Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Stop Fixing Behavior. Start Fixing This Instead.
150 views
Most people think growth means fixing behavior— being more patient, less reactive, communicating better. But if that actually worked, you wouldn’t keep ending up in the same place. The Torah points to something deeper— and once you see it, you can’t go back to just “trying harder.”
Categories:Torah/Mussar
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay guys, parasim.
It's actually a double para. It's paras
and parasim.
But the lesson or message we're focusing
on today is in parasim.
The para of kadoshim contains
I don't have the exact number but it
contains probably
80 mitzvah or something. Um a lot. The
613 mitzvah are scattered throughout the
Torah. Some paras don't discuss any
mitzvah. Some discuss one or two. Some
discuss multiple. This [snorts] one
discusses a good amount and a lot of
fundamental mitzvah.
For example, the mitzvah of love your
fellow, the mitzvah to not hate your
fellow.
But then there's some lesser well-known
mitzvah in this parha.
One of the mitzvah that we have in this
para is
to not pervert
justice, to be honest in business,
integrity.
But it's more than just integrity. It's
a little bit more specific and a it's a
little bit more nuance. And when you
read the actual sentence,
which I'll do in a second, it may seem a
little archaic, although there is
significance even in the present and
certainly spiritual significance even in
the present. The Torah says, "Don't
pervert justice with measurements, with
weights." And it goes on to list
different units of of measuring,
whether units to measure distance, units
of measuring weight, units of measuring
volume. When you're doing trade, don't
cheat people.
Don't um don't [snorts] rig your scales.
So, uh, to your advantage or to
anybody's advantage, it's prohibited.
It's stealing.
The next sentence then says that not
only can you not rig
because it's stealing,
if you have rigged scales or any unit of
measurement,
um, scales for weight, but you might
have some sort of tool to measure volume
or tool to measure distance.
And if you even own a rigged measuring
tool, that itself is a prohibition.
Then it says, "I am the Lord your God
who take who took you out of Egypt."
Okay,
seemingly it's it's pretty simple. Don't
steal, don't cheat. It's a little bit
more nuanced, guys, than just don't
steal and don't cheat. Because as we
know the real estate in uh the syntax
real estate in the Torah is very
expensive. The Torah is not going to
tell us something that we don't need to
know or something that we know already.
We already know you can't steal.
We already know that there's a
prohibition of cheating and that you
have to be honest in business.
What is the exact nuance over here?
So the Talmud emphasizes
that the prohibition over here is not
the stealing or the cheating. We know
you can't steal or you can't cheat. Who
cares if it's if it's robbery or or
battery or with faulty measuring tools,
you know, something a little bit more
sophisticated or cyber attacks or
whatever it is. What's the difference?
You can't cheat.
Why get into the details
of how you can't cheat? It's not
relevant. Don't do it.
So, the Talmud says that the prohibition
is not just on the act of cheating,
it's on the ownership of these tools
or the creation of these tools. Both.
Were you to create
some sort of measuring scale
that was rigged or some sort of
measuring tool that was rigged
that you could potentially use to your
advantage?
That itself is the prohibition.
If you use it, okay, you also violated
stealing.
If you don't use it, you are still
violating a Torah law.
You see the nuance here?
Now, why is that so significant?
The reason why it's significant
is because what's being prohibited here
is not a behavior,
an identity.
Usually the Torah is telling us what to
do or what not to do,
at least overtly.
Over here, it seems to be very clear
that the Torah is not just telling us
not to steal or not to cheat or not to
be dishonest,
but don't own tools
that put you in a position of
dishonesty.
Don't be that kind of guy.
Don't be that person. Don't be that
dude.
The Torah is preventing or forewarning
identity,
not just behavior.
Um there's there's something
[snorts] quite unique about this
mitzvah.
So generally like if you contrast this
to stealing when it comes to any mitzvah
or prohibition there's usually a minimal
amount.
So this is true with anything right? If
you eat matzah on pes in order to eat
mat you have to have a certain amount
right you have to have there's a minimum
amount you need a kazayas an olive size
whatever that means different different
ways of measuring that. Um when it comes
to
cooking on chabas I'm giving an example
right one may not cook on chabas
there is a there is a definition of
cooking like if is your steak rare is it
medium rare right there there there is
there's temperatures
everything has measurements in the Torah
when one steals
they are obligated to return what they
had stolen
but only if they stole a significant
amount amount. There's a there's a
minimum amount. There's a measurement.
You know what that minimum amount is? A
pr
which somewhere between like 5 to 10
cents.
But if you were to have if you stole
less than five to 10 cents, it's still
not allowed,
but you can't nobody could take legal
action against you.
Um, I remember once a rabbi living a
class and a I mean he's like a hakic
authority in Israel and a question came
to his court where somebody stole
um a lot of fruit from a fruit stand
but in increments of less than a pa.
So, we'd walk by the stand, steal a
strawberry, walk by again, and at the
end of the year, it's 365 strawberries
or or whatever it is, and that's a lot.
And there was a whole ethical question
or question. Does he need to return the
money or not? Over the course of a year,
he had stole a significant amount, but
every time he stole, it was be it was
below the threshold.
I I think he ended up having to pay
that. You consider you add it all up
together, right? But bottom line is
there are minimum amounts to what is
considered sealing, what isn't
considered ceiling.
However, when it comes to measuring
tools, how many measuring tools can't
you own
or does it matter to what degree you are
measuring? It doesn't make a difference.
There is no threshold
because even if they're not usable,
they're too small. They're not
functional. They're not usable.
Even if you're just holding on to them,
even if you're using them for chamber
pots, that's what some opinions say,
doesn't matter. You can't have them
because the prohibition over here
is not just don't act with dishonesty.
It's don't be dishonest.
It's not just about behavior. It's about
identity.
Which answers a very important question
that commentaries ask.
Why in the sentence
where it says not to maintain these
tools for dishonest business, for
dishonest measuring
um trying to think of what the
equivalent would be these days. I don't
know, some sort of app that can help you
hack things, you know? I don't know,
[laughter]
whatever it is, right? There there's
there's some sort of modern day
equivalent. You can't even own it,
right? Don't even download the app.
[snorts]
In the same sentence, the Torah says,
"I'm the Lord your God who had taken you
out of Egypt." And the commentaries
wonder what the connection is.
Rashi says, "This is why I took you out
of Egypt.
That's why you took us out of Egypt. You
took us out of Egypt.
We were suffering, man.
We were suffering physically with the
oppression. We were suffering
spiritually."
Um, if you look in the Hagada, it says,
you know, we we recount the story and it
saysanu,
which we often translate as the
Egyptians did bad to us.
commentaries say if you translate it
literally, it actually says they did bad
with us
because we were hanging out with the
wrong people. Like we were talking about
earlier and we had um
we were hanging out with the wrong
people and their mentality rubbed off us
rubbed off on us.
God finally took us out of Egypt
and he says, "I'm taking you out of
Egypt so you don't have faulty
measurement tools that are used to cheat
people." Like what? Why is Rashi saying
that?
The answer is because not having these
tools as an identity.
Not using the tools as a behavior, but
we're saying not just to not use them.
We're saying to not even own them
because we have an identity of honesty,
an identity of faith.
The commentaries point out
that what we saw
from the Exodus of Egypt, what we
witnessed, and the reason why it's so
fundamental to our faith, we talk about
it every Shabas and and every day we
mention it. We have a holiday centered
around it. It's the epitome of faith, of
God's presence in our life. We find
ourselves in a difficult point in an
Egypt and we know that God could take us
out
and sometimes we find ourselves in a
financially difficult situation and it
could be tempting to do unethical uh
business decisions.
But we have to remember that this is why
God took us out of Egypt
to remind ourselves even in difficult
circumstances.
God is still relevant. God still
matters.
We don't need to even own those tools,
let alone use them
because that's just not who we are.
There's a fascinating commentary
known as Rabenu Bakaya.
He's one of the spheric sages.
And I'll I'll tell you why I find him to
be fascinating is because every most
commentaries
have a certain style, a certain lit, not
just a literary style, but a certain
purpose that they're that they're
serving. For example, as we know Rashi,
his job is to give us the simple meaning
of the text
and the simple meaning of the text as he
interprets it based on Tammudic and
Midashic literature. So, Rashi sifts
through s thousands of pages of the
Talmud, thousands of passages of midrash
that discuss the portion, the Torah, the
para, and Rashi [snorts] will pick out
the explanations from the midrash that
he believes are the literal
interpretations,
right? You'll have other commentaries
such as the benezra, the barbanell that
will give literal interpretations but
more on personal interpretation rather
than um
rather than pulling from or calling from
sources. You'll have the Ramban
who focuses on Cabala. You'll have
um
trying to think of other examples but
whatever you know every every commentary
has their speed, has their style, has
their their purpose. You'll have the
clear who focuses on homalytic
interpretation
goes through everything. He'll say
here's the literal interpretation.
Here's the midashic interpretation.
Here's the cabalistic interpretation.
Here's the ethical interpretation. And
he goes through layers on every portion
of his commentary. So it's very
interesting to read. And over here he
discusses the ethical significance, the
ethical message of not owning faulty
weights.
And he says the truth is this is already
addressed
in the book of proverbs by King Salman.
Mish.
The truth is Mish is
Mish Proverbs is kind of a hard book to
read because it's looks like a bunch of
it could look like a bunch of bumper
stickers. There's no like storyline,
you know? It's it it's but it's King
Salman's ethical wisdom. And here's he
quotes King Salman. Here's what he says.
I quote for you guys
in the name of King Salman himself
who says my heart has been purified
who says I've been purified from my sins
I have multiple stones measuring stones
multiple measuring units
and both of them are are an abomination
to Hashem.
So says, "Well, what's King Salman
saying? [snorts] Why is he comparing my
heart being unclean to owning faulty
weights and faulty stones?"
Because the fact that one owns them,
whether he uses them or not, is not a
behavioral issue. It's a personality
issue.
And that personality issue needs to be
addressed.
And the way we start addressing it is
not even putting ourselves in that
situation.
Avoiding the situation altogether.
Many ethical
deficiencies
in life can be avoided
not through just doing things
differently but positioning positioning
ourselves.
That is the key to success.
Proper positioning the proper stance.
[snorts] So when the Torah says, "Don't
own these faulty tools.
I am the Lord your God who had taken you
out of Egypt. Rashi says this is the
reason I taken you out of Egypt. Well,
what does that mean? I took you out of
Egypt so you guys can position
yourselves ethically, not just act
ethically.
In the Torah, it speaks about the
prohibition of
owning
um these measuring tools that are meant
for cheating. Speaks about it in other
portions as well. And in the Torah, it's
actually just juxtaposed
to the story of Amalik.
They're like in the same in the same
para in the same paragraph.
So the major says that that suggests
that there's a connection.
What is the connection between the
nation of Amalik to owning these stones?
The nation of Amalik
um
is a nation that we are obligated to
annihilate.
They're a nation that wanted us
to be annihilated.
They [snorts] tried killing us. They
preempted their attack.
And it was a baseless hatred. It wasn't
it, you know, there's certain people
historically that would attack Jews
because of fear. When the Midionites
attacked the Jews, they were afraid.
We still have an obligation to defend
ourselves. That's fine. But but the
context is a little bit different. When
the Canaanites tried attacking the Jews
and Joshua led war, we were conquering
the land of Israel as we were supposed
to. They were afraid as were we. So
there's a war
when it comes to the Amalachites. When
it comes to the Amalik, we left Egypt.
We're on our way innocently to receive
the Torah at Mount Si and Amalik comes
and attacks us. But for what reason?
It wasn't anti-semit anti-semitism
guised as fear.
It was just anti-semitism. It was just
hatred.
So we have an obligation to annihilate
them, to get rid of them.
Whenever there is difficult moments in
Jewish history,
[snorts] we do two things.
We do the easy thing and we do the hard
thing. And we need to do both. And there
the easy thing is we got to defend
ourselves. We got to fight back. I say
easy because relative to the hard thing,
it's much easier as you'll soon see.
doesn't mean it's easy. Um, but the
easier thing is to fight back, is to
defend ourselves, is to protect
ourselves. That's necessary. No question
about it.
But then
we do the hard thing.
We don't justify why it happened, but we
also at the same time have some
introspection.
How did we position ourselves
for this to even be possible?
So the midrash says you know how we
position ourselves to allow a malik into
our lives to allow that crush of
self-confidence and doubt in our lives.
The spirit of a malik unfortunately
still lives
even if the nation does not.
that spirit that says
you're not worthy
and there's just no reason. [snorts]
You're just not worthy and we're willing
to crush you for no good reason to
spiritually crush you to tell you you're
not good enough.
You know how that's invited into our
lives? So the midra says, "Well, look at
what's juxtaposed next to it in the
Torah. The prohibition of faulty faulty
measuring tools.
There's a connection
of
We might not be cheating, but we're
owning something we shouldn't.
We've mispositioned ourselves.
And because we've mispositioned
ourselves, we've invited
a Malik into our lives.
Put it this way.
We're talking about owning weights that
we shouldn't for false business for for
for
what's the word [sighs]
for a lack of integrity of business
integrity.
The way the commentaries put it, we are
giving weight to the wrong thing by
owning that.
We are prioritizing the wrong thing by
owning that.
And when we prioritize the wrong things
in life, we invite the wrong things into
our lives.
When we prioritize the right things in
our life,
we invite goodness into our life. We
create less space for negativity.
A malik came and attacked us
because we were weighed down by weights
we shouldn't have owned. Even if we
didn't actually cheat, but it was in us.
And if we would have dropped that dead
weight figuratively and literally,
there would have been no space for a
Malik to come in our life.
At difficult moments in life,
the very first thing we need to ask us
ask ourselves is what is the most
important thing?
When I work with couples and they're
going through a difficult time,
there's fighting, there's distrust,
there's a feeling of disconnection.
There's two people that feel like
they're living parallel lives like
roommates.
The very first thing I do, and not in
this language, it's there's a little bit
more of a tactful way of saying it, but
I effectively say,
"What is most important to you in life?
What is that one thing you'd give up
anything and everything for
because it just matters so much?
And how would you know you were closer
to it if all the dead weight wasn't
holding you back? Those
corrupt measuring tools where we put
weight to the wrong things didn't hold
you back. What would you be most
connected with? Because that is the most
pure, happy, holy, safe version of you.
>> [snorts]
>> There's a
rav in Israelic
authority
known as Rabbi Asher Weiss,
an incredible scholar. He had wrote he
had written uh tons of literature
on um hahik
like hakic medical ethics stuff like
that. and he's like when it comes to
medical ethical questions, he's often
the go-to. You can look him up on
YouTube, by the way. He's on YouTube. He
has classes in English and he has a lot
of uh teachings on on Jewish medical
ethics. His name is Rabbi Asher Weiss.
He has a very good English, [snorts]
incredible Tal, incredible scholar.
and he had a student that was serving in
the military
and
his student
got injured severely in war in the ID he
was an IDF U reserve student he 20 years
old got injured severely
he's missing a leg
missing an arm
>> [snorts]
>> Rabbi Weiss comes into the room
and the very first thing this young
student says,
"Rabbi, I have important questions for
you."
Now, let me just pause for a second.
What do you think he's going to ask the
rabbi?
like God, why why is God doing this to
me? What I do to deserve this? Was it
worth it?
You know, you can get into political
discussion. Why did this all you? This
can go in many different directions. The
rabbi is bracing for the question.
Rabbi, I have important questions. I
have three questions for you.
Question number one,
I have only one arm.
I'm supposed to put tillin on my
stronger arm, but I only have one arm.
Which arm do I put my tillin on?
I was putting on the fillain on the arm
that had been blown off, but now it's
only on I only have one arm. Do I put
fillin on that arm? Do I just not put on
fillain?
That's question number one. [snorts]
Question number two,
I have to eat bread. And when I eat
bread, I need to wash.
Do I wash just my hand or do I wash also
the arm? You had one arm with no hand.
Do I just Do I have to wash the arm?
Because sometimes that helpful for
eating. You're supposed to wash your
hands. Do you need to wash your arm if
that's effectively my hand? That's
question number two.
Um,
question number three. Sorry, there's
actually four questions. Question number
three, Rabbi,
I'm going to be getting prosthetic arms.
Hopefully around sukus time.
Can I hold the lul of an esroer with my
prosthetic arm? You're supposed to hold
it with your hand. Is that considered my
hand?
Question number four. When my
prosthetics come, is it considered does
it have the status of a new garment
where I would say the blessing of some
people say the blessing of thinking God
when they have new clothing, when they
have new items, do I make [snorts] and I
guess that was his custom. Do I make
that braha?
Ra, Rabbi Asher Weiss is just looking at
this young guy
and going, "Whoa."
And he began to cry.
The rabbi began to cry
because this is a holy guy, holy kid.
He's 20 years old.
He has every right to complain against
God.
every light right or it would be
understandable were he to say I don't
believe anymore I'm done with this I
fought for my people and this is how I'm
treated
and instead
he wants to know how he could continue
to prioritize what is most important to
him is relationship with God how he
could continue to give weight to the
right thing
at the same time not putting weight or
giving weight to the wrong thing.
Because when [snorts] we put weight on
the right things in our life, when we
don't possess scales or measuring tools
for things that we should not be having,
we don't even own those tools because
we're our priorities are straight. We're
focused on the right thing.
relationships and life and faith and
everything just flows so much more
smoothly.
And God says based on Rashi, this is the
reason why he had taken us out of Egypt.
That's the story. And I'm sticking to
it.