Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
How to Feel Close When You’re Walking on Eggshells?
103 views
When your spouse is upset, do you feel like you’ve done something wrong—or that it’s your job to make it better? Rabbi Josh Zebberman and Boruch Noam DuBrow discuss feeling seen, staying steady, and finding your way back to a marriage where you can both relax and be yourselves.
Categories:Podcasts
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Hello everybody. Welcome back to another
episode of Marriage Talks with Rabbi
Josh Zimmerman.
Um this is a new project that we are
starting. I am very honored to be able
to be here
uh with Rabbi Josh, with Josh. I don't
know. What are we calling you? What do
you go by? What do you prefer to go by?
>> Front and behind my back or in front of
me?
>> [laughter]
>> Let's do both.
>> No, Josh is cool.
>> Okay, so Josh.
Um so really what's
I want to start off with over here is
when it comes to marriage, I think a lot
of people think of when they need to
grow their their marriage or develop
their marriage, oftentimes there's this
idea of therapy, there's this idea of
counseling.
A lot of people will even go so far as
to say, oh we don't need counseling or
what's the therapist going to do? But I
think there's there's this stigma
attached to any form of coaching or
counseling with marriage
that it's it's
only for when things are going wrong
um or that it's a negative stigma of
you know
I I don't need it. Now what I've seen
from you and from personal discussions
about your methodology and then from
hearing the podcast and the stuff you
put out that your approach is very very
different than the let's look at the
problems um and let's find solutions. So
can you can you talk a little bit about
what it is that your approach is, how
you came to that approach, and what
makes it different?
>> The approach essentially is
not defining the person as the problem.
When we look at the problem, we
we you know we have to understand the
problem, you have to solve it, and you
have to hope that solution works.
That's often a solution that comes
outside of the person.
When you look at the person
and the strength
and capability they have to face that
problem,
what emerges is a strength that comes or
a solution that within the person.
So the the way I like to look at it and
is to contrast
the way we should approach relationships
to the way we approach medicine.
I think you know you know you you spoke
about the stigma, the stigma that people
have in getting relationship help.
And there's this whole
movement to try to break the stigma.
And it's like totally missing the point
in my opinion.
The reason why there's a stigma is
because
people feel judged.
And instead of
let's break the stigma. In other words,
be okay with being judged. It's good for
you.
Why don't we just stop judging people?
Why do you have to be judged to be
helped?
In certain cases that's necessary when
it comes to medicine. That's why I want
to contrast this to medicine.
If God forbid somebody has cancer, you
need to go to the doctor, you have to
get an MRI or x-ray or whatever, a CT
scan. You have to identify the illness
and you have to remove it.
But what happens when a couple comes to
a therapist or coach or rabbi or
whatever
and they that practitioner takes the
same approach. Let me figure out what
the cancer is, what the problem is so we
could remove it. What actually happens?
People get defensive.
And people feel blamed.
So many people
have
shared with me and
I don't think I'm the only person privy
to have heard this.
They've tried they've gone to various
therapists and marriage counselors. And
by the way, I'm not throwing anybody
under the bus any anybody specifically
under the bus. There's wonderful people
out there.
And I don't think anybody is ill intent
either. I'm just telling you
anecdotally what people have shared with
me
that it turned into a shouting match, a
blaming session,
where the therapist was
a or even the rabbi or whatever, was a
referee
watching them fight. And the reason is
because they're trying, with good
intentions, trying to figure out what
the problem is so they could solve it,
and now people get defensive.
What you want to actually figure out
is what the problem isn't.
What isn't the problem?
That's a funny way to talk.
Uh another way to say that is what what
do you actually hope for? What do you
want your relationship to actually look
like?
That's something that is less
stigmatized.
That's something that's going to help
the guard go down,
which creates a space for connection,
respect, love, intimacy, joy, whatever.
>> Here's here's my question to that
or or I don't want to call it a
challenge, but here here's the question
I have on that or
does that
that doesn't negate necessarily that
that there may be in fact
a problem. Like the problem
may still exist
in a way where
I wouldn't say we're not ignoring it.
We're we're choosing not to focus on it.
We're choosing on to choosing to focus
on something positive, but that doesn't
necessarily take that doesn't change the
fact that
there is a or potentially is
a problem. Like back when I was in, you
know, in one of the things that
I absolutely despised was
when
they would take these really bad kids
and like, oh, we just have to praise
them and praise them and focus on
well, like no. In Torah, it clearly says
right? Stay away from evil and and
pursue good. You still have to modify
the negative behavior. You have to
identify what is the negative behavior
in order to to to know what you're going
away from. So
>> Yeah, that good question. The the
problem is very real.
At least it's very real to the people
experiencing.
It is.
And the pain is real.
So it's not just
you know, put on a smile, guys. Come on.
Laugh it out.
Walk tough it through.
But it is the belief that
people can be bigger than their
problems.
And that a problem
doesn't have to be a limitation.
It really doesn't need to be.
>> So the the problem will always be there
potentially,
but we as individuals and as a couple
will be in such a good place or we'll be
focused on the right things that
we'll be able to handle the problem
properly.
>> Exactly. Or create less less space for
it initially. One of the two happens.
When when they focus on identity, on
hope,
what we want a relationship to actually
look like, what what we who we need to
be. When once you take that approach,
either there's less space for the
problem to show up, depends on the
situation, or the problem is still
there, but you're no worse off. You now
you can face it together. You could
handle it together. You could deal with
it together.
>> So that really
kind of goes back to the idea that
when a a couple are getting married or
even if they've already been married,
they have to have
oh, I guess it really the question is
what is marriage then? Because you're
talking about two individuals who need
to be
individuals and yet at the same time
they're they're joining together in
something. So on the one hand, you have
to have a strong identity of self,
but then you also have to be able to
interact with a partner.
>> Yeah.
You got to do both. And that's tough.
That's tough. There there is this
balance. You know, we have a similar
issue or or I shouldn't say an issue, a
similar challenge when it comes to our
relationship with God.
We say Shema.
Hear, O Israel, the Lord is our God, the
Lord is one.
God is one.
Which means there's nothing else besides
God. He's the only one.
Like even me, my desires, my needs, my
wants. So
what are they what value do they
actually hold in compared to the
ultimate reality?
Right? So there's
there's a bigger right identity here.
There's a bigger picture.
And then right afterward we say
you should love the Lord your God.
Well, who am I to love God if I don't
even exist?
Okay, it turns out that you need to do
both.
Turns out that we need to realize
there's an existence larger than our own
and within that framework we have to put
our heart and soul into it and exist.
And it's the same in in marriage as
well.
Your spouse
I mean there is being self not being
self-centered, focusing on the
relationship, focusing on your spouse.
On the other hand, and this is this is
so important for men. Probably might be
important for women as well, but
I see this often with men and I have a
feeling what I'm about to say will be
relatable to a lot of our listeners.
On the other hand,
there needs to be independence.
A wife does not want to be married to a
mirror
to somebody who just reflects her.
Where she comes in, she's in a bad mood,
she had a hard day
and now
you're feeling down. She needs somebody
that can hold be strong. It's other way
as well. She's happy. She's in a great
mood.
But now there's pressure for her to be
in a good mood because your good mood is
contingent on her good mood.
So now she has this pressure to keep
that up.
And now
she either feels guilty for being in a
bad mood
or she feels pressure to be in a good
mood
because you have no independence. You're
just reflecting her.
You don't have any independent identity
that she could hold on to and respect
and and and feel safe with.
So there is this balance
I don't I don't even know if it's a
balance or like a synthesis
of
there's something bigger than our own
selves which is what helps us connect
and I have to bring myself into it
independently.
>> Being that
again there's two parts here there's the
self and then there's something bigger
than the self but the self still has to
be
strong it still has to be
you need to know what your baseline is
you need to know who you are.
So how how does
how does one
build that
identity of self then?
>> Yeah
I I think it starts with not building
but discovering.
The reason why I think that's important
an important distinction it doesn't need
to be built but the reason why I think
discovery is an important word is
because it's there.
You even if you're going through a
difficult time and you have a hard time
seeing it right now
you have interests you have passions you
have
values you have things that everybody
has something that matters to them.
Like you put put it this way if I sit in
a room with you long enough I could
I could piss you off.
And and I say that as a good as a good
thing it means there's something that
matters to you.
I could trigger you.
I don't know if I could trigger you I
mean
the whatever you could be triggered by
something.
Right there's something that matters to
you there's something that's important
to you.
Maybe it's politics may whatever but I'm
saying
ultimately that's going to be some sort
of value that matters to you
an identity
interest.
So I I think it with really discovering
it.
Once you discover it,
it's going to be a lot easier to build.
I mean there's the practical
element of this is, you know,
consistency and and show up and and do
what you got to do.
But it starts with
actually
finding real evidence of yourself.
>> So a husband who comes home from
a long day of work or a wife that comes
home from a long day of work or a wife
who has been at home and that is her
work and then her husband comes home and
in order to
I guess it sounds like you don't want
the way your day went to influence your
spouse, but at the same time
you shouldn't allow yourself to be
influenced by how your spouse's day
went.
In order for that to
to to happen in in in a in a positive
way, that means that
the husband checks himself at the door
and says, okay, where am I right now? Do
I need to flip my mood, flip my
attitude? Do I need to go for a run
around the block before I walk through
the door?
The wife says the same thing, you know,
her husband's
coming home or today's day and age where
things are very progressive, the wife's
coming home and the husband's been at
home all day, whatever it may be, you
know, however you want it.
They have to kind of check themselves
and say,
okay, who who am I really so that I
I can show up properly for my spouse. Is
is that
correct? Is that what happens in in in a
happy functioning marriage?
>> It will definitely make it happier, for
sure.
Because you're being intentional.
When you're being intentional with
any any negative experience in a
relationship
is
two partners experiencing a version of
each other that they don't like
or that they're having
a version of each other that they don't
like. Like, I mean like
preference.
A version of each other that makes them
feel unsafe, a version of them that
makes them feel unstable. I mean, that's
a more extreme like way of putting it.
So it it is recalibrating.
Like, wait a minute.
Who do I need to be in this moment?
I mean, you could call it recalibrating,
you could call it regulating.
You could call it
dropping your
unrealistic expectations. You could call
it whatever you want because it's going
to be different for each person.
Like, when I sit with a couple and I ask
them questions that lead them to
understanding who they need to be.
For some people, it's
I just need to regulate.
I just need to breathe.
I just need to like
drop the energy.
For some people, it's I need to get out
of my own head.
Because our brains could be a very
It's kind of ironic. I'm going off topic
here, but this is a little bit of a
irony.
We
usually think that the head could be a
very selfish place,
a self-centered place.
Right? When we're stuck in our own
heads.
Because your your heart reflects
outward.
Right? Your heart wants to love someone
else.
Your heart wants to respect someone else
outside of you.
The head is just you know, when we're
stuck in our own mind and it doesn't
have anything to do with how we
express emotion. So we end up being
stuck in our own brain and then
for some people, it's literally just
get out of my head.
There's a world around me.
And it's
not fair to bring my negative energy
into the home. That doesn't mean you
have to suppress it and hide it and
pretend to smile all day.
I mean, hopefully for the spouse who has
a
spouse going through a difficult time,
you could them.
But
so there is this balance. You still need
to be authentic, you need to be real,
but you you can schedule these things.
>> What does that look like? What does it
look like
scheduling because
life doesn't necessarily work on a
schedule.
[laughter]
I mean, it'd be nice if all the all the
problems that we experienced always I
mean, technically speaking, that's what
Monday is. Monday is problem day, right?
And then the rest of the week is
wonderful.
>> That's funny.
Scheduling means
not just dumping everything we're
feeling on someone else
or neglecting someone else
because of how we're feeling.
One of the two.
But maybe being more intentional in
how we share ourselves.
It's ironic because I keep saying
intentional and authentic and they sound
like op but it sounds like an oxymoron.
>> Cuz intentional is is
a a decision whereas authentic is as
things are.
>> Yeah.
Exactly.
Um and
I I'll tell you what it is is you want
to be intentional
and you want to embrace your spouse's
authenticity.
Your spouse is going to want to be
intentional and going to want to embrace
your authenticity.
You meet in the middle
and you can have a relationship that is
real but not overbearing.
Or when it's overbearing, it's
it's fine. Like
I was working with a couple once
and yeah, I mentioned this to you last
week at one of our other discussions.
She said I I want to come home
and it it's just okay that I'm in a bad
mood.
It's It's if I'm hormonal.
Like I don't need to be happy.
And I don' need him to make me happy. I
don't need to do anything about it. I
don't even need him to empathize. Just
stop getting scared
or intimidated or taking it personal.
Like I'm mad at you or something. I'm
not mad at you. My hormones are up the
roof, man. Just accept it. Just embrace
me for who I am. I don't want the
pressure
of having to be like perfect,
you know, which is the walking on
eggshells thing.
And she'll she'll try to be intentional,
trying to work on it, trying not to, you
know, but but like
while I'm working on it, just embrace
me.
>> That that seems like a very difficult
thing to do though.
I mean, I don't know where this idea
comes from that
that we have that everything needs to be
perfect all the time or everything needs
to be happy and dandy. Um
>> Yeah.
Well, yeah, exactly.
Yeah.
Sorry Sorry. Let's take a step back for
a second. When you say it's a difficult
thing to do, what what's a difficult
thing to do?
>> To be able to be authentic in that way
and at the same time
for the spouse to not
be worried about
or I don't know, take it personally, but
not take on that responsibility for for
the person whom they love when they when
they're coming home and and they're not
okay.
>> Yeah. It it means
being a spouse, not a mirror.
Being a person, not a mirror. Right?
It's
you're
you you married a person, not a mirror.
I not going to push back. I think you're
right. It's hard.
Um but but let me put it this way.
Is it worth it?
I don't mean is it worth it to live a
life that's hard. Obviously not.
Um is it always going to be hard?
If a person's in a rough spot, it's
particularly going to be hard.
Is it always going to be hard?
And
is the payoff worth it? Is a
relationship where you could feel
comfortable in a relationship where you
welcome your spouse
as they are so they don't have to be on
the eggshells. I mean isn't that worth
it?
>> So in a practical sense
what does it look like? Is that that you
know one spouse having a a rough day so
the other spouse
picks up the slack, puts the kids to
bed, washes the dishes, cooks dinner.
Um
like like what does that
what does it look like?
With the understanding that every
household is going to be different
because every person is going to need
something different.
>> That's the danger of what does it look
like.
It ironically it's easier to answer what
does it feel like.
>> Okay so what does it feel like?
>> Cuz cuz it cuz what it looks like
honestly doesn't matter.
We're willing to
do hard things and endure hard things
when there's a good reason.
I'll tell you just anecdotally what I
hear from women
when I'm working with couples.
I hear this one line again and again and
again and again and again.
Not from the same person by the way.
No I I hear this from a lot of women.
I just want him to see me
to notice me.
Like I want like hello I'm here.
The guy comes in after work or maybe
he's at home or whatever the thing is
but
men are like
okay everybody's going to accuse me for
being sexist and or or whatever but it's
men are like one track minded
not multitasking type people.
Men are not big picture people.
Men men like horse
And it's like
I'm overloaded with work and picking up
the kids from school
and everything.
And it's like every every additional
thing,
including the bills that are just
weighing on me,
are blinding my vision.
And with this big
dusty pile in front of us of all these
things, our spouse is like she's waving
her arms. Hello, do you see me?
You know, what does it look like to make
her feel seen?
I I I could give suggestions and I think
those are good suggestions that you
mentioned like cooking dinner or
whatever it is.
Um
but I I think it means something I'll
tell you a great story in a second.
I I think it means something different
for everybody and I don't think it has
to be something
dramatic.
As much as it is like intentional
signals like you saw me.
>> It also be personal to
to her and then to him.
>> Yes. Pro It needs to be personalized.
Better be personalized than than just
you know, I heard the advice from I I
once had a
client tell me
that he was having a very difficult time
with his spouse,
with his wife.
And it was suggested by
coach or rabbi or whatever it was, by
the practitioner suggested that
you go play a board game with her.
That was a nice suggestion. Give her
time, give her focus, you're you're
stopping whatever you're doing and
you're
and just it it it totally backfired.
She says, you know I don't like board
games. Like don't you ever listen to me?
How many times have I told you that I
hate board games?
Right? He was so focused on trying to
what do I do? What do I do? What do I
do? It's like
Stop the what do I do?
Just see her.
And so many things were backfiring,
compliments.
Right? He's
therapists were telling him you need to
compliment like this and compliment like
that and practice complimenting.
And and I'm not anti-compliments. I'm
not anti-board games. It's not just
But her these compliments made her feel
awkward.
She didn't believe them.
Finally,
I asked him, you know, you're so hung up
on like this compliment thing.
If you somehow complimented your wife in
a way that was pleasing to you, what
what would that
do? What would that accomplish?
She'd probably smile.
Oh, okay.
You don't want to compliment her. You
want to just smile.
Yeah. Oh, okay.
When was the last time you caught her
smiling?
Been a long time.
Said if I were to challenge you to think
about it
I don't know.
I I have a rule, by the way.
Yeah, I don't know if I should be
sharing this in public, but once I ask a
question, I can't back down.
Not just because I'm a stubborn person.
I'm willing to be whatever, let go of my
stubbornness, but because
I believe in you.
And I don't want to signify I don't even
want to I don't wouldn't want to signify
otherwise.
When did you catch your wife
smiling?
Finally, he answered the question.
He had
shared with her an article
that he thought would have been
interesting to her.
He's not an article guy.
Wasn't his thing.
But she felt like that's not your thing,
but you were thinking of me.
Okay, I felt seen.
Like I exist in your world.
I don't exist in the therapist's world
who said do a board game,
or in the the the coach's world who said
try throwing compliments. I exist in
your in my world and your world.
Like you get it.
I think when there's the you get it
moment
where you just you she feels seen.
You feel seen. You feel like you get
each other.
To your point, that's hard.
But when you have those moments,
it's easier to endure the more difficult
moments.
When you have more difficult moments,
it's easier to heal when you have other
moments besides that.
>> So
a a couple looking to get married or a
couple that's been married
for a while um
and whether things are going great or or
things
are not going great
and they're looking to make things great
again.
I guess initially I was going to ask
you know what goals should they be
setting, but it seems like it's less
about the external
um goals of of what our marriage looks
like and more about the internal of
who I am and who we are.
>> Oh, I'm so glad you said that.
[snorts]
[laughter]
I I'm like triggered by the word goals.
I I used to not be, but then I
I learned, I realized like goals are so
goals are okay.
Don't take this out of context. I'm not
like anti goals, but
they are external.
They they signify a thing you want to
accomplish, not a person identity you
want to become.
There's nothing wrong with a goal. I
think that's important and and whatever,
it's great.
But every goal has an identity attached
to it.
Uh, think of a goal. I don't know. Just
goal that somebody might have, a couple
that that a couple might have.
>> Having a nice house.
>> Having a nice house. Okay.
Now, if this couple had a nice house
that felt
like this was what difference would that
make to them as a couple? What would
that do for them?
>> They would make them happier.
>> It would make them happier.
And if they were happier as a couple
because they felt they had a nice house
that they were comfortable in,
what difference would that make to them?
>> They'd be more pleasant to be around
each other.
>> Right.
So, I'm more concerned not about the
nice house,
which is important, but about being
pleasant
to be around each other
because that's going to be
Otherwise, if you're not pleasant around
each other, you know what you're going
to do in that large house? You're going
to stay in different ends of the house.
And if you have a small house, you
haven't gotten to that small large house
yet, you'll be at each other's throats.
>> So,
Okay. So, therefore,
I I mean, I know you primarily work with
individuals who are not individuals,
couples who are already a couple,
but for couples who are looking to
become a couple,
then in theory then anybody should be
able to marry anybody.
Cuz if if my goal in marriage is just
to be able to be supportive of somebody
else,
then you can in theory support anybody.
>> Yeah. I mean, you have to like the
person.
>> Yeah.
>> You have to like each other. I I think
that's the the bottom line. I I'll tell
you this.
If a couple has all their external goals
lined up, we want our kids in the same
kinds of schools,
right?
Goals can be important. I'm not saying
goals are whatever.
We want to live in the same kind of
community. We want to have the same kind
of upbringing. We both want to be near
grandparents. Whatever it is, I don't
know.
But they don't
like each other. They don't enjoy each
other's company.
They don't
have fun together. And I don't mean like
they need to go bowling.
Whatever. But I'm saying they just
they don't want to look at each other.
I'm not talking about after a massive
fight. I'm just talking about you're
talking about the dating process.
Okay? Marriage we'll we'll get to in a
second.
Then
it's they're they're going to be aligned
superficially
even for important things to an relative
to their to them it's superficial.
If a couple likes each other,
then they're going to figure it out.
And if they like each other and
they have goals that align, I mean that
that's going to be much easier. It's
obviously easier when the goals align.
It is, right? If you if you both agree
on the same kinds of school for your
kids
and the same level of in your home,
right?
Not these are important goals and if you
if they're aligned, you're going to have
an easier time.
But you have to like each other.
Uh if you want like a
from a source
uh beautiful
that I've been learning from the
called
My
teachings and essays on
relationships on marriage.
And he talks about the
dynamic of marriage, the
the giver-receiver dynamic. The male is
the giver, the female is the receiver.
Right?
Which means the male can't be the
mirror, right? He has to actually be
proactive
and not just reflect what she has
uh or at least not reflect the
but but he has to actually give and she
has to be open to receiving and he has
to make her open to receiving and she
has to bring out a part of him that's
able to give.
But how does that then that that's like
a cycle. How do you get into that cycle?
So he quotes from the
is the blessings that we recite at the
wedding.
Rejoice, beloved friends.
Love each other, be friends.
Now in that context
you can be yourself which is a giver,
you can be yourself a receiver, you can
you can connect in that way.
>> So when a couple is
going through hard times and they come
to um
for counseling or coaching, guidance
what is your your
I mean again with understanding that
every couple is going to be different
what is your first step
getting them back to a place of
of joy and happiness and remembrance of
of
who they are as an individual and who
they were as a couple?
>> That's [clears throat]
often my first step.
It like you said no two couples are
alike.
I have [clears throat]
couples that reach out
and say like have you dealt with
this and this kind of addiction or this
and this kind of
issue
this kind of betrayal. Have you seen
that before? Yeah, but that's not going
to help you
because you're not them, you're you.
Right in
we say
Chapter one
um
you should be slow to judgment.
And the commentators explain what does
that mean be slow to judgment? Don't
think that just because you saw
something before even a thousand times
that you're an expert. Every individual
is different.
My first step
I would say my
eventually I want I want to get them
back to where they
felt they once were.
It's not always easy to start from that
place on my from from my perspective.
then, we had whatever it is. All valid
reasons. I'm not I'm not trying to
dismiss anything.
The starting point is
who do you need to be
right now?
That's a very big question. I obviously
I make it much smaller. I can tell you
how I make it smaller, but I I make it
much smaller.
>> Especially because like right now in
this moment
things aren't going well, so what do you
mean who do I need to be? It's it's
who does he or she need to be? Like why
is it my why isn't it the other person's
responsibility?
>> So it's an overwhelming question.
The way I make it less overwhelming the
reason why I I said the overwhelming
version is because I I just want you and
our listeners to understand
what I want them
to
what they what is necessary at this
moment.
Practically how I get them there
I I usually start off and I'm
like by the way if you're listening to
this and you're like oh I already know
what he does, it's still going to be
helpful.
I I've I've
I've counseled people that are like
practitioners in this method themselves.
Doesn't matter what you know because
we're trying to get to your heart.
But I ask them if if our discussion for
the next hour was a productive one.
What do you think you'd first notice
about yourself at the end of the hour?
In the beginning if it's your first time
you're like what did you just say?
But I'll ask it if this was a productive
discussion, how would you notice?
Like what are your best hopes from our
talking?
And usually it's like
you know, sometimes they'll say a goal,
we want better communication.
Like the house, right? I have to turn it
back into
what's happening in the house, right?
What's happening in communication? Like
if you had good communication or better
communication, what would that do for
you?
Oh, I'd be so much more relaxed. Oh.
What kind of spouse would you be if you
were more relaxed?
I'd be more pleasant.
And if you were more pleasant, what
would you notice that's different about
you? What kind of mindset would you
have? What kind
Now we're talking about you being a
pleasant person.
And how would that impact you
communicating? Oh, I communicate much
better when I'm a pleasant person.
Right? Sometimes it is, oh this when I
ask that question, sometimes oh my best
hopes is this person would shape up.
If that person shaped up,
why would you appreciate that?
I could finally sleep at night.
Still superficial because I'm not
asleep. This is all what we're here for,
right?
So
if you finally slept that night, what
would that do for you?
Right? And they'll describe some sort of
identity that they want to assume.
So my my first thing is to get them to
figure out who they really want to be.
Like what is it about them that's
actually worth fighting for?
Once you have two identities,
you can sew them together. Identity
goals, by the way, could conflict.
Identity will never conflict.
>> Why?
>> Because it's fundamental and it's deep.
Uh I I I don't know if I can tell you
why. I can tell you how.
>> So like you you have somebody who who
let's say is an introvert and then you
have somebody who's an extrovert.
Somebody who who
I mean maybe that's not identity, but
somebody who likes being around other
people and he likes giving to other
people versus
somebody who was really more quiet
reserved
who like to keep to themselves. And
again maybe that's not an internal
identity, that's an external expression.
>> Exactly. It's a great It's a good
example. So So let's say the introvert.
Let's say the husband is this
quiet introvert who wants to be left
alone and just sit down with a book
and vacation is literally sitting on the
balcony with a Diet Coke
and a book and being left alone by the
entire world. I may or may not be
talking about myself, but I'm kidding.
Um and
and for the wife she's an I'm just
kidding. But for the wife she's just
she's an extrovert and she wants to go
do things and talk to people
Right? So they're two different
personalities. How they ever going to
get along, right? So you ask the
introvert if if you got your way and you
could just be left alone, what would
that do for you?
Be more peaceful.
What kind of person would that make you?
That would make me a more
I'm just giving examples. That would
make me a more
more calm, happier person.
And you say to the extrovert
if you got to really
engage socially
and your husband agreed to be schlepped
along with you, what would that do for
you?
I can't relate to the satisfaction of
being super social. No, I'm kidding. I'm
not that bad of an introvert, but
um
right? I I I feel satisfied.
What would that do? What kind of person
would that make you? What would be
different about you if you were more
satisfied?
I feel like I'm myself again. I feel
alive.
So he's peaceful, she's alive.
What does that do to your relationship?
Those are identities that don't
conflict.
>> Again, it's because the the individual
is is at a place where they themselves
are in a good place and so therefore
they can show up as themselves
>> Yeah.
>> It It's like the the the metaphor of you
know your your your cup. Like if
if your cup is full, then you can pour
over to other people. But if your cup is
empty,
then you have nothing to give.
>> Exactly.
I I a couple once where he wanted a
divorce and she wanted to stay married.
Right?
And I said if if you got that divorce
that you were hoping to get,
what would that do for you? She said I'd
be left alone.
It was hard to hear that. It was a
really difficult session. I'm I'm
what would that do for you?
I'd be more peaceful.
Now mind you, they're not
they're divorcing, but they're going to
be co-parents, right? So they still have
to figure things out one way or another.
That's which is why they were ultimately
coming.
And if you were
So so he said if we got to I'd be left
alone and be at more peace.
And I said to her if you felt
somehow that you could save this
marriage and you didn't get divorced,
what would that do for you?
I'd feel just alive again. I'd feel
like a house is a home. I'd feel
like I could just be myself and not
overthink things.
Now as whether they decide to get
divorced or not, whether they decide to
get married or not,
it's not really
as much as I'd love to save marriages,
it's you know, I have to trust that they
know themselves and the situation better
than I do.
As co-parents, they're going to have
more respectful conversations
and hopefully have less
legal battles and and and drama.
If he could be more peaceful
and she could just feel like she's
herself,
right? Those are two identities that are
not going to conflict.
>> So it really boils down to
as as we've said so many times already,
it's it's about the self-identity and
and and
the individual being in
a good place. So
marriage,
relationship coaching and counseling is
really about
individual coaching and counseling for
two people who are sharing a life
together.
>> Yeah.
Your your individual identity
directly impacts the relationship
identity.
Could be the other way around as well,
right? The relationship identity will
relationship can make you happy.
But what do you have more control over?
>> Yourself?
>> Yeah.
>> So
what what about a situation where
if you've ever experienced this where
a couple comes to you
but only one
member of the couple is willing to to
work on the marriage which really means
work on themselves.
>> Oh, I love that question.
>> Cuz on the one hand from what you're
saying like
train keeps moving. You you work on
yourself because it's now it's not about
you and her together and and the
problems. It's about
you as an individual whether it's a he
or whether it's a she.
>> But they're both showing up.
>> But they're both showing up. Or maybe
maybe they're not both showing up. I
don't mean we can go through multiple
scenarios here.
>> Let let's assume they're both showing
up.
When when they're both showing up I I'm
smiling right now. If you're on Spotify
you don't see that. If you're on YouTube
you do.
Because what I'm thinking of
please don't take this obnoxiously as
like challenge accepted.
[laughter]
I'll tell you what I mean by that.
What I mean by that is like
they've showed up
and nobody forced them to.
They obviously want something for
themselves.
Not just the goal, but something deep
and meaningful.
They might not be willing to share it
with me.
Yet, I have to earn that trust or or
maybe they don't want their spouse
there.
But there there
there is something they want and and I
have to believe that
with incredible stubbornness because
they showed up.
It would be disrespectful to take them
when they say I don't really want I'm
good.
It would be disrespectful to take them
seriously.
Or as like my mentor always says,
don't believe your clients, believe in
your clients.
I I had a couple once where
she was debating whether she wanted to
share the
save the marriage or not.
They were they were in a base they were
literally about to get a
And they decided to get another shot.
And they were thankful that they did, by
the way.
They worked really hard.
But at the beginning,
she said I'm we're not sure.
And he said I'm pretty sure I don't want
to really save this marriage.
This was an introductory like an intake
type call. We haven't started our work
together yet.
I said really? He says yeah.
I said what are you doing here?
He said my wife asked me to be here.
I said do you do everything your wife
asks you to do?
Just no.
So only when she asks you to come
to save the marriage that that's the
only time you lit like what is going on
here?
I was just messing with him and he knew
it, but my point was like
what are you here for?
I have to believe I owe it to you to
believe in you that you're here for a
reason.
I once had a couple where
they were going through a really really
they were working really let me put it
nicely.
And honestly, they were working really
hard.
And
they were
It was like a second or it was like a
follow-up session, whatever it was, they
were he was exhausted.
And I said if this was a good
discussion, what do you think
how do you think like I start off the
session like what are your hopes for our
talking?
Says no hope.
I said no hope, nothing?
Says nothing.
And I
I I felt stuck and I kept thinking okay,
you're here.
I can't actually accept that you're
serious even though you look serious and
Finally, I said to him
you're going to think I'm nuts by the
way from this.
I said what are you doing here?
What compelled you to come if you feel
like those no if you would have said
there was I'm not very hopeful, so then
that would be obnoxious and say why are
you even a little bit hopeful?
It's not a catchphrase. I'm remembering.
I I believe it. I really do.
I won't take a client on if I don't
believe in them by the way.
Like if you're listening to this right
now and you
you reach out to me and I take you on as
a client
it's because I believe in you.
Otherwise, my success rate goes down.
I'm kidding.
So I I said to him
what do you
why did you come back?
He says because we started.
So?
I like completing things.
Finally, I had an in.
I'm like you like completing things? He
says yeah. I said why?
He says I feel just I feel better about
myself when I complete things.
Well, what's different about you when
you complete things?
I just feel more
complete
more whole.
We had a discussion about
him being more complete, more whole.
I don't care that he didn't mention it
in context of his relationship.
How you do anything is how you do
everything.
It doesn't matter like
and he got to learn about a version of
himself that can be more whole, more
complete, how that impacts his
relationship,
how that shapes the way he chooses to
approach his wife,
his children, whatever the situation
was.
>> So it's very clear that
a
I mean there there's going to have to be
more discussion around the the the topic
of
self identity, identity,
self healing, um
call it whatever you you you want to
call it.
Um
but but around the the individual
working and and and growing
to be able to get to a place where then
they can happily
show up in their marriage
to be able to be there as a support for
their spouse.
Because it's definitely not a small
package to unpack.
>> Yeah, it it's always
more effective to
to change yourself than to try to change
someone. You know, there's a great line
from Rabbi Twerski, if you win an
argument with your wife, then you're
married to a loser.
[laughter] Not worth it.
>> Okay, so then as we're as we begin to
wrap up, um
the I guess kind of the final question
for this part because I got a thousand
more questions, but the final question
for this one is is there a
a benefit or a a difference in a person
working on themselves
in the context of a relationship and a
marriage
versus
just working on them just working on
themselves.
>> Like are you going to do differently?
Is that the question?
>> Sure.
Is there any more power in it?
A story comes to mind. I forget who it
was.
I think Darren Hardy has a book called
Compound Effect.
And in it, I believe if I'm quoting the
right person, he talks about this idea
of
he he wrote down the dream girl that he
wanted to marry down to the color of her
shoes and the type of dress she wore and
the color of her hair and the color of
her eyes and then characteristics as
well.
And once he compiled that list, he
realized that
he was not the person that he needed to
be
to be deserving of that type of lady. So
what did he do? He worked on himself to
become the person that he needed to be
in order to be
deserving of that type of person. And
sure enough, once he got there
himself, that's when he brought this
person into his life. He attracted down
to the tea, the the red shoes and
everything, he attracted that person
into his life. So
again,
if we're working on ourselves to get
ourselves to a better place and that
therefore then
helps our marriage, is is there any more
pull when somebody's in a committed
relationship versus
just being on their own?
Is does the work look different if a
person is is in a committed relationship
versus doing the work on their own?
>> I do think that when a person's
in a relationship
and they're making changes but
exclusively for the relationship,
your spouse is a smart person.
[laughter]
It's like just tell me what to do and
I'll do it.
No, it doesn't work that way, right?
I think in many ways
when we change, when we make important
changes in life, not just because we
know it's going to trigger somebody.
There's merit to that. It's not a bad
thing.
But this is I don't want to be the kind
of person who triggers somebody whether
in practice triggers them or not.
A fundamental change. The fundamental
change doesn't have to It sounds scary,
fundamental change. Like I don't want to
fundamentally change myself. I'm good.
I'm happy.
I I don't mean like we like you.
However whoever is listening to this
here,
you're a good Honestly,
I don't know why I said change. I I want
to I want to backtrack for a second.
Please don't change.
I'll tell you
one of my favorite
stories I heard from my one of my
mentors, my counseling mentors,
prior to him going into clinical
psychology,
he was a college baseball player, very
good.
This is back in the '90s.
He had a baseball coach
that would
teach and he was very meticulous on how
they would swing, when they would swing,
and all the specifics.
You know, he was training for
professional baseball.
He switched courses.
And in the '90s, the coach would film
them, would film their swings.
And you know, there's no CapCut, there's
no edits app, there's no
You know, editing videos in the '90s was
a big deal.
Home videos in the '90s with
But he would edit each person's video.
He would edit out all the bad swings.
And he would show them the good swings.
And they would say, Coach, what about
the bad swings? We need to know what
we're doing wrong. He says, I don't want
you to do those.
I want you to do the good swings.
If they're doing good swings, they're
not going to be doing bad swings. So the
reason why I say this is because change
sounds like a scary word.
And maybe you need to change, but
if want to make it to sound less scary,
like you still want to recognize
yourself in the mirror type of thing,
just become more of
what you're already okay at or good at.
One of my favorite questions I I
I love
asking couples
is how did you meet?
Um
I haven't fully answered your question
yet, by the way. I'm aware. Don't worry.
Uh when when when I ask them how did you
meet? If if the couple were to come in
and I would say, so guys, what are we
here to talk about?
Tell me what's going on. If it's code
word for tell me about the worst part of
your relationship, and now they start
answering and now that's what they're
thinking about and that's that becomes
the rumination. That's what now they
say, oh, I'm a problem now if we solve
the guard goes up.
Versus
um how did you guys meet?
That's code word for tell me about a
better version of your relationship.
What did you like about him?
Right? There's there is a version of you
fundamentally
that is still there that you just want
to become more of.
Now going back to your question, should
you do that for the relationship or
should you do that regardless of the
relationship?
Should it be
or or uh
I I got to believe that you wanting to
be a better kind of person,
not just because you're afraid of your
spouse's reaction is going to be a good
thing,
a better thing.
>> All right. Well,
think that that gives everybody enough
to work on for
for the next week
um looking into themselves, figuring
out, remembering really
uh who they are, who they who they can
be, who they were.
And then even within the marriage, it's
looking back at
again, you know, when we first met,
who were we? And and what did what did
we appreciate about ourselves so much
and what did we appreciate about
appreciate about our spouse so much? I
think that's a
good place to start and a good place to
focus.
>> It could be very powerful.
And by the way, even if you've been
married like a really long time,
I I've asked couples that question.
Sometimes it could be 40 I you you know
you're asking this question about like
40 50 years ago. So
the brain is very
powerful place.
>> Absolutely.
Well, ladies and gentlemen, thank you
for tuning in. Thank you for listening.
If you have any questions, comments,
concerns, we would love to hear from
you. We definitely want to hear the
questions that you have, the experiences
that you've had, anything you want to
share or anything you have questions on,
please leave it in a in the description
or in in the comments below. Or if
you're on Spotify, you there's a feature
now that you can send messages or
Josh, do you have a way of people
getting a hold of you?
>> Yeah, you can
you can email me at [email protected].
>> Very simple, very straightforward. And
of course, everything is is always 100%
anonymous. But we thank you for joining
us and we look forward to speaking with
you next time.
>> Thank you guys.