Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

BEN SHAPIRO: GENIUS OR HERETIC?

45,042 views
Rabbi Yaron Reuven avatar
Rabbi Yaron Reuven

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] in the Torah world in the Torah World it doesn't matter how smart a person is says if has bad character traits it's forbidden forbidden to learn from him if he has heretical mindset if he says heretical things you're not allowed to learn from it's like eating pig and unfortunately many times people arrive at the wrong conclusion because the source of their information is horrendous now I've mentioned this person in the past but it seems like it needs to be uh mentioned again because perhaps people didn't hear enough and they still do it or maybe I didn't say enough and people are not listening or simply no one cares not sure who do you think is the most famous American Jewish speaker is let's call it religious but furthest from the truth what do you guys think is the most famous religious M no huh Jonathan saxs no Shapiro Shapiro what's his man's name again first Ben Shapiro Ben Shapiro Ben Shapiro is a smart clever young man it's probably around my age maybe a little give or take speaks extremely fast like a New Yorker sharp knows a little bit about a lot of different things and can hold a conversation with the best of them needless to say the bait and he wears a little keeper so he presents Judaism for many people it shouldn't surprise you that a few idiots have asked me if he could be mashiah because he wears a keeper and once in a while he mentions God when it suits him people think oh maybe he's going to be mashiah now now in order to be mashia at the first least you have to be a righteous Jew like you can't be a rash heretic and be mhia at the same time that cannot be which means that at the very least a person needs to meet the requirement of being a righteous Jew meaning he has to believe that Torah says he has to follow what it says right meaning you have to believe and accept the 13 principles of faith and follow what it says right all of the whole Torah now because he speaks fast because he speaks well and even correctly on many topics politically ignorant people and even sometimes people that are not as ignorant but simply easily fooled and naive assume that what he says in when it comes to Torah also is correct like his opinion for example about the political situation as far as whether it be racism whether really there is racism as much people say as there is or not or his opinion about abortion the many of the things that he says are correct when it comes to that when he talks about the liberal Lefty minded types of people and how much damage they cause to society many of the things that he says are correct there's no problem with it but I wish I wish he would just shut his mouth and stick to those topics and don't even say a single word about Torah because every single word that comes out of his mouth when he talks Torah is heretical so much so I have to mention it again today because his videos are extremely popular his show is extremely popular he gets to literally millions of followers millions of listeners and many ignorant people Jews and non-jews alike actually think that what he says is correct and no one is speaking against it from the Jewish World a few Christians are speaking against it but you know everything they believe is also wrong so who's listening to them so the problem is that he says things that are completely idiotic and when it comes to the truth but worse yet they're against the 13 principles of faith for example he does not believe in things that he can't prove scientifically that in itself is heretical that in itself is heretical that's a philosopher minded person that's how the the philosophers in Greece and r that's what they they had a belief they the way they tried to destroy Judaism and and Torah World say look we can't see God therefore it doesn't exist it's like see there's a closet okay so you know the closet exists you see that there is a building okay so you know the building exists you see that there's a chair okay so you know that the chair exists do you see God oh you don't see God okay so therefore God doesn't exist until a clever young Jewish guy came in the little Jewish kid says oh you see the chair yeah so you know chair exists you see the uh books so the books exist you see the uh people so the people exist you see the teacher's brain no okay so it doesn't exist so he has the mentality that if he doesn't see things therefore he doesn't know whether they exist or not and he gives the impression that a may or may not in Judaism we don't have such luxury to say maybe yes maybe not and whatever we feel like it so for example when he was asked by some atheist that he had a uh sit down with which by the way according to the and you're not allowed to have conversations with such people says benefited by simply enjoying one word like a joke that a Christian said and almost killed him for it not allowed to have these debates with Christians just for the sake of a show or have these discussions these these uh sit down coffee uh uh discussions uh with people oh let me talk to the atheist and have a you know a nice convers now let have such things why because Jewish people follow you they could potentially follow him as a result too this atheist this heretic because of you yeah but that's my show okay well you should change your show then what can I tell you and he has these debates with Christian missionaries and alikes and atheist and all types of people that we as a Jew Jews are not allowed to listen to hence the reason why all of a sudden in the last few years many modern Orthodox Jews began to have an interest in Christianity this is one of the sources because he's very popular and he speaks to Christians on a regular basis especially the Christian Missionary types he speaks to them and debates with them many modern Orthodox people get to see a little bit of Yos in their life a little bit of Mary a little bit of Yos maybe some Yosi but you have a keep on keep on keep up keep up still Jew that's what happens that's what happens in this philosophical type of minded you allow yourself to roam in the Lion's Den now he allows himself to ro in Alliance then because he did good in the political world as far as speaking against and tearing down a few people so he figures that he could take on religion also and unfortunately he's destroying any one of his lists that has any any inclination to Judaism at all why because everything he says is wrong it's simply wrong he says that he uh doesn't believe that there is a soul or an afterlife because he's not really sure or maybe there is but I'm not really sure but probably not that's what he says so Ence you die probably nothing going on you just turn to a tree just turn to a tree why is he the guy asks him so why do you keep the MIT why do you why do you keep the Torah oh I keep the Torah because I think that by following the religion it's just simply going to give you a better quality of life and a better Society not because God said so because it's better to have rules the rambam writes a needless to say a Jew a that keeps the seven noahide laws just because they make sense to him because he thinks it's going to give him a better life and not because God said so not only is called a fool in heaven but on top of it does not get rewarded for them does not go to heaven goes to G why you only go to heaven if you listen to the Torah because God said so not because it makes sense to you not to murder not because it makes sense to you not to steal but the little keeper guy from uh from uh from uh the uh the blog Ben Shapiro no no he does it because he thinks it's better for society it's better for for Humanity to keep it where we were well do do you believe there's a soul or something like a soul a pattern information that represents who you are that floats off the body and goes continues on so I don't know I mean honestly I don't know and and I don't think anybody has a great verifiable account of of of that I have suspicions but again there's suspicions less less about knowledge what I do know and the reason why I'm religious is that a religious lifestyle that that is based on certain fundamental premises I think makes life better for people I think that the the rules that are set down as currently understood at least uh are rules that that are likely to lead you to Leading a happier and better life than than your pure reason alone because pure reason alone Unleashed without even those Moorings in judeo Christianity can lead to a lot of really terrible places furthermore doesn't really believe in reincarnation doesn't believe in reincarnation doesn't make sense to him resurrection of the Dead doesn't really agree with what the SES said because he thinks that the whole issue of reincarnation and and and just the whole mystical aspect of the Torah is just something that came up recently as a defense against Christianity That's how little he knows he thinks that the whole mystical part of the Torah is something that came up re in recent Generations as a defense against the Christian idol worship that's this is how stupid he is when it comes to Torah I wish he was half as smart about Torah as he is about all the other nonsense that he talks about and a serious things that he talks about but the problem is that the ego has grown so much he simply assumes knowledge assumes knowledge so I was curious by the way that you know the ancient Jews said the SCH and you don't go anywhere after your your death right yeah the the idea of the afterlife is is a pretty modern invention in Judaism it really it really only crops up historically speaking a little bit in the prophets and it's usually the late prophets and it's and it's really maybe as a response to early Christianity or or Greek thought so yeah in the in the Bible itself there's no reference in the Torah there's no reference to the afterlife what do you think happens after the death of your body so I mean I only have suspicions because again unverifiable my suspicion is that if there if there is a God which I believe uh who exists outside of time and space and that what animates me is that I'm made in the image of God and that what animates my capacity is that I'm made in the image of God that I reunify with God that basically there's a the traditional Jewish take on this has been that there's a cleansing process Judaism doesn't believe in eternal hell so it's instead this idea that there's a cleansing process for your for your soul the part that you got from God that spark of life that you got from God you Schmutz Schmutz it up while you're alive and now there's a cleansing process and then and that's what hell is sort of and then you are reunited with God and you have greater understanding uh the idea of me being a distinct personage outside of my body I think is is a difficult one that's that's my own personal you don't think you're physically resurrected uh into heaven with God no I think I think that something like a soul or energy or Consciousness or something like that yes a form like an aquinus form right yes I think that those are actually two different things in Judaism as well like the the idea of which is the idea of resurrection of the dead that's a different idea than what happens after you die right is the idea that eventually the Messiah comes that we'll all be resurrected back in our physical bodies at a certain point which you know honestly given the nature of house science is moving and and the possibilities of cloning is is actually less crazy than it than it sounded probably a couple of thousand years ago yeah I debunk most of the modern you know the singularities coming we're going to upload everybody into the cloud and this is not going to happen no definitely not I me that's good that's good because I just feel like the computer would be really weird just weird to live inside a computer but or they we living in the in a computer now but there's no buffering or you know little pixels that are going off one of the worst things that just I think is just completely ridiculous but unfortunately I believe many people will believe him in this is when the guy asked him about mashia says you wife for mashia he says yeah but it's not the same it's not mashiah like people think like it's going to be some mystical figure no I'm waiting for a strong politician to come and bring order to the world you're not waiting for the Messiah to come he's not coming in the so I'm waiting I'm waiting for the Messiah to come in the form of a political figure right so the so the Messiah in in Judaism is a guy who's going to come back and is going to establish peace in Israel and is going to assure that that you know there's a there's sort of a happier world with a bunch of political aspects to it as as explained by my man but he's going to die too right he's not going to come back and everybody lives forever and and any of that kind offf Corporal agent he's just like us right in the Jewish view any person could be the Messiah any Jew can be the Messiah in the Jewish view right so I could be it who knows but it's I'm not but a good start he thinks the mashia is going to be a politician if the mashiach is a politician we should all commit suicide the qualific ation for a politician is to be a liar a liar and a liar you don't have to do anything else other than be a liar the people running for the highest office are typically the biggest Liars somebody showed me a video that apparently just hit the tape again of this imbecile uh Joe Biden who's running for president now one of the dumbest people in the universe is fooling the rest of the universe at the same time which shows how stupid the rest of society is he was caught lying on TV 20 30 years ago about everything he says he has three degrees from college barely has one said that he was a top top of his class in college out of 82 students he was 75th meaning he was he wasn't even top 50 percentile the degrees he says he has he doesn't have the accomplishes accomplishments he says he has he doesn't have he doesn't even know how to speak needless to speak for himself they have pictures of him during a debate with with Donald Trump where he's getting fed lines there a microphone in his hand a microphone in his ear somebody is telling him what to say he doesn't know how to speak in a debate the whole point is to know what you have on your mind he has people telling him what to say he when he gives a speech he reached from from a from a thing somebody's telling him what to say to a News Network about himself he doesn't know what to say when he was told read off these numbers this report of Corona virus of how many deaths that happened and so on he doesn't know numbers he says 1, and 5,000 and 6,000 and 5,000 and 6,000 all is one number all of this is what he doesn't know anything and guess what he could potentially be the next president of the United States one of the dumbest people that ever worked a c surface of the Earth is could potentially be in a position of power which really means the people behind them become president we just don't know who they are so you don't really have to be smart to be dangerous but when you're smart it actually makes you more dangerous needless to say Ben Shapiro in my opinion more dangerous than to the Jewish World why because many Jews especially young ones listen to him and hold what he says as this is Judaism why he has a keep on he's modern Orthodox he says he's you know modern Orthodox he doesn't deny it he says he's proud to be a Jew but once in a while say something heretical that either you don't know that it's heretical or if it is you're just like oh he probably has a source because he's so smart and he says it so quickly he probably knows what he's talking about so when he says that he thinks the mhia is going to be a politician people like oh you know what that makes sense maybe maybe you know what maybe I thought ah you know what oh maybe Trump is gonna be mashiah yeah but he has to be a Jew too no you know no Ben will figure that out maybe Ben shabir is going to run for office and he's mashah really and people have all these ludicrous beliefs when a person doesn't know the very basics of Judaism doesn't know anything doesn't know anything any Basics about Judaism violates the 13 principles of Faith openly and in public says that say the things that you prayed for all of you prayed for on onip you had a V and V he said I'm sorry for a lot of things but you know also what you said I'm sorry for you said I'm sorry for all the things you did during this life and the previous life meaning what reincarnation and a soul is not a mystical belief that only some people follow it's the foundation of Judaism it's the fundamentals of Judaism it's not a something that just came up and you could Cho it's in your you said I'm sorry for your previous life meaning you testify that you you have lived before this life so when someone says things like that so carelessly and just has conversations with Heretics like their friends guess what not only does it show that they're damaged they've become a heretic they are a heretic but all of the fans all of the listeners ERS all of the people that are listening to him especially after today after listening to today for sure are either Heretics are on their way to being Heretics and you're going to say wait a minute but he's really popular maybe he could do this maybe he could do that does popularity doesn't mean good big noise doesn't mean good theim Al Kings one has an extraordinary story in it that gives us a little bit of an idea of what to expect as far as how mssiah is going to show up because most of us we think that Messiah is going to come and some type of flashy way all of a sudden some politician takes off the mask and says I am mhia or some guy on YouTube says I am mashia and make some type of scene doesn't work that way it won't work that way I promise you it won't work that wayi did everything and anything possible that he could to defend the honor of hem in chapter 19 of the book of Kings 1 is fleeing after they killed righteous prophets and he rebuked them they tried to kill him and he Fleet them he eventually gets to the desert can't find any food and he passes out after crying to Hashem that he tried his best it's not working there's no food there's no nothing I guess Hashem wants to kill me that's it I don't deserve to live suddenly an angel of hasem comes toi wakes him up and tell him eat this and miraculously there was a little bit of food and water next to and in the middle of the desert so tired and consumed and literally on the verge of dying he was barely able to get up and eat the food he got he drank he ate and he passed out shortly later that same Angel wakes him up again says eat this more food you're going to need it because the journey is long he eats the food and gets superhuman powers to allow him to walk through the desert for 40 days and 40 nights without eating and drinking or stopping or sleeping this isak Supernatural but it's literal after 40 days and 40 nights of walking through the desert he arrives at Mount Mount saai gets to the mountain this is where Hashem wants him to be but he doesn't know why because Hashem hasn't spoken to him in a long time last he heard of him was 40 days ago from the angel suddenly here's a message what why are you here Elijah what are you doing here what you doing m in essence what is asking him what's your best Merit that allows you to be here why if I was I'd say listen I prayed every day in the morning morning in the afternoon at night I learned to did and by the way I did some rebuking I did some this and did some that I mention everything the whole I've been everything I ever did since the time I was born everything I remember I'm GNA mention mentions one thing says one I did that's everything at he says to I have acted with great zealousness for hem God of Legions for the children of isra have forsaken your Covenant they have raised your altars and have killed your prophets by the sword [Applause] he says to him now I alone have remained and they now seek to take my life Ence tells why am I here I was the only guy that was zealous for you I was the only guy that rebuked because they went against the Torah they said heretical things they worshiped Idols they they they did all types of things I fought for your name that's it forget about my prayers forget about Myaka forget about my learning forget everything else this is what why am I here you're asking me I'm here because I Fought For You many stupid people say oh why doesm need you to fight for him no he doesn't need you to fight for him he wants you to fight for him could have answered any other answer he was a righteous person was but the says I was zealous i f for your name when and everybody else was going against you and now because I went against them and for you they all want to kill me not just write stupid comments about me on the internet not just not donate not just steal money not just uh ban you no they want to kill me responds to him in kind he says to Y go out in the cave and stand on the mountain stand on top of the mountain Shem is saying I'm going to show you myself says and behold AEM was passing and great powerful wind smashing mountains and breaking rocks went before AEM but then a message came out AEM is not in the wind there's a big wind wow Shem is in the wind he's probably somewhere in this tornado passes passes passes and the message comes out Hashem is not the wind he's not in inside the wind either then after that a huge noise an earthquake see the whole mountain is shaking the ground is shaking and the message comes out AEM is not an earthquake hasem is not the earthquake and after the earthquake comes a fire and again says hem is not in the fire and after all of this theatrics this extraordinary Miracles after Miracle this can't even imagine what Eli was looking at suddenly nothing no noise at all no sound at all and that's when hasem shows up page 48a says from here we learn that when the king arrives everything is quiet meaning that all of these theatrics and craziness that happens that's before the king comes once the king shows up everybody's quiet if they're still noisy he's not the king he's not the king in the world today people are scared of Celebrity Status whether losing it or going against it people are scared to go against the norm even though the norm is abnormal why there's a lot of noise everywhere but don't think that just because something is popular that's what Hashem wants there's two billion plus people that are Muslims that want to kill Jews there's two and a half billion Christian Idol worshippers that are killing Jews spiritually on a regular basis and at times also physically too there are billions of people that are 100% Idol worshippers from all countries and so on you can't get any proofs as a you know of of validation of any kind as a result of large numbers it doesn't mean anything but you see what you can get is 100% certainty 100% certainty from just a few Jews because why they rely on an opinion that's the only opinion that counts it's God's opinion and God tells us his opinion sometimes directly sometimes indirectly through his sages if any of us goes against especially openly nonchalantly carelessly and arrogantly against the opinions of our sages that were accepted as Al accepted as this is the foundation of Judaism guess what you officially become a void you officially become something we ignore you officially become something we don't listen to why because what you're saying is antithetical to our belief system whether you wear a keeper or not is IR relevant whether you have a beard or not is IR relevant there are many people that have keas and beard that are horrible people and many that are good people there are many people that don't necessarily wear a keepa that are decent people now you already know my opinion about man's freedom of every day comes out with more videos that are worse than the ones from before and he continues to get more and more popular by the day just today or yesterday he got highlighted by some news Outlet by having a video saying don't fear like you shouldn't fear anything as if there's nothing to be scared of including God and he continues to get more and more popular and they continue to invite him in different synagogues that he's never been in and a aaric community in ashkanazi community community he's invited everywhere people simply are following the footsteps of the heretic but guess what he's a microcosm in comparison to a Ben Shapiro that has many more followers both Jews and non-jews meaning that he is not only hurting his fellow Jews with his heretical beliefs but on top of it he's giving the non-jewish world ammunition Amun to go against our belief system because he's showing something that's the opposite of true so it's very important for us to know that if you're going to continue listening to people that are Heretics you become a partner in a crime and with that being said you have to make sure that you take these things seriously not make an any type of fighting Wars on the internet I hate you you hate me not to make M between you and other Jews not to make a whole uh you know who can insult each other better but rather you have to be careful with which friends you choose and where you spend your time if your Rabbi your speaker is a follower of of of atheists is a friend of of idol worshippers and so on guess what you're going to become one too and this is the reason why shapir is moving to Baton by the way there's a rabi that's a perfect fit over there know really is he's moving to Bon that Community why because that's his foundation and that's where there there's further teaching there I wish he did CH because I think he do a lot good a lot of good I just don't think it's it's likely why he would have to stop what he's doing actually start learning Torah but that's not good for business his business and the only reason why I go public with stuff like this is because I know this is really the only way to get the message out there to do private teachings oh listen Ben you should change it's not going to work why because those messages those videos of his heretical teachings are out there in the millions he would have to literally remove every single video he's made talking about religion and on top of it file copyright infringement on any single person that ever has his video on there which is not happening because then they would file against him and so on meaning the damage is too big to fix hopefully he can do cha at least to contain his own life but I don't know how he can fix the rest of it my concern is not really him my concern is his followers his listeners that think that he's right because he's right on some other things he's right on this to say that you know you don't necessarily believe in an afterlife 100% because there's no real proof to it or the issues with souls or that the the mashiah has to be a politician or other different things that I've heard him say uh in different short clips people have sent me that are literally antithetical to Judaism altogether or simply just by itself him saying that he only keeps the Torah because he thinks it makes sense for society not necessarily because God said so or best yet my favorite he says that Judaism does not believe in Eternal punishment even though the ramban writes in sh that Eternal punishment is very much a fundamental belief of Judaism the page 17A and 16b both say that Eternal Gom is very much standard in Judaism and many other place but no Ben Shapiro that never even finished anything in his life according to the Torah he just decid no we don't believe in uh Eternal Gom we don't believe in it's just it's just a cleanup process because you have some but then everything's okay in so many words he created a new religion and he made Donald Trump or whoever WR you know right minded person as the Messiah that's what he did and that's a very very dangerous person much more dangerous than a lot of people think he may very well be a nice person but apparently all the Netflix that he watches all the movies that he talks about apparently they made his mind a little stupid spiritually a little stupid spiritually and unfortunately when you're a public person it's too expensive for you to be stupid spiritually why because now your opinion is now other people's knowledge your opinion is other people's knowledge therefore when your opinion is against the Torah their knowledge is against the Torah therefore they are going to go to G because of you so the only hope we have in order to reach some of those people is hopefully they watch this or they hear from about somebody from somebody else it's really the only hope at least we made our effort but that's it not debating him or anybody else have no no no nothing in this it's just that there's so much damage being caused by our selves by our own our own people our own people and no one's really doing enough about it so hopefully we could do something maybe to encourage others to do more but either way the Torah itself tells us that we have an obligation we have an obligation to say something we're very excited to offer you the new app 3.0 it's a newer faster app full of Torah lots of Kusa by the shim that we do myself rim raim uh where you'll have also newer features where you're able to use the app uh while you're using other applications on your phone you'll be able to share the uh the lectures directly from the app you'll be able to donate online and support our CU and our Torah work that we're doing and the most exciting feature is that you'll be able to actually ask questions directly on the app and get answers from the rabbis directly from the app this is something unprecedented and will'll be able to to offer it thank you again for all of your support check it out make sure you have the kosher Torah that uh will re-energize your n each and every single day to [Music]