Purim: The Chasam Sofer's Lazer Sharp Question of Fulfilling Hallel With Krias Hamegilla

this Torah class is brought to you by Torah anytime.com okay good morning I want to speak out somewhat of a lus on Pim on Milla so there a famous gar says like this thank you that throughout our history we had 48 Nim and seven female n and the says they didn't detract from what it says in the Torah they didn't add to what it says in the the only thing the N ever added was Mill nothing else they didn't tamper the N did not add they did not subtract the only addition made was M wants to know so why did they add M where did they get it from where did the get M from says they made it what if when we left and we left from servitude to Freedom we sang times of where it was from Death To Life wanted to kill us and then our lives were saved all the more so we should sing Shir Rashi learns and this is not the we're going to learn today rash learns if when we left which was from we sang sh certainly in the times of we should sing shash what does it mean from servitude to Freedom rash says when we left yeah so the shagas asks that's also that's not right learns from when we left famous between rash and but we're not going to get into that right now um so they made a I just want to speak out just off the bat the not we're not up to the the main writes in many places writes his to think about it means making how do we know if you learn something right so it come out yeah but nobody says that says says that if you look in the B um there's a there's a that M and and all the mitz that we do on and there's such a that it's says where does this come from he says you could you can make a to any of the M that we do whether it's or whether it's and say that they're CU make a if when we left which was only we needed to remember it with some kind of token gesture of so when a miral happens from you need to do something to commemorate on a level so the says it comes out you know like let's say a irreligious Jew yeah who puts up a happy it's the who came along and say do it this way like the or lay the you could do any and formulated it so even though you know sometimes you look well what's the guy doing he's lying his electric Min he's putting up a sign what's he doing he's remembering the miracle which is a Biblical obligation okay that's that's a different we're not getting into that today but again the gamar says what so now here the this is the question we're going to get into if so why don't we also say when we left we said so why don't we make the same from we said all the more so we should say that's the million dollar question asks why don't we say don't tell me because we do don't tell me because we do we don't okay so the gar gives a number of answers right the first answer the is don't say you know what kind of answer is that before you could say sh you could say Hal for a miracle that happened anywhere enters you can only say in other you can only say in by the way what's the logic of that why would you only be allowed to say Hal in a miracle that happens in not in a miracle that happens in what the says that the purpose of Hal is to recognize that this is a supernatural miracle from only the rebish and not through the agent of any Mal so therefore says Mar that the the rebish only deals with directly in it's not as direct can't say for Mir that takes place out of is in so you could say Hal but was in however before we entered what what I'm saying saying that was where was was well you know it's a big M between the Palestinians and the No No but but you have to remember from Remember The Two of saying there's miracle and then there's yam so yam you could always say h you can say Hal for any yam for a nest The Nest has to happen in AR right okay so that's the first answer wasn't having jurisdiction over so the Tak was also on the so he's saying it the okay but still the miracle didn't occur you know the the miraculous chain of events that transpired to save CL so that occurred in shushan I guess didn't occur in AR is yeah the Jews were saved fine now the says another answer this is the answer everyone knows reading is okay and then the brings another answer I understand how you could say because when you say in that's a true statement where we're not but how could you say h for por um says we're still the Servants of we didn't have freedom from and therefore we can't say Hal so yeah the gives three answers first answer you can only say Hal for Ling in Milla is and um you can't say Hal because what's enoughin between these answers would be if you missed Mig can you say how very good what let's say a person doesn't have a Milla let's say you know bakari gets up he's looking at the gab knew gab where's the Milla gab said I don't know where's your miguela you're in charge you know this is not it's not Chris at you supply the migu said I don't have miguela there's no Miguel in the H so there's not going to be Miguel s when you're in a certain town so now what do you say Hal or not so according to the answer you can't say Hal cuz it happened in so he can't say according to the answer that can't say according to that according to should say and you do say Hal now it's very interesting the writing in the 1700s thei was only discovered in the century they didn't have thei before this Century the in his travels he saw it in these libraries in the museum he memorized did and he records in the that he saw when he was traveling the that if you don't have now 200 years later they found the and they prove you know the's memory was correct that's what I'm going to discuss right now I want to tell you the famous Kasha of it's so famous that I first learned it last night but it's a it's a famous K now it's going to be famous the you ready Danel yeah you sure okay is like this Born Ready he was born ready says like this the later on a very important the gar the mishna the gar says Hal yeah do you have to sit when you say Hal do you have to stand when you say Hal what's about HAL anybody know you have to stay standing why because it says so you got to stand when you say Hal so now the sh is what about when you lay in the M do you have to stand when you lay in the Milla no the first Mish the third parak the Mish says may you could sit when you L when you're Ling for you standover Not A din in the Milla there's no D that creat how Miga has to be standing so why do you have to why you sitting if is so fine you want to sit fine but you should have to stand it's the that it's that's the says I prove it to you because says this is the RAB pasin that when you say you need to stand why because since says is a form of therefore you need to stand when you say so says by the same token when you lay in the Milla you should have to lay in the Milla standing yeah that's the maybe that's what they were Ming they Ming do hollow their way without without standing it's just we already existed to go back to the original thing so there that you should go ahead and say the way we say Hal right in this they saying say Hal however you want to say Hal and maybe you wouldn't even have to say Hal if you if you didn't read Mill maybe it's only through reading the Milla which they say you can go ahead and read sitting so what what do you mean even if you wouldn't in the Milla you wouldn't have to say we said already the right so you want to say Maybe not maybe not maybe what they were M was that they can go get you can go ahead and say Hollow through cus Milla and that's how they were Ming the H okay and that way they again they weren't M whether it's I'm saying even in that there were M Milla however they were most of it however they added on they said you can do it sitting why is it so ask you another the says they didn't add the only thing they added was is that adding they made a so that's what I'm getting at they adding they the OFA what then that you can in but the gamar the gar just say that they added Chris Mill and on that thear happens to have a Kasha why don't you say how Okay so to answer the you sort of have to argue on theer but on one the says they only added says that could be because of so the in his commentary to the H to the shst called h the says there's one there's one over here that you could argue on and is very clear that there's a different way of looking at it when says that might be every year is do you have a source that every year where's the from is from how many times did CL sing Shir one time we do that every year no yeah but that's to remember what they did but there's no D of singing sh every year she saying that year they had to stand so the says that the that the only right has to make is all you have a right to to learn out is at a time of a miracle you have to sing but every subsequent year you have no that there's to sing Shir now you want to know maybe the came along and said well in the first year Isa so let's do it every subsequent year that's what they added that's the addition the addition is for every subsequent year but that year that's not a not in fact says that if you look in the the sh says you have to sing Shir yeah that's exactly true that's the that they but how about every subsequent year on the says and the tells the whole story and then the says the next year they're and all ask why the next year why not that year what are they waiting for the answer is cuz you don't need the for that year that year you don't need that year you have but the is just arguing correctly but the only exists for that year it doesn't exist for subsequent years subsequent years say yeah what's is that they were then and it seems like it was for that year and future oh but not it said one second that year they celebrated I don't know does it say they [Music] were again according to even if say right it's not the I think well that's a different you know did they make a we spoke that Friday night tried to Institute They didn't accept the unless you say that the first year is from every subsequent years only only made it they didn't make it okay so let's take it one more step comes in and then says you know we mentioned that the that if you don't by the way the r R says that you don't say the ra could have picked any answer the ra picks the ra picks that reason so says therefore if you don't have You' be to say then says his understanding you wouldn't have to say Hal why because in year one so there's say so if you don't have a how you going to just fulfill how you fulfilling your saying but in year two the whole m m is only the and with M fine but if you don't have Milla maybe the would never they were uh so could be the answer to the question is why you don't have to stand for is that the wants to know why don't you say Hal so what's the the answer the answer is laning the Milla is Hal i what does that mean laning the Milla is halal that just means you're not to say because you're laning the Miga now you want me to stand during laning the M because it's not the the is a it's that did not obligate you to say since you're already laning the Miga so you want to know well if I don't have if I don't Lan the Miga now I should say Hal not maybe in year one if you did yes we would say in year one if you don't L the Miga if they couldn't come up with the Miga they would have to say Hal every subsequent year it's only and therefore the it's not the it has to have the of Hal it's not that theilla is the laning of is the reading of Hal it's that you're exempt from saying Hal because you ready lay the Milla yeah do you have to stand the first year the first time they did Milla if it's the right the first year yeah the come out that uh the first year they had to stand in the ti What yeah for holl for for mcgilla they had to stand yeah maybe oh why is there any recording to what Jews did in concentration camps who like I mean like during the Holocaust probably that the main application of that what they did like I mean that like why I mean they might not have a m so Oh you mean when would there be a case again this no no I'm just saying not when would be a case what they really how theying right you want to know like what happened in the H they didn't have a Milla did they say hello big right big when the conation comes what is recorded so again thei says you do say Hal I doubt they had AI then but by the sh Chua brings down that you don't say Hal you don't say Hal it's interesting they they tribute this to different people um say this idea they attribute it toaz they say very nicely what's theot that you have to say Hal for a miracle so a miracle normally happens it's an open Miracle you see the ym openly so therefore you have to acknowledge it in a clear open way the the the miracle of PM you didn't see hasem openly it's basically a chain of event each one could have been random but the the fact that they all these random chain events came together the Yem is Manifest in a very hidden way it's manifest through the combination of all the seemingly random through H yeah so therefore the Hal also has to be done beer so how's the Hal done beer by laning the Milla in other words the the same way the miracle happened in a hidden way in a way where Hashem was not manifest so the the Hal also has to be says blaz says the Hal has to be in a hidden way how is the in a hidden Way's name is not in the Miga so you lay in the Milla and from reading the the story that's like a a hidden Hal so that's the concept of shouldn't you shouldn't say so according to yeah exactly he uses to say more why Tak if you don't have a Milla you don't say Hal because the in of Hal on on perm has to specifically be in this type of way in a way of have a great day you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by Torah anytime.com