Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Failing to Plan is Planning to Fail (Part 1): Wills and Estates in Jewish Law
472 views
The first part in a series for the Boca Raton Synagogue (BRS) men's afternoon kollel. For more content, visit http://www.rabbiefremgoldberg.org.
Categories:Torah/Halacha
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good afternoon
and welcome back to the boca raton
synagogue men's afternoon colonel of the
doctor yet balazan
base madrish as always tremendous
gratitude to
the frolic family and the frog financial
group for sponsoring the afternoon cola
four afternoons a week
and i'm very excited to start a new
series and a new topic this week
motivated and inspired by what we spoke
about last week last week we talked
about
mitzvah kind of amazed the obligation
and responsibility
to fulfill the interest the will the
last will of a person on their deathbed
and whether that only applies to
monetary issues that applies to other
interests
that they express other things that they
care about and an obligation to
to follow through and to listen to them
so that was our topic last week which
motivates the launch of a new series
we're going to do on
jewish law the laches of estate planning
many of you maybe most of you have done
your estate planning your wills
and your testament but those who haven't
need to know that there are significant
and major
halachic considerations when it comes to
will and testament
it's not enough to go to a secular
lawyer well versed in the secular law
but jewish law has much to say about the
issue of
our last will the title of this series
is failing to plan is planning to fail
if you fail to plan if you've not been
thoughtful
and considerate if you've not
articulated your will if you've not
included the
considerations if you're not planning if
you're not if you're failing to plan
then you are planning to fail so we're
going to view the review of the halache
considerations
today will probably be just an
introduction to the entire subject some
of the things to think about
when preparing and i want to point out
as we begin
that we're not talking about living will
a halachic living will which is also
critically important
talks about what a person wants at the
end of their life
not after their death but really in the
transition from this world to the next
a person in end of life issues there are
critical end of life issues that can
come up
and there are a lot of living wills
there's a living will
in which you give power of attorney to
people to make a decision when you're
incapacitated
when you are unable to make those
decisions from a conscious
perspective but there are also halal
considerations in that
if a person is on dialysis must they
continue persons getting
pressers for for their blood pressure
must they continue
antibiotic for an infection must they
continue are you allowed to allow
something to run out does it need to be
reinitiated
dnr do not resuscitate dni do not
intubate
there are countless countless questions
that can come up
in end of life issues in fact my brother
rabbi dr judah goldberg just published a
really important article
in tradition the rca journal
that has a follow-up article by rafter
by willig
that endorses his perspective he's my
brother's an emergency room physician
and an extraordinary talmud and he
combines the two for this article
which has the endorsement in writing of
rav shakhtar and rabbi willig
following his article it's in the latest
edition of tradition i believe it's
available online now it's unlocked you
can access
you can access the articles well worth
reading but that's a totally separate
subject
the question of halachic living will
is a totally separate subject a very
important subject but not our topic for
today
our topic for today is the classic not
living will not what you want at the end
of your life
but a will what you want after your life
when you're no longer in this world your
possessions your ass
assets your real estate your jewelry
your leichter your kiddush cup your
megillah
the dishes that your parents smuggled
out of europe where do you want it to go
who do you want to have it how do you
want them to divide it
that is our discussion and failing to
plan
is planning to fail all that is number
one
before we even get to that question
we're going to look at and we are
streaming on several uh platforms
simultaneously so we're going to try to
do this and see if this works we are
looking at the gesher
chain source number one gesher to
kaczynski
it's a great rav of you shalom last
century and in gesher
which primarily deals with the end of
life issues
tahara shiva and the like he writes the
following
call ben adam hayodesh yesh mata
banav any individual who knows that
there is a
meaningful mission that is a goal and
mandate to his life in the children's
life
how much time is spent with lawyers and
estate planners
how much time is spent trying to figure
out how to operate of course within the
law
but to transfer as much wealth as
possible to the next generation without
having to share it with
uncle sam how much time how much
emotional energy
how much thoughtfulness how much
strategy is invested in those questions
and yet
people deal exclusively with the realm
of the material of the financial
of assets and they failed to talk about
tachle
the essence of life kinamer by vino
arishon as it says with
our great patriarch with the very first
jew the first ivory at least
hashem the torah hashem when hashem
comes to abram and he says
i must disclose to you what i'm going to
do to stone
i must be transparent with you what i'm
going to do to stone and why do i feel
obligated
why can i not withhold that information
why do i love you
and why do i cherish you hashem himself
testifies
because i know the manashitsava is bonov
you're leaving eight salva now avram had
many assets he was a very wealthy man
undoubtedly he had a team of wealth
managers estate managers
to help him plan but that's not why god
loved him god didn't love him because he
figured out how to move the most wealth
to the next generation
without having to pay taxes god loves
him because he's moving the greatest
virtue and righteousness the greatest
love of torah and mitzvos love of hashem
a life of faith
hashem he teaches them how to observe
the hashem now the rambam by the way
when he quotes this passage he says what
is that derek hashem
avraham is successful in leaving atsavah
what we call an
ethical will he doesn't only determine
where the things
should go he tells the next generation
here are my hopes and my dreams and my
aspirations
here's what my life was about and what i
sacrificed for and i hope you will
embrace the same thing
what is that derek hashem basham rusev
says that is the famous villas the
golden mean
to live a moderate life a normal life
that whose avram was and that's what he
passed on to the next generation
and the gesher chaim continues that
hashem loved avraham because avram took
the time to not only
articulate where he wanted the things to
go but to tell the next generation
what he expected and what he dreamt for
them what he wanted what he hoped
and so point number one in this new
series
on planning to failing to plan is
planning to fail
is that not only must one plan how to
leave a
will a will according to halacha which
is what we're going to talk about
but one should leave a sava an ethical
will
among those who did the gra the girl
left an ethical will very famous we have
the letter of the guerra
rivari levine the great sadiq of you
shalom left an ethical will
of oba left an ethical will countless of
our godolum
countless of our great leaders left in
ethical will some that we have access to
in fact it'd make a magnificent work i
don't know if anyone has ever done that
collected the ethical wills
of greats of generations past for us to
read what was important to them
you know we like to lump them in a box
as if they're all the same and assume
that
ah they probably all said the same thing
keep torah keep mitzvos
be a good person but they were different
and their dreams their hopes were
different and they lived in different
places and at different times
and so do we so take that time and don't
only plan
estate planning but do next generation
spiritual planning
how will you transmit how will you
communicate and articulate
hopes dreams and aspirations and whether
you choose to tie that to the assets
is your choice there are trusts that tie
meeting certain criteria in order to
access assets
i'm not a lawyer so the great
disappointment now i'm just joking my
parents i think are proud of me but i'm
not a lawyer
but a lawyer can tell you how to tie the
trust to those conditions
do they have to marry a jew i know a
member of our shul
who has a condition to grandchildren
inheriting that they have to all go on
march of the living
they have to secure their jewish
identity their jewish pride by going in
march of the living you can attach the
conditions within the law that you want
i'm not talking about the conditions for
the assets i'm talking about
communicating
it savvah that word savva will that
we're going to use
which can apply to either monetary or
ethics that word salva is like let's
which is mitzvos a mitzvah is a tsava
and it really means a connection through
mitzvos we have a connection to hashem
throughout what we leave what we
bequeath to the next generation
we remain connected to them but the
greatest connection that we hope
is the ethical one the spiritual one the
one that will last
and the one that will drive them for
generations to come
continues
when you write and you divide your
things to your children
be very careful this is we're going to
unpack and study together
do not include the word yerusha
inheritance
person has to be very careful why
because it's not arbitrary
it's not random and we don't have
autonomy we don't have the right to
simply decide and determine where it
goes
but it's given based on the torah's laws
the torah's principles if we're trying
to circumvent them we have to do it
legally
and there are what one might call legal
loopholes but there are legal mechanisms
that enable us to not simply follow the
dictates
of the torah when it comes to how things
are passed to the next generation
but one of the things to be aware of
says the gesture is don't use the word
yerusha inheritance
in this will use the lash and use the
word matana a gift
or a debt and we'll see these are the
mechanisms we're going to
employ vanish
in torah and so on and so forth skip
down
for example according to according to
the torah's
hierarchy of how our things are left a
spouse doesn't come before children
and within children sons inherit
daughters don't
so assuming one wants to include
daughters assume wants to include a
spouse
then you cannot simply write a will that
includes the word inheritance urushi
but rather you need to structure it
using different mechanisms different
tools different
instruments of transaction so that it's
binding even within allah
and that's what we're going to go
through
says the gesh we've seen many tsavos
many people leave wills that are filled
with errors
that are filled with mistakes chacos of
los angeles
and therefore it's a mistake it's not
structured properly
you can't you can't be casual when it
comes to this
you need to find someone who knows what
they're doing
and there's one time who's very wealthy
says i'm telling a story
who decided that in fact he wouldn't
have a will he would leave it to the
hierarchy
and to the way that torah determines
where it should go so let's say this man
had three sons
the older son got a double portion the
bahrain gets pishnaya a double portion
and the other two sons got simple
portions so you take the inheritance
three sons you divide it in four the
eldest son gets double pushing
and the other two each get a single
portion
and to the daughters they receive
nothing
and what happened pretty predictable
what happened
the daughters you can imagine can only
imagine they get up from shiva
and they shower they change there's a
meeting with the estate lawyer
who's going to unveil the parents last
will and testament
and what was determined by this wealthy
man daughters ah
you're on your own look for somebody
who's got money sons
two of you you get one portion the
oldest ah
my br my choicest you get a double
portion
how do you think that went you can only
imagine the animosity the enmity the
infighting the jealousy the resentment
not only towards one another but towards
the father i wonder what that shlosha
memorial
what that askara looked like what a
terrible thing so much so that the
observers who saw
what it did how it destroyed and ripped
apart the family said
better that the father would have had
nothing and left nothing
because at least he would have had an
intact family
and even the rabbis who saw now you
would have thought i would have thought
that abundant would have heaped praise
on such an individual i might have
thought the rabbanum would say
wow this individual is so loyal so
committed to torah
so following through on the torah i
might have said wow this individual is
so righteous to follow the dictates of
the torah but even the rabbanim
even the rabbanum were critical why
because the ushammi in the beginning of
alma says
that even though we have hierarchy of
how to give the minute
the person has to know the contemporary
relationships
today people are able to write their own
will
in a halachic way it doesn't mean you
can simply have a secular will and it
will supersede
but it means you can have any will that
doesn't follow the hierarchy of the
torah
and yet it's binding
tells us two very important things even
before we begin number one
don't just worry about your assets don't
just worry about your things
don't just worry about material
possessions but worry about as well
worry about leaving a value system worry
about communicating transmitting
articulating dreams and hopes and
aspirations
and whether strategically you want to
tie it to the trust or what you leave
or you simply are going to leave a
document that you want them all to read
and see
then that's something that's important
to read number one and number two
says something to geshek very bold which
is even though the torah tells us
a system in a hierarchy don't follow it
that's not the minogue
you're going to create tremendous
animosity don't think that they go honor
you at the
yeshiva dinner posthumously because you
follow the torah
don't think there's going to be article
biography about you posthumously because
you insisted on following the system of
the torah
in fact the opposite you'll leave a
family in absolute disarray
the pisces which is a wonderful series
of swarm a collection
rosh
talks about the laws of writing a will
and in
source number two he writes the
following
let's say you have your children and
your children meet with you and they say
abba tati dad mom we're good with
whatever you do
we are tamid we ourselves that you're a
shamayim
and therefore if you want to have no
will and simply follow what the torah
dictates
we're good the game is not to worry
that if you don't write a will the law
of the land
may supersede the nearest
so two things number one if you don't
have to worry that civilly
that the land in which you live in the
absence of a will
will substitute its own laws and number
two you're absolutely confident
that the next generation are going to
adhere to whatever the total wishes for
them then fine
don't have a will fine however that
doesn't happen
torah
and then he talks about the ethical will
we know many gadolin who left an ethical
will because there are things that are
hard to communicate directly
there are criticisms there are things
that are hard to say directly
and in fact it's more impactful you know
when you say it while you're still alive
they could blow you off
dad mom you always say that fine
whatever but when they're vulnerable
fragile when they've lost a parent when
they're receiving their inheritance
and their reading these are the hopes
the dreams the aspirations and even the
criticisms
what did we learn in passages of torah
says these
gave his sons and what were those
brachas those brachas were
in some cases very harsh criticisms and
all the commentaries point out
because a real a real bracha to a child
is not to tell them you're perfect and
you're amazing
and the world should serve you but it's
to tell them you're compulsive you're
impetuous
you anger easily you uh you need to
react slowly you need to be more
generous more kind
um
if you know it's not going to work don't
write it but he too
endorses both of the ideas of the gesh
and he continues
you should craft the will in such a way
that the next generation is bound
by it the gamma mekabal loya varadina
you shall
kashaba oven ghazal yemen yoshim
this is very important you also need to
craft it in such a way
to avoid the next generation potentially
violating stealing
they could be stealing how because if
according to the torah
a daughter doesn't inherit and you leave
a will that says a daughter gets half
the estate let's say you leave a son and
a daughter
and now the daughter takes half the
estate she might be stealing from her
brother
if you don't employ the halachic
instruments to enable her to access
what is due to her if you just leave it
as a secular
will without the conditions she might be
in gross violation
of stealing from her brother and
similarly other ways of dividing it that
are not according to allah
unless you engage the mechanism that
allows you to direct it toward those
different destinations
then the people who receive it might be
in violation of stealing
from those who really were supposed to
get it and he writes here in the
footnote
yes there are people
who will take the secular will and go to
court and take things for them based on
the secular will
that are going according to
you now maybe you can say that really
the ones who are due the money according
to the torah of their mokha they're
forgiving
whether they don't know the way it's
supposed to go or they feel coerced to
have to forgive
umustaminas yashimayam and therefore
they've given up any hope of getting it
back
hares so maybe now
they're taking something not stealing so
maybe the daughter
whose father in the will says that he's
leaving his daughter
maybe that father is in fact maybe that
daughter rather is in fact not doing
anything wrong
why because she's assuming that the
brother's mohammed that he's forgiving
because that's what the father would
have wanted maybe maybe
maybe if all the siblings go to court
and they divide it according to the
secular will
without employing the torah's terms
maybe there's an implicit forgiveness
the aphrodisiac and even though they
didn't belong in a secular court which
is in itself a prohibition
near the evidence or maybe it's not
stealing
so let's say if the following a man dies
and he has a secular will without any
halachic
conditions or any halachic uh any
variables
and now the daughter takes half the
assets of the father and now she wants
to sell something she inherited
the golf clubs of the of the father she
has no interest not that girls can't
play golf
but she has no interest in the in the
golf clubs she's going to sell them to
you
so he writes the episcopalic ocean you
have to be careful because if you go buy
the golf clubs
from the daughter who inherits from the
father but inherited incorrectly
inherited it inaccurately inherited it
stealing
because it doesn't really it's not
really coming to her then you are
purchasing stolen property so you have
to be careful and you have to be aware
so for these reasons and others it is so
critically important
to have a proper halachic will not
living will
which is also critically important but
will
number one because we want to meet the
standards
and the way we want the money to go may
not meet those standards
i for example have seven children kanai
nahara i have six daughters and a little
boy
according to the torah my son according
to the way my daughters think i would
want to do it
my son would inherit 100 of my things
but i don't think that would go over
very well
if in fact shy got everything and the
six girls got nothing
so correctly i want to be able to leave
to all of them
i need a halachic will in order to do
that in good conscience and in order to
make sure
that my daughters are not thieves number
two
is if there's no will in some cases the
state will disperse according to civil
law
which is not consistent with so if you
say you know what i don't want to deal
with it
i never took care of it i'm lazy i
procrastinate i don't want to spend the
money on it
i don't have to think about it so
there's no will in the absence of a will
then how does anyone know what you want
failing to plan is planning to fail
but it also means the state might
disperse what you have
not according to what you want and not
really according to your
according to your wishes a tremendous
goddess today
one of the gedoli adore undisputed i
spoke to once about this i don't have
permission to name
but said that it is critically
imperative not to follow
the torah's hierarchy today use the
halachic mechanisms
but to follow what's normally done
because no matter how firm your children
are
no matter how early one's children are
when it comes to
equality among the assets and among what
is bequeathed to them
they will not be satisfied with the
torah delineates and therefore
this god pointed out that today we
should use and employ the mechanisms
available to us to make sure that things
are done in an equitable and a fair
fashion for continuing the next page
torah tells us impressions in uh parshas
kedoshim
the left-naive mirsha among the
prohibitions a long litany of of
prohibitions
losing can't curse the deaf person and
don't put a stumbling block in front of
a blind person which we know in fact
doesn't apply to
literally putting the stumbling block in
front of the blind person
but applies more figuratively
in a set of truths called shiva's mata
levi is quoted simulated gimmel
and these sources i read many many
articles on this topic including from
rakhim jakter
rabbi willig and many others and the
safer
so so this uh chuba was quoted and he
says the following at the end
of now
she
if children take assets money that's not
due to them according to
and they keep it they're violating
ghazal so not only to ensure that your
wishes are followed
but to ensure and protect your children
from themselves violating the
prohibition of stealing
it's critically important to not only
determine and leave a will of where you
want it to go
but to do so in a way which employs the
halachic mechanisms
to to do so and to create challenges
the rambam is perhaps source number five
the rambam writes something which is a a
meaningful departure from what he
normally does
the mishna tour of the arakazaka for the
rambam is a halachic document
it's jewish law he's not interspersing
it with musser
he's not giving jewish thought he's not
giving lessons for life
it is strictly jewish law and yet
an unusual thing the rabbi writes
a person the rabbis instructed that a
person should never favor one child
in their life because we learned the
lesson of the brothers of yosef and
yosef
yosef was favored over his brothers and
the consequences were
catastrophic and therefore the ram says
when considering all of this
how we treat our children in their in
our lifetime and what will happen with
the children
after our lifetime a person needs to
prioritize
shalom bias prioritize shalom bias
prioritize the children getting along in
the future
now i'll tell you a tremendous martial
that really resonates for me
specifically
the gemara the marshalls and the gamora
bubba bastard
and the gemara there makes a comment and
the gemara says bastrila
semenya felibanim so i already told you
that barack hashem
have six daughters and one son in that
order
people like to ask me they have no right
to ask me when i say people like to ask
me i mean like the tsa agent
when i hand him all the passports well
ask me if he didn't come as number seven
how many more daughters would you have
good question but the gemara says
that if you have a daughter first
it's a great omen for sons what does
that mean according to simple
understanding of the gemara
it means that and again this is not
meant to be sexist misogynistic
that if you have a daughter first that
daughter is going to help you raise the
subsequent babies
so if you're first born as a son lazy
good for nothing entitled
sitting on the couch what's he going to
do for you but if your first child
is a girl and then you have a baby
you'll never hold that baby because the
girl's going to be so excited to hold
that baby rock the baby take care of the
baby
so bastard is even if you want to
dispute if it's true today and i can
tell you it still is true today but even
if you wanted to
dispute it's not true today it certainly
was true then but the marsha
has a different interpretation
look at what he says i'm sorry it's a
little bit fuzzy says anyone who wants
these sour sheets i'm happy to email
them to you
or share them with you later mashallah
if you have a boy first it means what do
you have
and what is the bakur entitled to a
double portion
and if you give the bahr this double
portion it's going to promote
and introduce animal enmity fighting
among the others
so therefore bastrilla simmons
you want the children to get along after
you die
if you're first born as a daughter and
you don't ever have to deal with the
issue of a double portion
semenya that will bode well for the
shalom bias among the children
after after the fact so the marsha here
and the rambam the end of nachos are
both writing
that a priority a tremendous priority
has to be shalom bias
when you talk about how we treat our
children in our lifetime but also what
we plan for them
after our lifetime we have to place an
emphasis on a priority on
shale and bias on everybody getting
along it's critically
critically important we have to provide
clarity
on delicate issues we're going to get to
this a little bit later also
we have a page in here
let's see if i can find it skip to it
for a moment on
a person's wishes to articulate and to
spell out
and to leave in our file here it is my
burial wishes i put this together
the letter concerns matters of extreme
importance to me i trust you will honor
my last and most fervently held wishes
and desires
i strongly desire to leave this world
fully in accordance with the practices
of our eternal people
and the haste and grief that accompanies
the passing of a loved one often
irreparable harm is done to the soul and
body of the deceased
i plead of you to treat my last rights
with compassion in accordance with my
sincere wishes
i think i worked off another document
and added to it these are my desires
kosher plain wood casket no autopsy no
creation no embalming
to be buried underground not in a
mausoleum no viewing of my remains after
death
the tarantula to be taken care of by and
i made this for myself
with the phone number shmeera someone
guard to be provided at the funeral
parlor
to my immediate family members please
observe the customer jewish morning
practices
create a shiva kaddish and so forth any
questions contact the jewish sacred
society
for adherence to my wishes may the
creator grant you health and happiness
satisfaction knowing you've complied
fully with my instructions
signed in a phone number if you have any
questions contact my rabbi robert from
goldberg
my phone number and my address on the
bottom and then we have the
language to add to a secular world which
we're going to get to will take us a
while to be able to get there
so it's very very important to consider
not only the ethical will
not only not only so
in that last will and testament that
will sit in a safety deposit deposit box
and that the estate planner will hold on
to should be
of course the actual binding will but it
should be preceded by in the folder
the ethical will here's my dreams my
hopes my aspirations my wants number one
number two my last burial wishes now
many have barak hashem
children for whom everything on that
list was a given
is obvious gonna sit shiva say kaddish
of course plain pine box of course
gonna bury in the ground of course but a
person doesn't know what could happen
and the fighting that could occur and
they don't know that who ultimately will
be there
could anyone have predicted before
corona that there'd be funerals
where family members were absent that
there would be funerals that only barely
had a minion
that there'd be funerals ives on
funerals during corona that were me
a child and the funeral director that
was the whole funeral
so would anyone have predicted it and
the more that we articulate
now that my burial wishes is not binding
legally i don't believe
i don't think that you can force someone
based on it but the more that we
articulate
and the more that we share and the more
that we communicate both before our
death and certainly after it
and the less guesswork we leave is a
great and generous gift we leave the
next generation
and it's a gift we leave ourselves
because it means that our will will be
followed
rather than in the absence of it
speculation that could lead to
fighting but also could lead to
violating ultimately
what we want where do we want to be
buried i can't tell you how often
including just this week
i have a conversation with a family who
loses a loved one very suddenly
and did they ever have a conversation
about where they want to be buried
forget the day every bar
buy plots which by the way a burial plot
is a piece of real estate
and it's only going up in value it's
only becoming more expensive
the sooner you buy it and you know you
have it the gift to the next generation
that doesn't fall on them
because it's only becoming more
expensive going forward but did you
leave instructions where you want to be
buried
do you want to be buried in america do
you want to be better than ever to
stroll where do you want to be buried
i'll never forget a couple years ago i
went to cuba for a day with a group a
humanitarian mission
we brought things to what is the barely
holding on jewish community in cuba
really humanitarian they didn't have
access to toilet paper and basic
medicines
and while we were there one of the
rabbis who went to the jewish cemetery
in havana
and one of the rabbis who was with us
grandparents had fled the nazis and made
their way to cuba as many did
and went to visit his grandfather buried
in the jewish cemetery in havana in cuba
and there's a beautiful headstone made
of marble his grandfather's buried there
his grandmother is not
why because after castro regime took
over and they had to flee as many
who were in a position to do did the
grandmother left with the family
and she's not buried with her husband in
cuba but as we stood there
it occurred to me it occurred to our
whole little group
that this rabbi's grandfather is buried
in cuba and when he was buried
there was a thriving jewish community
kololim and yeshivas and mikva
girls schools all kinds of schools youth
groups shules
there was a thriving jewish community
and did they ever anticipate that jews
wouldn't be able to come back nobody
could come back
i understand today maybe even the
government is reversing its policy and
listing cuba again as a
as an adversary of america reversing a
change that uh
occurred five years ago so did anyone
ever dream that
so we can never predict the future so a
person has very thoughtful where they
want to be buried
and maybe we'll get to next this is
going to take us a little while this
series
will get to the merit of being buried in
israel versus outside of israel
is there is it a virtue what is the
merit of being buried in israel outside
of israel
where will generations to come likely
still be going
and where but may they never go again
that we don't anticipate
right now who knows so the more we
articulate the more we share
advance the greater a gift to our
children the greater gift to ourselves
to ensure that that will be in fact that
that will in fact be
followed shalom buys shalom buys at what
age should a person write such a will
when should a person write such a will
when should it be prepared so
the shahbaz rabbi safar on yerusha
writes that yaakov called yosevin
towards the end of his life
so the key is that things are prepared
in advance how far in advance
who knows but prepared in advance don't
wait till it's too late don't wait till
it's too late
the uh kluger or kluger
uh sees it differently kluger
walks off it works off of possible
posix says in source six and passes
bihar sources
sanctify the fiftieth year and proclaim
it yovel
is in the fiftieth year
is yovel and what happens in yeovil
the shavu the shaft is a so every person
goes back to their land
isha mishpachto sort of kluger
says
that what does it mean
everyone when is it that you go back to
the earth at 50.
so a person should have their last will
of testament written
by the age of 50 by the age of 50
because at 50
is when a person goes to the land is
returned to the land
the shaft
therefore homolytically he's suggesting
not halal
homiletically by the age of 50 a person
should
write a will others say you should write
your will early on
my father taught me and he's on person
has certain responsibilities when you
get married
and you have increased responsibilities
when you have your first child you got
to get life insurance
you have to have disability insurance
and you have to have a will the moment
there are consequences to your absence
meaning there are people for whom
decisions have to be made is when you're
responsible to articulate them
it's not very romantic i'm not telling
you that in the middle of chevy brackets
you should draft the will
i will tell you that when you graduate
you they try to sell you burial plots
but that's not for now
i will tell you that it's not uh during
shovel brothers that you have to draft
your will
i'm not telling you that after the bris
the same day draft a will not that you
have a child
but with the responsibility you have to
you have to write this will
so by the age of 50 is the mclugar's
homelandic interpretation based on the
shaft of
so others say yaakov did it before the
very end of his life even though he was
already essentially terminally ill
and ended uh nearing his his deathbed
but
refiver cohen points out the contrast
medulla d'or source number seven
command chavez tells us the following
a person should always try to repent one
day before they die
don't wait to die to for atonement don't
have death be your atonement your kapara
try to repent try to repair try to
reform a day before you die
shout out to me so a student said them
yamas now that's nice and thought it's
nice in theory
but none of us get we don't get a
calendar invite
that tells us when we're coming upstairs
nobody tells us the day that
is coming to visit so how could a person
know how to repent the day before they
die
none of us get a memo about when is the
day we're going to die
some allah says exactly
now you understand what i was getting at
which is if my message is
repent the day before you die and you
don't know which day you're going to die
then repent every day because who knows
if tomorrow you'll die
very again sanguine thought a very
sobering thought god forbid god forbid
but one never knows accidents illnesses
terrible tragic again we just did a
funeral yesterday for a woman 55 years
old
who died suddenly on friday out of
absolutely nowhere
one never knows and therefore one should
live every day as a country song
live every day as if it's your last
because you never know
now why do you live every day as if it's
your last i think the country song i
don't really know the song
but i think the country song means go
out party have fun live every day
as if it's your last. that is not what
the gamer and chavez and what ruby
eliezer are saying
live every day as if it's your last
carpe diem what'll be eiser saying is
don't have regrets don't have regrets
there are conversations you need to have
have them there are plans you need to do
do them
don't have regrets in that sense so
therefore the five of cone says on his
conscious medium the door based on this
gamer in chavez
just like don't wait to do chuva don't
wait to become a better version of
yourself
because you can't wait till the day
you're gonna die to receive atonement no
one knows which day they're gonna die
so too don't wait to do your estate
planning until right before you die
because you probably won't be in a
condition to do it then and
we don't get a memo of when we are going
to
when we are going to die continues
the wisest of all men says
your garment should be white and your
head never lack oil in other words
purify yourself as much as possible as
often as possible
because you can't say ah the upon f now
when i get there i'll
da field me when i retire towards the
end of my life i'll finally do sitter
snippets and start to learn one word of
what i'm saying
i'll get to that later none of us ever
know if we're getting to later
so don't procrastinate don't delay and
don't push off the things that one needs
to do now which include shuva
include becoming the best version of
ourselves but also include
doing estate planning it's critical to
do it as
soon as possible
you compare it to a king who invite
servants to us
but didn't tell them so the wise
servants of the king
they dress for a royal affair the
yahshua passed away and they went
outside the king
they say does the kings pass lack for
anything
so it should be ready any moment they
invited us then tell us the time
we're talking about the king over here
the tips
the fools they went to work the fools
went to binge watch netflix
and they didn't get dressed and they
weren't ready
ah it takes effort it takes time so
they're not ready they're not ready what
happens
suddenly without warning the king
summons everybody the penguin to the
banquet
pikkhan shabbat necklace allah so those
who are wise they're ready
they're adorned they're dressed in their
finest because they were anticipating
they were ready
by tip but now the fools they have to
run in
and they're all dirty dirty physically
or dirty metaphysically
from that which they were doing in the
process
so the king was thrilled to welcome the
ones who were dressed in their finest
who were prepared who were ready and he
was furious at those
who had neglected to be ready so omar
the king says hello
yes those who were ready sit eat drink
but those who aren't ready you can stand
on the outskirts you stand on the
perimeter
and watch us party watch us indulge in
this banquet
so the same is true this muscle for this
world
if you wait and you wait and you wait
and you wait until it's too late you're
watching from the outside
but if you're ready every day then
you'll be ready when that day comes
and therefore what applies to our
personal transformation and growth
spiritually also applies
to our estate planning don't wait don't
delay be ready
be ready for when the time calls be
ready for when the time calls
okay we're going to leave it here for
today as the introduction covered the
introductory topics
we'll pick up next time first by talking
about stucca how much can you lead to
stucco
is it properly to sucka how do you
balance between what you're leaving your
children
and what you're trying to leave to make
the world a better place beyond just
your children
uh what what are the proportions or
ratio or amounts
that dictate how much you go to stakka
versus not go to staka
and then from there we'll go into the
mechanism what's the torah's hierarchy
and what instruments do we have that we
can employ in order to
complement shall we say the halacha's
instructions
if that doesn't meet exactly what our
goal is
and how we want to disperse our assets
after 120.
we'll pick it up next week with part two
have a wonderful day