Mishna Berura DH - Siman 39 Seif 1 Can a Mumar For Issurei Shabbos Midrabbanan Write Tefillin

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com we're continuing a mission abbrev we're up to similar mid Tess we're a middle of Sif alef the Macabre said that Phil and they were written by inevit and Isha are cut on even because it says anyone who is not bakshira anyone who's not commanded in Shira anyone who doesn't believe in Shira um then is not big Siva so we are up to miss because likewise publicly so in Simmons what does it mean to be a mumar to be Macau brings if you do it in front of ten Jews or if you know 10 people know about it but what if you don't know if it was in front of 10 people Vega writes the duration quotes as long as it's not known definitively he's not a mummar okay what if the person is outright but he makes a mistake he thinks he's allowed to do it in other words let's say do you keep the Sabbath yeah I keep the Sabbath what don't you do I don't make fires okay do you use electricity yeah that doesn't say in the Bible you know don't say in the in the talmud it seems like that might not be a mummar certainly if the guy let's say he brushes his teeth let's say he doesn't know Stam Hill regular Shabbos so then it seems like he would not be a mumar okay rice let's say he's a mummer for other avarice let's say he wears shortness is even for one thing he has the dinner of a guy who is that in such a case not only are the children past some some say that such still a need uh even if he doesn't do it this individual is not a barakashira levad it's in other words someone who does not wear it fill in cannot write to fill in foreign unless the person was imamar let s the PO the person was in foreign let's say the person doesn't wear it to fill in because he has to get to work so then I die in Huber Clarks here in other words the guy said yeah yeah it's fun is very important I I do wear it full and how can we haven't worn in a few months uh you know it's a really busy season I feel bad about it so then then such a person could ride this is even others standing upon him because that even if he is publicly foreign by the way the duration quotes that in Simon Shin pay hey Civ cotton hey the Mr Brewer brings aquarium that hold a person it does not become a mumar to be I'm through hello but this is the primagadam primagadam shita is that if someone's house like for example muksa later on is masupek about muktsa but here the Prima Gotham says it pretty definitively or Heights even if he's not doing it he's doing it he enjoys it even if he does it one time so because anyone who's not big Shira is not big Siva bakshira the evidence okay look in the beer with all of these it doesn't help if somebody's standing over them and they see they're doing this is not a lack of leshma over here this is the lack of being fundamentally disqualified from being able to produce this villain so that concludes Sif aleph with your permission we're going to do Sif base we have a double header today and tomorrow just uh in order to stay ahead okay so let's let's see Sif base another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com