Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Parsha Perspectives (5782, Mikeitz-Chanuka) - Is Beauty Vain or Valuable?
1,671 views
The Torah and its messages are timeless. Join me as we draw from the weekly Torah portion to extract lessons and inspiration for today from a wide and diverse range of sources and personalities. For more content, visit http://www.rabbiefremgoldberg.org. - Introduction - Why Do We Read Mikeitz During Chanuka (Izhbitz)? - Exile, Rest, and Vanity - Beauty and Vanity - Yosef and the Walking Dead (R. Chaim Volkin) - Yosef's Commitment to Truth (Alter of Kelm) - Yosef Led His Life with Integrity (R. Yerucham) - How Could Yosef Have Forgotten Everything? (R. Yisrael Salanter) - How Did Yosef Make Himself Into a Stranger? (R. Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev)
Chapters
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
good morning and afraid of hanukkah
it's wonderful to see everybody welcome
back great to be in person
great to continue to be in person
i want to thank our generous partner
sherry's serious sponsors for the year
becky and navi cats and family in memory
of becky's father david grossman
should have an aliyah
also uh sponsored by rifki schreiber in
memory of her father aaron benitsek a
very special person nashoma should have
and aliyah as well through our learning
and this year sponsored this morning by
miriam fox
in honor
of faye eisenberg's 90th birthday
where's fay
happy birthday
i have good news for you faye they say
the first 90 years are the hardest
so
it's going to be smooth sailing please
god from here
should be healthy happy
together with mari the two of you
big big mazel to have a very very happy
birthday
90.
unbelievable
amazing okay let's get started today is
hanukkah as you know the second day of
hanukkah a very important and auspicious
day of its own right second day of
chanukah and it is also parshas
meekhates parshas meekatz where's
hamilton he told me the shabbos will be
the 80th anniversary of his bar mitzvah
such milestones can i hurricane yearboo
for more and more people
so let's uh let's get started why do we
repurchase
in
even before we dive into the parish
itself let's begin with some chanukah
connections the best of the ishbits
of ishbits
says
we always read me
because both of them have a similar
story line they have the same illusion
commercial
at the end of last week's passion when
we last left off our suspenseful story
it seemed like all hope was lost yaakov
and yosef rather had been abandoned by
his brothers sold into slavery left to
die ignored and dismissed that yosef had
been utterly rejected his story was over
yaakov
and it seemed like it was all over the
brothers went to go tell their father
they thought this was the end of the
story they thought they had found
closure they thought they had finally
gotten rid of this great agitator named
yo safe their brother but yaakov was
inconsolable and yet it didn't seem like
it was closed
fast forward spoiler alert if you're not
up to next week's pasha i don't want to
ruin the story for you but yehudah next
week's pasha stands up for his brother
and in so doing repairs the damage done
when they had abandoned yosef benjamin
the only other brother to share a mother
and a father now they do not leave
binyama to die and therefore yosef
realizes they've learned their ways and
the story has a wonderful and a happy
ending
similarly when it came to the holiday of
hanukkah it seemed like all hope was
lost all the oil was defied defiled all
of the people were outnumbered we had no
chance
that we know that
oil oil is a symbol can you put it in
the iron in the back just leave it in
the arm on the back
okay so come on in everybody stand up
so it seemed like all hope was lost that
the shaman
okay so let's put annoying come on
it seemed like all hope was lost that
the shaman was defiled was tommy there
was nowhere else uh no other tame no
other shaman to use shemen oil is a
symbol of is a symbol of clause from the
jewish people hashemin is the same
letters of the shama of soul and we know
that just like oil just like olive
rather when you crush it what comes out
is more precious than the olive the
island itself does not have a great
value the olive creates shikha the olive
creates forgetfulness the olive creates
forgetfulness whereas the oil creates
remembering because what comes out of
the olive on its crust is more precious
than the olive itself the same is true
with the jewish people when we are
crushed when they try to squeeze us what
comes out what we learn about ourselves
is even more precious is easy more
valuable so we thought all the oil had
been defiled we thought all hope was
lost we thought militarily that we
didn't have a shot that the jewish
people were going to be eliminated so
says the ishbits the besance it's the
same storyline partials meekats and the
story of hanukkah a jew is never broken
the jew never gives up a jew never feels
all hope is lost yes
the moment that you give up hope the
moment that you give up your optimism
your positive attitude and faith
then shalom does it means you've lost
your mind when a jews of right mind then
they believe beyond all hope they
believe beyond all reason because the
jew never gives up okay that is all
number one the israelites are the
connection between precious medicates
and hanukkah the same storyline when it
seems like all hope is lost there is a
rising to greatness yo save all hope has
lost soul dismissed left to die turns
out he's the viceroy of egypt saves his
entire family's lives reconciliation and
reunion similarly olive was lost there's
no more oil all of it was lost we lost
dominion we lost the sovereignty of our
land and the next thing you know we are
back in charge all hope is not left as
has been pointed out by many people you
got to love the anti-zionist
anti-semitic
elected leaders wishing jews a happy
hanukkah who are totally uh ignorant of
the fact that hanukkah reflects the
jewish presence in israel for thousands
of years and our being liberated from
the occupiers of our land from thousands
of years ago so it's a beautiful thing
when illinois tulap and the others wish
jews a happy hanukkah acknowledging our
presence in the land for thousands of
years and that they were foreign
occupiers to us and we were liberated
and i guess we should say yes thank you
for that those good wishes we agree
totally another connection between
chanukah and
will delve into the parsha itself
and then we'll delve into the partial
itself and it's based on apostolic not
in precious medicates it's based on
apostate in all places in precious years
pastor compassion
we know that a very difficult a very
hard life you have suffered maybe more
than any other person and he did so with
faith and the posix says
i was not at ease neither was i quiet i
did not rest and yet vayavaroga's
trouble came trouble came this is a
pussican an eeyove that describes a fate
and a state of being relentless
suffering a state of relentless
suffering says you have all i wanted was
peace of mind all i wanted was peace and
quiet all i wanted was just one day no
drama no drama however
i was not able to achieve no drama all i
had was drama the metro shop at the
beginning of our partial describes that
each statement references a lack of rest
and tranquility
that is describing not only eov but it
goes all the way back to yakov avinu we
know in last week's pasha vaishaviakov
of leicester
we mentioned last week that yaakov who
had been through so much drama so many
ups and downs in his life so much pain
and suffering so much conflict and
tension all yakkawa was peace and quiet
can i have one day no question no
complaining no conflict no doctor's
appointments no doctors visits no
waiting rooms can i just have one day
one day of peace and quiet and yaakov
couldn't have it hashem said you want
you want shava that's not what this
world is for this is the factory floor
there are no recliners there are no
rocking chairs on the factory floor this
is the place we come to work we come to
grow we come to advance we come to make
progress so mrama says that sentiment
that sense that yaakov also bk
the yakov wanted peace and quiet that is
another interpretation of the
possibilities
is describing the life the ambition but
the failed wishes of yaakov
yaakov didn't recover from the trauma
with asav he endured the lying in the
seat of his uncle lavan then he suffered
with his daughter deena getting
kidnapped finally when she was returned
he has to deal with the disappearance of
yosef bk shack of leicester bashava but
he didn't get checked he didn't get
shava he didn't get manuka he didn't get
it all but there's another another
madrish
not here in save abrasions nor on iov
there's another medicine shmoos that
references the same pulsak as describing
this lack of rest but not about yaakov
and not about eof
just like yaakov could not fight quiet
in tranquility so to his children
so too we the jewish people have spent
our history plagued by exiles and by
enemies who oppress
and who pursue and who persecute and who
torture and who try to exterminate this
could be a description not only of eu of
the individual or not only of yaakov the
individual is this not a description of
the state of the jewish people is this
not capturing all of jewish history lo
salafi la shakata volo nachti wherever
we went whenever we went we started a
great new tuesday night series began
last week rebecca sola gave a
out of the park talk
on the rambam and the amahads you can
listen online to it it's also streamed
live mascots is picking it up next
tuesday and then i am the tuesday after
that and it's called the rabbis on the
run it's all about rabbinic scholarship
while fleeing for their lives some of
our greatest rapper you know we have
peace and quiet and we have peace of
mind and we have high speed wi-fi we
have outsourch
and we can't produce anything and some
of these great rabbis on the run
persecuted all they had was a quill and
a piece of parchment all they had was a
pen and ink no library no laptop no
backup copy and they produced the rambam
it's mishna torah the rush runs from
france to spain so we have an entire
series on tuesday nights called rabbis
on the run all the way through the mir
in shanghai and all the way until modern
times about total learning torah
scholarship that was studied that was
produced while fleeing for their lives
maybe the name of the series should be
los alamos
that all anyone wanted was peace and
quiet give me a basement just give me a
library give me a study give me a room
that i could just sit and learn and
write but nobody gets it so this is
really a description of all the jewish
people and that's what the magistrates
ready
under babylonia
we had no tranquility when we were
oppressed by persia
lo shakati we had no quiet we were
subjugated by greece
we had no peace
we had no rest and as we continue to
experience this gullis the fourth and
final gulas that we are still in today
we find trouble by elbow rogez
the exile of yavan of greece
is what we redeem from with the miracle
of chanukah it's a very interesting fact
about hanukkah it's called a gullus we
also have a message at the beginning of
pasha's braces bharatai sasov
darkness is the darkness of of yavan of
the syrian greeks the hellenists who
oppressed us in the land of israel isn't
it interesting that it's called golos
even though where did the story happen
in israel you could be in a state of
godless even when geographically we are
blessed with the modern miracle of the
state of israel it's a modern miracle we
have to value it to say thank you for it
we have to praise hashem for say halal
for it but we can be in gullah even when
geographically we've already begin we've
begun to fill the asghar to the
we have the beginning of the redemption
and that we're back in the land but it's
still called galas and hadina is still
called galas because look at yavan look
at the story of hanukkah hanukkah is
gullah
even though it took place in the land of
israel
meanwhile
so
the one that we're celebrating today
hanukkah
yavan is characterized as what yavan is
characterized as
the lo
nakhti
the maccabees defeated the syrian greeks
and the evannam and reinstated jewish
sovereignty jewish land over the land of
israel yavan's goal was not to
annihilate us they assaulted us
spiritually that's why there's no
mitzvah of suda and hanukkah
unlike purim where there's a mishta and
suda you have a big festive meal and you
give
gifts of food and drink to one's
neighbor and the thing centers around a
physical celebration chanukah country
distinction is not a physical
celebration it is a spiritual it's halal
of the hoda there's no obligation of a
meal and chanukah why because pura
mahashvarish wanted to physically
annihilate exterminate eliminate the
jewish people hanukkah they wanted to do
something different in some ways worse
they welcomed us to assimilate and to
integrate and to shed all of our values
and all of our ideals and to become one
of them they assaulted us spiritually
they tried to get us to assimilate
ancient greece what was it they wanted
us to assimilate to
ancient greece worshiped beauty
and form they introduced the world to
the idea of the olympics a competition
of perfecting the human body
they worshipped external superficial
beauty the aesthetic their culture was
the ultimate
in vanity they emphasized the external
the appearance the superficial the
surface jewish people began to
assimilate we were invited to assimilate
that was the gullus we were being
influenced and we likewise began to
place disproportionate focus on beauty
and attractiveness so therefore the
measure says
because you know what happens
you know what happens when you're
constantly pursuing vanity and beauty
and you're trying to keep up
we are in the capital of the united
states of america palm beach county of
being in denial of our age
denial of our age
i've had people say to me rabbi
you should get hair plugs you could
still have a full head of hair
color your hair you look uh fully gray
i'm not that old i'm not as old as i
look but i say what's the point
what's the point vanity this is the what
the rebona swarm did so yes there are
opportunities and gifts today cosmetic
surgery and botox and cosmetics and all
kinds of treatments people go through
and i'm not criticizing i'm not
analyzing halal it is a halachic
discussion volunteering or elective
surgery and there are opportunities
their gift to coach barclays give us
instruments and tools beautiful
wonderful take advantage feel good about
yourself however you know what happens
when you live a life of vanity when a
person lives a life that they're
consumed by how they appear in the
mirror and they appear to others and
their happiness and their satisfaction
and their peace of mind only comes when
they think that they meet the
expectations and the beauty of others
that they're trying to freeze time and
look the way they did
30 and 40 and 50 and 60 years ago then
you know what happens
you can never find rest you'll never be
at peace you're always trying to look
younger and younger more and more
beautiful to reverse aging and reverse
time and when you're consumed and when
you're stuck in that mentality and that
attitude
velonaki you can't turn back time you
can't turn back time
velonakti if you want a peace of mind
and rest then be beautiful put oneself
together be attractive without being
attracting but at the end of the day be
grateful that you're alive and grateful
to look that age and grateful for all
that comes with the wisdom and the
family and all that a person has
achieved because otherwise
otherwise a person simply has no peace
of mind they have no peace of mind you
know there were studies that showed that
last year i wrote about it there was an
enormous spike in cosmetic surgery and
botox treatments you know why
because people spent an entire year
looking into zoom
so when you have the luxury you look in
the mirror for a minute in the morning
and then you don't see yourself the rest
of the day you don't feel bad about how
you look
but when we were quarantined and locked
down then distance when the other only
way to study was to be on zoom that's
why everyone turned their cameras off
they were sick and tired of how they
looked what about us what luxury do we
have we rabbis who have to look right in
the camera and still see ourselves
it's a miracle we haven't broken any
cameras yet so velonachti so because
people spent the only way you weren't
with people you were on facetime and
face time there's another screen you see
yourself so people couldn't see
themselves they couldn't be happy
if a person can't be happy
what could you do what could you do not
everybody could be like faye at 90 look
like 30. you know
can i nah
kenai nahara but if you look like that
you don't look like if you look like 90
not 30 like so you look like 90 whoever
knew a 90 year old when you were growing
up you look like 90 walk around with a
badge of honor and pride i'm 90. should
look 90. can i know about hashem you
look 90.
otherwise you're robbed when you care
too much about how you look and when you
are so consumed and trying to chase
something that's fleeting and running
away from you because age is not
something that you can stop then you're
robbed of manuka san nefesh there's no
serenity there's no peace of mind
there's no happiness when we are
consumed by yavana
then the majority tells us
happiness is the result of contentment
serenity flows from a sense of
satisfaction and when you're never
satisfied you're never content you're
trying to chase something that's
fleeting an elusive
you can't have any peace of mind we
recovered our sense of manuka our
capacity for contentment when we
defeated yavan when we defeated the
worship of beauty but that's not the end
of the story we celebrate the defeat of
these values and yet our rabbis embrace
those same values
so i don't understand which is it
is beauty vain
we sing on friday night beauty is vain
is beauty vain or is beauty valuable
which is it the magician the mission in
megillah the end of the first power
quotes from shimon gamlio he said the
greek is the only other language other
than hebrew that you're allowed to write
a sacred torah in
you could use the oceans of hebrew you
could write in in hebrew
script or you could use greek and why
are you allowed to use greek to write a
safer term it's a kosher sacred written
in greek why
say hazaao because of its beauty
so beautiful since it's so beautiful we
embrace it we can use it moreover yavan
the greek empire is the result of noah's
barakah to his son no had a son
you have to look him the ephesus may
ephesus boundaries be extended
so yavin the descendants of jeffers
extend their boundary and their empire
and their namesake is characterized by
yoffi yaft ello kim leefest yeah yofi is
beauty
so is beauty vain
or is beauty valuable
i'll throw in a third question
this very holiday we're in right now
hanukkah
in which we celebrate the defeat of the
culture that was consumed by the pursuit
of beauty
is the holiday that is most associated
with the concept of hidden mitzvah
nobody in this room lights one candle
every night nobody you fulfill the
mitzvah light one candle each night good
nook shine you're done
i don't know what you alive the most
assimilated secular unaffiliated jew who
keeps hanukkah still knows that they
light a candle consistent with what
knight and nobody lights one candle
every night when we light more than one
candle every night what are we
fulfilling the mitzvah of
hidden mitzvah what is hidder
to beautify the mitzvah what
the very holiday that we defeated those
who are consumed by the pursuit of
beauty
we more than any other holiday
have a concept of hidden mitzvah have a
concept of beautifying the mitzvah not
only do we have mahadrin
we have a third level of
mahadra mina mahadran don't just
beautify your menorah has botox your
menorah has cosmetic surgery your
menorah has liposuction your menorah has
the menorah as every mahadra mahadra
mina mahadran our menorah gets every
treatment possible is using every cream
every everything possible so which is it
is beauty vein is beauty valuable what's
the answer so the answer because i want
to get into the parsha the answer is
that we both value beauty and form
but for completely different reasons
than the greeks the greeks worshiped
beauty as it ends unto itself for the
greeks yofi beauty the aesthetic the
superficial the surface
was and ends on its own right they saw
it as totally independent value onto its
own self
we also embrace value and form we see it
as important but only as a means
only as a vehicle to transform the
mundane to connect with our creator to
represent ourselves with dignity and
with class to be royalty the children of
the almighty we appreciate beauty as one
of the creations of hashem and just like
we have all kinds of disciplines in
order to connect with hashem we connect
with him through math and science we
connect with him through the natural
world we connect with him of course
through the sacred torah his diary and
we connect with him through beauty it's
one of the disciplines of the world so
we don't worship it on its own right
it's a means towards connecting with
hashem and that is the fundamental
difference between us and the greeks
not a coincidence the greeks said you're
not allowed to do brasmila or get into
hashem among the three things the greeks
outlawed was bris mila circumcision
because for them the beauty should never
be violated the body should never be
violated the body is beautiful the
body's a sculpture the body is an ends
unto itself the olympics we compete to
have the most perfect body what are you
doing cutting off a piece of the body
but for us the body is not in an ends
the body is a means to elevate the soul
the body is a cli it's a vessel that
houses the neshama for them beauty is
the goal for us beauty is the bridge
that joins the sacred and the profane it
is the channel between holiness and
mundane sacrifice the great shemi shmuel
explains that to truly appreciate noah's
blessing to a sanyefus you can't just
quote hafta pasak yaft elokim liefus
to expand the boundaries of beauty
how does the past again says to
when is beauty important when it dwells
in the tent of shame shame is
spirituality
yeshiva shame
yeshiva we are the progeny of shame we
are the spiritual
legacy inheritance ambassadors of shame
there's a place for beauty you have to
look in the ephesus but the yephs the
beauty of the yofi has to be ishmael
shame this be part of a greater ambition
of shame the greater goal of connecting
to hashem and so this holiday of
chanukah
seems contradictory it seems paradoxical
but it's not we reject beauty on the on
the one hand when beauty is the ends
when the
when the pursuit of beauty in the
pursuit of the superficial and the
surface when the pursuit of vanity
paralyzes us and it robs us of our
happiness
and our serenity
when we use beauty they have a more
beautiful kiddush cup a more beautiful
shabbos table more beautiful yantaf
table more beautiful menorah more
beautiful little vanessa more beautiful
filling when we embrace beauty not as an
ends but as the means to help uplift and
enrich and elevate our spirituality then
that's something that we that we accept
torah tells us that yosef
acted as a na'r
an adolescent he was immature he was
immature and unsophisticated what was it
about him that made him immature and
unsophisticated
what did he do he played video games all
day what made him so immature
he couldn't get out of bed he was late
to school and dominion sarah she says
you know what made yosef immature
he was a naar because he was consumed by
looking in the mirror and fixing his
hair
he was consumed by beautifying his
appearance and drawing attention to his
attractiveness
that's the act of an unsophisticated
immature person a child is consumed by
how they look an adult does the best
with what they have and then they get on
with their day
an adult does the best with what they've
been given and then they say i want my
spirituality to shine i want my soul to
shine i want personality to shine i want
the difference i make in this world to
shine
that's the that's the most important
that's the most important so that is
this holiday when we constantly have to
keep up with the latest styles and
fashions and feds when we whittle away
our savings and go into debt in the
pursuit of vanity then lonati
zugales
one of the lessons one of the messages
of hanukkah that we celebrate is to
defeat the voice of yavan within
ourselves the voice of yavan again
embrace the tools the instruments
embrace the treatments embrace what's
available i'm not sitting in judgment
and i'm not telling you that it's wrong
but i'm telling us that it has to have a
context
do not let it rob you of your serenity
your peace of mind and your happiness
you know you're allowed to light the
chanukah candles
from shikiya we light from sunset
and how long if you don't light at
sunset how long do you have to light the
candles umar says
until people are no longer walking
around in the marketplace there have to
be people who see the lit candles in
order to achieve the goal of persimenisa
in order to achieve the goal of
publicizing the miracle if no one sees
it you haven't publicized the miracle
people have to be walking around so we
shared as fast as in the in my article
last week this facade says
we'll come back to it this morning as
well but i want to tell you about
mushroom sauce of her the hilaga sausage
says
what's the shook
the shook is the market
the shook is the place that you're
buying more beauty products you're
buying more fashion clothing
regular shook you know how long you have
to light the menorah light the menorah
regal
don't go to town center mall for
hanukkah don't go to neiman marcus or
nordstrom's for hanukkah disconnect from
amazon
prime for hanukkah
for eight days
for eight days i don't need more things
i don't need the latest clothing i don't
need the latest treatment i don't need
the latest for eight days have some
manuka
do not suffer the goddess of yavan of
vilonati
regel min
let's avoid the shook for the eight days
of chanaka and find the manuka sadness
that we crave and not be a na'r like
yosef was a na'ar who was so consumed
only and exclusively by his appearance
okay let's start the parasha class page
in the earthquake
the privilege of reading parshas
meekhates
was the end of two years to the day para
was dreaming and in his dream he was
standing over the river para was
dreaming and the first dream places him
standing over the banks of a river two
years what was it two years from
so the major spacious rabbit tells us
hashem created an end to the darkness of
yosef's life he said you're going to be
in prison you're going to be
incarcerated for two years when the two
years to the day came up then hashem
said it's time for power to dream
because you're out of there like
vladimir it's time for you to be able to
be liberated from prison from
incarceration why did he spend two years
in prison by the way
why didn't he get out earlier so we know
because at the end of last week's pasha
when he reminds us
please remind paro about me he should
not have relied so heavily on a human
being and because he used two words
because at the end of last pasha he used
two words to remind him
that uh to request of him that he would
remember because the double language
that he used he spent two extra years
two years in prison had he not done so
how many years in prison would he have
spent
so most people assume the answer is none
zero but that's not correct yeah point
out why
he had to say it once
so in other words sorry if he had asked
once
please remember when you get out would
have spent one year in prison or zero
he would have spent zero why wouldn't he
be accountable for saying it once
because you have to do your
establish we spoke about that the
ramban's introduction to the partial
couple weeks ago was the balance between
amuna and establish faith and effort we
have to put in our effort so yosef had
to do his advocacy he had to do his
effort but there's such a thing as
excessive effort when you put in too
much effort then you lack faith in
hashem you've got excessive faith and
too little effort excessive effort and
too little faith like the three bears
you've got to find just the right amount
so the measure says this was to the day
this was to the day
two years that hashem said you're going
to spend two years incarcerated in
prison we'll let you out after two years
some parabola to have his dream now the
matrix is somewhat confusing
why do we associate
yosef being liberated with prison
two years to the day when he was
incarcerated it's not true
it was two years to the day that
paraguay's dream
the power's dream was not the day that
he was let out
why does the major characterize that
once paro had his dream hashem had ended
the darkness
hashem had ended the servitude when
power dreamt where was yosef
he was in prison
so what do you mean paro's dream
represents the end of yosef's
imprisonment in the middle of power's
dream while he schluft in his
he definitely had cotton sheets he had
egyptian cotton no
for sure he had egyptian cotton i don't
know how many what do they call that
how many threads pyro had however many
threads he had that's how many threads
he had i don't know what kind of pillow
he had
we'll leave that out whether he bought
his pillow late at night on television
ads i don't know what kind of pillow but
he definitely egyptian cotton so power
was fast to sleep in his bed having
multiple dreams and where's yosef
there's no egyptian cotton in prison so
what do you mean kate sam
while he was still in prison
vulcan
and he says something very fascinating
he says something very
i find
inspiring very uplifting
kimoshimatsu adam shanahan
when a rabbinical court has sentenced a
person's death when a person violated a
capital crime and they're due to suffer
capital punishment they have a status of
a gavra katila a gavra katila means
they're walking dead they're already
dead
so much so that's an interesting halal
question
if you murder somebody who's on death
row have you actually murdered
if you walk up to a corpse
this is a deeply disturbing
thing to do
you're deeply disturbed person but if
you take out a gun and shoot a corpse
take out a knife and stab a corpse
are you liable for murder
no you kill someone or something who's
dead you haven't committed an act of
murder so what if you murder somebody
who has been sentenced for capital
punishment
is an act of murder halal
so the gemara has a language gavra
katila that once a person has been nixar
once a person has been established that
they're going to be put to death they're
adam harug they're the walking dead
they're a corpse they happen to have a
heartbeat but they're already a corpse
they're really corpse so what do you see
you see that once something is destined
to be happened to happen
it already has the status as if it
already happened even earlier
but the moment something is concluded
it's going to happen
is when it really began to happen
we saw this last week
was it in parish or a municipal i don't
remember but we said that who was born
in padan aram said he wasn't born in
padan around he was born after no but
that's where rahul davon for him since
that's where she davened that's where
it's as if he was the idea of him was
born there so the beginning of his being
born already was there benjamin was
already there similarly here when a
person is sentenced to death they're
already dead even though they haven't
yet gotten the chair they're already
dead even though they haven't been put
to death so says
and the same thing here is true
who says paul's dream is the catalyst
that's going to begin the process of
yosef's liberation from prison so even
though he's still in prison while para
was sleeping dreaming and his catnip
egyptian sheets still
that's already the beginning of his
freedom that's the beginning of his
freedom what we see from here is the
same is true with us when we set our
mind and when we become determined and
when we
conclude that we're going to be or do
something it's as if it's already done
it's as if we still have to do it
doesn't mean you're off the hook of
doing it but when we really set our mind
to something when we've concluded
something we become determined to do
something it's already done jose was
already out of prison when power was
dreaming what do you mean he's out of
prison power stream he's sitting in
prison
check the surveillance camera he's
sitting in prison the answer is since
para's dream was the catalyst of his
getting out kilo he was already out even
when he was still there so you see how
rewarding it can be how enriching it is
how motivating it is
that just being determined to do
something carries us a very very long
way the word for will in hebrew is
ratson ratson is our will it's what we
want
rats on the root of the word rats rats
is to run just like i get from point a
to point b faster when i run the
stronger my will
the more determined i am
then the more likely i am to conclude
what i pledge what i promise to get from
point a to point b okay moving right
along
so paralyze these dreams we're not going
to focus on them we have in previous
years and as always i encourage you you
can listen to the previous years partial
shirum online to uh review what we did
not cover today
so he asked these two he has these two
dreams peric my mouth possible
so what happens para brings in
they're unsuccessful nobody's able to
accurately interpret the dream to power
satisfaction we talked about last year
or two years ago or three years ago
what was power dissatisfied with and
what did you say do in his
interpretation that none of them had
done
and what right did joseph have to do it
we talked about that previously sao
paulo is dissatisfied with their
interpretation yosef
they go retrieve them from the pit
shave in a haircut change your clothing
they bring them to paro para says
i had a dream and nobody could interpret
it
you know what i heard about you
i heard a rumor about you
tishmachalom tishma
toroto that you're able to hear a dream
and then come back with a legitimate
accurate authentic interpretation
is that true so they pulled this guy out
of prison they put him in front of paro
para says
para is the the egyptian empire at the
time is the strongest empire in the
world power is the most powerful man on
the globe on earth
this individual yosef who had been
rejected dejected despised by his family
left in a pit sold into slavery falsely
accused languishing in prison has a big
moment now to shine this is it and
what's his moment paro says to him i
heard about you i heard about you i
heard about you that you can interpret
dreams well and what is jose van
servaian yosef so
if you're yosef what do you answer right
now
yeah thank god i i listen i'm not
showing off not flexing
but it's true i'm a pretty good dream
interpreter
i have a lot of other faults but when it
comes to interpreting dreams
i can compete with the best of them how
can i help you i'm here to serve master
i'm here to serve paro i'm here to serve
your honor i'm here to serve mr
president mr prime minister mr ruler of
the world i'm here yeah it's true pretty
good i have that gift what can i do what
is your safe answer instead
excuse me
about
lyan yosef is paralympia
billah died
he says what you heard you heard that i
interred with dreams
nah
villa die it's not me
hello kim
all of a sudden he's running a discovery
seminar all of a sudden yosef is playing
the chabad playbook all of a sudden he's
opening a new khabar house all of a
sudden the karma's house loving
prayer he's been languishing in prison
he's been languishing in prison
hopeless helpless despondent no future
no opening nothing
finally gets his chance
para says i heard about you
i may need you the ruler of the world
most powerful man on earth
nah
bill i die it's not me i don't know what
you're talking about i'm not good at
this says the author of kelm his paolo
satsuma possible
bill adai torah is teaching us
everything about our character
everything about who we're meant to be
everything about how we're meant to
behave
yosef is kicked out of his family home
is 17 years old who mush labor is thrown
into the pit with snakes and scorpions
he's sold to the arab merchants they
sell him to potiphar he rises there for
10 years in his home now he thinks
10 years he's the cfo
of potiphar he's the cfo of a fortune
500 company he's the number two in the
company
he's got options he's a bill who nymphs
are based of chipotle
and what happens after
10 years the rhizoc he gets falsely
accused he's thrown into prison loses it
all has to declare bankruptcy
every headline he's smeared his image is
ruined he's sitting two years
languishing in prison the petta mages
look at malcolm sitting there one day i
don't know what he's doing in prison
he's he's benching he's lifting weights
he's playing basketball in the field
he's reading in the library i don't know
what jose is doing in prison
and all of a sudden someone comes in and
says you young man
come
shave haircut here's a change of
clothing
we're going to the oval office
going to the oval office
he comes into the palace
you see the impact of yosef's education
you see if you were to stop and think if
you were to be calculating in that
moment he never could have answered this
way he would have done what was best for
him
but he was so ingrained that so
instinctively so intuitively so
naturally did you save answer yosef was
so committed to truth
yosef was so educated and conditioned to
be humble and modest
really if you were calculating he would
have said
my entire best chance of being saved is
by saying it's me but he doesn't he says
bill a die i don't know what you're
talking about it's not me it's god
any clue i'm just an instrument i'm just
a vehicle for god i've had good luck
i've been able to interpret dreams but
you know
again just to give you a metaphor for
this
could you imagine that somebody's
sold from their family in a pit rises to
greatness then falsely accused
languishing in prison is brought to the
king and the king says i need surgery
and i heard you're the best surgeon
there is
i understand that you have 100 success
rate with your surgery my understanding
is that you're the best surgeon there is
ah i'm not such a good surgeon
i don't know what you're talking about i
don't know what you've heard
the truth is i have a hand that god
directs my hand and so far he's directed
it well
are you out of your mind
are you crazy risking it all this is
your shot this is your chance that one
word bill adai that one word bella die
but sometimes in that moment of truth we
have the opportunity to define our
entire lives
will he be humble will he be modest and
will he be true
he tells the story ryokan beloved tells
the story about a baker a new young man
who enters the yeshiva and one day in
shiri asks abom kasha he asked gevaldega
a great question on the rebbe rebbe
gives sheer and he raises his hand and
he has abandoned over there but is over
there and the whole students everybody
else all of his colleagues wow this new
young man this question
he's an eloy
awesome wow what a super genius and then
he says i i saw the question for biki
baker mcveigher asked the question
everyone says ah
everything we thought about him it just
turns out it's
her
it's just a ricky heger
so that boy is tempted to say was my
question it's my kasha but it's a moment
of truth for humility for honesty for
authenticity
it's a moment of truth and that's what
yosef ingrained with us in this one word
wow what a powerful message
that one word in the unknown translation
of it
in that one word it says so much
my mouth
so para repeats the dreams yosef
interprets them he interprets them to
power satisfaction and para says vayomar
para joseph on page 228 reyna santiago
arts mitzrayim i'm placing you on all of
eric smith's time
perique my mouth sorry possible keep
going i'm putting you in charge of all
of egypt
yosef he takes his ring off and he puts
it on yosef's hand
he dresses him in
royalty
he calls him a new name he calls him
he says
avreh
which really is bracha you're the source
of bracha you are a source of blessing
to me and to this country when a son saw
a quality when he places him over all of
you
and now he says to him
and without you no one can raise their
hand over all of egypt amparo and over
without you nobody could raise their
hand over all of egypt ani para
yosef goes from 17 years old
he's a shepherd
by the way last week remember when i
talked about shepard
nobody's kid comes home and says i gave
up medical school law school i'm not
taking the accounting exam i'm going to
be a shepherd
i got an email a couple hours after the
parshas year from somebody whose child
was poised to go i think to medical
school but decided first they wanted to
know the experience so they went to
israel they spent a month shepherding
they attached two pictures of their son
with a house cat with a flock of sheep
behind him shepherding the flock
so you never know what you say and you
never know what you're going to find out
and what you're going to learn
i want to take a month off i could use a
month with some sheep
just sheep
sheep don't talk back until sheep learn
how to write an email or a text message
a critical uh
i could use a few days with some sheep
anyway so yosef is the shepherd yosef's
hanging out in the field with some sheep
next thing you know 17 he's in a pit he
figures out how to run pouty far's home
next thing you know he's prison next
thing you know
he is
the secretary of
the treasury
the next thing he's in charge of the
entire economy not just of egypt but
it's the strongest economy of the world
and many commentators want to know
now again this is a question that was
asked previously
after we've lived through what we've
lived through and seen in our time you
don't have to have a competency
expertise experience
you don't have to have risen through the
ranks
to be appointed
the top in the land but leave that
editorial commentary aside
previously before anyone knew that or
saw that to be a fact they wondered how
is it that yosef who has no experience
he's no experience and now he's running
the entire country how could it be
police
says he didn't go to college he didn't
have an undergrad he didn't go to
graduate school
how did he do it how did he do it
till 17 he's learning in his father's
basement
then he's a shepherd in the field
then he's running potiphar's modest
house and then he's been in prison
what in his resume made him qualified to
run the entire egypt
mormon unqualified but moreover what
gave him the confidence to run the
entire egypt
says
the answer is yosef led his entire life
with integrity
yosef was careful and cautious his
entire life to be honest to have
integrity to never cheat to never cut
corners to never rationalize to never
justify malos
issues
and more important than any other
qualification you could have a million
initials after your name and before your
name you could have gone to countless
graduate schools you could have worked
and served in countless positions
countless companies but if you're not
honest and you don't have integrity
if you don't have the core character
then you're not going to be good and you
can have the core character traits you
could have honesty and integrity
fidelity to truth
and then even without the other training
you'll be able to rise to the occasion
so essentially says review
the question was jose wasn't trained for
this what on yosef resume made him
eligible or qualified or confident to do
it and the answer is
only all of yosef's life
everything about yosef's life his
attitude to punctuality into time his
attitude to charity and to giving how he
kept his financial books and his own his
own money his attitude towards la
shanhara's integrity his honesty his
relationship with others how he led his
entire life made him in fact qualified
and appropriate back my mouth possible
we're flying through the partial like
we've never done before
next page page 230. what happens joseph
has two kids
yosef has two children born him by his
wife osnas
his wife asanas and it was osnoff's
parents by the way
we mention this every year potiphara
familiar name
who's his mother-in-law
who's a swigger
uncomfortable pesach sider
uncomfortable thanksgiving dinner
i think so
okay i don't see a lot of people address
that but it's a fascinating development
in the story anyway so he has two
children
yosef names his eldest child menasha
is why god has made me forget all my
hardship and all my father's household
the name of the second is the frame that
has made me fruitful in the land of my
suffering how could yousef say that he
forgot everything about his childhood
he names his first son menasha kinase
grateful to hashem he's caused me to
forget all of my hardship and kobesavi
here i am far removed haven't seen my
brothers my father
thank god i'm over them thank god i
don't remember them thank god they're
not part of my consciousness or my
active memory and i named my son menasha
that thank god i've been able to forget
them.
you know what he forgot
this is an unbelievable insight of a
visceral salat
he says we human beings are given a gift
it's called selective memory
selective memory is an unbelievable gift
we don't have to remember and hold on to
all the hurt and the pain and the injury
we can choose to employ selective memory
we can choose to focus only on the
positive and to have nostalgia for the
good and to let go of that which hurt or
that which harmed
that's nashani
it seems to me that if you name your son
thank you for letting me forget
then you probably haven't forgotten
every time to use his name nanasha
he said
i forgot everything about my childhood
and my upbringing come for dinner
i forgot everything about my brothers
and my father did you do your homework
yet
every time he called them menasha he was
invoking menasha kinasani
so it says if you saw solanto he didn't
forget who would want to forget who
could ever forget
i as a rabbi do a lot of funerals
and the hardest funerals are for people
who held out to reunite with a mother or
a father or a sibling who passed away
and that person passed away without
their having reconciled
because no matter how much a person says
that they had given up that they had
moved on that they had had closure that
they had become comfortable with the
fact that they were not in touch
we're not designed to ever be okay
not having contact with a mother or a
father or a sibling
maybe on the surface maybe years of
therapy and thousands of dollars of
therapy and lots of botox treatments
maybe we convince ourselves that we're
okay with the fact that we're no longer
in touch with the mother the father the
sibling
however inside somewhere deep inside
we're still holding out we're still
longing and it's terribly terribly
traumatically painful when that person
dies
and now the individual realizes it can't
ever happen it can't ever happen
so when yosef
says menasha kinashani elokim i named my
son that i forgot
you don't name your son i forgot if you
forgot you don't even think about it to
name your son that you forgot if you
forgot you're not thinking about it and
so you don't name your son imagine that
prince speech
go safe
as you're chomping down on the bagels
and locks in egypt you'll say tell us
why you named him menasha
grabs the microphone at the bris
well let me tell you about my childhood
and why i named him menasha i named him
i named him thank you hashem for letting
me forget you'll notice
here in egypt you'll notice that i i
don't have any family here for the bris
you might have noticed
i've never had family visit me yet
well let me tell you
ah i forgot about them and i named my
son i forgot about them
that's not at all what's going on to the
restaurant yosef is modeling for us
selective memory
selective memory we have the capacity to
focus not on the hurt the harm the pain
that's not to say that we shouldn't try
to reckon reconcile and work it out
we shouldn't bury it or suppress it and
pretend it's not there we should try to
work it out
but do we want to hold ourselves back do
we want to become paralyzed and
debilitated by the thoughts and the
feelings of the hurt
or can hashem
you hashem thank you for selective
memory
thank you for the gift of selective
memory you know who else practiced
selective memory
hashem
in the navi
when he says
oh i remember our journey through the
mid bar
you remember how amazing it was you
never complained and you never clutched
and you were so grateful to me and we
were so in love on our trek and our
trail through the desert you remember
how beautiful it was
and you'll read the nothing you say what
did i read the same say for about midbar
as hashem
you remember how amazing it was what are
you talking about
the answer is hashem practice selective
memory and he has a perfect impeccable
memory
yet he chooses
to use selective memory we often have
the opposite we have the inverse problem
psychologists actually talk about this
we don't remember the good we only
remember the penny we practice selective
memory in the wrong direction
so at a ratio of five to one someone's
been good to us been there for us been
kind to us been loyal to us showed up
for us but one time they heard us and
all we remember is the one time and
we've utterly purged we've utterly
forgotten we've otherwise utterly
deleted all the good they've done at a
ratio of a hundred to one but all we
remember is the one hurt the one remark
the one
the one failure to get back to an email
that's what we hold on to
that's what we hold we have the inverse
selective memory but yosef
he names him
and he teaches us how we can use
selective memory in the positive
sees his brothers
fast forward paragraph
zion
sorry
there's a famine in the land the only
way the brothers will survive they go
down to egypt and they have to go find
the
they have to go to the secretary of the
economy and wait in line excuse me in
order to qualify for their food
or save the brothers of yours
let's keep reading a little bit more
they come and they bow down by our yosef
yosef sees his brothers and wow
can you imagine the adrenaline rush
what went through his mind
he's been away for all these years
thinks he's abandoned forgotten will
never be reunited or reconciled he has
these dreams in the back of his mind but
there's nothing about his life that
indicates that they're going to come
true and all of a sudden he's online
giving out coupons giving out food
giving out welfare giving out whatever
he's given out and all of a sudden
online
vayaki reim
now he sees people familiar all of a
sudden he sees his brothers i don't care
how old you are i don't care if you've
read this 90 times which would be
impressive because it would mean you
read it when you were
a few months old but
it's still the most exciting narrative
in the top no
it doesn't matter how many times and how
much you know how it ends it's still
devaldic to read every year vaisnakara
by da beritam kashos so what happens he
recognizes them but he acted like a
stranger vaisnak
he acted like a stranger towards them
and he spoke very harshly with them
and he says where are you from
he recognizes them which we just saw a
minute ago why are we repeating it
and despite his talking to them they
don't recognize somebody from
i forget where maybe israel
the beauty of technology and i count
myself so lucky to live in this time in
this place not only to get to study with
you every week or in person but so
privileged that people around the world
were able to listen together and they
whatsapp an email text great questions
that make you think so someone asked me
last week yosef looks in the mirror
sees the image the most know of aviv of
his father and that's what gave him the
fortitude and the courage the conviction
not to in fact give in to the seduction
racist positive he looked so much like
his father that when he saw himself in
the mirror
he saw the image of his father if he
looked so much like his father this
individual asked me why didn't his
brothers recognize
why didn't his brothers recognize him so
i answered i don't know i didn't look it
up i didn't see whether anyone talks
about it but the simple answer to me
would be because when he was in
potiphar's home he still had not risen
to the position of viceroy maybe in the
position of viceroy maybe there's some
garb
that you wear
maybe there's something about your
appearance which is different
maybe he hadn't like me gotten the hair
plugs or colored his beard and so he
looked different they didn't recognize
hey mohikiruhu it could also be i didn't
see anyone talk about this
it could be and this would make sense
that the brothers were so consumed by
their hunger pangs
that they didn't even notice anything
else
right in front of them was their brother
who maybe yosef was recognizable but
that doesn't mean that they had ahead of
the
the headspace to recognize him remember
said last week recorded some stuff for
last week if yosef saw the image of his
father and that kept him from sinning
why didn't the brothers see the image of
their father and keep them from sinning
and remember what we answered
when a person is filled with anger or
rage
their judgment is clouded their vision
is blurry they can't even see what's
right in front of them so similarly here
when a person is
is is hungry struggling with a famine
when a person is in a pandemic and
they've turned inward they're suffering
a plague and they're only thinking about
themselves they can't even see what's
right in front of them and blumenthal
shared with me i forgot who was injured
last week remember they throw them in
the pit and they go eat and gaza
critical of them he's suffering and
struggling in the pit with snakes and
scorpions and you're sitting down to all
you can eat buffet the chinese
what is going on over here sarah
blumenthal shared with me a mukkar
we're already out of time where i'd read
it to you inside it's gevaldic
he says don't be critical of the of the
of the brothers there's such a thing
called you ever get hangry
angry is
when you're really hungry so you have no
patience with someone you snap at them
you're quick to them
you're not yourself because you're angry
hungry angry you're angry the brothers
thought
let's maybe we're just hangry
let's have lunch and revisit this what
we do with him they ate lunch and they
still decided he's got to go but they
knew it wasn't coming from a position of
being hangry
so maybe here they're hungry again
maybe here they come down to mitraim
they're there because of famine they're
suffering they're struggling they had
the long journey the long
trip
and maybe they maybe yosef taka was
recognizable but they were so consumed
with themselves that they didn't bother
to recognize him so
the ikiru
and then
this is so sad i had so many more things
to tell you but we're going to have to
end off here says
what is the torah telling us when it
says he made himself into a stranger to
them
how do you understand or interpret why
yosef would make himself look like a
stranger
why would he conceal himself
wouldn't he want to reveal himself we
want to say hey it's mediocre
so the easy answer is they tried to kill
him once maybe they'll try to kill him
again but that's not a good answer why
he's much more powerful than they
he's got an army
you think joseph's giving out food
without marines standing on both sides
of him
with that secret service devoted to him
jose is much more powerful he's not
afraid of his life that can't be the
reason
why doesn't he reveal himself
you have to imagine he's been longing
and desperate according to cilantro he's
practiced selective memory he barely
even remembers what they did to him he
only longs to be reunited with them this
is the one who last week
all he wants is to be with his brothers
why why is not cara leia why in the
world would he make himself into a
stranger
okay we'll end here
just joking i'll tell you the answer
tell the answer of the conditional
slaves there are many answers but this
is what obliviously
says
he says this is evidence of the
righteousness and the greatness of yosef
yosef
yosev
yosef remembered
his dreams that's the next possible very
next puzzle
is vaisgor
he remembers his dreams
and in his dreams what happens the
brothers bow down to him
and his brothers had a bit
he had this dream and his brother said
that will never come true yosef said
this is my dream it's from hashem i
guarantee it's going to come true they
said you want to bet and i don't know if
they did a pinky promise or i don't know
exactly how they did this bet or what
they bet for but they had this enormous
bet they had this enormous
competitiveness and yosef realizes in
this moment
that he won the bet
the brothers are here and they're bowing
down because they need food they're
hungry and what happens when you told
someone that they've lost the debt
when they're willing to bet their life
savings they're willing to bet their
mother's life their fathers they willing
to bet everything that's how sure they
are
when a person realizes they lost a vet
that they were certain they would win
it's devastating
it's devastating and yosef wanted to
spare his brothers that pain that
devastation
is
if they realize the one who they were
bowing down to was in fact yosef it
would have been very difficult very
painful for them
so again
i would say this is also a continuation
of the altar of kalam's insight
you think jose stopped and said who who
has the who has the
mindset to stop and say hmm it's my
brothers all these years should i reveal
myself
if you had to stop and think about it he
could never hold back from revealing
himself it's only because his instinct
he had been conditioned he had been
taught he had been raised by parents who
taught him
to try to spare the pain of others so in
that moment instinctively intuitively in
super speed he realizes
my dream is coming true and if i tell
them right now while they're starving
while they're famished if i tell them
right now as they're bowing down that in
fact i won i was right
that's going to be unbearably painful i
could never cause pain not only to
anyone else but certainly not to my
brothers
and that's also why he went so far
so concerned with he was sparing the
pain of his brothers that he did not not
only did he not reveal himself even
though that meant that cost him telling
because you know what happened
let's play this out
yosef says to the brothers hey guys i
won nana nakishkish i won
in the bat
here i am i rose to greatness you're
bowing down to me you rely on me for
food and guess what go tell dad who won
you know what is going to do he's going
to say i also won
i was right to give him the colored coat
i was right to favor him i was right to
buy into his dreams when no one else did
and all it's going to do is create
further division
for the divisiveness further tension
further conflict
he understood that his father made a
mistake
to spoil him to begin with and he
understood that he had contributed to
that divisiveness to begin with and
remember all he wants is
all he wants is to be at peace and
reunited and fit in and belong
so at great great enormous personal pain
because it means he's still not reunited
with his father
but at great personal pain he's patient
and he says i need to wait for the right
time in the right way in the right place
and i'll reveal myself and will
reconcile and reunite them but if i do
it now
if i do it in this way in this time and
this place
it'll only divide it'll cause pain to
them it'll cause my father to react the
wrong way and therefore vais not care
and therefore he has the presence of
mind
to not reveal himself to make himself a
stranger to them
all
an expression of his greatness and his
righteousness to spare them unnecessary
pain i'm in pain because there was a lot
more to talk about
but we did say some nice ideas about
hanukkah wishing everybody a free look
at
a very happy birthday
30 more times to read pastures me cats i
hope you're ready to go
all right stay happy stay healthy stay
holy everybody