Parshas Bo: Practical Applications of Amirah L'Akum

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay before we begin we're safe for Ezra just want to speak out something interesting on the Parsha um there's a pause look in this week's pasta pastures by parakeet base it says call malacha Ibrahim all work should not be done on them so it doesn't say you should not do the work it says the work should not be done parishes boy yud Bayes tazayantha darshans for you and a guy cannot do the malacha for you so it seemed from this makhota and if a guy does malasa for you will be in because learning it is darkening it from the possible and in fact that is the position of the smug and that's the position of the uranium and Simmons however most we shine and disagree with that and mostly shine and learn that Amira akam is only Anissa drabana so if it's a message what is the reason for the Israel I know I'm not allowed to write on Shabbos I'm Now to turn on a light on Shabbos but why can't I ask a guy to do it for me what's the problem why isn't it writes for him today they're almost says if you could tell a guy to turn on the lights so then turning on a light is going to be a lenient thing you'll come to do it yourself so Tennessee drama it's a safeguard we're afraid you'll come to do it yourself that's what the round mom learns Rashi on the other hand Rashi contradicts himself she says it says there are certain things you have to be careful about one is taking care of certain uh needs that a person has you have to be careful what you say in other words you're not allowed to talk about you can't talk to your friend about your business on Travis so part of what you can talk about on Chavez is you can't talk about your business and you can't talk about doing malacha so if you're going to tell a girl to do malacha for you you're violating so now it's not it's now it comes out it's us you can't talk about Chavez is also because of schlichus so cool in other words if the guy turns on the light for you it's like you did it yourself it's like you did it yourself okay these are the three basic reasons why it may be awesome The Ramones reason you can't talk about malacha foreign by the way according to rasheem Shabbos that Amir al-aqim is also because of schlichus that for you so then it may come out why wouldn't we say then that it would be an it's a director to have a guy for you if you hold yes so then it should come out then a muralakum is in a sudarisa because the guy the guy because the guy is doing malacha for you and according to the opinion that yes okay this is the famous question of the chubasua okay that according to this logic of Rashi in that it's awesome why would it not be answered so the Samsung Cipher quotes this question of and soifer gives a very important answer says that could somebody else put on to fill in for you why not [Music] right your body has to perform the Mitzvah could so why could I tell us to marry this woman for me for me goodness the answer is ah my goof doesn't have to do the act of giving the money I have to do it and I have to make sure it's done anytime I have to make sure something is done I could have someone do it for me anytime I have to do it my body has to do it my body has to put on the toll and my body has to sit in the sukkah my body has to have the talus on so that I can't have a chef do it for me but if there's no Indian that my body has to do it if it's just that I have to make sure it gets done so whether I do it or I send an agent it would be the same thing oh so let's say when it comes to desecrating Shabbos the Mitzvah of resting on Shabbos where the midst or the violation of of is it that Hashem doesn't want Malachi to be done or Hashem doesn't want my body to do malacha so we may have said what is Revenge of not want on Shabbos he doesn't want malacha to be done so that's the case so then if I tell a guy to do malacha then I'm not fulfilling that Mitzvah of making sure Malachi is not done or maybe that would be called that God wants the world to be at rest so if either I'm violating that or I'm asking a guy to do malacha for me so then either way is being done and there the world is not at rest but another way to look at it is the same way Hashem doesn't want villain to be put on he wants my body to put on filling Hashem doesn't it's not that Hashem wants malacha not to be done it's Hashem wants my body not to do malacha if if there's a Mitzvah of uh the midst of Shabbos is not I should make sure work is not done in the world it's my body has to be at rest so it's my body has to be at rest so then if I ask a girl to do Malachi for me my body's still at rest so therefore there's no Israel rights of asking God to do malacha Kyle's question about the verb oh no so obviously the rambam and Rashi they have to learn that plastic is only a smacked Obama because they learned Amir akam is only in a job our question was why wouldn't there be in this the answer is the same way can't put on film for me Ashley cannot desecrate Shabbos for me because Shabbos is incumbent on my body the midst of Shabba says Hashem wants my body to be arrested my body's at rest the God is doing them Allah so I'll tell you uh a little hello maisa what do you do you come home Friday night if you if you hold that your body has to be at rest so if the guy does him a lot it's not that your body but when you have when you give the guy an instruction to do Melaka for you you stop thinking about it you're wondering did he do it right but it's not like no your body's at rest your mind is still thinking about it there's no it's still here hurry mutarim there's no it's there thinking about I think not allowed to think about like uh not sure no hella like that really we say Ryan's videos you know immersed in it but there's no issues if you think about sir okay so what do you do you come on Friday night and you were oh my God may start singing song Good you sure you're allowed to sing so I'm listening um but by both sides you come you see your the your car's headlights are off are on now what do you do okay don't go off automatically yeah what would a person do they see the headlights are on so it could be a hefted maruba the battery the car battery could die so what do you do are you allowed to ask a guy to turn off your headlights Sunshine so the first thing you have to know is if you're in a dark room on Shabbos and a guy comes in on on his own and he notices the lights are off and he turns on the light what do you have to do you have to leave the room you cannot get enough from it not again I know he didn't you didn't ask him you didn't ask him no he's staying in the room and he's doing it what's he doing in it no no he invited him to your Shabbos meal he came into your house he he was your electrician no he was the electrician he happened to in that case yeah yeah you can't have to walk out of the room you cannot get Hannah from the malaza we're going to Travis you didn't ask him he did it for you on his own yeah you have to leave the room you have to leave the room you know how to be Nana oh he just flip the switch you got to leave yeah no it's okay yeah right he happens to be in your house you got to leave the room you got to walk out of the room oh so if he put it on during the day and there's light anyway so he's not really creating a new benefit he's just enhancing the situation that's the difference but I'm telling me Friday night it's pitch black he turns on light you leave the room okay but oh fine I leave the room about what happens the next day the light is still on but do you have the sunlight coming in you have sunlight coming in so you could basically use the room without him so you'll have to stay for you even if you don't ask him it doesn't help you still can't get benefit from it but if your headlights are on and the guy on his own comes to you and says oh I see your headlights are on I'm gonna turn it off you can give him the key are you you're allowed to let him do it you're allowed to accept the offer why but you're now to get benefit from the Malachi of a guy on your behalf on Shabbos the answer is this is not called Hana turning on alive you're getting positive benefit from here you're not positive benefits yeah it's prevented it's preventative one second it says I want to put on the lights she gets him no he can't do it you have to tell them you can't do it more than that I said more than that there's nothing I could do this is so I'm just telling you have to disagree with someone I'm saying more than you you don't like elenia I'm telling you more the guy walks into your house on Chavez he sees the light is off he turns it on you gotta walk out you can't get her enough from Chavez she said what about air conditioning what about heat every case is different I'm talking about lights talking about turning on the lights you can't be Nana from the light on child that's fine in case of the headlights can you give them the key so one second so if the guy on his arm so first step number one if the guy on his own says can I turn off your headlight on Chavez you're allowed to take him up on the offer because that's considered indirect benefit it's preventive the key for getting to the car again if he asks you you could take him up on the office okay what if he doesn't ask you chances are if a guy sees your headlight to Iron Man Shabbos he's not going to hey come over oh I see your headlights on could I please turn it up chances are that's not going to happen so if that doesn't happen you could go out into the street find the guy and you could hint to him you know it's really a shame that my headlights are on because the battery is going to die you're allowed to do the remisa yeah he may not have very likely he says yeah it's a shame really it's a shame the battery is gonna die no knock knock you know fine what if he doesn't have so then you're allowed to ask straight out to the guy really turn off my headlights on Shabbos what do you mean if he offers on his own if he goes in and turns on my lights to man sometimes I gotta leave the room I can't even enjoy benefit without asking him and now you're saying you're allowed to ask him directly to turn off the headlights yes why because turning off lights is completely different than turning on lights turning online isn't a sir Daly Rise of skila and it's a positive benefit turning off light is not necessary there's no interest turn the light off on Shabbos why foreign because in the mix Dash they extinguish fire to make coals I'm not turning off my light to do anything I want it off so it's a Milwaukee the only time there's an Easter directive turning off a line on Chavez is a you're you're putting out wood a fire of wood logs to make coal or your take you're extinguishing the candle because you want it to light better the next time so if you're if you're turning something off you're turning off a fire because you want something out of it that's the asadai rice but in most cases of turning off a light most kids are turning off a lot you don't want anything out of the fire you're not taking you're not deriving anything out of the fire doesn't go to sleep the line is on I can't sleep with the light on turn on the fire rope that's not direct coming off no you're not directly benefiting from your Google it's indirect you're benefiting from the lack thereof not from the creation of anything positive so let's just talk about this case this case one second this case this is this is a open for the active this is a very clear but you can't have the guy even on his own turn on the light for you on Travis turning off your headlights so now it's now by the way the rambam learnsa but mostly China same location this is your battery's gonna die I'm the best thing is have let the garden realize on himself if he's not hint him if he's not you can ask him explicitly turn off my light now what if a light is on and somebody can't fall asleep or let's say an alarm is going to go off and it's going to wake you up five o'clock in the morning it's gonna disturb your sleep so you're not being Nana from the malacha you're trying to remove a nuisance right that also you show me let's must have the guard return but to have a good turn on a light on Shabbos can't do it can you turn you set the alarm for you to go on in the morning if you want it to come on set the alarm no there's no direct benefits no no is delay but it's the red there's no life you're going to show what what where's it you're going to Shabbos is going to be late yeah your neighbor's car was also Jewish it has the lights on a guy is not allowed to take it off or turn up the light but you are allowed to turn off the light oh yeah okay yeah that's a different story okay you're going you're going and your neighbor's car has a light on yeah you know what he made Shabbos he how come he's not allowed to ask you to do to turn off the light the Duke really yes we could ask a guy but no the Jew himself didn't make shopping yet he can't shut it down you could do it on my own because not Chavez but here if it is Shabbos can't have a guy turn on a life for you on channels okay that's amirula awesome you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com