Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Correct.
>> Okay. I want to share with you something
on
if you remember
the gar discussed in the Mishna
a guy who says
I'm a nazar on condition that I could
drink wine. That's you know what a what
a condition.
I'll be you know it's like I'll be
Jewish on condition I don't have to keep
the Tyra. you know, I'll I'll uh I'll
learn shas on condition. I don't have to
learn gamarra. I'll you know, I'll uh
put on fillin on condition. I don't have
to put anything on my arm or my head.
What exactly does it mean? I'll be a ner
condition. I don't have to drink wine.
So Gomorrah says no it's
asked the following question
asks
there's no way to be a through a
we say that a has to be similar to the
in other words only a that you could
fulfill through a
only only excuse me only [clears throat]
only something that you could do through
a could you make a tai you can't make a
nether or you can't make nazerus through
a I can't say I'll be a nuzer and then
someone and send someone to be a nazer
for me. So since there's no way to
fulfill
then you can't make a we learn out in
that you can only make a
where the act could be done.
Sois answers other people could bring
carbon of nause for you. So it's
considered it's a misa that you could do
through a but says kash is why does the
gar have a problem that it's it's
there's another problem there's a
different reason why the shouldn't work
because the msa cannot be be fulfilled
through by the way asks in the goas
why is the reason of
mashra
a worse reason than the reason to wants
the garra to say that it should not be a
good because you can't do the ma
why isus's reason better than the reason
the garra gives but that's to's kasha
why did the garra have to say it's not a
good because you're stipulating against
thera it shouldn't be a good because
it's an act that you can't do through
okay so I want to share with you
brisker's answer to this question.
Now, where I come from, it's a little
bit of a problem when you have an answer
to Tyus because Tyus didn't give that
answer. So, that means Tyus doesn't hold
of the answer. But
is uh
from the greatest
uh of the
So let's let's learn's
answer to Kasha.
I'm going to put it up.
Um here we go.
Where is it?
It's found in Kush Maran Riz Halevi.
Okay,
here we go. I'm putting it up for you.
[clears throat] It's the first Grizz in
Hilus Nazerus.
there.
Then he brings fromus
the tyus says other people could bring
the carbon for you. So it's considered
like you could do it through
Riker asks like we pointed out that
this still doesn't answer um other cases
in the durim
where you could make a and there the you
can't do through.
So the brisk brings the following from
he says
that that
you could make a
because you don't need to know to make a
by other areas. of Torah. We learn out
tonight from
Benu, right? We all know where do we
learn out the laws of from Benuaz
you don't need to learn out from benu
but because if you say something and
that this item should only be standing
on certain conditions
then
in that case
you don't need
it's aimed
there's something lacking in your
articulation of your commitment
You don't need a special to learn from.
You need
[clears throat]
if it was not fulfilled according to the
way you stipulated.
This is not included in man in his oath.
It's like if you made a nether under a
false pretense or if you make a with its
pes with it.
Why? It's not because this is a regular
forim. It doesn't have to be similar to
there meant there's a a more fundamental
loophole. Why? If you make a stipulation
that's unfulfilled, then there's not
it's [clears throat] because you didn't
articulate it. It's you're you didn't
mean it. You didn't mean it. Durham, you
have to mean it. If I say I'm going to
make another on condition that
that the clock changes, if the clock
doesn't change, the reason why it's not
an is not because I learned out from Ben
G Ruain that it's not an Ether. It's
because there's a special requirement
that a nether has to be enunciated
with your heart meaning it.
It's not because
The reason why it's not a good
is because you can't you can't make the
you can't make the misa through. That's
not the reason why
the of anderos do not need to be learned
out from this is a tremendous
inad
that when we're discussing the
stipulations of an this is not like a
stipulation of kaducen or other
effectuations.
It's different by a nether. It has to be
annunciated with the full participation
of your intent. And if this stipulation
is unfulfilled then it's lacking in your
kavana. It's lacking in your intention.
>> Okay. So
>> similar to what the ter was like
>> is that similar to what the garra is
saying?
Well
it's not at night. He was he was giving
specific conditions and because you
can't so therefore it's not a
>> well what about the fact that you're
stipulating against what the Tory says.
So what why doesn't work for what
the Garra says is answering's question
wants to know why didn't say that
tonight doesn't work because it's
So is saying no we're not the den of
learning out from
the that has to be
that's we learn out from
that's the
is not learned out from
but
that sounds like that's not because it's
not similar Tonight
ruin that's because you can't make such
a condition that that condition is null
and void that must be different. You
want to know is
ultimately the garra says in uh
in levy
that
And by the way, what's what's the lumbus
of ammonas?
Since it's
so according to you, you need to make a
nether from all aspects of nazeros. So
it's fundamentally flawed. Not sure. I
don't think it's the same thing. Ram
Shivan is saying that
it's like you excluded that aspect of
Nazeros and in order for Nazeros to be
you have to uh accept all aspects of
Nazeros. Okay, I wanted to do something
on Diodar.
I just I can't find the original source.
My Rebiker doesn't have it. I I have to
search further. I couldn't. Uh so we did
something on Yud B and Yalef. I think we
have to do at least three more. So stay
tuned. Now this week I have a wedding
Monday night. Um
and so it might uh we might do
tonight
a little bit earlier than 9:15. Okay.
And then Tuesday night. Stay tuned for
the further scheduling. Thank you very
much.
Um,
>> recording stopped.
