Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Why They Only Duchan on Yom Tov In Chutz La'Aretz Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 128 Seif 44

332 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

Okay, good morning friends. We're continuing in today we learn we're in middle of me dalled. We're in the middle of says the custom is in our communities that we only because we are dwelling in the joy of and someone with a good heart he could give a blessing but on other days some people are preoccupied with thoughts about their uh business even though we sayurim mutarim yeahurim when I say we say it's from the mirror mutarim ra says I think in in safer that even though you're now to be in yoururim of but the reality is many are and we're somewhat saddened that we can't work why only by because by we are in proximity to the suda and the the whole idea of why we is because [Music] we're so we try to juxtapose it to the as much as possible and therefore any we don't Just like even though we don't have a suda some places they even some places even on says the I'm sorry back on the previous page. In the land of Israel and in Egypt every day, the poimog now in the Galilee says the min Not to during the week only of shabas and says is that true in the only by they don't during the week in the north they don't during the week he doesn't know what this is based on the tries to explain it and he says they shouldn't change their minhug The Alvi says those who have already changed their Minhug, we don't have the power to restore it. Okay. Somebody who comes from who left to live in the Galilee, Rabos says that he should not and follow the min of his new place. Um let's say a group of Israelis come to Brooklyn and make says they should not every day they should be only of so there's a new sh in my neighborhood that you could have in any you want you could have ink there's like a wheel and you just turn it. It's a minion factory. And recently they put up a signing every minion. So is that correct? No. The minimum in America is not the it doesn't matter what your country of origin is unless I guess but it would be hard to say and it is the thing is it's a minion factory and you could dab in whatever you want. So it would be hard to say that you could d whatever you want but you but you could buy every minion. Wow. I said what do they do in that factory? They they do. Yeah, that's what the sign says. The sign says um every day. Now if look invari would say not to in America I don't think so. So let's say had a minion factory and let the it's hard to mix the two. You're going to let the any he wants. So that means Yeah. Okay. Anyway, let's continue. Um because then we're and whether it's a weekday or shabas by The says something very interesting. It's the if the isro and their mispel on their the says it's better for the kahan to shak than daven for the because through it's What about that are init? They're ding in their own minion and all they have is a so what's the question? What? But in every day anyway, what's the problem? He's under the no I'm sorry that are in. So what's the problem? Why can't he have why can't the says he doesn't have the courage he doesn't have the audacity to m the says you can Because sinceabour this is a required so then he could become to but I don't understand the problem. Why? Because the gab him it's not mus he doesn't in musf on that day I don't see the problem. So what like you were saying before the minion is a minion of the mayor every day. So that minion like but that minion is but it's so even people right what's the problem cuz him he can't mf you as many times as you want a day I don't understand the question what Is that come to in a place where they don't usually could they make their own and can the stipler said they could? I don't see how they could. That's like that's what we saw before that if they mean if they move here permanently they can't but if it's temporary they could. Um says no they can't. I don't see how they could. Um some places they don't there's no logic of this minu says that the basis of this is for the that a who's a bali cannot and since it's shabas they didn't go to the mikvah the says also since after the you say the and shabas we don't say so therefore they had a min the the brings it's not say even if you want to be just because you want to be not as but I don't understand that either as if what only on Shabas there's a mitzvah of and not le there's Le there's no mitzvah yam every day in the week. What? Every day in the week here kind of have to every day. No shabas is specific cuz it's okay. Um, this doesn't have an accustom to to uh to beautify themselves to uh a a high practice, a majestic practice to be on because of the next day and even without that every person has to himself for nevertheless this is not by the way this is one of the only places where you're going to find that the mishaba seems to say you need to go to the mikvah of yam here it is the gam Now if you look in um the the quotes the Maril that one of the reasons why is not and only for Yam is because of Balker another re couple reasons are beta and also there used to have goyam in the bases. Now what's the reason why why in the world do you need to yourself? If you're not being the pre brings and brings that even there's of the says it's only however the says even if we had the apher the parad The whole reason to be is so that you could go to these are there's no that's the adds the only applies when there was a says says it's why is it can't create a mikdash you know you got to be uh you got to be maybe an amo to make a z mikdash it's roy does and but the shalom says it's what does the hold says that's what he says you need to okay as the garra says that [Music] The Rama is that on even people are in their food and onto says the the language is a bit garbled. Heaven forbid that holy would be on Shabas that they can't work. What's more correct is that it's false and because of it's going on other days. It's going on weekdays. The breaks up being preoccupied with thoughts of business and meaning is going on Shabas is going on the weak. Okay, Rabbi Sai, we will pick it up here tomorrow in CIF Me. Um, please join us tonight at 8:30. We have an amazing shar on the 10 highlights of the Benes on [Music] McGillas. Have a great day everyone. Recording stopped.