Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 90 Seif 7 Not Davening Behind the Shul

this Torah class is brought to you by Torah anytime.com okay good morning everyone we're continuing in Zion Simon Sadi Zion the and the are continuation of places that you should not dve in okay a continu some places that you should not D in so s said don't D in in an open area like in a field because when it's in a place the on you don't D in a ruin because of Suspicion and because it might collapse and because of in other words and don't behind the if you're not going to be facing the sh in other words don't D on the back side of a sh with your back toward the sh the back of the sh is the side that the door opens into which is the opposite of the side that they face it's the opposite of the side that the see faces when they in other words according to the first is the side that the door is in which is opposite the side that they face when the some say just the opposite meaning basically behind the East wall where there no there's no way to get in and when your back is toward the sh even though you're facing the right direction he's called a Russ because it's like your back is literally toward the sh so basically one shot in the the first is rashi rashi learns let's say um here you see this this is uh this is the sh the aress here the m is here so the first of Rashi is you're standing here facing that way facing the other way you're facing the marav the of the other the is you're literally standing outside of the sh with your back toward the and your back toward the people even though you're facing the right direction but nevertheless you're it's like your your back is toward the seor therefore um you should be concerned for both opinions even when you on any side outside should to face the issue here is if it's recognizable that your back is toward the but let's in a house near the and you're facing properly and let's say your back is toward the wall of your house which happens to be the wall of the it's not recognizable that your your back is toward the it's only let's say when you're outside and it's recognizable that your back is toward the sh okay friends um says it would seem to me that which they say by behind the this issue is not during it's not during it's not during during and you're you're also you're not up to the issue is when the and so are you that it's not limited to this circumstance he holds if even not in the at that time says that is your davening on the side that the doorway is open to you know theoretically you could have a sh where the doorway is open and the East but it's not really recommended because then every single time A guy walks into the sh the whole sh sees it this way only yentas who turn around and are pacing now by the way I'm very into exercise you should try to exercise every day but not during the avening meaning you know obviously you're not going to come in with and stand on a treadmill right imagine you came in with two movers and put a treadmill by your seat so so too during the rest of the aving it's not a time for exercise no jumping jacks no push-ups also also walking walking is very good exercise but not during the avening you stay in your place if let's say you're not able to there are medications you could take for for people who can't sit but the proper decorum for ding is sitting in one place if you're facing I'm sorry if you're going to be backing clpp if you're going to put put your back toward the I'm sorry this is about you're ding in the direction that the door is open to which is the West now if you're going to turn around this is talking about how to rectify it if you're going to turn toward the it would come out you're ding toward the side that the you would not be called wicked if you're going to turn around from the sh comes out you're going to be ding in the opposite direction of the they're doing toward now let's say a guy he so AR in his daving he starts and for whatever reason he's daving in the opposite direction of the they're ding to the East and he ended up to the West in middle of sh what should he do he should turn around should turn around no you don't have to jump this happens this happens often something together nobody knows people are facing different direction oh you want to know let's say in and and then how did you realize in Middle you saw the sun I know I wouldn't say in that case you should turn around the ver here is not the importance of daving to the m it's not the importance is right so if the got it wrong I don't think that in Middle you would uh you know turn in the opposite direction I don't think so okay right there you're called Russ why you called the Russia looks like they're two deities according to this let's say like this let's say you're in the East and your back is toward the shul but you're davening in the direction of the tior you're okay you're not a Russia you're not a Russia in other words we're according to Rashi the Russia is the guy standing in the back of the sh with his back toward the people and he's ding to the Marv while the rest of the people are ding to the MRA and what if he's in the front of the sh and his back is to the people and he's diing to the MRA in the same direction as the people he's not a Russia it doesn't say he's a sadic but he's not a Russia either that's Rashi however there's another there are those who learn he's behind the East wall where there are no doors and when you're davening behind that wo his back is to the wall even though his face is toward the East so he's ding in the same direction as the people still called because he is among those who it says about them and their back is toward the temple so what should this guy do then if he's going to face the but now he's ding to the West even even though he's facing the West there's no problem the was ding toward the now what would Rashi say about that would Rashi say he's a Russia for daving in an opposite direction than theor I don't know we don't know that Rashi was talking about where the was ding to the e he's dominaing to the west and he's back is to the people and as Mish explained it looks like they're two Gods but in this case it doesn't look like they're two Gods I wouldn't say Rashi would say he's a Russia so the bottom line is the m says you should be for both says they youav in the West meaning if you need to be outside of the sh stand in the west and face the p and face the sh even though this is this is only obviously I don't know what this guy's is what what he has with the outside of the shaw we all know why why people like they like to D in in not in the main sanctuary you ever go into coat rooms coat rooms are one of the holiest places in the world because there's so mucha that takes place the only thing is the guy doesn't realize he has to DAV in the sh he can't go home and his wife says where were you he said I'm in sh no he wasn't in sh he should say I was in a coat room well why' you go to the coat room I don't know unclear but uh you need to be in the sh also women's sections are very popular but they should only be popular for women men should in the men's section but that's that's the uh ideal in other words you got to be outdoors it should be in the west your kid you have to watch your kid so don't stand in the front of the sh with your back to the sh don't stand in the back of the sh with your back to the stand in the back of the sh facing the sh also the North or the South that you should now if you're in the North or the South face the sh now why should you face the I'm in the north of the South should I face East I can face this we're talking about I can face this there's you hear this if you're standing in the North or the South it's better to face East than to face even to face East it's only like we said earlier otherwise you need to be in the the reason why you should face the sh is because we don't want your back to be to the sh I if I'm in the North and the South and I'm facing the sh I'm not ding in the direction of the people people but since I'm not doming in the opposite direction L but it's not an issue this is if you're in the North or the South if you're in the East or the West you would not be able to turn yourself to the north or to the South why not if somebody is in the East why would he not be able to turn himself to the cuz then it looks like you're daving in a different direction than the seor cuz they're ding in toward the East and the west and now for you to face the North and South that looks like you're facing an opposite direction okay we'll hold over here we continu of tomorrow okay have a great day everyone ex calisthetics you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by Torah anytime.com