Selling Holy Items For Items of Equal Holiness - Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 153 Seif 4-5

Okay, good morning everyone. We are continuing in Can you plateau? Could you stay on the same level of kadusha? Some prohibit and some permit. The says it's obvious that we're talking about there's another place to d because if you're gonna sell a shul for something else equal, it's better you're not going to have a place to den in other words or it's better to go up to buy a shul. You don't want to be stuck without a Let's see the You sell an old and you want to buy a new one. [snorts] Now again, the says we're talking about where there's another in the meantime. So again, the misha says the situation is you're selling an old sh and you want to buy a new one. So some say it's because you're not going up even though you're not going down. It's it's only when you could go up it. But when it comes to a where there's no room to go up, everyone would agree that if you sell it, you buy another one. This is all but you're not to sell any matter of to buy an equal one. Even if you're not concerned of negligence, let's say the other matter that you're going to buy is right here in front of you. All you're lacking is giving the money. Why? You have to go up. So, let's say I got a and I already have nine sets. Am I I'm allowed to trade it in for uh can I trade it in for shagasar or no? I have to now I have to be I have to buy I have to buy safer tyra now because you have to go up in kadusha or I have an old print of a safer now I want to buy the new print. I'm not allowed to give it back to the store and buy a new print. I have to keep it and go and buy the new print. If there's an issue with the first one or it doesn't work, it's too small. So if you have a shul that's too small, then for sure you could sell it to buy another one. We see a lot of people selling and buying others with their money. How are they allowed to do it? They're not going up in Kadusha. So I thought the mishan because there's no room to go up. So you have no choice. Can't say by everyone knows that it's done as o when they give it a they know it must be >> what a guy what about the guy who put on the safer may ace mishbah freedman. So now he doesn't want me to give it back to the store. The guy engraved on my safer who the the noise was. I once had that on a guy gave me a says you know pli. So I went and I paid money to remove his engraving and then I gave it. But that was allowed to do it. It was a kdish cup. What about a safer? So listen to this. He says, "And now days in the beginning when you buy a book, when you buy a safer talking about the is that you're buying it and it should be yours for as long as you need it. And if you're going to get find a nicer one, even though you didn't explicitly make this tonight, it's like you made the tonight. So whenever you buy a safer, you're buying it with the das that you could always exchange it. Does he mean for or is he takarim? He's talking about Let's see. Um, this is note 13. I don't see note 13. It's on page 17. Okay. Um, I don't understand what he's saying here. Why do you need this? Tonight, the Mishna said that in the you buy a nicer one. I guess because that was only but you're not allowed to everyone agrees you can't stay on equal footing and even the holds by safer but meaning everyone agrees you're not allowed to. So what's the people do it today? It's because it's like you you purchased it to be able to get a new a better one when you want to. Says it um that you're sell to get a more mud one. And the pisk also says this. However, says then mhud is not an Eloyd. That's what I would have thought. How is how is let's say ter has more kaduca? I wouldn't have thought so. I wouldn't have thought it's an elo kadusha. It's better but it doesn't have more holiness. It's more sanctified. You could put it on top of the other one. Very interesting. Okay. An individual has rights of sale on his personal. Okay. lived. If you collected money to build a ordin or a handkerch or a cloth for the now you want to change the purpose of collection. You collected it for a certain holy cause. Now you want to use it for something else. You you collected it for a you collected it for a base. Are you allowed to change the cause? You can only change it for a greater cause. However, if you use the money for what it was intended for, so you could use the rest for whatever you want, says the it's going on what we're about to say. We don't change. Question. What do you mean? If you collected money for a safer and you want to change, but you're not allowed to by safer. So why are we talking about the case of safer tra? You're not allowed to. What do you mean? You're not allowed to. So the first answer is you're not allowed to. It's it picked a safer case for the that for it you're not allowed to. Or there are things that you could sell a safer for namely supporting. Okay, we'll hold it over here in the >> recording. Stop.