Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

DEBATE - Jewish HaShkafa (50)

2,518 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

we're back starting a new week continuing our series of the Jewish ashfa uh tonight's sh will be for a for Rifka and Ben Rifka uh it's a uh just as a side note it's a newborn baby born prematurely at 28 weeks so please pay attention to the sh tonight and so the uh of the sh will be as significant as possible for the baby and for the mother to have a complete also for a foran s um also for AIT but let me see second tal s um David Bena Doris Bora and also for a for Mara B Julie Isa B Mara Samuel Ben Mara Seas Ben Mara Alexander Ben Marsha Lis Ben Mara sha Ben faran David Ben gabis elad benis uh Joshua Ben Noah alsoa Alex Ben Noah and alsoa nanel ysf Ben aaham and also a special happy uh birthday uh for own very dear team hasem uh member ital but levia and for her dear parents AR Ben Mala and Leia and to all of and all of the right just people that are watching our sh learning from them applying them to their life the the list continue to to uh grow but at the same token so are the blessings um so as a side note again a reminder uh for anyone who has not uh signed up to uh get one of these uh free boxes in the United States please because it's expensive to ship it to different countries you know some people from Africa want uh some CDs but it cost three $400 just to ship so uh we have to uh do this free offer specifically for the US uh this is a box of CDs for anyone who hasn't uh s seen the other videos we talked about it has 25 uh double CDs one is a CD one is a DVD having the uh movies lectures that have inspired countless people um and uh this is $170 value we're giving it for free one box per person uh one box for household to give it in your community number one it's uh doesn't put too much of a burden on any one particular person to give too many number two it's at least going to infuse some into your community into your family into your uh uh synagogue and uh so if you haven't uh signed up yet to get a free box please go to BH torah.org B is in boy H is an hasem uh Torah uh.org and bem we send you a box uh and and uh you'll get it within the next week or so so still within time before the very big day that uh we all need to already be uh you know getting ready for it now now um of course uh somebody reminded me today that today is one of the uh uh days that the guim here in the United States celebrate with a bunch of fireworks uh you know they're Independence Day uh and um there's no uh religious uh aspect of this particular holiday uh so there's no real uh you know idol worship that I know of that's connected to uh to this particular holiday but that does not mean that uh we should all go outside and start watching fireworks especially if that means it's going to come at the cost of you learning T of you fulfilling any type of Mitzvah or even simply schom uh but really the biggest thing is aside from schom is uh and aside from the uh vot that all of us are obligated to do on a day-to-day basis each one of us has to uh take a few things into account when they're considering these non-jewish so-called neutral holidays uh whether it's the ones in the US or in the other countries that you live in and the question is are you as excited are you as vested into the Jewish holidays as you are into the non-jewish holidays that's really the question each one of us is going to have to answer at one point when uh When Calls our name and we have to bring our uh because nothing else is going to come with us um that's the question that everybody has to answer you know did you get as excited and as vested uh into celebrating and P and uh you know even where you as a sad on as you are happy to blow up a bunch of fireworks and that's really a question that each person need to ask themselves because sometimes you see that people when you talk about Jewish holidays it's almost like you just told them somebody died uh but when it comes to uh the July 4th or Thanksgiving all of the other uh so-called uh neutral holidays some are debatable whether they're neutral or not but nonetheless you know people get so excited they go spend hundreds of dollars on uh on all types of things that are not really part of what uh you know you're uh you're supposed to be doing in your life and uh really a person needs to ask themselves ask themselves where their loyalty is you know and everyone can always say listen it's just having a good time why does I always have to be serious well listen you have to manage your own life but life is serious life is serious and uh as serious as it gets right now in Florida there uh there is a building that collapsed uh with many many people in it and uh many of them being Jewish and uh unfortunately there's been um such a uh situation where they're not really finding people that uh are alive in all of the uh turmoil that's there and all of the debris and they decided that tonight during that same time that you're uh listening to many people blow up fireworks I mean if you close your eyes if you close your eyes you're hearing things that sound like gunshots things that sound like bombs and in essence is the same exact thing as those n that are stuck under the uh under the debris over there they're also going to be hearing the same thing because they're going to blow up the same exact place but with actual bombs to demolish it uh tonight so uh life is very serious for all of those people that don't want to be serious life is very serious because uh I can assure you that those families those wives those husbands those children are not exactly celebrating uh Fourth of July right now and they're not exactly excited to hear explosions so listen you could care less you could live your own life and completely be nonchalant about the rest of am and that's your uh that's your choice but life is very much serious and uh the interesting thing is is that when you don't take other people's lives seriously when you don't take other people's uh difficulty seriously uh don't be surprised if the same exact treatment is given to you not by people but by himself and that's really one of the things the says that when a kosher person dies everyone that knows about it needs to mourn needs to mourn needless to say if a not only a kosher person but a person that's a a person that's dies person you know about it and you don't mourn over it it could bring a uh a prosecution against a person from heaven so I don't know if there was any Torah Scholars living there or not I do know there was a lot of Jewish people and uh there was a lot of people that had a lot of potential and there's a lot of people that did a lot of good so uh to use this day uh to celebrate a non-jewish uh day is not exactly ideal but again everybody has their own choices now this is indeed part of the Jewish ashfa this is part of the Jewish ideology where we have to focus on what's important and what's serious and not necessarily just about joking around and uh and uh you know and doing things that are not really connected to us especially since it gives examples to kids that are watching you you know they see that you're so vested into you know blowing up fireworks but not so much into uh celebrating PES or celebrating r or even celebrating Shabbat you're not so excited about that that gives more more more education to the kids uh than even a 10 years in Yesa uh simply by looking at their parents and that's that's one of the things that Shalom said about the uh uh the Jews in America years ago when he came to visit and he was told that there was many uh uh many people had uh you know their kids were starting to violate Shabbat and uh they asked the why do you think this is and uh wman says that their parents kept Shabbat but they complained about money they complained about money that they're not making on Shabbat because they're not working and because of that their kids learned from that and they said you know what I'm not going to lose money like my dad did they end up losing uh you know they ended up losing a Jew as a result of it because that kid ended up being a shabat and uh all his entire Judaism went into the garbage so a parent needs to know or even a brother or a sister a mother everybody needs to understand that you're not alone in the world you're not alone in the world your uh your action will create a reaction by someone even if you're not realizing uh that's the case even if you don't realize that someone's watching you there's always someone watching so uh when people are investing so much time and effort into these types of uh events these basketball and football and baseball and and uh and movies and fireworks and all of these different things that's in essence the educ ation you're giving to everyone that's watching you and uh it's you have to judge yourself more than anything else whether you are uh giving the right education uh to those that are watching you and whether you have the right amount of enthusiasm for the things that you really are supposed to be doing uh in comparison to the things that you know could be uh could be disposed of now the Kish used a couple of examples in the uh last week uh to show us the significance of what a d really is what is the opinion of the and and really comparing someone that knows a lot of Al versus someone that knows a lot of uh you know morals ethics now of course both are important and in essence both of them are supposed to come together and that's what we already reviewed for the last couple of months you cannot have just ala by itself just the Jewish law by itself you cannot have just morals by themselves because each one by itself turns into evil they all both have to come uh come together and each person that wants to be a complete person wants to become a scholar or even a decent human being has to have good morals as well as a good good amount of knowledge of of the law itself of the AL now if someone would want to determine who to choose as their Rabbi who to elect as their rabbi of the community uh who to uh uh to to use as a guide and things of that nature first a person needs to understand that the as good as a speaker is as good as a uh you know as a show someone gives as nice as a person is it's not worth much if the person does not know the law itself and at the very least has access to the law meaning that if you have somebody that you're using them to guide you to tell you you know what to do in your life issues with your marriage issues with your shid issues with your job and so on and so forth It's critical that you know that the way to decide whether this person is the right person or not to lead your community or even your life is based on their alic knowledge based on their alic knowledge and that's in essence how the sages were measured and are still measured today where a Torah scholar is measured based on their knowledge uh not anything else of course again I have to emphasize everything else has to come with it also but if there was a person that was a uh you know an expert in telling uh stories about amuna an expert in telling stories and uh you know of of rebuke an expert in telling stories ofid but did not know uh really the the basics of shabat or the basics of you know the K and things of that nature that's a good person to listen to and get motivated from from time to time but it's not someone that you would make your Rabbi and the reason why is because they don't have all of the tools that you need as a community or as an individual and so on so here the uh in section 19 of chapter 3 the K continues with even more details of examples and he says the following page 12b there's a story where uh Huna the son of rabman explains to Papa the of a high priest qu who has contracted satat commonly known as leprosy but actually is a spiritual disease in regards to whether he's permitted to marry a widow or not after he gave him the answer Papa got up and kissed him on the head and gave him his daughter as a wife so what what's going on here if Papa was a very wealthy man everybody wanted to marry his daughter of course you know you get married you don't have to do anything the father has all the money but it's not so easy to get the rich man's daughter now so now Papa was not only a rich man he was a Torah scholar so ra Papa was toiling over in a bet mid and couldn't get to the bottom of what happens if aen getsat if he gets does he lose all of his kadus because we know that if a getsat this spiritual and physical disease if he gets it he can no longer he's no longer fit to serve in a bet mikdash he can't serve in bet mikdash he can't be the qu anymore now the question is since he lost the ability to serve in a bet mikdash does he lose all of his Kusa where he's now allowed to marry a widow he's allowed to marry a divorce he's allowed to marry a woman that's not a virgin he's allowed to marry a woman that was a with a uh you know a non-jew once which according to is called a z so the question is is he allowed if he lost it so comes H and tells him this is although the Coen has lost his ability to serve in a bet mikdash here are the sources that show you that he did not lose his Kusa which means that he still is forbidden for marrying a widow and a divorce and a and a convert and a uh uh someone that was with a non-jew and someone that's not a virgin and so on and so forth he is only not allowed to serve in a bet mikdash that's it everything else stays the same says if you look at this what happens after that now he learned a he learned a new law now does it really apply to Papa himself no he's not a qu he's not going to go into the mdash no it doesn't really apply to his life does it apply to Huna no it doesn't apply to H either but Raa was so excited to learn this new that he got up and he kissed him on the forehead and he was so excited he said you are going to marry my daughter you're Myan everyone meet Myan this Myan he gave him his most prized possession all the money in the world is not worth your daughter so here we see something out of this world something completely abnormal wherea was so excited to learn this new this new to him that he gave him his PRI most prized possession now this as a side note shows also a side of the sages that many people don't know many people view the sages as people that are like you know cold like ice complete opposite the sages were very emotional people they were very sensitive people but the difference between them and the rest of the world is they knew exactly what to be emotional about where to express their emotions and K says the is stating that all the Torah study all the Torah study was handed down from Mount sa and it's showing us the Holiness of RA Papa's Soul that is his soul has become one with the Torah itself so much so that his love for the Torah and Thea was to such an extent that it excited him to such an extreme that he got up and he kissed Huna on his head and gave him his daughter here we see an expression of love not for Huna but for the Torah where someone that has delved into the Torah has toiled into figuring out what does this mean not just whose father is that guy and whose mother is that one and what was the name of this one no but things that require an extraordinary amount of research an extraordinary amount of mental strain an extraordinary amount of sacrifice to finally figure out what is the true law people that have toiled into that have have invested their entire lives into this when they finally get to the bottom line the type of happiness that it creates for them is unsurmountable it's something that you cannot express one time one of my dear friends zitron sent me a picture uh of RA kki is a person that everybody has seen has picture at some point but you don't necessarily see rki at a comedy club Shalom or at a sports event and you don't necessarily see him telling jokes either he's so specific about his speech that even His blessings even His blessings have been shortened since the has gone to where he used to say you know blessing and and success now he says bua bua meaning the acronym of he just uses the letters bua bua bua in order to limit the amount of strain that he uses in this world limit the amount of words that he uses in this world in order to dedicate all of his energy and all of his time into learning to now rki anyone that's seen the pictures and so on usually see rki is aik but he showed me a picture weki smile suddenly smile and the smile you didn't have to know anything you didn't have to learn know what Torah is you didn't have to know what Judaism is but as soon as you saw that smile you said that's what happiness looks like that is what happiness looks like and it's amazing that when you see Scholars when you see people smile it's you feel the happiness you feel it it's something that's out of this world because their happiness is not the same as just this joy that people get if you told them a joke or if they're eating something good or some other form of physical pleasure something that's dependent on something when they have their happiness it's something special so when I saw that picture I said yeah that's that's happiness that's what happiness looks like that's what happiness looks like now ra Papa that's what we're talking about here when ra Papa heard this new Al that he couldn't that he didn't get to on his own from H the joy that he got from it was something that just took over him it simply was overjoyed literally Overjoyed literally to the point where he's like I just want to give you everything to you gave me so much joy I what can I give you that would be even somewhat equivalent to it I'll give you my most prized possession my daughter that's what he did and that's what he did see the says that you see how Papa's Soul has become one with the T that it causes him to get such excitement when was the last time you saw somebody get so excited about a Harry Potter book or perhaps a newspaper article or maybe a something they watched on the news when was the last time someone watched one of these TV shows and they got got so excited said you know what I'm going to give my daughter to this movie star or you know what I'm going to give it to you because you watched it with me I'm going to give you my daughter because you watched the TV show with me or because you watched the the sports channel you saw some guy kick a ball earning $20 million for that ball and and the kick and because they won the game I'm going to give you my daughter what was the last time you saw such a thing no one in their right mind would ever do such a thing no one in the right mind would even think of such a thing no one would ever let his daughter or one his daughter to marry another guy just because they're both enjoying the game together I mean it's not at least not a normal person or a person that loves their daughter but here we see ra Papa in a moment got so much joy that he made a big decision the biggest decision that could possibly be how come it's okay for him to do it and not okay for the soccer fans not okay for the guys that like to uh the the same guy they voted for to win how come because here by getting the answer from Huna he got to know everything he could possibly want to know about aid for his daughter he got to know everything he could possibly want to know about the shid for his daughter which is does he know Torah or not that's all I need does he have a mind of Torah or not not is he smart or not not is he good-looking or not not is is he rich or not not is he tall or short or his eyes are green or burgundy or if his uh skin complexion is darker or whiter or or is heish or is HEI or none of that does he have d t or not the second that he saw and heard the D of that's all I need to know to give you my most prized possession hence my daughter uses this example the question is why did the use this example like why do I need to know that Papa was so excited over the Torah that he gave a daughter to to tuna I mean you could say love the Tor that's it save yourself six seven lines from the or you can say ra like the by UHA like the by and they he married off his daughter why do I need to know all these details I mean do I really need to know this whole scene why why do I need to know all of this and needless to say why is the Kaz using this and he says the following there's no doubt that no such thing could happen in the case of these people who are empty of Al and who study only the fear of God for why should such a person give his daughter to a person like Huna if the main component of the greatness of man lies in the moral discourse worthy of benefiting the masses what good does sharpness of Allah serve he says if you have to compare a person that knows Allah versus a person that knows only fear of God all he knows is lectures about G he doesn't know how to keep shabat he doesn't know how to keep kosher he doesn't know he doesn't really know much he just knows listen don't do anything nothing everything is forbidden or everything is allowed or you could just pick and choose whatever you want to listen to if it's a uh like some people uh ask me listen Rabbi this uh this three weeks thing is it uh what do you mean well I don't know he saying that you're not really allowed to shave and you're not really allowed to listen to music and you're not really allowed to do a few different things during this three weeks is that like rabal or is that from a Torah now I could easily give them an answer that many of these things are Customs from a rabbi but that would not be a good answer why because they wouldn't want know what to do with that answer if I tell them oh it's rabinal to them based on wherever they learned what they learned to even ask such a question that means oh it's rabinal oh okay so the heck with it I don't need to do any of this I don't need to I don't need to uh lower my uh joy in the world I could just continue things as is it's just uh rabinal just the rabbis just the rabbis this is unfortunately the teachings of people like Mesa and the others where they simply mock the rabbis to such an extent that they encourage people to Simply choose for themselves simply choose for themselves oh it's the rabis you don't have to listen to if it says it in the Torah then you can listen to okay but what where it says what in the Torah if it says what in the Torah if it says to keep Shabbat in the Torah okay but how do you keep Shabbat how do you keep Shabbat to keep Shabbat is in the oral toat that's by the rabbis the rabbis are going to explain to you all the different things but they don't think that far what ends up happening is that people don't know what to do with the information because they're not educated properly they haven't spent enough time learning about what the true Al is how to how to uh follow the AL what is and why that's required when you're following Al who are the Sages why should I listen to them they haven't they don't have all of these tools so what ends up happening is somebody asks you is this rabinal or is this biblical if you simply just tell them oh this is biblical and this is rabinal in essence what you're telling them keep this one that's biblical and don't keep anything else and that in essence makes you a partner to the crime a partner to their to the crime of killing them and everybody around them why because the punishment the punishment that who gives a person that violates some of his biblical mitv is not always death penalty sometimes it's much less if somebody stole something and they get caught they have to pay double they have to pay double simple if they hurt somebody they have to pay the the cost of what they uh what what the damage is rabinal on the other hand is death penalty all rabinal violations are death penalty now of course the people that don't respect the rabbis are going to say ah no come on that's crazy why do I why is the why do I have to listen to all these rabbis and so on and so forth now one of the uh people that uh I um mention in tonight's is Rifka and her new new Baby those born premature become a and like his great great-grandfather who is his great great-grandfather rwa the malel he used to be called Rafael because his his character traits was so beautiful that people said he's the same thing as a Mal he's same thing as an angel now ran Kawa was uh a giant Torah scholar brilliant in Torah was a uh had character traits of an Angel practice and taught fear of the almighty fought the wars of the Torah without any fear or any any limitations especially in the issues of modesty and was loved by the people to the extent when uh he uh eventually left this world 40,000 people 40,000 people showed up to his funeral now this is we're not talking about 500 or a thousand years ago we're talking about a little around 100 years ago less than 100 years ago and the Rafael was such a sadik that when he once heard that one of the community members there in Morocco his daughter was walking around with short sleeves he's walking around with short sleeves when he heard this he came to the father imagine the biggest Rabbi in Morocco shows up to your house yes hello yeah I hear that your daughter is walking around with short sleeves please speak to her speak to her okay but I spoke to her he says to him but you won't listen to me so Kawa says to him ah this is the this is the generation of mashia where it says G there's going to be a lot of the kids are not going to listen to parents so maybe if you tell her that in my name that I heard that she's walking around with short sleeves and she has to change that and do cha right away and she has to beat a little while later the rabbi came back came back to the father cuz he heard that the girl hasn't changed and he says to the father no what happened did you tell her what I told you he says I did so what did she say and the guy is embarrassed he said I don't want to repeat what my daughter said about the rav and I'm I'm really sorry she won't listen and what did she say no no no I don't want to repeat I don't want to repeat he was so embarrassed at how obnoxious and rude his daughter was that he was embarrassed to say to the r what his daughter said unfortunately that's like some people say about big RAB on a daily basis on the internet they type it he doesn't know he's an idiot he's a this he's a that people talk about rabbis like they talk about a uh enemy they won't even talk to their enemies this way but they talk about rabbis that way so this girl was of the same seed but she had a little bit of Merit why did she have a little bit of Merit she had a in her life so when Kawa heard this said ah okay I did what I could I did what I could as soon as he said that he left the daughter runs back home comes into the house she's scratching everywhere she doesn't know what's going on they look at her our our arms are full of boils full of boils and infections she's bed written the doctor show up no one understands what's going on but the father and the daughter know exactly what's going on you went against that's what you get that's what you get when the girl realized that this is 100% the case and it's not going away because surely she was stubborn at first trying to make excuses like a lot of people like to make excuses no it's just a coincidence just because he said it just because of this just because of that but after enough pain to break the kipa she realized please ask the r if he's willing to forgive me I promise him to do Chua I want to go meet him I want to meet the rabbi and apologize to him the father went to Kawa and said my daughter sincerely apologize please if you could just see my daughter and and and forgive her she the girl came apologized Kawa saw that she was sincere gave her a blessing shortly later completely healed as quickly as it came on it left as quickly as it came on it left this is something that uh are dear to ashem to such an extent that Hashem is willing is willing to forsake his own name and not the name of this meaning hasem will allow a person to sin and even do horrible things in the name of hem and he won't punish him right away but when it comes to his when it comes to his Scholars to his people that dedicate themselves the to Hashem does not uh does not uh have any any loose uh loose rope in there simply the worst thing that a person can do is go against the now waswa known as a miracle worker yes made many miracles this being one of many but is that why he's known absolutely not why is he known because he was an extraordinary when it came to an extraordinary when it came to such as the community never saw during that time anyone like him and he knew exactly how to solve problems and to add even more Merit to this young little boy that came into the world in the name of his grandfather we'll tell another story about where years ago there was a uh Arab guy Moroccan guy that uh was friends with the Jewish guy friends enough that uh the uh he asked uh he asked him to keep his money keep his money for him while he goes to Mecca so he gave the Jew the Arab guy gave the Jew the money and uh went to Mecca to celebrate his holiday when he came back he asked the Jew for the money for the money back and a Jew looks at the Arab says I have no idea what you're talking about I have no idea what you're talking about I never seen you in my life what what do you mean he never seen me in life and the Arab just sees black sees that his all of his life savings everything is gone and there's no way for him to get back but he doesn't know what to do he knows if he kills the guy it's not really going to solve the problem it's not going to give him the money this was a a bright Arab guy what am I going to do so the other Jews that see said no no you got to go to the go to he'll help you so he heard about the he goes to the says you got to bring him to he brings the Arab guy brings the Jew to De Tora and he tells listen this y from your he took my money do you have any proof no I don't have any proof any Witnesses no I don't have any Witnesses according to there's no Witnesses nothing you can do you can't just tell the guy give him the money back if he didn't really maybe the Arab guy's a liar but the same token know generally speaking people don't just make up lies out of nothing there's there's always something there has to be something there you can't just dismiss it Kawa says to him do you remember where you gave him the money yeah of course I remember the I remember exactly the place where did you give him the money says it was right next to a tree a tree certain distance from here this particular tree and what what the tree look like he tells him the the description of the tree and says to him what's the circumference of the the tree what's the circumference of the tree how big is the tree he say well I don't know he says go go to the tree go to the tree measure it take a rope measure it and bring it back to me Arab says okay says fine he leaves so then during this time the Jew is Left Behind with uh with the r and the r starts mumbling to himself and says I need to go I need to go yeah yeah I need to go yeah I need to go okay so he tells the Jewish guy says okay listen uh he's uh he's probably going to be gone for a really long time few hours so I'll be back in a few hours Jud tells him no no Rabbi that tree it's only probably 20 minutes from here it's only 20 minutes from I'll be right back so Kawa says to him if you know how far the tree is that means you saw where the tree is that means you were there that means the Arab is not lying go and give him all of the money with every single penny right now and the Jew realized that he just got caught and he went and returned the money to the Arab he had got the money ready as soon as the Arab came back he was ready to give him the circumference no no you don't have to say anything the Jew gave him all the money back I'm sorry I took your money the Arab went into the community into the Arab Community says there's no like this y this Rabbi there's no like him smartest man in the world that is that is the uh messenger of hasem big even though it was a Jewish criminal that led to this needless to say when you understand Al and you understand that you can't just dismiss things just because it comes from the wrong side or the wrong people or the wrong uh uh direction that you thought bottom line is you have to know the law and how to practice it the knew exactly who what when and how with every aspect of the Torah now at the time of uh of um who was one of there was a war that was the obviously Sadam Hussein Sadam Hussein had a very big interest very big interest in destroying is and so on now everyone knew he was a g a p it was a giant and so on what some people don't know is that he was also an extraordinary meal a very big meal and uh when Saddam Hussein announced that uh he is taken the name and his uh station of missles he called it the 17th of tamuz which is the uh the day where the uh the mdash was they broke into into so knew that this is a Rashad that's from relevant to the end of times a Rashad that is relevant to the Prophecies of the end of times and it's not just a typical rash that hates Jews so who according to the whole world is known as a as a not necessarily as a but he was a very big M he called the person who wrote this story this story is in a seph about in the sixth volume and this particular person that told the story is still there today Inon Inon where is the whole situation that happened recently in one of the people over there running the place he's still there today for anybody that wants to go check the story with him he's the one that wrote the story he's the one that witnessed the story and he gets a call from and uh he says to him listen I need you to prepare the place for me I'm bringing myself and uh nine other we need the place and we need privacy to do something so he understands the message make sure that no one else is going to be there but the same token it's a public place so they go there in the middle of the night and of course somehow the news finds out no one knows how they always find out it's like they have everybody's phones tapped but comes they see the cars middle of the night with nine Other M and they start doing what's called cabal cabal is practical cabala it's the type of stuff that if you don't know what you're doing and you mess with it most likely you're either going to die or you're going to Simply suffer for the rest of your life very very strange types of sufferings but if a person knows what they're doing and they're holy enough to deal with such a thing then these are these are things that a person could literally change nature with so brings these other and they start doing a whole sermon a whole type of thing where they start they have these 10 uh uh these black candles and all types of really interesting things perhaps some people think they saw this in the movies but nonetheless this is a uh part of theab and this reporter this reporter is there and the guy from is telling you got to leave you can't this is he says no you can't kick me out this is a public area it's public property I could be here if I want to he says no but the rabbi needs to do something you cannot record this he says I'm going to do whatever I want right about when there about to start the guy has his camera he refuses to leave suddenly his camera all the equipment explodes to Pieces Boom Out of Nowhere it explodes to Pieces the guy actually gets hurt they have to call an ambulance ambulance takes them he leaves and then they do what they have to do they complete it they say says we said succeeded Hussein is not going to Saddam Hussein is is not going to succeed he's going to fall and of course everyone knows the story that that's in essence what ended up happening now was a because of his cabalistic knowledge no was he famous because of it absolutely not was he respected by the other because of it no he wasn't of course people value that he knew all this knowledge but to become a g or even to become a is not because of cabalistic knowledge although everyone that doesn't know anything wants to attain it because it sounds cool you can move stuff with your mind you could do all types of things it sounds cool sounds like you become a superhero but only the fools only the fools run into this world without the right equipment only the fools because although it is extremely stimulating extraordinary amazing and every type of positive word you can describe for anyone with a little bit of understanding of what it is knows that it's not for everyone in fact it's not for the overwhelming majority of people to even learn about it or delve into it because if you are not pure enough if you're not pure enough if you are not holy enough to even delve over it you could create more damage than you can fix there's there's a hospital there's a hospital in Hal specifically with a department for people like this that delved into this cabalistic world without being uh well suited for it and unfortunately they're in uh Institution for the rest of their life now this this is not like some type of conspiracy I saw the place and the reality is that many people today want to buy all types of cabalistic works because they think that's what's going to make them holy they don't realize that in order to even be able to be well suited for this world you already have to be an expert in an expert in sh an expert in an expert in all of the basics expert not just you've read it once you got over it you've glanced into it perhaps maybe even wrote A Few articles about it an expert in all of that plus a bunch of other things literally you have to become a Pure vessel a pure vessel to get into this world and it's the reason why many of the people that are are into it and actually know what they're talking about generally don't discuss it with the public because it's literally not for everyone it's stuff that you hear stories about it stuff that perhaps you have the Merit of seeing a story come true uh with somebody that's into it but nonetheless it's not something for everyone and unfortunately many times people that are new to Judaism uh or people that are completely not Jewish at all you know they're uh they're Christians or whatever they are they like this type of stuff because they uh it sounds cool it sounds like miraculous and so on and you'll see many times them Del delve into this type of stuff most of the time nothing happens most of the time it's just complete waste of time and it just creates confusion and you start seeing uh people that don't even know how to spell ABA uh you know the word ABA which is father in Hebrew they don't know how to spell that even but they'll start talking to you about oh yeah but it has to do with the and it has to do with this they start naming different parts of the Nish as if like they're uh experts in a cabalistic world it's a you know for anyone that's remotely knowledgeable about Torah it sounds like a joke sounds like a joke why it's it's literally like someone who just learned algebra starting to discuss what his opinion is of the rocket science that was used to build a rocket to go to Mars just doesn't work doesn't work but unfortunately in the Torah world everything works for some people because don't let the facts ignore don't let the facts ruin a good story and that's unfortunately what happens many times but we also saw in the uh in last week's uh last week's sh where uh the brought an example from the page 48 where he says that uh uh Raa that Raa was a uh talking to rman about ROV now this whole example of he said that he's a great man he says bring him to me and let me see if he's a really great man and how did he test him he tested him with Al questions said you have any questions for me anyone doesn't know that whole section just watch last week's sh and he asked him some questions that were extraordinarily big questions the question is though is how come how come didn't go into another story how come he didn't ask him about rman didn't ask him about his Miracle working ability why would he ask him a miracle working ability because in the page 29b there is a uh an event that happened where ROV is expected to come into town where abay is and ab tells everybody in town do not host don't host him so everybody thought that AB the the biggest Rabbi is telling everyone not to host another G another sad that's coming into town because he wants to host them but as they would find out AB says to them no I'm not going to host them no one host them and I'm not going to host him either so instead of all the announcements you would have typically posters everywhere you know sadik is coming to this town everyone is running to host something no one is hosting soov comes into town nothing no one's hosting him no one's paying attention nothing said okay fine I'm GNA go and stay at the BET midash and he goes into the BET midash and he starts learning and learning and learning and learning and learning and as you would have it a mazik a demon comes in to the BET mid trying to kill everybody in sight but only finds yob sees this demon is an extraordinarily powerful demon with seven different heads looking like a uh a um some type of reptile like a snake with seven different heads and he says specific prayer specific name of hem one head comes off another name of hem another head comes off another name of AEM another comes off da within a few moments he kills this very powerful demon the next morning ABA comes he sees this whole thing is dead and raka is there raka says to them you endanger me he says listen I had to do it I had to do it why this demon this mazik has been torturing the city for a while no one can beat him no one can beat him now I know if I would tell listen we have this demon here he's torturing us this mazik is it maybe the r would say you know what I'm not coming I'm not coming out I'm not coming here to fight I'm coming here to to the town maybe to do some K help some people do cha I'm not coming to fight demons so I know if I tell the r there's a possibility that I'm putting a burden on the r on the other hand I know there's no other way to deal with it so I figured you know what no one talked to anything and let's see how Hashem decides if hashem's going to send this mazik to uh to that means it's his it's his to deal with because surely I knew that you can deal with it this is a story in question is when R was asking let me meet this guy and see how great he is why didn't they mention this story this guy is so powerful with a few names he destroys demons that were torturing an entire city how come because these types of things although extraordinary very very exciting to talk about that's not what makes a Gul that's not what makes someone a extraordinary person that the entire country the entire people need to listen to that's not the case surely it's a special person but if we're going to talk about the of the Tor tell us if you want to know who should be your Rabbi if you want to know who you should listen to if you want to know who's a real you cannot decide it based on their Supernatural ability you cannot decide it based on their storytelling you cannot decide it based on certain things that typically people decide on there speaking ability their looks their uh certain they have no you have to decide it and determine it based on their knowledge that's what you decided on and of course that they're they're practicing it themselves and that's actually what writes in he writes in he actually brings something very interesting where he says that the you have and you have the ISF isi and he says the in section 242 number one he says that theama says how do you pick your Rabbi how do you pick this this this Rabbi to lead the community and so on he said you pick a person who does not focus who does not have his focus on Pim you know toiling into the different possibilities of different things and mental stimulation but rather someone that is focused on what the is what is the bottom line tell me what to do what not to do bottom line but not based on his own opinion and what he thinks you should do because you live in Florida versus you live in Montana what is the P what do the say what is the here tell me don't tell me different opinions tell me bottom line yes or no allowed not allowed that's what I need to know now of course this is very interesting why is this interesting because really the the the trouble that has entered this last couple of generations perhaps where there's a lot of people that have called themselves rationalists all of them have this issue in common which is that they love to delve into things too far where you see that the from is a and if it's not in then it's in the r it says a right but they say no but you don't really have to listen to this because you could also listen to something else and they start making a whole mishmash of things this also situation is very common in the modern Orthodox world where you'll have a one of these rabbis give a talk and he gives you one of these what they call Source sheets so they give everybody a little notebook with all the sources that the guy is going the rabbi is going to use during the lecture so if it's let's say an hour talk you'll see 30 40 50 sources however many sources on this piece of paper and he goes over each one Rabbi such and such says this says this and this one says that and this one this thattt depending on how good of a speaker the person is you know sometimes they'll go through all of the sources sometimes only 10 20% but one thing that I've noticed personally and I've heard from other people the same type of uh uh issue what's the common denominator there is no conclusion there's no conclusion meaning after they go go they discuss whatever issue let's talk about let's say the issue of the the milk of the non-jews can you use it can you not use it and so on so they give you all the different sources of this one says this and this one says that and this one says this and of course in our toah it's it's extraordinary it's huge it's endless there's a million different opinions to everything but the job of the especially the leader of a community is to tell you yes or no allowed not allowed bottom line conclude everything for me conclude anything for me tell me yes or no don't leave it to me and unfortunately that's what's been happening they leave it to the community to decide for themselves and what ends up happening with an average person that did not either did not grow up with Torah or did not grow up with teachings of not no fear of Heaven whatsoever or does not have any real understanding or respect for the Sages and their opinions they all come up with the same conclusion oh if there's so many different opinions I'll just throw my opinion in there also that it probably match somebody in essence what they end up doing is whatever they want this is a destruction of the Torah this is a destruction of the tah and unfortunately the brainchild of all of that or perhaps even the parent I'm not really sure which one came first is this rational minded type of people where they Toil and Toil and toil into things and they conclude whatever they feel like whatever they feel like whatever is soothing to them and so on and really the uh the r writes in in the letter that he wrote the yite uh community that all of these people whether it's from the Christian Community that is trying to make everybody follow Yos uh or it's the uh the the m of of Muhammad or it's the Heretics or Jews that are trying to lead you in different places they'll have one common denominator they'll have one common thing which is they want to fulfill their desires therefore they need a way to do it they need a way to calm their conscience so how can I fulfill my desires that are animalistic but at the same token still be viewed by myself and others as righteous what do they do they try to rationalize the Torah and in essence destroy it in order to permit themselves to fulfill their animalistic desires which is the conclusion of all of it the reason why people rationalize the Torah mock the sages minimize the glory of hasem and all of these things have to do with the same bottom line the goal is to fulfill their own animalistic desires but they're not going to tell you that and some sometimes they themselves don't realize it that that's the real bottom line that's the reason why they're telling people to simply not listen to the sages not listen to the big rabbis not listen to what it says in the uh you know what was concluded by by the community and so on no just listen to what your heart says listen to your own judgment you're a smart guy you're a smart lady you can know you know what's best for you and in essence they tell a person that has never even flown a a a play a play plane with a remote control to go fly a rocket to outer space that's in essence what they're telling people to do and that's the big problem with people like that in the world where they say listen why don't you just debate me why don't you just debate me and I'll show you that my conclusion is the best conclusion it's not the old-fashioned conclusion that you have which is to listen to the sages and listen to the and just be like a good little boy no no you can conclude yourself You can conclude yourself now how come we don't debate such people whether they're Christian missionaries or they call themselves Messianic Jews or they're Heretics of other kinds like this Mesa and Prager and and Manis fredman and the others why why don't we just you know duke it out you know because just like in the secular world people have different opinions if they're running for office or if they're uh there's some type of uh uh money on the line or something something like that they'll duke it out with a uh with a debate why don't we do that this has to do also with also with which has to do with a few of them but one of theas is inah number 456 mitvah number 456 what mitvah is this the prohibition of listening to one who prophesizes in the name of a name of idolatry what does that have to do with debating with Heretics why is it that every single time somebody ask me can you debate somebody I tell them no and it has to do with this Al not just this but it has to do aot with this to why is it that everybody tells me that listen I want to such and such what do you think I told them don't do it why is it that when somebody told me listen there was somebody that did a debate with some Christian Missionary and he won now he wants to have a second event do you can you uh sponsor it and I say no why why first and foremost we have ala the Ala starts with this and grows much much further and thisa says says that there's a Prohibition of listening to one who prophesizes in the name of but the guy is not prophesizing in name of ab he's not even a prophet in fact he's a Jew and he is talking about Judaism just his own ideology of Judaism his own perception of Judaism so what does it have to do with it let's see the pur goes where this is based out of in the book of Deuteronomy chap 13: 2- 4 again this is in the book written about 800 years ago mitvah number 456 and the source of this Mitzvah is as follows where it says in the Torah Deuteronomy CH 13: 2-4 if there should stand up in your midst a prophet or a dreamer of a dream and he will produce to you a sign or a wonder and the sign or wonder of which he spoke to uh he spoke to you comes about saying let us follow gods of others that you did not know and we shall worship them do not listen to the words of that Prophet or to that dreamer of a dream for hasem your God is testing you to know whether you love AEM your God with all of your heart and with all of your soul here the basic meaning of this is that Hashem is already prophesizing both Christianity and Islam and all of the ones that came in between them telling you that if you have somebody that comes and tells you that they have a new way there's a new testament there is a Quran there is a prophet we call him Yos or Muhammad or any other Pikachu in between and they are telling you that listen the Torah is great but there's a new thing we call it the New Testament we call it the Quran we call it something else in between says hasem says already anyone that comes to you even if they perform Miracles like people say that these two made even if they are they predict something and it happens don't listen to them the second they tell you to steer away from the Tora they become what's called nav what's na false prophet so how come hasem is allowing this false prophet to make Miracles how come hasem is making is allowing this false prophet to predict things before they happen the verse says forem your God is testing you to know whether you love hasem your God with all of your heart and all of your soul so now the starts to elaborate says that in order to know whether someone is a real Prophet or not we have to test them we have to test him we have to know he has to do certain signs he has to prove himself to show that he has the powers of Prophecy and he has to predict certain things before they happen similar things similar things to these but there's a difference what the real Prophet tells you things in the name of hem to continue what hasem already said not change it here we have people that are changing it telling you there's a new covenant and a new uh a new way of serving hem and so on so here these verses the Torah is commanding us not to engage in Idol in in a idolatrous prophet where we have to to swiftly end the conversation with him and not even challenge him to prove his prophetic abilities as we do with a person who claims to Prophecy in the name of hem meaning if a person says I'm I'm I'm giving you prophecies in the name of ashem we listen to what he says we have he has to prove himself but if a person is giving you a new covenant person is giving you a new uh Quran or new way of thinking we don't even debate these people we don't talk to them we simply run away from them now even if this idolatrous Prophet produces a sign or a Wonder without us asking we must believe that these signs are nothing but Witchcraft and sorcery and that Hashem allowed them to possess and display such powers only in order to test us has a between RAB AKA and R where RAB AKA is saying that uh no this Prophet perhaps Hashem gave him the abilities because he was a good Prophet initially and then he turned bad but is saying no no no he is using sorcery and Witchcraft to make all this magic tricks it looks like the is leaning towards that way but either way even if somebody that's prophesizing a false religion a different different from Makes Miracles says things that going to happen without us trying to test them we still are forbidden from listening to this person and in fact we have to leave this person uh and uh not even debate them not prove anything nothing this is simply a test of mem now this test uh they're saying is this test is simply to uh to see our belief in Hashem and whether we're going to be swayed by Supernatural stunts now the term idolatrous Prophet is not simply just somebody that is uh prophesizing for uh idol worship itself directly but even if it's somebody that's simply telling you things that uh are connected to the toah but he got it from a different Source he got it from a different Source meaning it's not AEM that's also uh a now the question is why do we run away from this person at the time of the if you saw somebody as a false prophet you have to warn them stop doing what you're doing because if you do it again we have to take you to to the S and when kills them to death penalty false prophet gets a death penalty of course we don't have a s today and uh I think we have a lot of false prophets but we don't have S today every other day somebody else says they're the mashiach or they're this or they're that every other day somebody else has some type of stupid uh uh uh announcement to make to the world the question is why do we not debate this person why do we not discuss their mistakes maybe even try to get them to do chuva why don't we prove them that they're wrong why does the mitvah say that we have to not listen to anything that they say and in fact leave leave and the rambam says a person like this you're not even a person that's a missionary you're not even allowed to be within four am of him four am is six feet now to stand six feet next to such a person the says we are commanded not to listen to the words of one who prophesizes in the name of ab meaning to say that we should not examine him and should not ask him to provide us with signs of Wonders to substantiate his prophecy as we do with one who prophesies in the name of Hashem where he must accurately predict future events and prove that he's a genuine Prophet but rather immediately upon hearing him prophesizing in the name of ab we must prevent him from continuing the sinful Behavior as it's proper to do with anyone who is a wrongdoer or guilty a sinner a p if you persists with his opinion and continues to promote his idolatrous prophecy we carry out with with him the particular punishment that the Torah imposed upon him as start m page 89A which means that he would die through which is strangulation so here we see that a person that comes with falsehood we simply run away from such people we don't them we don't do nothing why gives the reason now among the underlying purposes of this Mitzvah is that people are often prone to error and their intellect is not always Keen enough to arrive at a correct conclusion regarding important matters the Torah was therefore concerned that perhaps due to the deceitful arguments and through engaging and lengthy dialogue and debate with a willful sinner who speaks falsehood and who prophesizes in the name of idolatry a person will be persuaded by his words and even if he will not be persuaded by the words of this idolatrous prophet and will not accept his beliefs he may perhaps have some doubts in his heart even even for one moment that there is some trace of Truth in that prophet's falsehood now we know that the words of the idolatrous Prophet cannot endure for more than a short time for the truth will un will ultimately emerge and show its way and will attest to the utter falsehood of the words of the Prophet nevertheless the Torah was concerned for us that we should not waste even one moment of Our Lives contemplating that sinful thought thus we must avoid all interaction and dialogue with such people see here is the bottom line This is not just in regards to someone that's a false prophet but anyone that simply speaks falsehood about the Torah especially someone that's doing it knowingly where dialoguing with such a person publicly or even dialoguing with them privately if you already know it it will be to no avail the person is not looking to change the person is not looking to do chuva the person is not look looking to learn but rather the person is looking to win they looking for their argument to win in this particular case to make a public event debating such a person is dangerous perhaps not to the speaker but to the audience perhaps not even to all of the audience maybe just some and perhaps not even some to for them to change their beliefs because generally speaking the people have the truth usually have something to hold on to but the says here even even though most people are prone to make an error and they could fall for the falsehood of the wrong side they're good speakers they're they're they're CL ever they have some ideas that perhaps make sense or touch a some type of nerve in your heart so some people can fall for that some people on the other hand they're not going to fall for it but they're going to think about it a little bit you know what what he says does make sense though it's wrong but it does make sense though that in itself is a problem that in itself is a problem that for a moment you liked what the heretic said and the third it's simply a waste of time and the Torah says says just wasting your time on this foolishness is enough enough of a reason not to delve into it just wasting your time thinking and and debating whether the Heretics words whether the idolatry uh his words are valed or not just even delving into it thinking about it for a few moments already is enough of a reason not to do it why you should be spending that time learning to you should spend that time do what you're supposed to be doing now of course does say you should know what to say to anus you should know what to say to a heretic and and and you know how to beat him in a debate if it ever comes but don't do that by learning his text don't do that by giv giving him a public stage and endangering others don't do that in order to get some type of fame or Fortune you want to help somebody no problem go ahead and help somebody but to give people a stage to go into all types of things like this is not something that should be done by the average person needless to say by most people has it been done yes it has been done by great rabbis the has done it in in Barcelona under dire circumstances he didn't want to do it other rabbis have done it throughout the ages but again under dire circumstances where they got rabinal approval by people that are much greater than them that this was needed they didn't make a career out of it they didn't do it every week or every month in order to get fans but rather they did it when there was some type of rescue mission that was in essence the goal of the whole thing not uh listen we're going to do it because we want to get some YouTube hits and that's one of the differences between someone who searching for the truth versus someone that is simply looking for fans looking to get views looking to get ratings this type of understanding requires a person both to have Torah knowledge in regards to and Torah knowledge when it comes to Musa when it comes to fear of heaven when it comes to ethics and how and morals in general how to behave in accordance to what the sages said now theim were not ones to kiss up to anyone but yet they mentioned these extraordinary stories about Papa getting up and choosing a new husband for his daughter based on a a new that he did not know showing him showing us that he loved Torah so much that he was so glued to the Torah that the second that he learned something new it caused him so much joy that it was a uh something that he couldn't even control it was worth everything for him and here the K says that this could never happen with someone one that strictly learns about just morals based on their own understanding morals that they learn from the streets morals that they learn from people that they meet not the you know the itself because although musar will tell you which direction you need to go in ALA is the actual Road itself ala is the actual Road itself so if a person just studies M they're not going to really know what's what's the actual Road even if they hit it same concept goes with if you just study Al if you just study the law you'll know the road but you won't know which you know how to go on this road you won't know how to practice this law that's why they both have to come together with each other now the K continues and says that from this we see the evident confutation of the point of view of those who lack the love of ala and have not perfected their soul with it for this knowledge of ala is the complete Perfection that Hashem lovesin elaborated on this basic point in the addendum of the book saying his own personal view that I would give all of my prayers that I've ever prayed in my life for one new learned from the now was one of the the Yesa system we have today is based on and he says that all of this all of the good that I have all the prayers that I make for p all the prayers that I made for good health all the prayers that I made for everything in my life I would give all of them all of them just to learn one new thing in the this is not to say that he's telling you that he knows everything although he didn't know whole lot than we could ever know but he's trying to tell you how valuable it is to learn a single thing a single thing in a toah if you really understand the value of toah and he would have given all of the prayers that he prayed his entire life just to learn one more and then continues the K says that good deeds are not assets that can be bought sold or exchanged was simply using this expression to convey the idea that a Torah scholar should sacrifice himself completely to studying Al and clarifying the law from the because that is the form of worship most beloved by hasem and it's on a higher level than prayer many times you'll see that people pray a lot and it's good to pray but it's even more important to know the priorities or the significance of things in the eyes of hasem theat page 10A has a story where ra sees rauna praying a long prayer and after a little while he rebukes him and he says to him you're spending all this time praying for things of this world when you could be already learning T which is going to make something much greater for the next World meaning that yes prayer is good but learning to is much more significant it doesn't mean that you don't pray you still have to pray when the time is to pray but you have to understand that to learn to especially when it comes to learning Al learning the bottom line of what needs to be done how to be done and so on that is the upper e line of tah that is the higher highest end of tah to know the will of is to know now the problem is that sometimes you have people that are going to tell you listen there are some things that are clear in a toah it's in a written toah you need to do it great and there are some things that are not so clear they're not so clear in the tah but we have the rabbis but the rabbis are not all in agreement on this so since the rabbis are not all in agreement on this you can just pick whichever Rabbi you want to listen to this is completely wrong page 14a says a person that looks for the leniencies of and the leniencies of he's a wicked person he's only looking for the leniency whatever fits his agenda the uh the uh person that is looking only for stringencies only for string stringencies only uh you know bet Shay only ones to do the most stringent stuff he is like a dark mule uh walking in darkness even that's what the says meaning you can't just pick and choose rabbis like you're choosing a new shirt for the weekend doesn't work that way first and foremost there has been a decision by the people that know a lot more T than us people that know a lot more than anybody else that everything that the has p on that's what goes by that's what goes by you are you go by the you go by now there are some things that the did not on he didn't passing on so then we look at the rambam generally speaking we look at the rambam if the rambam pass on it we go by the rambam that's what we go by but there are some things that are new in our age are new in our times that we need the pem of the recent generation to clarify for us either because they did not exist back then and therefore it's in essence a uh a uh show us how to apply the pre-existing to today's new world or it's a Clarity of how to apply specific to a new tool point being is you have Pim of today new circumstances of today are discussed by theim of today but the vast majority of stuff doesn't need that the vast majority of things how to keep Shabbat kosher you know all the the very basic stuff is things that you could simply follow the follow the uh theim of the generation whether it's or uh the uh uh um the K or you have a and so on and so forth you have you have enough material out there where there's really no place that you could walk into without knowing without having at least a few different things that you could apply to that place a few different things that are relevant to that thing whether it's a a business activity or transaction or certain life activity or whatever it is everything has some type of Torah available that's uh that's applicable to it and it surely is that have discussed this issue now you yourself are generally not going to have time to review the entire to yourself hence the reason why you need a rabbi that's a that's going to point you in the right direction of tell you yes or no if you're a scholar yourself then you need to have a rabbi to double check that what you're saying what you're concluding is right you're going in the right direction but generally speaking most people are not rabbis most people even if they are rabbis they're not qualified enough to for themselves that is the reason why even if somebody is smart enough to know where to go and find the final ruling it is still not a good idea in fact it is a terrible idea to teach the public the masses to go do that meaning if there is a book that's clear says yes no yes no basic things for the average person for example you have for the Safari people you have the uh Yak it's translated into English it's in Hebrew it's tells you yes or no on practically everything you need to know on your day-to-day life if you're in a uhi you have the which is a book that was written about 100 years ago and tells you yes or no about a lot of different things and of course there are other things that uh you have you have the also you have a lot of other things that you can review but the point being is is that to go tell people to go review the itself from 500 years ago and figure out or to go review every P out there and then figure out or to go give people a source sheet with 50 or 100 different sources discussing their views of the same point is ill advised and at at best case and at worst case it's it's horrible why because either people are not going to do it or they're going to arrive at the wrong conclusion because they don't have D they don't have D now you're GNA say okay listen but the guy sometimes he wants to be honest he says listen even though it's good to do XYZ it's not an obligation to do XYZ it's an obligation to do X so I just do X if you do X in essence fulfill the obligation yourself it's not great because this it's the the teaching is XYZ and you're doing X it's not great but it doesn't necessarily make you a sinner you're right but if you teach or you publicly announce that you know that XYZ is what everybody does but really you're only obligated to do X and that's what you tell people then you are not only a but but you are you are causing the public to sin why because by telling them your shortfalls publicly you're in essence publicizing a new teaching you're in essence telling them that it's okay that this becomes the new standard you're in essence making a new level for them to Aspire to and it's not the level of what they're supposed to be doing now of course not everybody's going to succeed doing XYZ but who are you to decide that why are you deciding for them to do only X now you're saying no I'm not deciding for them I'm just telling them what I do what benefit does it serve them to know that you only do X how does it benefit them to know that their leader their superhero only does X how does it make them better how does it make them better so you see this is not just an understanding of Al it's also understanding of M of of of morals of of how to behave and when a person does not have a rabbi to tell him when he's right when he's wrong the person simply will assume he's always right we all assume we're always right we all assume we're always right this is why the K time and time again tells us listen M and they go together but if you want to make sure that you're going in the right direction you have to have somebody that's an expert in the bottom line law the AL itself and that expert is not you it's somebody else make yourself a Rabbi now sometimes a person is going to think ah this is a modernday belief this is not in the Torah wrong wrong why last week's Paras we see lot of interesting things we see Pinas Ben saves the nation Sav jewry all the way to today because of his zealousness later on we see that Zim is the name of the person that committed a immorality he was the leader of the Shimon tribe and will forever be remembered as the person that went against AEM publicly by committing immorality with a Goya named they both will be remembered for eternity as the Sinners as the as wicked people for a single act he could have been righteous his whole life he was hundreds of years old Z hundreds of years old but he will be forever be remembered as a person that went against hem went against mosu publicly asash that was murdered and the murder of him and the Z that he was with save the nation and kby will be forever remembered for eternity as the filthy Harlot Goya that try to destroy Amy land forever they'll be remember this way further we go on and we hear about the census in the sensus this interesting way of how hasem is mentioning each name is ruven is the first born of Israel why do I need to know that ruen is firstborn thank you ruven is firstborn in other times that we mention the senses it doesn't say that ruen is first born this is to remind us that ruen was the first B chuva he made chuva for going against his father making a mistake changing the beds he made CH and that is what motivated y to do CH himself with Tam and will forever be remembered as the first B then you have the have the who are forever going to be remembered as part of all of which got murdered got killed by a himself for going against hem and going against mhu no one's ever going to call their kids the T a without knowing that you're calling you're naming your kid after Heretics no Jew is named korak today no one and anyone that calls themselves korak is simply a person that's like a Nim that goes against theem on purpose kak will be forever known as a person that went against mosu went against hem went against the T with his own opinion what to says the sons of course didn't die why didn't die because they did CH before it was too late they went against their own father and on the side of mosu then it continues and it says in the tribe of says for the tribe of yudah there was and died why they died seph Book of Genesis says that both killed them because they wasted seed they did not want to impregnate Tamar and keep her beautiful so saw this as evil and he killed both of them forever they will be known as the people that wasted seed and killed them that will never change they will forever be known as those people now remember we also have a Torah about us you have a Torah about you there's a Torah about me there's a book that written about all of us how do you want your name to be written in his book you have later on who's the first who killed him by having mosu and stone him to death Stone him to death stoning is throwing a person off of a two-story building if he still alive then they roll a huge Boulder on top of him and if he's still alive after getting crushed by the boulder then the all of the people that saw him sin and and the rest of clel throw stones at him until he dies thear says that although the death penalty of this world is no longer given because there's no still gives a death penalty the same exact death penalties the four different types of death penalties are still instituted into the world when you see somebody in a in a plane crash a building crash a uh a uh car crash or or the like that's the equivalent of stoning someone is burned in a house or burned in some place that's the fire someone drowns that's the Ken that's the uh strangulation so is the first he will forever be known as the first a week after we got the Torah and killed him what about his kids he had no Sons the Torah says but he had why the Tor mention his Five Daughters because they weread they were sadikot despite their father making a mistake of Eternity and they will be forever remembered as the sadikot that gave them land what's another that's mentioned in the the sah sah the daughter of Aer who of she was the granddaughter of when the tribes wanted to tell their father yob that that YF is still alive they knew that he's an old man if they give him so much good news at once it may kill him from a heart attack from Joy just like his uh his uh uh grandmother died s saru when she heard the good news that did not die from the she died from happiness so they didn't want to give yob such good news that his son that he's been crying over for for 20 years is still is is still alive so they said to Sak the little girl why don't you go sing to to Sabah why don't you grow sing to Yu Go sing to him he likes the way you sing he makes you put him in a good mood and then if he sings he hears the little granddaughter is is singing to him he becomes in a good mood he already have some joy in his heart and then we can give him the good news she could have easily said no I'm tired no I don't feel like it no come on I want to go play she could have done that and she would have been simply someone you've never heard of but instead she listened and she got rewarded getting blessed by yobu to live forever hence the reason why Sak is mentioned in this par because she's still alive at the time of mosu hundreds of years later she's still alive she never died she one of 10 people never died went to G with her clothes on the daughter of will forever be remembered as the says the two out of the four sons of thead which Isa is on thees had two sons the says were unequal weight with M and but killed both of them why despite having a father that's the qu shom shom chases peace loves Peace by bringing people to the Tora not taking the Tora down to them that's what the mishna says despite having a uncle mosenu the rabbi of is they made a sin they served theem in a foreign way they weren't serving an idol but they were serving hasem in a way that he did not allow simple it wasn't that Tor it wasn't the opinion of a Tor instead of being remembered as the two biggest that led is after mhe and they're remembered as the two people that hem killed them because they did not serve hem the way he wants them to they didn't go with d and forever they'll be remembered as that what about two people that weren't necessarily as great in Torah did not necessarily have the same uncle and the same father they didn't have the same pedigree but K and Yeshua also mentioned the as people that merited to lead is and even into is they were part of the very few exceptions that were alive to see all the mirim they were part of the mirim part of the spies but they did not join the against mosu against the land against theem and therefore unlike almost everybody in the generation that died in the desert continued to after and led and forever we remembered as that even though yesu says he was known at one point as theil as the fool the one that didn't know anything he didn't know any Tor but he loved Tor so why make him the afteru because that was the only thing that he was missing he had humility he had the love for he had the love for but he just didn't have the mental tools says why he doesn't know now he knows I'll gift him the Torah now he's the biggest rabbi in the world he's a prophet he's everything so we see all of these different people mentioned in the par for different reasons some for good some for bad but free eternity the decision to do put these names in the Tah were all alic reasons they weren't ideological reasons they weren't even Moral Moral reasons there were alic reasons that had an impact on eternity on eternity not only their own eternity but also on us today but it starts with Pinas pinhas Ben elazar the whole zealousness was anic debate not a moral debate what was theic debate when Z saw that mosenu was not giving him the respect that he believed he he was entitled to because he's been around for longer than Moshe he's been around since the time of yobu and Moshe was given death penalties without asking for permission from Z because M was the he didn't need permission from Z but Zim didn't agree with that so he wanted to debate debate Moshe onic issue he brought the Zona Cosby for midan and he did what he did with her and then after he did what he did with her he brought her in front of mosenu grabbing her by the hair ah what do you think of this Moshe it's good right why your wife is also for midan T is also for midan in front of all the rabbis you talk about somebody's wife Beyond crossing the line Beyond crossing the line even mentioning somebody's wife Beyond crossing the line you put the person in a shock why it's just unexpected it's something that is unexpected what does it have to do with anything you don't like what I did what does it have to do with my wife but that's what do and that's what Z did he says to Moshe she's like your wife your wife converted I'll convert her later also you probably with her before you converted her right so I'll do the same thingu didn't know what to say all the couldn't believe that the didn't know what to say they said what a buad says what an embarrassment it is a rabbi doesn't know what to say comes Pinas who is pinhas average person Paz he's not a he's not even a Coen he's Pinas he comes and he says Rabbi mosu didn't you teach us in the class just the other day that someone that's that that is a zealous person for hasem and sees a Jew in relation with a non-jew in the middle of the act itself is allowed to kill him that's the right you you told USU says to him ah you're right you remembered it you go do it says when Year many many years after this event he was only a couple years old and he saw that the was making an error what was the error there was an error there was saying listen we're going to wait for theim to come and Slaughter this CF to make it aan in mikdash and little little one two three years old he says I'm sorry but that's not the is anybody can Slaughter is can Slaughter the calf the Quan has to do the sacrifice but the slaughter it's not the Quan quim don't Slaughter says you're right but I have to kill you why you're not have to say uh you know in front of your Rabbi it's disrespect for the Tora it's disrespect for your Rabbi somebody's asking a question of the rabbi and you answer for the rabbi death penalty it's disrespectful Tora since he was only a couple years old even though he was a genius there was Mercy on him especially because his mother was she had mercy on him and he ended up becoming the biggest and the greatest the world has ever seen at his time he was as great as if he was m and together in one person but that is still the to say the AL in front of your Rabbi somebody asked the rabbi a question you shut up even if you know you shut up until the rabbi answers unless the rabbi is asking you what do you think it is then you answer that's a respect for the Torah so how come P theik that were all alive because of him why is he allowed to do such a thing when for and P comes over he says Rabbi you taught us in class the other day that uh if this guy is a he's with someone that's a canai someone that's jealous kills him he allowed to kill him how come he allowed to do it how come he's allowed to do it says in a place where there is a desecration of A's name there is no honor whatsoever considered for the sake of the rabbi meaning that although that is the that you're not allowed to say an Al in front of your Rabbi the reason why P did it was because there was a there was a desecration of hashem's name a desecration of hashem's name what desecration of hashem's name Z was in essence selling to the world listen I pasin differently than what you guys think right I'm thinking that M who probably did the same thing as me because he was already with before mat and if they already had kids before mat that means that before she converted because there was no conversion yet so before that he already did it so I'm doing the same thing I'm just going to be with a little bit have a good time and then we going to get married I'll convert and all that good stuff I'm going to pass similar but not the same that's that's a distortion of the Tor the destruction of the Tor and you're doing it in public you're making a YouTube video about it you're doing all types of things you're wrong and even if it was right you're publicizing it regularly that's a and says is in such a circumstance where there's a there's no consideration of the honor of the rabbi if the rabbi is inviting Christian missionaries to a synagogue there's no honor to the rabbi if the rabbi is saying there's no gam and distorting what T says there's no honor to the rabbi if the rabbi is saying all types of things that are against the Torah there's no honor to the rabbi in fact it's a mitzvah to publicize and go against such people and that's what the page 882a says the reason why P what he did was a Mitzvah was because he considered the honor of AEM as the reason why he spoke in front of his Rabbi it's not that he went against his Rabbi he didn't go against M no he said the is in this particular circumstance since there's a I do not have to take your honor into consideration as far as that's really the only reason why I wouldn't say in front of you but since that law is put aside just like the Shabbat is put aside if there's a p the honor of the rabbi is put aside when there is a desecration of hashem's name that that entire calculation that took me 20 minutes to explain to you happened in one second in P's mind a simple person that became a giant that's still alive today ASI Paz says I'm gonna give him shalom what's Shalom says the Z Shalom that is the name of the that is is the name of the that is the comes on a person that protects his bit and since since P was going to defend the breit defend the breit of is defend the morality of all is he gets the on top of him forever you protect your breit the will be on top of you you desecrate your bit leaves immediately but this whole argument this battle this war this murder was all based on all based on the law itself it wasn't some crazy guy that just loves AEM and he's afraid of g no it was anic dispute that went to the bottom line went to the bottom line this is what made P great the same exact par that talks about other great people but also other people that were not so great other people that chose to go against mosenu against hem against everything that we know and the reality is each and every single one of us needs to know that at some point at some point there's going to be a book shown to us of Our Own lives our own Torah what did we do how did we choose the direction in our life did we choose it based on our own rationale our own ideas or did we have something to stand on did we have the big shoulders of the sages to stand on to rely on because at least if I know that my error is the same error as mosu I'm okay with that why M's shoulders are as big as can be if I know that my error if it is an error is the same as rabo it's okay with me why is already dealing with it in sh I'm sure he's come up with some type of explanation but if my error is mine alone I decided to do something and I'm wrong what am I going to rely on myself myself they become the dust under the feet of theim that's what people rely on when they rely on themselves the dust that they're going to end up becoming there's no need for that you could be the sadik you could be the sadik you could rely on the shoulders of theim and when we do we're already winning we're already winning both in this world and the next by first and foremost having something to rely on as that's the M that's the tradition we've had from generation after generation since the time began but even more so we have a direction of what to do and how to do it for every single issue we'll encounter in this world it's like already having the blueprint for life already having the blueprint for life when you already have the blueprint you could pretty much assume it's going to be built it's going to be okay it's going to look okay when you don't have the blueprint and you're just making it as you go by it's like little kids some kids follow the instructions and they build the Lego some kids they don't want to follow the instructions and they build something most of the time it's not the same in fact most of the time it's a complete failure it's much easier to follow the instructions especially when the instructions are from hasem and from his best soldiers ever the best soldiers have to be zealous why because sometimes the only thing we're going to L listen to is a spear to the place we don't want let us not wait for the spear let's just simply listen to the instructions let's just listen to the words of we see it's worked for many many people before us it's working for people now and it'll work for us and for our kids [Music] I now [Music]