Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
progress okay everyone we're continuing
in we're learning Simon
P if it's permitted to read in a bath
house what's the issue with the bath
house we'll have to see is it an issue
of people being unclad is it an issue
of that was never used you're lad
reading
it the says
it means it was not used even once if it
was used
once then it's like an old
one since there was designation and
action in other words designation alone
is
meaningless but if there was designation
and action then we say it does have
significance says
the and an old one
outer
room that everyone is dressed your L
learn are dress some are
not you're allowed to ask how are you
invoke the name
of but you can't
say
adds you could even think in learning in
the middle
room the Inner
Room that everyone there is
unclad
sh
even sh
is in the Inner Room where everyone is
not dressed
even it's to answer aain in the bath
house
even though in we hold
in alone
is is worse so
in we said
why
said which is interesting that by a
daanan you would have to go back
because didn't we bring from
RAR in the end of sim P that regarding
since it's
m right because the Rama's last words in
Simon
and that's consistent with the den of
Bak that was hman however rer says
regarding
since so how how how does that work why
does if even a that
wasman you do have to go
[Music]
back
mhm because earlier
theim that you do go back even by daanan
so it seems like it's a question whether
you have to go back by
a there the M was talking about
by
so you do go
back so what exactly is this rer talking
about um
okay that's part of what we were
discussing last
time fine so
is it um
it's to the point where if you said it
in a in a Bak you would have to go back
[Music]
M
fine
um in the middle room where some are and
some
are some say now we're talking about at
the middle room some people are dressed
and some are not
dressed even if they're all dressed or
there's no one
there since this room is designated for
people to be
unclothed it has
a so you shouldn't in
there ACC
to in the room where the uh worker works
out of
and people stand there
unclothed according to
m in the room where the uh the bath
house attendant lives and some people
stand there
unclothed you're allow to learn there
and Dav in if no one's
there this is all the middle house the
inner
house they all stand there
unclothed and they bathe
there that's more
disgusting everybody would say it has a
din of a
bathroom it's even if no one is
there even if it's the D of that bath
house to bathe only in the
summer it's lacked in the winter
then even then it would have all the of
a bath
house its name has not been removed from
it if you did some kind of act that
changes
it you change the actual
edifice let's say you put your oven
there and you made it a place where
people live
you could even put up
a the same D would be regarding
a that if you do
a then you could change its status and
extricate it from the state of being a b
or a
B now in this area you're
all but you can't
learn said we'll start
this
likewise the only thing
that's says if you made a you don't have
to go
back you don't have to say it
again even if somebody was there
unclothed
provided he was not directly opposite
you when you were reading
it or if you turned
around
otherwise you'd have to repeat it
again okay we're going to hold it here
tomorrow Monday we'll see the laws of
Mikvah regarding whether saying and
kadus again just to sort of leave you
off with a
question is
not but it
is that's why the said at the end
of
it's and even you would have to go
back so I am not clear what is the den
regarding
you do go back likewise in Sim I
invol the M said that if you're in a
place if you find urine even in a place
where you should have been mic you don't
have to go
back
however if you knew that there was Ur
there and you intentionally viol ated
you have to go back CU you're
over so it seems like when you're over
you have to go back however reer says
when the at the end of sim when
says
says I
in Simon
I where somebody said sh and his GID was
touching
him the M BR says you do not have to go
back even though there
so it's not clear what in what
circumstances you have to go could be
sometimes you have to go back and
sometimes they're not in other words
there are certain uhar that they say if
you don't do it correctly you have to go
back and sometimes they
said have a wonderful
shabas recording stop sorry this the
beginning so sorry
pleas what exactly is wrong
