meaning that when a person does not listen to and double checks themselves even your mitvah can turn into the biggest sin that's ever happened in history how many millions of Jews have died because of this sin that look like aah she wanted to be modest inside the house he wanted her to be modest inside the house no guy ever sees nobody ever sees on her who asked you to do this who has you there are alic permissions to do certain things there areic restrictions to not do certain things a person needs to know what to do what not to do based on a Tor not based on their logic now when a person takes things to their own mind and they start deciding this is the this is comes from Pride because they assume they're right and they don't have to double check all of us have pride this is why had mercy on us and he allowed us to write the the oral toah as well why because now we can't us it use this Pride as an excuse why because you could find out whether you're right or wrong by simply asking your Rabbi by simply looking at is what you said and what you think written in a book in a t or is it simply your own idea that you're trying to be overly righteous says don't be overly righteous don't be more righteous than what the Torah says so does that mean that every woman could just talk to anybody no does that mean that every woman could has to be closed up and be so mad as that no one ever sees her no so what does it mean then it means you have certain things that's what we're going to go over now get off get off the Flor go back on your chairs now page 66a T is says he concerned themselves with the issues of protecting is protecting is he took care of is all types of Jewish Women and talks about all types of swear people make a vow to do something and if you say a vow you don't keep it you have a serious problem but there are certain conditions that you could break a v you have to get or three to to to allow you to break it so it says there was a certain person that made a vow what's the vow not to marry his niece in those days it was very common to marry your niece in fact it was meritorious to marry niece your your sister's daughter says there's already love and affection between the family it's allowed it's not a sister shalom it's the niece it's a sister's daughter but this guy says no no I'm not marrying her even though say it's a good thing I'm not marrying her why I'm not marrying her because she's ugly she's ugly I don't want to marry her she looks like Sao she doesn't not for me nose over here eyes over here not for me no so they brought the girl the parents brought the girl to R it says look now that our own Uncle doesn't want to marry her no one's going to want to marry her why it looks bad for the whole family so told his daughters take care of her beautify her beautify her they started taking care of her putting some makeup did her hair do all manic your pedicure uh redone everything redone after she finished he brought himself brought her to this Uncle he says my dear son is this the one that you made a not to marry no no no of course I want to marry her no no I didn't mean it I didn't mean it and at that moment says beautiful it's only poverty that makes them ugly why because they can't take care of themselves similar to the situation we had in Egypt the women made themselves ugly on purpose they put ashes on their face and so on why because they were scared if they look beautiful then the Egyptians will rape them but generally speaking are beautiful women now the continues and it says that there was a husband that had it with his wife he said says I'm making a I'm making a vow that unless RAB is himself finds one thing good about you one beautiful thing about you I'm getting divorced and R akba says one of the conditions that a husband could divorce his wife is if she's ugly that's so now it's a little funny story but it's not funny why because you see what's going on how much is how much are worried about now he can't just divorce her he has to get the permission of the rabbi so he says go to the rabbi and I want him himself to give me something good about you that's how ugly you are so this poor woman goes to R is and is not meeting her the people he says his daughter go deal with her you tell me what they tell them what's going on her husband say he going to divorce her cuz she's ugly and unless you can find something good about her he wants a divorce he want permission to get divorced so Kish says well maybe she has a really nice round head maybe it's really nice her head is really round and the daughter said no is like an egg it's like an egg so from here to here you don't have a nice head says maybe maybe she has nice hair nice hair maybe it's curly maybe it's straight shiny something go no her hair is like a bush tree going in all Direction like she got electrocuted no here so he says maybe she has nice eyes pretty eyes nice pretty eyes you know nice green eyes brown eyes some eyes go she has eyes like a cow there's C Perfect Circle what kind of eyes this woman has so then he says okay so maybe she has nice ears has nice ears maybe her ears are nice meaning he's looking for permission to find something nice about this girl so she can stay married M who's gonna marry this troll so says what nice ears her ears are thick and heavy and fat she has she has she has the the the beats the Beats headphones on on her ears without the Beats that's her ears says okay says okay maybe she has a nice little nose nice little cute little peachy nose something nose says what nose this girl what she has her nose looks like it's indented in our face okay maybe she has nice lips CU white lips what lips her lips are thick they're like a whale say her lips baby she has a nice neck oh neck her neck is crooked says okay maybe she at least has a nice stomach she goes what nice stomach it's several people she she when she moves you know it's like the Earth is moving with her she makes a spin the year ends oh no it's not like stomach okay maybe she has nice legs at least she has nice legs he's asking his daughter go find something nice about this poor girl while we're all laughing at our expense he's trying to find something nice baby she has nice legs a real she has nice legs goes no legs are like the duck thick on top thin on the bottom we're not even sure how it's holding up all this weight maybe she has a nice name this says what her name her name is means like dirt is like it's dirt ah says is ah I found the thing that's nice what's nice her name is appropriate to her body just like she's a BAL she has a deformed body the name belongs to this body no get he has to stay with her that's how much R isma loved the daughters of am why now he says okay let this guy go find somebody else poor girl who's going to she be with he has to find something but he can't invent the law says Ah I found something nice what's something nice her name is nice her name belongs to her body sometimes you have some girl that she's called Sunshine but she only brings death to the world her personality is dark she's called Sunshine but she's dark you know sometimes you have a girl named Simka but she's depressed s happiness but she's a manic depressant so here he says the name matches the body that's how wise the are but also how much they love now but here what do we learn that has to do with our issue goes over every single body part meaning that beauty is not outside of Judaism it's not prohibited to be beautiful it's not a it's not unfounded the the people that don't know Torah think that Jewish people like these dark people always wear black always like depressed or something you know like we all hiding in some cave that's the opposite of the tah why because we see here that beauty is very much part of Judaism they talk about it all the time going to the details of body parts beautiful nose beautiful hair beautiful this beautiful that meaning that you're perfectly allowed to be beautiful so where does modesty come from it says that beautiful looks is perfectly fine as long as it's not unladylike and vulgar meaning as long as it's notf or Gus unladylike meaning she's walking like she's some Street trash she's walking around like she belongs to the world woman walks around uncovered a whole body seed you have to ask her are you a piece of garbage no you're not a piece of garbage then how come you're allowing everybody to look at you no one allows strangers to look at what's inside the house but nobody cares if you look at their garbage why are you treating as a why are you treating your body as a piece of garbage allowing everybody to look at you allowing your everyone to look at your skin H come so that's not ladylike you're treat in your body like it's a piece of garbage anyone's allowed to look at it so if she's beautiful it's not a problem but if she's unladylike in her behavior in her clothing if she's exposed she's a uh or she's wearing something that attracts attention she's where she wears certain clothes that are extra tight meaning that it doesn't matter what col she's wearing it doesn't matter what pattern she has on it doesn't even matter what she has why cuz she pretty much left nothing to the imagination she walks around it might as well she walked around naked why because it's so tight our entire image of our body everybody knows everybody knows so that's attractive or she wears certain patterns or certain certain types of uh things where she has clothing with words on her chest or certain design just on the chest or pointing to the chest or the other body me parts that are you know that represent that so that's not allowed why the whole thing is blank except the part where the chest has Nike on it it has fendy it has something on it so what is every going to look at Naturally just that part where the words are they're just going to look at that or there was one dress some woman asked me if uh is this is this modest and you see that the dress is beautiful m m beautiful unfortunately the the uh the company was an Arab company cuz they're the only on that sell matter clothes today but anyway said oh beautiful but it's not allowed why it's not allowed has nothing to do with Arabs you're allowed to buy from Arabs if it's mod you're allowed why is it not allowed because if you look at the design on that specific dress it points exactly has a certain design that points directly at the top and directly at the bottom meaning those specific Parts no one is going to think about anything else other than those two things the the the the uh outfit covers the body but the design ruins the whole thing so there are certain clothes that are attracting they're attracting when she walks around she's going to attract people's attention naturally to that part of the body or the the the body the uh clothes is uh not covering a part of the body or it's too tight and so on and so forth but as far as her being beautiful perfectly fine but there's a Kosher Way of being beautiful meaning look like a lady cover your body make sure that you are not trying to actively attract attention you're allowed to be beautiful but if you're wearing a wig that's three foot long and when you walk around it's like one of these fancy horses you find in the movies walking around with their Fancy Tails the same thing as your hair guess what what do you think what RAB ever told you that wi is kosher forget part what Rabbi in the history hisory of man ever said that this long wig is kosher you walk around it's like the horse left a uh left a uh commercial he came to your house what happened who says this allowed who this is allowed it's not modest it's not modest needless to say the whole issue with AB the wigs coming from India but that we've already covered many many times the point is is that when a woman is looking to be modest it doesn't mean she has to make herself ugly in fact she's not allowed to make herself ugly she's not allowed to make herself ugly on purpose she has to be beautiful for her husband and she has she's allowed to look decent all the time but she's not allowed to do certain things that are specifically going to attract attention wearing specific type of clothes specific type of streaks specific types of cuts and so on and so forth but if hasem blessed her with beauty you have a nice and the has diamonds on it perfect yeah but it's going to bring attention let it bring attention everybody's G to know you're a queen and you have diamonds on your head hopefully they'll follow the mitvah you're beautifying the Mitzvah you're beautify there's nothing wrong with that's perfectly fine oh the dress is really expensive okay let it be expensive that's where you have money in the world if it's let it be expensive no problem it'sah going to give you the money back but if it's imod it doesn't matter if it's from the 9.99 store you're still not allowed to write to buy it so beauty is not prohibited immodesty is but immodesty also comes in the form of behavior a woman is allowed as thear said a woman is allowed to have a cordial relationship with Society if there's a uh some type of employee or some type of business or something Ty a family member uh that's a male he's allowed to talk to her she's allowed to talk to him about things that are necessary excuse me many of theim their wives ran businesses their wives ran businesses so what do you think do I Do's wife you know ran a business the uh the G ran a business many of the their wives ran businesses either Farms or little stores and there's many stories about these tadik meaning they dealt with men what do you think they they forced all their customers to be women no they dealt with men as customers there were men no problem they came they bought they sold from them sometimes they had lawsuits against them sometimes they had business transactions with them sometimes it was good sometimes it was bad but whatever was necessary conversation they had no problem at all what's not allowed what's prohibited unnecessary stuff so what's unnecessary stuff unnecessary stuff is in page 78 says we don't make use of women for no reason what does it mean we don't make a use for women for no reason you're not allowed to say hello to a woman for no reason what does it mean say hello to a woman for no reason you're not allow to socialize with her you're allowed to say hello as the TOs says over there's commentary on confirms as well you're allowed to say hello to a woman hello hello goodbye goodbye no problem but you're not allowed to start hey hello how you doing so where's your husband oh he's not home where did he go oh he's away for the weekend oh he's doing business how the kids where's your mom where is it start asking investigating questions private investigate that you're not allowed why it's unnecessary conversation but if it's necessary conversation listen I I need to ship something to your house oh is your husband home oh you know things like that no problem you're conducting business you conducting family Affairs no problem but if it starts becoming flirting why because we have a story in the Torah there was a woman by the name of schlomit schlomit was a very very nice lady and she's one of the few women that's mentioned in Torah by name only unfortunately for her she's mentioned in an unfavorable way why she was so nice she said hello to everybody including the Egyptians and the Egyptian took it seriously she decided oh she says hi to me she probably wants to be with me and he ended up raping her and from her came the person that cursed aem's name from the tribe of Dan but they didn't consider him from the tribe of Dan why because his father was a but his mom was a was a Jew point is he ended up cursing hashem's name and mosenu killed him gave him a death penalty but why because schit was flirtatious Hello Goodbye how's your wife how's the kids how are you what's going on what are you guys doing for the holidays what are you asking 500 question questions wa is this Jeopardy well what's the okay basic stuff no problem what does it all mean it means that you're allowed to do everything just in a Kosher Way being extreme being stringent is not necessarily always good as we saw from the story of yeshu came from something that looks like a mitvah protect the beauty of the woman yeah bring her everything to the house wine and Diner but only to you looks like a mitvah maybe it's aah must in Islam it's aah to to to have 90 wives and pretty much seclude them to nothingness for them it's a no it's not a why she needs to conduct herself in the world because the Torah knows if you secude her too much eventually she'll explode needless to say if we do that to our kids telling kids listen not allowed to use phone not allowed to use computers not allowed to use cars not allowed to not everything is not allowed guess what one day he's not going to be a kid anymore one day he's not gonna have to listen to you anymore one day he's 18 19 20 25 years old and he's going to find out a phone that he's not allowed to dka because he's not allowed for 20 years he daa wants it what's this not allowed for me all these years and guess what he sees the phone for the first time and he loses his mind why does he lose his mind why are all these religious kids that were you know contained to the extreme lose their mind as soon as they see a computer for the first time at 20 years old lose their mind as soon as they see a phone for the first time because they don't have any antibodies when you have a baby you bring your baby to the doctor and the doctors give him a flu shot and give him a tetanus shot and give him all types of shots but in reality what is it the shot is is the actual sickness it's the virus why would you on why in your right mind would you put a virus into a little baby because you're putting the virus on it in him or in her in order for him or her to develop antibiotic develop an antibiotic to be to develop a defense mechanism in case it comes back bigger and stronger and out of control that way you have already a defense system that's when you have a defense system if you teach your kids right and wrong here this is a phone you have to use this phone in a certain way this website allowed be.org allowed website not allowed this is allowed this is not allowed teaching them right and wrong that's what teaches them defense mechanism they know that the bad exists and they choose the good to Simply cut out the bad and pretend like it doesn't exist that's asking for problems because one day they're going to have access to the bed without any antibodies without any antibiotics without any defense mechanism so they're not going to know what to do so being extreme is not good in that aspect but there are times you have to be extreme when when it comes to character traits if you're an angry person you have to be extreme work on yourself really really hard not to be angry it's hard if you're an arrogant person you have to be extreme do everything possible to remove this Pride from your heart you have to be extreme with things like that when it comes to the Torah you have to make sure you know what to do and when to do it last but not least it's known among people that the color red is considered attracting but what most people don't know is that it's not for it's not prohibited all the time most people think red cancer not necessarily true ra the biggest zaric Rabbi in the world today the already said we know that red is allowed not only it's it's it's not a it's allowed actually where what's the source he says look in a song every one of us sings on Friday night me the uh the uh woman of Valor it says that ran a business that supported our family and so on she she has linen and purple wool her clothing but Ma which is the biggest expert in the world today in the Hebrew language says that actually is actually not purple it's red and red is allowed so how come so many are saying it's not allowed it says Red by itself is allowed red that's attracting is not allowed there are different shades of red they different shades of red if it's a normal relatively light type of red perfectly okay no problem it's a red stripe no problem red design no problem but if it's a red like a traffic light no color allowed if you look like a traffic light is not allowed if it's a traffic light you're carrying so much attention so the point is is that there are certain things that a person needs to go into the details find out who what when and how don't just assume being the most strict is the best thing to do only a uh an idiot thinks that strict on everything is is Judaism that's not Judaism strictness is actually the exact opposite of the Torah where do we see it from Christianity Christianity said no no oh mesty huh oh we're so holy that our holy men are not even allowed to be with women and our holy women are not allowed to be with men we have nuns and Priests what ends up happening out of this falsehood the priests rape a bunch of little boys and the women the nuns end up also doing it with boys girls the the the priest and anyone in between but it's all behind the scenes so these so-called holy women are the filthiest people on Earth throughout all of histories not my my look at the stories the personal bio stories of the popes the original popes and the popes throughout all of history and their personal lives that was uncovered afteron complete filth and disgusting G Nish of Life there were murderers rapists adulterers all the sins in the book they committed but in the eyes of the people no we're holy we're not married we're no married you're just you're just pretending that's Christianity Islam no different they forced the women to wear this uh this sack in the name of uh righteousness but the rich ones the rich ones that allow their wives to go away once in a while to vacation they leave Iran because in Iran you show your eye already it's already a death penalty you wink death penalty they kill everybody for fun but once they get on the plane this is a known thing once these women get on the plane they take off the black sack that they have on and they all have almost nothing on and they come to America or Europe the filthiest most disgusting behavior in the world wait but I thought you're modest no no no wasn't modest is a modest fakers so toah does not say be extreme but also doesn't say be lenient than everything there's times to be lenient there's times to be strict there's times to do this there's times to do that any idiot can tell you be strict all the time and nothing's allowed but only a will tell you what's allowed and what's not allowed when to be strict when not to be strict so this I think is very critical for all of all of all of us get a little bit of from this all the men also could encourage their wives to watch this with them and we arrive at much more righteous than we were over the last year [Music]