Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
There's a Part of You That Can ALWAYS Dream of Freedom [Shemos]
37 views
Why did Moshe doubt whether the Jews could take him seriously? This parsha reveals the part of the soul pain cannot touch. And why redemption and posibilities always begins there.
Categories:Torah/Parsha
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay friends, the story begins paras
shamosis
which is the book of Exodus. We start a
new book
and
there's a certain irony in the book of
Exodus
which is [clears throat]
the first few portions of it and the
beginning of it is the start of our
exiles, the start of our slavery in
Egypt. Yet it's referred to as safer
hagula, the book of Exodus, the book of
redemption.
And what we're going to notice in this
parha on a larger scale
is when redemption really starts.
Redemption doesn't actually start when
you leave Egypt. Redemption starts way
before that. That's number one. But
number two, how can we inspire other
people and even ourselves to experience
redemption? And I mean redemption on a
global level, the coming of Msiah,
redemption on a smaller scale. There's
circumstances
where we find ourselves in Egypt. We
find ourselves being suppressed.
Whether it be on a local level, whether
it be internally,
there's limitations. Limitations to a
relationship, limitations to to
experiencing joy and happiness.
And sometimes those are
um I don't want to say disguised as but
because that's not the right word.
Sometimes those are manifested as
mental health limitations.
Sometimes those are manifested as
relationship limitations. Sometimes
those are manifested as
as um just the social dynamics at work.
At the end of the day, it's gloss. It's
exile.
It's Egypt. Mashiach isn't yet here.
But how can we
see the light at the end of the tunnel?
And how could we realize that the light
at the end of the tunnel is not actually
at the end of the tunnel.
The reason why you see the light at the
end of the tunnel is because you see the
light where you are.
The opening of the tunnel is at the end
of the tunnel. That's where the light's
coming from. But it's shining to you
even when you're not yet at the end of
the tunnel. And what I mean to say is
even if we find ourselves in that
tunnel, we could still find light. We
could still find joy. We could still
find happiness. We could still find
freedom.
[sighs]
It starts with Moshe.
Moshe is born in this para Moses.
And Moshe is, this is going to sound a
little sacriiggious, but I'm just going
to say it. And Moshe had to be trained
to be a leader.
Moshe has to be trained
to to learn how to take the Jewish
people out of Egypt.
So let let's just rewind here for a
moment. The Torah recounts the tribes of
Israel that had descended into Egypt.
It names them.
Then it discusses the bitter slavery
that they're going through.
Pyro realizes these Jews are multiplying
way too quickly. They're going to take
over Wall Street and Hollywood and
soon they're going to be taking over
Venezuela. I don't know. They're things
are [laughter]
things are going down. We're going to
get blamed for they're going to we're
going to get blamed anyways. But that
wasn't Par's concern, right? He was
actually scared. So he said, "Let's
oppress them."
And slavery begins.
Moshe is I'm just going through the
story real quickly. Obviously missing
the the details here, but Mosha is born.
Mosha is put in a basket. He's saved by
Batya, who is Pyro's daughter, and
raised in Pyro's house,
which is an interesting thing because
commentaries,
you you know, when when Mosha first
rocks up on the scene when he's an
adult, what is the first thing we know
about Moshe?
He kills somebody. [laughter]
kills an Egyptian who is beating a Jew.
Okay, it wasn't murder. It was
protection. It was justified. I'm just I
think it's interesting. That's the first
thing we know about him. Um but the
Ramban
puts it a little bit differently.
He says, "What was Moshe doing there? He
grew up in the prince's house. He grew
up in Parro's house. What was he doing
among the slaves?" He was informed that
he was Jewish and he was excited to go
see his people.
And it's interesting, he never yet met a
Jew necessarily.
Yet he felt like these are my people and
he stood up for his people and he was
willing to take out that evil Egyptian
that was oppressing another Jew
for no justified reason. He was willing
to take him out to stick up for his
people. Now, commentaries do point out
that Mosha's leadership is quite
interesting because Mosha didn't grow up
in Jewish community.
He's never been to a bar mitzvah.
How is he leading the Jewish people?
He's never seen synagogue politics.
[laughter]
He's never He's never been unwelcome to
a synagogue because he didn't buy
ticket. I'm kidding, right? But what I
mean is culturally he he [laughter]
he's never been part of these people.
So, how is he um how is he the Jewish?
How is he going to lead them?
So, some commentary say that that's the
point
because he didn't grow up with them.
There was a certain appreciation he had
when Moshe first rocked up on the scene.
It says, "What's right before he sees
that Egyptian beating up another Jew?"
What does Moshe notice? I'll just quote
the two words of the verse.
He saw
their
in if you look at it English
they probably translate it as their
burden
as their iniquity.
But the word also means their tolerance.
He saw how are you guys tolerating this?
How is this acceptable?
Why do you think this is an acceptable
way of living?
The reason why it was unacceptable to
him is because of the background he grew
up in. Pyro's home. He grew up in
royalty.
Because he grew up in royalty, he was
able to expect of his people to live a
life of royalty and then ultimately be
able to redeem them. That's what the
commentary of Israel says.
Even though Moshe had that potential
perspective in him, he still needed to
be trained.
After killing that Egyptian, he pyro
found out and he was forced to flee for
his life. He goes to the town of Midian.
There's the whole situation with Ysro's
daughters at the well, him protecting
the daughters. He ends up marrying one
of Yurro's daughters, Sipura.
He has two children. And at this point,
Moshe is walking in the desert of
Midian.
And he sees
the burning bush that's not being
consumed. It's on fire, but it's not
being consumed. It's not losing any of
its of its identity. It's remaining.
And Moshe is just totally like, "What?
What is going on here?" And he hears the
voice of God. He meets God for the first
time.
God says, "Remove your shoes. this is
holy space and approach me and they get
into conversation
and the truth is they get into debate.
Go to the Jewish people. Go to Pharaoh.
Let the Jewish people know redemption is
coming. They're going to be free.
There's going to be freedom. And Mosha
says, "Uh, no. I'm not the guy. I I I
don't think you understand. That's not
me." [laughter]
He gets into a debate with God.
for like six days.
And Mosha's argument is, and by the way,
this is fascinating. Like the very first
things we know about Moshe, [laughter]
we don't know much about his education
and his upbringing. I mean, we know when
he was born, there was this beautiful
light shining from him. We knew he had
but his first encounter with God was a
fight, [laughter]
an argument.
And his argument is, I'm just going to
read the text here. And Moshe answers
and he says,
"They are not going to believe me. I'm
going to show up to the Jewish people
who are enslaved. Then I'm going to say
redemption's coming and they're not
going to be believe me. They're not
going to listen to my voice. They're
going to say, "God never appeared to
you."
To which God responds, "What are you
holding in your hand? Here's the staff.
Turn it into a snake." and plus the
various other signs.
Okay,
I want you to imagine you're
interviewing an employee to fill a very
important role
to lead an entire department
and the the guy says just before you
hire me, just know I might not be the
guy because I don't actually believe in
these people. [laughter]
Okay, you might not hire him, right? But
over here, the roles are reversed. Moshe
didn't show up to the interview. The
interview showed up to him. He wasn't
interested. God approaches him. God is
asserting that he's fit for this role,
and he's saying, "But they're not going
to believe me. God still wants him. God
still, what is going on here?
Why is Moshe doubting the Jewish people?
How could Moshe doubt the Jewish
people?"
The truth is there was a split among the
commentaries.
There are some commentaries that say
Moshe wasn't doubting the Jewish people
and when he said they're not going to
believe me, he wasn't doubting them. He
was doubting himself. He was doubting
his leadership capabilities.
I'm sure these Jewish people are great
people and I'm sure they'll believe
someone. It's just me that they won't
believe. I'm not the type of guy that
they should be believing it.
And you could attribute that to
humility. You could attribute that to to
misunderstanding of who he really was.
You could attribute that to his fears of
his inability to speak clearly
because he had a speech impediment.
There's a lot of things to attribute
that too. That's the approach of the
orim and some other commentaries, the
Malim, the Ramban
as well as Rashi. So this seems to be
just a simple reading of the text. Say
no. Moshe was doubting the Jewish
people.
He was literally doubting them. God says
let them know redemption is coming.
Moshe says not these guys. They are not
buying it, man. Well, what kind of
leader is that?
Okay. So,
God had to train Moshe and we'll we'll
we'll get into in a moment how God ended
up training Moshe.
But I I do think it's very important
that we explain Mosha's position
and explain God's position
just from Mosha's perspective for a
moment. You know who Moshe was? Moshe
was an empath.
He was an empathetic person. Moshe felt
people's pain.
In fact,
when he had fa when he had first met the
b faced the burning bush, you know what
the first thing he did was?
I'm going to read the text and I'll
translate. It says vast mohav.
Moshe turned his face away.
Elohim was afraid
to look at the face of God
to to sorry to gaze at God. God
responds,
"I see the pain, the iniquity of my
people. I see they're crying out. I see
their screaming. I know that they're in
pain. I'm going to save them."
And the Talmud says that Moshe was
rewarded for looking away.
He looked away. God exposes himself to
Moshe for the first time. And Mosha
looks away. And the Tal says Moshe was
rewarded. This is the trackus.
And many of the commentaries ask, well,
why was he rewarded for looking away?
Why is that like a good thing? Why is
that admirable?
So the Abarel
says,
one of the commentaries on the Torah
explains something fascinating.
What's going to happen if he gazes at
God?
He's going to get clarity.
And when you have clarity, it all makes
sense.
And when it all makes sense, you lose
empathy.
That's why you're suffering. You don't
want to do that.
He didn't want to make sense of the
Jewish people's suffering.
We know God does everything for a
reason.
We know God means well. We know God's
intentions are pure, but that doesn't
that that's none of our business.
Right? God has a plan. That's beautiful,
but that's not my business.
If you're in pain, I need to empathize
with you. Moshe was an empath. Moshe was
an empathetic person. He didn't want to
have that clarity. He didn't want to
make sense of the suffering. He looked
away.
God realized this is this is going to be
the leader. This is going to be the guy.
He really cares about his people. He's
sacrificing spiritual clarity to know
the ultimate truth so he can empathize.
The bashtov used to say that
everything hashem does
everything that happens in this world is
a lesson in our relationship to hashem
and our service to hashem and our
service to god.
Everything
said the bash can be traced back to a
divine godly lesson. So somebody once
challenged the bash and said what can we
learn from an atheist who doesn't
believe in God. You see the paradox
here. Everything in life is a lesson of
God. Well what do you what lesson about
God can you learn from somebody who
doesn't believe in God or somebody who
believes that God does not exist. So the
Bashmto said that when somebody's in
pain when somebody is suffering
instead of saying
God knows what he's doing I believe in
God. When somebody else is in pain be
like that atheist. Do something about
it. Try to help the person. Empathize
our relationship with God shouldn't
come at shouldn't cost our sensitivity
toward other people. Actually, on the
contrary,
so much so that Moshe was willing to
look away from God to forfeit that
clarity. And the reason why I mentioned
this is because Moshe was an empathetic
person.
And by the way, empathy is beautiful.
Empathy is necessary.
Everything in life has to exist in the
right dose though because if you
overempathize
you can also blind yourself
from how capable people really are.
Moshe knew how much pain these people
are in because of how empathetic he was.
So empathetic he was willing to look
away from God like the Barbanell says.
so empathetic that the first thing he
noticed was these people are in plain
when he saw them and was willing to take
out that Egyptian and and sacrifice his
own life. He had to run away to Midion.
[sighs]
He was so empathetic. He sees these
Jewish people enslaved for 210 years
and he says, "God, you want me to show
up to them and say, "Guys, I have good
news. Redemption's coming."
Great. Thanks, Moshe.
Thanks, says the guy born in the
prince's home who's never worked a day
in his life. [laughter]
How is that going to come off?
How are they going to respond to that?
Is that going to make them feel better
or worse?
This is a this is why Moshe was
declining the the position. This is why
Moshe was saying they're not going to
believe me. He was doubting them, but he
was doubting them because he empathized
with how much pain they're in. He
understood that they had 210 years of
suffering, of trauma, of difficulty.
And coming from a guy who grew up in
Pharaoh's home, who never worked a day
in his life
or never had to work or struggle day in
his life in that way,
it you the last thing you want to hear
is, "Guys,
it's going to be great."
It just doesn't work.
I I have a a friend who loves dark
humor. Anybody
[snorts]
any dark humor fans? Okay. Yeah.
[laughter]
Whenever when we were back in Yeshua,
whenever something would go wrong, he
would go, "Josh, look at the bright
side."
Exactly. Right. Waiting for him to
respond. [laughter]
Dead silence.
Um the but the last thing you want to
hear from somebody after 210 years of
suffering of slavery of of oppression
is guys
see that light at the end of the tunnel
look at the bright side. So Moshe is
telling God I they're not going to
believe me. They're in so much pain,
so much suffering.
Are they ready to actually hear about
the possibility of redemption?
And the answer is yes.
Moshe was trained. Moshe had to be
trained to be bold. And this is actually
what was occurring at the burning bush
saga. God was training Moshe. You're
empathetic. You got that down. But you
got to be a little bit more bold that
don't lose your sensitivity.
But believe in people,
understand that they're capable.
[snorts] And there are three
verses here that I'll just share with
you, three examples really in this story
where God insinuates to Moshe that you
got to look at these people a little bit
differently. You can't just see them for
their pain. Yes, empathize with their
pain. No, don't define them by their
pain.
There are three examples. And before I
get into these examples, I I just think
it this is so important. You know, when
I work with couples and and even
individuals,
really what I'm trying to figure out is
not what is wrong with them or why
they're in pain, but what are the
possibilities that could happen?
And I get accused all the time of being
not not by clients but like by other
people and you know in especially in the
marketing space. You're being too
positive.
And the truth is it's I'm not being
positive.
I'm being honest.
The possibilities are real.
The possibilities are there.
The capacity to appreciate those
possibilities are real. And there
it's not positivity,
it's identity.
Not defining people by their pain, yet
still empathizing with their pain.
And this is what God wanted, how God
wanted Moshe to see the Jewish people.
Don't define them by their pain.
Define them by their ability to have
greater possibilities.
And there are three verses or three
situations here where where God kind of
hinted to and really educated Moshe to
look at these people differently. And we
could derive from here um the ability to
believe in ourselves, to believe in
other people, which is what God was
trying to train Moshe to do. Number one,
let's go back to the beginning of the
portion, the beginning, the opening of
the book
where it's para shamos, the book of
names,
b these are the names of Israel, the
Jewish people
who've come to Egypt and it names the
Jewish people again, the 70 souls, the
70 people, the tribes that have come
down.
[sighs]
Um,
truth be told, we've named them already,
several portions ago, because when did
they really come down to Egypt? Not just
now,
but a generation prior when they
realized that it's Yoseph, Joseph, who
is the viceroy of Egypt. Let's come down
and get some food. Let's be taken care
of. Let's live in the town of Gan. Let's
reunite the family.
And the Torah enumerates the people that
have come down. It does it again.
And here's what it says. This is where
translations are dangerous. If you look
in an English, and I didn't actually
look at one in preparing for this
lesson, but if you look in an English,
my guess is it would say these are the
names of the Jewish people who have come
to Egypt. And that is incorrect.
And I have a lot of complaints about
that, which is not fair because I didn't
actually verify that that's what it
says, but I'm pretty sure it does.
It doesn't say who have come to Egypt.
If you translate it literally
who are coming to Egypt,
coming to Egypt,
it's been 210 years of slavery.
They've come down a generation prior to
meet Yoseph. Slavery didn't start until
Joseph died. So, they've been here for
more than 200 for for more than 210
years.
Why does it say who are coming to Egypt
despite being in slavery and being in in
pain and trauma and oppression and
suffering for that long?
There is a part of us that just showed
up.
There's a part of us that is untouched,
untraumatized.
And God says, "Stop talking to the
traumatized version of them. Talk to
them."
Yes, they have trauma and pain and
suffering,
but why can't you talk to them?
Anytime you meet somebody with trauma,
this is true with me any mental health
condition.
uh and the the
I I don't mean to say that I say this
with all sensitivity, but anytimes there
is some sort of acute mental issue,
it isn't perfect.
It's not pervasive.
There is the person experiencing trauma,
but somehow that person who's
experiencing trauma showed up to tell
the story.
And maybe they're still working through
it. Maybe they're still in pain.
They showed up to tell the story.
They're alive.
They deserve credit for what they have
accomplished because that's the
non-traumatized version of them. The
part of them that isn't traumatized. The
part of them that isn't totally
oppressed. The part of them that is
capable of hearing possibility. I'll
give you an example. I'll give you a
practical example. I was once working
with a client [snorts] who wanted to
enhance his relationship with his
spouse.
He says,
so I say he he says I I can't said why
not. I get home and my trauma just
too much too much. And this guy had
happened to have a lot of trauma.
Um like he really did. He had a lot
weighing on him.
I said,
"What time you get home?" He says 8:00
p.m.
I said, "Can you imagine
you're on your way home to be home by 8
and as you're on the bus leaving from
work,
you go, "Oh, shucks. I forgot something
at work in my office." And you're trying
to figure out what it is.
It's not your keys. It's not your phone.
It's not your briefcase. It's I left my
trauma. I left it on my desk.
I said, "Can you imagine that for a
second? Would that be a good thing?" He
said, "That'd be great."
I said, "I promise you it's going to be
there tomorrow waiting for you on your
desk. It's going to haunt you again.
Don't worry. [laughter]
Not going nowhere. But it's but for now,
you don't have it. Would that be a good
thing? That would be great."
I said, "How would you know it would be
great?"
He says, "What do you mean?" Well, how
would you know you forgot it?
What would be different about you? What
would your wife see differently in you?
Okay, imagine the second day this time
you for you remembered your trauma. You
brought it with you, but what you
noticed yesterday is still with you as
well.
How would you notice it showing up?
Right? He begins to describe
a part of him that the trauma does not
touch
because the trauma can't fully touch uh
devour you or he wouldn't be here to
tell the story.
And this is what Hashem was telling
Moshe.
Yes, they're in 210 years of pain, but
they're going to believe you because
yes, they're they have trauma. Yes, they
have pain. Yes, they have difficulty.
But there's a part of them that just
showed up to Egypt.
It doesn't say in the text they're
coming to Egypt. They've come to Egypt
despite being here for already 210 plus
years.
Hashem is trying to inspire Moshe to
look at the Jewish people a little bit
differently.
Example number two, [snorts] God appears
to Moshe in this burning bush that
hasn't isn't actually being consumed.
Um, it's a thorn bush.
Commentaries point out that the reason
why it's a thorn bush is because God is
insinuating to Moshe that I'm with you
in the pain. I'm with the Jewish people
in their pain. When I'm telling you
there's going to be redemption, I
understand the context of what's going
on here. I understand the pain that's
going on here. But the points out that
God also understands that the Jewish
people have the capacity of despite
being in pain, being in the thorns, they
could still be inspired. They could
still have fire. They could still be
They could still have the passion of
this bush that's being on fire, not
being consumed. The Jewish people have
that burning heart and connection and
yearning for redemption, yearning for
Messiah. We can believe that Msiah could
come tomorrow, today.
Despite being oppressed for thousands of
years, they could believe in redemption
despite being oppressed for 210 years.
Every individual can believe
that tomorrow can be better despite the
past not fully reflecting that.
Example number three,
and this really goes to the heart of how
Moshe is being trained to look at the
Jewish people, how God looks at the
Jewish people, how we need to look at
really any human being, and how we need
to look at ourselves, which is it's just
one line. God appears to Moshe in this
burning bush.
And what does God say?
God says,
"I've seen
I've seen
the suffering, the iniquity of my
nation."
That's in Egypt. I've seen their cries,
their screams.
Theel, again, we had mentioned him
earlier. The Barbaranel asks an
important question. Why is God saying,
"I've seen the pain of my people. Well,
they're not we're not his people yet.
We're just people.
We don't become his people till later.
We're just slaves.
The Abarbanel says, "Well, that might be
how we look at it, but that's not how
God looks at it.
We look like slaves, but at heart we're
his people. We feel like slaves, but at
heart, we're still his people." And
that's how God saw us. That's how God
wanted. And this is what he's conveying
to Moshe. This is how he wanted Moshe to
see us. Don't look at them or have uh
just for their pain, define them by
their pain.
They're my people. There's a part of
them, of ourselves, of us that has the
capacity to believe that this world can
be better, that Mashiach can come,
that there can be an experience of of of
of divine connection no matter where we
are, that this relationship,
no matter how difficult can be healed,
and that I don't have to be defined by
the trauma or by the difficulty, despite
how painful it is.
If I find larger identity, larger
definition,
that's my story and I'm sticking to it.