Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
okay good morning
everyone we're continuing
in we're
learning we're at the end
of the said
in that that forgotten he didn't sayu he
doesn't go
back even if he just finished
Ru and if he does go back after he
said then
it's but he rather
say it's
a that
is because he has to go back and say
an if he's going to go back and say
he'll have to go back and
say another time so that the should be
in order we saw yesterday that whenever
you go back even already said you have
to repeat so that they're in
order
namely
after you don't go back
if he forgot and he said in the wrong
place he
said he
said I'm sorry he
said says you got to say it again who
asks you to say Anu before
the explains that the need to
be and if you
say and then it's not it has to be
after you have to say in other words
what's the problem here you put Anu in
the wrong place no the problem is not
you put Anu in the wrong place the
problem is you put in the wrong place
has to be
after cannnot be
after
an says you have to say it
again is not so sure about
this why the primam explains that the
saf
is is the location of
Anu daa aftera therefore you have to say
it again
aftera or do we say look you don't even
have to say Anu an is
not so is if if an is not how could the
location of an
be right that sounds pretty logical if
you if you don't say it entirely it's
okay so how could it be if you say it in
the wrong place then you have to D it
again but then the
adds maybe it's not the location of
that's but it's a and has to be after
and when you say Anu you're making a so
it's not going to help so now the
problem is well if that's the problem
how is it going to help to say Anu after
you still didn't say re in the right
place in other
words the says well say Anu again well
that's not going to do anything because
the problem was not that you didn't say
Anu in the right place the problem was
that you didn't say in the right place
because you are M between it and
SL so the the says he doesn't understand
the
mug if the issue is if the issue is that
you didn't
say in the right place because you Mai
between and Anu
so then it's not going to help to say it
again you didn't put on in the right
place but if you don't even have to say
it then why would it be to say it in the
right place so I don't understand that
maybe you don't have to say it
but you do have to say it and the place
to say it is
after so say it
after I I think I understand the m in
other words the m is saying let's say I
didn't say an in the right spot maybe I
have
to say it
again
anyway says maybe you
don't and if you want you
could let's say that the same D would be
if you don't have 10
people like this let's say you don't
have 10 people fasting in the
sh from here we see if you don't have 10
people fasting you don't say an as a
separate says us later
on now there's a question whether this
applies to the tin seore that it's kava
so what's the case over
here um let's say you didn't have 10
people fasting in the
besses and then they come
after then the shots says it
and what if you didn't have 10 people
then the I guess wouldn't say it in
either let's say when the
started
ding had 10 people were fasting and they
left before
Anu he should not say Anu
I would have said he should say ano
usually it goes
by the beginning of the subject matter
if in the beginning of the subject
matter you had the requisite
she actually I don't understand why he
wouldn't say Anu because right now you
don't have 10 people fasting it does why
would it Go by now doesn't it Go by when
you
start but
the if you already started
then it's grandfathered in but if you
just started it's not grandfathered
in
mhm I wouldn't have thought this in fact
I don't really understand it why would
Anu not be like any other in other words
let's say the the
starts with a minion and he doesn't have
a minion could he f of course he could
finish so if he's allowed to finish cuz
it goes by the then why would Anu be any
different because you don't have 10
people fasting it doesn't so what are
you going to say is a is
a no it's not it's
part
what why not you need there's a you need
you need 10 people to say the word
an no there's no such then that you need
a min to say the word
watch see I did
it if nobody's fasting of course you
want to
know sometime
saying fasting or it is I don't know
what he's
saying saying if uh if you if let's say
when he was saying the word Anu he said
Anu you had 10 people fast and then they
walked out he finishes it right I but
you can't say you can't say no the
answer is your grandfather then so the
of grandfathered in we know go by the
beginning
of
no you say
what's the
case so he sticks it
into so the is
saying you don't
say
like let's say the forgot even in
then he shouldn't say
it this is very
interesting if who
forgot or
the because the doesn't say why is he
talking about a over
here maybe even the says it after in
other words what's if you forget on on a
fast day do you could you say it at the
end of so here the m is saying you say
after you say the word before
s
um page
34 number 28
and you say it before you
outside
H by the
way
um
thein that even if you don't have 10
people fasting the shots always
says so in this
case let's say you didn't have 10 people
fasting in the
besses you don't you don't have a minion
fasting then the shots doesn't even say
it
in holds you always say it in
paskin you only you don't say it in in
so the points out the that if you didn't
have and then after you
have is even according to that you don't
usually
say when you don't have a he would be
here but certainly who
says that if you don't have 10 people
fasting you still say it
in which by the way I think you could
ask on that as
well if when you started the you didn't
have 10 people
fasting how could you just in middle of
change courses and inject it into sh it
doesn't go by the beginning of it goes
by why do all the other of go by the
beginning and when it comes to it goes
by
it's very interesting okay let's begin
Simon should
we we'll start
it you know what we won't we won't start
it okay we're going to hold it over here
we'll pick up we'll start with K on
Monday yeah maybe somebody could think
about why does the din of Anu
why is it not grandfathered
in that if when you started sh you had
10 people fasting and then some of them
left you should not say
Anu you're allowed to say kadus no
you're allowed to say
kadus yeah why I
a I had it but now I don't have it no
grandfather in
so fasting is
different okay say have a good shabas
okay ctive
everyone recording stopped
