Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Hi, this is Dovid Orlofsky with our question
answer series where in a few minutes we try
to answer questions from our listeners. Now, this
person is apparently in Florida and I'm guessing
from the question he lives in Boca Raton. There's
a blood drive in Boca. That's that was the hint
that I picked up on. Yeah, that goes to the local
hospital. I believe that Boca is like 50% Yidden.
Some percentage from and some that is
not. Is it at least a Kiddush Hashem? 100%
I want to I want to tell you something that uh um
is a scary. Uh I knew somebody who needed a heart.
Needed a heart transplant. Now, we have a
problem giving donating hearts uh because
um you can't really be dead. If you're dead, then
the heart stops and then it's no good anymore.
You have to take the heart out
while the person is still alive.
So, what did they do? They came up with something
called brain death. There was a secular um
science writer who wrote a whole book on this and
he pointed out that there's never been a concept
of brain death and all the mistakes that are made
with it etc. etc. and you know. So, they came up
with brain death so that they could take the heart
out of a person who's still technically alive.
So, that's why for us it's obviously problematic.
A lot of donations are problematic. A lot of uh uh
donations that are given. There are those people
who of course are much more lenient after you're
dead uh to give a cornea or something like that.
But um uh but we don't participate in transplant
donation the same way. So, I heard somebody say,
you know, we don't give organs to from Jews cuz
they don't give to us. And uh I heard that and I'm
a much machid. what a frightening thing that is.
So, I'm not saying that halachically we should
do something that is problematic. Yeah? Um
but giving blood, that to me is a no-brainer. It's
it's First of all, half of it's going to a Yidden,
so there's a very good chance it's going to go
to a Yid, whether they're from or not. Yeah?
Um I I I I think that we can participate
in saving anybody's life. But for goodwill,
we find halacha will occasionally make
exceptions when it comes to non-Jews
um because of exactly that. Yeah, to be able to
keep goodwill, to be able to make people happy.
So, if we can give blood, we definitely should.
That's my opinion. I would encourage anybody who
can. They won't take my blood cuz I have
hepatitis and apparently they're a little
you know, skittish about taking people's
blood with hepatitis in it, you know? But
but if if you're healthy and you can give
the blood, you know, by all means a person
should. I encourage it 100%. This is Dovid
Orlofsky with our question and answer series.