Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Part 27: There is Room for Doubt Within Faith
2 views
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning everyone oh yeah one
more announcement before we start
tomorrow night we have a um a usual and
hopefully productive conference call SL
webcast Naomi Burger who is a phenomenal
local therapist who's really had a a
fantastically successful um string with
with people I've sent to her at least um
she and I will be having a very Frank
and open conversation about intimacy and
marriage um we're specifically doing it
that people people can call in
anonymously from the comfort of their
homes couples can listen together you
could also watch together live you could
send in anonymous questions as it's
going on so there's no Stigma attached
there's no excuse you can be cooking for
shabas and be talking about intimacy or
listening to it talk about intimacy so
it's tomorrow night at 8:30 details are
on the weekly or on Facebook or in that
flyer but um it's an area of marriage
which is so critically important to be
healthy for marriage to be healthy and
unfortunately there is a lot of struggle
in this area so you or your children or
grandchildren or friends or neighbors
you can tell them about it and they can
call in okay we continue with our amuna
series yes um again the amuna sh are
dedicated anonymously sponsored
anonymously in memory for Al of sh
G last week we began the onun we did the
entire first page of your booklet which
is his introduction to the topic of
amuna and if you recall here
the describ living a life life of amuna
as living a life In Color without amuna
without belief in the almighty without
feeling his divine presence in your life
his guiding hand on your shoulder
without feeling that there's meaning and
Order and purpose to all that occurs to
you so you're living life but it's in
black and white but when you believe
that there's an Almighty when you
understand as a creator of the universe
when you see his hand in all that
happens then all of a sudden life comes
alive you're now living life in full HD
color um you you know the language he
uses is that nature and the world are s
the song of amuna every Bird's chirp and
every leaf that changes color not here
in South Florida but every leaf that
changes color and every world event even
if they seem complicated or you're
disappointed in them but everything that
happens sings the song of amuna when you
live in a life where you don't just see
things as Randomness and chance but you
choose to take that leap and it
sometimes often requires a leap um to
see life with with amuna okay so that
brings us up I don't want to review
everything he said let's let's continue
page me which is the next page in the
booklet and he begins here with the
[Music]
r the
begins actually learning this with my
daughter for we going
through figure if you're becoming the
age of mitzvas you should learn the
foundations of Torah which are so the
ran begins that the foundation of
foundation
and the pillar of wisdom is to know that
there is a first cause that there is a
source for all that exists how do you
explain it to an 11 soon to be 12y old
it's very simple you say Tamar where did
you come from I came from you and Mommy
where did we come from well sa sa and B
and Zi and where did they come from and
you keep going and going and going you
say get back to not that they can name
it but if you were to trace it
theoretically all the way back you say
and where did that first person come
from huh that's a good question well the
answer is that's what Hashem is when you
wonder what is Hashem Hashem is when you
trace that trail all the way back and
there's no one who comes before him he
is the beginning of everything that's
Hashem now what does it mean there's
nothing who comes before him that's when
you start to get dizzy and get a
headache that's when you start to
scramble and uh and uh you're in trouble
when it's your child but it's
complicated we don't know we can't
identify we don't relate to what it
means to not have a beginning we live in
a world and operate in a world where
everyone we know has a beginning
they have a middle and at some point
hopefully after 120 they have an end we
operate within time time is one of the
creations of the world we recently read
bra and the V and others say what is the
first creation it's not the sh in the
beginning God created the heavens and
the Earth but that's not the first
creation it's a mistake it's a misnomer
what was the first
creation bous time bous elim God created
the beginning because before that there
was no beginning and middle and end
there was no yesterday today and
tomorrow there was no past present and
future ah so okay I got that God is not
bound by time so what is he I have no
idea I can't relate to it I can't
identify with it I can't describe it to
you I have no idea I just know what he's
not I've told you before that the rambam
writes we can't describe what God is
because we can't relate to it all we can
describe is what God is not he's not
bound by time he's not bound by space
he's not limited he's not emotional he
doesn't have any physical features we
could talk about what Hashem isn't we
can't talk about what he is because if
we could we would be him he is unique he
is singular he is one
he's which means that nobody can compare
nobody can even comprehend what he is so
the foundation of
Foundations the core of all wisdom and
living a life of wisdom is to accept is
to believe is to know that Hashem is the
first cause of all that exists I I can't
exactly explain it I can't really
unpackage that fully that's okay you
don't have to you just have to know that
we don't exist randomly or by chance
there may or may not have been a big
bang if there was a big bang it doesn't
conflict with our belief system see Dr
Jo Schroeder's books but whether there
was a big bang or no big bang There was
a cause to that big bang the Big Bang
did not erupt spontaneously abruptly out
of nowhere our belief is that if we
Trace things all the way back there's a
m there's a first cause this is not a
uniquely Jewish argument saying thas
ainus I still remember a little bit from
that intro to philosophy class I but
with Rabbi Walter
wsbg wonderful man Rabbi scholar so
there's a first cause and uh for all
that
exists okay
continuing so just like the foundation
of life you could be blinding groping
through life and feel you're a victim of
chance and not understand why anything
happens or you could live a life of
purpose and meaning and confidence that
even that which is difficult and and and
you don't welcome but it's reassuring
and it's and it's comforting to know
that it wasn't an accident that
everything happens so just like it's the
foundation of life it's the foundation
of Torah and serving
hasem the beginning of everything is to
know that there's Hashem in
general and to know that hasem has that
Hashem has dominion over the entire
world nobody can not even our president
elect can overpower the almighty nobody
can change his decision right hashem's
decisions are his decision we weren't
having class during Hurricane Matthew
which barash passed us by and we still
ding for those who were negatively
affected by it
but it's an amazing thing to me the
gamar says in the beginning of Tinus
that that Hashem gives the keys to all
the world and he says go conquer my
world he created Adam and Eve he put
them in the garden and he said go I've
given you knowledge and wisdom and
curiosity inquisitiveness go conquer the
world go invent GPS systems and cell
phones and Tesla cars and rocket ships
and go to the moon go go conquer the
world the gamar says that when God gave
us that key those keys originally he
held on to three
and what were the three he didn't give
us he didn't give us the key to
fertility he didn't give us the key to
weather to rain and he didn't give us
the key to the ability to bring the dead
back to life in essence the common
denominator of all three it's really one
he didn't give us the key to life so you
go speak to um speak to an IVF
specialist and they'll tell you that
they're become experts in mixing the
ingredients but whether the dish
actually takes or not
it they can't predict my next neighbor
Dr MOSI runs a fertility lab and he will
tell you that he sometimes in in the
course of a day he'll mix the sperm and
the Egg he'll create that zyga the
blastos he'll he'll wait a few days to
see how how it uh develops and you know
he'll do two couples at the same time
and one look like the most unhealthy
pre-embryos there's not a chance but
this couple spend $330,000 and they
don't have more eggs to harvest and it
is what it is so you do what you can do
do and you implant them and you hope for
the best but they look like they don't
have a shot there's nothing symmetrical
or healthy or or optimistic about them
and the other they've got eight
pre-embryos that look gorgeous
magnificent you know they are the valid
Victorian of their High School class
already so really there your challeng is
which one should we put in how many
should we put in because they're all so
amazing and beautiful and he'll tell you
that so many times the ones that look
like they don't have a Fighting Chance
produce the healthiest most beautiful
children and the ones that looked
perfect unfortunately don't yield a
successful pregnancy and he who spends
his entire life in that laboratory will
tell you that in the end of the day he
throws his hands up and he says he mixes
the ingredients tries to put him in the
oven but whether it comes out is up to
I'm sorry to describe it in those terms
but whether it comes out or not is
entirely up to Hashem so that's
fertility but the one that was so
striking to me with Matthew is we live
in this age where we can do anything
it's unbelievable what we can control
and manipulate and predict and yet and
yet A hurricane's coming and they have
no clue where it's going to hit when
it's going to hit how big it'll be how
fast those winds will turn and even more
they can't make it go away can't you
like blow up a bomb and redirect it
can't you like create a big fan a Super
Fan can't we with all of our technology
there's nothing we can do so we have all
the technology in the world and we're
still all hunkering down down and buying
flashlights and generators and hurricane
proof and shutters because when it's
when the Reon when Nature sends that
that wind your way there's nothing you
can
do we've not been able to overcome death
death is the great equalizer it doesn't
matter how much money you have how much
Fame you have how smart you are when
illness or death come your way there's
nothing we can do to overcome them so
Hashem gave us the keys to his world but
he held on to those three and we can try
to wrestle them away from him but we're
unsuccessful and look at our generation
who have who have made such progress in
technology in every area but the weather
weather men are they're just they're
just guessing they have no idea so
that's what the is saying that the
foundation of life is to realize
that he's the master of the
universe he created the whole world the
heavens and the
Earth so the foundation of life is to
understand that there is a creator of
the UN I and there is accountability to
him there is a creator of the universe
we have a relationship with him and we
have accountability to him just like it
would be absurd for a child to say when
they reach a certain age you know what I
don't believe you're my parents I think
I came into existence through
spontaneous generation I have no
relationship with you and I have no
accountability to you and I owe you
nothing you'd look at that child and
you'd say you're a you're a
you did not come into being
spontaneously you wouldn't be here
without them and you wouldn't be here
without their nurturing and loving and
caring you in your infancy and you
absolutely should have a relationship
with them but whether or not you choose
a relationship with them there's an
accountability to the decisions you make
towards them and that's the same thing
with us you can say I came into being
spontaneously I have there is no Creator
there is no God and I have no
relationship with him you can choose to
say that that doesn't make it
true says
the
says this is the gate to the righteous
come that this verse that we say
in that verse in Hal is talking about
the the character trait
ofun by the way notice I just called it
the character trait of amuna which we've
talked about previously also many think
that amuna is a philosophy when do you
talk about faith in philosophy 101 in
that I learned it's philosophy but Amun
is not philosophy
Amon is a character trait I can be
patient or impatient I can be quick to
anger slow to anger I can be jealous and
envious or I can be happy with what I
have and I can live life with faith or I
could live life in denial that there is
a God and moon is not a philosophical
leap amuna is a character trait the same
way that we work on our other character
traits we work on
Amun and what makes one righteous person
greater than another what determines the
levels of righteousness is the level of
Amun it's not how many BL you learned or
how much you did how much sta you gave
it's not how manyas you observe but it's
how much you feel and see and sense
Hashem in your life and you are
committed to
him thei Prophet says a righteous
person live
through his amuna what makes the person
righteous what gives them the energy and
the power and the happiness of life
living life with amuna I've seen rich
people who are miserable and I've seen
poor people who are the happiest gol
lucky I've ever seen I'll never forget I
was walking home with je somebody who
doesn't live here anymore I was once
walking home with jeel with somebody
with tattered clothing and I happen to
know that they struggle with real
poverty and they needed the community
support and help and the way there was a
a skip in his walk and talking to his
kids he was telling about the par and
these stories about sadik and just seems
so happy and every time he talk to him
he's just so happy and life is so great
and you want to say you hold up a mirror
like life is so great you got a lot of
challenges buddy do you not realize them
and then you have other people with
wealth and all the money in the world
and time and and they're just so unhappy
and miserable
so it's understanding that there is a
higher being things are not random
what one has what they need what are our
to calibrate our priorities and our
values and our how we measure happiness
all of it comes through is the core of
everything another p in M says that the
righteous person falls seven times but
they get up
so the in Proverbs contrast the
righteous person can fall seven times
they get up no problem the wicked person
falls one time Koo it's a knockout
they're out for the count they can't get
off the mat what's the difference
between them saysi the righteous person
is driven by a sense of amuna there's
Hashem he believes in me I believe in
him I have a I have a mission to
accomplish in this world so you know
what yeah I got knocked down I fell down
I gave into that Temptation I gave into
that urge I looked at or ate or said or
did that which I know better from and I
shouldn't have done but you know what I
can get up because Hashem gives me the
power and the strength if he believes in
me I believe in me and I have a mission
to accomplish so I can do it so when you
know that you have the best manager in
your corner when you have the best
audience Spectators rooting you on when
you have the best trainer who you
believe has given you everything you
need to win you can keep getting off off
the mat no matter how many times you're
knocked down but if you're all alone in
that corner you have no manager you have
no trainer and you have no one rooting
for you and you don't believe in
yourself you get knocked down once
you're done you're out for the count so
the is describing theim the righteous
person can get knocked down seven times
the wicked one time and they're out and
what's the difference between them is a
sense of amuna amuna is empowering it
gives you strength gives you confidence
gives you courage gives you faith it
gives you all these tools which are
necessary to endure the sometimes hard
situations that life throws your way or
the self-imposed mistakes that we all
make and fail prey to if we believe in
ourselves and we know Hashem believes in
us then we have the ability to keep
getting
up we're in the second
paragraph great rabbis May their memory
be a blessing say
this is going to be stay with me here a
little bit but here we come with some
cabalistic view but he says amuna gives
us the capacity to transcend nature
nature dictates certain things will
happen but if you live with amuna you
have the strength and the power and you
can invoke from that can transcend
nature
this great Reb used to be able to create
all kinds of Wonders and
miracles when he would employ his sense
of amuna in his heart and he would tap
into the depths and the profundity of
that amuna he was able to transcend and
supersede certain natural limitations
and at times when he would feel that the
person that he was offer who came to him
for a and he was trying to help that
they didn't have that level
of he would recite the over and over and
over with that person I forgot which
rean I forgot the story so I'm going to
butcher both but what's the story maybe
the STI someone came to the STi for br
they were in the hardest situation and I
forgot how the stier manipulated the
conversation but basically said I can't
give you AA only you can DAV and the
person no no no but I understand that
you have to give me a I came to you they
said that my child will only get better
if you get and he explained have you
davened I can't give you a br have you
no no no forget my daving yeah I DAV I
DAV i d forget that but I understand
that your BR is the only thing that I
please you with desperation and the ster
was trying I think it was theer the bat
was the balat two weeks in Tanya chap
26 just I sorry just cuz you learn all
day long and all day
so Styer Bal both neither but the the
idea was the idea was that how often how
often do even do we how often do we
think I have to do the schoola I have to
put the key in Thea wear the red Bendle
do the thing I have to get a br I have
to send my name in I have to give the I
have to take that shortcut i d yeah yeah
maybe I D maybe I don't D I talk during
ding I leave ding I come ding late d
yeah yeah but did I do that shortcut did
I do that did I do that uh often
counterfeit and um superstitious roote
so even and we have a tradition about we
don't minimize the says
that don't minimize even the BR of a
simple person somebody gives you a br
they're invoking blessing from hem don't
me don't don't reject it even the BR of
a very simple person of a child
is a very powerful force so we don't at
all minimize or reject braah but the BR
can't begin to compare or compete with
the power everyone of us has inside us
to turn to Hashem with a sense of
desperation whatever that desperation
you have for that one Doctor Who's the M
who could take care of you or your child
whatever that desperation to get into
that re or that g or that to get the
well that you could have if you just
close your eyes in sh or out of Sho take
your three steps back and three steps
forward or don't even open a sitter just
talk to hasem from your heart but when
we tap into that when we show Hashem
that unbelievable faith that unbridled
faith in that moment that the
desperation ultimately is directed
towards him then incredible things can
happen and and yes he's writing this
from a perspective but this is what the
rambam writes the rambam says
that God's Providence God's influence in
our lives is is directly proportional to
our belief in him or put differently if
you don't think God exists and you think
that all that dictates the world are the
rules of nature so God says no problem
let me pull back all yours The Rules of
Nature let's see how now you're a
statistic now you're a piece of data now
it's Randomness now let's see and when
you say God I could care less about the
data and I could care less about the
statistics but I believe in you and I
don't care what they're telling me and I
don't care what my chances are not that
we should ever not be realistic and so
on I'm not endorsing giving people false
hope should never ever give people false
hope but when when a person says Hashem
despite I'm realistically looking at the
data and statistics but despite that I'm
holding out hope and the knowledge that
you you can do everything so then the
ram says that the God's intervening in
nature suspending the rules of nature to
intervene in our life is directly
related it's proportional to the amount
of
that we show in
him is synonymous with Redemption why
were we liberated from Egypt because we
believed finally at first we didn't when
mosha first came down they say they they
couldn't hear
him they couldn't hear him what are you
talking about this a God is going to
take us out are you kidding this is the
only reality we know we don't know any
differently leave us alone but after
Hashem showed his hand inim and they
could no longer deny it they were ready
to take that leap of amuna and it was in
the Merit of finally recognizing there's
a Creator there's a first cause there's
a being he's involved in our lives he
craves a relationship he loves us we
love him we have
accountability finally accepting all
that is what merited that Redemption and
it's only when we feel that again that
will Merit the future Redemption
this ability to overcome the natural
order the
brisk from Wu's Uncle used to say that
uh he had it's a skoa but it's not a
schoola what was the schoola that if
you're ever in a difficult circumstance
if you're ever worried you should just
repeat the phrase over and over
again there is nothing nothing but him
there is no one but him and he tells the
story actually that running away from
the beginning of the Nazis anti-semites
and he was on a train and they came on
the train they thought he was going to
they were going to confront him knowing
who he was and he was going to be
persecuted and he just sat there and
closed his eyes and said over and over
and over and over no now again were
there people who had unbelievable amuna
who were murdered by the Nazis in the
Holocaust yes likely millions of them do
I mean to suggest that there's a direct
correlation that if you have the amuna
then you have no infertility and no
cancer and no marital problems and no
health problems and no antisemitism I'm
not suggesting that whatsoever
whatsoever however whatever does come
our way we have the toolkit to handle it
and hopefully to overcome it and if not
at least to be able to endure it when we
employ amuna so the bris said it's not
it's not a schoola in the sense that
it's something sticky
feel it's a prayer that expression that
phrase when you're really worried when
something's not going to go right ain't
it's really just actually an exercise in
mindfulness we spoke about in shabua is
that when your mind begins to race and
go in a million directions about now I'm
late and what if the plane doesn't take
off and what have to delayed and this
traffic is going to destroy me and I'm
waiting to get back to the biopsy what's
going to be with that so your mind races
in a gazillion and 10 different
directions and because it does and it's
way ahead of you it comes to every
conclusion there is out there what it
means for your marriage what it means
for your children what it means for your
health what it means for your parnasa
what it means for the state of Israel
what it means for the future of America
what it means for right if you allow
your mind to race you can come to what
was that Mark Twain quote I have
endured a million horrible things in my
life just none of them ever happened wow
it's an amazing uh it's not that wasn't
exactly the quote but I've endured I've
endured countless horrific things in my
life just none of them ever happened
it's a great quote so how do you
how do we come back to neutral how do
you Center your mind how do you come
back to a place of of equilibrium so the
brisar rav's advice is when your mind
races
a just keep repeating that Mantra it's
really a it's a meditation it's a
mindfulness meditation exercise you're
worried about the result you're worried
about the traffic you're worried about
the flight delay you're worried about
the pera you're worried about
the you keep coming back to you know
what I have to do the best I can I have
to do everything in my power but beyond
that
a there is nothing but him it's great
put it on your dashboard of your car and
put it on your kitchen and put on your
nightstand and put in the mirror in your
bathroom
a just keep coming back to that I do the
best I can I do everything that's in my
power and after that there is nothing
but him it is all
him we should make up cards or stickers
to give out very nice it's so
yeah and even within amuna is even if a
person doesn't have amuna with Clarity
and this is a very important Point that
he's making here that I want to make you
could come to these classes and have
the incorrect perception you know
Goldberg is giving all these talks about
amuna wow he must have unbelievable
amuna he lives with pure Faith
everything's perfect he sees hm all the
time so first of all I give all these
classes cuz I'm working on amuna and the
best way to work on amuna is to be
mindful of amuna the best way to be
mindful of amuna is to keep talking
about amuna but I want to make something
very clear
everyone almost everyone everyone
certainly I have moments of doubt they
people are not honest with you if they
tell you that every minute of every
single day there's nothing but Hashem
everything's pure Faith everything's all
good everyone has moments of saying
really why Hashem if you're there why
would you do this are you there I'm
looking for you I don't feel you I want
to feel you I want to connect with you
I'm looking for you and I want to
understand you and I'm protesting
against you so everyone goes through
their ups and downs in fact it's this
week's para in this week's para AB has
the a Hashem says to him take your son
your only son your precious son it's not
his only son but it's the only son from
that wife it's not the only son he loves
it's a beautiful Rashi it
says take your son
okay so he knows which one says which
son he says says your only son he says I
have two only Sons one's my only one
from AAR one's my only one from
s the one you love this is the beautiful
part AR says I love both hasem says fine
it's that's the you read that Rashi you
read Rashi and you could feel hashem's
exasperation like okay you're not like
you know who I'm talking about you have
to play this game for me take your son I
have two sons
the only son I love them
both there's a lot to talk about next
week's para when a dies and yesal comes
to the funeral yesal has been expelled
from the house he's been exiled he's
been rejected how does he show up at the
funeral it has a lot to do with this AER
because he knew as far away as he was
from his father that AER that his father
never stopped loving him but that's a
whole other discussion so God tells a
take that son that I promis through whom
you will build a Legacy and and
transform the world you know that son
that was going to build your family and
make you a name and the stars and the
sand and all that stuff remember that
son i' like you to take a knife and slit
his throat that's a test I'd say that's
a big
test and um why would Hashem give him
that test I I'd like to believe I I I uh
follow the commentaries who say God
never intended it but God gave that test
for a very simple reason A's intuition
was to do was he was a person of loving
kindness he was pred disposed he had an
intuition and instinct to love love love
love love love three talking to God you
there we spoke about the par yesterday
you're interrupted by three strangers
who come up and you tell God could you
wait a few minutes I got to take care of
these strangers you just love everybody
you love everybody love love love is
what pushed a so God says how do I know
that aam is really serving me with that
love maybe he loves because he's just a
lover that's who he is he's a lover he's
a child of the 60s he's a lover how do I
know that the love is really because
he's directing towards the service of me
so hasem says you know how I'm going to
test him I'm going to ask him to do
something that's the opposite of love
and let's see whether he really does it
all for me or does it all because that's
his Instinct if he's willing to and able
to do even that which comes unnaturally
it means that which comes naturally is
also for me so Hashem says take your son
and and slid his thrat Hashem never
meant it I wasn't going to fall through
on it but he wanted to know whether aam
was willing to say yes and when hasem
says jump he says how high even when
it's and that's why when the Mal says
stop he says now I
know that you have y I always knew you
had AA a I always knew you were a lover
but I didn't know if you had a I didn't
know if you were able to do this yakov's
intuition what's yakov's character
trait Tain
msov Yakov is all about truth honesty
truth he can't tell a lie no matter
matter what Hashem says it's wonderful
that you have this Instinct and
intuition towards truth how do I know
it's directed to me how will I know
there only one way I'd like you to dress
up like your brother and go lie to your
father let's see let's see so we all
have we're all predisposed with certain
intuition and Instinct and to direct
that towards Hashem is somewhat easy but
can we also do that which comes
unnaturally that which is uncomfortable
that's the test that each of the of us
went through and um and that's what what
revealed to Hashem what was what was
really happening so why am I telling you
all this let's come back so hasem says
to AB take your son go to the top of the
mountain do what you got to do and it
says on the third day ab arrives what
happened during those three days text
leaves it out what happened during those
three days so the medish fills in and
the med tells us that aam encountered
all these phenomena that tried to
convince him don't go through with this
what are you crazy so he tried to cross
the river and the river went high high
high up to his neck and he had to weade
his way through it and he tried to cross
the mountain and he tried to this and he
encountered that person and the medish
describes each of these things that try
to block his way
and
shalom in her in her Parish has a
beautiful explanation of this medish and
she describes that the medish is not
talking about natural phenomena the
river didn't come alive and talk to AB
the medes is really talking about all
these things that happened in aam's head
that every step of the way aam had these
thoughts that were haunting him that
said don't do this Hashem loves you he
would never want you to really do this
and he made that promise to you he can't
really want this and every step he took
he started doubting doubt plagued him
for three days and he had to overcome
the doubt each step till
finally finally it was the third day and
he put one foot in front of the other
and he arrived and aam becomes a edent
for us of being able to live with doubt
we don't encourage doubt we don't
introduce doubt we
don't dwell on the doubt but we allow
for doubt to to believe in hem amuna
this class to be successful doesn't mean
well it's only successful if we have
unbridled unquestioned amuna 247 365 the
rest of our life we hear news we endure
challenges we experience pain and it's
only natural that little doubts creep in
our own or we hear of others and little
doubt Creeps in that's okay aam had
those doubts creep in and aam put one
foot in front of the other until he Ares
struggling with the doubt is actually
what yields greater Faith there's room
for doubt in faith I actually think that
a faith that has no doubt in some ways
is a fake
faith if you live this life in this
world with what this world throws at you
and you've never had a moment of doubt
I'm not sure sure how authentic your
faith
is a faith which never had
doubt could be a very superficial lip
Service counterfeit Faith again we're
not searching for doubt or introducing
doubt or let's sit around skeptically
talking about all the reasons not to
believe in Hashem right we're not
introducing doubt but a doubt that a
faith that never had doubt I'm not sure
about there we have a concept called
amuna I'm not talking about that right
now but a sophisticated a sophisticated
amuna has also o had confrontations or
tension with doubt and that's what the
Reb is saying here theb is
saying you're not yet at a point of a
pure
clear unquestioned
Faith you're looking you're searching
you're asking you're curious
he's going to continue with this what
theb says
is you've arrived at Faith by struggling
with faith in other words the
destination is not one of pure Faith the
destination is searching to live with
faith so you could be the skeptic and
the cynic who sees everything in your
life as the excuse and the argument the
evidence that there's no Hashem or you
could be the Searcher who's looking
around through life every day for all of
the evidence that there is a
Hashem the goal is not necessarily or
not necessarily achievable to get to a
point of absolutely there's Hashem
there's no doubt there's no questions
there's no anything that's very very
difficult that's very very challenging
that's not necessarily the goal the goal
is to be struggling with faith to be
engaged in the struggle to be Liv living
with that tension to be a Searcher to be
looking to be interpreting the world
through the prism of amuna how do I make
sense of what has happened what does
this reveal about Hashem about his
greatness about his will how can I do
all of that okay we're going to stop
here we'll pick it up I think next week
I'm going to a wedding next Wednesday
flying in the morning so I don't think
we're having class but the week after
hasem we'll uh we'll pick it up question
yes questions you want your questions
recorded or not recorded I don't care
okay
question uh you mentioned about finding
comfort in auna in spite of difficult
situations
yes even though you don't question your
amuna how do you find the
Comfort I'll tell you what I meant by
that I I've I've lived a very blessed
life very very blessed life ple in Hara
one of the hardest things I went through
is when
um when in between my second and third
children my wife had a still birth dur
that was a boy but anyway it was a very
hard time and and living through that in
retrospect we're blessed seven healthy
amazing beautiful kids and it's nothing
compared to the hardship and challenges
that people go through I'm only sharing
it because it was it brought this to
light for me I vividly remember going
through that that
the only thing that gave me Comfort and
strength was the confidence that this
wasn't random it wasn't a fluke that
this was somehow directed from Hashem
what was the reason what was the cause
everyone tries to offer their comforting
things where was the Comfort the Comfort
was that I'm not saying if you go
through pain for no reason at all random
it's random that's that that just
compounds your pain vitim but if you say
I'm going through pain but there is
there's a greater reason this pain is
going to lead to the birth of something
greater I may see it I may never see it
I may understand it I may never
understand it but I know that pain is
never random and pain is never without a
reason then I know that every moment of
pain I can endure because it's going to
lead to a greater pleasure a greater a
greater reason so I don't know people
who are going through truly hard times
if you don't believe in God I don't know
how you get through it so God forbid
someone's diagnosed with something
terrible able so what they're supposed
to find comfort and Courage by saying
well I'm a statistic x% of the
population get this illness and I'm one
of those x% and x% will get better and I
may or may not be one of those x% that
get better and x% get the side effects
and I may or not be one of those x% and
you know what there's no meaning there's
no order there's no there's no meaning
to my pain I'm just suffering because
I'm a random statistic I don't know how
that person finds the strength to go
whereas if someone says I hate this pain
I object to this pain God I'm protesting
you're giving me or someone I love this
pain I will do everything in my power to
relieve this pain and to get rid of this
pain but if in the end of the day
there's pain there's a there's a reason
it's not a fluke that pain is going to
give birth to something better greater
there's reason there's order that's what
I meant by
that that s someone else had question
and
comment okay everyone have a great day