Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Efraim Palvanov: Five Examples He Is A Heretic

4,546 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

that the high priest, the Coen Gador, would go into the Holy of Holies and essentially almost hotbox it, you know, to use that. Uh, >> is that definite meaning? Is that conclusive? I know Rabbi Harry has a >> That's right. Rabbi Harry Rosenberg, good friend of mine. He's the the expert on on this stuff and on DMT in particular. >> But is that an accepted perspective? >> Oh, yeah. It's 100%. Yes. The cohenadul is getting high is taking hallucinogens when it's a Torah prohibition to such an extent that if the coenadul ever had a foreign thought he would get he would die on the spot in the telling me that he's using the Torah to get high. This is a person that wants to create a new Torah. He's fooling you. Fooling you. Fooling you. Do you understand? The Torah never speaks of an eternal gay because it doesn't exist. Doesn't exist. So there's nothing you can do to merit eternal damnation. It makes no sense. Oh, I was waiting for this. Of course. What are some of the examples that a frame Palmanov said heresy? Ah, okay. I'm not going to go with every single thing like we did with the other isim because I just simply I said it in the beginning. I don't have the time nor the patience. Um, but if you look at the comments on the video that I've made over there, people, some of them agreed, some of them were, you know, going against me as if I have some uh personal interest or benefit in exposing wicked people. Aside from a headache, there's nothing good that you get out of it. literally it's it's just it's it's it's a big nightmare but you do it because you want to help people that don't understand that they're in trouble don't understand that they're listening to heresy don't understand that they are going against Hashem so that's why we do it and as far as concerned if you look at the of the chapter 8 uh section five also section four there several of them talks about when it comes to heresy uh it's a mitzvah to expose heretics. There's no dean of uh whatsoever. Furthermore, we have been following this heretic for a couple years already. This is not something we discovered a week ago. We stayed quiet about it for a long time because I don't just make a video about every heretic that comes to my attention. It goes through a process, research, confirmation. sometimes contact sometimes uh other types of investigations and ultimately I always always have to get the approval of our ain that not only can I expose this person but I have to meaning it's an obligation uh for the sake of helping people. So this with this particular guy it was going on already for a couple of years. Now, as I said, every one of his lectures is full of heresy. But if you're not well, you know, well-versed in Torah, you will not know it because he makes everything look legit by putting sources on the screen. Just like Arav Aron Feldman Shik said in his video against the fry palov, he did a research of his own. He reviewed a bunch of videos. He reviewed a bunch of audios. He reviewed a bunch of different things on his own and he came to the conclusion and he even gave more details than I did that if Frank Palv is a heretic. He's meal panel by the way is worse than just a simple heretic. People said, "Oh no, but he didn't call him a heretic." Yeah, he said is the worst type of heretic. >> So he's just he's just he just uses the source of the terror to conclude things which are not >> it's the heretic that loses it's a heretic that at the time of would get death penalty. It's it's the worst of the worst. So the Gdoolador in America and around the world, he's the head of the uh you know the uh uh um there's an organization that's for the Torah sages. He's the head. He's the chief Raen Feldman. If you don't know who he is, then I don't know, get out of the rock that you're living in. He is the authority. Especially outside of Israel. Anywhere outside of Israel, you ask Torah community, do they know who Rav Arun Feldman is? Anyone that knows anything about Torah knows who he is. He's the head. He's the chief. He literally miraculously made a video about this and you know because it came to his attention and obviously he understood that this needs to be publicized and he calls Ephrine Palmanov a worse type of heretic and he gave examples that you could see and you could watch you know that Frank Palmanov says if you know some people tell me oh I watch all of his lectures but I don't remember ever saying the stuff. That's because you either don't remember or you're not wellversed enough in Torah to know that what you're hearing is heresy because he gives you the illusion that the source that he presents agrees with the conclusion that he tells you and it's the exact opposite. He gives you a source to make you think that the conclusion is what he says, but it's not. To give you an example, he says that gum is 12 months because said it. But anyone that studies, anyone that studies Torah in general and has studied that particular topic knows not only that there are many sources, literally thousands and thousands of sources that speak about gum being eternal, those sources in the Kumash, that's where Koh is until this day is in the prophets like Isaiah. Uh look at the last verse. Uh uh the sources are in the Mishna in the in the in the it's everywhere including rest himself saying in a different that it's eternal. So how come in one place he says it's 12 months another place he says it's eternal because there are two different types of sinners. There's a sinner that's called is meaning he's a sinner but he still keeps the you know the he still keeps Shabbat he still is not a heretic he's still not committing sins that would remove him from being part of is so he's still is but so therefore his his sentence could be maximum of 12 months for whatever sins he's made but then there are people that have removed themselves from is such as a person that died Shabbat or he died a heretic or he died a uh idol worshipper or or or adulterer or diff different things that that have uh remove a person from and they lose their uh which includes wasting seed by the way not you know they still part of is but they lose but nonetheless those people are not part of is now doesn't say that in fact what he says is that anyone that tells you that God punishes for more than 12 months is he's an that means God is evil. This is literally his words. >> To believe in eternal damnation is to believe in an evil God. There's no other way to get around it. There's no other way because that implies that God wanted you and not just you but millions of other people to spend eternity in torment and torture and fire and sulfur and brimstone. Why? It makes no sense. It's literally his words. Now, I know you guys want me to make videos with taking little segments of his uh heresy and put it in there and show you that he says this and show you that he says that. And we've done that for other heretics in the past. I honestly just don't want to waste the time or the mental energy on doing that uh for a couple of reasons. Number one, it's because I know that for the people that listen to the truth and are looking for the truth, they don't need it. They don't need to see. If you if you think that I'm a liar, then don't listen to me. If you think I'm making this stuff up, then why are you listening to me? But if you think I'm telling you the truth, then that's enough. Even even if you don't think you want you don't want to take my word for it. You think that Rav Arun Felman the 93 year old Torah sage, he has nothing better to do. than to make a video about some some punk that that calls himself a a scholar. Like you think that Raarin Feldman doesn't know the laws of Lashon, the laws of heresy. You think you could just fool the Gdola? You could just fool the biggest rabbi, ONE OF THE BIGGEST RABBIS IN the world. You can just fool him. People are really don't understand what a Torah scholar is. You don't understand that his mind at his age is sharper than anybody else. you meet or have ever met or ever will meet at this age sharper. His body may be frail and old, but his mind is sharper than the the the most sharp thing that you can imagine. But have had the privilege of speaking to him and and and I can assure you, you don't understand what a Torah scholar is until you speak to them. And in this particular case, Ravaran Feldman concluded this guy's a heretic of the worst kind. So even if you don't want to believe me, he said it. Ravaran Feldman said it. That's more than enough. I COULD SAY A THOUSAND TIMES and it's not equal to one time that Rab Aaron Felman concluded it. He is the bed. He is the authority. He is the Torah sage. He said it. Now, so for those of you that are normal, this would be sufficient. For those that are simply glued to heresy and do not want to see the truth, that even if I provide you the clips, it won't be enough for you. Because I know this from experience when we did it with Manis Freedman where we brought the clips of him saying things that are against the Torah and people say, "Well, why don't you SHOW US THE WHOLE video and then we could judge for oursel?" What do you mean? Then it's not a clip anymore. Then it's I'm not going to add me saying two words and then him talking for two hours just in hopes that you will get those 30 seconds that I'm referring to. So people that don't want to see the truth, even if the truth gets thrown at them, it won't matter. It won't help. Anyone that wants to learn, for example, about the topic of wasting seed, we have a film called Tikunit. In there, there are 116 sources. 116 sources from across the spectrum of Torah. Any one of those sources will show you that the article and the lectures that a Frank Pal made about the topic are heretical, are against the Torah, are stupid, are a lie, are a manipulation. Same thing goes with Gum. We have a film with 172 Torah sources from fromn from the zor from including uh like literally 172 sources but page 16b says 12 months. Yeah. Move another half a duff 17a and you'll see eternity. Like if you're just going to pick one word out of a whole book, you can arrive at any word. But if you read the whole topic and understand the topic in a comprehensive manner, the way the Torah is is is learned, then you realize that just like the says, we don't learn anything from just one source. We have to learn the entire source from different places. the Now this guy presents himself as if he is a learned person, as if he knows Cabala. He doesn't know Cabala. He doesn't know Torah. He doesn't know anything. But for the majority of people that are ignorant of what Torah really is, that are watching him, it sounds like he's a very, very knowledgeable person. until you see what he says and compare it to the real sources, compare it to the real conclusions. I'll give you another example. In one of his recent videos, he has the audacity to say that Araminu Arainu failed or may have failed, but I think he said he failed his test with a >> if I tell Abraham to sacrifice his child, will he realize that that's wrong and say, "No, I'm not going to do it." And so, he failed in that regard because he should have said, "No, this is not right. this is immoral. That was the nature of the test. He should have said no. And that's the proper way to interpret the I'll tell you why. And again, a lot of people when I said it last time, a lot of people got upset and said, "You're crazy. What are you talking about?" I'll tell you why we have to interpret it this way. Now, what sage has ever said that? I'll give you the answer. No one. No sage has ever said that. Why would no sage ever agree with a fry palinov's conclusion that failed? Because the Mishna in aot chapter five, I believe it's Mishna number two or three. Let's see. Says the exact opposite. Our forefather Abraham was tested with 10 trials and he withtood them all to show the degree of our forefather of love for God. So the Mishna the Mishna this is the authority of authorities concludes Abra passed his test. Now, if that's not enough for someone that has a heart of stone, go to also you will find the same thing but even more elaborate version. Ahan chapter 33 number two our forefather Abraham was tested with 10 trials before the holy one blessed is he and in all of them he was found to be whole meaning he passed all the test and in case you say well which test are they maybe it's not considered the so the ba elaborates these are the 10 trials two are associated with God's instruction to him go for yourself from your land to the land that I will show you this to with his sons. This is with the and with the HERETIC SAID FAILED THE test and then it continues with his wives and with with the four kings and so on. The point as we say in Hebrew He's fooling you. He's fooling you in so many words. He shows you, "Hey, this is the source." And he tells you, "This is what it means. It's black." No, no, but it's it says white. No, no, no. Don't believe what you're seeing. It's black. He tells you a source, but he gives you the wrong conclusion. He gives you his own conclusion. If he gives you the conclusion that the sages have concluded, no problem. But he doesn't. Furthermore, the guy does not believe that the oral Torah is authorative. He doesn't believe in the uh following the he thinks the Mishnabah is a different religion. He hates Torah scholars and the Karedi world. In fact, something came to my attention in the last 24 hours. This young woman, I believe, if I remember correctly, her name is Jules. She took him to school. Juel took a Frank Palmanov to school. She got it uh uh hold of one of his videos that he's in a podcast with some drug addict, drug dealer guy uh where he is saying Pomov is saying that the that the Ken Gdul, the holiest man of Am was used to get high because his scientific background tells him that each one of these chemicals that are used is something as a hallucinagen. Now, first of all, I could tell you his background is complete nonsense. He's not a scientist. Maybe he could write the word scientist. And if you look at the ingredients there, first of all, as Rabbi Harry points out, the coals were atim. And atim are actually acacia wood has a very high amount of DMT in it. So, there's definitely something to it, right? This this ktoid did did for sure have psychoactive properties. >> Is that definite? Meaning is that conclusive? I know Rabbi Harry has a >> That's right. Rabbi Harry Rosenberg, good friend of mine. He's the the expert on on this stuff and on DMT in particular. >> But is that an accepted perspective? >> Oh yeah, it's 100%. Yes. The guy doesn't know what he's talking about, but he knows how to present things in a way that has such confidence that has so much fluff that you believe it's true unless you're educated about the matter. So this young woman took what he said scientifically and proved how every SINGLE WORD THAT HE said is a lie. Like literally it's mindboggling how much nonsense comes out of his mouth that the high priest the coenador would go into the holy of holies and essentially almost hotbox it you know to use that uh and it would fill the room with with smoke and then our sages describe how he would see a vision of God of angels and and things like that. The Cohen Gadul is getting high is taking hallucinagens when it's a Torah prohibition to such an extent that if the Coen ever had a foreign thought, he would get he would die ON THE SPOT IN the And you're telling me that he's using the Torah to get high? This is a person that wants to create a NEW he's fooling you. Fooling you. Fooling you. Do you understand? He tells you is flawed. He failed the test of even though every we all cry and and and beg Hashem to give us another chance because of merit. He has said in many of his lectures things that are completely completely against the world of Torah. And if that's not enough, there's a channel called the Frank Pommanov that there is a few recordings on there that he was uh recorded in a conversation, a dialogue with someone where literally if you listen to what he's saying and you understand what Allah is versus what nonsense heresy is, it's clear heresy. So that's why I'll share with you a list of what you should read. Uh again, I'm warning you if you're going to go down this path. Uh but if you're serious about truth, then read those books and then slowly you'll start to understand. I'll give you a few to start with and we can go from there. Anything after the rumbum is essentially a stringency. Again, you can disagree with the rumbum. Fine. I disagree with him too. Sometimes there I don't agree with everything. Absolutely. He says, you know, you think that everybody should keep Allah. Well, which ala you want people to keep Mishna Torah or Mishna Burra? Cuz these are two different religions. Completely different religions. You look at Mishna Torah and you look at Mishna Burra, these are two completely different things. Almost nothing to do with each other. So which al exactly are you referring to? Because the mission of Torah is today the Rambam would be considered a heretic, a reformed Jew. >> I have no idea what you're talking about and I don't even know if you read my article. I quoted Safidim and I clearly said there that he says masturbation's prohibited. I made that emphatically explicitly clear. So I don't know where you're getting I don't know why you're twisting my words. I don't know what you read. I it makes no sense what you're saying. And again, I quoted the Rambam as well as saying very clearly that it's prohibited. So, I have no clue what you're talking about. Maybe you should read my article again. >> And if you go into the uh into the description over there, there's also like a PDF of different things that he has said that he says. The point I'm trying to tell you is for any Torah scholar, for any person that's knowledgeable in Torah, all you need is five minutes, if that much, to know that what he says is nonsense. 6 minutes to know that it's heresy. Seven minutes that he's dangerous because he's doing it intentionally. And then you can just simply gather as much evidence as you want, but it's to no end. But to a person that either is too ignorant or doesn't want this dream to be false, doesn't want their idol to to be really a villain, nothing that anyone will ever say will be enough. Rav Aron Feldman, the leader of Torah, says something. Anyone that's has a little bit of understanding of Tua immediately says, "I don't even care to ever see evidence, that's enough. But for people that want evidence, like I told you, you can find it. It's there. But you need to know what the truth looks like, what the truth sounds like in order to know how to identify falsehood." That's why for example in the US monetary system when they train people to work to to identify fake money what do they teach them? They don't teach them the different type of fake money. They teach them what the true money looks like what real money looks like. So you become so familiar with the truth that it's easy for you to find anything that steers from the truth. If you don't know what the truth looks like. If you don't know what the truth sounds like, then whatever Frank Palmanov or any other heretic will say will sound like the truth if it's said in a way that's appealing to you. So I already knew he's a heretic over two years ago. I didn't need two years to publicize it. I needed permission. Took two years to get permission. Not because it wasn't clear two years ago, but rather because it wasn't necessary until it became until now. But even now, I'm not, you know, I'm not being told to to make a million videos about it. And quite I wasn't even planning on talking about it now. But since people are not getting it, they're not understanding it. This is not for any There is no benefit. I don't even understand what people say. Oh, you're doing it because you want views. What views? What what do I care about views? I don't understand. Oh, you want you want uh I don't know what benefit can you possibly have out of exposing bad people. I don't understand how there's ever anybody thinks there's a benefit out of it. It's literally a headache of all headaches. Look at the comments. All of his all of his victims are cursing me and and thinking that I'm like the biggest villain in the world. What benefit is there? What benefit is there? I'm not here to save those people that are glued to the tumh and and and will deny the truth even if it's punches them in the face. They're a lost cause. This message is for people that are simply on the line that almost have fallen into it. Those are the people that are savable. Everybody that's over there too far, there's nothing you can do. You could show Musher Abenu himself can come and tell you Frank Palmanov and Manis Freiedman and all the other heretics are heretics and they're bad and they'll still go with them with Korak and they'll still go with him. Why? They're glued to the tum they're glued to the filth. They'll say no no you're the bad guy. That's what the followers of Kor said. They said to Mush, you're the bad guy. But the problem is anyone that understands Torah understands very quickly that this is bad. You don't want to listen. Suit yourself. Suit yourself. Do what you want to do. It's not uh it's not it's not it's not it's not unfortunately the type of world where you know we have uh leadership and authority that we could force people to do anything like they did at the time of Moshe. People could do whatever they want. You want to go listen to heretics. You want to go listen to idol worshippers. You want to go listen to liars. You want to be lied to. You want to feel good about it. feel like you're smarter, go do what you want. You want evidence, I provided you some. I provide you sources for some more. There's plenty out there. But again, like I said, if you don't know what the truth looks like, then you won't understand. You won't understand what what a lie looks like. And for anyone that understands what Torah scholars are, what Torah is, everything that I said is not necessary. Why? of Aaron Feldman said it. That's it. That's the end. That's enough. Enough said. If you don't know what Torah is, then you'll say, "No, what does he know? Why should I listen to him?" All types of stupid things that people say. Do what you want. You've been warned. I did my job. I'm finished. I'm done. Now, your blood is in your hands.