Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 94 Seif 9 If You Davened Sitting Do You Have To Daven Again?

79 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay friends we're doing a double header today we're doing C test till the end of the Simon um says someone who has to sitting wow let's say somebody wasn't feeling well and he has the DAV sitting and then an hour later he feels better and he could stand he needs to DAV again standing and he does not have to anything says someone who's going on the road he's close to hotel if he could turn aside from the road so that way fares don't interrupt him he should step to the side he shouldn't D in the hotel so that the people of the hotel don't disturb him so you know back in the day I guess the hotel was more of a public situation you know you maybe you slept in a bunk bed the guy on top of you was a gal the guy on the side of you was an IM and you know it was a it wasn't a conducive M for so you're better stepping off the road before you get there because otherwi when you get there the people staying there might disturb you if you cannot move to the side of the road in a place where people will not interrupt you should pray in the hotel in whatever corner you are able to says sh um wow if somebody DAV sitting and now things are better he standing he has to DAV again what does that mean where this man did not pass really that's a you have to so that means what you're ding on an airplane because you didn't think you'd land on time and you DAV sitting and now you land and you still have an hour to DAV so now what now uh you have to DAV again yeah the M says you have to DAV again meaning the points out earlier in he wrote M says that if you're M that by the time you get to your destination this m will still be present you should wait and not DAV while you're sitting so here we're talking about the guy calculated he thought he might miss his M so he Daven sitting or or he was anus by the way I just want to point something out in we spoke about a who daved um in his heart CU he wasn't feeling well so Mish said that if you get better it could be you don't have to DAV again because you're an oess so why over here do we say that when you get to your destination do you DAV again weren't you an O at the time you daved to DAV sitting let's see the miss this is not like where we hold that we hold that when you you have to innovate something new but here you don't have to in innovate something new so I guess my question is and men's going to write it down why when it comes to somebody who's sick and he doesn't um he's not he's not able to say the words if he's even though by the way we pasin that you should say it again but has a strong side you don't have to and daving sitting that when when things look better you have to again we don't this way says you don't have to DAV again that Wayfarers do not DAV again when they get to their destination friends what's better you have two possibilities for shots one old who's confined to a wheelchair and one a guy who's not a who could stand on his feet says rash the guy who stands on his feet has has uh precedence so like we see here that when youav sitting your okay continues he wants again as if he's confident that he'll be able to be in even though we're not again if somebody wanted to again he would not have to that which he's ding standing who that's the Innovation over his previous from that it is not nowadays so basically if you're traveling and you're sitting don't D again so the best thing is if you were traveling don't D in the hotel go to the side but if you're in the problem is in a gentile Hotel they have you know what a getka is I hope you know from from first grade a uh you know a statue of aara they have all kinds of ab abominable get you should not bring in there matters of what about to Davin in a base Tios of Reform or conserv you're not in a reformed conservative says when I leave the city then I'll pray it's interesting the rad doesn't say straight out what the issue with the hotel is he says the issue is the so the are not but the says straight out it's because there's there ah there's AER in theama you see we didn't read it wrong it's not the Rama is not trying to to cover up listen carefully you read the r it sounds like the reason why you shouldn't D in a hotel is sh that's not the reason the reason is because they're there the word is going on that when you can't move to the side of the road ding in a corner of a hotel why in the corner so that people don't disturb you but that's not why you shouldn't D in a hotel the reason you shouldn't have D in the hotel is because they're there the reason you should try to find the corner is so that they don't disturb you you don't what about the G the answer is if you don't have a choice you don't have to worry about the gkas because where we live they're gkas everywhere anyway all of our prayers are in cities full of if in the East world that you want to pray toward let's say you're about to DAV and you're want to face the m and you see there's a y over there he's staring you in the face or there's a getka over there so now what you ding East but if you ding East you're diving toward no all you D into a different side and the the explains you're not allow to bow down toward it even if it's covered in glass don't bow down to a gka I mean come on your whole life you've been good about and now all of a sudden you're going to a hotel and you're going to start bowing down to a gka come on you're a good guy why would you do that so dive into a different side even though it's not East let's say somebody's confined to a bed and it's one of these you know hospitals that they have gkas everywhere so the if there's no way to move to the side of the road and you have to walking sitting and even the hotel you know you won't find a corner is permitted to D on the road sitting or walking cuz that's your best option if you could find some kind of Valley in the hotel or this way you all the requirements and you could pray standing and withana okay so that's that completes our double header okay have a good day everyone