Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
From Boca Raton, Florida, Rabbis Ephraim
Goldberg, Philip Moskowitz, and Josh
Brody are taking you behind the Bima.
The BRS Rabbis schmooze about
contemporary issues and talk to special
guests who give a behind-the-scenes look
at how they got to where they are and
what keeps them going.
Welcome to Behind the Bima.
Good evening. It's Wednesday night, 9:00
p.m. I am Rabbi Ephraim Goldberg, your
host, joined by my dear friends and
colleagues, Rabbi Gavriel Pinchas
Moskowitz and Rabbi Joshua Brody.
And we are here to take you behind the
Bima. Behind the Bima throwback edition.
Very, very excited to be together
tonight. I want to begin by thanking our
generous sponsors, new friends, but
quickly dear friends, Jeremy and Merrill
Strauss, who sponsored many of the
Shiurim this week and behind the Bima
tonight in memory of Jeremy's father,
Michael Strauss. All of a shalom is the
shalom of Aliza Strauss is our
extraordinary people doing really,
really remarkable things. We thank them
for their generosity and we thank them
for the difference they are making in
Klal Yisrael. So, a huge thank you. If
you'd like to sponsor a future episode
of one of the top podcasts in the world,
then
please email Lee at brsonline.org,
l e e at brsonline.org.
Thanks to you for your rating and
reviews. All right.
the charts last week, so please continue
to do so. Take a moment. Just take out
your phone, rate, review, take one
moment, and we greatly appreciate it. If
you're watching on YouTube, feel free to
subscribe for a moment. Uh gentlemen,
Rabbis, how are you this fine evening?
I am phenomenal. Rabbi Brody, you had a
lot on your mind pre-show. Busy, busy
week here in Boca. We're actually uh
getting ready to move this summer, so we
started selling stuff.
One of the things we just put up on
What's that? Can you just clarify what
it means you're getting ready to move?
Like to another community. I'll leave
No, we are not moving. We would never
leave this community unless we would
make aliyah, which we're not making
aliyah yet. But we're moving a few
blocks away.
It's not something we wanted to do, but
because of this housing uh
uh you know what's going on right now
with housing, the house that we're
renting is now for sale. And you won't
Right. You could live in the house of of
behind the bema. You know like
Would you Whoever buys that house
Whoever buys that house, will you give
them a tour? I'll give them the official
official tour, VIP. Show them where all
the I'll show you them where we actually
film behind the bema.
I was going to say it's hard to say that
you have the rights to come back on
Wednesday nights to re-film behind the
bema there every Wednesday night.
Yeah, it's going to be weird. Do I have
to take a picture of my background so
I'll have the same background
Will they have Will they have better
Wi-Fi cuz you're a little bit higher
right now.
Who knows? Who knows? What's the little
bit
wondering Everyone's wondering um
where what Who's our guest?
What's What's our guest tonight Behind
the Bema has become known and beloved
for the guests. Really, frankly, I I
can't speak for the two of you, but I
don't know if we're much, but these
guests are of extraordinary life
stories, experiences, wisdom. They have
a lot to share. That's why we are
excited to spend our time with them to
gain from them and to bring their wisdom
to you. And we ask for your help when we
ask you to help us promote the podcast.
It's really because we want to get them
out. So Who's our guest tonight and why
don't we have a guest tonight? So to
clear the air or address the elephant in
the room, the answer is we have a
tremendously prominent, high-profile,
super exciting guest who uh was supposed
to be on tonight, but part of their
busy, high-profile life is they were
unable to make it tonight. And so um we
waited till the last minute to see if
they'd be able to get it done. That's
why we didn't advertise or promote who
it was. In the end, please God, they
will join us a different week. But you
know what? We're grateful. It's the
opportunity to throw back to the three
of us speaking. Now we'll find out who
really watches Behind the Bema for what.
The Who watches it for the guests and
who watches it for the band.
We're the hardcore fans. You just want
to hear us kibitz with each other. Who
are the hardcore fans? The truth is, for
a lucky listener who's listening live,
feel free to comment that you'd like to
come on for a moment to ask a question
or to offer a comment, and and maybe
we'll send you the the link for you to
join us live for others to see. So, in
the comments, if you have a question,
something you want us to speak about
tonight, and ask the rabbis about Boca
Raton Synagogue, about us, about our
lives, about our thoughts, our opinions
on things, feel free to submit it. We're
happy to address it. And if you want to
join us for a moment, we'll uh consider
that as well. So, a lot of lot going on
though. A lot going on in
you a question.
When we first started the show, did you
ever imagine us bringing on guests? Cuz
the first few shows were were were
guestless. It was just the three of us.
Was that an idea from the beginning? You
remember what it was first called?
Coffee Talk.
Right.
Coffee Talk.
Coffee Talk. Who drinks coffee at 9:00
at night? Coffee Talk. Cindy Schrier is
here.
So, we're we're good to go. We have a
Schrier present.
So, we have Coffee Talk.
Big week. Big mazel tov to the Schriers.
There is definitely a lot going on
around us in the world, in our country,
news out of Israel tonight
with a
the Dimona reactor and that area siren
going off, rocket launched, Israel
retaliating. Hopefully it does not
escalate. And we're wishing them well,
thinking about Avigail Brody. I was just
thinking that. The one who flipped the
siren.
That's why I was smiling as you
announced that. Everyone's like, why is
he probably smiling when you said this?
Bombs going off.
I know why you're smiling, cuz you can
picture Avigail by accident hitting the
siren.
Flipping the
or hitting the wrong siren. Yeah.
We're proud of her. She's the best.
had our conversation with our lone
soldiers the other day, and I asked each
one of them, you know, tell us something
cool about your service that might, you
know, be unexpected or people might not
might not be aware of. So, the first two
guys went, and it was one of the guys
was a sniper, and he was telling us
about how to be a sniper. And the other
guy is a driver, he's telling us how
what it's like to be a driver in the
army. And the third person, a woman in
our community,
said I can't tell you what I do. She
said I go into the office and I do some
computer work and I go home. I said,
"Can you be a little bit more explicit?"
She said, "No."
I said, "Wink once if something you did
last week affected something in Iran."
Right. And she she got very quiet very
quickly. I cut off the power to the
nuclear reactor. That's what I
Right. Exactly. Yeah, we're we're we
dive in all the time, of course, for all
our brothers and sisters in Israel and
around the world, but for the members,
the courageous members serving and
volunteering, we are deeply, deeply
appreciative. So, um
Yeah, there's a little definitely a lot
going on. Of course, we're a political,
so we don't address that, but I'll I'll
raise this. We
are based in had the privilege today to
convert four individuals, a mother and
three children, which is always exciting
when we welcome new members of the
tribe, new people to the Jewish people.
I find it extraordinarily inspiring to
ask them about their story, the
detective work we've talked about in the
past that goes into wanting to know why
somebody
convert and and when you when you know
their sincerity, when you feel and when
you're confident in their sincerity,
doing all that you need in order to
bring them as full members of the Jewish
people, it's a really exciting,
fulfilling, beautiful moment, and
beautiful experience.
Wow.
as we've spoken about in the past, it's
very motivational for us as well. You
know, we were all born into this, we
didn't have much of a choice, and while
each one of us goes through our own
journey and struggles along the way,
it's and I know you feel the same way,
it's very inspiring to watch other
people who did not have to be a part of
this
to be part of the journey because they
were looking for some more more meaning
and purpose in their lives, and to be
able to follow that trajectory all the
way until the end, it's really heroic
what they go through and the sacrifice
that they make and they they're
modern-day Avraham Avinu's. They leave
everything behind, they take on a
completely new path in life, and they do
it because they they're looking for more
and they're searching.
They are and we don't always appreciate
that. The the path doesn't end after the
conversion. It's complicated because
their relatives remain non-Jewish. And
how therefore to have family reunions
and experience holidays, um
relationships with children, and not
only irreligious but non-Jewish family.
Of course, can be navigated but is
complicated. So, the heroism and the
courage continues even beyond taking
that leap to actually convert and become
Jewish but to navigate the really
complicated area
You know, the Hazal or Rabbi the Hazal
tells us that kasheh gerim ke-sapachas
that converts can be difficult to the
Jewish people and it's a debate exactly
why but the consensus understanding and
the one that really inspires us is that
cuz converts really put the pressure on
us. Here they chose it, they joined it,
they took that leap. We're born into it
and we often
either resent it, neglect it, or don't
feel the joy of it. And so therefore
they kind of obligate us cuz that
passion, that enthusiasm which hopefully
becomes contagious and not a source of
resentment.
And as you said, I don't think we fully
appreciate that. In many respects, the
hardest part starts with conversion. You
articulated in terms of the family but
even in just in terms of regular growth,
the whole time in everyone's you're
heroic, you're doing heroic things,
you're there's your your meteoric rise
to Judaism and all of a sudden you
convert and the next day you show up to
shul and you're a regular person. And
you have regular responsibilities and
that glitz and glamour, so to speak, is
no longer there. And there are the ups
and downs of being a Jew and we convert
or we at least we see a lot of single
people down here in South Florida who
wish to convert and there are enormous
challenges afterwards in terms of
marriage and and some of the challenges
with that. So, I don't think everyone
appreciates that however hard the
conversion process is, those challenges,
as you said, continue on long into the
future.
Yes.
Yes. The the uh first of all, Ron asks,
one of our listeners, do you dissuade
people when they come to you to convert?
And the answer is that we don't actively
dissuade. We're living in a time that we
don't want to be rude, so we respond to,
of course, those who reach out, but we
have a whole system. We we're part of
the
Beis Din of America's network of Batei
Din that we are accepted and reputable
in by the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and
around the world. So, people we work
through sponsoring rabbis. When there's
a candidate for conversion, they have to
call a local rabbi willing to sponsor
them, oversee them, supervise them. And
the sponsoring rabbi comes and advocates
for them, and of course, we meet several
times, and we have expectations, rules,
we test them, and we make sure they're
socially integrated into community. But
ultimately, to an enormous degree, we're
relying on sponsoring rabbis. So, we're
not rude, and we don't ignore, and we
don't dissuade actively, but we will um
cross-examine sounds harsh or like
you're trying to catch someone, but we
will try to understand with some real
detective work, why would somebody leave
a life we'll tell them, you know,
someone say, "I'm spiritual or I'm
connected or I think this is the most
right thing to do." So, that's great.
Keep the seven Noachide laws and be
spiritual, and pray every day, but why
would you want this 613 laws? Why would
you want this rigid system? Why would
you want the cost of shmurah matzah on
Pesach and the cost of tuition and the
anti-Semitism and so on and so forth?
So, we'll say all the reasons trying to
convince them why they should not want
it, but we don't I wouldn't say that we
actively dissuade in a way that could be
perceived as as rude or as rejectionary.
Can I tell you a great Yeah, go ahead.
Let me tell you a funny story. When when
we got a call probably about 3 4 years
ago, there was a girl in FAU. She came
through Hillel and uh
I don't know how we got in touch with
each other, but she said she really
wanted to convert because you know, she
has this this strong affinity towards
the Jewish people. I said, "Well, what
why why do you have it?" She says,
"Well, her her her great-grandparents
were were Jewish."
So, I said, "Oh, that's that's that's
pretty interesting, you know." So, I'm
just
Mom's side? Dad's side? Just which
Yeah, that was uh my mom's mom's mom.
Right. Newsflash. Newsflash. She's like,
I'm like, you don't have to be actually
Jewish. She says, "No, but I really want
to convert." Right. Like
You don't need You're done. It's over.
Welcome. Right. Welcome back.
There's a There There are fascinating
phenomena we see down here, and I don't
remember if we ever spoken about this in
Behind the Bima, so forgive me if we
have, but we see fascinating phenomena
all the time, including, you know,
you'll see a Jewish guy who finds a non
who meets a non-Jewish woman and is
courting her. At some point, he realizes
either his parents or his grandmother or
grandparents will say, "You marry a
non-Jew, we're going to kill you." So,
he says, "Okay, I got to get her
converted because I want to still access
the inheritance." So, he brings to us,
and the woman will start to learn,
study, observe, experience, grow,
connect with community. She does
magnificent. It's beautiful. I love
this. He's like, "One second."
He's like, "I didn't sign up for this."
I didn't sign up for this. Exactly. So,
you know, sometimes then the woman will
stay with us and um
and the man will drop out. Or sometimes
the man actually becomes the baal
teshuvah. He takes it on, too,
experiencing the beauty through her.
Rabbi Davis, our colleague, has a term
for that.
Great line. You know, he calls it,
"Instead of losing one, we gain two."
So, instead of one person going off the
derech or losing them, we've gained two
observant, beautiful Jews. So, it's it's
really, really fascinating. Today's, you
know, I don't want to speak about
Obviously, nobody knows who I'm who I'm
talking about, but the truth is that
sometimes we have to do conversions,
let's just say, of someone who's
previously converted, of a woman who had
a conversion and then had children, and
then when she looked into it, it was
determined that the rabbi or the beis
din that converted her are not accepted
universally. They're not accepted by the
highest standards. They're not accepted,
let's say, by the chief rabbinate of
Israel, and people want to make aliyah.
And, you know, there's a lot of
criticism about when there was an effort
by the beis din of America to create a
network and to centralize the battei
din, to not make them subjective and
every rabbi making shabbos and converts
for themselves, but to create a a
system of standards and so on. There was
a lot of criticism that we're taking
away the autonomy of eyes and we are
disempowering and so on and so forth.
But you know, the problem is that don't
you want to serve the converts? So, that
that's who matters the most are are
these people. They're very vulnerable,
they're fragile, and they're coming to
us for help. And so, when when a rabbi
out of the goodness of their heart does
a conversion not through a network or
through a process which is recognized,
and they think they're doing something
so kind and others are unwilling to be
that kind, in fact, it's cruel, not
kind, because that person will find out
later in life, often in a very harsh
way, that in fact, they're not accepted
or recognized. So, we find ourselves
sometimes doing what we call gear
l'chumra, where we are reconverting
people and because possibly it wasn't
acceptable or it's not recognized by
all, which brings with it questions. Do
you make a bracha when you immerse in
the mikvah if you're only doing it as a
chumra as a stringency? If the couple
have children, they were married, she
converted before their marriage, so do
they need to remarry? If she really just
converted right now, what what
solidifies that marriage? Do they need
to remarry? Are you allowed to make a
bracha? Or do you just put the ring on
her finger in front of two witnesses?
So, it's fascinating both in the world
of conversion, but also raising the
issue of sometimes there are
um radical or pioneering or rabbis or
leaders in a lot of arenas of life who
project or put themselves forward as if
they are the compassionate, kind,
flexible ones, when in fact, they're not
doing an act of kindness, but an act of
cruelty, cuz they're setting a person on
a trajectory in which ultimately,
unfortunately, it's not going to go
well. So, um you know, it's possible
that sometimes such a woman and her
children will need to uh convert again.
It's fascinating what happens when you
convert a pregnant woman. The base din,
do they have to be aware that she's
pregnant? Sometimes you convert a woman,
she is uh visibly pregnant, although no
man or anyone should ever ask anyone,
are you pregnant or when the baby's due?
Um
you know, unless
they're asking you to cut the umbilical
cord at that point. So, uh sometimes
it's visible, but other times you find
out later. So, then it's a fascinating
question if the woman converted she was
pregnant, but the three rabbis didn't
know.
How do you treat the fetus inside her?
Did the fetus inside her also need
conversion? We just don't treat her body
as a barrier to the water and the fetus.
Or no, the fetus until it's born Uber
Yarahima, maybe the fetus is no
different than her lungs, her kidney,
her heart. It's an organ of the mother
till it's born and therefore it doesn't
need conversion. So, the rabbis didn't
need to know she was pregnant. We're not
going to review all the laws of
conversion, but there are It's crazy how
it goes. No, they're fascinating
questions that come up. Everything I
just mentioned very possibly came up
very recently. Um keep the questions
coming in the in the comments in the
comment section cuz we're happy and
excited to address them. Who remembers
the very first guest we ever had on
behind the Bema? I saw that question. I
was trying to remember.
Is Chai Schechter Rabbi Chai Schechter?
No.
Oh, was it Was it the comedian? Modi?
Oh, it was Modi?
We need the fact checker to tell us.
Any of our listeners want to enter a
raffle to find out? Now, here's another
question.
Did we have our first guest on behind
the Bema or did we have our first guest
guest on Coffee Talk?
Oh, that's right. I forgot that.
Yep. Our very first guest was It was It
was for us We weren't thinking that it
was Coffee Talk Three Rabbis
trying to connect with our our wonderful
community whom we weren't seeing cuz the
world was in a lockdown. And then
Yocheved, my wife's cousin Michael
Goldsmith who survived a month on a
respirator in the ICU with Corona where
several times the family was ready to
say goodbye to him, came out and came
home from the hospital to a heroic
welcome and he just marked the
anniversary of that. And and he and his
wonderful wife were our first guests.
Was it Coffee Talk or Behind the Bema?
Thank you to our fact checker who was
invited on by the way.
Wasn't Simon Mirsky? It wasn't Simon
Mirsky?
No, Simon came on
one one time only.
We definitely had Simon. We had the
moms. Who remembers when we went from
Coffee Talk to Behind the Bima? Why did
we change names?
Good question.
weren't drinking coffee anymore.
Good good questions, right?
I think it's a great question. It's how
do we all come up with names? Like
there's so many different There's
There's so many different things that
we've named, right? The weekly, the
show, your classes, the different, you
know, you sit around the table and
everyone throws out
Right from the
and forth on this one for a while,
though. There were a lot of different
options out there. We should We should
pull up the old texts and reveal the
other options for what Behind the Bima
was going to be called.
I think Behind the Bima works really
well. I really think it captures what
we're trying to do here, which is take
you behind the Bima and get a sense of
the conversations, the processes, the
thoughts. So, let's go Behind the Bima.
We met this week already several times
about Shavuos. Rabbis across the
country, across the world are trying to
plan Shavuos. So, you'll say, "Plan
Shavuos. Okay, what do you have to tell
me about it?" The answer is because last
Shavuos was much easier to plan than
this Shavuos. You know why? There was
nothing to plan. Cuz last Shavuos the
world was shut down. It was You were
scared to leave your front door. So, the
big radical, you remember, the risky,
crazy
Sit out in your driveway. Everyone bring
a folding chair to your driveway and
create the outdoor space base medrish.
It was about 400° humid and maybe a
little bit rain.
Yes, so last year was easy to plan. Two
years ago was easy to plan. When Shavuos
was normal, easier to plan. When there
was no Shavuos, I had the best Shavuos
of my life last year. I mean, other than
all the other ones where I get to teach
the community and so on and so forth.
But But last year I stayed up all night
long with my two sons-in-law. We learned
through the night. We had a vasikin
minyan outdoors. Remember, we weren't
inside yet. I just saw a picture
recently how we had We remember we had
three areas around the campus. We had
cones sectioned off. It was It was
really crazy, crazy times. And that was
last So, how do you plan this Shavuos?
Let's go behind the bema. What are the
thoughts? What are the considerations?
What are the questions? Rebbe Moskowitz,
what what are we struggling with?
Well, I struggle with everything. First
of all, the million-dollar question in
the room is masks, right? Right? Are you
going to require people to wear masks
throughout the night? Are you going to
create maskless sections for people in
the shul for those who are fully
vaccinated? Or certain rooms even at a
distance people might be able to go. Um
are you doing food throughout the night?
How are you doing food throughout the
night? Are you doing food indoors? Are
you doing food outdoors? Um are people
going to stay up all night if they have
to wear the masks? Are Um do we blow up
the whole model? Do we use this as an
opportunity to rethink all of Shavuos
night in that classic model that we've
used up until now? Maybe we try some
different types of opportunities. We
have the enormous enormous closeness
here, the enormous privilege this year
of hosting Rabbi Aaron Rapps and
Schachter, um which will be a great
benefit to all of us and to our learning
over Shavuos. But how do you How do you
utilize the greatness of our Schachter
in as many slots as possible and provide
those with opportunities? So, those are
some of the challenges that we are Just
some. Just some. And by the way, again,
we're not asking for sympathy, but a
person gets the brochure or you see the
website and you get excited, "Oh, the
Shavuos at BRS." You know, they probably
took 20 minutes and and planned Shavuos.
But the considerations that go into it,
the calculations to determine what's a
good theme and who gives the classes and
the slots as Rebbe Moskowitz just
described. And most importantly this
year, will people stay up all night with
masks, without masks, indoors, outdoors?
These issues are evolving, changing
regularly. People have such different
opinions. If you're vaccinated, um if
you're not yet vaccinated, you have a
different attitude, perhaps. If you're
never going to get vaccinated, where do
you fit in? What's your attitude? And we
mentioned in the past, but I think it
it's it's important to mention again.
What Everyone has an opinion. Everyone
listening to this right now has an
opinion. They're like, "Oh, that's an
easy Of course you can't do this." Or
"Of course you can do that. What they
don't realize is that you and I are
being bombarded with hundreds and
hundreds of people who all think that
they have the simple solution to that.
Right. And each person's solution is
against the other person's solution. And
our job is to take all of those
suggestions and to figure out what's
really safest and best for the community
in a way that's going to bring people
back together, magnify the Torah
learning, and of course keep everyone
safe.
And that's the real struggle.
Yeah. Yeah.
Listen, there's been a big question
that's existed for the entire last 13,
14 months, which is, you know, we have a
principle
which is it's easy to be stringent. It's
easy to be strict. It's easy to say no.
It's a lot harder to say yes. So, on the
one hand, you know, when it was
considered to be extraordinary times and
enormous high risk and high statistics
and huge contagion and a lot unknown
about a disease and a health care system
that threatened to be under overrun. So,
then the answer was that, you know, you
got to be strict. On any case of doubt,
you got to be strict. Are we still in
that same place? Or have we shifted now
where
in the state of Florida, we can't speak
for elsewhere,
if you're 16 years or older up, you
could be vaccinated. My 16-year-old
daughter has her second shot coming up.
So, we'll soon arrive at the time at
which if you're 16 or up, you can be
vaccinated. So, does that change the
calculation now? Do we now And within
our community,
predominantly people are vaccinated.
Right. And it So, we did Do we design
now rules and regulations that reflect
the reality that if you're an adult who
wants to be vaccinated, you can be. The
highest risk population can be
vaccinated. That doesn't mean we should
be reckless or careless in the policies,
but can we be a little bit more lenient?
Can we adopt airplane rules in shul?
What are airplane rules? I There are
countless people who we know travel,
they fly, they have during Corona, where
they're sitting not 6 ft, not 3 ft,
they're sharing an armrest with another
human being they don't know,
and they lower their mask to drink or to
eat and then put it back. And I know air
filtration system in an airplane may be
different, but I don't know if it is.
So, can we adopt an airplane rules?
Let's say on Shavuot night, you should
wear masks, try to be distanced, but if
you're learning with someone, take a
drink, you can lower it, there's more.
So, that's the question. And then which
airline and do we throw people off the
airline? So, that's Now, speaking of
your airline analogy, we also made a
significant change in the show last week
where we adopted a vaccinated section
where the chairs are a little bit
closer, and not everyone loved that
change in the show, Rabbi Goldberger. Do
you want to share your analogy as to why
not everyone loved that? Yeah, of
course. What we did is we created a
vaccinated section where the chairs were
closer together again because people,
according to the CDC, who are vaccinated
do not need to be distanced even though
they still have masks, which also
arguably they don't need to still be
doing, although I know variants and we
don't know in the future, but we are
still doing. And yet, a lot of
vaccinated people are not sitting in
them even though we incentivize them.
Rabbi Moscowitz brilliantly suggested we
incentivize them by putting back the
good chairs. Right. We have these really
We have chairs that are plush, comfy
chairs. Yeah, like you need to say
Krishna Malchut before the drasha when
you're sitting in one of those chairs.
They are good, good chairs. So, we
incentivized and motivated people to get
vaccinated, but many are not sitting in
them for a very simple reason, because
they're not 6 ft from the next person.
So, it The whole world's going to have
to learn to adjust to go back from first
class to business class to coach.
Because we should not and cannot
anticipate that from now on we're going
to go to
Just explain, they're not What bothers
them about the 6 ft is not COVID, it's
the comfort. Of course you want to Yeah,
you want to stretch it, yeah. Plus,
we've also found, and we're working on
it, our colleagues have also, that when
you take away the distancing, guess what
came back after a year of silence?
Yeah, talking. The buzz, the hum of the
talking, which is really, really sad. It
was wonderful. When people are far, they
can't talk, there's no one to talk to.
But when they're sitting next to
somebody,
that hum, that buzz has returned. Let's
go back to our comments. We have
wonderful people who've been commenting.
Our good friend
of A lot of cheesecake comments, by the
way.
of cheesecakes. So, our good friend our
newcomer, our avid listener, Joey's mom,
who's going to be a guest on behind the
Bema soon wonders how many flavors of
cheesecake does Chef Gersh cook up in
Boca for Shavuot. So Gersh responds,
"Triple chocolate, chocolate Oreo
crushed chocolate filling with white
chocolate chips."
Any cheesecake lovers out there?
This might surprise our listeners. I'm
not a huge eater and dairy and I I'm
Ashkenazi do not get along well
together.
Yeah. Yeah, I guess I'm out of my Brody.
You're you're vegan, right? Doesn't work
and I know you're not a big fan of
cheese so it's probably not going to Not
a fan of show up but you're Jewish you
stole Shavuot. Yeah. Yeah, we are. We
are. But um you know, I'm I'm the Grinch
who insists on the fleishigs even on
Shavuot itself. I do have to give credit
where credit is due especially if I want
to place to sleep tonight. The name
behind the Bema. We were thinking out
loud in my home and I said behind behind
the scenes were behind the something
behind the something and my amazing wife
the Rebbetzin said how about behind the
Bema. So we do give her credit where
credit is due on that topic. So Shavuot
is going behind the Bema. Shavuot is is
one example on conversion behind the
Bema about Shavuot is the thinking the
planning. Do we want to announce our
theme? Should we do a breaking news and
announce the theme at Boca Raton
Synagogue over Shavuot?
Does everyone know that for the last 15
seconds you guys were talking to each
other saying let's we say the theme is
No.
What's the breaking news?
You have the Moskowitz. Every year at
Boca Raton Synagogue we do a theme. This
year's theme is Torah and technology.
What does that mean? That means a lot of
things. It means Halacha, certain
changes that are taking place in our day
and age, Tushkofa, it's philosophy in
terms of mindfulness and how do we
disconnect to reconnect. All these types
of topics are some that we are going to
be speaking about over the holiday
Shavuot. But we like to package it
because we want people to come away from
Shavuot not with a bunch of just
disjointed classes, but we want people
to feel like we conquered a topic that
if you go to every class, you'll have a
broad understanding of a certain
subject. And so Torah technology is our
subject this year.
That's that's a great point and um
and there's so many areas of it and we
weave it into the Shiurim, the drashos
at night, the morning, the afternoon,
the classes. And right, like the goal is
to feel you walk away having acquired
not a comprehensive understanding of a
topic, but and this is a broad one and
we'll talk about Torah and technology,
some of the new issues that COVID
presented with technology, not only in
Halacha technology, in Shabbos
technology, in davening, but also in
Hashkafa, in our mentality, in our
attitude, in our personality, our
challenge to mindfulness and the like.
What are some of the past themes that
we've done at Boca Raton Synagogue on
Shavuos? I think our most successful one
was one year we spoke about Mashiach and
we tackled Mashiach from I think it was
like 16 different avenues. And the nice
part about that was because it was such
a concentrated topic, you came away
I don't know why everyone's laughing
right now.
What do you mean topics like what?
Mashiach. Like what?
No, so you came away at the end of
Shavuot, I don't know what just
happened. You came away at the end of
Shavuot with a real comprehensive
understanding of that topic, whether it
was who is Mashiach, where do you find
Mashiach, when's he going to come, was
the Lubavitcher Rebbe Mashiach? There
were some really
um provocative topics there and people
really felt that they had a grasp on the
topic. So that was uh I think that was
probably the most successful theme. And
our and our mission that that Shavuot
and every day is to bring Mashiach and
every one of us should take
responsibility. Mashiach is not here
because of us and to do the best that we
can to be the best that we Someone just
woke up.
Everybody needs to do the best they can
and be the best they Rabbi Brody has
schmutz on his face for the last like 2
years.
yeah, you remember Rabbi Moskowitz about
the one on Kabbalah?
That was also excellent. I spoke Zohar
that year. I spoke about the
the noted be Huda and his opposition to
the studying of Kabbalah. It was a That
was a great year.
Kabbalah. How young or how old do you
have to be to study Kabbalah? We also
attacked Kabbalah from a lot of
different angles. My favorite theme,
factor Shavuos. Where was that? Factor
truth, truth or or fiction?
Myth busters. Myth busters, yeah. That's
the one I'm thinking of. We did myth
busters. Like where is where is the ark?
Where's the Aaron buried? That you could
do again.
I did Where was Gan Eden? You did with
the Luchos, right? With the Where there
really two Luchos? We took a bunch of
myths surrounding Right, if you have a
tattoo, can you be buried in a Jewish
cemetery? We took a bunch of myths and
we and we attacked it and we went
through the theme of the the myth
busters. Who can forget though Jay
Keen's incredible efforts when he got
the kids to write up their Divrei Torah?
You remember he delivered them in front
of the rabbis. Shall I tell you a
beautiful beautiful story that came out?
Jay, I know Jay's listening, so this is
a tribute to Jay. We we Jay came up with
this idea that kids would write Divrei
Torah and then we would combine them to
put them out in a book for the community
to read, to learn, to have over Shavuos.
It was beautiful.
But then Jay had the idea we had another
component where the educators, the heads
of school, the rabbis of the community
sat at this dais and kids who wanted to
come to the front of the room give a
Divrei Torah got a candy, a prize. They
came in the afternoon.
I did not I did not take him out by the
I was going to say.
They came in the afternoon one by one.
And
welcome back.
That's the wrong week. They came in the
afternoon
one by one and and we gave them a prize.
One One year there's a kid who who
delivers a Divrei Torah and one of the
heads of school turns to us and says,
"Who Who's this kid? Who's this family?"
So we tell him and say, "Where's this
kid in school?" Said, "Public school."
And that head of school, that rabbi, who
might be the president of our school
now, said, "That child does not belong
in public No child belongs in public
school, but this child, that Divrei
Torah, that sincerity, that sweetness,
we got to get this kid in Jewish
school." And right after Shavuos met,
figured out what the obstacles were,
overcame them, overcame them, and it was
just a beautiful beautiful story. So,
check it out.
girls Threw a lot of love for that one.
ended up going.
Yeah. One by one. Let's catch up on some
of these comments that are coming in.
First of all, we definitely should
acknowledge that while we're talking
about this Shavuos is so hard, and last
year was so easy, we should not be at
all
um at all uh casual about that because
we're grateful to have to plan a
Shavuos. There are still communities
that are locked down, shut down. They're
still where we were last year, March,
April, May. And so, you know, we can be
extremely extremely grateful that we
have a Shavuos to plan. So, we're not
flippant or casual about that at all. We
are super super grateful. Someone wants
to know whether we still use the divider
for learning at BRS. Uh in the Sefardic
minyan, they do. In the Ashkenazi
minyanim, they don't. In the outdoor
minyan, they still do. Keep your
questions coming. Do you think this is
like an opportunity for a reset on the
way we we see we learn all night on
Shavuos? Like you started hearing year
after year that there were communities
where they would bring in uh you know,
sushi stations, and they'd bring in the
caterer, and this guy would have a
whole, you know, carving station, and
waffles. And Right. When I was growing
up,
JEC, there there was there was you
didn't bring food.
There was no food. You came and you you
sat down and you learned.
There was there were there weren't even
drinks. I'm saying
When I was first married, I and my
in-laws live in a community where I
spent a Shavuos, my first year married,
and at the shul, I was like shocked.
There were omelet stations and waffle
bars, midnight barbecue. I was like I
was like, is there any time to learn?
Can we
It's like, how do you compete with that?
Yeah.
We actually left out our most
successful, I think our most successful
program in all my years here on Shavuos,
it was a teen program.
Um when 13 Reasons Why first came out on
Netflix, that was all the kids were
talking about, and it there were a lot
of questions the kids were asking and
curious about. And Rabbi Gurevitch, you
did a panel with a mental health
professional in our community, our team
rabbi, about 13 reasons why. And I think
that might have been our most successful
Shavuot 19 program in in recent memory.
The teens The teens um
packed that night. They were all really
interested in it. Generated a lot of
conversations. And I believe we got
feedback later on that there was a teen
there who heard that conversation and as
a result reached out for help. And I
don't want to be over melodramatic and
describe that that panel saved their
life, but had a big impact on getting
the help
they actually said it did. If If you
remember, the email said that the person
it's not true. I just said I don't want
to be melodramatic.
Okay. You can be I'll be melodramatic
for you. We saved a person's life. Yeah.
Wow, Jay Keen corrects me that that
booklet on Shavuot actually was planned
and produced with our dear dear friend
Brian Galbut, Rabbi Dr. Boruch Twerski,
Rabbi Brian Galbut. So, that was one of
his brainchildren as well and and
result of his vision, his effort. We
miss him something terribly. We really
really miss him, so.
Torah marathon.
Right? That Torah marathon, that's what
it was called. That's right. That's
right. Good old days.
Yeah. Yeah.
So, go behind the bima with with our
listeners. We'll keep coming the
comments, the questions, the
conversations. We love it. You know,
somebody texted me right before we came
on, "Who'd you get? Who are the guests?"
I said, "We got great guests." They
said, "Who?" I said, "Us."
We're going to We're going to talk.
We're going to share. So, anyway, here
we are and we're happy to We're happy to
share some more. So, um we had a member
call me last week and um made a very
nice size donation, not connected to
this conversation, but said they were
thinking about that contribution and one
way it might possibly be used. And they
said, and this is not a This is an
individual I admire who's on a total
path of growth, phenomenal person. We're
so glad that he and his family are in
our community. But if I were to tell you
that someone came to me wanting to
promote a program for internet filters
for devices of adults and kids, this is
not the person who you'd probably
predict or from the demographic
religiously, even though that's an
unfair stereotype, that you might
predict. And yet he came to me and he
said, "I've got X number of kids they're
all over my house. Each one has a
device. I have a device, and I've no
idea what they're looking at, what
they're doing, what they have access
to." He said, "I have my IT people try
to look at it. I've tried to look into
it, and there's no good filter." So he
said, "Here's this money, go find a way
that we can offer a free license to
every member of for them and their
children to have something on their
device, but something moderate." See,
the challenge is there are filters which
will make you not even be able to listen
to Behind the Bima on your device, which
is cruel and unusual punishment, and
there are filters that do nothing. And
then the biggest problem is that our
kids are at least three steps ahead of
us and know exactly how to undo and get
around and, you know, disconnect the
filters. So the question was how to get
a filter. So I I was really moved by the
person's desire to do this and
commitment and generosity to help us
make it possible, but also it was just a
reminder that it's really, really
important to do. Unfilled filtered
unfettered access, adults, children, to
what's out there, it's it's beyond
There's nobody who's immune to the
challenges that can be presented.
So I think there It's It's It's a huge
problem, and I think, you know, just to
to hone in on that a little bit, I think
part of the challenge is is specifically
what you just said, which is that the
kids are always ahead of the parents. I
spoke to a parent last year, maybe 2
years ago, about this topic, about
filters and internet, and he said to me
he said, "You know, I give up." He said,
"At a certain point" he happens to have
a number of kids, upwards of seven kids,
and he said to me he said, "There's just
no possible way that I can keep track of
seven, eight devices every single night
wherever they're going." Don't forget,
they're not just on my internet, they're
going to friends' house. He goes,
"There's simply no way
between the television, the internet,
the Netflix." He goes, "There's no way I
can control everything." He said, "So,
I'm throwing my hands up in the air and
I'm just into education now." That was
his thing. He said, "I'm discussing it
openly with my kids. I'm telling them
I'm not going to be able to beat you.
I'm going to have to trust you and I'm
going to have to empower you." You know,
obviously that's challenging and you got
to know your kids to be able to do that,
but I empathized with the father. Right?
He was He was genuinely frustrated with
his inability to control and so he was
going to plan B. I think the other
challenge is is that so much of our
kids' work, certainly in certain
schools, is on the internet. So, they're
always on computers. They're always on
devices and they need those devices for
school work, legitimately. And so, to be
able to
That makes it hard not only to filter,
but it makes it hard to use it as a
motivator.
Meaning, you can't punish your kid and
be, "I need your device." Cuz they're
like, "Well, how am I supposed to do
school?"
Correct. Exactly. I won't do my school
work. I won't study for my test. I won't
Exactly. Exactly. So, creates an
enormous challenge for parents and and I
was actually talking to a group of dads
last night about this and they all had a
similar reaction, which is we try our
hardest, we're failing miserably, and we
don't really know what to do. So, we're
hoping
dad is struggling with it as well. You
know, you figure it out for yourself and
then try to figure out for your kids.
It's the same same problem. This week's
parsha Kedoshim to you. We live for
holiness, not happiness. So, how can we
You know what? I'll tell you the truth.
This individual reached out to me.
If if nothing else, of course we hope it
will do much more, but if nothing else,
if it generates a conversation in
families, if it generates a conversation
among parents, if it generates a
conversation for us adults, for
ourselves, to try to create some
accountability to one another, to think
about it, to at least become aware of
and and, you know,
recognize the the dangers and the
challenges of it. For that alone, it is
it is worth it. One of our listeners,
Shimmy, asks, "How do we get our guests
to come on the show? How do you convince
them?" To which the answer is very
simple.
We don't have to convince them. They're
so excited and eager to come on the
show. And this is not like this
the doors. Yeah, this is not empty PR
rhetoric cuz I want you to rate and
review and get the show listed higher.
I'm not exaggerating. The rabbis will
confirm. We get several emails a week of
people who ask, who are offer, who are
excited. Others who will reach out and
say, "I think so and so would be a great
guest. I would like you to put in
touch." I got an email today from
somebody who said, "So and so, a rebbe
at the Mir in Yerushalayim, very
prominent ram rosh yeshiva at the Mir in
Yerushalayim would be an amazing guest
behind the bema." I said, "They would
be. I would love to have them. I can't
imagine they'll come on." He said, "I
have a relationship. I think I can get
them. I'll make the introduction." So,
we'd be thrilled. We'd love to have him
on on the show. So, it doesn't take a
lot of convincing to get our guests.
They're excited because many of our
guests let Should we go behind the bema
about behind the bema for a minute?
Yeah. What do you look for in a guest?
Like what do people want to know always?
Like
Yes, let's go behind the bema about
behind the bema. So, our guests, there
are different buckets that they can fall
in. Our guests, there are the religious
inspiration guests,
the rav, the rebbetzin, the the person,
the scholar, the the righteous living
that we're looking to them for that
inspiration. There are the guests who
are not observant, but who probably
don't have an opportunity or a platform
to talk about the kind of things last
week. One of our our most popular
episodes yet, what was his name? Oh, Bob
Kraft. We had on Bob Kraft. We had on
Bob Bob Kraft and grateful to Rabbi
Schiner again for helping make that
happen. Um I don't know how many venues
or platforms Bob Kraft has to teach the
Pirkei Avot shiur that he gave on Behind
the Bima last week to talk about his
Judaism and so on. So, we we know it was
great to be able to have him on and and
we've had If you actually go back and
crunch the numbers of how many NFL
owners, how many judges, how many
billionaires, how many it's fascinating
the the breakdown of of who we had on.
Rosh yeshiva. We have other prominent
guests who are lined up and
scheduled and very very excited and
eager to be able to have on. I will tell
you this, we've mentioned it before and
we'll mention it again. Behind the Bima
does not pay one cent to the people
who've come on our show. We
fundamentally don't believe it's a good
use of the community's money. It's not
how we spend the money.
Um so we've never paid a guest, not one
penny.
There are podcasts, there are shows that
have dug deep into pockets. I'm sure
they got sponsorship. There's no
criticism or judgment of them for doing
it. Everyone's making their own
calculation how they do it. Behind the
Bima doesn't spend a penny on guests.
We're super grateful to all those who've
come on and grateful to those who will
be coming on. But we've had fascinating,
fascinating personalities and we're
looking forward to having the others.
And if you have connections and uh and
have recommendations, you know, again,
we have many scheduled for the near
future, but beyond, we'd love to talk to
you about that as well.
I find it
Our ask is also different, right? Our
ask is just give give us 5 minutes. Give
us 5 minutes of your time. Wednesday
night, won't keep you any longer. And
then once they're on, 5 minutes becomes
20 minutes, 30 minutes. And once once
they're on
5 minutes. The Jewish 5 minutes. That's
the ask. That's the hook. Correct.
Correct. That's how we do it. It's kind
of like last week, so Bob Kraft was not
available live, so you probably could
tell by the sunlight coming in through
his window at the time. Or he was in
California. Yeah, exactly. That it was
it was it was recorded beforehand. So I
happened to have have not been in Boca
and I was with my wife and I was like, I
got to go somewhere. I'll be back in 5
minutes. I just got to take care of
something.
So But she's like, why do you need to
take a microphone with you? Right.
That's the ask. That's the ask of our
guests and sometimes of other people
around us as well. All what we do to
bring Behind the Bima to you. And
childhood heroes.
And childhood heroes. And to make some
people's dreams come true. But we do
have we have the fantastic guests. We're
grateful to them. We're grateful for
their wisdom, their inspiration and that
you help us share it and promote it even
further.
One of the things I loved about last
week's guest, just to go back a little
bit and I know we've spoken about it. I
cannot tell you how many times I either
got texts, emails, or stopped in shul
the Shabbos by people who were inspired
to start learning Pirkei Avos because of
Bob Kraft. And to me, that's amazing.
People said they were so
almost like humbled by the fact that
here you have this NFL owner speaking
the words of our father, you know,
ethics of our fathers behind Pirkei Avos
off the top of his, you know, just like
going back and they said they were
embarrassed that they couldn't do the
same thing. And so they said to
themselves, you know what, if he could
do it, I can do it, too. And so a number
of people said that on last Shabbos,
they committed themselves to learning
Pirkei Avos with their family. Some the
entire perek, some one mishnah each
week. That's something they can discuss
at their Shabbos table. But they said if
Bob Kraft can do it, then we can do it,
too. And to me, that's an amazing Behind
the Bima story. I spoke to Bob,
Bob's brother-in-law and sister right
after the show. They called and they
said they were watching. They were so,
so happy with the way the interview
went.
So I said, why don't you start a weekly
Pirkei Avos with Bob? Just do a weekly
share.
A weekly share.
They loved it. They were
on why on why you Torah. We also might
start, we're we're we're toying with
this. We'd love to hear your feedback.
We're toying with starting a mailbag
from the mailbag segment of the show. We
get all kinds of emails, feedback,
criticism, compliments, suggestions
about the show. And that's just from our
immediate family members.
We get all kinds of
Right, we get all kinds of feedback. So
I want to share with you an email we got
after last week's show because hopefully
it will inspire you the way it inspired
us. Dear Rabbis, Wednesday's show was
really excellent. Bob Kraft, such a
Yiddishe heart. Having lived in Boston
for 38 years, I raised three children
there. We all know of all the good
things he did and are so proud of him.
Not sure the rest of the world knows.
Maybe now more people thanks to your
show. His wife Myra, alav hashalom, was
a tzadekes, she writes. In my 25 years
as chesed committee chair in the
community, Myra used to buy extra
Shabbos food through so-and-so, the best
caterer in the country.
Best kosher caterer in the country. I
should say his name if he is, Andrew
Wiener. And he and I would distribute it
to people in need. Yes, there were
people in need in Newton. She ordered
many a turkey and brisket meal, and we
dropped it off to families who never
asked for it or expected it. That's the
kind of person she was. Everything is
was done quietly without fanfare. She
never knew to whom it was going, and the
receivers never knew from whom it was
coming, all to save face. Amazing
people. Thank you for sharing it on your
show. So, we get great mailbag, and and
we'll share with you, by the way, the
good, the bad, and the ugly, because the
ones that rip us and criticize us,
they're also kind of fun.
I'll tell you something interesting
about last week.
right now?
I'll tell you No, I'll I'll tell you an
interesting experience I had last week.
We're not getting into the details of
it, but you know, we promote our our
show, Behind the Bima is promoted by us
or others on social media. So, let's
just say on one of the social media
platforms, the show was promoted, and
somebody had some feedback about a
particular guest or the wisdom of
bringing them, or and so on. And there
were some direct and harsh and
judgmental comments. So, I really
struggled. Should I answer? Should I get
involved in the conversation? Should I
respond? And then somebody told me, and
it was so empowering. I can't I can't
tell the two of you and to people
listening strongly enough how empowering
this is, and how much we have forgotten
and forfeited the power that we have.
Someone said to me, "Why would you
engage, and why would you get in
conversation? First of all, that
attention is clearly all the person who
wrote that wanted." Said, "Just delete
the post. If you delete the post, all
the comments go with it." And that's the
most powerful thing you can do. It's
your wall, it's your space, it's your
home, it's your reflection, it's your
wall.
Delete the post. If you delete your
post, all the comments that this person
those people
put there, they're gone with it. And I
was like, "That's so brilliant." It's
obvious and simple, and yet brilliant. I
don't have to think, "How can I answer?
How can I answer politically correct?
Should I respond? How do I respond? Do I
want to respond? Will it prolong?" I
just press boop, delete, gone. And you
know what? What's the person? They can't
have a tit for tat, they can't have a
complaint on you. It's my space. I'm
entitled to delete it. You can't hang a
poster on my door or my living room or
my kitchen if I don't want it there. I
can take it down. So, my wall is my
space. If I want to delete it, I could
delete it. And we sometimes I think
forget that we have that power.
And then you don't And you don't have to
respond to everything as you've spoken
about in the past that that's a struggle
for you sometimes to
you sometimes feel the need to respond
to everything and then you come to
realize that you don't have to and not
everything requires a response,
certainly certain emails.
Right, you get that email and the like
and
and you feel the text message, you feel
that everything you have to respond, but
you don't need to. For sure, you don't
need to.
Right.
Um
another topic.
Sefirah beards.
Mhm.
to give my wife credit, so I'm in good
shape on that one, but I might go into
the dog house now, but Sefirah beards.
You like it, you hate it.
Hate it.
You love it.
It just gets Itch. It gets itchy. It's
not comfortable.
I get people coming over to me saying,
"You look more like a rabbi." Which is
nice. Nice to hear that, but I can't
wait to take it off.
Let's say Let's put it this way. Both of
you look eligible to learn Kabbalah.
Kabbalah. I'm not there yet. I'm not
there yet, but
yes, it
this way a little. Turn this way a
little bit, Rabbi. It's not my favorite
time of the year, but I guess that's the
point. Who's got more white there? Near
Rabbi Miller.
Not my favorite time of the year.
Turn to the left. Let's see.
There it is. I love Sefirah beard. You
love it. Not the neck part, not the
itchy part,
but I always am excited to to grow it in
a little bit and it's not always You're
going like full on yeshiva with it
though. Like you're really
You got it working there. Well, part of
that's just Sefirah, but Part of it is
cuz it's cuz it's white. Okay,
exactly. That's definitely a big part of
it. Definitely a big part of it, but I,
you know,
the old the old Sefirah beard. Um
we've not been sponsored yet by a beard
oil, but now that we're three rabbis
with long beards coming in,
don't underestimate the beard oil. Very,
very important. Very important. Beard
oil.
This might be second to our trading
recipes on the show. This might be
second in the conversation.
the skin under the beard, moisturizes
the follicles, and it treats the the
beard. And the longer your beard gets,
the more important it is to use beard
oil. You don't use beard You don't use
beard oil? No.
Is that in addition to shampoo?
Okay, next topic. Yeah, I was going to
say, move on. Move on. Go back to the
mailbag.
Four in one.
We're going We're going to the mailbag.
If anybody has a First of all, keep the
comments and questions coming. We love
it. We love your What do you want to
hear? And if anybody wants to jump on,
we'd love to have you. Yeah, the
spin-off of our show behind
feedback last week also for the behind
the beard.
Behind the beard.
the Boston Bruins have a show like that,
I think, behind the beard. Um anyways, I
pop culture are very popular now. Like
they're coming back. There's a whole
world of
Well, it's trending if you go to Yeah, I
was I was in Israel. There's a whole
part new new new group that that that
wants to run for the Knesset. It's just
the beard group.
They're not working on the We have a
member, actually. We have a member who
comes from Crown Heights and started an
entire campaign in Crown Heights about
beards and hipsters, showing that the
hipsters and the and the Chabadniks have
a lot more in common than they realize,
because they're both growing the beards.
And he did a whole video.
Um we should actually send the link out.
It's a whole video. Do you remember what
it was? When the hipsters came to Crown
Heights, there was a lot of conflict.
That's right. There was conflict. The
hipsters were creating their bike lane
right through the Chabadnikers, and it
was a challenge. So, this amazing
individual who's joined our community,
what a bracha to us. There we go. Keora
Labs is going to be sending Keora Labs.
We will promote the beard oil.
This is my beard hero right here. Talk
about the beard hero here.
We need it before we shave it off.
And Keora Labs is my beard hero. I've
I've been watching that beard for a long
time. His and Rabbi Simon Jacobson.
Keora Labs, amazing company that wins a
lot of awards, not only for its
products, but how it treats its staff
and customers. We love you, Chaim. So,
thank you thank you for that. What was I
What were we talking about a second ago?
Oh, the hipsters. Oh, the hipsters. No,
so you remember what he called it? He
made a great logo of a beard and he and
he called the program unite the beards
and he made like a great night with beer
where Chabad guys and hipsters and Crown
Heights got together for unite the
beards in order to bring a sense of
unity together. It was just a brilliant
brilliant view, a brilliant brilliant
idea and you and he ran with it. So, um
How much How is your sleep, guys? How
much are you sleeping these days? Uh
I just started going back to the gym, so
now it's it's it's a lot less.
Gym
you why I'm asking. 5:30
that question come from? I'll tell you
why. I'll tell you why.
Article in Article in the New York Times
yesterday. I don't like to mention that
newspaper by name, but article in a
national newspaper yesterday whose title
is sleeping too little in middle age may
increase dementia. First of all, this is
a classic This is a classic I was
reading it. Tell you how tired I am.
You're reading it 4:00 in the morning.
No, I was reading it sleeping too little
in the Middle Ages. Like, what do we
care about how well they slept in the
Middle Ages?
Cuz By the way, the only person who
would read it that way is like somebody
who learns Rishonim.
Somebody who has to say all the
Meforshim, you know, our commentators
from the Middle Ages. Who else would
read in 2021 a headline middle So, the
sleeping too little in not the Middle
Ages, but sleeping too little in middle
age may increase dementia risk study
finds. Research tracking thousands of
people from age 50 on, of which none of
us are there, suggests that those who
sleep 6 hours or less a night are more
likely to develop dementia in their late
70s. Oh, it's terrible.
sleep 6 hours or less a night from the
age of 50, you're more likely to develop
dementia in your 70s. That scared me.
That has
say something?
I have to wake up in 6 hours and 9
minutes, so I got 9 minutes left. Why
Why do you wake up so early?
I got to go to the gym. What time do you
wake up? Actually, it's 5:00 a.m., so is
my math off? Yes. 7 hours. Yeah.
No, but I will tell you I believe it cuz
when I was training for the Boston
Marathon last year, which I did not run
unfortunately,
one of the things that my coach told me
and really drilled into me early on is
he said if you don't get enough sleep, I
promise you you will get injured and you
will flame out. He said I promise you. I
said ah, I don't need sleep. I'm fine,
you know, when you're in your Shiva,
it's like a sign of being macho to get
as little sleep as possible. Well, the
first couple days running, I was going
through my night regular schedule and I
couldn't function. And my body wasn't
recovering well and I came back to the
coach and he said, "Yeah, exactly." He
says, "Your body needs the sleep in
order to recover." And he says, "The
less you give that time to your body to
recover, you're not going to be as
successful." So, I believe it. You know,
again in your Shiva, getting little
sleep is a sign of honor. It's a badge
of honor.
And not all of us get as much sleep as
we should, but
it's something to aspire to.
I agree with that and I think that we
need to change that culture. I'm guilty
myself of it and of not owning this
issue. Um but we do, we have this
culture of of the business syndrome. So
busy, crazy busy. I don't sleep. How
little do you sleep? How much do you
sleep? You know, but the most impressive
people we probably know probably do get
enough sleep because they've prioritized
that and they've scheduled their life
around it. So, I don't think it means
they're sleeping in 11:00 a.m. or
they're sleeping, you know, for a nap in
the afternoon necessarily, but it means
they've prioritized. They know the sleep
they need to operate. They need the
minimum and they know how they can make
it up. I will tell you that I won't say
balancing out this article, but there
was an article on a scientific study
that said that you can make up sleep on
the weekends, which I loved how that
study fits perfectly for Shabbos.
Shabbos. It said if you're sleep
deprived during the week, because people
will tell you, "No, you can't make it
up. You need it every night. You can't
ever make it up." This study said that
you can make it up on the weekends and
that is shaina b'shabbos ooh ah, sleep
on Shabbos. It is the best, but sleep is
important. Do you find that as you got
older, you don't need as much sleep and
as you can't sleep late? Like I remember
back in the day you could sleep on a
thing you know
Well,
you can or but I am
I'm definitely without a doubt more
productive and I more important than
that I'm more creative
if I get enough sleep. Mornings where I
don't get enough sleep, I can function,
I can go through the day, I can go
through the motions, but in terms of
me being as as as productive as possible
and more importantly me being as
creative as possible, sleep definitely
helps that. Listen, I was reading
Yeah, sorry. No, no, we we've designed
chemically these band-aids that don't
even that mask and don't make us realize
how much we need sleep. So, whether it's
coffee or whether it's
you know, caffeine pills or Monster
drink or 3-hour energy, 5-hour energy,
however many hours energy. So, you know,
so we basically we feel a little
sluggish, we drink another coffee.
Jeffrey asked me today I walked into the
office it was like 4:00 and I was making
another one of the coffees in the
Keurig. He says, "How many of those do
you have a day?"
Right.
Like four or five.
Do you really? Yeah. That's a lot. Wow.
It's black also. No no milk, no sugar.
So, I drink one coffee in the morning. I
have one coffee in the morning, one
caffeine in the afternoon.
But what I did is I'm so tired all the
time because this is an area I need a
lot of work. So, I I just I used to have
like an 8-oz cup. I got 16 I got these
huge cups.
wondering why you got those. I bought
these huge cups because psychologically
I still feel like I have one cup in the
morning, one cup in the afternoon. My
cup happens to be twice the size the cup
used to be. It's still
one in the morning, still one in the
morning, one in the afternoon.
Yeah, wait till next year. It's going to
be a bucket.
Yeah.
cup. It happens to It happens to be a
great example of we recognize in our
lives areas that we need discipline,
eating, speaking,
what we look at. Sometimes we don't
think of sleep as a discipline. It's
like I go to sleep when I can and I wake
up when I have to and it's just not an
area that I have control over or that I
or that I need to be disciplined. But
But study jarred me, it really jumped
out at me because it was one of those
classic examples of yeah, run yourself
ragged in your youth when you think you
got it, but the study says you're going
to pay you're going to pay for it one
day. Dementia is terrible. Again, just
to to to push back on the utopia of you
and I going to sleep at 9:00 at night,
the challenge is it's not feasible. And
I've tried it. But when you have
children in the house who have homework,
who have responsibilities, by the time
your kids I don't even go to sleep
anymore, but the time they don't need
you anymore, it's 10:00 at night, 10:30
at night, 11:00 at night. You and I are
doing a lot of teaching at night,
sometimes to 10:00, to 10:30. It's very
hard to finish teaching. Last night I
finished teaching at 10:15. It's very
hard to finish teaching at 10:15 and
being asleep by 10:16. You're wound up,
the adrenaline is rushing. Agreed, but
let's say but let's say yeah, but let's
say you made the commitment, a
commitment you make to yourself, which I
think are the commitments that we
violate the most.
Right? In our time management, our
exercise, our eating, our prioritizing
our own learning. It's easy The
commitments we'll make to others we
really feel. I'll tell you what, my dear
friend Rabbi Yaakov Glasser, um
who heroically donated his kidney to his
father. This is an amazing story. He
used it in drasha in his shul. I'm not
stealing it from him, I'm borrowing it
from him. So, Rabbi Yaakov Glasser
donated his kidney to his father. A
great, great story. A great, great,
great, great people, he and his father.
So, before he could donate his kidney,
he had to get in shape. He had a
nutritionist, he had a health expert,
someone guiding him, getting him in
shape, taking good care of him. So, he
did it and he got himself into the shape
he needed to be. Surgery happened,
donated his kidney. Thank God his
father's doing well, he's doing well.
So, the nutritionist, this health expert
calls him a few months later and says we
need to make an appointment. He's like,
why? She said I need to see you. So, he
comes and sees her and um and basically
reviews, how are you doing? I need to
weigh you, I need to see how you're
doing. He's like, what what's the
problem? Like, you you gave me great
habits when I needed to get in shape in
order to donate the kidney to my father.
I'm good. She said, you don't
understand. Listen to this. Listen to
this insight. She said, you don't
understand. When you were doing it for
your father,
I'm confident you would stay with it.
But now that it's for yourself, I'm
worried you're going to let it go.
So when we do for others, it's sometimes
much easier to be disciplined. But when
it comes to the promises we make
ourselves or the things we're doing for
ourselves, it's easy to be like, "Ah,
I'll sleep more. Ah, I'll eat better.
This I'll start diet tomorrow. I'll
learn a little bit extra on this end."
So we burn the candle on both ends. We
totally neglect ourselves. And I think
this is that, you know, it is an area
that needs that discipline and it's a
harsh reminder that we will pay for it
one day if we don't if we don't take
care of it when we're young. So that's
why the Rambam said 8 hours. Jeff Bezos
apparently said 8 hours. You got to get
8 hours of sleep. We should be a badge
of honor and a point of pride.
4:00 every morning. Bob Iger, former CEO
of Disney.
goes to sleep 4:00 every afternoon.
Right.
Doubtful, but okay. What time does he go
to sleep?
I I didn't ask him. It wasn't in It
wasn't that part wasn't in the
autobiography. Great autobiography
though. If anyone wants a really
motivational, inspiring story, Bob
Iger's autobiography, The Disney Story.
Mhm, interesting. Would you believe that
we're almost out of time?
What are the books you guys reading?
What are you guys reading these days? I
see Rabbi Brody's got his book shelf
right I'll tell you what I'm reading.
I'll tell you what I'm reading. David
Mueller's Houdini book and David
Mueller's book about being in the
mosque, The Jew in the mosque, the
distributor of halal meat. And he posts
week after sponsoring the show I'm still
getting calls from all over the world. I
heard about your book of mine in the
Bima. Some very renowned people. So we
highly recommend that book again. It's
worth it. So you should read that book
while you're putting in your beard oil
from Keora Labs.
While
with a big thank you to the Strauses.
You too.
While you're booking Lenny Friedman for
a musical concert after
booking Lenny Friedman and while
wherever you are you're getting to know
a Shryer somewhere.
A new question we have from one of our
listeners as we are rounding out our
show to guests. Who needs guests? While
we're rounding out our show tonight
being It's a It's a little fun with I'm
saying it's fun when we get into it a
little bit.
Yeah. Isaac wants to know any tips.
Any tips for someone going to Israel for
the year next year? Ooh.
Any tips?
most of it. Do you want me to go first?
Yeah, go ahead. What's your tip?
Know yourself, and I really mean that. I
think there's so much peer pressure in
Yeshiva to act a certain way, behave a
certain way,
um jump skip um jump steps that you
might not be ready to jump just to be
able to fit in. I think one of the most
important things I realize now in
perspective is how important it is to
know yourself. Every one of us is
unique. Every one of us is different.
Every one of us has different talents.
Just because someone might be great at
learning Gemara doesn't mean that you
can't find your own place in learning
Gemara, or maybe your place in learning
Machshava, or learning Chassidus, or
learning Mussar. But, I think you really
have to know yourself, and everything
else goes forth from there. What you're
going to learn, the type of person
you're going to become, it all comes
from you. It can't be dictated because
someone else tells you to be a certain
way.
Well said. Well said. I'll say something
that's probably very radical, and I
don't think that anyone's probably going
to listen to me on this one, but don't
bring your phone. Don't bring your
smartphone. Like, if you need a phone,
like we figured out how to go a whole
year. We spoke to our parents once or
twice of you know a a year maybe. At
least what I did. I don't know if
What was that game, Snake? As long as
you had Snake on your phone.
You take advantage. You'll be You'll be
lost in the learning. You'll just enjoy
the year. You don't You get one year
off.
Leave it at home.
Immerse yourself. Immerse yourself. You
can't be 100% immersed if you've got
that phone buzzing every 2 seconds. You
can't.
I'll give you a third piece of advice,
which is
get the most out of your year. I think
even more now than when we were there,
there are really comfortable, convenient
places to stay. Some people's parents
have apartments, and uncle, their
cousins have a American style home. So,
you just stay in Yeshiva or seminary, or
you go to whoever has the best shower,
and the best bed, and the best food.
But, you're missing out on the on the
Chavaya, the go around Israel. You're
missing out on those weekends which will
transform and change your life. Go and
explore the rich tapestry of the Jewish
people. Go to places you'd never go. Go
to Bat Ayin for Shabbos and Chevron. Go
to Bnei Brak for Shabbos and go to
Tzfat. Go to here, go to there. People,
the the Rebbes and the teachers and the
Morahs and the and the Yeshivas and
Seminaries, they're amazing. But they're
also extraordinary people all over
Israel. Find their classes, get
experiences, develop those
relationships. Take advantage. Totally
take advantage because too many people
take the easy way out. They never leave.
The whole year is over. They never
really went to where they wanted to go
for Shabbos. It's those Shabboses, the
informal experiences, which will change
you forever. So, go with a plan. Go with
a list of what you want to do. Go make
it happen. My daughter, I'll tell you a
future guest on Behind the Bima, my
daughter is in Israel for the year.
Called this week. She called Rabbi Benji
Levine, Rabbi Ari Levine's grandson.
He's been to Bnei Brak for Shabbos. So,
one of my other daughters went there for
Shabbos. She left me a voicemail. She
was like on fire just from She left a
voicemail. She just said, "My name is
Liora Goldberg. I'm from Boca. You know
my parents." He said, "Hi your parents
at the shul in Boca and your
grandparents and your sister."
You know what he said? He's such a
tzaddik. He goes He goes, "It's April.
How come it took almost the whole year
for you to call to ask to come for
Shabbos?" Rabbi Ari Rabbi Ari Levine, a
tzaddik in our times grandson, right,
grew up in America. Great great person.
We're going to bring him on Behind the
Bima. So, my kids go to Israel with a
list they've got to experience. They
already went to Sha'ar Ayin for Shabbos.
And you know, the the the experiences
all over Israel, those are the things
that Your teachers are amazing and
learning Torah is amazing, but the
people, the people of Israel and the
experience of Israel, pss, nothing
compares. Really really amazing. Really
really amazing.
So, with that, gentlemen, we're an hour
in and end here. It's been a great show.
I would say this is Behind the Bima on
Behind the Bima.
Behind the Bima of Behind the Bima? Of
Behind the Bima. We're behind the Behind
the Bima. Behind Behind the Bima. That's
a good title. So, when the show gets
posted, Matthew, let's call it behind
behind the Bima. Want to thank our
listeners and the people who have
commented, asked questions, and uh want
to thank all those who take a moment to
inconvenience yourself. Take a moment.
Open your podcast player and rate
review. Everyone right now, we'll shoot
right up to number one. Everyone take a
moment while we're on the air. No, take
a moment. Take a moment to subscribe on
YouTube. Be notified in real time every
time we go live with a learning
opportunity. Grateful again to the
Strauses for sponsoring and thank all of
you and tell you until next time. Stay
happy, stay healthy, and stay home.