Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay, good morning everyone.
I'm going to give one more day till we
start the new topic.
First of all, today's a tinus. So I
don't know what people's schedules are
and also we need to
give uh advanced notice so that you
could gather your friends, your
relatives, your associates, your
acquaintances, people you know, people
you don't know to join us starting
tomorrow. So today we're going to we're
going to do
okay the Rambam writes
The coal of was extinguished
that had remained viban
and it caused that the whole galos
should be removed.
The mishaba says on this third day of
tish gadalia was assassinated. He was
appointed the leader after the of the
small remnant
Israel because when Gadaya was killed
they were all exiled and many were
killed.
Okay. If you look in the infer
the Ezra this is recorded. However,
comes the B
in
and the B brings from
that
they say that he was not killed on this
day.
He was killed on rash
and we pushed off the [clears throat]
fast.
So there's a historic
question. When exactly was Gdia
assassinated the the Ram says
the B brings from no rash. Is there a
navina says? Yes, there's a big navina
says. If someone has a ma and some
gdala,
normally if you make a ma on a fast day,
the bal habris has to fast.
Except if it's a tish of
tishka is more lenient than other fasts.
Tishka is even more lenient than a
regular
than a regular.
So on a tish of na the bal habris
breaks his fast and makes the suda on
tishab
so too says the taz if someone made a
bris on
so the would be the balabris would break
his fast why because is fundamentally
it's even more lenient than tishab
that's tishab that's aka would break his
So
says, "No, no, no, no, no. That's not a
good comparison."
Everyone sees that it's pushed off
because it's not being observed on
Shabas. It's being observed observed on
Sunday. So everyone sees the
they see that the was on Shabas. It was
pushed off.
the first time it happened they pushed
it off and they decreed fundamentally
that it's always observed on the third.
So therefore the gazer of is always on
the third and it's not pushed off and
therefore a bal brris would not break
his fast to if he made a bris on
the rabba
[snorts] brings
and the taz and then he brings in the
end if you look in the
he disagrees with the taz he says that a
balbrris would break his fast
comes the mate Ephraim and the mate
Ephraim brings me that Gdal was assassin
Rashashana and was pushed off.
Therefore,
normally a woman who gave birth then on
a tinus sib a woman who gave birth fasts
contrary to contrary to maybe popular
uh practice
I'm not saying that there isn't what to
rely on but according to the technical
a woman who gave birth she's [snorts]
not within seven days or she's not
within a month.
So she fasts on a regular tinus unless
she's experiencing um
nevertheless on the matim says she could
be why
she could be withash
because it's somewhat of a fundamentally
also the mate says if a brisma comes in
on
and it's hard for the bow bris to fast
so the mate is not willing to rely on
this indiscriminately but the balbrris
and it's difficult.
So then he dins after after six hours
after
and he could eat and he's not mash the
fast. [snorts]
Interestingly, the Gabriel brings down
that
was
and therefore it has a
Gabriel says
fores
or for a
for a mass
or a brass abras.
>> [snorts]
>> that they could eat after
not all are willing to rely on this
leniency that the B brings from but
combined with other factors. There is an
element that Gdalia perhaps could be
considered aid. By the way, I have a
safer uh that Rabbi Raf Rafalitz gave
me.
These are pisque
of the
and in tough
theor brings from the ezra
in zakaria
that gdala was killed on the first day
of rash and theor says well that's
contradicted by the shas by rash and
comes the
will end with
There are pkim that hold you're allowed
to fast on rashashana. According to the
pisk you're lad rashash shana why did
they push off so gadalia if you're
fundamentally allowed to fast on
rashashana and gdala was assassin
rashashana they should have been the
fast on rashashana the fact that they
push it off doesn't that indicate you're
not allowed to fast on rashashana
so comes the sh
And he says Rashashana
that really Gdala was assassinated on
Rashashana
but he was stabbed but he didn't die
yet. He didn't die until the next day
and therefore they were not the
that's why the
shuck
so he was attacked on rash and his was
on accordingly
would not have any status of being a
nida because not only was it
it was never it didn't happen on
Rashashana. It happened on S Gada. There
was a tragedy that occurred on
Rashashana. But the uh pet of Gdaya did
not happen until the 3rd of Tish. Okay.
So, uh you have 24 hours to gather your
friends and your neighbors and your
relatives and your acquaintances to join
us tomorrow for the start of
a major in
Hang in there.
One more minute.
>> Recording stopped.
